Debate: Citizen of the State of New York
Is state citizenship the answer to immigration reform?

Claim: State citizenship is not the answer to immigration reform
Reason: The idea of allowing states to grant citizenship may have historical roots, but it has serious drawbacks.
Warrant 0: the pros outweigh the cons and can offer a better path to citizenship
Warrant 1: the pros do not outweigh the cons and can not offer a better path to citizenship
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: State citizenship is the answer to immigration reform
Reason: The idea of allowing states to grant citizenship may have historical roots, but it has serious drawbacks.
Warrant 0: the pros outweigh the cons and can offer a better path to citizenship
Warrant 1: the pros do not outweigh the cons and can not offer a better path to citizenship
Correct warrant: 0