Debate: Making Vaccination Mandatory for All Children
Should parents no longer be allowed to get religious or philosophical exemptions from having their children immunized?

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Parents muse be able to choose what is best for their children and family.
Warrant 0: unvaccinated children endanger the other children they encounter and infringe on the rights of other parents to keep their children safe
Warrant 1: unvaccinated children don't endanger the other children they encounter and do not infringe on the rights of other parents to keep their children safe
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: If vaccinations are not mandatory then those making selfish choices will cause others to be harmed.
Warrant 0: the selfish choice is to use the vaccine
Warrant 1: the selfish choice is to refuse the vaccine
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Vaccinations can cause polio even in the weakened form.
Warrant 0: this is a ridiculous myth that has no basis in reality and is in every way factually incorrect
Warrant 1: this is not a ridiculous myth that has no basis in reality and is in every way not factually incorrect
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Vaccination should remain a personal choice.
Warrant 0: children can make personal choices for themselves under the law
Warrant 1: children can't make personal choices for themselves under the law
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: Herd immunity protects against those that cannot be vaccinated.
Warrant 0: many need to be vaccinated to benefit from herd immunity
Warrant 1: one does not need vaccinated to benefit from herd immunity
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: It is unfair for families affected by vaccine injuries to say that their suffering is for the greater good.
Warrant 0: suffering of an individual, while unfair, does not overshadow a threat to the public
Warrant 1: suffering of an individual, is unfair, and overshadows a threat to the public
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: Unvaccinated children places others at risk.
Warrant 0: a free society has such risks
Warrant 1: a free society does not need such risks
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Some are not willing to take the risk of vaccine injuries.
Warrant 0: the risk of not vaccinating the entire population is much riskier than the individual risk of vaccine injury
Warrant 1: the risk of not vaccinating the entire population is much less risky than the individual risk of vaccine injury
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: There are thousands of people injured by vaccines, and years of studies that make me question their safety.
Warrant 0: the plague killed no one
Warrant 1: the plague killed literally millions
Correct warrant: 0