Spreadsheet: kevin_presto__19792__Update 011016
Sheet: All Plants

HIGHLY CONFIDENTAIL
These highly confidential ratings assess security issues currently facing the US Commercial Nuclear Fleet. The P(b) below indicates our probabilty (based on the best available current information) that the nuclear unit could: 1) experience an extended outage should they have a  forced outage 2) an extension of a current outage or 3) an "unplanned" maintenance outage occuring to address security issues. Note the NRC has not developed a specific response to the security issue and the Chairman has sent a letter to each Governor asking them to implement a response. NEI has taken the position that this is not the correct response and that the Federal Government should develop a comprehensive and consistent response given that the threat is a National issue and not a State issue. The President has been given differing staff viewpoints and it is uncertain where this falls given the current priorities.
 |  | Plants | Net Mwe | P(b) Security Extended shutdown | Comments
No. Within RR | No. Of plants (103 Total) | EAST
 |  | ECAR
1 |  | BEAVER VALLEY 1 | 810 | M
 |  | BEAVER VALLEY 2 | 833 | M
 |  | DAVIS BESSE | 877 | L
 |  | DC COOK 1 | 1020 | M
 |  | DC COOK 2 | 1090 | M
 |  | FERMI 2 | 1098 | H | Close to Detroit and Toledo
 |  | PALISADES | 780 | L
 |  | PERRY 1 | 1194 | M | Near Cleveland
 |  | ERCOT
1 |  | COMANCHE PEAK 1 | 1150 | M
 |  | COMANCHE PEAK 2 | 1150 | M
 |  | SOUTH TEXAS 1 | 1250 | M | Chemical facilities near site
 |  | SOUTH TEXAS 2 | 1250 | M | Chemical facilities near site
 |  | FRCC
1 |  | CRYSTAL RIVER 3 | 825 | H | Near St. Petersburg and Tampa
 |  | ST LUCIE 1 | 839 | M | Densely populated on east coast of Florida
 |  | ST LUCIE 2 | 839 | M | Densely populated on east coast of Florida
 |  | TURKEY POINT 3 | 693 | H | Near Miami hard to defend
 |  | TURKEY POINT 4 | 693 | H
 |  | MAAC
1 |  | CALVERT CLIFFS 1 | 825 | H | Very Close to Washington DC
 |  | CALVERT CLIFFS 2 | 825 | H
 |  | HOPE CREEK | 1031 | H | Near Wilmington and DuPont Plants
 |  | LIMERICK 1 | 1055 | M
 |  | LIMERICK 2 | 1108 | M
 |  | OYSTER CREEK 1 | 610 | H | Near NY City
 |  | PEACH BOTTOM 2 | 1100 | M
 |  | PEACH BOTTOM 3 | 1100 | M
 |  | SALEM 1 | 1106 | H
 |  | SALEM 2 | 1106 | H
 |  | SUSQUEHANNA 1 | 1090 | L
 |  | SUSQUEHANNA 2 | 1094 | L
 |  | THREE MILE ISLAND 1 | 786 | VH | Site of prior major event and hard to get to
 |  | MAIN
1 |  | BRAIDWOOD 1 | 1134 | L
 |  | BRAIDWOOD 2 | 1134 | L
 |  | BYRON 1 | 1116 | L
 |  | BYRON 2 | 1116 | L
 |  | CLINTON 1 | 930 | L | Critical relationship to grid
 |  | [NAME] | 794 | M
 |  | [NAME] 3 | 794 | M
 |  | KEWAUNEE | 503 | M
 |  | LASALLE 1 | 1078 | M
 |  | LASALLE 2 | 1078 | M
 |  | POINT BEACH 1 | 485 | L
 |  | POINT BEACH 2 | 485 | L
 |  | QUAD CITIES 1 | 789 | M
 |  | QUAD CITIES 2 | 789 | M
 |  | MAPP
1 |  | COOPER | 764 | L
 |  | [NAME] | 538 | M
 |  | FORT CALHOUN | 478 | M
 |  | MONTICELLO | 600 | L
 |  | PRAIRIE ISLAND 1 | 540 | M
 |  | PRAIRIE ISLAND 2 | 540 | M
 |  | NPCC (NEPOOL)
1 |  | MILLSTONE 2 | 870 | M
 |  | MILLSTONE 3 | 1149 | M
 |  | PILGRIM 1 | 670 | H | Near Boston and major gas lines, Key Transmission
 |  | SEABROOK | 1162 | H | Fairly close to Boston
 |  | VERMONT YANKEE | 504 | H | Rural hard to get to quickly and critical to grid
 |  | NPCC (NYPP)
1 |  | FITZPATRICK | 780 | M
 |  | GINNA | 470 | M
 |  | INDIAN POINT 2 | 975 | VH | Close to NY City Maintainence outage coming up around 27-Oct-01
 |  | INDIAN POINT 3 | 965 | VH | Close to NY City
 |  | NINE MILE POINT 1 | 610 | M
 |  | NINE MILE POINT 2 | 1137 | M
 |  | SERC
1 |  | BROWNS FERRY 2 | 1065 | M
 |  | BROWNS FERRY 3 | 1065 | M
 |  | BRUNSWICK 1 | 767 | M
 |  | BRUNSWICK 2 | 754 | M
 |  | CATAWBA 1 | 1129 | M | Close to Charlotte
 |  | CATAWBA 2 | 1129 | M | Close to Charlotte
 |  | FARLEY 1 | 822 | L
 |  | FARLEY 2 | 854 | L
 |  | HARRIS | 860 | M
 |  | HATCH 1 | 800 | L
 |  | HATCH 2 | 818 | L
 |  | MCGUIRE 1 | 1129 | H | Very close to Charlotte
 |  | MCGUIRE 2 | 1129 | H
 |  | NORTH ANNA 1 | 893 | H | Close to Washington DC Metro area
 |  | NORTH ANNA 2 | 897 | H
 |  | OCONEE 1 | 846 | M | Very Rural Gov already practiced drill
 |  | OCONEE 2 | 846 | M
 |  | OCONEE 3 | 846 | M
 |  | ROBINSON 2 | 683 | M
 |  | SEQUOYAH 1 | 1148 | M
 |  | SEQUOYAH 2 | 1148 | M
 |  | SUMMER | 885 | H | Very close to Columbia SC, [NAME] already nervous
 |  | SURRY 1 | 801 | M
 |  | SURRY 2 | 801 | M
 |  | VOGTLE 1 | 1162 | M
 |  | VOGTLE 2 | 1162 | M
 |  | WATTS BAR 1 | 1150 | L
 |  | SPP
1 |  | ARKANSAS 1 | 836 | L
 |  | ARKANSAS 2 | 858 | L
 |  | CALLAWAY | 1235 | M | Rural and close enough to capital
 |  | GRAND GULF | 1142 | L
 |  | RIVER BEND 1 | 936 | H | Near Chemical Petro Chemical Plants
 |  | WATERFORD 3 | 1075 | L
 |  | WOLF CREEK | 1135 | M | Rural but near freeways
 |  | WEST
 |  | WSCC
1 |  | COLUMBIA | 1107 | L
 |  | DIABLO CANYON 1 | 1073 | M
 |  | DIABLO CANYON 2 | 1087 | M
 |  | PALO VERDE 1 | 1243 | H | Major energy center with 1 hour of Phoenix
 |  | PALO VERDE 2 | 1243 | H
 |  | PALO VERDE 3 | 1247 | H
 |  | SAN ONOFRE 2 | 1070 | VH | Near LA, San Diego right off I-5 past difficulties
 |  | SAN ONOFRE 3 | 1080 | VH
 |  | [NAME]P(b) Extended shutdown if shutdown occurs |  |  | P(b)
 |  | Very High | VH | > 75% | If shut down p(b) shutdown will be extended to
 |  | High | H | 50%- 75 % | address security concerns due to current
 |  | Medium | M | 25% - 50% | situation and other criteria.
 |  | Low | L | 25%<
 |  | *Note - HGP will send seperate white paper on security issues.