Review (5/5): Once I used this, not going back
I've never used liquid eyeliner in "pencil" or "pen" form before, only pencil/crayon/kohl form or paintbrushes, but now that I've tried it, I think this is going to be my go-to. With the "dry" products, I couldn't get any glide, got uneven lines, and it actually hurt if I tried to get it as dark as I wanted. Maybe this was just because of how my eyes are but it was just bad. With the "wet" products, there tended the be smearing, lines that were too wide, lack of control, and I couldn't put it on upper eyelid. This gel liner was perfect -- great control, dark, no smearing, glides on, only thick line if I want it to be, goes on my upper eyelid. I even used it over cosplay face makeup (dry) and it went on.