Debate: Do We Need More Advice About Eating Well?
Maybe Americans would be healthier if we understood nutrition better. Or maybe we know enough, and eat poorly for other reasons.

Claim: We do not need more advice about eating well
Reason: The internet contains sufficient nutrition information.
Warrant 0: most people have the internet
Warrant 1: not everyone has the internet
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: We need more advice about eating well
Reason: We can learn healthy habits to defend against the marketing of the food industrial complex.
Warrant 0: it is not easier to just do the opposite of what food advertisers tell you
Warrant 1: it is easier to just do the opposite of what food advertisers tell you
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: We do not need more advice about eating well
Reason: Some kids are not taught by parents how to cook, and many schools have done away with home economics in favor of science and math.
Warrant 0: there is a large supply of information available online that anyone and everyone can access
Warrant 1: there isn't a large supply of information available online that anyone and everyone can access
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: We do not need more advice about eating well
Reason: We can learn healthy habits to defend against the marketing of the food industrial complex.
Warrant 0: we can't learn healthy habits ourselves
Warrant 1: we can learn healthy habits ourselves
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: We do not need more advice about eating well
Reason: Americans might be healthier if we understood nutrition better.
Warrant 0: there is not much of information available to everyone and a none of it is common sense that people usually just ignore
Warrant 1: there is lots of information available to everyone and a lot of it is common sense that people usually just ignore
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: We do not need more advice about eating well
Reason: Some kids are not taught by parents how to cook, and many schools have done away with home economics in favor of science and math.
Warrant 0: some kids know how to cook at home
Warrant 1: some kids don't know how to cook at home
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: We do not need more advice about eating well
Reason: Some kids are not taught by parents how to cook, and many schools have done away with home economics in favor of science and math.
Warrant 0: the internet and tv have more than enough resources to counteract the above
Warrant 1: the internet and tv do not have enough resources to counteract the above
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: We need more advice about eating well
Reason: Information regarding healthy eating is readily accessible to any who care to educate themselves.
Warrant 0: This information offers the same bland choices, people need to learn new ways to eat exciting food that is satisfying and healthy
Warrant 1: This information offers the same bland choices, people do not need to learn new ways to eat exciting food that is satisfying and healthy
Correct warrant: 0