Review (4/5): Nice eyeliner
I had never used this eyeliner before but wanted to give it a try. I'm really happy with it. It is a roll up liner with a very smooth application. It goes on a nice deep black. Add a little pressure and you can get it to look like a liquid liner or you can smudge it for a smokier effect. When you first put it on you have some time to work with it. Once it sets (maybe 10 minutes or so) it stays put really well all day long. Any unintentional smudging only happened right after applying.
In general this type of liner doesn't last as long as a pencil that you sharpen but I think the trade off is worth it when it wears so nicely and doesn't come off during the day. It's also really reasonably priced. I'll buy it again.