English: First Minister, you've just referred to SAGE, but SAGE said in September that a curfew on bars would have a marginal impact on reducing transmissions. You say there is evidence; well, if there is evidence, publish that evidence so that people can see the results of your proposals. And let's be clear: nowhere else in the UK are hospitality businesses facing these sorts of measures on a national basis. Here, in Wales, a pub will be open but won't be allowed to sell any alcohol whether it's in Cardiff or Conwy. Do you except these businesses to survive on pop and pork scratchings? Now, First Minister, Carlsberg UK have said this, and I quote: 'Leaving pubs open, but only until 6.00 p.m. with no service of a responsibly enjoyed beer or glass of wine shows a complete lack of understanding or respect for this crucial part of our society and the sector.' And Alistair Darby of Brains has said that the new rules for pubs are a 'huge slap in the face' for the sector. Of course, the Welsh Government must now ensure that business support is made available urgently, and that it's accessible to those that need it. Now, you'll have to forgive businesses across Wales if they're not entirely confident that they'll get the help that they need. The shambolic handling of the economic resilience fund phase 3 must not be allowed to be repeated. However, we've just heard from your economy Minister that businesses will not be able to apply for financial support until January. First Minister, that is simply not good enough. Do you seriously believe that businesses will survive this period, given that they will not be able to access support until January, and, therefore, will you now reconsider this catastrophic decision and ensure that businesses get the help they need now and not in four or five weeks' time?
Welsh: Prif Weinidog, rydych chi newydd gyfeirio at SAGE, ond dywedodd SAGE ym mis Medi y byddai cyrffyw ar fariau yn cael effaith ymylol ar leihau trosglwyddiadau. Rydych hi'n dweud bod tystiolaeth; wel, os oes tystiolaeth, cyhoeddwch y dystiolaeth honno fel y gall pobl weld canlyniadau eich cynigion. A gadewch i ni fod yn eglur: nid oes busnesau lletygarwch yn unman arall yn y DU yn wynebu'r mathau hyn o fesurau ar sail genedlaethol. Yma, yng Nghymru, bydd tafarn ar agor ond ni fydd yn cael gwerthu unrhyw alcohol pa un a yw yng Nghaerdydd neu yng Nghonwy. A ydych chi'n disgwyl i'r busnesau hyn oroesi ar ddiodydd ysgafn a chrafiadau porc? Nawr, Prif Weinidog, mae Carlsberg UK wedi dweud hyn, a dyfynnaf: 'Mae gadael tafarndai ar agor, ond dim ond tan 6.00 p.m. heb weini cwrw neu wydraid o win i'w fwynhau yn gyfrifol yn dangos diffyg dealltwriaeth a pharch llwyr at y rhan hollbwysig hon o'n cymdeithas a'r sector.' Ac mae Alistair Darby o Brains wedi dweud bod y rheolau newydd i dafarndai yn 'ergyd enfawr' i'r sector. Wrth gwrs, mae'n rhaid i Lywodraeth Cymru sicrhau nawr bod cymorth busnes ar gael ar frys, a'i fod yn hygyrch i'r rhai sydd ei angen. Nawr, bydd yn rhaid i chi faddau i fusnesau ledled Cymru os nad ydyn nhw'n gwbl ffyddiog y byddan nhw'n cael y cymorth sydd ei angen arnyn nhw. Ni ddylid caniatáu i'r ffordd draed moch o ymdrin â cham 3 y gronfa cadernid economaidd gael ei hailadrodd. Fodd bynnag, rydym ni newydd glywed gan eich Gweinidog yr economi na fydd busnesau yn gallu gwneud cais am gymorth ariannol tan fis Ionawr. Prif Weinidog, nid yw hynny'n ddigon da. A ydych o ddifrif yn credu y bydd busnesau yn goroesi'r cyfnod hwn, o gofio na fyddan nhw'n gallu cael cymorth tan fis Ionawr, ac, felly, a wnewch chi ailystyried nawr y penderfyniad trychinebus hwn a sicrhau bod busnesau yn cael y cymorth sydd ei angen arnyn nhw nawr ac nid ymhen pedair neu bum wythnos?