Review (4/5): Very nice! Great for more natural/subtle makeup
I saw this product used in a makeup tutorial video and was immediately interested since I lean almost exclusively toward more subdued makeup using neutral/nude colors. This eyeliner is a soft reddish-brown color and goes on very smoothly. It adds a very subtle hint of color to the water line or the actual eyelid, but it also doesn't seem to stay on all that well even with setting spray. Also, just a heads up, this is a retractable pencil! I didn't realize this until I sharpened it and only afterward learned that the top of the pencil twists. Oops!
Overall, it's a lovely product! I just wish it didn't wear off so easily. Not sure I'd buy it again since I've used products that cost half as much as this that worked much better (Elf Cosmetics! Still my fave!), but I've never seen this color anywhere else, which was the biggest buying point for me.