Review (5/5): Great product
I always used Bare Minerals powdered liner... but I ended up with black dust in my cheeks, which smeared, got on clothes, ruined everything, and never washed off completely. I switched to a pencil, which made my lids break out in a rash. This product does well, has healthful ingredients, goes on easily, and washes off easily. My only drawback-- I have to make sure not to moisturize the area around my eyes or the liner runs.