Review (4/5): Pretty good!
I have tried Lume before and wasn't super into the dispenser (dotted top with the cream). When a stick came out I decided to give it another whirl. I have zero irritation and it's very comfortable. I can swipe it on and dress and don't need to wait for it to dry or anything. Peony is a nice floral scent that I like.
However, there are days when it seems like this gets me through 24 hours and I smell great..and days where I reek halfway through the day. This was the same for the first time I tried Lume. I have no idea, I WFH and am not doing heavy labor. This isn't an antiperspirant so I sweat up a storm and don't reach for this on sleeveless days.
I don't know about anyone else but I swap between "irritating clog your pores but works" antiperspirants and a more "natural" deodorant to let my skin recover. This works as my "recovery" deodorant to keep my skin happy, but the variability of it's effectiveness is very strange for me. I am very glad they came out with a solid stick. I know it's not really their avenue, but gosh, if they could make an antiperspirant version we might have something close to perfect.