Tobey Maguire
Giải thưởng

| Association | Year | Category | Nominated Work | Result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Black Reel Awards | 2003 | Best Film | 25th Hour | Đề cử |
| CinEuphoria Awards | 2011 | Best Actor – International Competition | Brothers | Đoạt giải |
| Empire Awards | 2005 | Best Actor | Spider-Man 2 | Đề cử |
| Golden Globe Awards | 2010 | Best Actor in a Motion Picture – Drama | Brothers | Đề cử |
| Golden Schmoes Awards | 2002 | Favorite Celebrity of the Year | — | Đề cử |
| Kid's Choice Awards | 2003 | Favorite Male Butt Kicker | Spider-Man | Đề cử |
| Kid's Choice Awards | 2005 | Favorite Movie Actor | Spider-Man 2 | Đề cử |
| MTV Movie + TV Awards | 2003 | Best Male Performance | Spider-Man | Đề cử |
| MTV Movie + TV Awards | 2003 | Best Kiss | Spider-Man | Đoạt giải |
| MTV Movie + TV Awards | 2005 | Best Hero | Spider-Man 2 | Đề cử |
| MTV Movie + TV Awards | 2008 | Best Fight | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| National Movie Awards | 2007 | Best Performance by a Male | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| Online Film & Television Association Awards | 2001 | Best Supporting Actor | Wonder Boys | Đề cử |
| People's Choice Awards | 2005 | Favorite Male Action Movie Star | Spider-Man 2 | Đề cử |
| People's Choice Awards | 2005 | Favorite On-Screen Chemistry | Spider-Man 2 | Đề cử |
| People's Choice Awards | 2008 | Favorite On-Screen Match-Up | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards | 2001 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role | Wonder Boys | Đề cử |
| Prism Awards | 2010 | Performance in a Feature Film | Brothers | Đề cử |
| Saturn Awards | 1999 | Best Younger Actor/Actress | Pleasantville | Đoạt giải |
| Saturn Awards | 2003 | Best Actor | Spider-Man | Đề cử |
| Saturn Awards | 2005 | Best Actor | Spider-Man 2 | Đoạt giải |
| Saturn Awards | 2010 | Best Actor | Brothers | Đề cử |
| Screen Actors Guild Awards | 2000 | Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture | The Cider House Rules | Đề cử |
| Screen Actors Guild Awards | 2004 | Outstanding Performance by a Cast in a Motion Picture | Seabiscuit | Đề cử |
| SFX Awards | 2003 | Best SF or Fantasy Film Actor | Spider-Man | Đề cử |
| Spike Video Game Awards | 2004 | Best Performance by a Male | Spider-Man 2 | Đề cử |
| Tallinn Black Nights Film Festival | 2019 | Best Youth Film | Get Duked! | Đoạt giải |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2000 | Choice Movie Actor | The Cider House Rules | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2000 | Choice Movie: Liar | Wonder Boys | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2002 | Choice Movie Actor: Drama/Action-Adventure | Spider-Man | Đoạt giải |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2002 | Choice Movie: Chemistry | Spider-Man | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2002 | Choice Movie: Liplock | Spider-Man | Đoạt giải |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2007 | Choice Movie Actor: Action/Adventure | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2007 | Choice Movie: Liplock | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2007 | Choice Movie: Dance | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2007 | Choice Movie: Rumble | Spider-Man 3 | Đề cử |
| Teen Choice Awards | 2010 | Choice Movie Actor: Drama | Brothers | Đề cử |
| Toronto Film Critics Association Awards | 2000 | Best Supporting Performance – Male | Wonder Boys | Đoạt giải |
| Young Artist Awards | 1993 | Best Young Actor in a New Television Series | Great Scott! | Đề cử |
1 2 3 4 5 6  Shared with Kirsten Dunst
↑  Shared with James Franco
↑  Shared with James Franco, Topher Grace & Thomas Haden Church