Review (1/5): Bad formula. Bad application.
I got this for Christmas and it's absolutely awful. It's watery and is not pigmented at all. The stamp doesn't even have color on it; if I wanted to use the stamp I'd need to cover it with another eyeliner. Huge disappointment. It's a good thing it's cheap because I'd hate to know my mom spent money on this.
The cat eye is what I stamped and drew in with the pen, and the stamp underneath that looks like a smudge is the actual stamp.