Review (5/5): Best shaving soap ever.  And it's made in America.  What else do you need?
This stuff is great. I've been using Ogallala's shaving soap for a couple of weeks now, and I love it. It's easy to lather, and the lather is rich, lubricates well, and smells fantastic. It lathers as well or better than Taylor of Old Bond Street's shaving creams, and I think that's saying a lot. My first shaving soap when I switched to traditional wet shaving was the Col. Conk Bay Rum, and the scent of this Ogallala is much more intense and far outlasts the former. If you like bay rum and close shaves with no razor burn, then this is the stuff for you. I will definitely be buying it again, whenever the hell it finally runs out.
Oh, and I ordered it on a Wednesday with standard get-you-a-dollar-credit-with-Prime shipping, and it was at my house Monday when I came home from work.