Review (5/5): Happy cake
I wouldn't ordinarily spend so much but I've been using the same cake liner for more than 15 years - they last forever. This is really pigmented. If you are new to cake liner you'll probably have a learning curve but personally I think it's easier than liquid or those gel pots that dry up in two weeks. I've only used a fine brush so far, we'll see how it does with my thicker angled brush.
I'm not having any issues with fallout or smudging. It does take more than one swipe to remove, and I think the container could be better. I like to put a few drops of water in the lid to dip my brush in, but this lid is flat, without a lip or edge around it, which makes it a challenge.