Review (5/5): Great quality and selection...
I'm so happy I bought this eyeliner set. The colors are extremely vivid, and they pop, even on my darker skin. I'm a black eyeliner fanatic, and have been wanting to switch things up. I love the mix of colors, which includes average, everyday colors as well as colors appropriate for a night out. They aren't clumpy or runny, and they stay put nicely.
The formula was a pleasant surprise. These pencils glide smoothly, even over eyeshadow and my waterline. The waterline is always a challenging area, because I tear up easily and often. I can create a sharp line or smudge it out, and either way, it wears extremely well. In one photo, I'm wearing black on the waterline and inner corner, and in the other, I'm wearing champagne on the waterline.
I like that these liners each arrive sealed, but be aware that the plastic can be tough to get off, and also that the liners are extremely soft. I broke one unwrapping it, but luckily, they sharpen well, without constantly breaking. The quality, value, and variety of this set are excellent, overall...it's a win.