Review (5/5): Yay!  So glad I took a chance and bought these.
Very easy to apply and smudge, if you want a smokey look. Colors are as described. Pencil is soft and doesn't pull when applying. Very happy with these! I will update if i notice they don't hold up, but so far, so good!
Update: These are awesome! They hold up just as well as the $$$ ones. I'm wearing AQUATIC and the color is bright and really cool. They don't melt down your face. I highly recommend these.