But Hatch was pretty much out of the rest of the debate, bewildered by the carnage around him and unsure how to respond to it.
Hatch was indifferent to the carnage around him.
mnli hypothesis: Hatch was indifferent to the carnage around him. premise: But Hatch was pretty much out of the rest of the debate, bewildered by the carnage around him and unsure how to respond to it.