Review (3/5): Doesn't remove 100% of makeup, strange scent
I really wanted to like this product. I was looking for a cheaper alternative to the cleansing oil I have been using for the past year: Kiehl's Midnight Recovery Cleansing Oil, which costs $30+ for one bottle (though it's larger than this one). Neutrogena's cleansing oil is thick, doesn't emulsify as quickly as nicer ones, and does not remove all my waterproof eye makeup in one wash. I have found there are still smudges of mascara under my eyes in the morning after I used the oil before I went to bed. This happens even if I spend extra time rubbing the oil into my eyelashes. It does, however, remove all the rest of my makeup (foundation, eyebrow filler, powder). Also, the oil smells like the candy Smarties - powdery and sweet. I suppose you get what you pay for. As always, oil cleansers work much better than soap for removing makeup, but I don't know if I'll buy again.