Results of Chemotherapy Alone, with Sequential or Concurrent Addition of 52 Weeks of Trastuzumab in the NCCTG N9831 HER2-Positive Adjuvant Breast Cancer Trial.
Authors: E. Perez, V. Suman, N. Davidson, J. Gralow, P. Kaufman, J. Ingle, S. Dakhil, J. Zujewski, T. Pisansky, R. Jenkins
Journal: Cancer Research (2009)

Abstract Background: N9831 is the only randomized phase III trial comparing safety and efficacy of the addition of trastuzumab (H) to doxorubicin and cyclophosphamide then paclitaxel (Arm A: AC→T) either following (Arm B: AC→T→H) or starting concurrently with paclitaxel (Arm C: AC→T+H→H) for women with resected Stage I-III invasive HER2+ breast cancer. The 3 yr cumulative incidence of NYHA class III or IV congestive heart failure or sudden cardiac death was previously reported: 3.3% in Arm C, 2.8% in Arm B (Perez EA, et al. JCO 2008). The comparison of AC→T to AC→T+H→H was reported in a joint analysis of N9831 and NSABP B-31 in 2005 and updated in 2007, demonstrating a 52% reduction in risk of a disease event (Romond E et al., NEJM 2005; Perez EA, et al. ASCO 2007).Materials and Methods: Primary endpoint is disease-free survival (DFS). At the second planned interim analysis of Arm A vs. Arm B, the O’Brien-Fleming boundary (OFB) was crossed. NCCTG Independent Data Safety Monitoring Committee approved the release of these data as well as the data pertaining to Arm B vs. Arm C due to slow pace of events [expected 647 events in 4 yr follow-up period (f/u) vs. actual 334 events in 4.5 yr f/u]. Shortly thereafter, there were sufficient events to perform the first planned interim analysis of B vs. C. We present the results of each of these pairwise comparisons taking into account the potential for crossover to Arm C after the release of the joint analysis findings in 2005.Results: From 5/2000 to 4/2005, 2448 eligible women were enrolled for the Arm A (n=1087) vs. Arm B (n=1097) comparison. Median f/u is 5.5 yrs. with 386 events. The addition of trastuzumab sequentially to AC→T significantly improved DFS, univariately [HR(Arm B/Arm A)=0.70, 95% CI: 57-86%, logrank p=0.0005] and after adjusting for age, tumor size, number of positive nodes, and ER [PPH: HRadj=0.67 (95% CI: 0.55-0.82)]. 5 yr DFS was increased from 72% with AC→T to 80% with AC→T →H.From 5/2000 to 4/2005, 1903 eligible women were enrolled for the Arm B (n=954) vs. Arm C (n=949) comparison. Median f/u is 5.3 yrs. with 312 events. The log-rank p-value testing whether DFS differs with respect to starting time of trastuzumab was 0.019. [Not crossing pre-specified OFB for statistical significance]. After adjusting for tumor size, number of positive nodes, and ER, HRadj(Arm C/Arm B)=0.75 (95% CI: 0.60-0.94)]. 5 yr DFS was increased from 80% with AC→T →H to 84% for AC→T+H →H.Conclusions: DFS is significantly improved with the addition of 52 weeks of H (sequentially or concurrently) to AC→ T. There is a statistically significant 33% reduction in the risk of an event with the sequential addition of H following AC→T. There is a strong trend for a 25% reduction in the risk of an event with starting H concurrently with T relative to sequentially after T. Therefore, based on a positive risk/benefit ratio, we recommend that trastuzumab be incorporated in a concurrent fashion with T chemotherapy.Acknowledgements: NIH CA25224, Breast Cancer Research Foundation, Genentech. Citation Information: Cancer Res 2009;69(24 Suppl):Abstract nr 80. NOTE: This abstract was accepted for presentation at the Symposium after the Abstract Book went to press.