Debate: Are Public Universities Neglecting In-State Students?
State schools are accepting more and more nonresidents to bridge budget gaps.

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: They want to take advantage of higher tuitions paid by foreign and out of state students.
Warrant 0: it's unethical to boost funds through outside sources
Warrant 1: it's perfectly valid to boost funds through outside sources
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: Public University accept out of state students so they can get more money.
Warrant 0: out of state students' money help in-state students
Warrant 1: out of state students outnumber in-state students
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: Public University accept out of state students so they can get more money.
Warrant 0: the extra money is spent on all students
Warrant 1: the extra money isn't spent on all students
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: There are a lot of Chinese students in US universities.
Warrant 0: the presence of Chinese students means other students aren't being educated
Warrant 1: the presence of Chinese students doesn't mean other students are being mis-treated
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: Public University accept out of state students so they can get more money.
Warrant 0: more money means a better education for everyone
Warrant 1: more money does not mean a better education for everyone
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: They want to take advantage of higher tuitions paid by foreign and out of state students.
Warrant 0: tuition from out of state students can raise the rate of in-state students
Warrant 1: tuition from out of state students can lower the rate of in-state students
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: The UC system admits far fewer CA high school students than it was designed to.
Warrant 0: the statistics does not prove neglecting
Warrant 1: the statistics proves neglecting
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are neglecting in-state students
Reason: They want to take advantage of higher tuitions paid by foreign and out of state students.
Warrant 0: universities gain additional funds they can use to enrich the experience on in-state students
Warrant 1: universities gain additional funds to make more profit
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are not neglecting in-state students
Reason: They want to take advantage of higher tuitions paid by foreign and out of state students.
Warrant 0: it's unethical to boost funds through outside sources
Warrant 1: it's perfectly valid to boost funds through outside sources
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Public universities are not neglecting in-state students
Reason: Public University accept out of state students so they can get more money.
Warrant 0: out of state students' money help in-state students
Warrant 1: out of state students outnumber in-state students
Correct warrant: 0