Review (4/5): Excellent--my long search is over!
It's very very difficult to find a hypoallergic dark purple eyeliner that has a small enough applicator to make a thin line, stays on, and yet comes off before bedtime only when I take it off. I have been searching for this for decades. I was so excited when gel came out, but the brushes are never thin enough and pencils don't make thin enough lines. With sharpeners, you lose a lot of product and they never get as sharp as when new or you just lose the whole tip. Forget regular pencil eyeliners, same prob, but I can't use those anyway b/c no color comes off on my eye; it's like trying to use an actual crayon. I would have given this 5 stars, but I can't put it near the corner of my eye b/c it just ends up IN my eye, but at least it's not as irritating as any others, and that's probably just my own crazy sensitivity--I can get close enough that it looks good. Mind you, I'm only putting it under the lashes and NOT on the inner lid rim. Plus, I have been given the tip to wipe off excess before application, but I think as I age my damn eyes have gotten more sensitive. I have searched for years. I have mostly green hazel eyes, and dark purple is the only thing that doesn't make my eyes look brown. I've used this for a month or so, so I highly recommend it!