Debate: Should Queen Elizabeth II Step Down?
As the British royal family welcomes the third in line to the throne, is it time for the House of Windsor to consider a retirement policy?

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: It meant something to her generation to make a vow which she did to serve her people until her death.
Warrant 0: her generation is still around
Warrant 1: her generation is mostly dead
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: Queen Elizabeth II lead through difficult time periods and is a continued source of pride for the United Kingdom.
Warrant 0: she has reigned and done her duty for a very long time and is deserving of respect
Warrant 1: she has reigned and done her duty for a very long time and is deserving of rest
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: It meant something to her generation to make a vow which she did to serve her people until her death.
Warrant 0: societal needs change with time, policy should change with time to better serve the needs of the people
Warrant 1: societal needs don't change with time
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: Precedent should not be broken.
Warrant 0: History is rife with royalty stepping down.
Warrant 1: History rarely records royalty stepping down.
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should step down
Reason: Charles should become King at a younger age than his mother's.
Warrant 0: the people still love Elizabeth
Warrant 1: the people no longer love Elizabeth
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: Having lived through some of the more catastrophic changes on this planet, political as well as economic. Having made some very tough decisions, which impact millions of people...Her Royal Highness, has probably, more wisdom than all journalists combined.
Warrant 0: the queen has done a lot for her country already
Warrant 1: the queen has still a lot to do for her country
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: Queen Elizabeth II lead through difficult time periods and is a continued source of pride for the United Kingdom.
Warrant 0: she should has shown she is quite capable
Warrant 1: she should quit while she's ahead
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should not step down
Reason: Having lived through some of the more catastrophic changes on this planet, political as well as economic. Having made some very tough decisions, which impact millions of people...Her Royal Highness, has probably, more wisdom than all journalists combined.
Warrant 0: she has earned her right to retire in peace
Warrant 1: she has earned her right to continue leading her country
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Queen Elizabeth II should step down
Reason: It meant something to her generation to make a vow which she did to serve her people until her death.
Warrant 0: her generation is still around
Warrant 1: her generation is mostly dead
Correct warrant: 1