Review (1/5): If you don't mind the smell of Cherry Cough Syrup in your Oil Cleanser, by all means!
I bought this cleansing oil out of desperation while I was waiting for my Banila co. Clean It Zero cleansing oil to come from Korea. All I can say is I'm glad my Banila co. oil came only a couple days after I bought this one, because I really dislike this Neutrogena Oil.
First off, I hate the smell. It reminds me of sickeningly sweet cherry cough syrup from when I was a kid. Secondly, this stuff burned the heck out of my eyes. You are supposed to be able to use cleansing oils to remove ALL makeup, including eye make-up. So, when I use a cleansing oil to remove my eye-makeup I do not expect to feel like I'm staring into the seventh level of Hell. For the few times I used it, I just ended up using eye-makeup remover for my eyes instead.
Aside from the nauseating scent and my burnt retinas, the cleansing oil does a fairly good job at removing makeup. It also rinses away easily (as any cleansing oil should). Since receiving my Banila co. Cleansing oil I would also say that I prefer the pump dispenser of Neutrogena's oil better than the "sorbet" texture that Banila co.'s cleanser comes in. The pump is a much more convenient and hygienic option than opening the lid and scooping out the solidified oil with Banila's.
If it weren't for the scent or the burning eyes, I would have no complaints about the cleanser. I'd might even give it 4 stars if it weren't for those two things. In the meantime, I can get over the scent and the burning eyes in moments of desperation, but this is not going to be my primary oil cleanser.