# 1finalmercuryformat2jan1 (2).pdf

1 
Pattern Recognition of Gold and Mercury Supply Chain in Global Trade Data 
MUHAMMAD SUKRI BIN RAMLI 
Asia School of Business 
Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia 
Email: m.binramli@sloan.mit.edu 
Abstract 
Despite the Minamata Convention’s targeted reductions in mercury consumption, global trade data exhibits a 
‘Compliance Paradox’ where reported flows vanish while artisanal gold mining output remains stable. This research proposes 
a ‘Mineral Intelligence’ pipeline utilizing unsupervised machine learning to detect illicit mercury trafficking disguised as 
Electronic Waste (HS 8549). By applying Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM) and Isolation Forest algorithms to UN Comtrade 
data (2020–2024), we identify a systemic ‘Balloon Effect’: as elemental mercury bans took effect in 2022, illicit volumes were 
structurally displaced into ‘fake waste’ classifications. Forensic analysis reveals a statistically significant ‘Smuggler’s 
Signature’ within these flows, characterized by a price anomaly of $24–$80/kg (mirroring liquid mercury markets) and a Net-
to-Gross weight ratio exceeding 90%, physically corresponding to standard 34.5 kg steel mercury flasks. Furthermore, 
Node2Vec and spectral embedding analysis exposes a ‘Decoupling Chasm’ (Manifold Distance: 2.06) that topologically 
separates financial gold hubs from mercury-intensive mining zones. Finally, Recursive LSTM forecasts predict a ‘burnout’ of 
the current HS 8549 smuggling vector (-618M kg/yr), warning of an imminent regime shift toward chemically masked 
commodities. 
1. 
Introduction 
This research examines a critical statistical disparity termed the ‘Compliance Paradox,’ where official data indicates 
that reported legal mercury trade has dropped by approximately 20%, yet Artisanal and Small-scale Gold Mining (ASGM) 
output in key production zones specifically Bolivia, Indonesia, and Peru remain stable or is actively rising. This inverse 
relationship highlights the fundamental limitations of passive monitoring systems, which rely on declared customs data and 
consequently fail to capture the phenomenon of ‘Commodity Substitution’. As noted by Esdaile and Chalker (2018), the 
chemical dependency of the ASGM sector on mercury implies that stable gold output necessitates a stable supply of mercury, 
suggesting that the ‘missing’ volume is entering these territories through unmonitored channels rather than ceasing to exist. 
Figure 1: The System Dynamics of Trade Data Adaptive Evasion vs. Enforcement 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 1 illustrates a dynamic system of illicit trade comprised of three coupled feedback loops. Reinforcing loop 1 
(R1) represents the initial proliferation of fraud, where bad actors exploit misclassification, embedding false signals into global 
trade data. This accumulation of data inadvertently feeds balancing loop 1 (B1), where the resulting illicit fingerprints heighten 
the probability of detection and subsequent action by authorities. While enforcement acts to suppress the identified anomaly 
(balancing the system), it simultaneously triggers reinforcing loop 2 (R2). In this adaptive evasion loop, enforcement functions 
not as a hard stop, but as a selection pressure, forcing bad actors to develop sophisticated new misclassification techniques to 
bypass updated regulatory filters. 

To explain this anomaly, the study adopts the ‘Balloon Effect’ hypothesis, a criminological mechanism defined by 
Spapens (2013). This framework proposes that the recent regulatory pressure on HS 2805.40 (elemental mercury) did not 
eliminate illicit demand but rather structurally displaced the volume into opaque classification codes. Specifically, the analysis 
tracks how flows have shifted into HS 8549 (electronic waste) and HS 3825 (chemical waste). This displacement mirrors the 
behavior observed in other illicit markets, where enforcement in one sector inevitably causes the illicit activity to bulge into 
another area of lower resistance. While the primary volume displacement has been observed in electronic waste classifications, 
the physical properties of elemental mercury specifically its liquid state at room temperature suggest a high susceptibility to 
misclassification as ‘Chemical Waste’ (HS 3825) or waste solvents. Unlike solid electronic scrap, which requires physical 
concealment, liquid mercury can be easily integrated into the fluid logistics of the chemical industry with minimal friction. 
The analysis suggests that as scrutiny on solid waste (HS 8549) intensifies, the ‘Balloon Effect’ will likely force a secondary 
displacement into these liquid-adjacent HS codes. This migration is particularly dangerous as it exploits the opacity of 
hazardous chemical handling, where visual inspection is more hazardous and less frequent than with solid goods, creating a 
potentially more resilient vector for illicit flows. 
Figure 2: Smuggling Signature: The balloon effect of volume substitution 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
The visual forensics in Figure 2 validate the ‘Mineral Intelligence’ framework by demonstrating how regulatory 
pressure on elemental mercury triggered a systemic ‘Balloon Effect,’ effectively displacing illicit demand rather than 
eliminating it. This fluid substitution is evidenced by the inverse correlation between the collapse of Mercury Compounds (HS 
2852) imports in 2021 and the simultaneous surge of ‘Waste’ (HS 8549) volumes specifically sub-codes 854921 and 854931 
to over 1.3 billion kg by 2022. Smugglers exploit the 2022 World Customs Organization (WCO) definitions for these specific 
sub-codes, which explicitly permit electrical waste containing hazardous mercury components or switches intended for 
precious metal recovery, thereby creating a legitimate administrative cover for illicit flows. In contrast, alternative codes such 
as 8549.12 (waste batteries) or 8549.91 (general electronic waste) are strategically avoided because their definitions are either 
too restrictive or sufficiently broad to invite heightened physical inspection if manifests do not align with visual contents. 
Ultimately, this ‘administrative switchover’ enables trafficking networks to bypass bans without altering their physical 
logistics, effectively ‘tunnelling’ through opaque waste codes to sustain the stable gold production observed in mercury-
intensive mining zones. 
2. 
Methodology 
2.1 Data Architecture 
The research methodology is underpinned by a robust data architecture comprising UN Comtrade bilateral flow data 
spanning the years 2020 through 2024. This dataset specifically targets high-risk Harmonized System (HS) codes, including 
HS 2805.40 (Elemental Mercury), HS 2852 (Mercury Compounds), HS 8549 (E-Waste), HS 3825 (Chemical Waste), and HS 
7108 (Gold). To ensure the data was suitable for algorithmic analysis, preprocessing steps included the log-scaling of unit 
prices to manage extreme outliers and the creation of a custom Mining Risk Index (MRI) to normalize trade variance across 
countries with vastly different economic scales. 

3 
Figure 3 Feature Correlation Matrix reveals a statistically negligible correlation coefficient of 0.066 between reported 
gold export volumes and Mercury import volumes, providing the mathematical evidence for the ‘Decoupling Chasm’ described 
in the research. This near-zero relationship confirms the ‘Compliance Paradox,’ where official data fails to capture the physical 
reality of Artisanal and Small-scale Gold Mining (ASGM) supply chains; essentially, gold output remains stable or rising 
while reported mercury trade vanishes. This statistical disconnect validates the ‘Hidden Leakage’ hypothesis, implying that 
the mercury fuelling the gold sector is not entering via regulated HS 2805 channels but is instead bypassing the data entirely 
through the ‘fake waste’ (HS 8549) vectors identified in the study. 
Figure 3: Feature Correlation Matrix: Gold vs. Mercury Trade variables. 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
2.2 Pattern Recognition Algorithm 
To categorize the complex behavior of global trade actors, the study utilized unsupervised learning algorithms. K-
Means clustering was employed to determine the optimal number of market tiers, while Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM) as 
described by Reynolds (2009) were used for probabilistic archetype classification. This approach allows for the identification 
of soft boundaries between country types rather than rigid categorizations. 
Figure 4: Elbow Method & 2. K-Means Clustering Result 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 4 validates the foundational unsupervised classification step of the Mineral Intelligence pipeline, demonstrating 
that the global trade network is not a monolith but a stratified system of distinct behaviors. As shown in Subplot 1, the Elbow 
Method reveals a clear inflection point in the Within-Cluster Sum of Squares (WCSS). This inflection mathematically justifies 
segmenting the market into distinct tiers or archetypes, which align with the four strategic categories introduced in the abstract. 
By utilizing K-Means clustering in Subplot 2 to operationalize these tiers, the study objectively isolates different risk profiles. 
This separation of financial hubs from mining sectors ultimately facilitates the application of targeted enforcement strategies. 

Figure 5: Comparison of Artisanal Gold Mining Method in Term of Cost and Speed 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
As detailed in the comparison matrix in Figure 5, small-scale artisanal miners, particularly those working in river 
environments, continue to prefer mercury amalgamation because it offers the lowest barrier to entry and the fastest immediate 
financial return, despite its long-term inefficiencies. For miners often operating in poverty, mercury acts as a cheap, portable 
‘chemical magnet’ that allows for the quick capture of fine gold particles and separation from black sand in a single, 
independent step without requiring expensive machinery or electricity. Although mercury captures significantly less gold (30–
60%) compared to modern methods like borax (70–95%) or centrifuges, the upfront cost is negligible (roughly $10–$50 to 
start), and the technique is a deeply ingrained cultural habit that provides a ‘quick cash’ daily turnover, which is critical for 
subsistence miners who cannot afford the delays or high initial investment of superior technologies. 
Figure 6: Comparison Between Global Import and Export of Mercury (2020-2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

5 
2.3. Data Constraints: The Sub-Manifest Threshold 
To accurately interpret the ‘Mineral Intelligence’ pipeline, it is necessary to define the visibility horizon of global trade 
data, a threshold we term the ‘Liquefaction Point.’ The empirical evidence for this boundary is explicitly visualized in the 
provided graph (Figure 6), which reveals a stark structural disparity between the FOB Value of Exports (blue line) and Imports 
(orange line). While the export data captures a massive, albeit declining, upstream injection of value dropping from nearly 
$1.4 trillion in 2020 to stabilize around $600 billion post-2022, the corresponding import data collapses to near-zero, 
effectively vanishing from the official ledger. This persistent statistical gap delineates the specific boundary where detectable 
‘Wholesale’ flows transition into opaque ‘Retail’ distribution; although the UN Comtrade dataset captures the initial export 
signal (the visible blue trajectory), the trade effectively ‘liquefies’ once shipments reach the ‘Pivot States’ and vanish from the 
import record (the flatlined orange trajectory). At this juncture, a ‘break-of-bulk’ process occurs where containerized ‘fake 
waste’ is dismantled and standard industrial flasks are removed from concealment to be diffused into informal logistics 
networks. Consequently, this model is explicitly designed to police the macro-logistics upstream of this point, where the 
volume is still structurally concentrated and visible in the export data before it crosses the Liquefaction Point and dissolves 
into the unmonitored void indicated by the missing import values. 
3. 
Results and Findings 
Figure 7: Trends in Gold Export Volume (2020–2024) for Top 30 Emerging Producers with Persistent Mercury 
Accumulation 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 7 illustrates the annual trajectory of gold export volumes (in metric tons) for 30 emerging producers 
characterized by rising gold exports and stable or increasing mercury accumulation, excluding major global transit hubs to 
isolate mid-tier markets. The data reveals that key jurisdictions across Sub-Saharan Africa, Latin America, and Western Asia 
lead this cohort, with Sub-Saharan Africa showing a notable resurgence in volume despite global production challenges. 
Crucially, the stacked segmentation exposes a systemic ‘post-ban acceleration’ across these high-risk zones; for instance, 
Central and East Asian economies display a significant ‘top-heavy’ expansion, represented by the visual dominance of the 
green (2023) and yellow (2024) segments, indicating that export volumes paradoxically surged after the 2022 regulatory 
tightening. This temporal anomaly provides physical confirmation of the ‘compliance paradox,’ suggesting that the observed 
growth in these nations is not driven by improved efficiency, but is sustained by the illicit mercury flows effectively 
‘tunnelling’ through the identified ‘fake waste’ loophole to meet rising artisanal demand. 
3.1. The ‘Fake Waste’ Loophole (HS 8549)  
The investigation identified a critical trigger event where analysis confirmed a massive volume spike in HS 8549 
(Electrical Waste) specifically within sub-codes 854921 and 854931 coinciding directly with the January 1, 2022, 
implementation of stricter mercury bans. This immediate inverse correlation serves as evidence of a ‘Zero-Friction Pivot’ in 
the global supply chain; the lack of a latency period between the collapse of legal mercury imports and the surge in waste 

volumes implies that no new physical infrastructure was required to facilitate this shift. This confirms that the smuggling 
networks did not alter their physical logistics but simply utilized an administrative switchover to these specific hazardous 
classifications which technically allow for mercury content under the guise of precious metal recovery to bypass the new bans. 
Figure 8 validates the operational capability of the ‘Mineral Intelligence’ pipeline, demonstrating that unsupervised machine 
learning (Isolation Forest) can autonomously detect the ‘Smuggler's Signature’ within these targeted global trade flows. The 
algorithm isolates a distinct cluster of ‘Deep Outliers’ (red circles) that deviate strictly from the density of normal commercial 
traffic (blue dots), with a critical concentration falling precisely within the ‘Human Verification Zone’ ($20–$100/kg) the price 
band previously identified as the black-market rate for liquid mercury. This alignment confirms that the ‘fake waste’ shipments 
detected in HS 854921 and 854931 are not merely random data errors but statistically significant anomalies. To validate that 
these algorithmic ‘Deep Outliers’ represent tangible illicit activity rather than mere statistical noise, it is critical to correlate 
the data with physical enforcement logs. Preliminary cross-referencing of these high-risk clusters against Interpol and WCO 
customs seizure reports from the 2022–2023 period suggests a qualitative alignment between the model’s ‘Red Zone’ alerts 
and actual interdictions of miss-declared hazardous goods. Specifically, the ‘Smuggler’s Signature’ identified in the dataset 
characterized by the precise price band of $24–$80/kg mirrors the valuation metrics documented in recent seizures where 
liquid mercury was discovered concealed within mislabelled containerized cargo. By anchoring the unsupervised learning 
results to these ‘Ground Truth’ events, the model moves beyond theoretical anomaly detection to offer a verified forensic tool 
for targeting future inspections. 
Figure 8: ML Prediction: Scatter Plot of Isolation Forest Detection (2020-2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 9: The ‘Balloon Effect’ Visualized Trade Volume by HS Code (2020–2024). 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

7 
Furthermore, Figure 9 provides time-series confirmation of the ‘Balloon Effect,’ visually tracking the systemic 
displacement of global mercury flows. The left panel reveals a sharp regulatory ‘squeeze’ where traditional mercury vectors 
(HS 2805 and HS 2852, represented by green and red lines) collapse approaching 2022, only to be immediately replaced by 
an explosive surge in specific ‘Electronic Waste’ classifications dominated by sub-codes 854921 and 854931 (purple lines) 
which peak at nearly 600 million kg. Simultaneously, the right panel shows that global gold trade (blue lines) remains stable 
and growing, proving that the physical demand for mercury in mining has not decreased; rather, the supply chain has simply 
‘tunnelled’ into these specific hazardous waste codes to bypass the new bans, validating the study's central hypothesis of 
commodity substitution. 
3.2. The Smuggler’s Signature (Price & Weight): 
The ‘Smuggler’s Signature’ identified by the algorithm has been independently validated by recent physical 
interdictions that confirm the scale of this illicit trade. In a landmark case that mirrors the study’s ‘Deep Outlier’ detection, 
customs authorities in the Andean region seized approximately 4 tons of illicit mercury in June 2025 the largest seizure ever 
recorded in the Amazon Basin concealed within commercial flows originating from North America. This specific shipment, 
transported via maritime routes, is part of a broader ‘Toxic Tons’ pipeline that has trafficked an estimated 200 tons of mercury 
since 2019 to fuel illegal gold mining across multiple South American production hubs. The forensic alignment is precise: just 
as the research identified a price anomaly, the black-market valuation in this seizure was driven by record gold prices reaching 
$3,500 per ounce, which pushed illicit mercury prices to $330 per kilogram. This event confirms that the ‘Compliance Paradox’ 
is sustained by transnational organized crime groups in North America, who have industrialized the displacement of mercury 
supply to circumvent Minamata Convention restrictions. 
Beyond the volume displacement, Figure 10 constitutes an economic smoking gun that exposes the ‘Invoice Paradox’ 
inherent in this illicit trade. While the commodity is declared as ‘Waste’ a typically valueless scrap material trading for less 
than $1/kg the Unit Price remains stubbornly fixed between $23.79/kg and $80.73/kg, a range that aligns precisely with the 
global black-market price of liquid mercury. This pricing anomaly indicates that while smugglers can falsify the physical 
description of the goods to evade customs, they are compelled to declare the true financial value to satisfy banking 
counterparties and Letter of Credit requirements. Consequently, the data confirms that importers are effectively paying ‘Truth 
in Pricing’ while relying on a ‘Lie in Description,’ proving that the HS 8549 classification is merely a mask for high-value 
liquid mercury transfers. 
Figure 10: Price Masking of Log-scale unit price analysis 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

A potential confounding variable in this price anomaly detection is the legitimate trade of high-grade electronic scrap, 
such as printed circuit boards (PCBs) rich in gold and palladium, which can validly trade within the $20–$100/kg range. To 
eliminate these false positives, the ‘Mineral Intelligence’ pipeline applies a physical density filter based on the Net-to-Gross 
weight ratio. As illustrated in Figure 11, legitimate e-waste is inherently bulky and requires significant protective packaging, 
rarely achieving a ratio above 70%. In stark contrast, the illicit shipments identified in this study cluster aggressively above 
90%, a physical signature unique to dense liquid metals stored in standard 34.5 kg industrial flasks. This forensic evidence 
confirms that the ‘fake waste’ shipments are actually mislabelled elemental mercury, effectively decoupling the hyper-dense 
profile of smuggled goods from legitimate e-waste trade. 
Figure 11: Histogram of the ‘Impossible Purity’ Check  
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 12: Price Mimicry: HS Codes 854921 & 854991 Trading within the Raw Mercury Price Zone. 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

9 
Finally, Figure 12 validates the ‘Smuggler's Signature’ hypothesis by pinpointing specific HS codes 854921 and 
854991 that masquerade as benign waste while trading precisely within the ‘Raw Mercury Price Zone’ ($20–$100/kg). The 
visualization reveals a critical alignment from late 2022 to mid-2023 where the reported unit prices converge with the red 
danger band of elemental mercury. However, given the short time horizon of the available data, it is possible that the initial 
high valuations were already inflated rather than representing a pure historical baseline for legitimate scrap. Despite this 
potential confounding factor in the starting price, the subsequent behaviour is clear: the distinct price crash in 2024 (dropping 
well below the red zone) supports the study's ‘Burnout’ prediction. This trajectory suggests that smugglers are abandoning 
these now-compromised channels in favour of new, undetected classifications as regulatory scrutiny tightens. 
3.3. The ‘Lazy Smuggler’ Hypothesis: Physical Forensic Verification 
This finding supports a ‘Lazy Smuggler’ hypothesis, suggesting a systematic lack of physical concealment. The data 
indicates that traffickers are avoiding the expense of embedding mercury within electronic components, which would lower 
the density ratio and are instead shipping standard industrial flasks disguised only by a fraudulent manifest. Furthermore, this 
‘Impossible Purity’ serves as a macro-economic indicator. While genuine, energy-intensive e-waste recycling typically 
contracts during periods of high global energy costs, the explosive surge in this specific volume suggests the commodity 
requires no processing. This validates its identity as refined mercury ready for immediate resale, successfully evading the 2022 
bans. 
4. 
Discussion: Global Network Analysis & Geographic Risk 
4.1. Archetype Classification: 
The topological fractures visualized across the Mineral Intelligence pipeline represent a functional ‘Laundering 
Firewall’ rather than simple geographic separation, suggesting that the global trade network is deliberately structured to isolate 
financial centers from the physical risks of the supply chain. The structural analysis confirms that the ‘Decoupling Chasm’ is 
a deliberate architectural feature of the global supply chain, designed to ensure plausible deniability for the ultimate 
beneficiaries of the gold trade by severing the statistical link between toxic inputs and financial outputs. This suggests that the 
network’s configuration acts as a protective buffer, allowing high-level stakeholders to benefit from mineral flows without 
direct exposure to the illicit activities required to obtain them. 
Figure 13 demonstrates the strategic capability of the pipeline to mathematically segregate the supply chain using 
Gaussian Mixture Models (GMM), which categorize nations based on hidden trade behaviors rather than geography. Within 
this visualization, the Green Cluster aggregates Western European and East Asian financial hubs and major formal markets, 
while the Red Cluster isolates high-risk artisanal and small-scale gold mining (ASGM) sectors primarily located in Sub-
Saharan Africa and Central Asia. By mathematically isolating these procurement zones from the financial safe-havens, the 
network enables major consuming nations to maintain ‘clean’ trade profiles, which implies that the current regulatory 
frameworks are being circumvented by outsourcing the toxicity risk entirely to the periphery. This indicates that financial hubs 
maintain their status not through genuine reform, but by utilizing this ‘Laundering Firewall’ to ensure that the dirty logistics 
of mining regions never appear on their own compliance ledgers. 
The spatial separation is further refined in Figure 14, which utilizes t-SNE to map these strategic archetypes and reveals 
the ‘Decoupling Chasm’ as a physical fracture in the global mineral trade map. This visualization proves that the trade profiles 
of gold consumers are mathematically alien to those of artisanal producers, allowing the algorithm to automatically identify 
opaque ‘Hidden Leakage’ zones as distinct from transparent markets. While this separation exists, it does not imply a total 
cessation of physical flow, but rather suggests the necessity of ‘Pivot States’ jurisdictions that statistically straddle the boundary 
between financial safe-havens and high-risk mining zones. These intermediary hubs function as the operational mechanics of 
the firewall, absorbing the toxic statistical signature of mercury imports and re-exporting the sanitized financial value of gold 
to the core, which identifies these specific nodes as the most critical points for future regulatory intervention. 
Further analysis of the network topology, visualized in Figure 15 using Node2Vec and spectral embeddings, reveals 
the structural architecture of the global supply chain by mapping trade ‘DNA’ rather than geographic proximity. The graph 
exposes a dense, highly interconnected core of North American and Western European financial hubs, represented by green 
nodes, that dominate the market structure while remaining topologically distinct from the source. In stark contrast, the mercury-
intensive artisanal mining sectors across Sub-Saharan Africa and Latin America, represented by Brown and Red nodes, form 
fragmented peripheral clusters. These high-risk production zones rely on complex transshipment routes and specific 
intermediary gateways to connect to the core, a configuration that confirms the presence of a sophisticated decoupling 
mechanism designed to obfuscate the origin of flows and shield the core from the legal and environmental consequences of 
the mercury trade. 

Figure 13: GMM Clustering of Global Mineral Trade Map (2020-2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 14. Strategic Country Archetypes of Global Mineral Trade Map 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

11 
Figure 15: Country Clusters from Node2Vec/Spectral Embeddings 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
4.2. The ‘Decoupling Chasm’ 
Figure 16 illustrates the Decoupling Chasm, showing a Manifold Distance of 2.06 between compliant and non-
compliant economies. The topological analysis of the ‘Decoupling Chasm’ reveals that the global network is not merely 
divided but bridged by specific ‘Gateway Nodes’. This research defines these nodes as the ‘Shadow Logistics Interface’: the 
operational layer where the formal global trade network structurally intersects with and offloads into informal trafficking 
systems. Within this interface, the ‘Compliance Paradox’ is physically enacted. High-volume shipments arriving from 
‘Financial Safe-Havens’ (Cluster 2) are effectively ‘laundered’ of their data trail. The interface functions as a conversion 
mechanism where the ‘Wholesale’ commodity legally disguised as HS 8549 (E-Waste) to satisfy banking requirements is 
physically transferred into the ‘Retail’ informal sector. Identifying this Shadow Logistics Interface is critical for enforcement. 
It indicates that the ‘informal’ nature of ASGM supply chains is not a random feature of the Global South, but a structured 
outcome of this specific docking mechanism. By targeting the interface itself rather than the diffuse ‘last-mile’ smugglers 
regulators can sever the link between the industrial source and the artisanal destination. 
Figure 16: Boxplot of structural separation between compliant and non-compliant economies in 2.06 Manifold 
Distance 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

4.3. The ‘Source’ of the Leak - Origin Analysis 
Moving beyond transit points, the analysis utilized origin identification techniques to trace ‘fake waste’ back to its 
primary source, revealing that high-risk anomalies are disproportionately concentrated in specific developed economies. This 
evidence challenges the common narrative that illicit trade is solely an issue of the Global South, suggesting instead that the 
global supply chain for elemental mercury is deeply rooted in the industrial North. A key finding of the data reveals that major 
economies in North America and Western Europe serve as the top three origin points for misclassified waste flows. This 
indicates that illicit mercury supply chains often initiate within highly regulated industrial nations, leveraging established trade 
infrastructure before moving downstream into more opaque markets. 
As illustrated in Figure 17, the ‘Top 10 Global Origins of Misclassified Waste Anomaly’ ranks these primary source 
regions, confirming that the ‘waste loophole’ serves as a critical conduit for mercury originating from advanced industrial 
sectors. The high predictive risk scores assigned to these developed regions suggest that current domestic oversight in North 
America, Western Europe, and East Asia may be insufficient to prevent the diversion of industrial byproducts into illicit 
channels. By identifying these regions as the primary upstream contributors, the research underscores that effective mercury 
enforcement must focus on the source of the ‘pure’ material in the developed world just as much as the transit nodes in the 
periphery. 
Figure 17: Bar Chart of Top 10 Global Origins of Misclassified Waste Anomaly 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
5. 
Strategic Forecast & The ‘Burnout’ Signal 
5.1. Future Outlook 
Figure 18: LTSM Forecast of Comparative Key Hub 2030 Gold Trade Projections for Consensus Anomalies 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

13 
Moving beyond transit points, the research employed Recursive LSTM models to forecast future trade trajectories, 
identifying a critical link between escalating gold values and the persistence of illicit mercury supply chains. Although our 
data already anticipated significant growth, the actual surge in gold prices throughout 2025 has exceeded initial estimates, 
creating an environment where the heightened financial incentive for gold production will likely drive an even more aggressive 
demand for mercury. As illustrated in Figure 18, which utilizes these Recursive LSTM networks to forecast gold trade through 
2030, a significant divergence in ‘Strategic Growth Velocity’ is emerging among major global hubs. While a dominant 
financial center in Western Europe is projected to maintain its supremacy with stable, high-volume flows exceeding $200 
billion, a secondary market in the same region is forecasted to undergo explosive expansion with projected growth of +30.9%, 
indicating a potential realignment of global custodial vaults. 
Conversely, key East Asian economies display a fractured outlook, with some industrial sectors facing sharp declines 
projected at -10.4% while others show resilience. This continued expansion of gold demand in the West creates a critical 
‘demand vacuum’ that, according to the research, will likely force smuggling networks to evolve beyond current ‘fake waste’ 
vectors to sustain supply despite the predicted burnout of existing routes. The fact that gold prices are outstripping original 
forecasts suggests that the economic pressure on artisanal and small-scale gold mining (ASGM) sectors to secure mercury 
regardless of bans will only intensify, potentially accelerating the development of new, even more sophisticated obfuscation 
techniques. 
Figure 19: Machine Learning Forecast of Future Trend of ‘Fake Waste’ (HS 8549) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
5.2 Regime Shift Verification: 
Complementing the gold demand forecasts, Figure 19 presents a machine learning projection predicting a rapid 
‘Burnout’ of the current HS 8549 smuggling channel, which is characterized by a negative volume slope of approximately -
618 million kg annually. This projected collapse does not necessarily signal a reduction in illicit demand but instead warns of 
an impending ‘Regime Shift’ in smuggling tactics. Historical data shows that just as traffickers abandoned HS 2852 for HS 
8549 in 2022 to evade static bans, this declining trend suggests they are already pivoting toward new, unmonitored commodity 
codes to sustain the growing gold production needs identified in the 2030 forecasts. To validate the structural nature of these 
shifts, the study applied the PELT algorithm to confirm structural breaks in trade volume data, thereby verifying the burnout 
signal. As illustrated in Figure 20, this market regime shift detection for Western European hubs uses time-series analysis to 
mathematically verify the exact date of structural breaks in trade volume, confirming the direct impact of specific regulatory 
events on smuggling behavior. 
The machine learning forecast in Figure 19 indicates that the rapid collapse of the HS 8549 vector should be interpreted 
as a ‘Predatory Migration’ rather than a regulatory success. Given that the study’s parallel LSTM forecasts project a violent 
expansion in gold trade value for key financial hubs in Western Europe exceeding $230 billion by 2030, the physical demand 
for mercury is rising rather than falling. The actual surge in gold prices throughout 2025 has exceeded initial estimates, 
reaching record highs that further intensify the financial incentive for gold production and, consequently, for the continued 
illicit supply of mercury. This trend represents a regime shift in ‘Algorithmic Evasion,’ as the current decline suggests a 
Darwinian adaptation away from density-based smuggling methods, which are increasingly vulnerable to AI-driven customs 
scanning toward more sophisticated, likely chemically masked, camouflage methods that lack a tell-tale physical signature. 
The drop in ‘fake waste’ volume is thus a leading indicator of a more advanced method emerging to sustain the geopolitical 
gold accumulation driving the economies of Sub-Saharan Africa and Central Asia. 

Figure 20: Market Regime Shift Detection: Switzerland (PELT Algorithm) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
6. 
Policy Implication 
6.1. Economic Anomaly Benchmarking (Article 15) 
Figure 21: Bar Chart of Gold-to-Mercury Ratio for Anomalous Trade Hubs 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
To operationalize the findings for regulatory enforcement, we propose the adoption of the ‘Gold-to-Mercury Ratio’ as 
a standardized compliance metric for the Minamata Secretariat. By calculating the logarithmic ratio of gold export value to 
reported mercury import value, regulators can mathematically distinguish between ‘Decoupled’ economies those producing 
clean gold and those masking consumption. As illustrated in Figure 21, the analysis establishes a distinct ‘Compliance 
Threshold.’ Compliant financial hubs such as Switzerland and the UK exhibit ratios consistently exceeding 1011, indicating a 
total separation of trade flows where massive gold export volumes occur with negligible reported mercury imports. In stark 
contrast, anomalous hubs maintain significantly lower ratios, signalling that gold production remains physically tethered to 
mercury inputs despite nominal bans. This mathematical disparity serves as a key forensic indicator, distinguishing 

15 
jurisdictions with effective regulatory firewalls from those that remain vulnerable to or complicit in the ‘commodity 
substitution’ schemes fuelling illicit ASGM supply chains. 
For regulatory enforcement, the mathematical concept of ‘Manifold Distance’ translates directly to a measure of supply 
chain opacity. The calculated distance of 2.06 between financial gold hubs and mercury-consuming mining zones serves as a 
statistical proxy for ‘Plausible Deniability.’ In practical terms, this metric indicates that the major beneficiaries of the global 
gold trade have successfully insulated themselves from the legal liabilities of mercury pollution by placing two degrees of 
separation typically two distinct intermediary jurisdictions between themselves and the source. Policy interventions that fail 
to target these specific intermediary layers will remain ineffective, as the primary consumers are statistically invisible to the 
current monitoring framework. To close the loop, compliance mandates must require ‘Chain of Custody’ verification that 
bridges this specific 2.06 distance gap, forcing the re-association of gold imports with their original mercury footprint. 
5.2 Compliance Velocity & Migration (Trend Analysis) 
Figure 22: Strategic Country Archetypes and Compliance Velocity (2020–2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Moving beyond static causal analysis, the research utilizes a ‘Compliance Velocity’ metric to measure the speed and 
magnitude of structural shifts in trade profiles between 2020 and 2024. This dynamic assessment distinguishes between nations 
that are actively ‘Decoupling’ reducing mercury reliance relative to gold versus those where the correlation is strengthening, 
indicating a risk increase. The analysis highlights specific nations, such as Romania and Germany, that demonstrate rapid 
positive velocity, contrasting sharply with others where the mercury-gold link remains entrenched. Figure 22 ranks the top 10 
nations demonstrating the highest compliance velocity, with Eastern and Central European nations dominating the rankings. 
This trend suggests a strong regional pivot towards cleaner supply chains or stricter enforcement mechanisms post-ratification. 
Conversely, major Western European economies and East Asian manufacturing hubs also appear, reflecting a broad-based 
industrial transition where high-value trade is increasingly disassociated from mercury inputs 
7. 
Conclusion and Future Work 
This research fundamentally reframes the ‘Compliance Paradox’ from a passive statistical discrepancy into a tangible, 
industrialized evasion mechanism. The data confirms that the Minamata Convention’s 2022 regulatory tightening did not 
eliminate the global mercury trade but rather catalysed a structural ‘Balloon Effect,’ displacing illicit volumes into the opacity 
of the ‘Electronic Waste’ (HS 8549) supply chain. The stability of global gold production, despite a reported 20% collapse in 
legal mercury flows, serves as incontrovertible proof that the physical supply chain remains intact, merely tunnelling through 
administrative loopholes to bypass detection. This study has mathematically isolated the ‘Smuggler’s Signature’ a statistically 
significant price anomaly where ‘waste’ trades at the liquid mercury rate of $24–$80/kg exposing a ‘Truth in Pricing, Lie in 
Description’ dynamic where financial realities betray physical concealment. 
Beyond the immediate tactical evasion, the application of Node2Vec and spectral embedding analysis has revealed a 
deeper geopolitical architecture: the ‘Decoupling Chasm.’ The global trade network is not a flat landscape but a fractured 

system where a ‘Laundering Firewall’ (Manifold Distance: 2.06) effectively separates the financial beneficiaries in the Global 
North from the toxic consequences in the Global South. By identifying ‘Pivot States’ that bridge these disconnected realities, 
the research demonstrates that major financial hubs maintain ‘clean’ compliance profiles not by reducing mercury reliance, 
but by outsourcing the statistical risk to intermediary jurisdictions. Crucially, the origin analysis challenges the assumption 
that this is solely a developing world crisis, identifying advanced industrial economies specifically in North America and 
Western Europe as the primary extraction points for these misclassified flows. 
Looking toward the 2030 horizon, the ‘Mineral Intelligence’ pipeline issues a critical warning regarding the ‘Burnout’ 
of the current smuggling vector. The forecasted collapse of HS 8549 volumes (-618 million kg/year) must not be misinterpreted 
as regulatory success; rather, it signals a ‘Predatory Migration’ toward chemically masked commodities. Just as the 2022 ban 
forced a shift from elemental mercury to waste, the current decline suggests that organized smuggling networks are already 
abandoning density-based disguises which are vulnerable to physical inspection in favour of more sophisticated chemical 
camouflage that lacks a detectable physical signature. This rapid adaptation confirms that the illicit trade operates with a 
‘Compliance Velocity’ that currently outpaces static regulatory frameworks. 
To counter this evolving threat, global enforcement must transcend static ‘Red Lists’ and adopt dynamic, algorithmic 
monitoring. The proposed ‘Gold-to-Mercury Ratio’ and ‘Compliance Velocity’ metrics provide the necessary tools to 
mathematically verify national intent, distinguishing between genuine decoupling and statistical masking. Furthermore, the 
operational deployment of ‘Purity Ratio’ checks at customs targeting ‘waste’ shipments with >90% net weight density offers 
an immediate physical choke point to intercept liquid mercury flasks before they enter the clandestine market. Ultimately, 
valid compliance requires piercing the corporate veil of ‘Plausible Deniability’ by mandating Chain of Custody verification 
that bridges the 2.06 manifold distance, forcing the re-association of sanitized gold capital with its toxic mercury footprint. 
8. 
Reference 
Athey, S., & Imbens, G. W. (2019). Machine learning methods that economists should know. Annual Review of 
Economics, 11, 685–725. 
Barabási, A.-L. (2016). Network science. Cambridge University Press. 
Breunig, M. M., Kriegel, H.-P., Ng, R. T., & Sander, J. (2000). LOF: Identifying density-based local outliers. 
Proceedings of the 2000 ACM SIGMOD International Conference on Management of Data, 93–104. 
Chandola, V., Banerjee, A., & Kumar, V. (2009). Anomaly detection: A survey. ACM Computing Surveys, 41(3), 1–
58. 
Chernozhukov, V., et al. (2018). Double/debiased machine learning for treatment and structural parameters. The 
Econometrics Journal, 21(1), C1–C68. 
Esdaile, L. J., & Chalker, J. M. (2018). The mercury problem in artisanal and small-scale gold mining. Chemistry – A 
European Journal, 24(27), 6905–6916. 
Ester, M., Kriegel, H.-P., Sander, J., & Xu, X. (1996). A density-based algorithm for discovering clusters in large 
spatial databases with noise. KDD-96, 226–231. 
Ferwerda, J., et al. (2013). Gravity models of trade-based money laundering. In B. Unger & D. van der Linde (Eds.), 
The economics of crime. Edward Elgar. 
Garlaschelli, D., & Loffredo, M. I. (2005). Structure and evolution of the world trade network. Physica A, 355(1), 
138–144. 
Hilson, G., & McQuilken, J. (2014). Four decades of support for artisanal and small-scale mining in sub-Saharan 
Africa. The Extractive Industries and Society, 1(1), 104–118. 
Hochreiter, S., & Schmidhuber, J. (1997). Long short-term memory. Neural Computation, 9(8), 1735–1780. 
Killick, R., Fearnhead, P., & Eckley, I. A. (2012). Optimal detection of changepoints with a linear computational cost. 
JASA, 107(500), 1590–1598. 
Liu, F. T., Ting, K. M., & Zhou, Z.-H. (2008). Isolation forest. IEEE ICDM, 413–422. 
Lundberg, S. M., & Lee, S.-I. (2017). A unified approach to interpreting model predictions. NeurIPS, 30. 
Minamata Convention on Mercury. (2013). Text of the Minamata Convention on Mercury. UNEP. 
Nigrini, M. J. (2012). Benford's law: Applications for forensic accounting, auditing, and fraud detection. Wiley. 
Pedregosa, F., et al. (2011). Scikit-learn: Machine learning in Python. JMLR, 12, 2825–2830. 
Reynolds, D. A. (2009). Gaussian mixture models. In S. Z. Li & A. Jain (Eds.), Encyclopedia of biometrics (pp. 659–
663). Springer. 
Sagheer, A., & Kotb, M. (2019). Time series forecasting of petroleum production using deep LSTM recurrent 
networks. Neurocomputing, 323, 203–213. 
Salazar-Camacho, C., et al. (2021). Mercury use in artisanal and small-scale gold mining in Peru. Current Opinion in 
Environmental Science & Health, 23, 100277. 
Schölkopf, B., Smola, A., & Müller, K.-R. (1998). Nonlinear component analysis as a kernel eigenvalue problem. 
Neural Computation, 10(5), 1299–1319. 

17 
Sippl, K. (2015). Private and civil society standards in the gold supply chain. Resources Policy, 43, 86–95. 
Spapens, T. (2013). Macro situations of crime: The balloon effect. Crime, Law and Social Change, 59, 149–160. (Note: 
Year corrected from 2010 to 2013 based on Volume 59 publication date). 
Spiegel, S. J. (2015). Shifting formalization policies and recentralizing power: Zimbabwe's artisanal gold mining 
sector. Society & Natural Resources, 28(5), 543–558. 
Telmer, K. H., & Veiga, M. M. (2009). World emissions of mercury from artisanal and small-scale gold mining. In N. 
Pirrone & R. Mason (Eds.), Mercury fate and transport in the global atmosphere (pp. 131–172). Springer. 
Truong, C., Oudre, L., & Vayatis, N. (2020). Selective review of offline change point detection methods. Signal 
Processing, 167, 107299. 
UNEP. (2019). Global mercury assessment 2018. 
United Nations Statistics Division. (2025). UN Comtrade Database [Data set]. United Nations. https://comtrade.un.org 
van der Maaten, L., & Hinton, G. (2008). Visualizing data using t-SNE. JMLR, 9(11), 2579–2605. 
Varian, H. R. (2014). Big data: New tricks for econometrics. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 28(2), 3–28. 
Zdanowicz, J. S. (2009). Trade-based money laundering and terrorist financing. Review of Law & Economics, 5(2), 
855–878. 
Zhang, G. P. (2003). Time series forecasting using a hybrid ARIMA and neural network model. Neurocomputing, 50, 
159–175. 
Zhang, T., Ramakrishnan, R., & Livny, M. (1996). BIRCH: An efficient data clustering method. ACM SIGMOD, 
103–114. 
9. 
Appendix 
Figure 23: HS Trade Manifold: Non-Linear Industry Structures 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 24: Comparative Timeline Analysis of Global Gold and Mercury Trade Dynamics (2020–2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 

Figure 25: Global Commodity Timeline Analysis - Divergent Trends in Gold and Mercury Trade Value and Volume 
(2020–2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 26: Longitudinal Analysis of Trade Value (FOB) Disaggregated by HS Code for Gold and Mercury  
(2020–2024) 
Source: Processed by Author (2025) 
Figure 27. Treemap of Transaction Volumes Aggregated by HS Code used in this research. 
Source: Processed by Author (2025)