Security in Code Reviews: Ensuring Secure and Robust Software Development
Tags: webdev, programming, tutorial, beginners
Published: 2023-08-06 11:25:12




In today's digital age, security is of utmost importance in software development. With the increasing number of cyber threats and vulnerabilities, it is crucial for organizations to prioritize security measures to protect their systems and data. One significant aspect of ensuring security in software development is conducting thorough code reviews. Code reviews play a vital role in identifying and rectifying security flaws, ensuring that the software is secure and robust.

Code review involves a thorough examination of the code by a code reviewer or a dedicated team, who analyze the code for bugs, vulnerabilities, and adherence to best practices. In this article, we will delve into the importance of code review in software development and explore the best practices that can be employed for a successful code review process.

### Table of Contents

- [Importance of security in software development](#importance-of-security-in-software-development)
- [Role of code reviews in ensuring security](#role-of-code-reviews-in-ensuring-security)
- [Common Security Vulnerabilities](#common-security-vulnerabilities)
  * [Overview of prevalent security vulnerabilities](#overview-of-prevalent-security-vulnerabilities)
  * [SQL Injection](#sql-injection)
  * [Cross-Site Scripting (XSS)](#crosssite-scripting-xss)
  * [Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF)](#crosssite-request-forgery-csrf)
- [Examples of real-world incidents caused by security vulnerabilities](#examples-of-realworld-incidents-caused-by-security-vulnerabilities)
  * [Snapchat](#snapchat)
  * [Cloudbleed (2017)](#cloudbleed-2017)
  * [Twitter (2020)](#twitter-2020)
  * [Dallas police department database leak](#dallas-police-department-database-leak)
  * [Triple data breach at Mailchimp](#triple-data-breach-at-mailchimp)
- [Incorporating Security into the Code Review Process](#incorporating-security-into-the-code-review-process)
  * [Best practices for security-focused code reviews](#best-practices-for-securityfocused-code-reviews)
      + [Understand the application](#understand-the-application)
      + [Follow secure coding practices](#follow-secure-coding-practices)
      + [Use a checklist](#use-a-checklist)
      + [Look for common vulnerabilities](#look-for-common-vulnerabilities)
  * [Training developers for security awareness during code reviews](#training-developers-for-security-awareness-during-code-reviews)
      + [Security awareness training](#security-awareness-training)
      + [Code review workshops](#code-review-workshops)
      + [Collaborations](#collaborations)
- [Roles and Responsibilities](#roles-and-responsibilities)
  * [Role of developers in conducting code reviews](#role-of-developers-in-conducting-code-reviews)
  * [Responsibilities of security experts during code reviews](#responsibilities-of-security-experts-during-code-reviews)
  * [Collaboration between teams for efficient code reviews](#collaboration-between-teams-for-efficient-code-reviews)
- [Challenges in Security Code Reviews](#challenges-in-security-code-reviews)
  * [Lack of Security Knowledge](#lack-of-security-knowledge)
  * [Time Constraints](#time-constraints)
  * [Communication Gaps](#communication-gaps)
  * [Complexity of Code](#complexity-of-code)
  * [Resistance to Feedback](#resistance-to-feedback)
  * [False Positives/Negatives](#false-positivesnegatives)
  * [Wrapping up](#wrapping-up)

{%- # TOC end -%}


## Importance of security in software development

Security is really important in software development because it affects how safe and protected systems and data are. If software lacks proper security measures, it becomes at risk of different types of threats like unauthorized access, data breaches, and malicious attacks. These threats can cause big financial losses, damage a company's reputation, and may even lead to legal trouble for organizations.

When organizations prioritize security in software development, they can protect sensitive information, earn their customers' trust, and lower the risk of security issues. To do this, they use things like encryption, authentication, access controls, and secure coding practices to keep the software safe and private.

With the rise of hacking and cybercrime, security has become a top concern for businesses and individuals alike. Hackers are constantly looking for vulnerabilities in software to exploit and gain unauthorized access to sensitive information. By implementing robust security measures during the development process, developers can stay one step ahead of potential threats and protect their software from being compromised.

## Role of code reviews in ensuring security

Code reviews play a crucial role in ensuring the security of software applications. During a code review, developers or security experts thoroughly examine the source code to identify any vulnerabilities or weaknesses that could be exploited by attackers. They analyze the code for security best practices, and potential security risks.

Code reviews help detect common security issues such as input validation vulnerabilities, insecure data storage, authentication and authorization weaknesses, and insecure communication protocols. By catching these issues early in the development process, organizations can address them before they become significant security risks.

Code reviews also promote knowledge sharing and collaboration among development teams. By reviewing each other's code, developers can learn from one another, share best practices, and improve their coding skills. This collaborative approach helps raise awareness about security concerns and fosters a culture of security-conscious development.

If you want to learn more about How Code review works you check my following article:

{% embed https://dev.to/documatic/the-art-of-code-review-1lo4 %}

## Common Security Vulnerabilities

### Overview of prevalent security vulnerabilities

In the world of software development, there are various types of security vulnerabilities that can expose applications to attacks and compromise sensitive data. It is crucial for developers to be aware of these vulnerabilities and take necessary precautions to mitigate them. Here are some of the most common security vulnerabilities:

### SQL Injection

This vulnerability occurs when an attacker injects malicious SQL code into an application's database query. It can lead to unauthorized access, data loss, or even a complete takeover of the database.

Here's an example of a vulnerable code snippet that could lead to SQL Injection:

```python
# Vulnerable Code
import sqlite3

def get_user_data(username):
    query = "SELECT * FROM users WHERE username = '" + username + "';"
    connection = sqlite3.connect("database.db")
    cursor = connection.cursor()
    cursor.execute(query)
    user_data = cursor.fetchall()
    connection.close()
    return user_data
```

In the above code, the **`username`** variable is directly concatenated into the SQL query string without any validation or parameterization. This makes it vulnerable to SQL Injection attacks.

Now, let's see the secure version:

```python
# Secure Code
import sqlite3

def get_user_data(username):
    query = "SELECT * FROM users WHERE username = ?;"
    connection = sqlite3.connect("database.db")
    cursor = connection.cursor()
    cursor.execute(query, (username,))
    user_data = cursor.fetchall()
    connection.close()
    return user_data
```

In this secure version, I have used a placeholder (**`?`**) for the user input. The **`username`** variable is passed as a parameter to the **`execute`** method, which ensures that the input is treated as data and not executable code, preventing SQL Injection attacks.

### Cross-Site Scripting (XSS)

XSS vulnerabilities allow attackers to inject malicious scripts into web pages viewed by other users. This can lead to session hijacking, cookie theft, or the execution of arbitrary code on the victim's browser.

Here's an example of a vulnerable code snippet that could lead to XSS:

```python
# Vulnerable Code
from flask import Flask, request

app = Flask(__name__)

@app.route('/search')
def search():
    query = request.args.get('query')
    return '<p>Search results for: ' + query + '</p>'
```

In the above code, the user-provided search query is directly concatenated into the HTML response without proper validation or escaping. This makes it susceptible to Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) attacks.

An attacker can exploit this vulnerability by inserting malicious scripts in the search query, which will be executed when the response is rendered in the user's browser. For example, an attacker can craft a URL like this:

```text
http://example.com/search?query=<script>alert('XSS Attack!')</script>
```

When a user visits the above URL, the script will be executed in their browser, leading to an alert with the message "XSS Attack!”

Now, let's see the secure version:

```python
# Secure Code
from flask import Flask, request, escape

app = Flask(__name__)

@app.route('/search')
def search():
    query = request.args.get('query')
    safe_query = escape(query)
    return '<p>Search results for: ' + safe_query + '</p>'
```

In this secure version, I have used the [`escape`](https://tedboy.github.io/flask/generated/flask.escape.html) function (provided by the Flask framework) to sanitize the user input before including it in the HTML response. The **`escape`** function ensures that any potentially harmful HTML tags or scripts are rendered as harmless text.

### Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF)

CSRF vulnerabilities enable attackers to trick authenticated users into performing unintended actions on a website. This can lead to unauthorized transactions, data manipulation, or even account compromise.

Here's an example of a vulnerable code snippet that could lead to CSRF:

```python
# Vulnerable Code
from flask import Flask, render_template_string, request

app = Flask(__name__)

@app.route('/transfer', methods=['POST'])
def transfer():
    amount = request.form.get('amount')
    destination_account = request.form.get('destination_account')

    # ... 

    return 'Transfer successful!'
```

In this vulnerable code, a transfer operation is performed when the **`/transfer`** endpoint is accessed with a POST request. The amount and destination account are taken from the request form data. 

The problem is, this code doesn't protect against a type of attack called CSRF. An attacker can take advantage of this vulnerability by making a harmful website or tricking a logged-in user into going to a page with a hidden form. When the user visits that page, a transfer request is automatically sent to the **`/transfer`** part of the website, and since the user is already logged in, the transfer will happen without their knowledge or permission.

```python
# Secure Code
from flask import Flask, render_template_string, request
from flask_wtf.csrf import CSRFProtect

app = Flask(__name__)
csrf = CSRFProtect(app)

@app.route('/transfer', methods=['POST'])
@csrf.exempt  # Exempt CSRF protection for this route 
def transfer():
    amount = request.form.get('amount')
    destination_account = request.form.get('destination_account')

    # ... 

    return 'Transfer successful!'
```

In this secure version, we use the **`flask_wtf.csrf.CSRFProtect`** extension to protect against CSRF attacks. The **`CSRFProtect`** class integrates Cross-Site Request Forgery protection into the Flask app. By using this protection, the server generates and validates a CSRF token for each user session, ensuring that only authenticated users can perform sensitive actions like the transfer operation.

## Examples of real-world incidents caused by security vulnerabilities

Real-life incidents resulting from security vulnerabilities serve as a strong reminder of how crucial it is to conduct comprehensive code reviews and follow secure coding practices. Let me share some notable examples:

### Snapchat

[Gibson Security](https://gibsonsec.org/snapchat/) detailed vulnerabilities in the snapchat service, which was dismissed as a purely theoretical attack. A week later, brute force enumeration had revealed 4.6 million usernames and phone numbers.

> [Source](https://www.horangi.com/blog/real-life-examples-of-web-vulnerabilities)

### Cloudbleed (2017)

Google’s Project Zero found [an issue in Cloudflare’s edge servers](https://bugs.chromium.org/p/project-zero/issues/detail?id=1139) made it possible to dump memory potentially containing sensitive data, some of which were cached by search engines. This security bug was named Cloudbleed.

> [Source](https://www.horangi.com/blog/real-life-examples-of-web-vulnerabilities)

### Twitter (2020)

In mid-July 2020, [Twitter](https://twiiter.com) suffered a massive spear-phishing attack. Cybercriminals compromised the social network’s admin panel, got control over accounts of famous Twitter users, both private and corporate, and staged fake Bitcoin giveaways on their behalf.

> [Source](https://www.ekransystem.com/en/blog/top-10-cyber-security-breaches)

### Dallas police department database leak

In a chain of instances in March and April 2021, the city of Dallas suffered massive data losses because of employee negligence. An employee deleted 8.7 million important files that the Dallas Police Department had collected as evidence for its cases: video, photos, audio, case notes, and other items. Most of the deleted files were owned by the family violence unit.

> [Source](https://www.ekransystem.com/en/blog/real-life-examples-insider-threat-caused-breaches)

### Triple data breach at Mailchimp

Throughout 2022, [Mailchimp](https://mailchimp.com/) and its partners were targeted by cybercriminals and suffered from several attacks. In January 2023, malicious actors managed to carry out a successful phishing attack and tricked at least one Mailchimp employee into exposing their credentials.

> [Source](https://www.ekransystem.com/en/blog/real-life-examples-insider-threat-caused-breaches)

## Incorporating Security into the Code Review Process

### Best practices for security-focused code reviews

When it comes to conducting security-focused code reviews, there are several best practices that developers and security professionals should follow. These practices help ensure that potential security vulnerabilities are identified and addressed before the code is deployed.

#### Understand the application

It is crucial to have a deep understanding of the application being reviewed. This includes knowing its functionality, potential attack vectors, and the sensitive data it handles. Without this understanding, it becomes difficult to spot security issues effectively.

#### Follow secure coding practices

Code reviews should ensure that developers follow to secure coding practices. This includes validating user input, using safe queries to prevent SQL injection, and implementing proper access controls. By following these practices, developers can significantly reduce the risk of common security vulnerabilities.

#### Use a checklist

Creating a security-focused code review checklist helps ensure that all relevant security concerns are addressed. The checklist can include items such as input validation, authentication and authorization mechanisms, encryption practices, and error handling. This helps reviewers cover all essential aspects of security during the review process.

#### Look for common vulnerabilities

Code reviewers should be familiar with common security vulnerabilities, such as Cross-Site Scripting (XSS), Cross-Site Request Forgery (CSRF), and Remote Code Execution (RCE). By actively searching for these vulnerabilities, reviewers can identify potential weaknesses in the code and suggest appropriate remediation measures.

### Training developers for security awareness during code reviews

To effectively incorporate security into the code review process, developers need to be trained to have a strong security mindset. This ensures that they are aware of the potential security risks and can actively identify and address them during code reviews.

#### Security awareness training

Developers should receive regular security awareness training to stay updated on the latest security threats and vulnerabilities. This training should cover topics such as secure coding practices, common attack vectors, and techniques for identifying and mitigating security vulnerabilities.

#### Code review workshops

Conducting code review workshops can help developers improve their code review skills. These workshops can include hands-on exercises that focus on identifying security vulnerabilities and providing feedback on code quality. By actively participating in such workshops, developers can enhance their ability to spot security issues during code reviews.

#### Collaborations

Encouraging collaboration between developers and security professionals is essential for effective code reviews. Security professionals can provide guidance and support to developers during the code review process, ensuring that potential security vulnerabilities are adequately addressed.

## Roles and Responsibilities

### Role of developers in conducting code reviews

Code reviews are really important in software development, and developers have a big responsibility in making sure the code is good and secure. When doing security-focused code reviews, developers need to be trained to find possible security problems in the code they check. They should know about secure coding practices and be able to find common security issues, like problems with input validation and output encoding, authentication and authorization mistakes, and insecure ways of handling data.

Developers should also be responsible for providing constructive feedback during code reviews. This includes suggesting alternative implementations or pointing out potential improvements to enhance the security of the code. By actively participating in code reviews, developers can contribute to the overall security posture of the application and help prevent security incidents in the future.

### Responsibilities of security experts during code reviews

While developers are important in code reviews, security experts have a special job to make sure the code is thoroughly checked for security problems. These experts are usually part of a special security team and have special knowledge and skills to find and fix security issues.

During code reviews, security experts should focus on identifying security vulnerabilities that may have been missed by the developers. They should have a deep understanding of common security vulnerabilities and attack and use this knowledge to review the code for potential weaknesses. Additionally, security experts should provide guidance and work closely with developers to address any identified vulnerabilities.

### Collaboration between teams for efficient code reviews

Efficient code reviews require collaboration between developers and security experts. Both teams should work together to ensure that security concerns are addressed effectively. Collaboration can take various forms, such as regular meetings or discussions, sharing of knowledge and best practices, and providing feedback and guidance throughout the code review process.

Developers should actively seek guidance from security experts whenever they encounter complex security issues or need clarification on best practices. Similarly, security experts should be approachable and readily available to provide assistance and guidance to developers during code reviews. This collaborative approach not only enhances the overall security of the application but also promotes a culture of security awareness and continuous learning within the development team.

To make it easier for everyone to work together and make code reviews smoother, organizations can use different tools and resources. Some tools, like static code analysis, can automatically find common security problems and give developers helpful information during the code review. Other tools, like dynamic application security testing, can simulate real attacks and find vulnerabilities that may not be easily seen with static analysis alone. These tools can be really useful in keeping the code safe and secure.


{% embed https://dev.to/documatic/how-to-use-static-code-analysis-tools-to-improve-your-typescript-codebase-b6g %}

## Challenges in Security Code Reviews

Code reviews play a crucial role in ensuring the security and integrity of software applications. However, there are several challenges that organizations often face during security-focused code reviews. Understanding these challenges and implementing strategies to overcome them can significantly improve the code review process and enhance the overall security posture of the organization.

### Lack of Security Knowledge

One of the most common challenges is the lack of security knowledge among developers and reviewers. Many developers may not be aware of common security vulnerabilities and best practices, which can result in overlooking critical issues during the review process.

**Solution**

Providing security awareness training to developers can help address the lack of security knowledge. Training sessions can cover common vulnerabilities, best coding practices, and secure coding guidelines. By equipping developers with the necessary security knowledge, organizations can enhance the effectiveness of code reviews.

### Time Constraints

Code reviews, especially those focused on security, require time and attention to detail. However, developers often have tight deadlines and may prioritize functionality over security. This can lead to rushed and incomplete code reviews, increasing the risk of missing potential security vulnerabilities.

**Solution** 

When checking code for security, we should balance speed and thoroughness. We can do this by having clear guidelines for reviews, using tools that find security problems quickly, encouraging teamwork among developers, and training them to write secure code from the beginning. This way, we keep software safe without slowing down the process.

Establishing clear and concise security guidelines can help developers prioritize security during the code review process. These guidelines should include specific instructions on how to identify and address common security vulnerabilities. Regularly updating and reinforcing these guidelines can ensure that security remains a top priority.

### Communication Gaps

Effective communication between developers and security professionals is essential for successful code reviews. However, communication gaps and misunderstandings can occur due to differences in technical backgrounds and terminology. This can hinder the identification and resolution of security issues.

**Solution**

You can promote open communication, establish a common language, provide training sessions, encourage collaboration, use visual aids, and conduct follow-up discussions. These steps will enhance understanding between developers and security professionals, making it easier to identify and resolve security issues effectively.

### Complexity of Code

The complexity of modern software applications can pose a challenge during code reviews. Large codebases with multiple interconnected components can make it difficult to identify potential vulnerabilities and understand the overall security posture of the application.

**Solution**

Break down the code into smaller, manageable sections. Focus on reviewing one part at a time to ensure a thorough examination. Encourage developers to write clear and well-documented code, making it easier for reviewers to understand. Use tools and automated checks to identify potential vulnerabilities. Collaboration between team members can also help in discussing complex parts and finding solutions together. By taking these steps, code reviews can be more effective in ensuring the security of the software application.

### Resistance to Feedback

Developers may sometimes be resistant to feedback, especially when it comes to security issues. This can be due to a lack of awareness or a perception that addressing security vulnerabilities may impact development timelines or introduce additional complexity.

**Solution** 

You need to create a friendly atmosphere where everyone feels comfortable discussing security. Explain the importance of fixing security issues and offer help to understand and resolve them easily. By working together and supporting each other, developers will be more open to feedback and focused on improving software security.

### False Positives/Negatives

Automated security tools may generate false positives (flagging non-issues as vulnerabilities) or false negatives (missing actual security flaws).

**Solution**

Combine manual reviews with automated tools to reduce false positives/negatives. Encourage reviewers to verify the findings of automated tools manually. Regularly update and fine-tune the automated tools to improve their accuracy.

{% embed https://dev.to/documatic/awesome-sql-code-review-tools-for-developers-50c4 %}

By acknowledging and addressing these challenges, organizations can enhance the effectiveness of security code reviews and reduce the likelihood of security breaches in their software products. Regular code reviews, combined with a security-conscious development approach, can significantly improve the overall security posture of the software.

***

### Wrapping up

Code reviews are one of the most effective ways to provide security for software. They are a great way to catch vulnerabilities and other potential weaknesses in the code before software is even released.

Code reviews involve an informed, third-party reviewer who analyzes the code for potential security issues. A review can be conducted by any member of the development team who has knowledge of coding and the app under review. It is important that developers take the time to do a code review because it will help them identify potential security risks and vulnerabilities in their code that could otherwise go unnoticed.

So, my fellow developers, let us take what we have learned and apply it in our future. Let us continue to prioritize security in our code reviews and ensure that our software is as impenetrable as a bank vault. And remember, even though the road to secure and robust software development may be long and full of challenges, it's also filled with laughter, camaraderie, and the occasional victory dance when we finally squash that bug that has been haunting us for days.

If you want more articles on similar topics just let me know in the comments section. And don't forget to ❤️ the article. I'll see you in the next one. In the meantime you can follow me here: