Debate: Can Dual Citizens Be Good Americans?
Should dual citizenship be allowed? The pros and cons of pledging allegiance to more than one country.

Claim: Dual citizenship should not be allowed
Reason: Dual citizenship allows one to enjoy the pros and cons of the home country and the country that is welcoming them.
Warrant 0: people shouldn't be welcomed in more than one country
Warrant 1: people should be welcomed in more than one country
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Dual citizenship should not be allowed
Reason: A person should be part of a country he/she shares a culture.
Warrant 0: each country has it's own culture
Warrant 1: each person has their own culture
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Dual citizenship should not be allowed
Reason: The dual citizen can have the best of both countries.
Warrant 0: America should be first
Warrant 1: America doesn't have to be first
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Dual citizenship should be allowed
Reason: Harvard billionaires have demonstrated that duel citizenship shows a lack of commitment to the United States.
Warrant 0: few duel citizens have done much good for our country
Warrant 1: many duel citizens who have done much good for our country
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Dual citizenship should be allowed
Reason: Dual citizens do not have true allegiance to either country and get away without paying taxes.
Warrant 0: taxes are crucial for countries
Warrant 1: taxes are unethical
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Dual citizenship should be allowed
Reason: Dual citizens do not have true allegiance to either country and get away without paying taxes.
Warrant 0: dual citizens shouldn't be able to choose their loyalty
Warrant 1: dual citizens can choose their loyalty
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Dual citizenship should not be allowed
Reason: A person should be part of a country he/she shares a culture.
Warrant 0: there is no room in a person's heart for more than one culture
Warrant 1: there is room in a person's heart for more than one culture
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Dual citizenship should be allowed
Reason: Dual citizens do not have true allegiance to either country and get away without paying taxes.
Warrant 0: one needs to have a true allegiance in order to have their tax responsibility enforced
Warrant 1: one doesn't need to have true allegiance in order to have their tax responsibility enforced
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Dual citizenship should not be allowed
Reason: America has more opportunity, but people are still loyal to their homes.
Warrant 0: you should be able to take advantage of American opportunity without loyalty to it
Warrant 1: you shouldn't be able to take advantage of American opportunity without loyalty to it
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Dual citizenship should not be allowed
Reason: A person should be part of a country he/she shares a culture.
Warrant 0: It's impossible for anyone to have more than one culture.
Warrant 1: It's possible for everyone to have more than one culture.
Correct warrant: 0