Debate: Do Teachers Need to Have Experience?
Many charter schools rely on young inexperienced, but motivated, people who quit after a few years. Is that a good idea?

Claim: Teachers need to have experience
Reason: Teachers become better and more consistent with more experience.
Warrant 0: too much experience may make teachers set in their ways and not open to fresh ideas, hiring new teachers might be a better decision.
Warrant 1: too much experience does not make teachers set in their ways and not open to fresh ideas, hiring new teachers might not be a better decision.
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Teachers do not need to have experience
Reason: Enthusiasm by young teachers can actually be worth more than teachers who have a negative attitude.
Warrant 0: enthusiasm is not as important as skills as an educator
Warrant 1: enthusiasm is more important than skills as an educator
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Teachers do not need to have experience
Reason: Enthusiasm by young teachers can actually be worth more than teachers who have a negative attitude.
Warrant 0: teachers can still be excited after having training, it shows they truly love their job
Warrant 1: teachers might not still be excited after having training, even if they truly love their job
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Teachers need to have experience
Reason: It took me 5 years to become a good teacher.
Warrant 0: 5 years is a lot of time spent in the classroom
Warrant 1: 5 years is practically nothing
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Teachers do not need to have experience
Reason: Experienced teachers lose their zest by the 6th or 7th year.
Warrant 0: zest isn't as important as being knowledgeable
Warrant 1: zest is just as important as being knowledgeable
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Teachers do not need to have experience
Reason: Teachers become better and more consistent with more experience.
Warrant 0: too much experience may make teachers set in their ways and not open to fresh ideas, hiring new teachers might be a better decision.
Warrant 1: too much experience does not make teachers set in their ways and not open to fresh ideas, hiring new teachers might not be a better decision.
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Teachers need to have experience
Reason: Enthusiasm by young teachers can actually be worth more than teachers who have a negative attitude.
Warrant 0: enthusiasm is not as important as skills as an educator
Warrant 1: enthusiasm is more important than skills as an educator
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Teachers need to have experience
Reason: Enthusiasm by young teachers can actually be worth more than teachers who have a negative attitude.
Warrant 0: teachers can still be excited after having training, it shows they truly love their job
Warrant 1: teachers might not still be excited after having training, even if they truly love their job
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Teachers do not need to have experience
Reason: It took me 5 years to become a good teacher.
Warrant 0: 5 years is a lot of time spent in the classroom
Warrant 1: 5 years is practically nothing
Correct warrant: 1