Review (2/5): Great brand, but a hit or miss product
I absolutely love this eyeliner and have been using it for years. It doesnt smudge, is actually water proof, and isnt too terrible to take off.
Unfortunately, during the past 8 months, every order I place through Amazon comes in dry and clumpy, giving it a shelf life of only a few days (compared to a few months). While I understand that it's not a reflection of the brand itself, it's really become a hassle.