Review (2/5): Fade too Quickly on Oily Eyelids
Very creamy but a total fail for oily eyelids. They are not waterproof and fade away within an hour on me. Even with primer. If you find NYX Jumbo eye pencils work for you then maybe give J.Cat a try. They are very similar, only with sturdier cuter packaging. You will need a pencil sharpener as they do NOT windup. Vanilla Sky is a gorgeous sky blue with excellent pigmentation that shows up on any skintone. Baby Purple is a very sheer very light purple that doesn't show up much.