Debate: Should College Be for Everyone?
Should as many people as possible be encouraged to attend college, or is the value of higher education exaggerated?

Claim: College free for everyone
Reason: Banks can get bailed out, but young people with student loans are locked into debt.
Warrant 0: the students can't choose this path over less expensive routes (community college, transfer to state)
Warrant 1: the students can choose this path over less expensive routes (community college, transfer to state)
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: College not free for everyone
Reason: Not everyone can be a scientist or a doctor and I am tired of advising these below average and unrealistic students.
Warrant 0: challenging college courses won't discourage below-average students from continuing their education
Warrant 1: challenging college courses will discourage below-average students from continuing their education
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: College not free for everyone
Reason: Not everyone can be a scientist or a doctor and I am tired of advising these below average and unrealistic students.
Warrant 0: we can make a college for garbage men
Warrant 1: we can't make a college for garbage men
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: College free for everyone
Reason: Banks can get bailed out, but young people with student loans are locked into debt.
Warrant 0: not everyone is cut out for it
Warrant 1: everyone is cut out for it
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: College not free for everyone
Reason: Banks can get bailed out, but young people with student loans are locked into debt.
Warrant 0: the students can't choose this path over less expensive routes (community college, transfer to state)
Warrant 1: the students can choose this path over less expensive routes (community college, transfer to state)
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: College free for everyone
Reason: Not everyone can be a scientist or a doctor and I am tired of advising these below average and unrealistic students.
Warrant 0: challenging college courses won't discourage below-average students from continuing their education
Warrant 1: challenging college courses will discourage below-average students from continuing their education
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: College free for everyone
Reason: Not everyone can be a scientist or a doctor and I am tired of advising these below average and unrealistic students.
Warrant 0: we can make a college for garbage men
Warrant 1: we can't make a college for garbage men
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: College not free for everyone
Reason: Banks can get bailed out, but young people with student loans are locked into debt.
Warrant 0: not everyone is cut out for it
Warrant 1: everyone is cut out for it
Correct warrant: 0