Premise: Edgar Allan Poe ( [ poʊ ] born Edgar Poe ; January 19 , 1809 -- October 7 , 1849 ) was an American writer , editor , and literary critic . However , Poe later failed as an officer cadet at West Point , declaring a firm wish to be a poet and writer , and he ultimately parted ways with John Allan . A number of his homes are dedicated museums today .
Hypothesis: Edgar Allan Poe was a raven.
Label: CONTRADICTION