Review (5/5): Great Balm, converted me from another brand.
I was using Honest Amish but I find that the Liberty balm provides more control with FAR less greasiness even when using the absolute minimum amount of Honest Amish. And as for softness, my wife says the beard is as soft if not softer than before. The scent is masculine but dissipates very quickly. Although I liked the scent, Honest Amish was stronger and at times even started to go a little rancid if I accidentally used too much.
I have definitely converted. Liberty Beard Balm is awesome.