Review (3/5): Not flake proof, nor waterproof
I got this today, was excited to try it.
My first impression was it seemed dry and didn't seem to go on well, took 2 coats to see it.
Through the day I'd find flakes on my cheeks from it which if its old and drying out you'd expect but its suppose to be new.
As for waterproof it isn't, it came right off when it got wet, so dont cry..
It never smudged just flaked.
From all the great reviews i guess i was the unlucky one and got a dried out tube of mascara.