Debate: Should All Immigrants Get ID Cards?
Should cities issue identification for anyone who has no passport or driver's license, even if they are not in the country legally?

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Giving all immigrants ID cards would allow police to get information about people from their home country.
Warrant 0: people want the police to know their information
Warrant 1: people don't want the police to know their information
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: It would give dignity to both immigrants and democracy.
Warrant 0: dignity should be bestowed freely
Warrant 1: dignity should be earned
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Legal identification would help police identify people.
Warrant 0: the government should know who is who
Warrant 1: the government should not know who is who
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Undocumented people would no longer remain anonymous to the government.
Warrant 0: people don't have the right to be anonymous
Warrant 1: people have the right to be anonymous
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should get ID cards
Reason: After crossing our border unlawfully they do not deserve an ID card as this is approval of being in our country
Warrant 0: immigrants continue to spill into the US in spite of our disapproval
Warrant 1: immigrants continue to spill into the US in spite of our approval
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: ID cards will be helpful in deportations.
Warrant 0: id cards and deportation will cost the country small amounts of money
Warrant 1: id cards and deportation will cost the country tons of money
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Legal identification would help police identify people.
Warrant 0: immigrants really don't want to be identified
Warrant 1: immigrants need to be identified
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Undocumented people would no longer remain anonymous to the government.
Warrant 0: ID cards can be forged
Warrant 1: ID cards cannot be forged
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Legal identification would help police identify people.
Warrant 0: identifying people is the only fun part of a police officers job
Warrant 1: identifying people is the goal of a police officers job
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Giving all immigrants ID cards would allow police to get information about people from their home country.
Warrant 0: Police need information
Warrant 1: Police don't need information
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: All immigrants should not get ID cards
Reason: Millions of people will get authorized to work or will return home to improve their lives with work.
Warrant 0: those people won't send money back home to fund drug lords
Warrant 1: those people send money back home to fund drug lords
Correct warrant: 1