Review (5/5): High quality eye liner. You won't be disappointed..
My first day using this (in combination with Jane Cosmetic Eye Primer) has left me amazed! I live in NYC where summer commutes are hot, sweaty, and not fun when you get to work to find your make up has smudged and/or transferred to your upper lid. Not with this eyeliner! I just washed my face and it only dulled the black and didn't smudge it, I still had a crisp cat eye after submerging my face in water. It does come off very easy with any make up remover though. I am super impressed with the quality of this. It is definitely "very black" and stayed pretty much perfect and fresh through the whole day and night. I suggest you find a good quality slanted eye brush for best results of course. I even accidentally rubbed my eye at one point today and no smudge. So glad I found this!!