A basket-platform trial for neurofibromatosis type 1: A potential model for rare cancer predisposition syndromes.
Authors: Annette Bakker, Britt Dhaenens, Guenter Heimann, Marco Nievo, Rosalie Ferner, Gareth D Evans, Pierre Wolkenstein, Jonas Leubner, Jaishri O'Neill Blakeley, Scott Randall Plotkin, Michael J. Fisher, AeRang Kim, Pablo Hernáiz Driever, Amedeo A. Azizi, Cornelia Potratz, Charlotte Carton, Uchenna Iloeje, George Kirk, Eric Legius, Rianne Oostenbrink
Journal: Journal of Clinical Oncology (2023)

e22550 Background: Neurofibromatosis Type 1 (NF1) is a rare hereditary condition that predisposes to the development of a variety of tumors. Variability in disease manifestation, prevalence and severity, in combination with a low prevalence complicates the efficient conduct of clinical trials in NF1. NF1-associated tumors mainly but not exclusively affect the nervous system as well as the skin, and a percentage of those tumors exhibit a significantly increased risk of malignant transformation. There is an urgent need to identify effective treatments for NF1-associated tumors. The development of innovative trial designs that accelerate the ability to assess new investigational agents is essential. The European Patient-Centric Clinical Trial Platforms (EU-PEARL) is an Innovative Medicines Initiative (IMI) project, aiming to create platform trials for diseases with high unmet medical need. As part of EU-PEARL, we designed a basket-platform trial in NF1 that could serve as a prototype for accelerating drug studies in rare cancer predisposition syndromes. Methods: The trial was designed by NF1 experts, a dedicated statistician and a trial designer. Subprotocols were written for previously prioritized manifestations including plexiform neurofibroma, cutaneous neurofibroma, low-grade glioma, and optic pathway glioma. Collaboration with NF1 experts from the USA was sought to ensure alignment with trials for NF1 in the USA. Results: To optimally learn from a small number of potential participants, patients should be able to participate in both an observational and a treatment phase. The observational phase will serve as longitudinal natural history study, providing data that can be used as a comparator for the treatment arms. To enter the treatment phase, patients must meet additional eligibility criteria. Patients will be randomized to a sequence of available drugs, rather than one single drug. This may allow for the addition of newly identified drugs during the course of the trial. If a drug concept fails or unacceptable toxicity arises, patients may re-enter the observational phase or be re-randomized to a different treatment arm if eligible. Drug-specific eligibility criteria and endpoints are listed separately in Intervention-Specific-Appendices (ISAs), allowing flexibility and adaptability that is needed for a highly variable and progressive rare disorder like NF1. This trial design allows optimal learning from a limited number of patients. Conclusions: We designed a basket-platform trial for four manifestations of NF1. This trial design addresses challenges that may be encountered when designing a clinical trial for NF1. This trial will be the future of clinical trials for NF1 in Europe. Its design could serve as a prototype for other rare diseases: it enhances the chances of finding beneficial treatments by optimizing patient inclusion and invigorating international collaborations.