Review (3/5): Never Fully Dries
I liked this mascara because it's a natural formula and it's non-irritating. I also really liked that it adds noticeable length to my lashes. I'm not sure if it really promotes strength and growth because I put castor oil on my lashes at night anyways (which makes them grow and thicken). This mascara also layers pretty well. For these reasons, I've purchased this mascara more than once. HOWEVER, it always always.... always!! smudges throughout the day. I'm constantly having to check a mirror to make sure the mascara isn't giving me smudgy dark circles. It even gets on my upper eyelids sometimes throughout the day. So If you have oily skin like i do.. beware :( regardless of skin type if you scratch or touch your eye this mascara WILL rub off onto your finger. When you apply it, it's very difficult not to be a little messy of a process. If you cry or get watery eye'd then it's game over. I now put this under my waterproof mascara from Pacifica but i still have the smudging issue. SO. If you don't mind the maintenance of it, it's a nice organic mascara. If you don't keep a mirror with you all day to keep an eye on it though.. may not be for you.