Review (5/5): To be continued....
Have only tried both. The scrub is just what it says a scrub... Nothing super life changing. The callous remover barely softened my calluses but I will give it another try after a good soak
Update: 7/16/21... Soaked in the tub for about 20 mins...got it then gave this another try and I let it sit about 10 mins and gently used me for scraper abs these calluses on my inner heel where rubbed away...I think after a few more soaks they will b softer