Unveiling CodiumAI PR-Agent: A Comparative Analysis Against GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests
Tags: opensource, github, ai, productivity
Published: 2023-12-18 14:25:21

Comparing CodiumAI PR-Agent to Copilot for Pull Request

Are you drowning in pull requests? Are endless revisions slowing you down? Well, trust me you're not alone. This is because traditional workflows lack speed. All thanks to the advent of AI-powered pull request assistants a game-changer in efficiency and accuracy, reshaping how you work.

As you must have guessed there are so many solutions out there but the two prominent solutions are [CodiumAI's PR-Agent](https://www.codium.ai/products/git-plugin/) and [GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests](https://github.com/features/copilot). These titans promise enhanced workflows, superior code quality, and seamless collaboration. 

Before we dive in, it's important to let you know what you will learn in this article. This article is more than just a comparison article between **CodiumAI PR-Agent** and **GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests**, we will build a muscle memory from the ground up by looking at a series of important and key concepts before diving into the comparisons and their importance. Sounds good?

This article is aimed at developers and project managers who want to elevate their efficiency, collaboration, and code brilliance in team-based software development.

## What is a PR?

A Pull Request (PR) is a fundamental concept in version control and collaborative software development, primarily used in platforms like [GitHub](https://github.com/), [GitLab](https://about.gitlab.com/), or [Bitbucket](https://bitbucket.org/product). It's a mechanism that enables developers to propose changes to a codebase hosted in a repository.

### How does this work? 

- A developer makes changes in their local copy of a repository, such as fixing a bug or adding a new feature.
To incorporate these changes into the main codebase (often referred to as the "**master**" branch), they create a Pull Request.

- **Creating a Pull Request**: The developer creates a branch in the repository to work on their changes, separating them from the main codebase. Once the changes are complete, they initiate a Pull Request, signaling that they want their changes reviewed and potentially merged into the main branch.

- **Review Process**: Other team members or collaborators are invited to review the proposed changes within the Pull Request. Discussions, comments, and feedback occur within the PR, allowing for collaboration and refinement of the code.

- **Merge or Close**: After the changes in the PR have been reviewed, tested, and approved, the changes are merged into the main branch. If there are issues or the changes are not yet ready, the PR can be closed without merging.

## What are PR-Agents?
Pull Request Agents, are AI-powered assistants designed to enhance the process of reviewing and managing code changes within software development teams. These agents operate within version control platforms, analyzing code modifications proposed by developers before merging them into the main codebase.

In simpler terms, they're like smart collaborators that help developers improve the quality of their code changes and ensure smooth integration into the larger project. PR-Agents leverage machine learning and natural language processing to suggest improvements, detect potential issues, and assist with code reviews.

PR-Agent offers extensive pull request functionalities across various git providers: [GitHub](https://github.com/), [GitLab](https://about.gitlab.com/), or [Bitbucket](https://bitbucket.org/product), [CodeCommit](https://aws.amazon.com/codecommit/), [Azure DevOps](https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/products/devops), [Gerrit](https://www.gerritcodereview.com/). 

The diagram below illustrates PR-Agent tools and their flow:

![PR-Agent illustration](https://dev-to-uploads.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/articles/qyy62ikhifwc0i9ubade.png)

## Why do streamlined review procedures matter? 

It is a known fact that effective code reviews are the backbone of code quality, consistency, and maintainability, streamlined review processes ensure:

- **Timely Releases**: Prevent delays in releasing new features or updates.
- **Faster Development Workflow**: Avoid bottlenecks that slow down progress.
- **Enhanced Code Quality**: Minimize bugs and errors for a more robust product.
- **Positive Developer Experience**: Avoid frustration and dissatisfaction among team members.

Now that you understand the basics, let's move on to talk about these two technologies in detail.

## CodiumAI PR-Agent

![CodiumAI PR-Agent](https://dev-to-uploads.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/articles/u8sue0eu95tf1qfzozkm.png)

[CodiumAI PR-Agent](https://www.codium.ai/products/git-plugin/) is an open-source tool aiming to help developers review pull requests faster and more efficiently. This tool is built by AI experts [Itamar Friedman](https://www.linkedin.com/in/itamarf/), [Dedy Kredo](https://www.linkedin.com/in/dedy-kredo/), and other team members at [CodiumAI](https://www.codium.ai/). The PR-Agent gives developers and repo maintainers information to expedite the PR approval process. It also provides code suggestions that help improve the PR’s integrity, from finding bugs to (soon) providing meaningful tests. This seamless integration allows developers to see the effects of their work, without having to leave the git provider (GitHub, Gitlab, etc.) environment.

Using the PR-Agent, you can cut review time in half, write cleaner, and more efficient code. It automatically analyzes the commits and the PR and can provide several types of feedback:

- **PR Review**: Feedback about the PR main theme, type, relevant tests, security issues, focused PR, and various suggestions for the PR content. 
- **Code Suggestion**: Committable code suggestions for improving the PR. 
- **Auto-Description**: Automatically generating PR description - name, type, summary, and code walkthrough.
- **Question Answering**: Answering free-text questions about the PR.

Check out CodiumAI PR-Agent on [GitHub](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent).

> Installation
Follow these steps to install and run the [CodiumAI PR-Agent](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/INSTALL.md) tool on different git platforms.

CodiumAI PR-Agent automatically analyzes the pull request and provides several types of commands:

> Just mention `@CodiumAI-Agent` and add the desired command in any PR comment. The agent will generate a response based on your command e.g `@CodiumAI-Agent /review`

- `/describe`

The [describe tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/DESCRIBE.md) scans the PR code changes and automatically generates PR description - title, type, summary, walkthrough, and labels. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR. 

- `/review`

The [review tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/REVIEW.md) scans the PR code changes, and automatically generates a PR review. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR. 

- `/ask "..."`

The [ask tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/ASK.md) answers questions about the PR, based on the PR code changes. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR.

- `/improve`

The [improve tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/IMPROVE.md) scans the PR code changes, and automatically generates committable suggestions for improving the PR code. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR.

- `/update_changelog`

The [update_changelog tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/UPDATE_CHANGELOG.md) automatically updates the CHANGELOG.md file with the PR changes. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR.

- `/similar_issue`

The [similar issue tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/SIMILAR_ISSUE.md) retrieves the most similar issues to the current issue. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR.

- `/add_docs`

The [add_docs tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/ADD_DOCUMENTATION.md) scans the PR code changes and automatically suggests documentation for the undocumented code components (functions, classes, etc.). It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR.

- `/generate_labels`

The [generate_labels tool](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/docs/GENERATE_CUSTOM_LABELS.md) scans the PR code changes and given a list of labels and their descriptions, it automatically suggests labels that match the PR code changes. It can be invoked manually by commenting on any PR. 

Check out the usage guide for running the PR-Agent commands via different interfaces [here](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/Usage.md).

### Why use CodiumAI PR-Agent?

- It emphasizes real-life practical usage with each tool (review, improve, ask, etc.) having a single GPT-4 call, no more. 
- The time taken to obtain an answer is less than 30 seconds. 
- CodiumAI PR-Agent supports multiple git providers (GitHub, Gitlab, Bitbucket, CodeCommit), there are multiple ways to use the tool (CLI, GitHub Action, GitHub App, Docker, etc.), and multiple models (GPT-4, GPT-3.5, Anthropic, Cohere, Llama2).
- It is open-source, and contributions are welcome from the community.
- The JSON prompting strategy enables to have modular, customizable tools. For example, the `/review` tool categories can be controlled via the [configuration](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/pr_agent/settings/configuration.toml) file. Adding additional categories is easy and accessible.
- CodiumAI PR-Agent's [compression strategy](https://github.com/Codium-ai/pr-agent/blob/main/PR_COMPRESSION.md) has an ability that enables it to effectively tackle both short and long PRs.

## GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests

[GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests](https://github.com/features/copilot) is an AI-powered code completion tool developed by [GitHub](https://github.com/) in collaboration with [OpenAI](https://openai.com/). It integrates directly into the code editor, providing real-time suggestions and completions as developers write code. Leveraging OpenAI's GPT (G**enerative Pre-trained Transformer**) technology, Copilot analyzes the context of the code being written and generates suggestions for entire lines or chunks of code.

> Copilot helps developers to quickly discover alternative ways to solve problems, write tests, and explore new APIs without having to tediously tailor a search for answers on sites like Stack Overflow and across the internet, - says [Friedman](https://www.linkedin.com/in/natfriedman/) (GitHub CEO).

It aims to enhance developer productivity by offering intelligent code suggestions, reducing repetitive coding tasks, and providing assistance in various aspects of software development, ultimately aiming to expedite the coding process and improve code quality.

How GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests works is shown in the image below.

![GitHub Copilot internal workings](https://dev-to-uploads.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/articles/iktbthpqv8jt0b4vq9ke.png)

### Key features of GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests include:

- **AI-Powered Code Suggestions**: Copilot assists developers by offering suggestions for code completion, including function calls, variable assignments, loops, and more. It provides intelligent hints based on the current context and the desired functionality.

- **Natural Language Understanding**: Developers can write code in plain English-like descriptions or comments, and Copilot interprets these and generates corresponding code snippets. This allows for a more natural and expressive way of coding.

- **Support for Multiple Languages**: GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests supports various programming languages, enabling developers to receive contextually relevant code suggestions across a wide range of programming paradigms.

- **Autocompletion and Refactoring**: Copilot not only helps in writing new code but also assists in refactoring existing code by providing suggestions for optimizations, cleaner implementations, and more efficient solutions.

- **Learning from User Interactions**: As developers use Copilot, the tool learns from the interactions and feedback, improving its suggestions and adapting to developers' coding styles over time.

- **Collaborative Development**: Copilot facilitates collaborative coding by suggesting shared code snippets, enabling faster and more efficient teamwork.

- **Integration with GitHub**: Seamlessly integrated into the GitHub ecosystem, Copilot augments the coding experience for developers using GitHub's repositories and version control systems.

### GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests commands

GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests provides various commands, referred to as **copilot commands**, that allow developers to interact with the tool and get specific code suggestions or functionalities. Here's a list and explanation of some common Copilot commands:

- `@copilot` 

This command serves as a marker tag inserted in the pull request description or code comments to invoke Copilot's functionality. When used in a comment or description, Copilot reads these tags to understand the developer's intent and provide relevant code suggestions or actions.

- `@copilot:all`

A command that showcases all different kinds of content in one go. It's used to request diverse content suggestions from Copilot within a single command.

- `@copilot:summary`

This command expands to provide a concise, one-paragraph summary of the changes or functionality outlined in the pull request. It's useful for quickly grasping the essence of the modifications.

- `@copilot:walkthrough`

When used, this command expands to offer a detailed list of changes, including links to relevant pieces of code. It provides a more comprehensive overview of the modifications made in the pull request.

- `@copilot:poem`

An interesting command that requests Copilot to generate a poem related to the changes in the pull request. It's more of a creative or fun way to summarize modifications.


## CodiumAI PR-Agent vs. GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests

| Feature           | CodiumAI PR-Agent   | GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests |
| ----------------- | ------------------- |----------------|
| Availability       | Readily available              |       Waitlist required      |
| Open Source       | Yes               |       No         |
| Pricing           | Free for individual developers              |       Paid       |
| Supported commands       | Supports many command               |       Supports only one command      |
| Git platforms support       | All (GitHub, GitLab, Bitbucket, CodeCommit)                |     GitHub only      |
| IDE integration       | Available on Visual Studio Code, Vim, JetBrains IDEs              |       Available on Visual Studio Code, Vim, Neovim, JetBrains IDEs, Azure Data Studio |
| Multiple language support       | Yes              |       Yes      |
| Powered by GPT      | Yes               |       Yes       |
| Test Generation     | Yes               |       Yes       |
| Code Completion     | Yes               |       Yes       |
| Code Analysis       | Yes               |       Yes       |
| AI-powered Features       | Auto-description, code review, Q&A, code suggestion,documentation, etc.  |   Pull request summaries, review enhancements, auto-completion   |

## Some limitations of Codium PR-Agent
The PR-Agent is very resourceful too but it also comes with its limitations, let's have a look at some of these.

- **Quality and Security of Generated Code**

PR-Agent generates code based on patterns and examples from its training data. The quality and security of the suggested code may vary, potentially leading to suboptimal or insecure implementations. It's crucial to review and validate the generated code thoroughly.

- **Biases and Inaccuracies**

Like any AI model, PR-Agent might exhibit biases or inaccuracies present in its training data. It might generate code that reflects biases or includes inaccuracies, requiring developers to critically assess and validate the suggestions.


- **Open Source Collaboration**

The transparent and community-backed nature of open-source tools offers great visibility and support from a diverse pool of contributors. However, this collaborative approach might result in a slower pace of development and features that might lack the refined polish found in proprietary tools such as GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests.

- **Limited Understanding of Context**

Explanation: While PR-Agent excels at providing suggestions, it might lack a deep understanding of specific project contexts, business requirements, or domain-specific intricacies. Developers might need to fine-tune or adapt the suggestions to fit their particular use cases.


## Conclusion

Exploring AI-driven pull request tools has been enlightening. CodiumAI's PR-Agent and GitHub Copilot for Pull Requests offer valuable support, each with its distinct strengths. Those valuing customization, adaptability, and immediate accessibility might favor CodiumAI's PR-Agent.

PR-Agent's extensive command toolkit empowers users to tailor the tool to their preferences, in contrast to Copilot's single-command approach. This granularity facilitates personalized code analysis, pull request descriptions, and interactive functions, fostering a closer bond with the tool and amplifying productivity.

PR-Agent's platform flexibility enables diverse teams to standardize workflows across platforms, ensuring uniform code quality. Its adaptable pricing structure democratizes AI access, making it inclusive for all. With scalable paid tiers offering advanced features, it caters to varied team needs—ready for instant use, no waiting, no subscriptions. 


{% embed https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YZQSwUbqQrc&t=2s %}