Premise: Edward John ` Ed ' Gagliardi ( February 13 , 1952 -- May 11 , 2014 ) was an American bass guitarist , best known as the original bass player for the 1970s rock band Foreigner . Gagliardi died of cancer on May 11 , 2014 , after battling cancer for eight years .
Hypothesis: Ed Gagliardi died on October 13, 2005.
Label: CONTRADICTION