Review (2/5): OUCH!
I have fine, thick hair that is almost waist length and when I put my hair up in one of these, at first I really liked it. It's nice not to have to go around your hair multiple times like I have to with most scruchi/elastic type holders.
Unfortunately, getting this out of my long hair was AWFUL. There's simply no way to get this out of your hair without it rolling and when it does, it takes hair with it until I had a mess that required a pair of scissors and my husband's help to get it out without ripping out lots of hair. I stretched the band out as best I could while my husband clipped it with the scissors and thankfully only clipped the band and not my hair.
I think these would probably be fine with shorter hair but with my long hair, it just rolled it right up into a snarl.
Normally I really like this brand and I've bought lots of their products but this just wasn't for me.