Review (4/5): Not perfect but pretty good.
I really like these, I bought all the colors because I liked the first one I bought so much. The product goes on easy and you can layer it for a more dramatic effect. You do need a primer on your eyes though or it wont stay on very well. My only issue is that they seem to dry out quickly and the product becomes crumbly, even if you are super careful about closing the lid quickly. I found that dampening my applicator brush just a bit helps moisten it back up a little.