Review (4/5): Pretty good, but does smudge under eyes
Nice color, easy enough to apply, and no irritation (for me anyway).
I'm knocking off a star because as the day goes on, it tends to run a little bit and I have black smudges under my lower lashes. I got in the habit of carrying Q-tips with me so that I can clean it off. I usually do this 1-2 a day.
I'm going to try a couple of other organic mascaras, but if I don't find one that I like better I'll probably come back to this one.