Review (4/5): 4.5 Stars - Above Average Performance
After hearing many times of "the fat" I decided to buy my own puck of Mitchell's and see what the fuss was about. It turned out to be a really great soap though not my favorite.
Lather:
Doesn't bloom into a full lather avalanche like TOBS does for me but isn't too thin either. Certainly adequate.
Face Protection:
On the slick side, good blade glide. Just for face protection alone this is a great product.
Cost:
A little on the high side. Razorock has similar soaps available for a third less. I'm not sure that they preform to exactly the same level but since I own some I will be putting this to the test. Not super extravagant though.
Scent:
This is where Mitchell's really loses me. I like strong scents with my shave. TOBS Mr. Taylor is great for a classic yet clean scent that sticks with you. Mitchell's smells like a bar of Ivory Soap. Clean for sure, but nothing to get excited about.
Overall:
I wish I could give Mitchell's 4.5 stars. It will give you a great shave. The price isn't that bad and the lack of strong scent may actually be preferable to some people. If you haven't tried it I suggest giving it a go.