Debate: Does Tenure Protect Bad Teachers or Good Schools?
Do job protections prevent bad faculty from being removed or do they provide for greater stability in a demanding, low-paid profession?

Claim: Tenure does not protect bad teachers
Reason: Tenure prevents bad teachers from being weeded out early in their career.
Warrant 0: tenure doen's only protect the good
Warrant 1: tenure also protects the good
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Tenure does not protect bad teachers
Reason: Tenure allows for teachers who drink on the job or fall asleep at their desks to bargain for bonuses and increased retirement in order to get rid of them.
Warrant 0: even bad teachers won't lose their jobs
Warrant 1: even bad teachers don't lose their jobs
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Tenure does not provides stability
Reason: The security of tenure is necessary to compensate for the low salary of teachers.
Warrant 0: a poor salary is a part of the job and not being paid well ensures a teacher will be good
Warrant 1: a poor salary is a part of the job and not being paid well does not ensure a teacher will be good
Correct warrant: 1