Review (5/5): Great value for the price
I bought this about 2 months ago, store it laying on its side, in the drawer of an acrylic cabinet. I have 3 different colors and none if dried out. I'm not sure why others are having issues.
These are so completely waterproof! I suddenly had to go into the hospital and came home 3 days later. I still had this eyeliner on because the face soap and water they gave me did not take it off. I use Mary Kay eye makeup remover and it comes off just fine.
When you put it on, let it dry before using an eyelash curler or it smears off. It's easy to apply if you steady your elbow, draw the line the highest you want it to go towards your brow and then fill in anything elbow that line that shows your normal skin color. I also usually go over it again after my mascara dried because it's easier to what your missed right up next to your lashes.
It looks really pretty to top your lashes with a black line and then top it with a colored line just above it.