Review (5/5): Wow!
The reason I wanted to try this eyeliner is because I am getting married soon, and I have not found an eyeliner that will actually stay put on my face. (Why I care so littler during my normal life, I don't know!) My normal go-to is a waterproof self-sharpening pencil from the drug store, but by the end of the day, it always ends up under my eyes, so I resort to wiping my fingers under my eyes every couple hours to maintain.
I read about this eyeliner from some blog about wedding makeup, and, although I have failed in the past with liquid eyeliner, I gave this a shot. I have tried the drugstore brands and just could not figure it out - I had ugly lines, more seemed to end up on my eyelashes than eyelid, and the finish seemed like it had a shiny appearance. This eyeliner is NOTHING like the drugstore brands I tried. The tip is like a marker, but with a perfect shape and point. It looks as black as a the self-sharpening ones I've used, but IT ACTUALLY STAYS IN PLACE! I will say a little tiny bit of a smudge appeared after a 14 hour day with 2 hours of sweating. But when I use an eye primer (Wet and Wild is cheap and works SO WELL), this stuff doesn't budge. I was hungover and lazy last weekend and was able to wake up and leave the house with this stuff still in place from the day before!
One of the pointers I saw in a video was to turn this on its side and use the side of the eyeliner to line along your lashes. That is working really well for me and keeps the line really close to the lash line. I barely use the actual tip of this liner unless it is to fill in or to experiment with a cat eye.
I plan on this being the only eyeliner I use again! Pricey, but I feel its worth it!