Premise: Jake Gyllenhaal . In 2005 , Gyllenhaal portrayed Anthony `` Swoff '' Swofford in Jarhead , Gwyneth Paltrow 's love interest in Proof , and Jack Twist in Ang Lee 's Brokeback Mountain .
Hypothesis: Jake Gyllenhaal had been signed to star in Jarhead but withdrew before production could begin.
Label: CONTRADICTION