Debate: Beachfront Access
Should those with beachfront homes have to open their land to the public?

Claim: Beachfront homes should have to open their land to the public
Reason: Lakes are public and should be accessible.
Warrant 0: there are already plenty of public lakes on public lands
Warrant 1: there aren't already enough public lakes on public lands
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Beachfront homes should have to open their land to the public
Reason: If a hurricane destroys their beach house, they are compensated with aid, so allowing people to walk on the beach is a fair trade off.
Warrant 0: disasters like hurricanes are common
Warrant 1: disasters like hurricanes are very rare
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Beachfront homes should not have to open their land to the public
Reason: Lakes are public and should be accessible.
Warrant 0: there are already plenty of public lakes on public lands
Warrant 1: there aren't already enough public lakes on public lands
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Beachfront homes should not have to open their land to the public
Reason: If a hurricane destroys their beach house, they are compensated with aid, so allowing people to walk on the beach is a fair trade off.
Warrant 0: disasters like hurricanes are common
Warrant 1: disasters like hurricanes are very rare
Correct warrant: 1