Comparison of 2 Triage Scoring Guidelines for Allocation of Mechanical Ventilators
Authors: Hannah Wunsch, Andrea D. Hill, Nicholas Bosch, Neill K. J. Adhikari, Gordon Rubenfeld, Allan Walkey, Bruno L. Ferreyro, Bourke W. Tillmann, Andre C. K. B. Amaral, Damon C. Scales, Eddy Fan, Brian H. Cuthbertson, Robert A. Fowler
Journal: JAMA Network Open (2020)

<h3>Importance</h3> In the current setting of the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic, there is concern for the possible need for triage criteria for ventilator allocation; to our knowledge, the implications of using specific criteria have never been assessed. <h3>Objective</h3> To determine which and how many admissions to intensive care units are identified as having the lowest priority for ventilator allocation using 2 distinct sets of proposed triage criteria. <h3>Design, Setting, and Participants</h3> This retrospective cohort study conducted in spring 2020 used data collected from US hospitals and reported in the Philips eICU Collaborative Research Database. Adult admissions (N = 40 439) to 291 intensive care units from 2014 to 2015 who received mechanical ventilation and were not elective surgery patients were included. <h3>Exposures</h3> Two sets of triage criteria: New York State Ventilator Allocation triage criteria developed in 2015 and 2 selected criteria from a 4-component allocation framework developed in 2020 using principles of saving lives and saving life-years (referred to as save lives/life-years criteria). Two other equity-focused criteria of this framework, giving heightened priority to health care workers and other essential workers, and prioritizing younger over older patients, were not included. <h3>Main Outcomes and Measures</h3> Sequential Organ Failure Assessment (SOFA) scores were calculated for admissions. The proportion of patients who met initial criteria for the lowest level of priority for mechanical ventilation using each set of criteria and their characteristics and outcomes were assessed. Agreement was compared between the 2 sets of triage criteria, recognizing differences in stated criteria aims. <h3>Results</h3> Among 40 439 intensive care unit admissions of patients who received mechanical ventilation, the mean (SD) age was 62.6 (16.6) years, 54.9% were male, and the mean (SD) SOFA score was 4.5 (3.7). Using the New York State triage criteria, 8.9% (95% CI, 8.7%-9.2%) were in the lowest priority category; these lowest priority admissions had a mean (SD) age of 62.9 (16.6) years, used a median (interquartile range) of 57.3 (20.1-133.5) ventilator hours each, and had a hospital survival rate of 38.6% (95% CI, 37.0%-40.2%). Using the save lives/life-years triage criteria, 4.3% (95% CI, 4.1%-4.5%) were in the lowest priority category; these admissions had a mean (SD) age of 68.6 (13.2) years, used a median (interquartile range) of 61.7 (24.3-142.8) ventilator hours each, and had a hospital survival rate of 56.2% (95% CI, 53.8%-58.7%). Only 655 admissions (1.6%) were in the lowest priority category for both guidelines, with the κ statistic for agreement equal to 0.20 (95% CI, 0.18-0.21). <h3>Conclusions and Relevance</h3> Use of selected criteria from 2 proposed ventilator triage guidelines identified approximately 1 in every 10 to 25 admissions as having the lowest priority for ventilator allocation, with little agreement. Clinical assessment of different potential criteria for triage decisions in critically ill populations is important to ensure valid allocation of resources.