Essential Hypertension
Authors: Oscar A. Carretero, Suzanne Oparil
Journal: Circulation (2000)

HomeCirculationVol. 101, No. 3Essential Hypertension Free AccessOtherPDF/EPUBAboutView PDFView EPUBSections ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload citationsTrack citationsPermissions ShareShare onFacebookTwitterLinked InMendeleyRedditDiggEmail Jump toFree AccessOtherPDF/EPUBEssential Hypertension Part I: Definition and Etiology Oscar A. Carretero and Suzanne Oparil Oscar A. CarreteroOscar A. Carretero From the Hypertension and Vascular Research Division, Heart and Vascular Institute, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, Mich (O.A.C.), and the Division of Cardiovascular Disease, Vascular Biology and Hypertension Program, University of Alabama School of Medicine, Birmingham (S.O.). and Suzanne OparilSuzanne Oparil From the Hypertension and Vascular Research Division, Heart and Vascular Institute, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, Mich (O.A.C.), and the Division of Cardiovascular Disease, Vascular Biology and Hypertension Program, University of Alabama School of Medicine, Birmingham (S.O.). Originally published25 Jan 2000https://doi.org/10.1161/01.CIR.101.3.329Circulation. 2000;101:329–335Essential hypertension remains a major modifiable risk factor for cardiovascular disease (CVD) despite important advances in our understanding of its pathophysiology and the availability of effective treatment strategies. High blood pressure (BP) increases the risk of CVD for millions of people worldwide, and there is evidence that the problem is only getting worse. In the past decade, age-adjusted rates of stroke incidence have risen, and the slope of the age-adjusted rate of decline in coronary disease has leveled off. The incidence of end-stage renal disease and the prevalence of heart failure have also increased. A major contributor to these trends is inadequate control of BP in the hypertensive population. This review of current concepts regarding the definition, etiology, and treatment of essential hypertension is intended to aid the clinician in identifying those individuals at high risk who need to undergo evaluation and treatment, as well as in selecting optimal treatment strategies for hypertensive patients with comorbid conditions and/or target organ damage. The part of the review that deals with the genetic basis of hypertension and the gene/environment interaction that may lead to elevated BP is still a work in progress. Information gained from the Human Genome Project and from ongoing studies of the genetic basis of hypertension both in animal models and human populations may revolutionize the treatment of hypertension by replacing current empirical therapy with more effective, targeted treatments based on the genotype of the patient. Concepts introduced in this review form the basis for such "pharmacogenomic" approaches to antihypertensive therapy.Definition of Essential or Primary HypertensionBP is a quantitative trait that is highly variable1 ; in population studies, BP has a normal distribution that is slightly skewed to the right. There is a strong positive and continuous correlation between BP and the risk of CVD (stroke, myocardial infarction, heart failure), renal disease, and mortality, even in the normotensive range. This correlation is more robust with systolic than with diastolic BP.2 There is no specific level of BP where cardiovascular and renal complications start to occur; thus the definition of hypertension is arbitrary but needed for practical reasons in patient assessment and treatment.The Sixth Report of the Joint National Committee on Prevention, Detection, Evaluation, and Treatment of High Blood Pressure (JNC VI) defined and classified hypertension in adults, as shown in Table 1.3 The diagnosis of hypertension is made when the average of 2 or more diastolic BP measurements on at least 2 subsequent visits is ≥90 mm Hg or when the average of multiple systolic BP readings on 2 or more subsequent visits is consistently ≥140 mm Hg. Isolated systolic hypertension is defined as systolic BP ≥140 mm Hg and diastolic BP <90 mm Hg. Individuals with high normal BP tend to maintain pressures that are above average for the general population and are at greater risk for development of definite hypertension and cardiovascular events than the general population. With the use of these definitions, it is estimated that 43 million people in the United States have hypertension or are taking antihypertensive medication, which is ≈24% of the adult population. This proportion changes with (1) race, being higher in blacks (32.4%) and lower in whites (23.3%) and Mexican Americans (22.6%); (2) age, because in industrialized countries systolic BP rises throughout life, whereas diastolic BP rises until age 55 to 60 years and thus the greater increase in prevalence of hypertension among the elderly is mainly due to systolic hypertension; (3) geographic patterns, because hypertension is more prevalent in the southeastern United States; (4) gender, because hypertension is more prevalent in men (though menopause tends to abolish this difference); and (5) socioeconomic status, which is an indicator of lifestyle attributes and is inversely related to the prevalence, morbidity, and mortality rates of hypertension.Essential, primary, or idiopathic hypertension is defined as high BP in which secondary causes such as renovascular disease, renal failure, pheochromocytoma, aldosteronism, or other causes of secondary hypertension or mendelian forms (monogenic) are not present. Essential hypertension accounts for 95% of all cases of hypertension. Essential hypertension is a heterogeneous disorder, with different patients having different causal factors that lead to high BP. Essential hypertension needs to be separated into various syndromes because the causes of high BP in most patients presently classified as having essential hypertension can be recognized.Known Etiological Factors in Essential HypertensionAlthough it has frequently been indicated that the causes of essential hypertension are not known, this is only partially true because we have little information on genetic variations or genes that are overexpressed or underexpressed as well as the intermediary phenotypes that they regulate to cause high BP.4 A number of factors increase BP, including (1) obesity, (2) insulin resistance, (3) high alcohol intake, (4) high salt intake (in salt-sensitive patients), (5) aging and perhaps (6) sedentary lifestyle, (7) stress, (8) low potassium intake, and (9) low calcium intake.56 Furthermore, many of these factors are additive, such as obesity and alcohol intake.In this review, variations in BP that are genetically determined will be called "inherited BP," although we do not know which genes cause BP to vary; we know from family studies that inherited BP can range from low normal BP to severe hypertension. Factors that increase BP, such as obesity and high alcohol and salt intake, will be called "hyperten-sinogenic factors." Some of these factors have inherited, behavioral, and environmental components. Inherited BP could be considered core BP, whereas hypertensinogenic factors cause BP to increase above the range of inherited BPs, thus creating 4 main possibilities: (1) patients who have inherited BP in the optimal category (<120/<80 mm Hg); if 1 or more hypertensinogenic factors are added, BP would probably increase but remain in the normal range (<135/<85 mm Hg) (Figure 1, first 2 columns); (2) patients who have inherited BP in the normal category (≤130/≤85 mm Hg); if 1 or more hypertensinogenic factors are added, BP will probably increase to the high normal range (130 to 139/85 to 89 mm Hg) or to stage 1 of the hypertensive category (140 to 159/90 to 99 mm Hg) (Figure 1, second 2 columns); (3) patients who have inherited BP in the high normal category (130 to 139/85 to 89 mm Hg); if 1 or more hypertensinogenic factors are added, BP will increase to the hypertensive range (≥140/≥90 mm Hg) (Figure 1, third 2 columns); and (4) patients who have inherited BP in the hypertensive range; addition of 1 or more hypertensinogenic factors will make hypertension more severe, changing it from stage 1 to stage 2 or 3 (Figure 1, fourth to sixth 2 columns).Theoretically, in a population unaffected by hypertensinogenic factors, BP will have a normal distribution; it will be skewed to the right and will have a narrow base or less variance (Figure 2, continuous line). When 1 hypertensinogenic factor is added to this population, such as increased body mass, one would expect the normal distribution curve to be further skewed to the right; consequently the base will be wider (more variance) and the curve will be flatter (Figure 2, broken line). If a second hypertensinogenic factor such as alcohol intake is added to increased body mass, the curve will be skewed more to the right and the variance will increase further, with more subjects classified as hypertensive (Figure 2, dotted line).Discovering which genetic variations place BP on the left or right side of the distribution curve is of both theoretical and practical importance because it could help the physician to better treat or cure hypertension.7 Recognition of the hypertensinogenic factors may allow nonpharmacological prevention, treatment, or cure of hypertension. Hypertensinogenic factors such as obesity, insulin resistance, or high alcohol intake also have an important genetic component. Furthermore, there are interactions between genetic and environmental factors (Figure 2) that influence intermediary phenotypes such as sympathetic nerve activity, the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone and renal kallikrein-kinin systems, and endothelial factors, which in turn influence other intermediary phenotypes such as sodium excretion, vascular reactivity, and cardiac contractility. These and many other intermediary phenotypes determine total vascular resistance and cardiac output and, consequently, BP. Recognition of the hypertensinogenic factor(s) and establishing that the patient's hypertension is the result of obesity (either alone or combined with other factors such as insulin resistance or high alcohol intake) or old age instead of essential hypertension may help the physician as well as the patient and his or her family to modify or eliminate these hypertensinogenic and CVD risk factors when possible, which may cure the hypertension or at least facilitate control of BP. When the hypertensinogenic factor cannot be reduced or eliminated, as with systolic hypertension induced by aging (arteriosclerosis), recognition of the underlying cause of high BP will emphasize the need for (1) further studies to determine whether the patient has arteriosclerosis and/or atherosclerosis, the magnitude of the disease, and whether there are occlusive lesions; (2) treatment of the atherosclerosis with lifestyle and dietary changes and lipid-lowering agents if necessary; and (3) pharmacological treatment of systolic hypertension to decrease passive stiffness (arteriosclerosis) of the major central elastic arteries and decrease morbidity and mortality rates. Thus recognition of factors that induce hypertension is not only of theoretical but also of practical importance. In conclusion, as stated by Beilin,8 "it is no longer appropriate to define essential hypertension as a rise in blood pressure without cause," since a number of causes can be clearly identified in most cases of so-called "essential hypertension." As discussed later in more detail, there is clear evidence that changes in lifestyle, including dietary changes that reduce body weight, fat, and alcohol intake and increase potassium and calcium intake,9 as well as exercise,1011 reduce or normalize BP in many patients.Inherited BPThe identification of variant (allelic) genes that contribute to the development of hypertension is complicated by the fact that the 2 phenotypes that determine BP, cardiac output and total peripheral resistance, are controlled by intermediary phenotypes, including the autonomic nervous system, vasopressor/vasodepressor hormones, the structure of the cardiovascular system, body fluid volume and renal function, and many others. Furthermore, these intermediary phenotypes are also controlled by complex mechanisms including BP itself.12 Thus there are many genes that could participate in the development of hypertension.The influence of genes on BP has been suggested by family studies demonstrating associations of BP among siblings and between parents and children. There is a better association among BP values in biological children than in adopted children and in identical as opposed to nonidentical twins. BP variability attributed to all genetic factors varies from 25% in pedigree studies to 65% in twin studies. Furthermore, genetic factors also influence behavioral patterns, which might lead to BP elevation. For example, a tendency toward obesity or alcoholism will be influenced by both genetic and environmental factors; thus the proportion of BP variability caused by inheritance is difficult to determine and may vary in different populations.Mutations in at least 10 genes have been shown to raise or lower BP through a common pathway by increasing or decreasing salt and water reabsorption by the nephron.1314 The genetic mutations responsible for 3 rare forms of mendelian (monogenic) hypertensive syndromes−glucocorticoid-remediable aldosteronism (GRA), Liddle's syndrome, and apparent mineralocorticoid excess−have been identified, whereas in a fourth, autosomal dominant hypertension with brachydactyly, the gene is not yet identified but has been mapped to chromosome 12 (12p). Subtle variations in one of these genes may also cause some forms of "essential" hypertension. For a review of the mutations that cause a decrease in BP, see Lifton.13Glucocorticoid-Remediable AldosteronismThis is an autosomal dominant form of monogenic hypertension in which aldosterone secretion is regulated by adrenocorticotropic hormone. Glucocorticoid treatment causes BP to decrease and gives the syndrome its name. The genetic mutation that causes GRA has been identified by Lifton14 as a chimeric gene fusing nucleotide sequences of the promoter-regulatory region of 11β-hydroxylase (controlled by adrenocorticotropic hormone) and the structural portion of the aldosterone synthase gene. The chimeric gene results from a meiotic mismatch and unequal crossing over. The patients are usually thought to have primary aldosteronism because they exhibit volume expansion, metabolic alkalosis with hypokalemia, low plasma renin, and high aldosterone. Most of the patients first described as having GRA showed severe hypertension and died prematurely from stroke. However, with the development of direct genetic testing, the BP of patients with this syndrome was found to cover a wide range, including normotensive levels.1516 In patients with GRA and normal BP, expression of the chimeric gene may be variable, but because steroid levels are similar in patients with severe and mild hypertension, this seems unlikely. It is also possible that the genetic background of the trait (other than the chimeric mutation), such as high renal kallikrein, places the inherited BP of these subjects in the low or ideal normal range and the mutation causes BP to increase to high normal or hypertensive stage 1. Thus the final BP would be the combined result of the inherited BP (including the genetic mutation) and the increase in BP caused by hypertensinogenic factors such as salt.Liddle's SyndromeThis is an autosomal dominant form of monogenic hypertension that results from mutations in the amiloride-sensitive epithelial sodium channel, leading to increased channel activity.17 The mutations reported to date result in the elimination of 45 to 75 amino acids from the cytoplasmic carboxyl terminus of β- or γ-subunits of the channel; thus Liddle's syndrome is genetically heterogeneous. It is characterized by the early onset of hypertension with hypokalemia and suppression of both plasma renin activity and aldosterone, the latter differentiating this syndrome from primary aldosteronism. Both the hypertension and the hypokalemia vary in severity, raising the possibility that some patients classified as having salt-sensitive essential hypertension actually have Liddle's syndrome.18 It is also possible that high BP in blacks, who are frequently salt-sensitive, is due to a polymorphism in one of the sodium channel genes or in one of the genes of systems that regulate it, causing its activity to increase.Apparent Mineralocorticoid ExcessThis is an autosomal recessive form of monogenic juvenile hypertension that results from a mutation in the renal-specific isoform 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase gene.19 Normally this enzyme converts cortisol to the inactive metabolite cortisone. In the distal nephron this is important because cortisol and aldosterone have a similar affinity for the mineralocorticoid receptor. The enzymatic deficiency allows the mineralocorticoid receptors in the nephron to be occupied and activated by cortisol, causing sodium and water retention, volume expansion, low renin, low aldosterone, and more importantly, a salt-sensitive form of hypertension. Thus this gene may be a locus for salt-sensitive essential hypertension.Autosomal Dominant Hypertension With BrachydactylyIn this monogenic syndrome, hypertension and brachydactyly are always inherited together (100% cosegregation).4 Affected persons are shorter than nonaffected relatives. The gene for hypertension has been mapped to the short arm of chromosome 12 (12p) in a large Turkish kindred. Two other families with this syndrome have been reported, 1 in Canada and 1 in the United States. In addition, the study of a Japanese child with hypertension and type E brachydactyly has allowed the area on 12p containing the gene mutation to be pinpointed further, although the gene responsible for this syndrome has not yet been cloned. Unlike the other 3 autosomal forms of hypertension, BP is not affected by volume expansion and the underlying mechanism is not known. Thus identification of the gene responsible may help clarify some of the genetic alterations in essential hypertension.Essential or Primary HypertensionThe genetic alterations responsible for inherited "essential" hypertension remain largely unknown.4 Results from family studies suggest several possible intermediary phenotypes (genetic traits) that may be related to inherited high BP, such as high sodium-lithium countertransport, low urinary kallikrein excretion, high fasting plasma insulin concentrations, high-density LDL subfractions, fat pattern index, and body mass index (BMI).12 Jeunemaitre et al2021 first reported a polymorphism in the angiotensinogen gene linked with essential hypertension in hypertensive siblings from Utah and France. This polymorphism consists of a substitution of thymidine for cytosine in nucleotide 704, which causes substitution of methionine for threonine at position 235 (M235T) and is associated with increased concentrations of plasma angiotensinogen. This variant appears to be in tight linkage disequilibrium with a promoter mutation in which adenine replaces guanine (-6A) upstream from the initiation side of transcription.22 Tests of promoter activity suggest that this nucleotide substitution increases the rate of gene transcription, which may explain the higher angiotensinogen concentration found in subjects with the variant M235T.22 Many studies have been published on various racial groups with regard to the association between allelic variations in angiotensinogen and hypertension.23 However, these variations explain only a small part of the BP variation (≈6%). Furthermore, plasma angiotensinogen concentrations, though higher in patients with the polymorphism, clearly overlap with normotensive patients.Polymorphisms and mutations in other genes such as angiotensin-converting enzyme, β2-adrenergic receptor, α-adducin, angiotensinase C, renin-binding protein, G-protein β3-subunit, atrial natriuretic factor, and the insulin receptor have also been linked to the development of essential hypertension; however, most of them show a weak association if any, and most of these studies need further confirmation. Thus these gene alterations will not be discussed here because they go beyond the scope of this review (see Luft4 ).Hypertensinogenic FactorsThere is evidence that obesity, insulin resistance, high alcohol intake, high salt intake, a sedentary lifestyle, stress, dyslipidemia, and low potassium or calcium intake increase BP in susceptible subjects. Here we will briefly discuss obesity and insulin resistance; other hypertensinogenic factors will be discussed in the section "Lifestyle Modification."Obesity and Insulin ResistanceObesity, and especially abdominal obesity, is the main hypertensinogenic factor. It was estimated in the Framingham study that each 10% weight gain is associated with a 6.5 mm Hg increase in systolic BP.24 Obesity is also the cause of insulin resistance, adult-onset diabetes mellitus, left ventricular hypertrophy, hyperlipidemia, and atherosclerotic disease. Thus obesity is an important cardiovascular health problem; its incidence and prevalence are rising in most industrialized societies and in the United States has reached epidemic proportions. The relationship between BP and body fat is not restricted to the morbidly obese but is continuous throughout the entire range of body weight. A direct association between hypertension and BMI (weight in kilograms divided by the square height in meters) has been observed in cross-sectional and longitudinal population studies from early childhood to old age.25 A BMI of <25 is considered normal or healthy, whereas a BMI of 26 to 28 (as compared with BMI <23) increases the risk of high BP by 180% and the risk of insulin resistance by >1000%. Thus insulin resistance is present in many patients with obesity and hypertension.The mechanism by which obesity raises BP is not fully understood, but increased BMI is associated with an increase in plasma volume and cardiac output; both these alterations and BP can be decreased by weight loss in both normotensive and hypertensive subjects,26 even when sodium intake is kept relatively constant.27 BP in obese adolescents is sodium-sensitive, and fasting insulin is the best predictor of this sensitivity.26 In these adolescents, mean BP dropped by 10 mm Hg after changing from 2 weeks on a high-sodium diet (>250 mmol sodium/d) to a low-sodium diet (<30 mmol/d). When some of these subjects lost weight by dieting, BP decreased by 10 mm Hg and salt sensitivity was no longer present. The variables that best predicted sodium sensitivity were fasting plasma insulin, plasma aldosterone, and plasma norepinephrine, supporting the hypothesis that BP is sensitive to dietary sodium and that this sensitivity may be due to the combined effect of hyperinsulinemia, hyperaldosteronism, and increased activity of the sympathetic nervous system. It is not clear whether body fat by itself is a factor because in overweight women, exercise for 1 hour per day, 3 times per week lowered BP, and this decrease was observed mainly in those who initially had high fasting insulin and whose insulin levels fell in response to exercise. In this study weight loss was not a factor because the subjects were on a free diet and actually gained an average of 2.6 pounds during the 6-month exercise trial,10 which suggests that exercise decreases plasma insulin by a different mechanism than loss of body weight. These studies can be interpreted as showing that high plasma insulin causes salt sensitivity and that decreasing insulin resistance by losing weight or exercising reduces BP. Furthermore, nonobese hypertensive subjects are much more likely to exhibit insulin resistance than normotensive individuals.28 On the other hand, insulin by itself has a vasodilator effect. In obese subjects with hypertension there is resistance to the effects of insulin on glucose uptake. However, in addition to this metabolic effect, insulin increases both sympathetic nerve activity and sodium and water retention, and it could be that the hypertension is due to the lack of resistance to these secondary effects of insulin.29 More recently, insulin-like growth factor I30 and leptin,31 a neuropeptide that regulates appetite, have also been implicated in the pathogenesis of obesity-induced hypertension. Thus, although the mechanisms by which obesity and insulin resistance increase BP remain undefined, it is clear that these increases in BP are overlain on the inherited BP.Diagnosis of HypertensionInitial EvaluationThe goals of the initial evaluation are to determine baseline BP; assess the presence and extent of target organ damage and concomitant CVD; screen for potentially curable specific causes of hypertension (secondary hypertension); identify hypertensinogenic factors and other CVD risk factors; and characterize the patient to facilitate the choice of therapy (especially drug selection) and define prognosis.BP MeasurementThe accurate and reproducible measurement of BP by the cuff technique is the most important part of the diagnostic evaluation and follow-up of the patient and should be carried out in a standardized fashion (Table 2) with the use of properly calibrated and certified equipment.33233 A mercury sphygmomanometer is preferred; acceptable alternatives include a recently calibrated aneroid manometer or a validated electronic device attached to an arm cuff. Two or 3 measurements should be taken at each visit, and at least 2 minutes should be allowed between readings. The diastolic reading is taken at the level when sounds disappear (Korotkoff phase V).Measurement of BP by patients or family members and/or automated ambulatory BP monitoring often helps verify the diagnosis and assess the severity of hypertension. BP values obtained outside the clinical setting are lower and correlate better with target organ damage than BP measurements by healthcare personnel. Self-measurement of BP has several potential advantages, including distinguishing sustained hypertension from hypertension that occurs only in the healthcare setting ("white coat" hypertension); assessing the response to antihypertensive treatment; improving adherence to treatment by making the patient a "partner" in his or her own care; and lowering costs by reducing the need for frequent office BP checks. Accordingly, ambulatory or self-monitoring of BP is recommended for many patients with high BP, particularly those who appear to be resistant to antihypertensive treatment. A limitation of home or workplace BP measurements is that accurate and calibrated BP monitors must be used and that careful and repeated instruction in how to measure BP must be given.Medical History and Physical ExaminationA careful, complete history should be obtained and a physical examination performed in all patients before beginning treatment. The assessment should include the elements described in Table 3. It should help to identify known, remediable causes of high BP; establish the presence or absence of target organ damage and CVD; and identify other CVD or comorbid conditions that might affect prognosis or treatment.Laboratory Tests and Other Diagnostic ProceduresRoutine tests include only urinalysis, complete blood count, blood chemistry (potassium, sodium, creatinine, fasting glucose, total and high-density lipoprotein or HDL cholesterol), and a 12-lead ECG. Optional tests indicated in selected patients for the diagnosis of secondary hypertension and/or comorbid conditions include creatinine clearance, 24-hour urinary protein, measurement of microalbuminuria, uric acid, calcium, glycosylated hemoglobin, fasting triglycerides, limited echocardiography,34 and plasma renin activity/aldosterone measurements.This is Part I of a 2-part article. Part II of this article will be published in the February 1, 2000 issue of Circulation.Download figureDownload PowerPoint Figure 1. Additive effect of hypertensinogenic factors (hatched areas) such as obesity and alcohol intake on hereditary systolic (white areas) and diastolic BP (black areas). Abscissa indicates the stage of inherited BP according to JNC VI without adding the effect of the hypertensinogenic factors. Patients with normal or high normal inherited BP become hypertensive stage 1 when BP is increased by a hypertensinogenic factor. In patients with inherited hypertension in stages 1 to 3, their hypertension becomes more severe when hypertensinogenic factors are added.Download figureDownload PowerPoint Figure 2. Interaction among genetic and environmental factors in the development of hypertension. Left side of figure shows how environmental factors and multiple genes responsible for high BP interact and affect intermediary phenotypes. The result of these intermediary phenotypes is blood pressure with a normal distribution skewed to the right. Continuous line indicates the theoretical BP of the population that is not affected by hypertensinogenic factors; shaded area indicates systolic BP in the hypertensive range. Broken and dotted lines indicate populations in which 1 (obesity) or 2 hypertensinogenic factors (obesity plus high alcohol intake) have been added. Notice that in these 2 populations the distribution curves are shifted to the right (high BP) and the number of hypertensive individuals is significantly increased when hypertensinogenic factors are added. Table 1. Definitions and Classification of Blood Pressure LevelsCategorySystolic, mm HgDiastolic, mm HgOptimal<120and<80Normal<130and<85High normal130–139or85–89HypertensionStage 1 (mild)140–159or90–99Subgroup: borderline140–149or90–94Stage 2 (moderate)160–179or100–109Stage 3 (severe)≥180or≥110Isolated systolic hypertension≥140and<90Subgroup: borderline140–149and<90When a patient's systolic and di