Dying Cells and Extracellular Histones in AKI
Authors: Diane L. Rosin, Mark D. Okusa
Journal: Journal of the American Society of Nephrology (2012)

The sequelae of tissue injury caused by hypoxia, ischemia, mechanical stress, or pathogen-induced inflammation are initiated in part by the release of danger/damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) from damaged or dying cells.1 Typically serving normal functions in cell homeostasis within the cell, these endogenous molecules are recognized as danger signals by cell surface receptors when released into extracellular spaces. In AKI, as well as other kidney disorders and injury to other organs, the ensuing inflammation and recruitment of the immune system contribute to the pathogenesis and resolution of disease. A wide variety of candidate DAMPs and their putative receptors have been identified, and their role in kidney disease is gradually being uncovered1. While some receptors appear to be selective for DAMPs, others such as toll-like receptors (TLRs)2,3 respond to DAMPs and are included among pattern recognition receptors for pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs). DNA extruded from apoptotic or necrotic cells falls in one of the DAMPs categories, but it also is becoming clear that associated nuclear molecules, such as histones, contribute to tissue injury and disease. In the current issue of JASN Allam et al.4 investigate whether histone release from dying renal cells functions like DAMPs and contributes to AKI in a TLR-dependent manner. The appearance of histones in the extracellular space is not well understood but may arise from apoptotic or necrotic cells through passive release (perhaps as dying cells release their cell contents), from proinflammatory cells by active secretion, or as a component of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) from infiltrating neutrophils. In a cell death process termed NETosis that seems largely to be involved with clearance of invading pathogens, nuclear DNA and associated proteins (such as histones), some of which are antimicrobial, are extruded from neutrophils into the extracellular space to form fibrous networks, called NETs.5 Neutrophils are often the first responders to pathogens and tissue injury and are recruited to inflammatory sites to contain infections by a variety of means, including NETosis.6 NETs serve important antibacterial functions, but histones (and perhaps other NET components) may also produce collateral damage to host bystander cells. Although the term NET was originally named for and described in neutrophils, extracellular traps containing DNA and proteins are also released from other cells, including monocytes/macrophages and eosinophils7 and may serve as a more generalized defense mechanism. Indeed, extracellular traps and histones, in particular, may play a role in a variety of inflammatory and autoimmune disorders, such as stroke,8 systemic lupus erythematosus,9 thrombosis,10 and AKI, although the latter has not yet been examined. To explore the role of histones in kidney injury, Allam et al. conducted a very thorough series of experiments to demonstrate that histones, when released by damaged cells, mediate cell death and inflammation and contribute importantly to postischemic and septic acute kidney.4 They first demonstrated that dying tubular epithelial cells release histones and that histones act directly on renal epithelial and endothelial cells grown in culture to induce both apoptotic and necrotic cell death. The pathophysiological relevance of extracellular histones was explored in mice. Direct visualization of local microcirculatory events was established through in vivo microscopy of the mouse cremaster muscle in which local application of histones enhanced leukocyte migration and adherence, and immunostaining showed transendothelial migration of neutrophils and monocyte/macrophages. Chemokine-induced chemotaxis and adhesion molecule-induced rolling, adhesion, and transmigration of leukocytes mediate these processes.11,12 Next, Allam et al. injected histones directly into the kidney by intra-arterial injection, which led to inflammation, necrosis, and increased proinflammatory cytokine expression in the injected kidney that was prevented by digestion of the histone preparation with activated protein C, a commonly used method for confirming histone-specific effects. The deleterious effects of histones depended on pretreatment of mice with a low dose of LPS to induce TLR2 and TLR4 expression and were absent in TLR2/4 double-null mice, suggesting a role in septic AKI. In an effort to demonstrate cause and effect, the authors injected blocking antibodies and showed that neutralization of extracellular histones, and specifically of histone H4, prevented tubular injury and loss of renal function in endotoxin-induced AKI and renal ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI), respectively, thus suggesting a more general role of histones in different forms of AKI. Importantly, neutralization of histones reduced neutrophil recruitment, which is known to have a pathogenic role in AKI, and the induction of cytokine and chemokine expression in IRI. These in vivo studies demonstrate nicely that extracellular histones contribute to the inflammatory process and loss of kidney function in IRI and, in combination with the authors' in vitro studies, suggest that released histones act directly on renal epithelial and endothelial cells to induce injury, consistent with similar findings in a lung injury model.13 At this point, the more difficult question of whether dying or injured renal cells in vivo are the source of extracellular histones remains to be answered. In view of the rapid and extensive infiltration of neutrophils in AKI,14 it is intriguing to speculate that NETs are a source of extracellular histone accumulation, a concept that has not yet been explored in AKI. In the next series of elegant experiments, Allam et al.4 examined signaling mechanisms underlying the direct cellular effects of extracellular histones and showed that histones induce proinflammatory cytokine release through TLR2/4 activation of NF-kB.15 To determine which pattern recognition receptors mediate the effect of histones the authors isolated bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (BMDCs) from MyD88 and TRIF (TIR domain-containing adaptor-inducing interferon-β)–deficient mice. MyD88 is the adaptor molecule for all TLRs except TLR3, which signals through TRIF. Histone H4-induced release of TNF-α and IL-6 was completely abrogated in BMDCs from MyD88-deficient but not from TRIF-deficient mice, indicating that TLR3 was not involved. BMDCs from mice deficient in individual genes for TLRs released cytokines in response to H4 stimulation, but BMDCs lacking both TLR2 and TLR4 did not respond to H4 and were completely unable to secrete TNFα and IL-6. To examine a direct interaction with these receptors, the authors used fluorescently labeled H4 and found that H4 binds independently with high affinity to TL2 or TL4. Last, a dual requirement for both TLR2 and TLR4 was demonstrated in vivo; injection of H4 failed to increase plasma concentrations of IL-6 and TNFα in TLR2/TLR4 double-null mice. Further investigation will be needed to understand the nature of this apparent receptor cooperativity and the reason why both are needed for a histone-induced proinflammatory state. In addition to the mechanisms that the authors have uncovered, extracellular histones also inhibit efferocytosis,16 a term coined to describe the clearance of apoptotic cells by phagocytic cells, such as macrophages, which may thereby prolong the acute inflammatory process and tissue injury. The findings reported in this paper prompt other questions about the mechanisms of kidney injury. For example, what triggers histone release in IRI? If the mechanism bears similarities to NETosis, it is likely that a cell death process cannot go unchecked and requires mediators of regulation whose cell source and mechanisms of action remain to be identified. In view of the authors' findings on histones and dendritic cells, is histone-induced cytokine release in IRI dependent on the presence of dendritic cells, and do extracellular histones bind to cell surface receptors on other cell types to provoke an inflammatory response? In summary, these intriguing results demonstrate the important contribution of extracellular histones in directly injuring target cells and causing release of proinflammatory cytokines through TLR2/4. Similar effects of histones have been reported in liver injury,17 lung injury,13 and sepsis.18 Confirmation that injured or dying kidney epithelial cells release histones in vivo requires further study that may also reveal whether release of histones from damaged host cells is comparable to release from dying neutrophils. It is very interesting to consider a role for NETs in mediating tissue injury, as suggested by NET formation in lung injury,13 but their role in AKI remains unclear. Neutrophils are key players in kidney IRI; widespread infiltration and activation of neutrophils in the kidney with release of NETs could contribute to or be a primary source of extracellular histones. In addition, the pathophysiological significance of these findings will be reinforced if it is found that the prevailing concentration of extracellular histones in the local microenvironment is sufficient to activate TLR2 and TLR4 following AKI. As such they would offer potential new therapeutic targets for the treatment of various forms of AKI. Disclosures None. D.L.R and M.D.O. were supported by NIH Grants R01 DK062324, R01 DK083406, R01 DK085259, and R21 DK093841.