Debate: Can Wal-Mart Make Us Healthier?
How the company's plan to cut salt, sugar and fat from its food might affect our diets.

Claim: Wal-Mart can make us healthier
Reason: Wal-Mart is doing well for trying to help consumers eat better.
Warrant 0: junk will always be available and not all consumers have access to a Walmart
Warrant 1: junk may not always be available and all consumers have access to a Walmart
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wal-Mart can't make us healthier
Reason: There will still be unhealthy products available in Wal-Mart.
Warrant 0: the FDA forces food products to have nutrition information on the packaging, more selection is worse
Warrant 1: the FDA forces food products to have nutrition information on the packaging, more selection is better
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Wal-Mart can make us healthier
Reason: A healthy food initiative is a great way for Wal-Mart to show its loyalty to customers.
Warrant 0: Wal-Mart only wants to get customers and doesn't care about their health
Warrant 1: Wal-Mart wants to get customers and cares about their health
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wal-Mart can make us healthier
Reason: A healthy food initiative is a great way for Wal-Mart to show its loyalty to customers.
Warrant 0: Walmart has good intention of starting a healthy food initiative
Warrant 1: Walmart has no intention of starting a healthy food initiative
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Wal-Mart can't make us healthier
Reason: Wal-Mart is only looking out for themselves and their bottom line, they are not looking to help others.
Warrant 0: it would benefit them financially to help their customers
Warrant 1: it wouldn't benefit them financially to help their customers
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wal-Mart can't make us healthier
Reason: Wal-mart's changes do more for its image than public health; it is the government's job to look out for public health.
Warrant 0: the government will regulate Wal-Mart
Warrant 1: the government will not regulate Wal-Mart
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wal-Mart cannot make us healthier
Reason: Wal-Mart is doing well for trying to help consumers eat better.
Warrant 0: junk will always be available and not all consumers have access to a Walmart
Warrant 1: junk may not always be available and all consumers have access to a Walmart
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Wal-Mart can make us healthier
Reason: There will still be unhealthy products available in Wal-Mart.
Warrant 0: the FDA forces food products to have nutrition information on the packaging, more selection is worse
Warrant 1: the FDA forces food products to have nutrition information on the packaging, more selection is better
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wal-Mart cannot make us healthier
Reason: A healthy food initiative is a great way for Wal-Mart to show its loyalty to customers.
Warrant 0: Wal-Mart only wants to get customers and doesn't care about their health
Warrant 1: Wal-Mart wants to get customers and cares about their health
Correct warrant: 0