Debate: Are 'Starchitects' Ruining Cities?
Are superstar architects, who often work in cities they know little about, creating buildings that don't mesh well with the surroundings?

Claim: 'Starchitects' are not ruining cities
Reason: Starchitects adhere to a more rigorous set of industry standards than do local architects.
Warrant 0: those rigorous standards won't prevent maximum economic gain
Warrant 1: those rigorous standards prevent maximum economic gain
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: 'Starchitects' are not ruining cities
Reason: If you don't judge by personal taste, New York has amazing architecture.
Warrant 0: that architecture does not fit in with the traditional style
Warrant 1: that architecture fits in with the traditional style
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: 'Starchitects' are not ruining cities
Reason: A small city with architectural treasures can become an international destination for architecture aficionados.
Warrant 0: small cities have the space or accommodations for large amounts of tourists
Warrant 1: small cities do not have the space or accommodations for large amounts of tourists
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: 'Starchitects' are not ruining cities
Reason: A small city with architectural treasures can become an international destination for architecture aficionados.
Warrant 0: small cities are not being overrun by tourists
Warrant 1: small cities are being overrun by tourists
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: 'Starchitects' are not ruining cities
Reason: Work from the Architects Collaborative and sculptors, which includes many well-known names, have enhanced large cities.
Warrant 0: these simply overcrowd cities and take over the skyline blocking the beauty of nature
Warrant 1: these add to the skyline and the beauty of nature
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: 'Starchitects' are ruining cities
Reason: Starchitects adhere to a more rigorous set of industry standards than do local architects.
Warrant 0: those rigorous standards won't prevent maximum economic gain
Warrant 1: those rigorous standards prevent maximum economic gain
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: 'Starchitects' are ruining cities
Reason: If you don't judge by personal taste, New York has amazing architecture.
Warrant 0: that architecture does not fit in with the traditional style
Warrant 1: that architecture fits in with the traditional style
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: 'Starchitects' are ruining cities
Reason: A small city with architectural treasures can become an international destination for architecture aficionados.
Warrant 0: small cities have the space or accommodations for large amounts of tourists
Warrant 1: small cities do not have the space or accommodations for large amounts of tourists
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: 'Starchitects' are ruining cities
Reason: A small city with architectural treasures can become an international destination for architecture aficionados.
Warrant 0: small cities are not being overrun by tourists
Warrant 1: small cities are being overrun by tourists
Correct warrant: 1