Review (4/5): No too bad
I was expecting a bit more for the price. For liquid eyeshadow, these are probably the best out of all the ones I have. But they are a bit streaky and require multiple passes. Depending on the passes, it can clump funny on the lid.
Some of my eyeliners don't like to give over this shadow. I don't know if it is the liners or the shadow, so that doesn't impact the review.