Debate: Should Home-Schoolers Play for High School Teams?
Home-schoolers may not want their children in the classroom but they'd like to see them on the football field. Is that their right?

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Has worked  quite well in West Chester Ohio.
Warrant 0: West Chester Ohio is definitely a good role model for efficiency
Warrant 1: West Chester Ohio is definitely not a good role model for efficiency
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Has worked  quite well in West Chester Ohio.
Warrant 0: it worked for the West Chester case
Warrant 1: the West Chester case is an exception, and all other cases have ended badly or just not worked
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: They have paid for the right through taxes and deserve the chance to further their athletic abilities.
Warrant 0: they freely chose to forego the tax benefits of public education
Warrant 1: they freely chose not to forego the tax benefits of public education
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: Those choosing to home school should not be allowed to just take what they want from public education.
Warrant 0: sports is a part of education
Warrant 1: sports isn't a part of education
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Has worked  quite well in West Chester Ohio.
Warrant 0: what works in OH may work elsewhere
Warrant 1: what works in OH may not work elsewhere
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should not play for high school teams
Reason: Those choosing to home school should not be allowed to just take what they want from public education.
Warrant 0: parents should pay a fee
Warrant 1: paretnts are paying a cost for not utilizing public schools
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Home schoolers are discriminated against when they can't play sports.
Warrant 0: people are discriminated against in the real world, too
Warrant 1: people are not allowed to be discriminated against in the real world
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: Home schooled kids could enjoy sports and company of others around them.
Warrant 0: there are many community sports programs held outside of schools
Warrant 1: there are not many community sports programs held outside of schools
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: It is right for home-schoolers to play for high school sports teams if they meet the same academic and other requirements for enrolled kids.
Warrant 0: nearly all home-schooled child meets these requirements
Warrant 1: nearly no home-schooled child meets these requirements
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Home-schoolers should play for high school teams
Reason: If home schooled children get to pick a high school sports team high school kids will want to be able to play for other schools.
Warrant 0: picking teams encourages competitiveness
Warrant 1: picking teams is not the way the system works
Correct warrant: 0