Review (4/5): Maybe it was a bad batch...
I had received an American Beauty Ultra-Easy Lip-liner in the color butterscotch as a gift last Christmas and I absolutely loved it! I used to never wear lipstick/lipliner EVER!
I have dark caramel skin color and dark lips. Since I wasn't used to seeing myself and never wore any type of lipstick, I always wanted to stick with nudes.. however, I always struggled finding anything I felt looked good on my lips being that they are not the "perfect" hint of pink and therefore weren't complimented by very many nudes.... but this lipliner changed my life. it was a neutral color that looked great on me and I just loved it....
when American Beauty went out of business or what ever happened. ha! I struggled to find this item, in this color and when I found it on here I was sooooo excited I ended up ordering 3 (I believe).... honestly, I wish I would have waited to receive 1 before ordering the other 2.... I don't know if it was a knock off or if that batch was just a bad one.. but it just felt and looked different on me... I ended up giving them to my sister because I just didn't love it the way I used to.... they are super easy to apply though and are sort of matte, so you can use it as lipstick and not just liner....
Moral of the story is.. this is a great product.. but if you are going to order it, try to stick to only 1 at a time.