O.J.: Made in America
Penghargaan

| Penghargaan | Kategori | Penerima dan nomine | Hasil |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Academy Awards | Best Documentary Feature | O.J.: Made in America | Belum diputuskan |
| ACE Eddie Awards | Best Edited Documentary Feature | Bret Granato, Maya Mumma and Ben Sozanski | Menang |
| Alliance of Women Film Journalists Awards | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| American Film Institute Awards | AFI Special Award | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Austin Film Critics Association Awards | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| Black Reel Awards | Best Feature Documentary | Ezra Edelman | Belum diputuskan |
| Black Reel Awards | Outstanding Emerging Filmmaker | Ezra Edelman | Belum diputuskan |
| Boston Society of Film Critics | Best Documentary Film | Ezra Edelman | Menang |
| Central Ohio Film Critics Association | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Belum diputuskan |
| Chicago Film Critics Association | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Cinema Audio Society | Outstanding Achievement in Sound Mixing for a Motion Picture – Documentary | Keith Hodne and Eric Di Stefano | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Nonfiction Feature Filmmaking | Ezra Edelman | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Nonfiction Feature Filmmaking | Caroline Waterlow | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Direction | Ezra Edelman | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Editing | Bret Granato, Maya Mumma, and Ben Sozanski | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Production | Ezra Edelman | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Production | Caroline Waterlow | Belum diputuskan |
| Cinema Eye Honors Awards, US | Outstanding Achievement in Original Music Score | Gary Lionelli | Belum diputuskan |
| Critics' Choice Documentary Awards | Best Documentary (Theatrical Feature) | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Critics' Choice Documentary Awards | Best Director (Theatrical Feature) | Ezra Edelman | Menang |
| Critics' Choice Documentary Awards | Best Sports Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Critics' Choice Documentary Awards | Best Limited Documentary Series | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Critics' Choice Documentary Awards | Best Political Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| Detroit Film Critics Society | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Florida Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Runner-up |
| Gotham Independent Film Awards | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Houston Film Critics Society Awards | Best Documentary Feature | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Independent Spirit Awards | Best Documentary Feature | O.J.: Made in America | Belum diputuskan |
| Indiana Film Journalists Association, US | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| IndieWire Critics Poll | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| IndieWire Critics Poll | Best Editing | Bret Granato, Maya Mumma and Ben Sozanski | Runner-up |
| IndieWire Critics Poll | Best Film | O.J.: Made in America | 5th Place |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Ezra Edelman | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Deirdre Fenton | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Libby Geist | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Nina Krstic | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Erin Leyden | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Tamara Rosenberg | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Connor Schell | Menang |
| International Documentary Association | IDA Award for Best Feature | Caroline Waterlow | Menang |
| Kansas City Film Critics Circle | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Las Vegas Film Critics Society | Best Documentary Film | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Editing | Bret Granato, Maya Mumma, and Ben Sozanski | Menang |
| Los Angeles Film Critics Association | Best Documentary Film | Ezra Edelman | Runner-up |
| National Board of Review | Best Documentary Film | Ezra Edelman | Menang |
| National Society of Film Critics Awards | Best Non-Fiction Film | Ezra Edelman | Menang |
| Nevada Film Critics Society | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| New York Film Critics Circle | Best Documentary Film | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| New York Film Critics Online | Top Films of the Year | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Oklahoma Film Critics Circle | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Oklahoma Film Critics Circle | Best Film | O.J.: Made in America | 4th Place |
| Online Film Critics Society | Best Documentary Film | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Online Film Critics Society | Best Picture | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| Philadelphia Film Festival | Audience Award - Best Feature | Ezra Edelman | Menang |
| Phoenix Critics Circle | Best Documentary Film | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Phoenix Film Critics Society | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| Producers Guild of America Awards | Best Documentary Motion Picture | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| San Diego Film Critics Society | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| San Francisco Film Critics Circle | Best Documentary Film | Ezra Edelman | Nominasi |
| Satellite Awards | Best Documentary Film | Ezra Edelman | Nominasi |
| Seattle Film Critics | Best Documentary | Ezra Edelman | Belum diputuskan |
| Vancouver Film Critics Circle Awards | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Nominasi |
| Village Voice Film Poll | Best Documentary | O.J.: Made in America | Menang |
| Village Voice Film Poll | Best Film | O.J.: Made in America | 5th Place |
| Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association | Best Documentary | Ezra Edelman | Nominasi |