Review (1/5): Should have said no
I pulled the little tab to open it up to put my soap in and the whole piece came off. Can't get it back inside. Not gonna waste my time trying to pop it back in. Will just put the soap on the outside and use it that way. The little strap is good for hanging but if it was placed in a different spot it would make it easier to hold when it gets slippery with soap.
Not even worth the effort to return it.