The show , Peter and the Starcatcher , received positive reviews .
Playbill.com , May 1 , 2012 It won five. Although the show garnered positive-to-mixed reviews by most critics , it received a rave review from The New York Times , with Ben Brantley writing : `` When the H.M.S . Neverland goes down in `` Peter and the Starcatcher , '' it ’ s the most enthralling shipwreck since James Cameron sent the Titanic to her watery grave in the late 1990s . . .
Peter and the Starcatcher