Review (3/5): Great lather, great value, smells like soap
I'm going to give it 3 b/c I just don't like the way the paper looks all torn and crappy on my shelf for the 6 or so months it takes for me to use the stick. Also the soapy smell is super strong so if your not a fan of super strong plain soap smell then this won't be for you. On the plus side, I haven't found a better deal as far as shaving soap goes.
The shave is good, not the best but good and can be kind of gummy if the brush does not have enough moisture to create a proper lather. To be honest I'm a big fan of making the lather in a bowl and taking my time with it to get it just right. Let's just say it's the quietest part of my day so why not stretch it out a bit.
I'm going to stay w/ Col. Conk for most days (good value). I also keep a tub of Taylor of Old Bond on the shelf for when I'm in a big hurry or for date nights (pricey but smells nice). Tried Proraso and Musgo Real....both smell too strongly of menthol for my taste. Just using those on big rush days.