The New Guy scored under 10 % , defined by over 95 reviews , and is regarded , according to Rotten Tomatoes , as incoherent , silly , and unoriginal , it shows the same old teen gross-out comedy cliches .
`` Flixster On Metacritic , the film has a 24 % rating , indicating `` '' generally unfavorable reviews '' '' based on reviews from 23 critics . ''
The New Guy