Review (3/5): Be advised: the "tingle" is from menthol...
I am on the fence about this product. I wanted to try a clay facial cleanser, and tried this. I do not care for products that use menthol and I should have been tipped off by the use of the words "tingles as it cleans". But I thought it would be from the combination of willow bark and clay. When I first used it, I immediately knew it was the familiar menthol burn. I read the ingredients and, while its midway down on the list, menthol is an ingredient.
I won't use this as often as I would like due to the menthol burning feeling. But I do like the texture of the product and my face feels clean after using it.