From: NeurIPS.cc/2019/Workshop/Neuro_AI/Program_Chairs
title: Paper Decision
decision: Accept (Poster)

From: NeurIPS.cc/2019/Workshop/Neuro_AI/Paper2/AnonReviewer1
title: Lack of details and proper motivation renders MothNet useless
importance: 1: Irrelevant
importance_comment: The relevance of this work was not at all clear. 
rigor_comment: Not clear why they did what they did. 
clarity_comment: The manuscript is readable but the logic is very unclear. 
clarity: 3: Average readability
evaluation: 1: Very poor
intersection_comment: Not clear at all what is BNN or how it is relevant. Some claim about faster learning is mentioned. Not sure why. 
intersection: 1: Very low
technical_rigor: 2: Marginally convincing
category: Not applicable

From: NeurIPS.cc/2019/Workshop/Neuro_AI/Paper2/AnonReviewer2
title: An interesting attempt to use neuroscience to inspire AI
importance: 3: Important
importance_comment: The paper presents a biologically-insured model for classification, i.e., Cyborg. 
The idea of using computational principles in neuroscience to inspire machine learning/AI is an important research direction. I think this paper represents an interesting attempt along this direction. It could help inspiring future endeavors on this topic.
rigor_comment: The proposed method attach a previously proposed model MothNet, which is inspired based on the physiology of insect olfaction system to a ML classifier. The MothNet acts as a front-end feature generator. 

The authors compare their method to several baseline methods. They also tried other feature generators rather than MothNet.  Overall, the authors found that Cyborg can achieve better performance on down-sampled, vectorized MNIST, Omnigplot.

The techniques used are solid in general.
clarity_comment: I found the paper is well-written and relatively easy to follow., although the paper would improve if the motivations could be better articulated. 
clarity: 3: Average readability
evaluation: 4: Very good
intersection_comment: Although the work heavily relies on MothNet, which has been proposed previously. However, the authors' serious effort to combine the ingredients from neuroscience and AI to come out with better method should be applauded. 
intersection: 3: Medium
comment: Overall,  I think this is a quite interesting contribution showing some promise of integrating computational principles learned from neuroscience to ML.  
A few comments/suggestions.
First, it would be great to see the method tested in more challenging datasets to see if the results generalized. 
Second, it would be helpful to gain some insights about why the performance improves. One possible idea-  because there are several ingredients in the MothNet, one could keep a subset of these and see how that change the performance.

technical_rigor: 4: Very convincing
category: Neuro->AI

From: NeurIPS.cc/2019/Workshop/Neuro_AI/Paper2/AnonReviewer3
title: feature extraction method based on neural network simulated from olfactory structure
importance: 3: Important
importance_comment: This paper build a biologically inspired neural network from the moth olfactory system and used that as a feature extraction network to preprocess images before using other machine learning algorithms. This is an interesting idea.
rigor_comment: The authors identified key component for computation from the moth olfactory system. They showed using this network to preprocess image pixel data and generate features as input for other machine learning algorithm can increase performance.  However, the preprocessing step is like adding more layers to a CNN (more parameters) and this comparison is not convincing enough to show the importance of the biologically inspired network.
clarity_comment: The paper is clearly written, but missing some critical control to show the advantage of this feature extraction network.
clarity: 3: Average readability
evaluation: 3: Good
intersection_comment: Nevertheless, the biologically inspired network is a neat idea and has great potential. 
intersection: 3: Medium
comment: Good as preliminary, but need significant improvement.
technical_rigor: 2: Marginally convincing
category: Neuro->AI