Review (5/5): Exactly what I wanted
Highly pigmented, doesn't smear or break me out, does transfer a bit (I have very hooded eyes) but is easy to clean up, does well enough in the waterline, a little goes a long way actually and I'm still learning to only pick up what I actually need since I use this for eyes and brows (mostly brows), has decent hold, this product is a bit shiny but I just lightly pat what's left of my setting powder over it and I'm good all day, does seem to have stained my white synthetic brush a bit gray after washing it off after a week of use, plays well over eyebrow pencil and under eyebrow powder/ eye shadow. Haven't tried it as mascara, but I've heard it works for that but isn't super dramatic like I like, so maybe one day if I ever have a clean spooly. I'm looking forward to trying the rest of the line.