Review (5/5): Smells great and it works.
So I bought this back in July 2012 and I like it still so far. I don't shave very often since my beard growth isn't crazy nor is it thick like some others, so I haven't made much of a dent in one of the pucks lol
So I can't really compare it to many other soaps since I'm relatively new to wet shaving. But the scent for this is awesome out of the box! Hell, even through the box. When I received it in the mail, I could pretty much smell what it was XD But mind you, it's actually not THAT strong. When shaving, it's pretty faint so you don't really smell it. And for the lather, I'm not sure if it's my technique, brush, or the soap but it's not as easy to make a lather with it as it is with the VDH soap for example. But, I make it work anyway and I prefer this over the VDH =P So I like it and recommend it!
--UPDATE--
So I thought I might as well update this review. (12/26/13) I am still on the first puck out of the two XD It's the only shave soap I use since I haven't needed to purchase any other 'cause this has lasted me so long! I'm almost done with the first but still have about 1/4 of it left or so. My technique has gotten better as well so this lathers just fine. I don't shave as often as most people still-- once every 5-7 days-- so this has lasted me a long time. Definitely recommended!