Debate: Should Affirmative Action Be Based on Income?
Will the Supreme Court decision on race-based preferences push colleges to resort to less effective methods to promote to diversity?

Claim: Affirmative actions should be based on income
Reason: If race is such a big part of the economic hardships and the reasons people are denied opportunities, then economic based actions would be a better solution.
Warrant 0: we don't want better solutions
Warrant 1: we want better solutions
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Affirmative actions should be based on income
Reason: Socioecomonics should play a higher role in college admissions instead of race.
Warrant 0: race is just one factor
Warrant 1: race is an important issue
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Affirmative actions should not be based on income
Reason: If race is such a big part of the economic hardships and the reasons people are denied opportunities, then economic based actions would be a better solution.
Warrant 0: we don't want better solutions
Warrant 1: we want better solutions
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Affirmative actions should not be based on income
Reason: Socioecomonics should play a higher role in college admissions instead of race.
Warrant 0: race is just one factor
Warrant 1: race is an important issue
Correct warrant: 1