Debate: Should Companies Tell Us When They Get Hacked?
Although hacking is common, it's rare for companies to talk about it. Would disclosure make consumers safer, or just help hackers?

Claim: Disclosure makes consumers safer
Reason: Companies should disclose hacking attempts as a matter of national security.
Warrant 0: disclosure would not create competition between hackers to one up the others
Warrant 1: disclosure would create competition between hackers to one up the others
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Disclosure makes consumers safer
Reason: Corporations should cover the losses of identity theft of their customer if they are hacked and should be required to inform customer right away.
Warrant 0: hackers don't follow the rules anyway
Warrant 1: white hat hackers follow the rules
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Disclosure makes consumers safer
Reason: Corporations should cover the losses of identity theft of their customer if they are hacked and should be required to inform customer right away.
Warrant 0: customers would have submitted their information already
Warrant 1: customers would not submitted their information yet
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Disclosure makes consumers safer
Reason: Companies that keep sensitive information about their customers, should disclose hacks to those customers.
Warrant 0: disclosure doesn't reveal sensitive information
Warrant 1: disclosure would reveal sensitive information
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Disclosure does not make consumers safer
Reason: Companies should disclose hacking attempts as a matter of national security.
Warrant 0: disclosure would not create competition between hackers to one up the others
Warrant 1: disclosure would create competition between hackers to one up the others
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Disclosure does not make consumers safer
Reason: Corporations should cover the losses of identity theft of their customer if they are hacked and should be required to inform customer right away.
Warrant 0: hackers don't follow the rules anyway
Warrant 1: white hat hackers follow the rules
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Disclosure does not make consumers safer
Reason: Corporations should cover the losses of identity theft of their customer if they are hacked and should be required to inform customer right away.
Warrant 0: customers would have submitted their information already
Warrant 1: customers would not submitted their information yet
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Disclosure does not make consumers safer
Reason: Companies that keep sensitive information about their customers, should disclose hacks to those customers.
Warrant 0: disclosure doesn't reveal sensitive information
Warrant 1: disclosure would reveal sensitive information
Correct warrant: 1