Review (2/5): Not Waterproof, SmudgeProof, or OilProof... Disappears Throughout the Day.
The first pic was of the eyeliner freshly applied in the morning.
Initial thoughts were that it's not very pigmented. I bought it in brown since I like more natural and soft looking eyeliner. Black can be too harsh for my eyes.
Ink pigment was uneven. In one stroke you could see darker more pigmented parts and some watery looking lighter brown parts. Had to go over multiple times for smooth color.
Nice and thin brush tip for very precise application and sharp wing.
It's definitely not waterproof. Even while applying it in the morning there was a dot of water that touched my eye and that part of the eyeliner disappeared.
I also attached pictures of swatches of it on my hand, and what happened to them after I ran water on top.
Definitely not smudge-proof or oil-proof either.
I wore it on top of my Thank Me Later Eye Primer, but it still smudged underneath my eye.
Staying power overall was lousy. As you can see in the close-up photos of my eye after I had been wearing it for a while. Some parts of it completely disappeared, and a lot of it smudged underneath.
For reference, I have combination skin. Very, very dry and sensitive in most areas, oily at the nose and eyes. I also wear contacts and frequently apply eyedrops. (Although I did not use that much eyedrops today since I was testing the eyeliner)
This eyeliner stood no chance T-T
Not the absolute WORST eyeliner I've ever used, but it's up there...