Review (5/5): Pretty Good Colors!
This was so fun! I love Essie but $9 or $10/bottle is always hard for me to stomach. Paying $2.50/bottle (even when I didn't know what I was getting) was a steal. Two of the colors are almost identical (the coral colored orange ones) but the rest of the colors are so different and fun that it's so insignificant. I got one glitter and one chrome. The rest are just regular polishes. I haven't tried the polishes yet, but I'll update if anything seems different with the formula.
UPDATE: I've used several colors and they definitely seem like true Essie polishes. They're probably a bit older--I can tell because the brushes are slim not wide (I believe Essie changed to the thick, wide brushes about a year ago). However, the polishes are not thick or clumpy like some nail polishes get when they age.