Worldwide Disparities in Recovery of Cardiac Testing 1 Year Into COVID-19
Authors: Andrew J. Einstein, Cole Hirschfeld, Michelle C. Williams, Joao V. Vitola, Nathan Better, Todd C. Villines, Rodrigo Cerci, Leslee J. Shaw, Andrew D. Choi, Sharmila Dorbala, Ganesan Karthikeyan, Bin Lu, Valentin Sinitsyn, Alexey A. Ansheles, Takashi Kudo, Chiara Bucciarelli-Ducci, Bjarne Linde Nørgaard, Pál Maurovich-Horvat, Roxana Campisi, Elisa Milan, Lizette Louw, Adel H. Allam, Mona Bhatia, Lorenzo Sewanan, Eli Malkovskiy, Yosef Cohen, Michael Randazzo, Jagat Narula, Olga Morozova, Thomas N.B. Pascual, Yaroslav Pynda, Maurizio Dondi, Diana Paez, Andrew J. Einstein, Diana Paez, Maurizio Dondi, Nathan Better, Rodrigo Cerci, Sharmila Dorbala, Ganesan Karthikeyan, Thomas N.B. Pascual, Leslee J. Shaw, Todd C. Villines, Joao V. Vitola, Michelle C. Williams, Yaroslav Pynda, Gerd Hinterleitner, Yao Lu, Olga Morozova, Zhuoran Xu, Cole B. Hirschfeld, Yosef Cohen, Ikenna Erinne, Eli Malkovskiy, Michael Randazzo, Lorenzo Sewanan, Mrinali Shetty, Andrew Choi, Juan Lopez-Mattei, Purvi Parwani, Artan Goda, Ervina Shirka, Salah Bouyoucef, Lydia Chelghoum, Farouk Mansouri, Abdelkader Medjahedi, Qais Naili, Mokhtar Ridouh, Diego Alasia, Lucia Alberghina, Natalia Aramayo, Diego Buchara, Franco Gabriel Busso, Jose Javier Bustos Rivadero, Jorge Camilletti, Hugo Campanelli, Roxana Campisi, Ricardo Belisario Castro, Mariana Daicz, Horacio del Riego, Laura Dragonetti, Diego Echazarreta, Juan Erriest, Fernando Faccio, Adolfo Facello, Hugo Gallegos, Ricardo Geronazzo, Horacio Glait, Victor Hasbani, Victor Jäger, Julio Manuel Lewkowicz, Jose Lotti, Neiva Maciel, Osvaldo Masoli, Edgardo Mastrovito, Maria Medus, Maria Fernanda Merani, Susana Molteni, Marcos Montecinos, Gustavo Parisi, Claudio Pereyra Sueldo, Diego Perez de Arenaza, Luis Quintana, Alejandro Radzinschi, Marcela Redruello, Marina Rodríguez, Horacio Rojas, Arturo Romero Acuña, Daniel Schere, Sonia Traverso, Gustavo Vazquez, Susana Zeffiro, Mari Sakanyan, Scott Beuzeville, Raef Boktor, Michael Crowley, D'Arne Downie, Girish Dwivedi, Barry Elison, Omar Farouque, Kim Jasper, Subodh Joshi, Joseph Lee, Kenneth Lee, Elaine Lui, Peter Mcconachie, Joanne Meaker, Dee Nandurkar, Johanne Neill, Edward O'Rourke, Patricia O'Sullivan, George Pandos, Manuja Premaratne, David Prior, Natalie Rutherford, Connor Saunders, Kim Taubman, Andrew Tauro, Andrew Taylor, James Theuerle, Paul Thomas, Jonathan Tow, Anthony Upton, Shankar Vamadevan, Victor Wayne, Eva Alina Wegner, David Wong, John Younger, Dietrich Beitzke, Gudrun Feuchtner, Oliver Sommer, Konrad Weiss, Natallia Maroz-Vadalazhskaya, Uladzimir Tserakhau, Filip Homans, Caroline M. Van De Heyning, Raúl Araujo, Valentina Soldat-Stankovic, Sinisa Stankovic, Augusto Almeida, Carlos Anselmi, Guilherme S.A. Azevedo, Marcio Sommer Bittencourt, Diego Bromfman Pianta, Estevan Cabeda, Lara Carreira, Rodrigo Cerci, Igor Coelho, Fernando de Amorim Fernandes, Andrea de Lorenzo, Roberta Delgado, Fernanda Erthal, Fabio Fernandes, Juliano Fernandes, Thiago Ferreira de Souza, Murilo Foppa, Wilson Furlan Matos Alves, Cibele Gontijo, Ilan Gottlieb, Gabriel Grossman, Maria Helena Albernaz Siqueira, Cesar Higa Nomura, Katia Hiromoto Koga, Ronaldo Lima, Rafael Lopes, Hugo Humberto Marçal Filho, Paulo Masiero, Luiz Mastrocola, Maria Eduarda Menezes de Siqueira, Claudio Mesquita, Danilo Naves, Filipe Penna, Ibraim Pinto, Thércio Rocha, Juliana Leal Rocha, Alfredo Rodrigues, Leila Salioni, Adelina Sanches, Marcelo Santos, Leonardo Sara Da Silva, Paulo Schvartzman, Cristina Sebastião Matushita, Tiago Senra, Marcelo Silva, Carlos Eduardo Soares, Bernardo Spiro, Carlos Eduardo Suaide Silva, Rafael Torres, Guilherme Urpia Monte, Andrea Vilela, Alexandre Volney Villa, Joao Vitola, Themissa Voss, Roberto Waltrick, Marcello Zapparoli, Hamid Naseer, Marina Garcheva-Tsacheva, Tiémégna Florence Ouattara, Sarameth Thou, Soley Varoeun, Gad Abikhzer, Rob Beanlands, Michael Chetrit, Dominique Dabreo, Carole Dennie, Matthias Friedrich, Mohmmed Nassoh Hafez, Kate Hanneman, Robert Miller, Anastasia Oikonomou, Idan Roifman, Gary Small, Vikas Tandon, Adwait Trivedi, James White, Katherine Zukotynski, Rita Alay, Carmen Concha, Teresa Massardo, Pedro Abad, Kelly Anzola, Harold Arturo, Luis Benitez, Alberto Cadena, Carlos Caicedo Zamudio, Antonio Calderón, Claudia T. Gutierrez Villamil, Claudia Jaimes, Juan L. Londono, Nelson Lopez, Sonia Merlano-Gaitan, Ramon Murgieitio-Cabrera, Manuel Valencia, Damiana Vergel, Alejandro Zuluaga Santamaria, Felix Solis, Tonci Batinic, Maja Franceschi, Maja Hrabak Paar, Marina Prpic, Cuba: Juan Felipe Batista, Lazaro Omar Cabrera, Amalia Peix, Yamilé Peña, Luis Manuel Rochela Vázquez, Ioannis Ntalas, Milan Kaminek, Vladimir Kincl, Otto Lang, Jawdat Abdulla, Morten Bøttcher, Martin Busk, Uka Geisler, Lars C. Gormsen, Nicolaj Hansson, Søren Hess, Jens Hove, Lars Thorbjoern Jensen, Magnus T. Jensen, Kristian Hay Kragholm, Bjarne L. Nørgaard, Kristian Øvrehus, Jan Rasmussen, Niels Peter Rønnow Sand, Hanne Sondergaard, Tomas Zaremba, Herwin Speckter, Nelson Amores, Mayra Sanchez Velez, Taghreed Abd Alrahman, Sherif Abd Elsamad, Alia Abdelfattah, Adel Allam, Sameh Elkaffas, Mona Hassan, Elshaymaa Hussein, Ahmed Ibrahim, Ahmed Kandeel, Mohamed Mandour Ali, Mahmoud Shaaban, Camila Flores, Verónica Vanesa Gómez Leiva, Anita Liiver, Martti Larikka, Valtteri Uusitalo, Denis Agostini, Clothilde Berger, Matthieu Dietz, Fabien Hyafil, Mickaël Ohana, Kevin Prigent, Hamza Regaieg, Laure Sarda-Mantel, Darach O. H-Ici, Harold Ayetey, George Angelidis, Christina Fragkaki, Chrysoula Fragkiadaki, Panagiotis Georgoulias, Maria Koutelou, Elena Kyrozi, Niki Lama, Ioannis Ntalas, Vassilis Prassopoulos, Michael Spartalis, Theodora Zaglavara, Carla Gonzalez, Goleat Gutierrez, Alejandro Maldonado, Yassine Martinez, Attila Kovács, Bálint Szilveszter, Nilesh Banthia, Vivek Bhat, Mona Bhatia, Partha Choudhury, Vijay Sai Chowdekar, Johann Christopher, Tushar Garg, Naresh Kumar Goyal, Ripen Kumar Gupta, Abhishek Gupta, Julie Hephzibah, Shashank Jain, Jesu Krupa, Parveen Kumar, Sukriti Kumar, Arati Lalchandani, Animesh Mishra, Vivaswan Dutt Mishra, Parul Mohan, Ahmad Ozair, Shivani Pandey, Ramanathapuram Parameswaran, Chetan Patel, Tapan Patel, Shivani Patel, Leena Robinson Vimala, Dr Pradosh Kumar Sarangi, Shantanu Sengupta, Arvind Sethi, Amit Sharma, Awadhesh Kumar Sharma, Punit Sharma, Apurva Shrigiriwar, Santosh Singh, Harpreet Singh, Ashwani Sood, Atul Verma, Ajay Vyas, Erwin Affandi Soeriadi, Edison Bun, Febby Hutomo, Hilman Syawaluddin, Ryan Yudistiro, Amjed Albadr, Majid Assadi, Farshad Emami, Alireza Emami-Ardekani, Saeed Farzanehfar, Ramezan Jafari, Reyhaneh Manafi-Farid, Maryam Tajik, Yoav Arnson, Shmuel Fuchs, Ronen Goldkorn, John Kennedy, Marina Leitman, Aryeh Shalev, Wanda Acampa, Domenico Albano, Pierpaolo Alongi, Gaspare Arnone, Roberta Assante, Anna Baritussio, Matteo Bauckneht, Francesco Bianco, Rachele Bonfiglioli, Francesco Bovenzi, Isabella Bruno, Andrea Bruno, Elena Busnardo, Elena Califaretti, Roberta Casoni, Vittorio Censullo, Franca Chierichetti, Marcello Chiocchi, Corrado Cittanti, Alberto Clemente, Alberto Cuocolo, Maria Luisa De Rimini, Giuseppe De Vincentis, Veronica Della Tommasina, Santo Dellegrottaglie, Paola Anna Erba, Laura Evangelista, Lara Faggi, Evelina Faragasso, Luigia Florimonte, Viviana Frantellizzi, Marco Gatti, Angela Gaudiano, Fabrizia Gelardi, Alberto Gerali, Alessia Gimelli, Marco Guglielmo, Lucia Leccisotti, Riccardo Liga, Carlo Liguori, Giampiero Longo, Margherita Maffione, Claudio Marcassa, Giovanni Matassa, Donato Mele, Elisa Milan, Luca Mircoli, Andrea Paccagnella, Sara Pacella, Federica Padovano, Dario Pellegrini, Valeria Pergola, Luca Pugliese, Natale Quartuccio, Lucia Rampin, Fabrizio Ricci, Giuseppe Rubini, Vincenzo Russo, Gianmario Sambuceti, Alessandra Scatteia, Roberto Sciagrà, Gianluca Spidalieri, Antonella Stefanelli, Carlo Tedeschi, Guido Ventroni, Dainia Baugh, Ernest Madu, Tadao Aikawa, Hiroshi Asano, Shinichiro Fujimoto, Koichiro Fujise, Yoshimitsu Fukushima, Kae Fukuyama, Yasutaka Ichikawa, Reiko Ideguchi, Nobuo Iguchi, Masamichi Imai, Hayato Ishimura, Satoshi Isobe, Kimiteru Ito, Yu Izawa, Toshiaki Kadokami, Tokuo Kasai, Takao Kato, Takashi Kawamoto, Shigeru Kiryu, Shinichiro Kumita, Osamu Manabe, Hirotaka Maruno, Naoya Matsumoto, Masao Miyagawa, Masao Moroi, Shigeki Nagamachi, Kenichi Nakajima, Ryo Nakazato, Mamoru Nanasato, Masanao Naya, Takashi Norikane, Yasutoshi Ohta, Yoichi Otomi, Hideki Otsuka, Noriko Oyama-Manabe, Masaki Saito, Masayoshi Sarai, Junichi Sato, Daisuke Sato, Shinya Shiraishi, Kentaro Takanami, Kazuya Takehana, Yasuyo Taniguchi, Hiroki Teragawa, Nobuo Tomizawa, Kyoko Umeji, Yasushi Wakabayashi, Shinichiro Yamada, Shinya Yamazaki, Tatsuya Yoneyama, Mohammad Rawashdeh, Tairkhan Dautov, Khalid Makhdomi, Mostafa Abass, Masoud Garashi, Qaisar Siraj, Marika Kalnina, Mohamad Haidar, Renata Komiagiene, Giedre Kviecinskiene, Donatas Vajauskas, Noor Khairiah A. Karim, Mady Doucoure, Luise Reichmuth, Anthony Samuel, Mohamed Lemine Dieng, Ambedhkar Shantaram Naojee, Estrella Aguilera Hernandez, Cesar Rene Alducin Tellez, Erick Alexánderson-Rosas, Erika Barragan, Manuel Cabada, Daniel Calderón, Isabel Carvajal-Juarez, José Esparza, Manlio Gerardo Gama-Moreno, Virginia Garcia Quinto, Nelsy Coromoto Gonzalez, Mary Carmen Herrera-Zarza, Aloha Meave, Jesus Gregorio Medina Verdugo, Gabriela Melendez, Rafael Humberto Morales Murguia, Carlos Salvador Navarro Quiroz, Mario Ornelas, Andres Preciado-Anaya, Oscar Ulises Preciado-Gutiérrez, Adriana Puente, Aristóteles Ramírez Salazar, Sandra Graciela Rosales Uvera, Sandra Rosales-Uvera, Jose Antonio Serna Macias, Lilia Sierra-Galan, Lilia M. Sierra-Galan, Juan Carlos Tirado Alderete, Enrique Vallejo, Marc Faraggi, Erdenechimeg Sereegotov, Nouzha Ben Rais, Nadia Ismaili Alaoui, Thiri Kyiphyu, Su Thet Oo, Soe Myat Win, Htin Zar, Ram Ghimire, Madhu Neupane, Andor Glaudemans, Riemer Slart, Derk Verschure, Berry Allen, John Edmond, Clare Mckenzie, Stuart Tie, Niels Van Pelt, Kirsten Worthington, Calum Young, Idrissa Adamou Soli, Shehu Kana, Uchenna Onubogu, Mahmoud Sani, Anders Tjellaug Bråten, Arve Jørgensen, Hanne-Elin Vassbotn, Humoud Al Dhuhli, Zabah Jawa, Naima Tag, Shazia Fatima, Muhammad Babar Imran, Muhammad Numair Younis, Mohammad Saadullah, Yariela Herrera Malo, Dora Lenturut-Katal, Manuel Castillo, José Ortellado, Afroza Akhter, F. Aaysha Cader, Raihan Hussain, Saidur Rahman Khan, Tapati Mandal, Faria Nasreen, Yunqiang An, Dianbo Cao, Lianggeng Gong, Yang Hou, Chongfu Jia, Tao Li, Caiying Li, Hui Liu, Wenya Liu, Jinkang Liu, Bin Lu, Ming-Yen Ng, Heshui Shi, Chunxiang Tang, Ximing Wang, Zhaoqian Wang, Yining Wang, Jiang Wu, Yan Yi, Li Yuan, Tong Zhang, Longjiang Zhang, Edith Chavez, Carlos Cruz, Christian Llontop, Rosanna Morales, Paz Abrihan, Asela Bustos-Barroso, Michele Duldulao-Ogbac, Christopher Eduarte, Jerry Obaldo, Alvin Quinon, Belinda San Juan, Carlo Joe San Juan, Marie Rhiamar Sauler-Gomez, Mila Uy, Magdalena Kostkiewicz, Jolanta Kunikowska, Anna Teresinska, Tomasz Urbanik, Nuno Bettencourt, Ricardo Fontes-Carvalho, Cristina Gavina, Lino Gonçalves, Filipe Macedo, Nuno Moreno, Carla Sousa, Ana Teresa Timoteo, Maria João Vidigal, Mahmoud Al Heidous, Subramaniyan Ramanathan, Samer Arnous, Said Aytani, Angela Byrne, Tadhg Gleeson, David Kerins, Julie O'Brien, Ji-In Bang, Henry Bom, Miju Cheon, Gi Jeong Cheon, Sang-Geon Cho, Chae Moon Hong, Yong Hyu Jeong, Won Jun Kang, Yeon-Koo Kang, Ji-Young Kim, So Won Oh, Young So, Ho-Chun Song, Kyoung Sook Won, Soo Woong Yoo, Irena Mitevska, Marija Vavlukis, Barbara Gužic Salobir, Monika Štalc, Theodora Benedek, Marian Pop, Claudiu Stan, Alexey Ansheles, Olga Dariy, Nina Gagarina, Irina Itskovich, Anatoliy Karalkin, Alexander Kokov, Gulya Marina, Ekaterina Migunova, Viktor Pospelov, Daria Ryzhkova, Guzaliya Sayfullina, Vladimir Sergienko, Irina Shurupova, Valentin Sinitsyn, Margarita Vakhromeeva, Nailia Valiullina, Konstantin Zavadovsky, Kirill Zhuravlev, Rami Abazid, Turki Al Garni, Mirvat Alasnag, Ahmed Aljizeeri, Hamid Amer, Ahmad Amro, Hesham Hamdy, Osama Smettei, Dragana Sobic Saranovic, Marina Vlajkovic, Felix Keng, Jason See, Zuzana Berecova, Jana Polakova Mistinova, Osayande Evbuomwan, Nerisha Govender, Jonathan Hack, Bawinile Hadebe, Khanyisile Hlongwa, Mitchell Kaplan, Hoosen Lakhi, Katarina Milos, Moshe Modiselle, Stuart More, Ntanganedzeni Muambadzi, Leonie Scholtz, Manuel Barreiro-Perez, Isabel Blanco, Jordi Broncano, Alicia Camarero, Irene Casáns-Tormo, Javier De Haro, Albert Flotats, Elia García, Ceferino Gutierrez Mendiguchia, Amelia Jimenez-Heffernan, Ruben Leta, Javier Lopez Diaz, Luis Lumbreras Vega, Ana Manovel-Sánchez, Amparo Martinez Monzonis, Bianca Patrut, Virginia Pubul, Ricardo Ruano Perez, Nahla Zeidan, Damayanthi Nanayakkara, Ahmed Suliman, Henrik Engblom, Mustafa Murtadha, Ellen Ostenfeld, Magnus Simonsson, Hatem Alkadhi, Ronny Ralf Buechel, Peter Burger, Christoph Gräni, Christel Kamani, Nadine Kawel-Böhm, Bernd Klaeser, Robert Manka, John Prior, Tawika Kaewchur, Benjapa Khiewvan, Arpakorn Kositwattanarerk, Sirianong Namwongprom, Tanyaluck Thientunyakit, Haluk Burcak Sayman, Mahmut Yüksel, Mugisha Julius Sebikali, Emmy Okello, Pavlo Korol, Iryna Noverko, Maryna Satyr, Tahir Ahmad, Khaled Alfakih, Ivo Andrade, Susan Buckingham, Anda Bularga, John-Paul Carpenter, Graham Cole, David Cusack, Sarojini David, Patrick Davis, Timothy Fairbairn, Arjun Ghosh, Prasad Guntur Ramkumar, Mark Hamilton, Faisal Haque, Benjamin Hudson, Annette Johnstone, V.J. Karthikeyan, Mike Kay, Mohammad Ali Khan, Jamie Kitt, Chen Sheng Low, Elisa Mcalindon, David Mccreavy, Brian Morrissey, Manish Motwani, Dilip Na, Edward Nicol, Dilip Patel, Jonathan Rodrigues, Chris Rofe, Rebecca Schofield, Thomas Semple, Azeem Sheikh, Apurva Sinha, Deepak Subedi, William Topping, Katherine Tweed, Stephen Richard Underwood, Jonathan Weir-Mccall, Hamed Zuhairy, Taimur Abbasi, Shady Abohashem, Sandra Abramson, Mouaz Al-Mallah, Mohan Ashok Kumar, Mallory Balmer-Swain, Daniel Berman, Adam Bernheim, Sabha Bhatti, Robert Biederman, Erik Bieging, Scott Bingham, Stephen Bloom, Sean Blue, Andressa Borges, Kelley Branch, Paco Bravo, Sujatha Buddhe, Matthew Budoff, Renée Bullock-Palmer, Michael Cahill, Candace Candela, Jane Cao, Saurav Chatterjee, Yiannis Chatzizisis, Nita Ray Chaudhuri, Michael Cheezum, Anjali Chelliah, Tiffany Chen, Marcus Chen, Lu Chen, Andrew Choi, Aalap Chokshi, Jina Chung, Sorin Danciu, William DeSisto, Michael Dilorenzo, Rami Doukky, William Duvall, Maros Ferencik, Cameron Foster, Anthon Fuisz, Michael Gannon, David German, Myron Gerson, Jeffrey Geske, Fadi Hage, Agha Haider, Sofia Haider, Yasmin Hamirani, Karen Hassen, Robert Hendel, Jacqueline Henkel, Stephen Horgan, Mark Hyun, Rajesh Janardhanan, Scott Jerome, Dinesh Kalra, David Kassop, Mona Kinkhabwala, George Kinzfogl, Bernard Koch, Lynne Koweek, Joseph Krepp, Younghoon Kwon, Jay Layer, John Lesser, Steve Leung, Bernadette Lisske, Juan Lopez-Mattei, Kathleen Magurany, Jeremy Markowitz, Brenda Mccullough, Azita Moalemi, Chanan Moffitt, Juan Montanez, Warren Moore, Shamil Morayati, Mahmud Mossa-Basha, Zorana Mrsic, Venkatesh Murthy, Prashant Nagpal, Katarina Nelson, Prabhjot Nijjar, Rupal O’Quinn, Purvi Parwani, Edward Passen, Toral Patel, Pravin Patil, Amit Pursnani, Nancy Quachang, Mark Rabbat, Pragya Ranjan, Patricia Rodriguez Lozano, Mary Schemmer, Rebecca Seifried, Nishant Shah, Amee Shah, Sujata Shanbhag, Gaurav Sharma, Robert Skotnicki, Michael Sobczak, Prem Soman, Vincent Sorrell, Monvadi Srichai, Jim Streeter, Leah Strickland, Suliman Suliman, Naghmeh Tebyanian, Dustin Thomas, Randall Thompson, Seth Uretsky, Srikanth Vallurupalli, Marian Vandyck-Acquah, Vikas Verma, Todd Villines, Joseph Weinstein, David Wolinsky, Karolina Zareba, Michael Zgaljardic, Mario Beretta, Rodolfo Ferrando, Miguel Kapitan, Fernando Mut, Omoa Djuraev, Gulnora Rozikhodjaeva, Luisa Vera, Binh Duong Duc, Xuan Canh Nguyen, Phuoc Minh Hiep Nguyen
Journal: Journal of the American College of Cardiology (2022)

The extent to which health care systems have adapted to the COVID-19 pandemic to provide necessary cardiac diagnostic services is unknown. The aim of this study was to determine the impact of the pandemic on cardiac testing practices, volumes and types of diagnostic services, and perceived psychological stress to health care providers worldwide. The International Atomic Energy Agency conducted a worldwide survey assessing alterations from baseline in cardiovascular diagnostic care at the pandemic's onset and 1 year later. Multivariable regression was used to determine factors associated with procedure volume recovery. Surveys were submitted from 669 centers in 107 countries. Worldwide reduction in cardiac procedure volumes of 64% from March 2019 to April 2020 recovered by April 2021 in high- and upper middle-income countries (recovery rates of 108% and 99%) but remained depressed in lower middle- and low-income countries (46% and 30% recovery). Although stress testing was used 12% less frequently in 2021 than in 2019, coronary computed tomographic angiography was used 14% more, a trend also seen for other advanced cardiac imaging modalities (positron emission tomography and magnetic resonance; 22%-25% increases). Pandemic-related psychological stress was estimated to have affected nearly 40% of staff, impacting patient care at 78% of sites. In multivariable regression, only lower-income status and physicians' psychological stress were significant in predicting recovery of cardiac testing. Cardiac diagnostic testing has yet to recover to prepandemic levels in lower-income countries. Worldwide, the decrease in standard stress testing is offset by greater use of advanced cardiac imaging modalities. Pandemic-related psychological stress among providers is widespread and associated with poor recovery of cardiac testing.