Review (4/5): Good deal but the product separates occasionally.
It's hard to tell the shade online and from the tube. It's a bit too dark but it does a decent job of concealing. I have extremely dark circles and this performs as well as other drug store concealers (can't say for high end) so I'd rather pay 3 bucks a piece then 8-10. Also since the shade is off its not going to brighten my undereye area as much.
THIS PART IS IMPORTANT. The product will separate from time to time so when you squeeze the tube clear liquid may come out which is probably mostly just water from the ingredients. I just keep squeezing until the actual product comes out. So beware when buying as some people don't care as much but some really do.