Debate: Should the Government Grade Colleges?
Should the government rate colleges to hold them accountable for graduation rates, student debt and access for the poor and minorities?

Claim: Government should not grade colleges
Reason: Government grading colleges would serve taxpayers, who expect high results from colleges.
Warrant 0: the government should not serve taxpayers in this way
Warrant 1: the government should serve taxpayers in this way
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Government should grade colleges
Reason: Public schools before college should be the main focus of the government.
Warrant 0: the government grades public schools
Warrant 1: the government doesn't grade public schools
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Government should grade colleges
Reason: Student learning can't be measured.
Warrant 0: we would be measuring the schools and not students
Warrant 1: we would be measuring the students and not schools
Correct warrant: 0