Debate: To Tip or Not to Tip
Should restaurants do away with tipping?

Claim: To tip
Reason: Diners may not be able to select the server, but they can compensate them according to their service.
Warrant 0: this is fair because people will not be too picky or judgmental to offer a fair tip
Warrant 1: this is unfair because people could be too picky or judgmental to offer a fair tip
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: To tip
Reason: Tipping rewards entrepreneurial spirit and hard work.
Warrant 0: society needs rank and file workers more than entrepreneurs
Warrant 1: society needs entrepreneurs more than rank and file workers,
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: To tip
Reason: Tipping rewards entrepreneurial spirit and hard work.
Warrant 0: most waiters do no work hard
Warrant 1: most waiters do work hard
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Not to tip
Reason: Tips are insulting to customers and servers.
Warrant 0: a person will allow you to insult them if they are paid
Warrant 1: a person won't allow you to insult them if they are paid
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: To tip
Reason: Tipping servers provides an added incentive to create a pleasant environment for the customers.
Warrant 0: they should make a pleasant environment anyway
Warrant 1: they have no incentive to make a pleasant environment anyway
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Not to tip
Reason: This would allow for worker to have higher wages.
Warrant 0: servers will make more than minimum wage regardless of tipping
Warrant 1: servers will make more than minimum wage only when they are tipped
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Not to tip
Reason: In other parts of the world, including Japan, Europe, and New Zealand, restaurant employees earn a living wage and aren't dependent on patrons' tips.
Warrant 0: the US runs similarly and they should make minimum wage
Warrant 1: the US runs differently and they make less than half minimum wage
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Not to tip
Reason: Wait staff should be taken care of by the restauranteur.
Warrant 0: the restauranteur is  taking care of the staff
Warrant 1: the restauranteur is not taking care of the staff
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Not to tip
Reason: In other parts of the world, including Japan, Europe, and New Zealand, restaurant employees earn a living wage and aren't dependent on patrons' tips.
Warrant 0: the waiters in Japan are offended if you don't tip
Warrant 1: the waiters in Japan are offended if you tip
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: To tip
Reason: Tipping is important, especially in small towns where there are few career options.
Warrant 0: people need jobs
Warrant 1: people need to start getting better jobs
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: To tip
Reason: Getting rid of tips would create another problem for the American worker.
Warrant 0: the worker in this field has chosen to work in this risky business
Warrant 1: the worker in this field has unwisely chosen to work in this risky business
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Not to tip
Reason: Places in which you pick your order up or clean up after yourself have tip jars, and we do not owe them those tips.
Warrant 0: no tip should be given for proper food preparation
Warrant 1: the tip is given for proper food preparation
Correct warrant: 0