Review (4/5): Some pretty colors...but too glittery
Let me preface this by saying that the colors are pretty and generally well pigmented (I use it with Too Faced Shadow Insurance). My issue is that many of the colors are very glittery - I like shimmery shadows, but we are talking big chunks of glitter here in several of the colors. If you're familiar with Urban Decay's "Midnight Cowgirl" shadow family you'll get the picture. Basically the entire palette is gliterry, except for two matte shades. If you get this, make sure to put a tissue under your eyes to catch the fall-out or you'll look like a disco ball. I'm talking serious fall-out here.
The colors are:
Full Moon: Glittery Champagne
Night Light: Supremely Glittery rosey pink (this one has a chalky texture, making it impossible to apply without massive fallout.)
Spotlight: Matte Beige
Nightcap: Shimmery medium tan
After Hours: Chalky glittery medium beige
Moonstone: Glittery deep tan
Cocoa Star: Matte chocolate brown
Eclipse: Glittery Chestnut brown
Night Fever: Glittery Chocolate brown
The positives: The packaging is cute, the colors are fairly pigmented, Too Faced includes looks cards so you can get ideas on looks.
The negatives: This is only a good palette if you already have a nice collection of eyeshadow and you want something to throw in your purse when you're going out of town and know you'll be partying (and you have the patience to deal with massive fallout). You can definitely make some work appropriate looks, but these are more glittery than shimmery, making it a bit juvenile. Some of the shadows are chalky too. I also have the Urban Decay Naked palette and the colors are MUCH better, as is the quality of the shadows. Personally I think Naked is also a better deal. It's $50, so $14 more, but you get more colors, the shadows are better quality (creamier and smoother), and it comes with a nice brush.
I find that I don't use this palette much. It isn't a palette that has an obvious place in my makeup collection.
Updated: I am still experimenting with this palette (I brought it in my makeup bag on vacation and left my UD Naked palette at home) and I've definitely created some nice looks that are completely appropriate for daily life. I just don't LOVE it. The problem is, I have the Urban Decay Naked palette. The colors are similar between UD Naked and TF Natural at Night (warm browns and champagnes) but the Urban Decay colors are shimmers (I love shimmers) and many of the shads in the Too Faced Naked at Night palette are glitters. That makes the TF colors much harder to work with due to fallout. Ultimately, this palette is 3.5 stars to me. It has nice colors and you can create some great looks (provided you put tissue under your eyes to catch the fallout), but the UD Naked Palette is just better in my opinion in terms of pigmentation, ease of application, and blending.