Premise: Andrew Moray ( Norman French : Andreu de Moray ; Andreas de Moravia ) , also known as Andrew de Moray , Andrew of Moray , or Andrew Murray , an esquire , was prominent in the Scottish Wars of Independence . He led the rising in north Scotland in the summer of 1297 against the occupation by King Edward I of England , successfully regaining control of the area for King John Balliol . Sir Andrew Murray ( 1298 -- 1338 ) , also known as Sir Andrew Moray , or Sir Andrew de Moray , was a Scottish military and political leader who supported David II of Scotland against Edward Balliol and King Edward III of England during the so-called Second War of Scottish Independence .
Hypothesis: Andrew Moray favored English occupation of Scotland.
Label: CONTRADICTION