Debate: Is Immigration Really a Problem?
Is unauthorized immigration as much of a problem for the U.S. as some claim?

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Illegal immigrants have overrun large portions of California.
Warrant 0: these portions of California are doing far worse than anywhere else in the state
Warrant 1: these portions of California are doing better than anywhere else in the state
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Illegal immigrants take advantage of the freebies America has to offer without paying into the system.
Warrant 0: America can handle the leeching without much concern
Warrant 1: America cannot handle the leeching without  concern
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Immigrants are poorly educated, low earning, and entitled.
Warrant 0: many americans are educated and rich
Warrant 1: many americans are also very uneducated and have no money
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Illegal immigrants take advantage of the freebies America has to offer without paying into the system.
Warrant 0: immigrants don't pay into the system
Warrant 1: Americans don't want immigrants to pay into the system
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Immigrants are poorly educated, low earning, and entitled.
Warrant 0: immigrants will never have our status
Warrant 1: immigrants will begin to have our status
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Immigrants are poorly educated, low earning, and entitled.
Warrant 0: that is a narrow view by ignorance
Warrant 1: that is not a narrow view by ignorance
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Undocumented workers burden society.
Warrant 0: undocumented workers also perform many jobs others won't do
Warrant 1: undocumented workers do not perform many jobs others won't do
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Immigration is not really a problem
Reason: Citizens are unwilling to do the work of immigrants.
Warrant 0: immigrants have made citizens lazy
Warrant 1: immigrants haven't made citizens lazy
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Illegal immigrants have overrun large portions of California.
Warrant 0: the immigrants are only a problem in California
Warrant 1: the immigrants are not only a problem in California, but everywhere
Correct warrant: 1

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Undocumented workers burden society.
Warrant 0: many workers are undocumented
Warrant 1: not all workers are undocumented
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Illegal immigrants crowd the schools which in turn causes higher property taxes.
Warrant 0: the middle class is not doing well with higher taxes
Warrant 1: the middle class is doing ok even with higher taxes
Correct warrant: 0

Claim: Immigration is really a problem
Reason: Deportation should be used to solve the problem.
Warrant 0: the country can only deport a certain number of immigrants
Warrant 1: the country can deport immigrants
Correct warrant: 0