Review (3/5): Not smudgeproof for deep set eyes.
I was happy with the color. It's a true dark brown. Not the "black-brown" that most dark brown eyeliners are. Based on the other reviews, I was hopeful that it would not smear/smudge onto my upper lid. Sadly, that wasn't true. If you have deep set eyes where your lash line touches your upper lid, this is not the liner for you. If you have more protruding eyes where the lash line does not touch your upper lid, I'm sure it would be wonderful for you. I've tried nearly every reasonably priced waterproof/smudge proof liner out there, and every one of them smudges off onto my upper lid within just a couple hours of wear.