Debate: Do Wealthy Colleges Deserve Their Tax Breaks?
Should government change its tax exemption policies for universities as a way of equalizing educational resources in America?

Claim: Wealthy colleges deserve tax breaks
Reason: Columbia College lets low income students attend for almost no tuition cost.
Warrant 0: those students could not attend a state college for the same amount
Warrant 1: those students could likely attend a state college for the same amount
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Wealthy colleges do not deserve tax breaks
Reason: Harvard is very wealthy and that money could provide education to thousands. Instead, it just serves to suggest that Harvard provides a superior education.
Warrant 0: the wealthy do not need a superior education
Warrant 1: the wealthy need a superior education
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Wealthy colleges do not deserve tax breaks
Reason: Harvard is very wealthy and that money could provide education to thousands. Instead, it just serves to suggest that Harvard provides a superior education.
Warrant 0: these colleges educate our ruling elite, which we need
Warrant 1: these colleges educate our ruling elite, which we do not need
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wealthy colleges do not deserve tax breaks
Reason: Columbia College lets low income students attend for almost no tuition cost.
Warrant 0: those students could not attend a state college for the same amount
Warrant 1: those students could likely attend a state college for the same amount
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wealthy colleges deserve tax breaks
Reason: Harvard is very wealthy and that money could provide education to thousands. Instead, it just serves to suggest that Harvard provides a superior education.
Warrant 0: the wealthy do not need a superior education
Warrant 1: the wealthy need a superior education
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Wealthy colleges deserve tax breaks
Reason: Harvard is very wealthy and that money could provide education to thousands. Instead, it just serves to suggest that Harvard provides a superior education.
Warrant 0: these colleges educate our ruling elite, which we need
Warrant 1: these colleges educate our ruling elite, which we do not need
Correct warrant: 0