Review (5/5): Works great!
It is smudge-proof and yet comes off easily with just water. I used this liner when I had eyelash extensions and it worked great. I was able to remove the eyeliner with wet q-tip so I didn't irritate my lashes. It's hard to find eyeliner that doesn't have oil in the ingredients and this one is a great find for those looking for eyeliner that can work with false lashes or lash extensions.