Review (4/5): Better than expected
I was afraid it would be too dark and orange, but it actually turned out lighter on my skin, which I wanted (for brightness). It covers pretty well and has solid longevity. I don't have prominent dark circles, just the typical blueish discoloration near the inner corners of the eyes, so I can't speak for how well it would work for dark circles. As for covering pimples, it did a good job on the spot I covered on my chest; it stayed locked in place all day.
On the downside, it takes a bit of effort to blend out and looks a bit chalky on my skin.
This is the first all natural makeup product I've used and I'm glad I gave it a shot.