Review (4/5): Surprisingly great
Pros:
Made my eyelashes look like butterflies. Nice deep black color
Definitely waterproof (cried twice while wearing, no flaking or smudging)
Cons:
I have no idea why, but it's really wet when you first apply it. I get it on the crease of my eyelid all the time. It has the consistency of runny acrylic paint. It's not just me being clumsy I promise. But the upside to this is that it wipes off amazingly well