Spreadsheet: 1e3f2765-3176-4599-b797-f1f62f22a235
Sheet: Appendix E

Hospital | FACID | Cohort | Hospital Commercial Composite Relative Price | Top Commercial Payers- Payer 1 | % of Comm. Payments- Payer  1 | FY12 Relative Price-  Payer 1 | Top Commercial Payers- Payer 2 | % of Comm. Payments- Payer  2 | FY12 Relative Price-  Payer 2 | Top Commercial Payers- Payer 3 | % of Comm. Payments- Payer  3 | FY12 Relative Price-  Payer 3
[NAME] | 2006 | Community Hospital | 19.12839940788484 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5861078035682126 | 16.9230769230769 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1382795051557162 | 21.5384615384615 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1161042887343467 | 10.7692307692308
Athol Memorial Hospital | 2226 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 35.27153909724493 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4445073571772439 | 6.153846153846154 | Fallon Community Health Plan | 0.2060670629101105 | 63.9344262295082 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.08823980799779617 | 9.230769230769232
Baystate Franklin Medical Center | 2120 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 57.72234482275466 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.3799682204107006 | 67.6923076923077 | Health New England | 0.3098313238753826 | 43.75 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.08564888940316666 | 66.15384615384615
Baystate [NAME] | 2148 | Community Hospital | 33.51018460137313 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4095078027118635 | 55.38461538461539 | Health New England | 0.1854895984749025 | 18.75 | Fallon Community Health Plan | 0.08727409063608088 | 31.14754098360656
Baystate Medical Center | 2339 | Teaching Hospital | 60.19878800616506 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.422896649880628 | 84.61538461538461 | Health New England | 0.2802126595822763 | 50 | UniCare | 0.07101710879387163 | 81.53846153846153
Berkshire Medical Center | 2313 | Teaching Hospital | 81.05020491803279 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5163940830275341 | 87.6923076923077 | Health New England | 0.2055407081639372 | 62.5 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.08636000579011952 | 87.6923076923077
Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital - Milton | 2227 | Community Hospital | 23.50992350764664 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4803535328162732 | 23.07692307692308 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.3028120645834447 | 10.76923076923077 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1096659035571319 | 7.692307692307693
Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital - Needham | 2054 | Community Hospital | 37.73368537200504 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4282505780106734 | 32.30769230769231 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2660057852965386 | 20 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.152466074156389 | 43.07692307692308
Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center | 2069 | Academic Medical Center | 73.72642534470859 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4674834867618217 | 83.07692307692308 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2810817782147442 | 64.61538461538461 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1246151294974982 | 80
Boston Children's Hospital | 2139 | Specialty Hospital | 95.23706499514788 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5673314389425499 | 98.46153846153847 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1723562294410436 | 93.84615384615384 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.0931443808148872 | 98.46153846153847
Boston Medical Center | 2307 | Academic Medical Center | 57.56046346893342 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4586365065814162 | 41.53846153846154 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2550579026912204 | 52.30769230769231 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1060059900228738 | 23.07692307692308
[NAME] and Women's Faulkner Hospital | 2048 | Teaching Hospital | 73.56055136508232 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4797046569613736 | 76.92307692307693 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2662176609646878 | 70.76923076923077 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1123412318251013 | 58.46153846153847
[NAME] and Women's Hospital | 2921 | Academic Medical Center | 91.96815045744918 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5306837198917634 | 93.84615384615384 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1784294286324319 | 81.53846153846153 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.09164625244994652 | 96.92307692307692
Cambridge Health Alliance | 2108 | Teaching Hospital | 16.72834641072346 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5351933696205889 | 10.76923076923077 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1597502022049022 | 13.84615384615385 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1522986674356833 | 6.153846153846154
[NAME] | 2135 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 81.52057256394689 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4880180604825066 | 92.3076923076923 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2845222584892479 | 92.3076923076923 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.08797331239017044 | 84.61538461538461
[NAME] | 2126 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 42.0156348518285 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4286723732212302 | 46.15384615384615 | Fallon Community Health Plan | 0.1459239358990636 | 36.0655737704918 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1457790749676651 | 86.15384615384616
Cooley Dickinson Hospital | 2155 | Community Hospital | 74.96190626313576 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.2898054056398922 | 69.23076923076923 | Health New England | 0.2792301760830527 | 81.25 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1352710144272509 | 83.07692307692308
[NAME] | 2335 | Specialty Hospital | 90.33648332373286 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4554948006504544 | 63.07692307692307 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2253135209516596 | 87.6923076923077 | Aetna | 0.09063561675886563 | 100
Emerson Hospital | 2018 | Community Hospital | 47.85030345253478 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5237647155155652 | 49.23076923076923 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.169491528039198 | 26.15384615384616 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1321076989206318 | 53.84615384615385
Fairview Hospital | 2052 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 75.36066449488581 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5563776568427847 | 89.23076923076924 | Health New England | 0.1818085012361986 | 56.25 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.08571156196172358 | 89.23076923076924
Falmouth Hospital | 2289 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 77.49442621653459 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5572058863754038 | 90.76923076923077 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2468857898175123 | 95.38461538461539 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.0881052212960994 | 86.15384615384616
[NAME] | 2038 | Community Hospital | 46.43666741913555 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4728235119767391 | 52.30769230769231 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2114466756831306 | 69.23076923076923 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1823557050092837 | 55.38461538461539
Harrington Memorial Hospital | 2143 | Community Hospital | 45.41422925131942 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4483962784969904 | 66.15384615384615 | Fallon Community Health Plan | 0.232515686315536 | 55.73770491803278 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1167591090357399 | 55.38461538461539
HealthAlliance Hospital | 2034 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 51.05360562327775 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4200034599681648 | 15.38461538461539 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1703863079900655 | 15.38461538461539 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1284672390019425 | 32.30769230769231
Heywood Hospital | 2036 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 22.48262429358741 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4913195199318062 | 9.230769230769232 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1559481835545916 | 12.30769230769231 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1126995479749364 | 9.230769230769232
Holyoke Medical Center | 2145 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 27.50198496100136 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4704470277303084 | 12.30769230769231 | Health New England | 0.2978196647142605 | 25 | UniCare | 0.04994753306279676 | 21.53846153846154
[NAME] | 2082 | Community Hospital | 55.00263688446748 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5694496782265761 | 47.69230769230769 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2012347375819576 | 49.23076923076923 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1051510308283644 | 40
Kindred Hospital - Boston | 2091 | Specialty Hospital
Kindred Hospital - Boston North Shore | 2171 | Specialty Hospital
Lahey Clinic | 2033 | Teaching Hospital | 61.38171383868106 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5051665911318051 | 72.3076923076923 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2213374744800525 | 73.84615384615385 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1153601547456217 | 67.6923076923077
Lawrence General Hospital | 2099 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 24.86851417236208 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.578015295942951 | 18.46153846153846 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1280895569900282 | 18.46153846153846 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1182824451320538 | 18.46153846153846
Lowell General Hospital | 2040 | Community Hospital | 33.8615062788987 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.545398603499853 | 27.69230769230769 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1652129391839748 | 43.07692307692308 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1279419440477114 | 26.15384615384616
Marlborough Hospital | 2103 | Community Hospital | 46.96620603895194 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4395151425118141 | 30.76923076923077 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1597506867983368 | 33.84615384615385 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1520567808235532 | 30.76923076923077
[NAME]'s Vineyard Hospital | 2042 | Community Hospital | 86.1170732917659 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.6163834403054742 | 100 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2534254545771829 | 84.61538461538461 | Neighborhood Health Plan | 0.05475005017810351 | 96.29629629629629
Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary | 2167 | Specialty Hospital | 46.86080525846009 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5181409424161258 | 60 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1944844427137773 | 13.84615384615385 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1221613945737939 | 29.23076923076923
Massachusetts General Hospital | 2168 | Academic Medical Center | 91.8866000212767 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5755397708908031 | 95.38461538461539 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1327058215006535 | 80 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.09975535727880773 | 93.84615384615384
Mercy Medical Center | 2149 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 29.11740606463967 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.3987150900911359 | 4.615384615384619 | Health New England | 0.347097141944048 | 31.25 | UniCare | 0.06909846209988457 | 66.1538461538461
Merrimack Valley Hospital | 2131 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 19.88639747092616 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.6329434851448186 | 21.5384615384615 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1401312104563651 | 16.9230769230769 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1290873386664616 | 7.69230769230769
MetroWest Medical Center | 2020 | Community Hospital | 40.56403125562962 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5165185280703557 | 36.92307692307693 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2156827353335061 | 29.23076923076923 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1354357859756454 | 35.38461538461539
Milford Regional Medical Center | 2105 | Community Hospital | 45.75485277557226 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4430434494231033 | 40 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.255043186150943 | 38.46153846153847 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1024606044772352 | 52.30769230769231
[NAME] | 2022 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 26.91854508196722 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5007546115453224 | 13.84615384615385 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.245982148241615 | 36.92307692307693 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1341290027189748 | 27.69230769230769
Mount Auburn Hospital | 2071 | Teaching Hospital | 55.49066849399841 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4948169901118699 | 61.53846153846154 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2077398065955439 | 47.69230769230769 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1950538909202673 | 72.3076923076923
Nantucket Cottage Hospital | 2044 | Community Hospital | 70.36824571148341 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.7244379818804105 | 96.92307692307692 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1115831737008392 | 98.46153846153847 | Neighborhood Health Plan | 0.08744915643220709 | 94.44444444444444
Nashoba Valley Medical Center | 2298 | Community Hospital | 33.94290427525571 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4753613810844854 | 24.61538461538462 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2026445486292588 | 24.61538461538462 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1773907507872023 | 16.92307692307692
New England Baptist Hospital | 2059 | Specialty Hospital | 47.53073121811738 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5625780477700956 | 64.61538461538461 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2234114738187772 | 12.30769230769231 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1143522618064655 | 38.46153846153847
Newton-Wellesley Hospital | 2075 | Community Hospital | 65.58476724061879 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5043299569379048 | 73.84615384615385 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2114811689906943 | 66.15384615384615 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1449215980098997 | 73.84615384615385
Noble Hospital | 2076 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 15.27398737798328 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4632230860356556 | 1.538461538461539 | Health New England | 0.2663958885219445 | 6.25 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.06526763968347044 | 6.153846153846154
North Adams Regional Hospital | 2061 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 64.80939995796552 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5828099000717064 | 56.92307692307692 | Health New England | 0.197805330314497 | 100 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.0930942532622018 | 92.3076923076923
North Shore Medical Center | 2073 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 72.26564810922736 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4846283218261948 | 78.46153846153847 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1627247087118026 | 69.23076923076923 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1437618191042064 | 76.92307692307693
Northeast Hospital | 2007 | Community Hospital | 41.54418614004225 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5312623620090942 | 50.76923076923077 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1622774125489574 | 41.53846153846154 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1387005528830424 | 44.61538461538462
Quincy Medical Center | 2151 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 19.24212113192077 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4584086259112475 | 3.076923076923077 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2710502321425294 | 4.615384615384616 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1831706269714936 | 4.615384615384616
Saint Vincent Hospital | 2128 | Teaching Hospital | 56.38004413619167 | Fallon Community Health Plan | 0.4323106439707396 | 57.37704918032787 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.3161069516228496 | 33.84615384615385 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1016847426862518 | 50.76923076923077
Saints Medical Center | 2063 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 12.09733387627855 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.6080951806294324 | 7.692307692307693 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1234964916934128 | 3.076923076923077 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1034324445939682 | 1.538461538461539
Signature Healthcare Brockton Hospital | 2118 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 34.52716088303519 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4858378649884951 | 26.15384615384616 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2649297701408027 | 23.07692307692308 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1178744376990964 | 33.84615384615385
South Shore Hospital | 2107 | Community Hospital | 76.1259966969211 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4442187915977315 | 81.53846153846153 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.3302825752953459 | 89.23076923076924 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1067885964193668 | 70.76923076923077
Southcoast Hospitals Group | 2010 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 53.01792400323821 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.6133203157391987 | 58.46153846153847 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1208199521234236 | 75.38461538461539 | United Healthcare Insurance Company | 0.06432840352822293 | 50.81967213114754
Steward Carney Hospital (Annualized) | 2003AN | Teaching Hospital | 34.25994669795899 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.3999260832015355 | 38.46153846153847 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2393224946839325 | 56.92307692307692 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2292521710206274 | 24.61538461538462
Steward Good Samaritan Medical Center (Annualized) | 2101AN | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 43.87157723963279 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4946904331408809 | 44.61538461538462 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1970002467180137 | 47.69230769230769 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.194908412985825 | 44.61538461538462
Steward Holy Family Hospital (Annualized) | 2225AN | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 34.05310873434735 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4846297617501493 | 20 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2412199545222954 | 41.53846153846154 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1267789655392065 | 35.38461538461539
Steward Norwood Hospital (Annualized) | 2114AN | Community Hospital | 42.37526044504642 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4678871636176772 | 29.23076923076923 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.214709498143036 | 40 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1916193917524015 | 49.23076923076923
[NAME] Hospital (Annualized) | 2011AN | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 48.62770272549417 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4532066220709646 | 43.07692307692308 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2102509282224808 | 76.92307692307693 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1765131429499812 | 50.76923076923077
[NAME] Medical Center (Annualized) | 2085AN | Teaching Hospital | 57.54038811825696 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4511009817492858 | 70.76923076923077 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2272501872335482 | 64.61538461538461 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2165542351233341 | 67.6923076923077
Sturdy Memorial Hospital | 2100 | Community Hospital | 64.33713654455913 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.5190676211962348 | 86.15384615384616 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2001547370534644 | 72.3076923076923 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1290734119330038 | 83.07692307692308
Tufts Medical Center | 2299 | Academic Medical Center | 70.27328891172243 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4995531522702758 | 80 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.198171767052513 | 63.07692307692307 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1744752673045511 | 61.53846153846154
UMass Memorial Medical Center | 2841 | Academic Medical Center | 78.77880090841157 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4308781328693936 | 75.38461538461539 | Fallon Community Health Plan | 0.1797467478719549 | 77.04918032786885 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1300064341718396 | 75.38461538461539
Winchester Hospital | 2094 | Community Hospital | 44.57047973782946 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4721352246472313 | 53.84615384615385 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.207074440858588 | 63.07692307692307 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1843342539764361 | 56.92307692307692
Wing Memorial Hospital | 2181 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 22.51795368035122 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4587943770364052 | 35.38461538461539 | Health New England | 0.1362880816326443 | 12.5 | UniCare | 0.1003820549022917 | 16.92307692307692
Unannualized/ As Filed:
Steward Carney Hospital | 2003 | Teaching Hospital | 34.25994669795899 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.3999260832015355 | 38.46153846153847 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2393224946839325 | 56.92307692307692 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2292521710206274 | 24.61538461538462
Steward Good Samaritan Medical Center | 2101 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 43.87157723963279 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4946904331408809 | 44.61538461538462 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1970002467180137 | 47.69230769230769 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.194908412985825 | 44.61538461538462
Steward Holy Family Hospital | 2225 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 34.05310873434735 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4846297617501493 | 20 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2412199545222954 | 41.53846153846154 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.1267789655392065 | 35.38461538461539
Steward Norwood Hospital | 2114 | Community Hospital | 42.37526044504642 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4678871636176772 | 29.23076923076923 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.214709498143036 | 40 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1916193917524015 | 49.23076923076923
[NAME] Hospital | 2011 | Community, Disproportionate Share Hospital | 48.62770272549417 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4532066220709646 | 43.07692307692308 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2102509282224808 | 76.92307692307693 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.1765131429499812 | 50.76923076923077
[NAME] Medical Center | 2085 | Teaching Hospital | 57.54038811825696 | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts | 0.4511009817492858 | 70.76923076923077 | Tufts Health Plan | 0.2272501872335482 | 64.61538461538461 | Harvard Pilgrim Health Care | 0.2165542351233341 | 67.6923076923077