Review (1/5): Worst I have ever used.
The worst eye liner I have ever used. There ain't anything waterproof about this liner. Something happened the first day at used this liner and I cried and my tears were basically black. Not only is it not waterproof, it wanders!! I constantly have to wipe under my eyes and my fingers always come away with liner on them. Excessive amounts. I'm no stranger to wandering eyeliner but this is ridiculous. So no, don't use this.