Debate: Bring Back Cubicles?
Should the open office layout be reconsidered?

Claim: Open office layout should be reconsidered
Reason: Open offices can be distracting.
Warrant 0: as working adults employees may not be able to ignore distractions
Warrant 1: as working adults employees should be able to ignore distractions
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Open office layout should be reconsidered
Reason: Open offices can be distracting.
Warrant 0: distractions can break up a mundane day
Warrant 1: distractions can't really break up a mundane day
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Open office layout should be reconsidered
Reason: Social needs at work can be satisfied by a cafeteria or lounge.
Warrant 0: people are happier in cubes until then
Warrant 1: people are happier in cubicles until then
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Open office layout should not be reconsidered
Reason: Open offices can be distracting.
Warrant 0: as working adults employees may not be able to ignore distractions
Warrant 1: as working adults employees should be able to ignore distractions
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Open office layout should not be reconsidered
Reason: Open offices can be distracting.
Warrant 0: distractions can break up a mundane day
Warrant 1: distractions can't really break up a mundane day
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Open office layout should not be reconsidered
Reason: Social needs at work can be satisfied by a cafeteria or lounge.
Warrant 0: people are happier in cubes until then
Warrant 1: people are happier in cubicles until then
Correct warrant: 0