Review (5/5): Exfoliating version is back!!!  Now they have two varieties - one with and one without exfoliation
*** UPDATE Nov 9 2015 ***
They have now added the exfoliating version back, in another listing. That means people who love this soap for whatever other reasons without the exfoliation can give it 5 stars for that. People like me, who can't find strong exfoliating soap from any other brand (I have specifically ordered at least 10 other brands, Loofah, etc. etc. just trying to find one with strong exfoliation - and none have it, except maybe Tasmanian (http://amzn.com/B00CQOHOXY (but this is better)), can now use Honest For Men again - their exfoliating line. So not this listing, but the other listing. Not that exfoliating soap should matter, but actually, I'd be scrubbing with rocks from brooks if humans lived out in nature.
*** Original review a few days before ***
This was my favorite soap - and I depended on it for the fantastic exfoliation, better than any other I've tried (and I tried a dozen kinds).
All of a sudden, in this last batch, they have simply removed the exfoliation completely. Now, when you look at the website, it says "Important Information: We have recently removed our exfoliating oats and coffee grounds due to customer feedback. Our scent is now 100% essential oils no fragrance oil."
Well, I'm here to give you a 1 star review for this "important information". There are 1,000 other soaps that you can buy with various interesting scents, etc. But this was the only soap you can buy that had great exfoliation.
And now they've removed it.
Hopefully, the 'customer feedback' that caused them to remove the exfoliation will be blasted away by the customer feedback complaining that the exfoliation is missing, and they'll put it back.
In the meantime - goodbye, 'Honest for Men'.