Debate: Can Hamas-Fatah Unity Lead to Mideast Peace?
Will a reconciliation between Fatah and Hamas improve the chances of Arab-Israeli peace, which have dimmed as U.S.-backed talks foundered?

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: It is likely that Jewish people would be slaughtered, proof of that is what is happening between Egyptians and Muslims.
Warrant 0: Jewish people need to stop being killed
Warrant 1: Jewish people must stop being killed
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: Jorday, Egypt, Syria and Lebanon attacked Israel in 1948.
Warrant 0: that was almost 70 years ago
Warrant 1: that was only 70 years ago
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: Arab leaders have no interest in sitting beside a Jewish State that is responsible for decades of Arab refugees.
Warrant 0: Arab leaders are willing to change for peace
Warrant 1: Arab leaders aren't willing to change for peace
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: Jorday, Egypt, Syria and Lebanon attacked Israel in 1948.
Warrant 0: that attack did not lead to treaties to resolve issues
Warrant 1: that attack lead to treaties to resolve issues
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: It is likely that Jewish people would be slaughtered, proof of that is what is happening between Egyptians and Muslims.
Warrant 0: the only peace lies in genocide
Warrant 1: only war and turmoil lies in genocide
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: Arabs main goal is to destroy Israel.
Warrant 0: destroying Israel isn't the way to go
Warrant 1: destroying Israel is the way to go
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can't lead to mideast peace
Reason: Arab leaders have no interest in sitting beside a Jewish State that is responsible for decades of Arab refugees.
Warrant 0: together Fatah and Hamas can afford to buy new territory far from Israel
Warrant 1: together Fatah and Hamas cannot afford to buy new territory far from Israel
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can lead to mideast peace
Reason: It is likely that Jewish people would be slaughtered, proof of that is what is happening between Egyptians and Muslims.
Warrant 0: Jewish people need to stop being killed
Warrant 1: Jewish people must stop being killed
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can lead to mideast peace
Reason: Jorday, Egypt, Syria and Lebanon attacked Israel in 1948.
Warrant 0: that was almost 70 years ago
Warrant 1: that was only 70 years ago
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Hamas-Fatah unity can lead to mideast peace
Reason: Arab leaders have no interest in sitting beside a Jewish State that is responsible for decades of Arab refugees.
Warrant 0: Arab leaders are willing to change for peace
Warrant 1: Arab leaders aren't willing to change for peace
Correct warrant: 0