Yet Another Post on AI and Copyright
Tags: ai, copyright
Published: 2023-10-26 02:42:39

A few days ago the news of Nightshade overtook the internet. Nightshade is a tool devised by researchers at the University of Chicago with the primary aim of protecting artists' works from unauthorized use by AI models, particularly in image generation. The mechanism it employs is termed 'data poisoning', which involves subtly altering images in a way that is imperceptible to humans but can significantly disrupt AI models during their training phase. When an AI model processes a 'poisoned' image, it may misinterpret the content, resulting in distorted outcomes that deviate from the intended or original art.

The project was led under the guidance of computer science professor Ben Zhao. He spearheaded the team that created Nightshade with a vision of tipping the power balance back from AI companies towards artists, ensuring that the rights and original works of artists are duly protected against unauthorized usage by AI models.

A quick internet search and you can see the not-so-right images generated by AI poisoned by Nightshade ([from dataconomy.com](https://dataconomy.com/2023/10/25/nightshade-ai-art-artist/))

![](https://dev-to-uploads.s3.amazonaws.com/uploads/articles/ok6037g72y7bk8kzm2r6.png)

Well, here's what ChatGPT thinks that AI can do to get around data poisoning, seems like it will be quite the arms race:

> The advent of data poisoning as a mechanism to thwart unauthorized use of artistic creations by AI, as exhibited by the Nightshade tool, presents a new challenge for the AI community. However, the evolutionary nature of AI suggests that methods to counteract data poisoning could emerge over time. Here are speculative approaches on how AI might adapt to or overcome data poisoning:

> 1. **Enhanced Detection Algorithms:** AI could be equipped with sophisticated algorithms capable of detecting and neutralizing poisoned data either before or during the training process. These algorithms might identify unusual patterns or inconsistencies indicative of data poisoning.

> 2. **Robust Training Data Verification:** Implementing rigorous verification processes to ascertain the integrity and authenticity of training data could mitigate the risks posed by data poisoning. This might include verifying data sources and employing data integrity checks like checksums.

> 3. **Advanced Data Cleaning and Pre-processing:** Employing advanced data cleaning and pre-processing techniques could help identify and eliminate poisoned data from training datasets. This might involve statistical analysis to detect outliers or anomalies indicative of data poisoning.

> 4. **Meta-Learning and Transfer Learning:** Meta-learning, where AI learns the process of learning, could yield models less susceptible to data poisoning. Similarly, transfer learning could be used to train new models on clean data, making them more robust against data poisoning.

> 5. **Human-in-the-loop (HITL) Training:** Incorporating human oversight during training could provide an additional layer of protection against data poisoning. Humans could review training data, model parameters, and outputs to identify and rectify issues stemming from data poisoning.

> 6. **Multi-Modal Learning:** Training AI on data from multiple sources or modalities could foster models that are more resilient to data poisoning. If one modality is poisoned, the AI might still learn accurate models from the other modalities.

> 7. **Federated Learning:** This decentralized training approach could potentially diversify the sources of training data and the environments in which training occurs, thus reducing the risks associated with data poisoning.

> 8. **Adversarial Training:** Training AI models to recognize and resist adversarial attacks, including data poisoning, by exposing them to poisoned data in a controlled environment, and teaching them to correct for it.

> 9. **Blockchain for Data Verification:** Utilizing blockchain technology to verify the authenticity and integrity of training data could provide a robust mechanism to combat data poisoning.

> 10. **Legal and Regulatory Measures:** Establishing strict legal and regulatory frameworks to deter and penalize data poisoning could also play a significant role in mitigating this challenge.

Ah, how cute! It has proposed that we set laws against data poisoning, hehe. It proceeds to say, 

> These speculative methods underscore the potential pathways towards addressing the challenges posed by data poisoning in AI training processes. Through a combination of technological innovation and legal frameworks, it might be possible to strike a balance that fosters AI evolution while ensuring the rightful protection of original artistic creations.

Well folks, This is gonna be an interesting adventure.