Debate: Keeping Only the Best Behaved
Are charter schools, with their high rates of suspension and expulsion, cherry-picking students?

Claim: Charter schools are cherry-picking students
Reason: Charter schools getting rid of problem students creates more problems.
Warrant 0: charter schools have problem students
Warrant 1: charter schools don't have any problem students
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Charter schools are cherry-picking students
Reason: Faux Lotteries are just a form of cherry picking.
Warrant 0: an independent body isn't used to conduct the lottery
Warrant 1: an independent body conducts the lottery
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Charter schools are cherry-picking students
Reason: Charter schools getting rid of problem students creates more problems.
Warrant 0: these students rarely create problematic learning atmospheres and hinder other students
Warrant 1: these students often create problematic learning atmospheres and hinder other students
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Charter schools are cherry-picking students
Reason: Extra suspensions in charter schools are a failure of their business model and should be liable for results and restitution.
Warrant 0: the charter schools do have bad children
Warrant 1: the charter schools do not  have bad children
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Charter schools are cherry-picking students
Reason: Faux Lotteries are just a form of cherry picking.
Warrant 0: this has yet to be proven in court
Warrant 1: this has been proven in court
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Charter schools are not cherry-picking students
Reason: Charter schools getting rid of problem students creates more problems.
Warrant 0: charter schools have problem students
Warrant 1: charter schools don't have any problem students
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Charter schools are not cherry-picking students
Reason: Faux Lotteries are just a form of cherry picking.
Warrant 0: an independent body isn't used to conduct the lottery
Warrant 1: an independent body conducts the lottery
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Charter schools are not cherry-picking students
Reason: Charter schools getting rid of problem students creates more problems.
Warrant 0: these students rarely create problematic learning atmospheres and hinder other students
Warrant 1: these students often create problematic learning atmospheres and hinder other students
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Charter schools are not cherry-picking students
Reason: Extra suspensions in charter schools are a failure of their business model and should be liable for results and restitution.
Warrant 0: the charter schools do have bad children
Warrant 1: the charter schools do not  have bad children
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Charter schools are not cherry-picking students
Reason: Faux Lotteries are just a form of cherry picking.
Warrant 0: this has yet to be proven in court
Warrant 1: this has been proven in court
Correct warrant: 0