Debate: Making Vaccination Mandatory for All Children
Should parents no longer be allowed to get religious or philosophical exemptions from having their children immunized?

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: Parents who do not vaccinate their children should consider what it is like to raise a child in a more disease prevalent country.
Warrant 0: vaccines do not prevent disease
Warrant 1: vaccines prevent disease
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: Anyone refusing to vaccinate children should be liable for any disease or death they cause.
Warrant 0: it will be made clear the unvaccinated are at fault
Warrant 1: it won't be possible to make clear which unvaccinated are at fault
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: Cases of measles, mumps and other diseases are increasing.
Warrant 0: infectious diseases were a natural part of life until we cured them with vaccines
Warrant 1: infectious diseases are a natural part of life
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: People who choose not to vaccinate their children endanger their children as well as others.
Warrant 0: the earth is overpopulated
Warrant 1: the earth is underpopulated
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Doctors advocate for vaccines even though they know they carry risks.
Warrant 0: doctors do not know what is best for children better than their parents
Warrant 1: doctors know what is best for children better than their parents
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: There can be allergies, and homeopathy is a better alternative.
Warrant 0: homeopathy is going to help those with polio or measles and those who are allergic cannot get exemptions
Warrant 1: homeopathy is not going to do anything for polio or measles and those who are allergic can get exemptions
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should be mandatory for all children
Reason: We all have a right to be protected against communicable diseases which cause serious issues or death.
Warrant 0: I can protect myself if i so choose
Warrant 1: I cannot protect myself if i so choose
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Parents muse be able to choose what is best for their children and family.
Warrant 0: vaccination is not what is best for children
Warrant 1: vaccination is what is best for children
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Increasing the number of vaccinations for children causes more people to refuse to be vaccinated at all.
Warrant 0: those people don't have a risk of breaking down our herd immunity
Warrant 1: those people have a risk of breaking down our herd immunity
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Vaccination should not be mandatory for all children
Reason: Some are not willing to take the risk of vaccine injuries.
Warrant 0: willingness to take the vaccine doesn't matter
Warrant 1: willingness to take the vaccine matters
Correct warrant: 1