Review (3/5): One winner and one loser
Buffalo Trace- great smell! My bathroom smells like it for ever after I shower. Great lather and lasts a while. Will buy again and again
The other- no scent that I have noticed. Takes forever to work up a lather. If its wet and you squeeze a bit too hard it changes form. I won't buy it again.
Conclusion: 50% success isn't terrible but, next time I'll buy just the one.