The Expanding Repertoire of Circular RNAs
Authors: Paul N Valdmanis, Mark A Kay
Journal: Molecular Therapy (2013)

In recent years, reports suggesting a process of exon shuffling and the generation of circular RNAs have not gained wide support because they are inconsistent with the established dogma of linear exon splicing. This debate has now come full circle with evidence proving more definitively the existence of circular RNAs in two recent articles published in the 21 March issue of Nature. These articles describe an abundance of examples of circular RNAs in humans, mice, and Caenorhabditis elegans as well as a plausible mechanism for the function of at least some of these as "microRNA sponges" within a cell.1Hansen TB Jensen TI Clausen BH Bramsen JB Finsen B Damgaard CK et al.Natural RNA circles function as efficient microRNA sponges.Nature. 2013; 495: 384-388Crossref PubMed Scopus (5222) Google Scholar,2Memczak S Jens M Elefsinioti A Torti F Krueger J Rybak A et al.Circular RNAs are a large class of animal RNAs with regulatory potency.Nature. 2013; 495: 333-338Crossref PubMed Scopus (5207) Google Scholar A microRNA (miRNA) sponge is a sequence that sequesters the available pool of a given miRNA so as to reduce its capacity to act on target genes. However, there is as yet relatively little information on the role that these circular RNAs play in cellular homeostasis or disease, such that one might question why these findings deserve the attention of readers of Molecular Therapy. One might have asked similar questions in the 1990s following the discovery of miRNAs, small interfering RNAs (siRNAs), and RNA interference (RNAi). Although miRNA pathways were once thought to be limited to plants and invertebrates, their importance in normal human development and disease becomes more apparent on almost a weekly basis. Moreover, delivery of short duplex siRNAs or DNA templates capable of producing RNA hairpins that are processed into siRNAs—eliciting robust RNAi-induced gene knockdown and RNAi-based therapies—is now in advanced clinical trials.3Kubowicz P Zelaszczyk D Pekala E RNAi in clinical studies.Curr Med Chem. 2013; 20: 1801-1816Crossref PubMed Scopus (56) Google Scholar,4Martinez T Wright N López-Fraga M Jiménez AI Pañeda C Silencing human genetic diseases with oligonucleotide-based therapies.Hum Genet. 2013; 132: 481-493Crossref PubMed Scopus (40) Google Scholar,5Ramachandran PV Ignacimuthu S RNA interference—a silent but an efficient therapeutic tool.Appl Biochem Biotechnol. 2013; 169: 1774-1789Crossref PubMed Scopus (30) Google Scholar It is not too much of a stretch to speculate that manipulating endogenous circular RNAs will someday provide novel approaches to treat human disease. Circular RNAs were first described anecdotally in the 1990s, and the most well-studied example is that generated from the sex-determining Y (SRY) gene.6Capel B Swain A Nicolis S Hacker A Walter M Koopman P et al.Circular transcripts of the testis-determining geneSry in adult mouse testis.Cell. 1993; 73: 1019-1030Abstract Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (835) Google Scholar The significance of circular RNAs fell somewhat under the radar until last year, when a few large-scale high-throughput sequencing experiments brought them again to the fore in this age of "big data."7Al-Balool HH Weber D Liu Y Wade M Guleria K Nam PL et al.Post-transcriptional exon shuffling events in humans can be evolutionarily conserved and abundant.Genome Res. 2011; 21: 1788-1799Crossref PubMed Scopus (39) Google Scholar,8Jeck WR Sorrentino JA Wang K Slevin MK Burd CE Liu J et al.Circular RNAs are abundant, conserved, and associated with ALU repeats.RNA. 2013; 19: 141-157Crossref PubMed Scopus (2849) Google Scholar,9Salzman J Gawad C Wang PL Lacayo N Brown PO Circular RNAs are the predominant transcript isoform from hundreds of human genes in diverse cell types.PloS One. 2012; 7: e30733Crossref PubMed Scopus (1727) Google Scholar These reports identified thousands of circular and nonlinear exon-shuffling events, derived from 1–2% of the genes transcribed in a cell. The circular RNAs were identified from multiple tissue types,9Salzman J Gawad C Wang PL Lacayo N Brown PO Circular RNAs are the predominant transcript isoform from hundreds of human genes in diverse cell types.PloS One. 2012; 7: e30733Crossref PubMed Scopus (1727) Google Scholar were resistant to RNase R treatment (which degrades linear RNA species), and had longer half-lives in cells relative to their linear RNA transcript counterparts.8Jeck WR Sorrentino JA Wang K Slevin MK Burd CE Liu J et al.Circular RNAs are abundant, conserved, and associated with ALU repeats.RNA. 2013; 19: 141-157Crossref PubMed Scopus (2849) Google Scholar Only the linear forms of these RNAs were present in heavy polyribosome fractions, suggesting that the circular forms are not translated.8Jeck WR Sorrentino JA Wang K Slevin MK Burd CE Liu J et al.Circular RNAs are abundant, conserved, and associated with ALU repeats.RNA. 2013; 19: 141-157Crossref PubMed Scopus (2849) Google Scholar A few mechanisms for the formation of circular RNAs have been proposed (Figure 1), such as via circularization of a single exon, facilitated by the presence of adjacent repetitive sequence.6Capel B Swain A Nicolis S Hacker A Walter M Koopman P et al.Circular transcripts of the testis-determining geneSry in adult mouse testis.Cell. 1993; 73: 1019-1030Abstract Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (835) Google Scholar Alternatively, circular transcripts can form after either the choice of an incorrect splice acceptor or removal of several consecutive exons in an alternatively spliced transcript. The most basic form of circular RNA involves the looping-back of sequences to a previous exon within the transcript, for instance, a junction between the 3′end of exon 3 and the 5′ end of exon 2 in a gene (Figure 1). The intronic sequence surrounding many circular transcripts is noticeably longer and enriched for repetitive elements such as ALU repeats, often in an inverted orientation.8Jeck WR Sorrentino JA Wang K Slevin MK Burd CE Liu J et al.Circular RNAs are abundant, conserved, and associated with ALU repeats.RNA. 2013; 19: 141-157Crossref PubMed Scopus (2849) Google Scholar In the two new studies in Nature, the primary circular RNA of interest is an antisense transcript to CDR1 termed CDR1as (CDR1 antisense, used herein) or ciRS-7 (circular RNA sponge for miR-7).1Hansen TB Jensen TI Clausen BH Bramsen JB Finsen B Damgaard CK et al.Natural RNA circles function as efficient microRNA sponges.Nature. 2013; 495: 384-388Crossref PubMed Scopus (5222) Google Scholar,2Memczak S Jens M Elefsinioti A Torti F Krueger J Rybak A et al.Circular RNAs are a large class of animal RNAs with regulatory potency.Nature. 2013; 495: 333-338Crossref PubMed Scopus (5207) Google Scholar This RNA was validated by rigorous bioinformatic and molecular studies. Seventy-four copies of a miR-7 binding site are present in this circular RNA owing to the presence of a tandem repeat in the transcribed sequence of CDR1as. These binding sites are conserved across eutherian (placental) mammals, whereas the intervening sequences generally are not. Other examples of miRNA sponges—for example, pseudogenes that act as competitive inhibitors of endogenous targets—often exist at an equivalent or lower stoichiometric abundance relative to their natural gene targets.10Poliseno L Salmena L Zhang J Carver B Haveman WJ Pandolfi PP A coding-independent function of gene and pseudogene mRNAs regulates tumour biology.Nature. 2010; 465: 1033-1038Crossref PubMed Scopus (1883) Google Scholar By contrast, the approximately 70 miR-7 targets present in the CDR1as transcript imply that the pool of cytoplasmic miR-7 would be rapidly sequestered following expression of CDR1as. Identification of circular RNAs specific for a miRNA of interest or engineering of the CDR1as sequences to include binding sites for the miRNA of interest could be a powerful mechanism to curb the effects of miRNAs that are overexpressed in a disease context, including many examples in oncogenesis. The study by Hansen et al.1Hansen TB Jensen TI Clausen BH Bramsen JB Finsen B Damgaard CK et al.Natural RNA circles function as efficient microRNA sponges.Nature. 2013; 495: 384-388Crossref PubMed Scopus (5222) Google Scholar showed that inverted repeats before and after the CDR1as transcript were essential for its circularization. Disabling these inverted repeats ensures that the CDR1as sequence remains linear and is subject to repression and eventual degradation by miR-7. Curiously, although the circular RNA transcript is resistant to miR-7–mediated degradation, the same group showed that a sequence with perfect complementarity to miR-671 also exists in CDR1as but is subject to Ago2-mediated cleavage and degradation.11Hansen TB Wiklund ED Bramsen JB Villadsen SB Statham AL Clark SJ et al.miRNA-dependent gene silencing involving Ago2-mediated cleavage of a circular antisense RNA.EMBO J. 2011; 30: 4414-4422Crossref PubMed Scopus (711) Google Scholar Biotin-coupled miR-7 could pull down CDR1as, and fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis showed colocalization and compartmentalization of miR-7 and CDR1as to processing bodies dependent on the presence of miR-7. Many, if not most, of the proteins necessary for miRNA gene silencing are localized to processing bodies, which play fundamental roles in general messenger RNA (mRNA) decay, nonsense-mediated mRNA decay, AU-rich element–mediated mRNA decay, and miRNA-induced mRNA silencing. The two RNA species are also coexpressed in pyramidal neurons and interneurons. Stable but low and forced expression of CDR1as in HeLa cells was able to compete for miR-7 species and prevented repression of known miR-7 target 3′ untranslated regions for the genes SNCA, EGFR, and IRS2. Finally, some of the functional characteristics for CDR1as were observed for the well-known but still understudied SRY gene and its circular RNA product that harbors corresponding target sites for miR-138 (ref. 1Hansen TB Jensen TI Clausen BH Bramsen JB Finsen B Damgaard CK et al.Natural RNA circles function as efficient microRNA sponges.Nature. 2013; 495: 384-388Crossref PubMed Scopus (5222) Google Scholar). Memczak et al.2Memczak S Jens M Elefsinioti A Torti F Krueger J Rybak A et al.Circular RNAs are a large class of animal RNAs with regulatory potency.Nature. 2013; 495: 333-338Crossref PubMed Scopus (5207) Google Scholar focused on profiling the increasing numbers of circular RNAs they were able to cull from RNA sequencing data sets. They found nearly 2,000 circular RNAs each in humans and mice and approximately 700 in C. elegans. The vast majority of the identified circular RNAs overlapped with coding exons; 223 circular RNAs were fully exonic and conserved between humans and mice. Using these data, they could show that the third (wobble) nucleotide of codons in general was under greater selective pressure within these genes than in other genes—indicative of an evolutionary constraint for the nucleotide sequence of these circular RNAs. In addition, for circular RNAs containing multiple copies of the same miRNA seed, this seed sequence was much more conserved than the surrounding region. This, again, was most notable in the CDR1as transcript. The authors also validated CDR1as functionally, in this case by means of a zebrafish model. Zebrafish retain the ancestral miR-7 sequence but not the CDR1as transcript, which emerged following the evolution of placental mammals. Consistent with the role of miR-7 in neuronal function,1Hansen TB Jensen TI Clausen BH Bramsen JB Finsen B Damgaard CK et al.Natural RNA circles function as efficient microRNA sponges.Nature. 2013; 495: 384-388Crossref PubMed Scopus (5222) Google Scholar the authors found that antagomirs to miR-7 caused a reduction in midbrain size. Likewise, delivery of CDR1as in zebrafish, which presumably also sponges miR-7, led to a similar reduction in midbrain size in this model. Functional similarities between CDR1as and the remaining circular RNAs that have been identified remain to be determined. Many of the latter are much shorter and have less obvious potential as miRNA sponges; moreover, at least a subset of them may simply reflect by-products of alternative splicing (Figure 1). So what are the other functions of these circular RNAs? Considering the historical evolution of our understanding of RNA biogenesis and function, it would be unwise to dismiss these RNAs as mere "junk" and move on. Yet the majority of circular transcripts comprise only a very few number of exons. Perhaps they can compete with exon splice enhancers or suppressors and thereby provide at least a partial explanation for the vast complexities and pervasiveness of alternative splicing. Or perhaps they act as sponges for other RNA-binding proteins. Several important questions remain; the mean length of the circular transcripts has not been established, nor the number of isoforms generated per coding transcript or how they are regulated or degraded. Answering these questions should provide some clue to what other cellular functions could be perturbed (intentionally or not) by delivering circular RNAs. These circular RNAs may be relics of an ancestral world and/or may be related to existing viral RNA species that remain circular today, a notable example being the hepatitis D virus genome. This RNA virus replicates through a process of RNA-mediated RNA transcription despite the lack of a virus-encoded RNA-dependent RNA polymerase.12Haussecker D Cao D Huang Y Parameswaran P Fire AZ Kay MA Capped small RNAs and MOV10 in human hepatitis delta virus replication.Nat Struct Mol Biol. 2008; 15: 714-721Crossref PubMed Scopus (63) Google Scholar Could circular RNAs be copied in a similar manner? In any event, our experience in manipulating viral sequences may be a starting point for generating deliberately designed circular RNAs. Furthermore, minicircle DNA vectors that contain virtually no DNA between the 5′ end of the promoter and the 3′ end of the polyadenylation site are persistently transcribed and, unlike their canonical plasmid counterparts (which are transcriptionally silenced), remain bound to RNA polymerase II across the whole expression cassette.13Gracey Maniar LE Maniar JM Chen ZY Lu J Fire AZ Kay MA Minicircle DNA vectors achieve sustained expression reflected by active chromatin and transcriptional level.Mol Ther. 2013; 21: 131-138Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (92) Google Scholar Understanding the expression and epigenetic status of circular RNAs could help improve our understanding of epigenetic changes in gene expression persistence or silencing in the context of gene transfer vectors. The large data sets that identify circular RNAs that are largely overlapping between independent studies,8Jeck WR Sorrentino JA Wang K Slevin MK Burd CE Liu J et al.Circular RNAs are abundant, conserved, and associated with ALU repeats.RNA. 2013; 19: 141-157Crossref PubMed Scopus (2849) Google Scholar along with evidence for potential function, indicate that their physiological impact can no longer be ignored, and the surprising revelations from these recent articles will provide new avenues for researching their function. Thus far, the following conclusions can be drawn about circular RNAs: they are conserved across tissues and appear in multiple species, and they are generally not translated and lack a poly(A) tail, yet are stable and resistant to exonuclease digestion. Some circular RNA species are large, but the vast majority appear to be three or fewer exons long. Much of this initial work has been performed using custom databases and enrichment procedures and thus probably underestimates the true abundance of these circular RNAs. It will be beneficial to establish consolidated protocols not only for the detection of these circular RNAs but also for their biogenesis from a biotechnology standpoint, thus adding another weapon to our arsenal for combating disease. In time, the potential for developing new nucleic acid therapeutics from circular RNAs will be realized, and lessons learned from current gene and oligonucleotide approaches may prove to be invaluable for their implementation. This work was supported by National Institutes of Health grant HL064274.