Review (1/5): My soap grew little black spots
I loved the Incredibly Clear Face Cleansing Stick (the one in the plastic tube), I used it for years and so I was super excited to try the plastic free version. I was so disappointed. The formula is different, which is to be expected, but this one would leave a residue behind on my face and it was really hard to rinse off. It also made my face mildly sting a few times. After a couple weeks, it grew a little black spot so I just used my nail to scrape it off. A little bit later it did it again, so I scraped it off again and continued using it. After seeing a third black spot, I threw it away. I kept the bar in a soap holder so it had time to dry in between uses and it was never constantly wet so I know it wasn't a user error. Unfortunately very disappointed.