Bullet Club
Penghargaan yang pernah diraih

AAW Wrestling
AAW Heritage Championship (1 kali) – Ace Austin
All Elite Wrestling
Dynamite Dozen Battle Royale (2023) – Juice Robinson
Canadian Wrestling's Elite
Elite 8 (2017) – Chase Owens
Consejo Mundial de Lucha Libre
CMLL World Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) –  El Terrible
CMLL World Tag Team Championship (2 kali) – El Terrible & Tama Tonga (1), Rey Bucanero & Tama Tonga (1)
Mexican National Light Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) – Mephisto
Global Force Wrestling
GFW NEX*GEN Championship (1 kali) –  Cody
DDT Pro-Wrestling
Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship (1 kali) – Ishimori
NWA Smoky Mountain Wrestling
NWA Southeastern Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) –  Chase Owens
Family Wrestling Entertainment
FWE Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) –  AJ Styles
FWE Tag Team Championship (1 kali) – Young Bucks
Future Stars of Wrestling
FSW Mecca Grand Championship (1 kali, saat ini) – Chris Bey
FSW Tag Team Championship (1 kali, saat ini) – Ace Austin & Chris Bey
German Wrestling Federation
Light Heavyweight World Cup (2019) – El Phantasmo
Impact Wrestling/Total Nonstop Action Wrestling
Impact/TNA World Tag Team Championship (4 kali, saat ini) –  The Good Brothers (2), Ace Austin & Chris Bey (2 kali, saat ini)
Impact X Division Championship (1 kali) –  Ace Austin
Feast or Fired (2023 – Tag Team Championship contract) – Chris Bey
Impact Year End Award (1 kali)
Male Tag Team of the Year (2023) – Ace Austin and Chris Bey
National Wrestling Alliance
NWA World Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) –  Cody
New Japan Pro-Wrestling
IWGP World Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) – Jay White
IWGP Heavyweight Championship (5 kali) – AJ Styles (2), Kenny Omega (1), Jay White (1), Evil (1)
IWGP Global Heavyweight Championship (1 kali, saat ini, perdana) – David Finlay
IWGP Intercontinental Championship (4 kali) – Bad Luck Fale (1), Kenny Omega (1), Jay White (1), Evil (1)
IWGP Junior Heavyweight Championship (7 kali) – Prince Devitt (1), Kenny Omega (2), Marty Scurll (1), Taiji Ishimori (3)
IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Championship (11 kali) Young Bucks (7), El Phantasmo & Taiji Ishimori (3), Drilla Moloney & Clark Connors (1 kali)
IWGP Tag Team Championship (12 kali) – Good Brothers (3), Tanga Loa & Tama Tonga (7), Young Bucks (1), Bad Luck Fale & Chase Owens (1)
IWGP United States Championship (4 kali) – Kenny Omega (1), Cody (1), Kenta (1), Juice Robinson (1)
NEVER Openweight Championship (7 kali, saat ini) – Yujiro Takahashi (1), Kenta (1), Jay White (1), Evil (3, saat ini), Karl Anderson (1), David Finlay (1)
Strong Openweight Championship (2 kali) – Kenta (2)
Strong Openweight Tag Team Championship (1 kali) – Alex Coughlin & Gabe Kidd
NEVER Openweight 6-Man Tag Team Championship (9 kali) –Bad Luck Fale, Yujiro Takahashi & Tama Tonga (1), Kenny Omega & Young Bucks (2), Bad Luck Fale, Tama Tonga & Tanga Loa (2), Marty Scurll & Young Bucks (1), Taiji Ishimori, Tama Tonga & Tanga Loa (1), Evil, Sho & Yujiro Takahashi (2)
Best of the Super Juniors (2013) – Prince Devitt
World Tag League (2013) – Good Brothers
World Tag League (2020)  – Tanga Loa & Tama Tonga
Super J-Cup (2019, 2020) – El Phantasmo
Super Jr. Tag Tournament (2013) – Young Bucks
G1 Climax (2016) – Kenny Omega
New Japan Cup (2020) – Evil
New Japan Cup USA (2020) – Kenta
New Japan Rambo (2021) – Bad Luck Fale & Chase Owens
IWGP United States Championship Tournament (2017) – Kenny Omega
KOPW (3 kali) – Chase Owens (1), Sho (1) and Taiji Ishimori (1)
STRONG Survivor (2023) – Kenta
Pro Wrestling Guerrilla
PWG World Tag Team Championship (1 kali) – Young Bucks
Pro Wrestling Illustrated
Feud of the Year (2017) Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada
DDT Pro-Wrestling
Ironman Heavymetalweight Championship (2 kali) – Young Bucks (1), Brandi Rhodes (1)
Revolution Pro Wrestling
RPW British Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) – AJ Styles
RPW British Cruiserweight Championship (2 kali) – Prince Devitt (1), El Phantasmo (1)
Ring of Honor
ROH World Championship (3 kali) – Adam Cole (2), Cody (1)
ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Championship (3 kali, saat ini) – Adam Page & Young Bucks (1), Cody & Young Bucks (1), Jay White & The Gunns (1, saat ini)
ROH World Tag Team Championship (4 kali) – Tanga Loa & Tama Tonga (1), Young Bucks (3)
ROH World Television Championship (1 kali) – Marty Scurll
ROH Wrestler of the Year (2017) – Cody
Tag Team of the Year (2017) – Young Bucks
Best Final Battle Entrance (2017) – Marty Scurll
Breakout Star of the Year (2017) – Adam Page
Sports Illustrated
Wrestler of the Year (2017) – Kenny Omega
Tokyo Sports
Technique Award (2016) – Kenny Omega
Best Bout Award (2017) Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada pada 4 Januari
Best Bout Award (2018) Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada pada 9 Juni
World Series Wrestling
WSW World Heavyweight Championship (1 kali) – Robbie Eagles
WSW Tag Team Championship (1 kali) – Young Bucks
WrestleCircus
Big Top Tag-Team Championship (1 kali) – Tanga Loa & Tama Tonga
What Culture Pro Wrestling/Defiant Wrestling
WCPW/Defiant Championship (1 kali) – Marty Scurll
WCPW Internet Championship (1 kali) – Cody
Wrestling Observer Newsletter
Best Wrestling Maneuver (2014) Young Bucks' Meltzer Driver
Best Wrestling Maneuver (2015) AJ Styles' Styles Clash
Best Wrestling Maneuver (2016, 2017, 2018) Kenny Omega's One-Winged Angel
Feud of the Year (2017)  Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada
Most Outstanding Wrestler (2014, 2015, 2016) AJ Styles
Japan MVP (2018) – Kenny Omega
Most Improved (2018) – Adam Page
Most Outstanding Wrestler (2018) – Kenny Omega
Pro Wrestling Match of the Year (2014) AJ Styles vs. Minoru Suzuki pada 1 Agustus
Pro Wrestling Match of the Year (2017) Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okada pada 4 Januari
Pro Wrestling Match of the Year (2018) Kenny Omega vs. Kazuchika Okad] pada 9 Juni
Tag Team of the Year (2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018) Young Bucks
Worst Gimmick (2016) Bone Soldier
Most Overrated (2021) Evil
Wrestler of the Year (2015, 2016) AJ Styles
Best Booker – Gedo (2018, 2019)
Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame (Class of 2019) – Gedo