Review (3/5): Thin but doesn’t glide well and smudges easily.
Purchased this eyeliner because I was looking for a dark brown pencil eyeliner and this Pony Effect slim liner was inexpensive and didn’t have glitter. The pencil itself is very slim, however it doesn’t glide and generate pigment particularly well on my eyelids. I had significant trouble getting the right shape. The formulation feels on the dry side. I’ve had much better experience with conventional brands like Stila or Marc Jacobs liners and even Clio, another Korean brand.
I have hooded eyes and eyeliners to tend to smudge on me on occasion. This one does so immediately and gives me raccoon eyes. I’m gonna test it out a bit longer but I’m definitely regretting my purchase.