Debate: Should Voting Be a Constitutional Right?
Should a constitutional amendment guarantee the right to vote, to fend off efforts that inhibit and restrict voting?

Claim: Voting should be a constitutional right
Reason: The right to vote should be easier to exercise than other rights.
Warrant 0: rights cannot be lost if the individual does not deserve them
Warrant 1: rights can be lost if the individual does not deserve them
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Voting should not be a constitutional right
Reason: Voters should be educated.
Warrant 0: voters don't learn about the constitution at school
Warrant 1: voters can learn about the constitution at school
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Voting should not be a constitutional right
Reason: No one should be allowed to vote unless they can pass a test.
Warrant 0: all citizens should be tested on their civics knowledge
Warrant 1: no citizens should be tested on their civics knowledge
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Voting should not be a constitutional right
Reason: There should be more prerequisites to voting than being alive.
Warrant 0: being a sentient being is not enough
Warrant 1: being a sentient being is more than enough
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Voting should not be a constitutional right
Reason: There should be more prerequisites to voting than being alive.
Warrant 0: constitutional rights should not have prerequisites
Warrant 1: constitutional rights should have prerequisites
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Voting should not be a constitutional right
Reason: The right to vote should be easier to exercise than other rights.
Warrant 0: rights cannot be lost if the individual does not deserve them
Warrant 1: rights can be lost if the individual does not deserve them
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Voting should be a constitutional right
Reason: Voters should be educated.
Warrant 0: voters don't learn about the constitution at school
Warrant 1: voters can learn about the constitution at school
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Voting should be a constitutional right
Reason: No one should be allowed to vote unless they can pass a test.
Warrant 0: all citizens should be tested on their civics knowledge
Warrant 1: no citizens should be tested on their civics knowledge
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Voting should be a constitutional right
Reason: There should be more prerequisites to voting than being alive.
Warrant 0: being a sentient being is not enough
Warrant 1: being a sentient being is more than enough
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Voting should be a constitutional right
Reason: There should be more prerequisites to voting than being alive.
Warrant 0: constitutional rights should not have prerequisites
Warrant 1: constitutional rights should have prerequisites
Correct warrant: 1