English: Minister, I'd like a statement, please, that will provide some reassurance to my business owners and which justifies how you've taken those decisions to restrict the sale of alcohol and actually close pubs, clubs, bars, restaurants and hospitality businesses from 6 o'clock on Friday. I want some explanation why, and what evidence you've used to decide that, but also how you're going to fund this terrific loss of business that many of our businesses are going to incur. The economic resilience fund lifeline you are offering is simply not good enough and, according to Business Wales, some payments will not even start to reach businesses until January. So, your Government's actions will see hospitality businesses lose even more money. Businesses have now to make an online application to their respective local authority for the discretionary elements. Like last time, is there a likelihood that this money will run out? Applications are still going to be dealt with on a first-come, first-served basis. We saw what happened last time - it crashed after just a day. I've still got people who've not had any funding yet from phase 3, so what confidence can I have that, as a Government, you're going to take some responsibility for these lockdowns that you've forced on our businesses? Will you please provide a statement on that and how you will ensure that all applications are appraised, whether an appeals process is likely to be made available and, finally, whether commercial galleries that sell art - I have a very good gallery in my constituency that sells art - will have to close? If they do, how is it, therefore, fair that shops can sell art to the public? There are so many questions that we have, Minister, and I think, as finance Minister, you should really be putting some more information out there that we can explain to our businesses, and I'd like it on record that I'm absolutely appalled by the decision made by you, your Government and the First Minister.
Welsh: Gweinidog, fe hoffwn i gael datganiad i roi rhywfaint o sicrwydd i'r rhai sy'n berchen ar fusnesau yn fy ardal i a chyfiawnhad am y penderfyniadau hynny a wnaethoch chi i gyfyngu ar werthu alcohol a chau tafarndai, clybiau, bariau, bwytai a busnesau lletygarwch o 6 o'r gloch ddydd Gwener. Rwy'n awyddus i gael rhywfaint o esboniad pam, a pha dystiolaeth a oedd gennych wrth benderfynu ar hynny ond hefyd sut ydych chi am ariannu'r golled aruthrol hon i lawer iawn o'n busnesau ni. Nid yw'r gronfa cadernid economaidd yr ydych chi'n ei chynnig yn ddigonol, ac yn ôl Busnes Cymru ni fydd rhai taliadau yn dechrau cyrraedd y busnesau hyd yn oed tan fis Ionawr. Felly, fe fydd camau eich Llywodraeth chi yn golygu y bydd busnesau lletygarwch yn colli mwy byth o arian. Mae'n rhaid i fusnesau wneud cais ar-lein erbyn hyn i'w hawdurdod lleol perthnasol nhw am yr elfennau dewisol. Fel y tro diwethaf, a oes yna debygolrwydd y bydd yr arian hwn yn dod i ben? Fe gaiff y ceisiadau eu trin o hyd ar sail y cyntaf i'r felin. Fe welsom ni'r hyn a ddigwyddodd y tro diwethaf - fe chwalodd y system ymhen un diwrnod yn unig. Rwy'n gwybod am rai yn y rhanbarth nad ydyn nhw byth wedi cael unrhyw gyllid o gam 3, felly pa hyder sydd gennyf i y byddwch chi, yn y Llywodraeth, yn cymryd rhywfaint o gyfrifoldeb am y cyfyngiadau hyn a orfodwyd ar ein busnesau? A wnewch chi roi datganiad ar hynny, os gwelwch chi'n dda, a sut y byddwch chi'n sicrhau y bydd pob cais yn cael ei werthuso, a fydd proses apelio yn debygol o fod ar gael ac, yn olaf, a fydd yn rhaid i orielau masnachol sy'n gwerthu gwaith celf gau? - mae gennyf i oriel dda iawn yn fy etholaeth i sy'n gwerthu gweithiau celf. Os mai felly y bydd hi, sut ellir cyfiawnhau y gall siopau werthu gwaith celf i'r cyhoedd? Mae llaweroedd o gwestiynau gennym ni, Gweinidog, ac yn fy marn i, fe ddylech chi, fel Gweinidog Cyllid, roi mwy o wybodaeth inni fel y gallwn egluro i'n busnesau ni. Ac fe hoffwn i ddweud ar goedd fy mod i wedi cael fy siomi'n ddirfawr gan y penderfyniad a wnaethoch chi, eich Llywodraeth chi a'r Prif Weinidog.