Best and Worst Situations to Use Zustand and Jotai with Next.js
Tags: nextjs, zustand, jotai, javascript
Published: 2024-07-09 04:36:34

State management is an essential part of developing robust React applications, including those built with Next.js. Zustand and Jotai are two popular state management libraries that offer different approaches to managing state. This article will explore the best and worst situations to use Zustand and Jotai in a Next.js application, complete with code samples to illustrate their usage.

# Zustand

## Overview

Zustand is a small, fast, and scalable state management library for React. It provides a simple API and is known for its performance and ease of use.

## Best Situations to Use Zustand

1.  **Simple State Management Needs**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application requires simple, global state management without complex logic.
-   **Example**: Managing UI states like modals, sidebars, or global loading states.
```
// store.js  
import create from 'zustand';  
  
export const useStore = create((set) => ({  
  isModalOpen: false,  
  toggleModal: () => set((state) => ({ isModalOpen: !state.isModalOpen })),  
}));

// Modal.js  
import React from 'react';  
import { useStore } from '../store';  
  
const Modal = () => {  
  const { isModalOpen, toggleModal } = useStore();  
  return (  
    <div>  
      {isModalOpen && <div>Modal Content</div>}  
      <button onClick={toggleModal}>Toggle Modal</button>  
    </div>  
  );  
};  
  
export default Modal;
```
2\. **High Performance Requirements**:

-   **Scenario**: When performance is critical, and you need a state management library with minimal overhead.
-   **Example**: Real-time applications where state updates need to be highly performant, such as live chat or gaming apps.

3\. **Ease of Integration**:

-   **Scenario**: When you need a state management solution that integrates easily with existing React components without significant boilerplate.
-   **Example**: Quickly adding state management to a small to medium-sized project without restructuring the codebase.

4\. **Server-Side Rendering (SSR)**:

-   **Scenario**: When using SSR with Next.js and you need a state management library that plays well with both client and server.
-   **Example**: Applications where initial state needs to be rendered on the server for SEO benefits or faster initial load times.
```
// pages/\_app.js  
import App from 'next/app';  
import { useStore } from '../store';  
  
const MyApp = ({ Component, pageProps }) => {  
  return <Component {...pageProps} />;  
};  
  
MyApp.getInitialProps = async (appContext) => {  
  const appProps = await App.getInitialProps(appContext);  
  const { isModalOpen } = useStore.getState();  
  return { ...appProps, initialZustandState: { isModalOpen } };  
};  
  
export default MyApp;
```
## Worst Situations to Use Zustand

1\. **Complex State Logic**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application has very complex state management needs, including deep state trees and complex relationships.
-   **Example**: Large enterprise applications with numerous interconnected stateful components and complex state transitions.

2\. **Extensive Derived State**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application heavily relies on derived state and you need built-in support for selectors and memoization.
-   **Example**: Applications that require extensive computed properties based on the state, similar to what you might use Recoil or MobX for.

3\. **Extremely Large Applications**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application is extremely large and requires a highly structured approach to state management.
-   **Example**: Applications with multiple teams working on different modules where a more opinionated and structured state management approach might be beneficial.

# Jotai:

## Overview

Jotai is a minimalistic state management library for React that focuses on atomic state. It allows you to manage state in small, isolated pieces called atoms.

## Best Situations to Use Jotai

1\. **Atomic State Management**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application benefits from fine-grained control over state and you prefer managing state in small, isolated pieces.
-   **Example**: Complex forms where each field’s state is managed independently.
```
// atoms.js  
import { atom } from 'jotai';  
  
export const formFieldAtom = atom('');

// FormField.js  
import React from 'react';  
import { useAtom } from 'jotai';  
import { formFieldAtom } from '../atoms';  
  
const FormField = () => {  
  const \[value, setValue\] = useAtom(formFieldAtom);  
  return (  
    <input value={value} onChange={(e) => setValue(e.target.value)} />  
  );  
};  
  
export default FormField;
```
1\. **Scoped State**:

-   **Scenario**: When you need to manage state that is scoped to specific components or sections of your application.
-   **Example**: Multi-step wizards or dashboards where each section has its own independent state.

2\. **Dynamic State Requirements**:

-   **Scenario**: When state needs to be created and managed dynamically at runtime.
-   **Example**: Dynamic forms or data-driven components where the structure of the state is not known upfront.

3\. **Ease of Debugging**:

-   **Scenario**: When you need to easily track and debug state changes in your application.
-   **Example**: Applications where understanding the flow of state changes is critical for maintaining and debugging.

# Worst Situations to Use Jotai

1\. **Global State Management**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application requires a lot of global state management and you prefer a more centralized approach.
-   **Example**: Applications where most of the state is global and needs to be accessed and modified by various parts of the application.

2\. **Complex Inter-Component Communication**:

-   **Scenario**: When your application requires complex interactions and communication between different components.
-   **Example**: Applications with numerous components that need to share and react to each other’s state changes frequently.

3\. **Performance Optimization**:

-   **Scenario**: When performance optimization is critical and you need built-in tools for memoization and derived state.
-   **Example**: Applications where heavy computations are derived from the state and need efficient re-computation strategies.

4\. **Server-Side Rendering (SSR)**:

-   **Scenario**: While Jotai supports SSR, it may require more boilerplate and setup compared to other state management libraries.
-   **Example**: Applications where SSR setup needs to be straightforward and minimal.

# Conclusion

Both Zustand and Jotai offer unique advantages and are suitable for different scenarios in Next.js applications:

-   **Use Zustand** if you need simple, high-performance state management with minimal setup and are dealing with mostly global state or require smooth SSR integration.
-   **Use Jotai** if you prefer atomic state management, need fine-grained control over state, or are dealing with scoped or dynamic state requirements.

Choosing the right state management solution depends on the specific needs of your application, its complexity, and your team’s familiarity with the tools. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of Zustand and Jotai, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your project’s goals and requirements.