Debate: Should Home-Schoolers Play for High School Teams?
Home-schoolers may not want their children in the classroom but they'd like to see them on the football field. Is that their right?

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: Playing with high school teams allows home-schoolers to have more social interaction.
Warrant 0: home-schooled children would associate with public school children
Warrant 1: home-schooled children would rather not associate with public school children
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Public schools earn their funding by the number of students who are actually enrolled, therefore, anyone who doesn't enroll should not get to use services paid for with that money.
Warrant 0: the parents can't pay a fee
Warrant 1: the parents can pay a fee
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Home schoolers are not part of the community.
Warrant 0: they do not lack a path to learn team building
Warrant 1: they lack a path to learn team building
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: Playing with high school teams allows home-schoolers to have more social interaction.
Warrant 0: parents don't want these students to have social interaction
Warrant 1: students at home schools don't have social interaction
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: All children should be able to participate in sports.
Warrant 0: kids can play sports at home or in private leagues
Warrant 1: kids cannot always play sports at home or in private leagues
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Like private school, boarding school, and religious school students, home schooled students might pay taxes, but the school colors are not meaningful to them.
Warrant 0: children should be allowed to have the experience of athletics
Warrant 1: children shouldn't be allowed to have the experience of athletics if they haven't earned it
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Like private school, boarding school, and religious school students, home schooled students might pay taxes, but the school colors are not meaningful to them.
Warrant 0: the school colors are the most important part of athletic events which teach kids comradery
Warrant 1: the school colors aren't the most important part of athletic events which teach kids comradery
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: Has worked  quite well in West Chester Ohio.
Warrant 0: West Chester Ohio is definitely a good role model for efficiency
Warrant 1: West Chester Ohio is definitely not a good role model for efficiency
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: Has worked  quite well in West Chester Ohio.
Warrant 0: it worked for the West Chester case
Warrant 1: the West Chester case is an exception, and all other cases have ended badly or just not worked
Correct warrant: 1