Debate: Do Non-Muslims Help or Hurt Women by Wearing Hijabs?
Some will wear a headscarf in solidarity with Muslim women. Others say that only perpetuates the sexist dogma of conservative clerics.

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: A hijab should not be treated as a fashion statement.
Warrant 0: making a fashion statement helps
Warrant 1: making a fashion statement hurts
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: Hijabs are a disrespectful thing for women.
Warrant 0: more people wearing them would not lessen the disrespect
Warrant 1: more people wearing them would lessen the disrespect
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: Public displays of religion make others uncomfortable.
Warrant 0: people should be uncomfortable
Warrant 1: people should not be uncomfortable
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: Hijabs are a sexist garment and should not be used as a symbol for anything.
Warrant 0: the best way to defeat sexism is to remove it
Warrant 1: the best way to defeat sexism is to embrace it
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: This control of women is horrendous.
Warrant 0: wearing a hijab offers a form of exclusion among women
Warrant 1: wearing a hijab offers a form of solidarity among women
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: Public displays of religion make others uncomfortable.
Warrant 0: we all deserve to be uncomfortable in a truly free society
Warrant 1: we all deserve to be comfortable in a truly free society
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: It fills me with regret that Muslim men are continuing to use hijabs to subjugate women as they have for hundreds of years.
Warrant 0: it is cool to wear these as long as I can take them off when I want
Warrant 1: it isn't cool to wear these
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: It is also degrading to males.
Warrant 0: it doesn't  even the playing field especially if there's degradation involved
Warrant 1: it evens the playing field even if there's degradation involved
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Non-Muslims hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: Hijabs are a sexist garment and should not be used as a symbol for anything.
Warrant 0: wearing them perpetuates a sexist practice
Warrant 1: wearing them more would make them seem less sexist
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Non-Muslims do not hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: A hijab should not be treated as a fashion statement.
Warrant 0: making a fashion statement helps
Warrant 1: making a fashion statement hurts
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Non-Muslims do not hurt women by wearing hijabs
Reason: Hijabs are a disrespectful thing for women.
Warrant 0: more people wearing them would not lessen the disrespect
Warrant 1: more people wearing them would lessen the disrespect
Correct warrant: 1