Debate: Should Happy Hour Be Banned?
Some states ban happy hour deals for promoting excessive drinking and drunken driving. Should more do so?

Claim: Happy hour should not be banned
Reason: People can use public transit systems during happy hour.
Warrant 0: drunkards using the bus aren't a danger to anyone
Warrant 1: drunkards using the bus always harass people
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Happy hour should not be banned
Reason: We have already seen that historically, prohibition does not end well.
Warrant 0: ending happy hour is basically the same thing as a ban on all liquor
Warrant 1: ending happy hour is not the same thing as a ban on all liquor
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Happy hour should not be banned
Reason: Most people are not irresponsible.
Warrant 0: only a few irresponsible people can effect the whole community
Warrant 1: only a few irresponsible people will not effect the whole community
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Happy hour should not be banned
Reason: We have already seen that historically, prohibition does not end well.
Warrant 0: ending happy hour is far from prohibition
Warrant 1: ending happy hour is just like prohibition
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Happy hour should not be banned
Reason: The number of beverages per person should be restricted instead.
Warrant 0: that cannot be a reliable way to do things
Warrant 1: that can be a reliable way to do things
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Happy hour should not be banned
Reason: Most people are not irresponsible.
Warrant 0: the small group of people who usually attend happy hour are very responsible
Warrant 1: the small group of people who usually attend happy hour are disproportionately irresponsible
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Happy hour should be banned
Reason: People can use public transit systems during happy hour.
Warrant 0: drunkards using the bus aren't a danger to anyone
Warrant 1: drunkards using the bus always harass people
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Happy hour should be banned
Reason: We have already seen that historically, prohibition does not end well.
Warrant 0: ending happy hour is basically the same thing as a ban on all liquor
Warrant 1: ending happy hour is not the same thing as a ban on all liquor
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Happy hour should be banned
Reason: Most people are not irresponsible.
Warrant 0: only a few irresponsible people can effect the whole community
Warrant 1: only a few irresponsible people will not effect the whole community
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Happy hour should be banned
Reason: We have already seen that historically, prohibition does not end well.
Warrant 0: ending happy hour is far from prohibition
Warrant 1: ending happy hour is just like prohibition
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Happy hour should be banned
Reason: The number of beverages per person should be restricted instead.
Warrant 0: that cannot be a reliable way to do things
Warrant 1: that can be a reliable way to do things
Correct warrant: 0