Review (2/5): Can look good, but doesn't wear well--flakes/smudges a LOT
The smell is rather nice, if not slightly cloying (smells like raspberry vanilla lotion), but it's a welcome change from the chemical smell of most mascaras. It takes a while to build for volume, but you can get a nice effect.
My issue though is that for me, it flaked and smudged like mad throughout the day. After putting it on in the morning, when I looked in the mirror in the afternoon, I could definitely see a lot of mascara underneath my eye giving me the look of dark circles. I will say that I do use oil as a moisturizer, but this is not really a problem I've had with other regular mascaras--at least to this extent. A little flaking, sure, but when I moistened a q-tip and tried to clean up my undereye area, there was a significant amount of black that was picked up. What a disappointment for $20!