Review (5/5): not too bad for a first attempt
I haven't came across many mud mask, just Kiehl's Rare Earth Pore cleansing in the past. So I can only compare this two. This is much thicker, creamier than Kiehl's, and it has a strong minty scent which leaves a cooling sensation on the skin. However, as time past, the mintiness became more subtle, not too overpowering as I first packed it on my face. I can feel my skin tighten as the mask dries up, the color changes from dark gray to a whitish gray. I can see slight minimization of my pores, not too bad for a first attempt!