Conditions: Ophthalmic Solutions
Keywords: Eye Redness Eye Comfort Red Eyes
Allocation: RANDOMIZED | Intervention model: PARALLEL
Enrollment: 120
Healthy volunteers: yes

Brief summary:
This is a single center, double-blinded study designed to demonstrate the therapeutic equivalence of over-the-counter eye drops in healthy adults with red eyes.

Detailed description:
Eligible participants will use assigned eye drop products as directed. Participants will be required to attend 2 consecutive clinic visits. Assessments for eye redness and eye comfort will be completed. Participants will complete brief questionnaires about their eyes.

Arms:
arm 1: None arm 2: None arm 3: None

Interventions: intervention 1: F# 13418-148 Eye Drops intervention 2: F#13418-158 Eye Drops intervention 3: F# PF-004390 Eye Drops
Intervention descriptions: intervention 1: ocular clear liquid. Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; Glycerin 0.40% 1-2 drops will be instilled as instructed over one day intervention 2: ocular clear liquid Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0% 1-2 drops will be instilled as instructed over one day intervention 3: Ocular clear liquid Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; 1-2 drops will be instilled as instructed over one day

Protocol document:
Prot_002.pdf: 
COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 
1 of 53 
 
CLINICAL PROTOCOL 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
 
 A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled Study to Evaluate the 
Efficacy of Two Investigational OTC Eye Drops in Healthy 
Adults with Red Eye  
 
Investigational Product Name: 
    
Protocol Number: 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
IND / IDE / EudraCT number: 
N/A 
Phase: 
III 
Version Date  
Protocol Final Draft  
Version: 28MAR2017 
 
 
This document contains privileged and confidential information belonging to the Sponsor.  Except as otherwise 
agreed to in writing, by accepting or reviewing this document, you agree to hold the information contained herein in 
confidence and not copy or disclose it to others (except where required by applicable law) or use it for unauthorized 
purposes.  In the event information is disclosed to others, as required by applicable law, they must be informed that 
the information is privileged and confidential and may not be further disclosed by them.  These restrictions on 
disclosures will apply equally to all future information supplied to you that is indicated as privileged and 
confidential.  You agree that no unpublished information contained herein will be published or disclosed without the 
prior written approval of Sponsor.  In the event of any actual or suspected breach of this obligation, Sponsor must be 
promptly notified. 


CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 
COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 
2 of 53 
 
1. 
SYNOPSIS 
Name of Sponsor/Company: Johnson & Johnson Consumer Inc. (JJCI) 
Active Ingredient(s):   
Investigational Product #1 -  
 Eye Drops: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; Glycerin 0.40% 
(F# 13418-148) 
 
Investigational Product #2 - 
 Eye Drops: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; Glycerin 0.20%, 
Hypromellose  0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0% (F# 13418-158),  
 
Positive Control: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, (F# PF-004390 UPC #74300008035) 
 
Title of Study:   A Single-Center, Randomized, Controlled Study to Evaluate the Efficacy of 
Two Investigational OTC Eye Drops in Healthy Adults with Red Eye  
Countries: United States 
Principal Investigator/Site:  
 
Andover Eye Associates 
300 Brickstone Square 
Andover, MA  01810 
Phase of development: III 
Objectives:  
The objective of this study is to demonstrate the therapeutic equivalence of two investigational, 
over-the-counter (OTC) redness reliever eye drop formulations to an existing marketed OTC 
redness reliever eye drop in healthy adults with red eye. 
 
Methodology:  
 
This is a 3-arm, single center, double-blinded, balanced incomplete randomized block design 
study. Subjects will undergo a 1-day (3 doses over 9 hours total) intervention period where each 
subject will be randomly assigned to receive 2 of the 3 test products to apply to the left and right 
eyes. For the duration of the study, subjects will be asked to refrain from using all eye treatments, 
including contact lenses. 
 
Eligible subjects will complete 2 clinic visits. All subjects will have an ocular health and vision 
exam for inclusion in the study during clinic Visit 1.  Eligible subjects will have ocular redness 
assessments using a 5- point redness scale at Baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product 
application), and then 30 seconds, 60 seconds, and 2 minutes following the 1st product 
application.  Subjects will also complete ocular comfort assessments for each eye using a scale of 
0 to 10 at Baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product application) and immediately following the 
Ocular Redness Assessment completed at 60 seconds after the 1st product application.  The first 
dose will be instilled by trained study staff at the clinic. Subjects will also complete a 
questionnaire at Baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product application) and immediately 
following the 2- minute Ocular Redness Assessment.  Subjects will be provided product and 


CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 
COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 
3 of 53 
 
written and verbal instructions to apply the test product at home.  Subjects will apply test products 
at home at 4.5 hours (± 30 minutes) and 9 (± 30 minutes) hours after the 1st product application in 
the clinic.  They will also complete an Ocular Comfort Assessment and questionnaire at 10 hours 
(+ 15 minutes) and 12 hours (+ 15 minutes) at home. 
 
Subjects will return in approximately 24 ± 1 hour(s) for a final vision exam.   
 
Number of subjects (planned):  
Randomize 120 subjects to complete with 114 subjects 
Diagnosis and main criteria for inclusion:  
General Inclusion Criteria: 
1. Able and willing to comprehend and follow the requirements of the study (including 
availability on scheduled visit dates) based upon research site personnel’s assessment; 
2. Able and willing to provide a signed and dated Informed Consent document and 
Authorization for the Release of Health Information for Research  
3. Male or female of any race or ethnicity, aged 18 years and older; 
4. Females of childbearing potential who have a negative urine pregnancy test at the 
Screening/Baseline visit (Visit 1);  
5. Able to read and understand the local language; 
6. Healthy subjects presenting in office with bilateral, mild/moderate ocular redness 
 
;  
7. History of topical ocular vasoconstrictor use or a desire to use topical OTC 
vasoconstrictors for eye redness relief within the last 6 months; 
8. Ocular health within normal limits, in the judgement of the medically qualified 
investigator, including visual acuity of 
 or better in each eye [as measured 
using Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) chart)] at Visit 1; 
9. Male and female subjects with reproductive potential who agree to practice a medically 
acceptable form of birth control (described in section 10.7.4) during the study and for 30 
days following the last dose of investigational product.  Females must have used such 
birth control for at least 3 months prior to the Screening/Baseline Visit 1. 
Subject Exclusion Criteria 
Subjects presenting with any of the following will not be included in the study: 
1. Suspected alcohol or substance abuse (e.g., amphetamines, benzodiazepines, 
cocaine, marijuana, opiates); 
2. Known sensitivity, allergy or contraindications to any investigational product 
ingredient;  


CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 
COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 
4 of 53 
 
3. Females who are pregnant, planning to become pregnant or breastfeeding during the 
study; 
4. Subjects who were previously screened and determined to be ineligible for the 
study;  
5. Use of a therapeutic eye treatment (over-the-counter or prescription) within 2 days 
of the Screening/Baseline visit (Visit 1) and throughout study participation; 
6. Participation in any clinical study investigation within 30 days of Screening/Baseline 
visit (Visit 1); 
7. Relative, partner or staff of any clinical research site personnel; 
8. Active infection of any type at the start of the study; particularly, presence of active 
ocular infection (bacterial, viral, or fungal) or positive history of an ocular herpetic 
infection; 
9. Any ocular condition that could affect the subject's safety or trial parameter, such as 
severe ocular allergy; 
10. Planned surgery during the trial period, 6 months prior to clinic visit 1 or 30 days 
after the end of study period; 
11. Has a compromised immune system; 
12. Has any acute or chronic, medical or psychiatric conditions) that may increase the risk 
associated with study participation or investigational product administration or may 
interfere with the interpretation of study results and, in the judgement of the medically 
qualified investigator, would make the subject inappropriate for entry in this study;   
13. Contact lens use within 24 hours prior to clinic Visit 1 and during their participation in 
the study; 
14. Saline eye drop use within 24 hours prior to clinic Visit 1 and during their participation in 
the study; 
15. Use of any new OTC or prescription medications within 24 hours prior to clinic Visit 1 
and throughout study participation. 
 
If the subject reports taking medication, a history of allergy, and/or a chronic disease which in the 
opinion of the investigator will not affect the clinical parameter(s) being assessed in this study or 
the safety of the subject, the subject may be enrolled in the study and it will be noted on the 
Investigator’s source document. 
 
Study product, dosage and mode of administration:   
Investigational Product #1: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; Glycerin 0.40% (F# 13418-148), 1-2 drops 
in the assigned eye every 4.5 hours (3 doses total), topical application 
Investigational Product #2: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%; Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, 
Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0% (F# 13418-158), 1-2 drops in the assigned eye every 4.5 hours (3 
doses total), topical application 
 
Reference therapy (comparator or placebo control), dosage and mode of administration:  
 
Positive Control: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, (F# PF-004390, UPC 
#74300008035), 1-2 drops in the assigned eye every 4.5 hours (3 doses total), topical application 








 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
8 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
               
               
 
Table of Contents, List of Tables, and List of Figures  
CLINICAL PROTOCOL .................................................................................................................1 
1. 
SYNOPSIS ...................................................................................................................2 
2. 
STUDY FLOW CHART AND SCHEDULE OF ACTIVITIES .................................7 
3. 
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND DEFINITIONS OF TERMS.............................11 
4. 
ETHICS ......................................................................................................................12 
4.1. 
Institutional Review Board (IRB) / Independent Ethics Committee (IEC) ................12 
4.2. 
Ethical Conduct of the Study ......................................................................................12 
4.3. 
Subject Information and Consent ...............................................................................12 
5. 
STUDY ADMINISTRATIVE STRUCTURE ...........................................................13 
6. 
INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................14 
7. 
STUDY OBJECTIVES AND ENDPOINTS ..............................................................15 
8. 
INVESTIGATIONAL PLAN .....................................................................................16 
8.1. 
Overall Study Design and Plan ...................................................................................16 
8.2. 
Criteria for Subject Termination .................................................................................16 
8.3. 
Subject Inclusion / Exclusion Criteria ........................................................................16 
9. 
INVESTIGATIONAL PRODUCT MATERIALS AND MANAGEMENT .............20 
9.1. 
Description of Investigational Products ......................................................................20 
9.2. 
Investigational Product Packaging and Labeling .......................................................21 
9.3. 
Blinding and Unblinding ............................................................................................21 
9.4. 
Method of Assigning Subjects to Treatment Groups .................................................22 
9.5. 
Study Product Storage and Accountability .................................................................22 
9.6. 
Administration of the Investigational Product ............................................................23 
9.7. 
Product Quality Complaints .......................................................................................23 
10. 
STUDY PROCEDURES ............................................................................................24 
10.1. 
Overview .....................................................................................................................24 
10.2. 
Visit 1 (Day 1) – Screening/Baseline .........................................................................24 
10.3. 
Visit 2 (24 hrs ± 1 hr) End of Study ...........................................................................25 
10.4. 
Randomization ............................................................................................................25 
10.5. 
End of Study Procedures ............................................................................................25 
10.6. 
Unscheduled Follow Up Visit(s) ................................................................................25 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
9 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
10.7. 
Life Style Guidelines ..................................................................................................25 
10.8. 
Treatment Compliance ................................................................................................26 
10.9. 
Previous and Concomitant Medications .....................................................................26 
10.10. 
Rescue Therapy ..........................................................................................................27 
11. 
ASSESSMENTS.........................................................................................................28 
11.1. 
Efficacy Measurements and Evaluations ....................................................................28 
11.2. 
Ocular Safety Assessments .........................................................................................29 
12. 
ADVERSE EVENT REPORTING ............................................................................30 
12.1. 
Introduction .................................................................................................................30 
12.2. 
Reporting Period .........................................................................................................30 
12.3. 
Definition of an Adverse Event ..................................................................................30 
12.4. 
Abnormal Test Findings .............................................................................................31 
12.5. 
Serious Adverse Events (SAE) for Drugs ..................................................................31 
12.6. 
Hospitalization ............................................................................................................32 
12.7. 
Resolution ...................................................................................................................33 
12.8. 
Severity Assessment ...................................................................................................33 
12.9. 
Causality Assessment .................................................................................................34 
12.10. 
Special Situations ........................................................................................................36 
12.11. 
Exposure In Utero .......................................................................................................37 
13. 
STATISTICS ..............................................................................................................38 
13.1. 
Sample Size Determination ........................................................................................38 
13.2. 
Analysis Sets ...............................................................................................................38 
13.3. 
Efficacy Analysis ........................................................................................................39 
13.4. 
Statistical Hypothesis ..................................................................................................39 
13.5. 
Data Computations and Data Imputations ..................................................................40 
13.6. 
Analysis Method .........................................................................................................40 
14. 
DIRECT ACCESS TO SOURCE DATA/DOCUMENTS.........................................41 
14.1. 
Study Monitoring ........................................................................................................41 
14.2. 
Audits and Inspections ................................................................................................41 
14.3. 
Institutional Review Board (IRB) ...............................................................................42 
15. 
QUALITY CONTROL AND QUALITY ASSURANCE .........................................43 
16. 
DATA HANDLING AND RECORDKEEPING .......................................................44 
16.1. 
Case Report Forms / Electronic Data Capture ............................................................44 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
10 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
16.2. 
Inspection of Records .................................................................................................44 
16.3. 
Retention of Records ..................................................................................................44 
17. 
SPONSOR DISCONTINUATION CRITERIA .........................................................45 
18. 
DEFINITION OF END OF STUDY ..........................................................................46 
19. 
PUBLICATION POLICY ..........................................................................................47 
20. 
LIST OF REFERENCES ............................................................................................48 
21. 
APPENDIX 1 - PROCEDURES, TESTS, EQUIPMENT AND TECHNIQUES......49 
22. 
APPENDIX 2 – SUBJECT QUESTIONNAIRES .....................................................52 
 
LIST OF TABLES 
Table 1: 
Abbreviations and Specialist Terms ...........................................................................11 
Table 2: 
Investigational Products ..............................................................................................20 
Table 3: 
Investigational Control Product ..................................................................................20 
                                                                                                      
 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
11 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
3. 
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AND DEFINITIONS OF TERMS 
The following abbreviations and specialist terms are used in this study protocol. 
Table 1: 
Abbreviations and Specialist Terms  
Abbreviation or Specialist Term 
Explanation 
AE(s) 
Adverse Event(s) 
BAK 
Benzalkonium chloride 
CRF 
Case Report Form 
DPR 
Designated Physician Representative 
EDC 
Electronic Data Capture 
ETDRS 
Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study 
FDA 
Food & Drug Administration 
GCP 
Good Clinical Practice 
ICH 
International Conference on Harmonization 
IEC 
Independent Ethics Committee 
IRB 
Institutional Review Board 
ITT 
Intent to Treat 
OTC 
Over-the -counter 
PI 
Principal Investigator 
PQC 
Product Quality Complaint 
SAE 
Serious Adverse Event 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
12 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
4. 
ETHICS 
4.1. 
Institutional Review Board (IRB) / Independent Ethics Committee (IEC) 
It is the responsibility of the Investigator to have prospective approval of the study protocol, protocol 
amendments, informed consent forms, and other relevant documents, e.g., advertisements, if applicable, 
from the IRB/IEC. All correspondence with the IRB/IEC should be retained in the Investigator Site 
Master File (SMF). Copies of IRB/IEC approvals should be forwarded to the Sponsor. 
The only circumstance in which a protocol amendment may be initiated prior to IRB/IEC approval is 
where the change is necessary to eliminate apparent immediate hazards to the subjects.  In that event, the 
Investigator must notify the IRB/IEC and the Sponsor in writing within 5 working days after 
implementation. 
4.2. 
Ethical Conduct of the Study 
The study will be performed in accordance with the protocol, International Conference on 
Harmonisation Good Clinical Practice guidelines (ICH E6) and applicable local regulatory requirements 
and laws. 
4.3. 
Subject Information and Consent 
All parties will ensure protection of subject personal data and will not include subject names or subject 
initials on any forms, reports, publications, or in any other disclosures.  Each subject will be assigned a 
subject ID number that is used in the Case Report Form (CRF) in lieu of the subject’s name.  In case of 
data transfer, the Sponsor will maintain high standards of confidentiality and protection of subject 
personal data. 
The informed consent form must be agreed to by the Sponsor and the IRB/IEC and must be in 
compliance with current ICH E6, Good Clinical Practices, local regulatory requirements, and legal 
requirements and be in a language that the subject can read and understand.   
The Investigator must ensure that each study subject is fully informed about the nature and objectives of 
the study and possible risks associated with participation.  The Investigator, or a person designated by 
the Investigator, will obtain written informed consent from each subject before any study-specific 
activity is performed.  The informed consent form used in this study, and any changes made during the 
course of the study, must be prospectively approved by both the IRB and the Sponsor before use.  The 
Investigator will retain the original of each subject's signed consent form.  A copy of the signed and 
dated consent form will be provided to subjects. 
Only subjects who provide informed consent will enter in the study. 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
13 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
5. 
STUDY ADMINISTRATIVE STRUCTURE 
Details on the administrative structure of the study (e.g., Principal Investigator (PI)/study site personnel, 
the Sponsor’s study team, and the external service providers) will be included in the study contact list.  
The study contact list will also include contact information for the Sponsor, Investigator(s), Monitor(s), 
and IRB(s), as well as the names and titles of the person(s) authorized to sign the protocol and the 
protocol amendment(s) for the sponsor.  This list will be maintained in the trial and site master files 
throughout the study for inclusion in the Trial Master File.  
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
14 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
6. 
INTRODUCTION 
Red eye is a common ophthalmologic condition and can include almost any part of the eye.1 
Conjunctival hyperaemia is caused by vasodilation of the conjunctival blood vessels in response to 
irritation.  This vasodilation causes the red appearance of the normally white appearing sclera, leading to 
the condition commonly known as “red eye”. 3   Red eye is treatable with over-the-counter (OTC) 
medications. 2  
 
Preservatives like benzalkonium chloride (BAK) have come under the scrutiny of research studies over 
the years for their potential to disrupt the protective tear film and ocular surface cells. The medical 
community has deemed that despite its efficient bactericidal qualities, BAK is more cytotoxic in high 
quantities than many other preservatives. In order to provide an alternative to BAK, this study will be 
conducted to test the efficacy of two new investigational products containing, 
  
 
 
  
 
 
 
  
 
 
   
 




 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
16 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
8. 
INVESTIGATIONAL PLAN 
8.1. 
Overall Study Design and Plan 
 
This is a 3-arm, single center, double-blinded, balanced incomplete randomized block design study. 
Subjects will undergo a 1-day (3 doses over 9 hours total) intervention period where each subject will be 
randomly assigned to receive 2 of the 3 test products to apply to the left and right eyes. For the duration 
of the study, subjects will be asked to refrain from using all eye treatments, including contact lenses. 
 
Eligible subjects will complete 2 clinic visits. All subjects will have an ocular health and vision exam for 
inclusion in the study during clinic Visit 1.  Eligible subjects will have ocular redness assessments using 
a 5- point redness scale at Baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product application), and then 30 seconds, 
60 seconds, and 2 minutes following 1st product application.  Subjects will also complete Ocular 
Comfort Assessment for each eye using a scale of 0 to 10 at Baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product 
application) and immediately following the Ocular Redness Assessment completed 60 seconds after the 
1st product application. The first dose will be instilled by trained study staff at the clinic. Subjects will 
also complete a questionnaire at Baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product application) and 
immediately following the 2- minute Ocular Redness Assessment.  Subjects will be provided product 
and written and verbal instructions to apply the test product at home.  Subjects will apply test products at 
home at 4.5 hours (± 30 minutes) and 9 (± 30 minutes) hours after the 1st product application in the 
clinic.  They will also complete an Ocular Comfort Assessment and questionnaire at 10 hours (+ 15 
minutes) and 12 hours (+15 minutes) at home. 
 
Subjects will return in approximately 24 ± 1 hour(s) for a final vision exam.   
 
8.2. 
Criteria for Subject Termination 
Premature termination of this clinical study may occur because of a regulatory authority decision, 
change in opinion of the IRB/IEC, product safety problems or at the discretion of the Sponsor. In 
addition, the Sponsor retains the right to discontinue the study at any time. 
8.3. 
Subject Inclusion / Exclusion Criteria 
8.3.1. 
Subject Inclusion Criteria 
This clinical study can fulfill its objectives only if appropriate subjects are enrolled. The following 
eligibility criteria are designed to select subjects for whom protocol treatment is considered appropriate.  
All relevant medical and non-medical conditions should be taken into consideration when deciding 
whether this protocol is suitable for a particular subject.  No waivers to inclusion or exclusion criteria 
will be permitted. 
Subjects must meet all of the following inclusion criteria (and none of the exclusion criteria) to be 
eligible for enrollment into this study: 
 




 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
18 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
10. Planned surgery during the trial period, or 6 months prior to clinic visit 1 or 30 days after 
the end of study period; 
11. Has a compromised immune system; 
12. Has any acute or chronic, medical or psychiatric conditions) that may increase the risk associated 
with study participation or investigational product administration or may interfere with the 
interpretation of study results and, in the judgement of the medically qualified investigator, 
would make the subject inappropriate for entry in this study;   
13. Contact lens use within 24 hours prior to clinic Visit 1 and during their participation in the study; 
14. Saline eye drop use within 24 hours prior to clinic Visit 1 and during their participation in the 
study; 
15. Use of any new OTC or prescription medications within 24 hours prior to clinic Visit 1 and 
throughout study participation. 
 
If the subject reports taking medication, a history of allergy, and/or a chronic disease which in the 
opinion of the investigator will not affect the clinical parameter(s) being assessed in this study or the 
safety of the subject, the subject may be enrolled in the study and it will be noted on the Investigator’s 
source document. 
8.3.3. 
Subject Withdrawal Criteria 
Subjects have the right to withdraw from the study at any time for any reason without compromising 
their rights to receive further treatment.  The Investigator and/or the Sponsor may terminate a subject 
from investigational treatment and/or study follow-up in the event of any of the following: 
 Medical reasons considered significant by the subject, Investigator and/or the Sponsor, which 
may include, an adverse event, inter-current illness or medical reasons unrelated to the study 
 Nonmedical reasons (e.g., subject request or noncompliance with the treatment procedure as 
determined by the investigator, the Sponsor and/or subject) 
 Pregnancy 
 Serious eligibility or on-study violation of the protocol 
 Administrative or other reasons 
Should a subject decide to withdraw from the study at any point, all efforts should be made to complete 
all end of study assessments (if subject cannot come to study site, a telephone call to collect information 
could be performed).  In case of questions surrounding the circumstances that a subject needs to be 
withdrawn from the study (e.g., protocol deviation), the Sponsor, or the Sponsor representative should 
be consulted.  The reason for withdrawal should be documented in the subject’s source document and on 
the Subject Disposition EDC page.  
If a subject does not return for a scheduled visit, three documented attempts will be made to contact the 
subject via: 
1. Documented phone call (date, time, person completing the call, result) 
2. Regular mail 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
19 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
3. Certified letter/return receipt (if service is available) 
The site should request the subject return all used/unused investigational product(s), and follow-up with 
the subject regarding any unresolved adverse events.  
If the subject withdraws from the study and also withdraws consent for disclosure of future information, 
no further evaluations will be performed and no additional data will be collected. The Sponsor may 
retain and continue to use any data collected before such withdrawal of consent.  
 




 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
21 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 
9.2. 
Investigational Product Packaging and Labeling 
All three products will be identical in color. Test products will be provided in randomization number 
specific kits. utilizing a one-part label containing the following information:  
 Protocol Number 
 Randomization Number 
 Right Eye or Left Eye 
 Site Identification 
 24-Hour Emergency Phone Number  
 Directions for Use 
 For Investigational Use 
 Warnings 
 Net Contents  
 Expiration 
 Storage Conditions 
Labeling of study supplies will be in compliance with applicable regulatory requirements. All 
investigational, including any commercially available, must be stored in accordance with the 
manufacturers’ instructions. Investigational product supplies must be stored separately. Until dispensed 
to the subjects, the investigational product will be stored in a securely locked area, only accessible to 
authorized personnel. 
9.3. 
Blinding and Unblinding  
 
The Sponsor will provide blinded investigational product. The Investigator/Clinician and the subjects 
will not have access to the treatment code.  
 
The Investigator/Clinician will not know which treatment has been administered to subjects. Personnel 
dispensing the test products, collecting used products or supervising their use will not participate in the 
examination of subjects in order to minimize potential bias. During supervised use, other staff members 
including the Investigator/Clinician will not have access to the area where the product is being 
administered.  
 
The randomization scheme will be used by the Clinical and Consumer Packaging Operations 
Department to generate the subject specific single disclosure envelopes. The site clinical study 
coordinator will receive one package containing individual subject specific disclosure envelopes 
indicating treatment decode for each randomization number. Identification of the products assigned to a 
subject may be revealed in the event of a serious adverse event by opening the single subject specific 
envelope that displays the subject’s randomization number. In such an instance, the Investigator will, if 
circumstances and time permit, contact the Sponsor prior to breaking the code. The date and reason for 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
22 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
such unblinding must be described on the subject’s source document. Upon completion of the study, all 
subject specific disclosure envelopes must be returned to the study monitor who will return them to the 
sponsor.  
 
Blinding should only be broken when required and only for the subject in question. The Investigator 
must notify the Sponsor, when circumstances and time permit, prior to unblinding of any subject. 
Expectedness of serious and related adverse events should be assessed using the Safety Attestation letter 
and/or, for marketed products, the locally approved labeling.  
 
If there is a medical emergency and the Investigator deems it necessary to know the subject’s study 
treatment urgently for the subject’s proper medical care, the Investigator may break the treatment code 
immediately, and then contact the Study Director or designee as soon as possible afterward. If in the 
opinion of the Investigator it is necessary to break the treatment code and circumstances allow, the 
Investigator will first contact the Study Director or designee for consultation about breaking the study 
blind. 
9.4. 
Method of Assigning Subjects to Treatment Groups 
 
As the subjects sign a consent form, (s)he will be sequentially issued a subject ID. The subject ID will 
begin with the center ID “1001” followed by a four- digit unique subject identifier, e.g. “10011001”. 
Upon qualifying, a unique randomization number will be assigned. This number determines the 
treatment sequence assignment for each subject according to a randomization schedule.  Each subject 
will be randomized to receive 2 of the 3 Investigational Products, one for each eye.  Both products will 
be packaged in individual subject kits.  The product labels will clearly state “LEFT EYE” or “RIGHT 
EYE”.  The randomization will be assigned sequentially, from 1-120. Once a randomization number has 
been assigned to a subject, it cannot be reassigned to another subject. The treatment sequence 
assignments of the investigational product and control will be based on a randomization scheme devised 
by the Sponsor. The randomization scheme will be used by the Sponsor to generate the randomization-
number-specific single disclosure envelopes. 
9.5. 
Study Product Storage and Accountability 
The Investigator, or a designated study staff, will ensure that all investigational products are stored in a 
secured area at room temperature and in accordance with applicable regulatory requirements.  Until 
dispensed, the investigational product will be stored in a securely locked area, accessible only to 
authorized personnel.  
The Investigator must maintain adequate records documenting the receipt, use, loss, or other disposition 
of the investigational product on the Investigational Product Accountability Log supplied by the Sponsor 
or Designee.  The log must identify the investigational product and account for its disposition on a 
subject-by-subject basis, including specific dates and quantities dispensed and returned.  The log must 
be signed by the individual who dispensed/retrieved the study product, and copies must be provided to 
the Sponsor at the end of the study for the Trial Master File. 
At the end of the study, the Study Monitor will conduct the final investigational product accountability. 
All investigational products and study disclosure envelopes must be returned to the Sponsor. The 
Sponsor will provide instructions as to return of any used and unused investigational product.   


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
23 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
9.6. 
Administration of the Investigational Product 
Subjects will be provided written and oral instructions for their products by the site.  
9.7. 
Product Quality Complaints  
 
A Product Quality Complaint (PQC) is any written, electronic, or oral communication that alleges 
deficiencies related to the identity, quality, durability, reliability or safety of a product, including its 
labeling, delivery system or packaging integrity.  This does not include effectiveness, preference or 
performance measures, which will be reviewed in aggregate at appropriate intervals. 
 
Any issues with the product discovered during the initial inventory of study supplies should follow the 
instructions provided on the receipt letter; no PQC form should be filed for issues identified when 
opening or unpacking a shipment. Subsequently, any observation of a PQC requires immediate 
notification to the study manager via a completed PQC form and telephone call. 
The PI or designee should complete, sign and forward a copy of the PQC form, via an agreed upon 
secure exchange, to the study manager listed below. 
 
 
 
 
 
 
In addition, PQC information must be included on the Investigational Product Dispensing and 
Accountability Log or equivalent in the comments field.  The Study Manager listed can assist you or 
answer questions related to this process.  To aid in the initial conversation and understanding of a PQC, 
the site staff may be asked to photograph the issue and send it to the Study Manager.  
When enrolling subjects into this study it is the site’s responsibility to instruct subjects not to use the 
product if they have a concern related to the product such as an issue with the labeling, investigational 
product or package integrity and to immediately report it using the instruction on the Informed Consent 
or product label.   
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
24 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
10. 
STUDY PROCEDURES 
10.1. 
Overview 
Collection of adverse events and concomitant medications will start after the study-specific informed 
consent document has been signed and continue until completion of the follow-up/end of study 
procedures.  The Schedule of Activities/Study Flow Chart (Table 1) summarizes dose administration and 
the timing and frequency of safety and efficacy procedures and measurements.  In the event of abnormal 
safety findings during the conduct of the study, the attending clinician may request additional safety 
evaluations, either immediately or subsequently at a frequency considered appropriate. 
10.2. 
Visit 1 (Day 1) – Screening/Baseline 
Informed consent will be obtained from the subjects before any study related assessments are conducted.  
Trained study staff will complete the following activities for each subject: 
 Obtain written Informed Consent and Authorization for the Release of Health Information for 
Research;  
 Collect demography 
 Collect significant medical history within one year, e.g., major medical conditions 
 Collect history of prior (past 30 days) and concomitant medications and non-drug therapy 
 A urine pregnancy test (dipstick) will be completed on all women of child bearing potential 
 Pre-treatment Baseline Subject Ocular Comfort Assessment will be evaluated using a Scale 
 
 
 Pre-treatment Baseline Subject questionnaire will be completed; 
 Perform vision/ eye examination.  The following procedures will be performed: 
 Visual Acuity 
 Slit lamp biomicroscopy 
 Pre-treatment Baseline ocular redness will be assessed by a trained clinician; 
 Review inclusion exclusion criteria; 
 Randomization; 
 The first dose of each Investigational product will be instilled in the clinic by trained study staff;   
 Investigational products will be instilled in each eye, and then the assessments described below 
will begin; 
 Ocular redness will be assessed at 30 seconds, 60 seconds and 2 minutes after product 
application; 
 Subject Ocular Comfort Assessment will be evaluated immediately following the 60 second 
Ocular Redness Assessment (and before the 2-minute Ocular Redness Assessment) using a scale 
; 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
25 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 A Post-treatment subject questionnaire will be administered immediately following the 2-minute 
Ocular Redness Assessment; 
 Investigational products, instructions for use, diary and questionnaires will be dispensed to the 
subjects for the home use; 
 Verbal and written instructions will be provided for subject home use.  Subjects will be 
instructed to apply 1-2 drops of each test product in the designated eye two more times on the 
same day as clinic visit 1, at 4.5 hours (± 30 minutes) and 9 (± 30 minutes) after the first dose 
applied at the clinic.   They will also complete subject questionnaires and ocular comfort 
assessments at home at 10 hours (+ 15 minutes) and 12 hours (+ 15 minutes);    
 Visit 2 appointment will be scheduled;  
 Adverse events will be assessed 
10.3. 
Visit 2 (24 hrs ± 1 hr) End of Study 
 Update any changes in medical history or concomitant medications and non-drug therapies;  
 Assess for adverse events since last visit; 
 Collect investigational products, collect and review diaries and questionnaires; 
 Complete final vision/eye exam.  This exam will consist of only a Visual Acuity assessment;   
 Complete Subject Disposition/Exit 
10.4. 
Randomization 
Subjects who meet the eligibility criteria, will be randomized during Visit 1. The Sponsor will be 
responsible for the generation of the randomization schedule and products will be packaged in individual 
subject kits according to this randomization schedule.  
10.5. 
End of Study Procedures  
End of study is defined as the subject’s last day of study participation due to study completion or early 
withdrawal/termination. Assessment of adverse events, collection of study materials and subject 
disposition should be completed.  
10.6. 
Unscheduled Follow Up Visit(s) 
If a subject experiences an adverse event that is deemed to have a causal relationship to the trial 
procedures, when the subject either completes or discontinues participation in the study, he/she must 
return to the site for a follow-up visit and should be followed until the adverse event resolves.  
10.7. 
Life Style Guidelines  
10.7.1. 
Meals and Dietary Restrictions  
All subjects will be asked to maintain their normal dietary habits throughout this study. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
26 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
10.7.2. 
Alcohol, Caffeine and Tobacco Consumption / Restrictions  
There is no alcohol, caffeine or tobacco limits or restrictions placed on subjects who choose to 
participate in this study.  
10.7.3. 
Physical Activity Requirements / Restrictions  
There are no physical activity requirements or restrictions for subjects who choose to participate in this 
study.  
10.7.4. 
Contraception for Females 
Male and female subjects with reproductive potential must agree to practice a medically acceptable form 
of birth control during the study and for 30 days following the last dose of investigational product 
whichever is later.  Females must have used such birth control for at least 3 months prior to the 
Screening/Baseline visit.  
Medically acceptable forms of birth control that may be used by the subject and/or his/her partner 
include:  
 Established use of hormonal methods of contraception (oral, injected, implanted, patch or 
vaginal ring)  
 Barrier methods of contraception with spermicide: condom or occlusive cap (diaphragm or 
cervical/vault caps) with spermicidal foam/gel/ film/ cream/ suppository.  
 Intrauterine device (IUD) or intrauterine system (IUS)  
 Surgical sterilization (e.g., vasectomy that has been confirmed effective by sperm count 
check, tubal occlusion, hysterectomy, bilateral salpingectomy) 
 Abstinence from heterosexual intercourse:  When this is in line with the preferred and usual 
lifestyle of the subject.  Periodic abstinence (e.g., calendar, ovulation, symptothermal, post-
ovulation methods) and withdrawal are not acceptable methods of contraception.  
A female subject who is postmenopausal (i.e., amenorrheic for at least 12 months prior to the 
Screening/Baseline visit) is not considered of reproductive potential. 
10.8. 
Treatment Compliance  
 
Each subject will record at-home eye drop use on the subject diary.  Study personnel will review the 
subject diary at the next clinic visit to ensure subject was compliant with the instructions.  Any 
deviations from the study requirements will be recorded on the deviation log. 
10.9. 
Previous and Concomitant Medications  
Medications or non-drug therapies used 30 days before the Screening visit and during the study will be 
recorded in the source document.  
Any medication the subject takes other than the investigational product specified in the protocol is 
considered concomitant medication. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
27 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
10.10. 
Rescue Therapy   
No rescue therapy is provided for in this protocol. 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
28 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
11. 
ASSESSMENTS  
11.1. 
Efficacy Measurements and Evaluations  
 
The efficacy measurements include clinician assessment of ocular redness, subject reported ocular comfort and 
subject questionnaire. 
 
11.1.1. 
Clinician Ocular Redness Assessment 
 
 
The clinical assessment of redness will use a 
 
.  Redness will be evaluated in each eye at baseline (pre-treatment prior 
to 1st product application) and then 30 seconds, 60 seconds, and 2 minutes after the 1st 
product application.  
 
 
 
11.1.2. 
Subject Ocular Comfort Assessment 
 
The subject reported Ocular Comfort Assessment will be evaluated in each eye using a scale 
at baseline (pre-treatment prior to 1st product application) and immediately 
following the 60 second Ocular Redness Assessment after 1st product application (and before 
the 2-minute Ocular Redness Assessment), and then from home at 10 hours (+15 minutes) 
and 12 hours (+ 15 minutes) after the 1st product application.  Increments of 0.5 are not 
permitted.  Subjects will be shown the scale and asked to select the point on the scale that 
corresponds to their comfort level.   The Ocular Comfort scale is included below: 
 
 
 
 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
29 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
11.1.3. 
A subject questionnaire will be completed at Baseline (pre-treatment), and post-treatment 
after the 2-minute ocular redness assessment in-clinic, and at home at 10 hours (+15 minutes) 
and 12 hours (+ 15 minutes) after the 1st product application.   
11.2. 
Ocular Safety Assessments 
Ocular vision exams will be completed at screening (visual acuity and slip lamp biomicroscopy) and 
also approximately 24 hours after 1st product application (visual acuity only).   
Safety will be monitored and assessed by the collection, evaluation, and analysis of subject reported 
spontaneous adverse events (AEs). If an AE is reported, the subject will be asked to elaborate on the 
nature of the event. The Investigator or designated clinician will evaluate and record according to the 
Adverse Event Reporting section (Section 12) of the protocol. 
 
Any clinically important abnormalities or causally-related AEs persisting will be followed by the 
Investigator until resolution or until reaching a clinically stable endpoint. AEs will be reported by the 
subject for the duration of the study, beginning with the signing of the study specific informed consent. 
AEs will be followed by the Investigator as specified in Section 12, Adverse Event Reporting.   
 
A clinically significant visual acuity decrease (defined as an increase of 
 or greater in logMAR 
score) from baseline (Visit 1) will be considered an Adverse Event. logMAR scores will be recorded in 
the source document.   
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
30 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
12. 
ADVERSE EVENT REPORTING  
12.1. 
Introduction 
All observed or volunteered AEs regardless of treatment group, or suspected causal relationship to the 
investigational product(s) will be reported as described in the following sections.  For all AEs, the 
Investigator or medically qualified individual (MD/DO/DMD/DDS) must pursue and obtain information 
adequate both to determine the outcome of the AE and to assess whether it meets the criteria for 
classification as a Serious Adverse Event (SAE) requiring immediate notification (within 24 hours) to 
the Sponsor or its designated representative.  For all AEs, sufficient information should be obtained by 
the Investigator or medically qualified individual (MD/DO/ DMD/DDS) to try to determine causality.  
The Investigator is required to assess causality.  For AEs with a suspected causal relationship to the 
investigational product, follow-up by the Investigator or medically qualified individual (MD/DO/ 
DMD/DDS) is required until the event or its sequelae resolve or stabilize at a level acceptable to the 
Investigator, and the Sponsor concurs with that assessment. 
12.2. 
Reporting Period 
All AEs, whether serious or non-serious, observed and/or spontaneously reported, beginning from the 
time the informed consent is signed and dated, are collected on the source document. AEs of randomized 
subjects will be reported in EDC while screen failure subjects will not. Informed consent is considered 
the point at which the subject is participating in the clinical study and all events are captured even if it is 
prior to undergoing any study-related procedure and/or receiving investigational product Non-serious 
adverse events will be reported through the subject’s last study visit (or termination if the subject 
terminates early from the study for any reason).  Non-serious adverse events are to be reported in the 
source documents and the adverse event page of the EDC. Details of any signs and symptoms will be 
described and recorded, including resolution of the adverse event.  
Spontaneous reports of serious AEs will be collected through and including 30 calendar days after 
administration of the subject’s last dose or exposure to investigational product.   
Serious AEs require immediate notification to the Sponsor or its designated representative.  Any SAE 
occurring any time after the reporting period must be promptly reported if a causal relationship to study 
product is suspected. 
12.3. 
Definition of an Adverse Event  
An AE is any untoward medical occurrence that occurs in a subject after they have signed an informed 
consent for a trial involving an investigational product.  Any AE that occurs after the informed consent 
has been signed, until first usage of investigational product, will be considered non-treatment emergent 
and cannot (by virtue of time of occurrence) have a causal relationship with the investigational product.   
The event does not need to have a suspected causal relationship with the investigational product or 
device.  Therefore, an AE can be any unfavorable and unintended sign, symptom, disease or injury 
temporally associated with the use of an investigational product whether or not related to the 
investigational product.  Examples of adverse events include but are not limited to: 
 
Abnormal test findings,  
 
Clinically important symptoms and signs,  


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
31 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 
Changes in physical examination findings, 
 
Hypersensitivity, and  
 
Progression/worsening of underlying disease.  
Additionally, they may include the signs or symptoms resulting from: 
 Overdose,  
 Withdrawal,  
 Abuse,  
 Drug misuse,  
 Drug interactions, 
 Medication errors,  
 Product dependency, 
 Exposure in utero, and 
 Study related procedure. 
12.4. 
Abnormal Test Findings 
The criteria for determining whether an abnormal objective test finding should be reported as an adverse 
event are as follows: 
 Test result is associated with accompanying symptoms, and/or 
 Test result requires additional diagnostic testing or medical/surgical intervention, and/or 
 Test result leads to a discontinuation from the study, significant additional concomitant 
treatment, or other therapy, and/or  
 Test result is considered to be an adverse event by the Investigator or the Sponsor. 
Merely repeating an abnormal test, in the absence of any of the above conditions, does not constitute an 
adverse event.  Any abnormal test result that is determined to be an error does not require reporting as an 
adverse event. 
12.5. 
Serious Adverse Events (SAE) for Drugs  
An AE or suspected adverse reaction is considered “serious” for a drug study if, in the view of either the 
Investigator (MD/DO/ DMD/DDS) or the Sponsor, it results in any of the following outcomes:  
 Results in death, 
 Is life-threatening (immediate risk of death), 
 Requires inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization, 
 Results in persistent or significant incapacity or substantial disruption of the ability to 
conduct normal life functions,  


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
32 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 Results in congenital anomaly/birth defect,  
 Is considered medically significant (medical and scientific judgment should be exercised in 
deciding whether expedited reporting is appropriate in other situations, such as important 
medical events that may not result in death, be life-threatening or require hospitalization but 
may be considered a serious adverse drug experience when, based upon appropriate medical 
judgment, they may jeopardize the subject and may require medical or surgical intervention 
to prevent one of the other outcomes listed above).  Examples of such medical events include 
allergic bronchospasm requiring intensive treatment in an Emergency Room or at home, 
blood dyscrasia, or convulsions that do not result in hospitalization; or development of drug 
dependency or drug abuse, or malignancy), or, 
 Is a suspected transmission of any infectious agent via a medical product (medically 
significant) and should be reported as an SAE in the category ‘Other medically important 
conditions.’ 
12.6. 
Hospitalization 
Adverse events reported from clinical studies associated with hospitalization or prolonging 
hospitalization are considered serious.  Any initial admission (even if less than 24 hours) to a healthcare 
facility meets these criteria.  Admission also includes transfer within the hospital to an acute/intensive 
care unit (e.g., from the psychiatric wing to a medical floor, medical floor to a coronary care unit, 
neurological floor to a tuberculosis unit).  Hospitalization does not include the following:  
 Rehabilitation facilities,  
 Hospice facilities,  
 Respite care (e.g., caregiver relief),  
 Skilled nursing facilities,  
 Nursing homes,  
 Emergency room visits (unless the reason for the emergency room visit meets one of the 
other outcomes in the definition of serious), and/or  
 Same day surgeries (as outpatient/same day/ambulatory procedures)  
 Hospitalization or prolongation of hospitalization in the absence of a precipitating, clinical 
AE is not in itself a SAE.  Examples include:  
 Admission for treatment of a pre-existing condition not associated with the development of a 
new AE or with a worsening of the pre-existing condition (e.g., for work-up of persistent pre-
treatment lab abnormality),  
 Social admission (e.g., subject has no place to sleep),  
 Administrative admission (e.g., for yearly physical exam),  
 Protocol-specified admission during a clinical study (e.g., for a procedure required by the 
study protocol),  


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
33 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 Optional admission not associated with a precipitating clinical AE (e.g., or elective cosmetic 
surgery),  
Pre-planned treatments or surgical procedures should be noted in the baseline source documentation for 
the entire protocol and/or for the individual subject.  
 Diagnostic and therapeutic non-invasive and invasive procedures, such as surgery, should not 
be reported as AEs.  However, the medical condition for which the procedure was performed 
should be reported if it meets the definition of an AE.  For example, an acute appendicitis 
that begins during the AE reporting period should be reported as the AE and the resulting 
appendectomy should be recorded as treatment of the AE. 
12.7. 
Resolution 
The Investigator will be required to assess the outcome of the AE for investigational product  as one of 
the following:  
 Resolved,  
 Not Resolved, 
 Fatal, 
 Resolved with sequelae,  
 Resolving, or 
 Unknown. 
Any causally-related AEs unresolved upon completion of the last study visit will be followed up by the 
study staff until the event or its sequelae resolve or stabilize at a level acceptable to the Investigator and 
recorded in the EDC system.  An event that is assessed as resolved with sequelae or resolving indicates 
that the subject has stabilized to a level acceptable to the Investigator and has concurrence by the 
Sponsor. 
12.8. 
Severity Assessment 
The severity of AEs from investigational product will be assessed by the Investigator or medically 
qualified individual (MD/DO/ DMD/DDS) using the following general categorical descriptors:  
MILD: 
Awareness of symptoms that are easily tolerated, causing minimal discomfort and not 
interfering with subject's usual function or normal everyday activities 
MODERATE: 
Sufficient discomfort is present to cause interference to some extent with subject's 
usual function or normal everyday activity   
SEVERE:  
Extreme distress, causing significant impairment of functioning or incapacitation; 
interferes significantly with subject's usual function; prevents normal everyday 
activities 
Note the distinction between the severity and the seriousness of an AE.  A severe event is not 
necessarily a serious event.  For example, a headache may be severe (interferes significantly with 
subject's usual function) but would not be classified as serious unless it met one of the criteria for SAEs, 
listed above. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
34 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
12.9. 
Causality Assessment 
 The Investigator’s or medically qualified individual (MD/DO/ DMD/DDS) assessment of 
causality for investigational product (i.e., relationship to investigational product) must be 
provided for all AEs (serious and nonserious).  An Investigator’s causality assessment is the 
determination of whether there exists a reasonable possibility that the investigational product 
caused or contributed to an AE.  
 
Not Related - An AE that is not related to the use of the drug  
 
Doubtful - An AE for which an alternative explanation is more likely, e.g., concomitant 
drug(s), concomitant disease(s), or the relationship in time suggests that a causal 
relationship to investigational product is unlikely.  
 Possible - An AE that might be due to the use of the drug.  An alternative explanation, e.g., 
concomitant drug(s), concomitant disease(s), is inconclusive.  The relationship in time is 
reasonable; therefore, the causal relationship to investigational product cannot be excluded.  
 
Probable - An AE that might be due to the use of the drug.  The relationship in time is 
suggestive (e.g., confirmed by dechallenge) and an alternative explanation is less likely, 
e.g., concomitant drug(s), concomitant disease(s).  
 
Very Likely - An AE that is listed as a possible adverse reaction and cannot be reasonably 
explained by an alternative explanation, e.g., concomitant drug(s), concomitant disease(s).  
The relationship in time is very suggestive (e.g., it is confirmed by dechallenge and 
rechallenge) for a causal relationship to the drug. 
If the Investigator determines a SAE is associated with study procedures, the Investigator must record 
this suspected causal relationship in the source documents and in the EDC system, as appropriate, and 
report such an assessment in accordance with the SAE reporting requirements, if applicable. 
12.9.1. 
Withdrawal Due to Adverse Events 
When a subject withdraws due to a SAE, the SAEs must be reported in accordance with the reporting 
requirements defined below. 
12.9.2. 
Eliciting Adverse Event Information 
The Investigator is to report all directly observed AEs and all AEs spontaneously reported by the study 
subject.  In addition, each study subject will be questioned about AEs.  
12.9.3. 
Reporting Requirements 
Each AE is to be assessed to determine if it meets the criteria for a SAE.  If a SAE occurs, expedited 
reporting will follow local and international regulations, as appropriate.  
For randomized subjects, all AEs will be reported on the AE source document page and then will be 
entered in EDC. A Clinical Serious Adverse Event (SAE) Report Form must also be completed if the 
event is considered to be serious.  It should be noted that this Clinical SAE Report Form for collection of 
SAE information is not the same as the AE EDC page.  Where the same data are collected, the forms 
must be completed in a consistent manner.  For example, the same AE term should be used on both 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
35 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
forms.  Adverse events should be reported using concise medical terminology in the EDC system as well 
as on the form for collection of SAE information. 
12.9.3.1. Serious Adverse Event Reporting Requirements 
If a SAE occurs, the Sponsor is to be initially notified by telephone immediately upon awareness of the 
event by the Investigator’s site.  Within 24 hours of the Investigator site’s awareness of the event, the 
study site must send the Sponsor the Clinical SAE Report Form (via a secure e-mail).  This timeframe 
also applies to additional new information (follow-up) on previously forwarded SAE reports as well as 
to the initial and follow-up reporting of EIU cases.  In the rare event that the Investigator’s site does not 
become aware of the occurrence of a SAE immediately (e.g., if an outpatient study subject initially seeks 
treatment elsewhere), the Investigator’s site is to report the event immediately after learning of it as 
described and document the time of the study site’s first awareness of the AE.   
For all SAEs, the Investigator is obligated to pursue and provide information to the Sponsor in 
accordance with the timeframes for reporting specified above.  In addition, an Investigator may be 
requested by the Sponsor to obtain specific additional follow-up information in an expedited fashion.  
This information may be more detailed than that captured on the AE case report form.  In general, this 
will include a description of the adverse event in sufficient detail to allow for a complete medical 
assessment of the case and independent determination of possible causality.  Information on other 
possible causes of the event, such as concomitant medications and illnesses must be provided. In the 
case of a subject death, a summary of available autopsy findings (if available) and death certificate 
should be collected if permission is obtained from the subject’s family.  For a hospitalization, a copy of 
the hospital discharge summary should be requested. If obtained, these documents (with subject’s 
personal identifiers redacted) should be submitted as soon as possible to the Sponsor or its designated 
representative.  
Appropriate SAE forms will be provided to the study site at the initiation of the study.  Upon 
notification of an SAE at the study site, the Investigator or designated study site staff should call and 
speak to their Sponsor’s study team contact immediately to initially notify them of the SAE.   
Within 24 hours of awareness of the event, the Investigator or designated study site staff: 
 
Complete the Clinical SAE Report Form [that has been provided to you by the Sponsor or 
their designee] with as much information as possible, however at a minimum, the subject 
identification number, name of product, SAE, and name of reporter are required);   
 
Ensures the Investigator signs the Clinical SAE Report Form prior to sending to the 
Sponsor;  
 
Scans and send via secure email the Clinical SAE Report Form and any supportive 
documentation to the Sponsor contacts.   
 The Sponsor contact information: 
 
 
 
 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
36 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
12.10. 
Special Situations 
Special Situations (SS): Safety events that may not meet the definition of an AE; however, are required 
to be collected to meet Health Authority requirements. Examples include: 
 Overdose of a J&J medicinal product. 
 Pregnancy exposure (maternal and paternal) to a J&J medicinal product or medical 
device. 
 Exposure to a J&J product from breastfeeding. 
 Suspected abuse/misuse of a J&J medicinal product or medical device. 
 Inadvertent or accidental exposure to a J&J medicinal product or medical device 
(including occupational exposure). 
 Any failure of expected pharmacological or medical device action (i.e., lack of effect) of 
a J&J product. 
 Unexpected therapeutic or clinical benefit from use of a J&J product. 
 Medication error involving a J&J medicinal product or medical device with or without 
patient/consumer exposure to the J&J product, (e.g., product name confusion) OR that caused 
an unintended effect or could cause an intended effect (e.g. adult medicine given to a young 
child). 
 Suspected transmission of an infectious agent via a J&J product. 
 Off-label use.  Note: Off-label use of a product without an associated AE should be collected 
only when it is specifically and voluntarily brought to the attention of the company in an 
unsolicited manner by a reporter (e.g., Patient or HCP), or data obtained from databases 
where off-label use may be systematically collected (e.g., reimbursement database in US), 
and in accordance with local procedure in compliance with local laws and regulations. 
 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
37 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
12.11. 
Exposure In Utero 
For investigational products within clinical studies and for marketed products, an exposure in utero EIU 
occurs if:  
1. A woman is exposed to the investigational product at any time between her last menses prior to 
conception through the delivery of the baby.  
2. There is a possibility of intrauterine exposure to drug via semen from the male partner who is 
taking the investigational product at the time of conception, thereby possibly exposing the fetus 
to the product.  
If any study subject or study subject’s partner becomes or is found to be pregnant during the study 
subject’s participation, the Investigator must report the pregnancy to the Sponsor on a Pregnancy 
Notification Form (to be provided by the Sponsor when applicable).  In addition, the Investigator must 
submit information regarding environmental exposure to a Sponsor product in a pregnant woman (e.g., a 
nurse reports that she is pregnant and has been exposed to a cytotoxic product by inhalation or spillage) 
using the Pregnancy Notification Form.  This must be done irrespective of whether an adverse event has 
occurred and notification must occur within 24 hours of awareness of the pregnancy.  Initial notification 
via telephone to the Sponsor’s study team contact must occur immediately upon the Investigator site’s 
awareness of the pregnancy.  The Pregnancy Notification Form must then be sent to the Sponsor within 
24 hours of the site’s awareness.  The information submitted should include the anticipated date of 
delivery (see below for information related to induced termination of pregnancy).  
Follow-up is conducted to obtain pregnancy outcome information on all EIU reports.  The Investigator 
will follow the pregnancy until completion or until pregnancy termination (i.e., induced abortion) and 
then notify the Sponsor of the outcome.  The Investigator will provide this information as a follow-up to 
the initial Drug Exposure During Pregnancy Collection Form A and/or End of Pregnancy Collection 
Form B (provided by the Sponsor when applicable).  The reason(s) for an induced abortion should be 
specified.  An EIU report is not created when an ectopic pregnancy report is received since this 
pregnancy is not usually viable.  Rather, a SAE case is created with the event of ectopic pregnancy.   
The Investigator should follow the procedures for reporting SAEs if the outcome of the pregnancy meets 
the criteria for immediate classification as a SAE (i.e., spontaneous abortion, stillbirth, neonatal death, or 
congenital anomaly [including that in an aborted fetus, stillbirth, or neonatal death]).  In the case of a 
live birth, the “normality” of the newborn can be assessed at the time of birth (i.e., no minimum follow-
up period of a presumably normal infant is required before an End of Pregnancy Collection Form B can 
be completed).  The “normality” of an aborted fetus can be assessed by gross visual inspection, unless 
pre-abortion test findings are suggestive of a congenital anomaly.   
Additional pregnancy outcomes that are classified as SAEs and should be reported as such include:  
 
“Spontaneous abortion” includes miscarriage and missed abortion.  
 
All neonatal deaths that occur within 1 month of birth, without regard to causality. 
 
Any infant death after 1 month that the Investigator assesses as possibly related to in utero 
exposure to the investigational product.  
 
 








 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
41 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
14. 
DIRECT ACCESS TO SOURCE DATA/DOCUMENTS 
The investigator(s)/institution(s) will permit study-related monitoring, audits, IRB/IEC review and 
regulatory inspection(s) by providing direct access to source data/documents.  
14.1. 
Study Monitoring 
Before an investigational site can enter a subject into the study, a representative of Johnson & Johnson 
will visit the investigational study site to: 
 Determine the adequacy of the facilities 
 Discuss with the investigator(s) and other personnel their responsibilities the site's 
responsibility with regard to protocol adherence as well as the study and monitoring 
responsibilities of Johnson & Johnson or its representatives.  These responsibilities will be 
documented in a Clinical Study Agreement between Johnson & Johnson and the investigator. 
During the study, a monitor from Johnson & Johnson or representative will have regular contacts with 
the investigational site, for the following: 
 Provide information and support to the investigator(s) 
 Confirm that facilities remain acceptable 
 Confirm that the investigational team is adhering to the protocol, that data are being 
accurately recorded in the source documents and case report forms, and that investigational 
product accountability checks are being performed 
 Perform source data verification.  This includes a comparison of the data in the case report 
forms with the subject’s medical records at the hospital or practice, and other records 
relevant to the study.  This will require direct access to all original records for each subject 
(e.g., clinic charts). 
 Record and report all protocol deviations not previously sent to Johnson & Johnson. 
 Confirm AEs and SAEs have been properly documented in the EDC system and confirm any 
SAEs have been forwarded to Johnson & Johnson and those SAEs that met criteria for 
reporting have been forwarded to the IRB. 
The monitor will be available between visits if the investigator(s) or other staff needs information or 
study-related direction. 
14.2. 
Audits and Inspections 
Authorized representatives of Johnson & Johnson, a regulatory authority, an Independent Ethics 
Committee or an Institutional Review Board may visit the site to perform audits or inspections, 
including source data verification.  The purpose of a Johnson & Johnson audit or inspection is to 
systematically and independently examine all study-related activities and documents to determine 
whether these activities were conducted, and data were recorded, analyzed, and accurately reported 
according to the protocol, Good Clinical Practice guidelines of the International Conference on 
Harmonization, and any applicable regulatory requirements.  The investigator should contact their study 
contacts immediately if contacted by a regulatory agency about an inspection. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
42 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
14.3. 
Institutional Review Board (IRB) 
The Principal Investigator must obtain IRB approval for the investigation.  Initial IRB approval, and all 
materials approved by the IRB for this study including the subject consent form and recruitment 
materials must be maintained in the Site Master File by the Investigator and made available for 
inspection. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
43 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
15. 
QUALITY CONTROL AND QUALITY ASSURANCE 
To ensure compliance with Good Clinical Practices and all applicable regulatory requirements, Johnson 
& Johnson may conduct a quality assurance audit.  Please see Section 14.2 for more details regarding 
the audit process. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
44 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
16. 
DATA HANDLING AND RECORDKEEPING 
16.1. 
Case Report Forms / Electronic Data Capture 
As used in this protocol, the term case report form (CRF) should be understood to refer to the Electronic 
Data Capture system.  
All data will be collected on source documents first and then recorded in the Electronic Data Capture 
(EDC) system.   
The EDC system, is the database where pertinent study data is collected such as demography, subject 
randomization, ocular assessments, adverse events, and subject disposition. 
Electronic Data Capture pages should be completed for each randomized subject.  The completed pages 
of the EDC system are the sole property of the Sponsor and should not be made available in any form to 
third parties, except for authorized representatives of the Sponsor or appropriate regulatory authorities, 
without written permission from the Sponsor. 
It is the Investigator's responsibility to ensure completion and to review and approve all information 
captured in the EDC. The subject’s data in the EDC system must be electronically signed by the 
Investigator. These signatures serve to attest that the information contained in the EDC system is true. 
At all times, the Investigator has final personal responsibility for the accuracy and authenticity of all 
clinical data entered in the EDC. Subject source documents are the Investigator's subject records 
maintained at the study site. In cases where the source documents are the hospital or the physician's 
chart, the information collected in the EDC must match those charts. 
All final data recorded in EDC system will be kept by the Sponsor and at the clinical site.   
All data recorded on source documents will be kept at the clinical site. 
16.2. 
Inspection of Records 
To enable evaluations and/or audits from regulatory authorities or the Sponsor, the investigator agrees to 
keep records including the identity of all participating subjects (sufficient information to link records, 
e.g., CRFs and hospital records), all original signed informed consent forms, copies of all CRFs, SAE 
forms, source documents, and detailed records of treatment disposition.  The records should be retained 
by the investigator according to ICH guidelines, local regulations, or as specified in the Clinical Study 
Agreement, whichever is longer. 
16.3. 
Retention of Records 
The Principal Investigator must maintain all documentation relating to the study for a period of 2 years 
after the last marketing application approval, or if not approved 2 years following the discontinuance of 
the test article for investigation.  If it becomes necessary for Johnson & Johnson or the Regulatory 
Authority to review any documentation relating to the study, the Investigator must permit access to such 
records. 
If the investigator relocates, retires, or for any reason withdraws from the study, the Sponsor should be 
prospectively notified.  The study records must be transferred to an acceptable designee, such as another 
investigator, another institution, or to the Sponsor.  The investigator must obtain Sponsor's written 
permission before disposing of any records, even if retention requirements have been met. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
45 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
17. 
SPONSOR DISCONTINUATION CRITERIA 
Premature termination of this clinical study may occur because of a regulatory authority decision, 
change in opinion of the IRB/IEC, drug safety problems, or at the discretion of the sponsor.  In addition, 
the sponsor retains the right to discontinue development of this investigational compound at any time. 
If a study is prematurely terminated or discontinued, the Sponsor will promptly notify the Investigator.  
After notification, the investigator must contact all participating subjects within 2 weeks.  All study 
materials must be collected and all CRFs completed to the greatest extent possible. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
46 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
18. 
DEFINITION OF END OF STUDY  
The end of this study will be when the last subject completes their last visit. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
47 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
19. 
PUBLICATION POLICY 
Publication of study results by the Investigator is discussed in the Clinical Study Agreement, as 
appropriate.  Results from this study may be published in the form of oral or written presentations at 
scientific meetings or as one or more peer-reviewed journal articles.  In these cases, no information on 
individual subjects will be revealed. 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
48 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
20. 
LIST OF REFERENCES 
 
1. Cronau, H.; Kankanala, R.R.; Mauger, T.  Diagnosis and Management of Red Eye in Primary Care.  
American Family Physician. 2010;81(2):137-144, 145.   
2. Hara, J.H..  The red eye: diagnosis and treatment.  American Family Physician.  1996 Dec; 54(8): 
2423-30. 
3. Murphy, P.J.; Lau, J.S.S; Sim, M.M.L; Woods, R.L.  How red is a white eye?  Clinical grading of 
normal conjunctiva hyperaemia.  Eye.  2007 (21): 633-638.  
4.  
 
 
 
 
 
 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
49 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
21. 
APPENDIX 1 - PROCEDURES, TESTS, EQUIPMENT AND 
TECHNIQUES 
 
 
Visual Acuity Procedures 


 
COMPANY 
CONFIDENTIAL 
50 of 53 
 
CO-161103095739-VCCT 
Version: Final 28MAR2017 
 
 


 
 
 
COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 
Page 51 of 53 
 
 
Slit Lamp Biomicroscopy 




 
 
 
COMPANY CONFIDENTIAL 
Page 53 of 53 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
    
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
                     
                           
                              
                            
                           
   
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
     
 
                     
                           
                              
                            
                           
   
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
  
 
                     
                           
                              
                            
                           
   
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
 
 
                       
                           
                              
                            
                         
   
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
  
                     
                           
                              
                            
                            
   
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
 
                       
                           
                              
                            
                         
  
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
    
                     
                           
                              
                            
                           
   
             
       
            
             
         
 
             
           
                   
                    
             
 
 

SAP_003.pdf: 
Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
A SINGLE-CENTER, RANDOMIZED, CONTROLLED 
STUDY TO EVALUATE THE EFFICACY OF TWO 
INVESTIGATIONAL OTC EYE DROPS IN HEALTHY
ADULTS WITH RED EYE
Statistical Analysis Plan
(SAP)
Version: Final
Version Date: 19 June 2017


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Statistical Analysis Plan
___________________________________________________________________________
Company Confidential
Page 2 of 59
CONTENTS
1
Introduction......................................................................................................3
1.1
Study Objectives ................................................................................................3
1.2
Study Design......................................................................................................3
2
Interim Analyses ..............................................................................................4
3
Analysis Sets .....................................................................................................4
3.1
Efficacy Analyses Sets.......................................................................................4
3.2
Safety Analysis Set ............................................................................................4
3.3
Other Analysis Sets............................................................................................4
4
Endpoints and covariates ................................................................................4
4.1
Efficacy Endpoint(s)..........................................................................................4
4.1.1
Primary Efficacy Endpoint ................................................................................5
4.1.2
Secondary Efficacy Endpoints...........................................................................5
4.1.3
Exploratory Efficacy Endpoints.........................................................................6
4.2
Safety Endpoints................................................................................................6
4.3
Other Endpoints .................................................................................................6
4.3.1
PK Endpoints .....................................................................................................6
4.3.2
PD Endpoints .....................................................................................................6
4.3.3
Outcomes Research Endpoints ..........................................................................6
4.4
Covariates ..........................................................................................................6
5
Handling of Missing Values ............................................................................6
6
Statistical Methodology and Statistical Analyses..........................................7
6.1
Statistical Hypotheses ........................................................................................7
6.2
Statistical Decision Rules ..................................................................................7
6.3
Statistical Methods.............................................................................................7
6.3.1
Primary Endpoint...............................................................................................7
6.3.2
Secondary Endpoints .........................................................................................8
6.3.3
Exploratory Endpoint.........................................................................................8
6.4
Statistical Analyses ............................................................................................9
6.4.1
Demographic and Baseline Characteristics .......................................................9
6.4.2
Primary Efficacy Analysis.................................................................................9
6.4.3
Secondary Efficacy Analysis .............................................................................9
6.4.4
Safety Analyses..................................................................................................9
APPENDICES..................................................................................................................11
APPENDIX 1: SUMMARY TABLES AND FIGURES...............................................11
APPENDIX 2: DATA LISTINGS ..................................................................................13
14.1
Subject Disposition..........................................................................................14
14.2
EFFICACY VARIABLES...............................................................................23
14.3
Safety Data Summary ......................................................................................34






Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 5 of 59
The clinician assessment of redness will use a 
 
  Redness will be evaluated in each eye at baseline (pre-
treatment prior to 1st product application), 30sec, 60sec, and 2 min after the first product 
application.  
:
The subject reported Ocular Comfort Assessment will be evaluated in each eye using 
VAS scale 
 at baseline, about 60 seconds after product application, and at 10 and 
12 hours after the first product application.  
.  Subjects 
will be shown the VAS scale and asked to select the point on the scale that corresponds to 
their comfort level.   The ocular comfort scale is included below:
A subject questionnaire will be administered to evaluate consumer sensory benefits. The 
questionnaire will be completed at Baseline, after the 2-minute ocular redness assessment 
in-clinic, and at home at the 10 (+15 minutes) and 12 (+15 minutes) hours after the first 
product application.
4.1.1
Primary Efficacy Endpoint
The primary efficacy endpoint is the change from baseline in redness at 60 seconds after 
the first application.
4.1.2
Secondary Efficacy Endpoints
The secondary efficacy endpoints include:
Change from baseline in redness at 30 seconds after the first application.
Change from baseline in redness at 2 minutes after the first application.
Change from baseline in ocular comfort at approximately 60 seconds after the 
first application.  
Change from baseline in ocular comfort at approximately 10hr after the first 
application.  
Change from baseline in ocular comfort at approximately 12hr after the first 
application.  


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 6 of 59
Subject questionnaire at each collection time point. The Subject Questionnaire 
assesses consumer sensory benefits and includes 6 questions at baseline and 7 
questions at 2 minutes, 10 hours, and 12 hours after first product application.  
Change from baseline in both redness and ocular comfort will be calculated as the 
baseline score minus the post-baseline score.
4.1.3
Exploratory Efficacy Endpoints
Not applicable.
4.2
Safety Endpoints
The safety endpoints include the Adverse Events. The summarization of adverse events is 
detailed in section 6.4.4. 
4.3
Other Endpoints
Not applicable.
4.3.1
PK Endpoints
Not applicable.
4.3.2
PD Endpoints
Not applicable.
4.3.3
Outcomes Research Endpoints
Not applicable.
4.4
Covariates
For the analysis of ocular redness assessment and ocular comfort assessment, the 
corresponding baseline measurement will be used as the covariate in the analysis model, 
detailed information please refer section 6.3.
5
HANDLING OF MISSING VALUES
No missing data will be imputed. The efficacy analysis will be based on the ITT subjects 
with observed data.






Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 9 of 59
6.4
Statistical Analyses
The Quantitative Science Department will be responsible for data management and 
statistical analyses.
The numbering and titles of summary tables and figures are displayed in Appendix 1. The 
numbering and titles of data listings are displayed in Appendix 2.
6.4.1
Demographic and Baseline Characteristics
Descriptive statistics (number of subjects, mean, and standard deviation, median, 
minimum and maximum value for continuous variables; the number and percentage of 
subjects in each response category for categorical variables) will be provided for 
demographic and baseline characteristics for all randomized subjects by treatment 
sequence.
The number and percentage of subjects reporting medical history will be tabulated by 
condition and treatment group.  The number and percentage of subjects receiving each 
prior medication, concomitant medication and non-drug therapy/procedure will be 
presented for each category (prior medication, concomitant medication, non-drug 
therapy/procedure) by treatment sequence.  Medications that were stopped before the date 
of study medication was taken will be considered prior medications.  All other 
medications will be considered concomitant medications.  
6.4.2
Primary Efficacy Analysis
See section 6.3.1.
6.4.3
Secondary Efficacy Analysis
See section 6.3.2.
6.4.4
Safety Analyses
The safety analysis will be based on the safety analysis set. The adverse events will be 
summarized using the MedDRA coding dictionary by the following:

Number and percentage of subjects experiencing treatment-emergent adverse 
events

Most common treatment-emergent adverse events (≥5% in one or more 
treatment sequence).  

Number and percentage of subjects with treatment-emergent adverse events 
by severity 
Treatment-emergent adverse events are those with a start date and time on or after the 
date and time of study dose administration.
The number of subjects with treatment-emergent adverse events will also be summarized 
by sex, age group (18-64 years, ≥ 65 years) and race (white, non-white).    


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 10 of 59

Number and percentage of subjects who discontinued the trial due to adverse 
events

Number and percentage of subjects experiencing a serious adverse event

Number and percentage of subjects experiencing treatment-related adverse 
events (relationship to study medication is marked as possible, probable or 
very likely)
AEs with unknown relationship to treatment will be counted as treatment-related.

Number and percentage of subjects with treatment-related adverse events by 
severity.
Subjects will be counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 11 of 59
APPENDICES
APPENDIX 1: SUMMARY TABLES AND FIGURES


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 12 of 59
FIGURES:
None.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 13 of 59
APPENDIX 2: DATA LISTINGS


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 14 of 59
14.1 SUBJECT DISPOSITION


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 15 of 59
14.1.1
Disposition of Subjects and Analysis Sets (All Randomized Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.1 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                       Disposition of Subjects and Analysis Sets                                                      
                                                       All Randomized Subjects                                                      
                                       
                                  
         A/B                     A/C                      B/C                      Total 
                                           
(N=xx)                  (N=xx)                  (N=xx)                 (N=xx)       
                                    ----------------------   ---------------------   --------------------------   ----------------
                                            n    (%)                 n    (%)                 n    (%)               n    (%)    
                                    
------------------     
---------------         ---------------      
----------------
Randomized                                    xx                      xx                       xx                      xx          
Completed                                     xx(xx.x%)              xx(xx.x%)                xx(xx.x%)               xx(xx.x%)   
Discontinued                                   x( x.x%)              x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)   
Reason for Discontinuation                                                                                                        
  Adverse Event                                x                      x                        x                       x          
  Protocol Violation                           x                      x                        x                       x          
  Withdrawal by Subject                        x                      x                        x                       x          
  Lost to Follow-Up                            x                      x                        x                       x          
  Lack of Efficacy                             x                      x                        x                       x          
  Non-Compliance with Study Drug               x                      x                        x                       x          
  Study Termination by Sponsor                x                      x                        x                       x          
  Screen Failure                               x                      x                        x                       x          
  Death                                        x                      x                        x                       x          
  Pregnancy                                    x                      x                        x                       x           
  Other                                        x                      x                        x                       x           
Safety Analysis Population                  xx(100%)               xx(100%)               xx(100%)           
xx(100%)      
Intent-to-Treat Subjects                   xx(100%)               xx(100%)               xx(100%)              
xx(100%)     
====
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 16 of 59
14.1.2
Summary of Protocol Deviations (All Randomized Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.2 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                    Summary of Protocol Deviations                                                    
                                                       All Randomized Subjects                                                        
=====================================================================================================================================
                                  
                       A/B                  A/C                B/C                Total 
                                                        
(N=xx)               (N=xx)             (N=xx)           (N=xx)       
                                  
            -------------------   ------------------   -----------------   ----------------
  Category                                                n    (%)              n    (%)           n    (%)         n    (%)    
----------------------------------------------
------------------  
  ---------------    --------------   
----------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE PROTOCOL DEVIATION              xx(xx.x%)            xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)         xx(xx.x%)   
CATEGORY 1                                               x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)   
CATEGORY 2                                                  x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)   
CATEGORY 3                                                  x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)   
CATEGORY 4                                                  x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)   
…
===
===================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Number of deviations is presented for each protocol deviation category.                                                             
                                                         
                                                                            


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 17 of 59
14.1.3
Demographics and Baseline Characteristics (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.3 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                     Demographic Characteristics                                               
Intent-to-treat Subjects
     
                                                A/B                        A/C                      B/C                    Total 
                                                (N=xx)                    (N=xx)                   (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
                                          
----------------------    ---------------------   --------------------------
---------
Age (Years)                                                                                                                              
  n                                            
xx                        xx        
          xx                   
xx        
  Mean                                           xx.x                      xx.x      
          xx.x                 
xx.x      
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                     xx.xx     
           xx.xx                
xx.xx     
  Median                                         xx.x                      xx.x      
           xx.x                 
xx.x      
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                    (xx-xx)    
          (xx-xx)               (xx-xx)    
Sex, n (%)                                                                                 
                                           
  Male                                           xx( xx.x%)                xx( xx.x%)           
xx( xx.x%)         
xx( xx.x%)
  Female                                       
xx( xx.x%)                xx( xx.x%)
          xx( xx.x%)           
xx( xx.x%)
  Total                                          xx( 100%)                 xx( 100%) 
          xx( 100%)            
xx( 100%) 
Race, n (%)                                                                                
                                           
  White                                          xx( xx.x%)                xx( xx.x%)
          xx( xx.x%)         
xx( xx.x%)
  Black or African American                      x( xx.x%)                  x( xx.x%)
            x( xx.x%)             x( xx.x%)
  Asian                                          x                          x        
            x                     x        
  Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander      x                          x        
            x                     x        
  American Indian or Alaska Native               x                          x        
            x                     x        
  Other                                          x                          x        
            x                     x        
  Total                                        
xx( 100%)                 xx( 100%) 
          xx( 100%)            
xx( 100%) 
Ethnicity, n (%)                                                                           
                                           
  Hispanic or Latino                             x( xx.x%)                  x( xx.x%)
            x( xx.x%)         
   x( xx.x%)
  Not Hispanic or Latino                       
xx( xx.x%)                xx( xx.x%)
           xx( xx.x%)           
xx( xx.x%)
  Not Reported                                   x                          x        
            x                     x        
  Unknown                                        x                          x        
            x                 
   x        
  Total                                        
xx( 100%)                 xx( 100%) 
           xx( 100%)            
xx( 100%) 
====
===================================================================================================================
A: 
 Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 18 of 59
14.1.4
Medical History (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.4 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                           Medical History                                               
Intent-to-treat Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                           A/B                 A/C                B/C                 Total          
                                                         
(N=xx)               (N=xx)             (N=xx)           (N=xx)       
                                  
             -------------------   ------------------   -----------------   ----------------
Condition                                                 n    (%)              n    (%)           n    (%)         n    (%)    
----------------------------------------------
  ------------------  
  ---------------    --------------   
----------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE MEDICAL HISTORY             
xx(xx.x%)            xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)         xx(xx.x%)   
Condition 1                                            xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Condition 2                                            xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Condition 3                                            xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
…
===
===================================================================================================================
A: 
 Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 19 of 59
14.1.5
Prior Medication (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.5 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                           Prior Medication                                               
Intent-to-treat Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                           A/B                 A/C                B/C                 Total          
                                                         
(N=xx)               (N=xx)             (N=xx)           (N=xx)       
                                  
             -------------------   ------------------   -----------------   ----------------
Prior Medication                                          n    (%)            n    (%)           n    (%)         n    (%)    
----------------------------------------------
  ------------------  
  ---------------    --------------   
----------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE PRIOR MEDICATION            
xx(xx.x%)            xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)         xx(xx.x%)   
Medication 1                                           xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Medication 2                                           xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Medication 3                                           xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
…
====
===================================================================================================================
A: 
 Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 20 of 59
14.1.6
Concomitant Medication (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.6 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                        Concomitant Medication                                               
Intent-to-treat Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                           A/B                 A/C                B/C                 Total          
                                                         
(N=xx)               (N=xx)             (N=xx)           (N=xx)       
                                  
             -------------------   ------------------   -----------------   ----------------
Concomitant Medication                                   n    (%)            n    (%)           n    (%)         n    (%)    
----------------------------------------------
  ------------------  
  ---------------    --------------   
----------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE CONCOMITANT MEDICATION      
xx(xx.x%)            xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)         xx(xx.x%)   
Medication 1                                           xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Medication 2                                           xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Medication 3                                           xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
…
====
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 21 of 59
14.1.7
Prior Non-drug Therapy / Procedure (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.7 (Page 1 of 1)                                                  
Prior Non-drug Therapy / Procedure
Intent-to-treat Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                              A/B                
A/C                B/C               Total       
                                                              (N=xx)               (N=xx)             (N=xx)           (N=xx)       
                                  
                     ----------------   ------------------   -----------------   ------------
Prior Non-drug Therapy/Procedure                               n    (%)            n    (%)           n    (%)         n    (%)    
-----------------------------------------------------------  --------------  
  ---------------    --------------   
-------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE PRIOR NON-DRUG THERAPY/PROCEDURE
xx(xx.x%)            xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)         xx(xx.x%)
Non-drug Therapy / Procedure 1                           
xx( xx.x%)          xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Non-drug Therapy / Procedure  2                              xx( xx.x%)           xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)
Non-drug Therapy / Procedure  3                              xx( xx.x%)           xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)
…
===
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 22 of 59
14.1.8
Concomitant Non-drug Therapy / Procedure (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.1.8 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
Concomitant Non-drug Therapy / Procedure
Intent-to-treat Subjects
==================================================================================================================================
                                                                    A/B                  A/C                B/C              Total       
                                                                   (N=xx)               (N=xx)             (N=xx)           (N=xx)       
                                  
                            -------------   --------------   -    -------------
  
----------
Concomitant Non-drug Therapy/Procedure                            n    (%)            n    (%)           n    (%)         n    (%)    
-----------------------------------------------------------       --------------  
  ---------------    ------------   
-----------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE CONCOMITANT NON-DRUG THERAPY/PROCEDURE  xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)          xx(xx.x%)         xx(xx.x%)
Non-drug Therapy / Procedure 1                                 
xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)   
  xx( xx.x%)     
xx( xx.x%)
Non-drug Therapy / Procedure  2                                    xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%
Non-drug Therapy / Procedure  3                                    xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)         xx( xx.x%)
…
===
===================================================================================================================
A: 
 Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 23 of 59
14.2 EFFICACY VARIABLES


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 24 of 59
14.2.1.1
Analysis of Change from Baseline in Redness (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.2.1.1 (Page 1 of 3)
Analysis of Change from Baseline in Redness  
Intent-to-treat Subjects
====================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                              
                                                 Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Visit                                          (N=xx)                        (N=xx)                           (N=xx)               
------------------------------------
  -----------------------     
-----------------------       -----------------------------  
Baseline 
   n                                           xx                            xx                             xx              
  
Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
  
S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
  Median                         
            x.xx                          x.xx                           x.xx          
    Min,Max                        
           (x.xx,x.xx)                   (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)     
30 Seconds After First Application
   n                                           xx                            xx                             xx              
  
Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
  
S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
  Median                         
            x.xx                          x.xx                           x.xx          
    Min,Max                        
           (x.xx,x.xx)                   (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)     
  Change from Baseline 
   n                                           xx                            xx                             xx              
  
Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
  
S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                          x.xxx         
  Median                                       x.xx                          x.xx                           x.xx          
    Min,Max                                     (x.xx,x.xx)                   (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)     
    Adjusted Mean                                x.xx                          x.xx                           x.xx          
    s.e.                                         x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
  Pairwise Comparison vs
    Difference           
                                         x.xx                            x.xx           
    s.e.                                                                         x.xxx                           x.xxx           
  
Between Treatment p-value [1]                                               0.xxx a                         0.xxx a         
95% CI                                                                     [x.xxx, x.xxxx]                 [x.xxx, x.xxxx]  
  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ocular redness was assessed on a 5-point severity scale with 0.5 increments (0=none, 1=mild, 2=moderate, 3=severe, and 4=extremely 
severe).
[1] P-values are based on mixed effect analysis of covariance model with treatment as factor, baseline value as a covariate.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 25 of 59
                                                      Table 14.2.1.1 (Page 2 of 3)
Analysis of Change from Baseline in Redness 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
====================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                              
                                                Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Visit                                          (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
60 Seconds After First Application 
    n                                            xx                             xx                              xx              
    Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
    Median                                        x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    Min,Max                                      (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                     (x.xx,x.xx)     
  Change from Baseline 
    n                                            xx                             xx                              xx              
    Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
    Median                                        x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    Min,Max                                      (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                     (x.xx,x.xx)     
    Adjusted Mean                                 x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    s.e.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
  Pairwise Comparison vs 
    Difference           
                                         x.xx                            x.xx           
    s.e.                                                                         x.xxx                           x.xxx           
    Between Treatment p-value [1]                                                0.xxx a                         0.xxx a         
    95% CI                                                                     [x.xxx, x.xxxx]                 [x.xxx, x.xxxx]  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ocular redness was assessed on a 5-point severity scale with 0.5 increments (0=none, 1=mild, 2=moderate, 3=severe, and 4=extremely 
severe).
[1] P-values are based on mixed effect analysis of covariance model with treatment as factor, baseline value as a covariate.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 26 of 59
                                                      Table 14.2.1.1 (Page 3 of 3)
Analysis of Change from Baseline in Redness 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
====================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                              
                                                Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Visit                                          (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
2 Minutes After First Application 
    n                                            xx                             xx                              xx              
    Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
    Median                                        x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    Min,Max                                      (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                     (x.xx,x.xx)     
  Change from Baseline 
    n                                            xx                             xx                              xx              
    Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
    Median                                        x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    Min,Max                                      (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                     (x.xx,x.xx)     
    Adjusted Mean                                 x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    s.e.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
  Pairwise Comparison vs 
    Difference           
                                         x.xx                            x.xx           
    s.e.                                                                         x.xxx                           x.xxx           
    Between Treatment p-value [1]                                                0.xxx a                         0.xxx a         
    95% CI                                                                     [x.xxx, x.xxxx]                 [x.xxx, x.xxxx]  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ocular redness was assessed on a 5-point severity scale with 0.5 increments (0=none, 1=mild, 2=moderate, 3=severe, and 4=extremely 
severe).
[1] P-values are based on mixed effect analysis of covariance model with treatment as factor, baseline value as a covariate.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 27 of 59
14.2.1.2
Summary of Change from Baseline in Redness at 60 Seconds Subgroups (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                      Table 14.2.1.2 (Page 1 of x)
Summary of Change from Baseline in Redness at 60 Seconds by Subgroups
Intent-to-treat Subjects
Male
====================================================================================================================================
                                                                                         Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%   
                                
                                            Glycerin 0.20%
                              
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%       
Hypromellose 0.2%
                           
Tet
.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%         Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Visit                                (N=xx)                        (N=xx)                      (N=xx)               
------------------------------  -----------------------     
-----------------------   -----------------------------             
Baseline 
                  n                  xx                            xx                        xx              
                  Mean               x.xx                           x.xx                       x.xx          
                  S.D.               x.xxx                          x.xxx                      x.xxx         
                
Median             x.xx                          x.xx                      x.xx          
                
Min,Max            x.xx,x.xx)                   (x.xx,x.xx)               (x.xx,x.xx)     
60 seconds After First Application 
                  n                  xx                             xx                         xx              
                  Mean               x.xx                           x.xx                       x.xx          
                  S.D.               x.xxx                          x.xxx                      x.xxx         
                  Median             x.xx                           x.xx                       x.xx          
                  Min,Max            x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                (x.xx,x.xx)     
Change from Baseline 
                  n                  xx                             xx                         xx              
                  Mean               x.xx                           x.xx                       x.xx          
                  S.D.               x.xxx                          x.xxx                      x.xxx         
                  Median             x.xx                           x.xx                       x.xx          
                  Min,Max            x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                (x.xx,x.xx)     
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ocular redness was assessed on a 5-point severity scale with 0.5 increments (0=none, 1=mild, 2=moderate, 3=severe, and 4=extremely 
severe).
The tables for other subgroups will be similar as this.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 28 of 59
14.2.1.3
Analysis of Responder in Redness (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
                                                    
                                                     Table 14.2.1.3 (Page 1 of 1)
Analysis of Responder [1] in Redness 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
====================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                              
                                                Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Visit                                          (N=xx)                        (N=xx)                           (N=xx)               
------------------------------------  
   -----------------------     
-----------------------       -----------------------------  
60 Seconds After First Application  
   Responder                                  xx(xx.x%)                      xx(xx.x%)                      xx(xx.x%)            
    Non-Responder                               xx(xx.xx%)                     xx(xx.xx%)                      xx(xx.xx%)            
    Total                                      xx( 100%)                      xx( 100%)                       xx( 100%)            
    Adjusted Responder proportion              xx.x                          xx.x                           xx.x          
    
  Pairwise Comparison vs.
    Odds Ratio           
                                       x.xx                            x.xx           
    95% CI                                                                      [x.xxx, x.xxxx]                 [x.xxx, x.xxxx]  
  
Between Treatment p-value [2]                                               0.xxx a                         0.xxx a         
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[1] The responder is defined as the subject whose assessment score at 60 seconds after the initial eye drop is less than the 
assessment score at baseline.
[2] P-values are from the GEE model with treatment as factor.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 29 of 59
14.2.2
Analysis of Change from Baseline in Ocular Comfort (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
Table 14.2.2(Page 1 of 3)
Analysis of Change from Baseline in Ocular Comfort 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
====================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                              
                                                 Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Visit                                          (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
60 Seconds After First Application 
    n                                            xx                             xx                              xx              
    Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
    Median                                        x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    Min,Max                                      (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                     (x.xx,x.xx)     
  Change from Baseline 
    n                                            xx                             xx                              xx              
    Mean                                          x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    S.D.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
    Median                                        x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    Min,Max                                      (x.xx,x.xx)                    (x.xx,x.xx)                     (x.xx,x.xx)     
    Adjusted Mean                                 x.xx                           x.xx                            x.xx          
    s.e.                                          x.xxx                          x.xxx                           x.xxx         
  Pairwise Comparison vs 
    Difference           
                                         x.xx                            x.xx           
    s.e.                                                                         x.xxx                           x.xxx           
    Between Treatment p-value [1]                                                0.xxx a                         0.xxx a         
    95% CI                                                                     [x.xxx, x.xxxx]                 [x.xxx, x.xxxx]  
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ocular comfort was assessed on an 11-point VAS scale (0-10)in which 0 = very uncomfortable and 10 = very comfortable.
[1] P-values are based on mixed effect analysis of covariance model with treatment as factor, baseline value as a covariate.
The tables for 10hr after the first application and 12hr after the first application will be similar as this.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 30 of 59
14.2.3
Summary of Subject Questionnaire (Intent-to-treat Subjects)
Table 14.2.3(Page 1 of x)
Summary of Subject Questionnaire 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                              
                                                 Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
Baseline                                         (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
Q1: My eye appears healthy
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
……
Q6: My eye xxxxxxxxxxx
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)            
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
======================================================================================================================================
[1] Response of No opinion will not be included in the calculation of mean, S.D., Median, Min and Max.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 31 of 59
Table 14.2.3(Page 2 of x)
Summary of Subject Questionnaire 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                                                                                             Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
2 minutes after 1st application                  (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
Q1: My eye appears healthy
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
……
Q7: My eye xxxxxxxxxxx
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                       xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
======================================================================================================================================
[1] Response of No opinion will not be included in the calculation of mean, S.D., Median, Min and Max.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 32 of 59
Table 14.2.3(Page 3 of x)
Summary of Subject Questionnaire 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                                                                                             Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
10 hrs after 1st application                     (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
Q1: The product feels gentle on my eye 
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
……
Q7: My eye xxxxxxxxxxx
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
======================================================================================================================================
[1] Response of No opinion will not be included in the calculation of mean, S.D., Median, Min and Max.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 33 of 59
Table 14.2.3(Page 4 of x)
Summary of Subject Questionnaire 
Intent-to-treat Subjects
                                                                                                           Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%                 
                                                                                                             Glycerin 0.20%
                                            
            Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%            
Hypromellose 0.2%
                                          
Te
0.05%        
Glycerin 0.40%              Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%   
12 hrs after 1st application                     (N=xx)                         (N=xx)                           (N=xx)                 
------------------------------------       -----------------------       -----------------------        -----------------------------  
Q1: The product feels gentle on my eye 
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
……
Q7: My eye xxxxxxxxxxx
Strongly agree (1)                              xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat agree (2)                               xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Neither agree or disagree (3)                    xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Somewhat disagree (4)                            xx (xx.x%)                 
xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly disagree (5)                            xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
No opinion [1]                                   xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                        xx (xx.x%)             
Strongly agree & Somewhat agree                xx (xx.x%)                  xx (xx.x%)                         xx (xx.x%)             
        
  N                                            
xx                          xx                                xx                   
  Mean                                           xx.x                        xx.x                              xx.x                 
  S.D.                                           xx.xx                       xx.xx                              xx.xx                
  Median                                         xx.x                         xx.x                               xx.x                 
  Min-Max                                      (xx-xx)                      (xx-xx)                            (xx-xx)               
======================================================================================================================================
[1] Response of No opinion will not be included in the calculation of mean, S.D., Median, Min and Max.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 34 of 59
14.3
SAFETY DATA SUMMARY


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 35 of 59
14.3.1
Summary of Adverse Events (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                        Table 14.3.1 (Page 1 of 1)                                                      
                                                      Summary of Adverse Events (AEs)                                                       
                                                         Safety Analysis Set                                                          
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                                  A/B                 A/C                B/C                 Total 
                                                                (N=xx)             (N=xx)             (N=xx)            
(N=xx)  
                                                         ----------------    ---------------      ----------------- ----------------
                                                                 n    (%)           n    (%)           n    (%)          n    (%)    
----------------------------------------      
         ---------------   ---------------     
---------------   
-------------
Subjects with any treatment-emergent AEs                       xx( x.x%)           xx( x.x%)        
xx( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)        
Subjects with any serious AEs [1]                                x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)         x( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)
Subjects who discontinued due to any AEs [1]                     x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)         x( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)        
Deaths [1]                                                      x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)         x( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)
Subjects with any treatment-related AEs [2]                      x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)         x( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)
Subjects with any serious treatment-related AEs                  x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)         x( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)
Subjects who discontinued due to any treatment-related AEs       x( x.x%)            x( x.x%)         x( x.x%)          xx (xx.x%)        
===
================================================================================================================  
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
[1] Includes both non-treatment emergent and treatment-emergent adverse events.                                                     
[2] Treatment-related adverse events are AEs with relationship to study medication of very likely, probable, possible or unknown.                     


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 36 of 59
14.3.2
Subjects with Treatment-Emergent Adverse Events (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.2 (Page 1 of x)                                                     
Subjects with Treatment-Emergent Adverse Events [1]                  
                                                       Safety Analysis Set
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                  A/B                        A/C                      B/C                    Total 
                                                (N=xx)                    (N=xx)                   (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
System Organ Class                       ----------------           ---------------            -----------------   ----------------
   Preferred Term                               n    (%)                  n    (%)                 n    (%)               n    (%)    
----------------------------------------   ---------------     
    ---------------            ---------------      
-------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE AE                   xx( x.x%)                  xx( x.x%)       
     
xx( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
BODY SYSTEM 1                                    x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                                    x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)         
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                                x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
...
===
=================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Note: AEs are coded by MedDRA Dictionary version 16.x.                                                                                                 
[1] Subjects were counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term.                                               
  System Organ Class and Preferred Terms listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.  


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 37 of 59
14.3.3
Subjects with Treatment-emergent Adverse Events by Subgroup (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.3 (Page 1 of 1)                                                     
                                  Subjects with Treatment-Emergent Adverse Events by Subgroup                            
                                                         Safety Analysis Set                                                          
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                  A/B                        A/C                      B/C                    Total 
                                                (N=xx)                    (N=xx)                   (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
System Organ Class                       ----------------           ---------------            -----------------   ----------------
   Preferred Term                               n/M  (%)                  n/M  (%)                 n/M (%)               n/M (%)    
----------------------------------------   ---------------     
    ---------------            ---------------      
-------------
Gender, n/M (%) [1]
  Male                                         x/xx( x.x%)               x/xx( x.x%)              x/xx( x.x%)           x/xx (xx.x%)
  Female                                       x/xx( x.x%)               x/xx( x.x%)              x/xx( x.x%)           x/xx (xx.x%)
Age Group (years), n/M (%) [1]                                                                                                      
  <18                                          x/xx( x.x%)               x/xx( x.x%)             x/xx( x.x%)           x/xx (xx.x%)
  >=18                                         x/xx( x.x%)               x/xx( x.x%)              x/xx( x.x%)           x/xx (xx.x%)
Race, n/M (%) [1]                                                                                                                   
  White                                        x/xx( x.x%)               x/xx( x.x%)              x/xx( x.x%)           x/xx (xx.x%)
  Non-White                                    x/xx( x.x%)               x/xx( x.x%)              x/xx( x.x%)           x/xx (xx.x%)
====
=================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
[1] n = number of subjects who reported an adverse event; M = total number of subjects in the subgroup.                             


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 38 of 59
14.3.4
Most Commonly Reported (>=5% of Subjects in One or More Treatment Groups) Treatment-Emergent 
Adverse Events (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.4 (Page 1 of 1)                                                     
             Most Commonly Reported (>=5% of Subjects in One or More Treatment Groups) Treatment-Emergent Adverse Events              
                                                         Safety Analysis Set                                                          
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                              A/B                  A/C                B/C                    Total 
                                                            (N=xx)              (N=xx)             (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
System Organ Class                                      --------------    ---------------      -----------------   ----------------
   Preferred Term                                           n    (%)            n    (%)           n    (%)               n    (%)    
--------------------------------------------------     ---------------     ---------------     ---------------      
-------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE MOST COMMONLY REPORTED AE        xx( x.x%)            xx( x.x%)       
xx( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
BODY SYSTEM 1                                                x( x.x%)             x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                                            x( x.x%)             x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                                            x( x.x%)             x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                                                x( x.x%)             x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                                            x( x.x%)             x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                                            x( x.x%)             x( x.x%)          x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
==================================================================================================================================  
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Subjects are counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term.                                                      
System Organ Class and Preferred Terms listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.  
MedDRA Coding Dictionary version 18.0.                                                                                              


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 39 of 59
14.3.5
Summary of Treatment-Emergent Adverse Events by Severity (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.5 (Page 1 of x)                                                     
                                       Summary of Treatment-emergent Adverse Events by Severity                                       
                                                         Safety Analysis Set                                                          
======================================================================================================================================
                                          A/B                                   A/C                                 B/C            
                                        (N=xx)                 
           (N=xx)               
           (N=xx)           
                ------------------------           -----------------------------      ----------------------------
System Organ Class                 Mild     Moderate  Severe          Mild     Moderate  Severe       Mild     Moderate 
Severe 
   Preferred Term                 n (%)      n (%)    
n (%)         n (%)     n (%)    
n (%)       n (%)      n (%)    
n (%)
------------------------------
------------------------------
------------------------  --------
----------------------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE AE   xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)     xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)
xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)
BODY SYSTEM 1                   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)     
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)     
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%)
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)     
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)     
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)     
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ...   
...
====
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Subjects are counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term by selecting the most severe event.          
Listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.                                
MedDRA Coding Dictionary version 18.0.                                                                                     


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 40 of 59
14.3.6
Subjects Who Discontinued the Trial Due to Adverse Events (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.6 (Page 1 of 1)                                                     
Subjects Who Discontinued the Trial Due to Adverse Events [1]                  
                                                       Safety Analysis Set
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                  A/B                        A/C                      B/C                    Total 
                                                (N=xx)                    (N=xx)                   (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
System Organ Class                       ----------------           ---------------            -----------------   ----------------
   Preferred Term                               n    (%)                  n    (%)                 n    (%)               n    (%)    
----------------------------------------   ---------------     
    ---------------            ---------------      
-------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE AE                   xx( x.x%)                  xx( x.x%)       
     
xx( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
BODY SYSTEM 1                                    x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                                    x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)         
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                                x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
...
===
=================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Note: AEs are coded by MedDRA Dictionary version 16.x.                                                                                                 
[1] Subjects were counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term.                                               
  System Organ Class and Preferred Terms listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.  


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 41 of 59
14.3.7
Subjects with Serious Adverse Events (Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.7 (Page 1 of 1)                                                     
Subjects with Serious Adverse Events [1]                  
                                                       Safety Analysis Set
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                  A/B                        A/C                      B/C                    Total 
                                                (N=xx)                    (N=xx)                   (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
System Organ Class                       ----------------           ---------------            -----------------   ----------------
   Preferred Term                               n    (%)                  n    (%)                 n    (%)               n    (%)    
----------------------------------------   ---------------     
    ---------------            ---------------      
-------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE AE                   xx( x.x%)                  xx( x.x%)       
     
xx( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
BODY SYSTEM 1                                    x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                                    x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)         
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                                x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
...
===
=================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Note: AEs are coded by MedDRA Dictionary version 16.x.                                                                                                
[1] Subjects were counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term.                                               
  System Organ Class and Preferred Terms listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.  


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 42 of 59
14.3.8
Subjects with Treatment-related Adverse Events Term (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.8 (Page 1 of x)                                                     
Subjects with Treatment-related* Adverse Events [1]                  
                                                       Safety Analysis Set
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                  A/B                        A/C                      B/C                    Total 
                                                (N=xx)                    (N=xx)                   (N=xx)               
(N=xx)  
System Organ Class                       ----------------           ---------------            -----------------   ----------------
   Preferred Term                               n    (%)                  n    (%)                 n    (%)               n    (%)    
----------------------------------------   ---------------     
    ---------------            ---------------      
-------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE TREATMENT-RELATED AE  xx( x.x%)                  xx( x.x%)       
     
xx( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
BODY SYSTEM 1                                    x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)        
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                                    x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)         
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                                x( x.x%)                   x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                                x( x.x%)                  x( x.x%)                x( x.x%)             xx (xx.x%)
  ...   
...
===
==================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Note: AEs are coded by MedDRA Dictionary version 16.x.                                                                                                 
*Treatment-related adverse events are AEs with relationship to study medication of very likely, probable, possible or unknown.                        
[1] Subjects were counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term.                                              
System Organ Class and Preferred Terms listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.  


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 43 of 59
14.3.9
Summary of Treatment-related Adverse Events by Severity (Safety Analysis Set)
                                                     Table 14.3.9 (Page 1 of x)                                                     
                                       Summary of Treatment-related Adverse Events* (TRAE) by Severity                                       
                                                         Safety Analysis Set                                                          
======================================================================================================================================
                                          A/B                                   A/C                                  B/C            
                                        (N=xx)                  
            (N=xx)                           (N=xx)           
                ------------------------            -----------------------------      ----------------------------
System Organ Class                 Mild     Moderate   Severe           Mild     Moderate   Severe       Mild      Moderate  Severe 
   Preferred Term                 n (%)      n (%)    
n (%)          n (%)     n (%)    
n (%)       n (%)      n (%)    
n (%)
------------------------------
------------------------------   
------------------------  --------
----------------------------
SUBJECTS WITH AT LEAST ONE TRAE xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)      xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)   xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)  xx( x.x%)
BODY SYSTEM 1                   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)       x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 1                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)       x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 2                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%)  
  x( x.x%)   x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%)
x( x.x%)   x( x.x%) 
x( x.x%)
  ...   
BODY SYSTEM 2                   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)      x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 3                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)       x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ADVERSE EVENT 4                x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)       x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)    x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)   x( x.x%)
  ...   
...
====
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%, Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
*Treatment-related adverse events are AEs with relationship to study medication of very likely, probable, possible or unknown.                        
Subjects are counted only once for each system organ class and preferred term by selecting the most severe event.          
Listed in descending order of frequency reported by all subjects within System Organ Class.                                
MedDRA Coding Dictionary version 18.0.                                                                                     


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 44 of 59
16.1.7
Randomization Schedule (All Randomized Subjects)
Listing 16.1.7 (Page 1 of x)
Randomization Schedule
All Randomized Subjects
====================================================================================================================================   
Randomization     Subject      Treatment             Treatment      Treatment                                        
Number              ID         Sequence      Eye       Code         Description                                       
---------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------   
001            xxxxxxxx        AB        Left     
  A        
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%       
                                           Right        B        
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
     …
====================================================================================================================================   


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 45 of 59
16.2.1.1
Subject Disposition Listing (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.1.1 (Page 1 of 3)
Subject Disposition Listing
All Randomized Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                                    Treatment         
                                                                                                            --------------------------
                           Intent-          Safety           Date             Study Completion/                Date          Date     
Treatment     Subject      to-Treat         Analysis       Completed/          Discontinuation                 First         Last     
Sequence        ID         Subjects          Set           Withdrew                Reason                      Use            Use      
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB       xxxxxxxx        Yes              Yes         14DEC2011           
COMPLETED                     21SEP2011     04OCT2011
     
...
                                                                                                                                
===
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 46 of 59
16.2.1.2
Discontinued Subjects (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.1.2 (Page 1 of 1)
                                                        Discontinued Subjects 
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                                                                                    Treatment         
                                                                                                            --------------------------
                           Intent-          Safety           Date             Study Completion/                Date          Date     
Treatment     Subject      to-Treat         Analysis       Completed/          Discontinuation                 First         Last     
Sequence        ID         Subjects          Set           Withdrew                Reason                      Use            Use      
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB       xxxxxxxx        Yes              Yes          14DEC2011           DISCONTINUED                  21SEP2011    04OCT2011
     
...
                                                                                                                                
===
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 47 of 59
16.2.2
Subjects with Protocol Deviations (All randomized Subjects)
Listing 16.2.2 (Page 1 of 1)
Subjects with Protocol Deviations
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
================================================================================================================================= 
Treatment                       Code of                                                Action                                    
Sequence          Subject ID   Deviation    Description of Deviations                 Taken Code            Comments                  
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB                xxxxxxxx     xxxxx        xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx                   xxxxxxxxx        xxxxxxxxxxxxxx           
                   xxxxxxxx     xxxxx        xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx                   xxxxxxxxx        xxxxxxxxxxxxxx           
                   xxxxxxxx     xxxxx        xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx                   xxxxxxxxx        xxxxxxxxxxxxxx           
                                                                                                                                   
      ...
                                                                                                                                   
====
===============================================================================================================   
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Protocol Deviation Code List                                                                                                         
1. Inclusion/Exclusion; 2. Investigational Product; 3. ConMeds; 4. Lab; 5. Visit Schedule; 6. Procedures/Tests; 7. Randomization;
8. Safety ; 9. Protocol Specific Discontinuation; 10. Non-Compliance; 11. Other      
Action Taken Code List:
  1. No action taken - minor deviation; 2. Subject discontinued; 3. Subject discontinued and replaced; 
  4. No action taken - subject completed the study; 5. Site re-trained; 6. Other.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 48 of 59
16.2.3
Subjects Excluded from the Primary Analysis (All randomized Subjects)
                                                     Listing 16.2.3 (Page 1 of 1)
                                              Subjects Excluded from the Primary Analysis
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
===============================================================================================================================
Treatment       Subject                                               Completed          Intent-to-treat            Primary
Sequence         ID            Reason for Exclusion                    Study?               Subjects              Analysis     
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB            xxxxxxxx           xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx                        xxx                  xxx                      xx
...
===
=============================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 49 of 59
16.2.4.1
Demographic and Baseline Characteristics (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.4.1 (Page 1 of 3)
                                               Demographic Characteristics
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
===============================================================================================================================
Treatment                    
          Date of                        
                                               
Sequence          Subject ID 
           Birth               Age      
     Sex          
Race            Ethnicity  
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB                 xxxxxxxx
          xxxx-xx-xx            xx       
     xxx            xxxxx           xxxxxxxxx  
                    xxxxxxxx
          xxxx-xx-xx            xx       
   
xxx            xxxxx           xxxxxxxxx  
                    xxxxxxxx
         xxxx-xx-xx            xx       
   
xxx            xxxxx           xxxxxxxxx
...
                              
                                         
                                               
================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 50 of 59
16.2.4.2
Medical History (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.4.2 (Page 1 of 3)
Medical History
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
===============================================================================================================================
Treatment                                     Term for                   Start            End             Medical History
Sequence            Subject ID             Medical History               Date           
Date                 Ongoing     
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB                   xxxxxxxx         
     xxxxxxxx                 xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx            No        
                     xxxxxxxx                xxxxxxxx                 xxxx-xx-xx        xxxx-xx-xx             No        
                     xxxxxxxx                xxxxxxxx                 xxxx-xx-xx        xxxx-xx-xx             No        
...
                                                                                                                               
================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 51 of 59
16.2.4.3
Prior and Concomitant Medications (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.4.3 (Page 1 of 3)
Prior and Concomitant Medications
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
================================================================================================================================
Treatment                                     Name of                             Start               End             Medication
Sequence            Subject ID               Medication       Indication          Date              
Date              Ongoing     
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB                   xxxxxxxx         
     xxxxxxxx        xxxxxxxx          xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx            No        
                     xxxxxxxx                xxxxxxxx         xxxxxxxx          xxxx-xx-xx        xxxx-xx-xx             No        
                     xxxxxxxx                xxxxxxxx         xxxxxxxx          xxxx-xx-xx        xxxx-xx-xx             No        
...
                                                                                                                               
================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 52 of 59
16.2.4.4
Prior and Concomitant Non-Drug Therapy / Procedure (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.4.4 (Page 1 of 3)
Prior and Concomitant Non-Drug Therapy / Procedure
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
================================================================================================================================
Treatment                                  Name of Non-Drug                      Start               End             Medication
Sequence            Subject ID            Therapy / Procedure                    Date              
Date              Ongoing     
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB                   xxxxxxxx         
     xxxxxxxx                         xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx            No        
                     xxxxxxxx                xxxxxxxx                         xxxx-xx-xx        xxxx-xx-xx             No        
                     xxxxxxxx                xxxxxxxx                         xxxx-xx-xx        xxxx-xx-xx             No        
...
                                                                                                                               
================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 53 of 59
16.2.6.1
Ocular Redness Assessment (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.6.1 (Page 1 of 3)
Ocular Redness Assessment
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
=================================================================================================================================
Treatment                Assessment  Right                   Redness    Reduction from               Start              End
Sequence   Subject ID    Time Point   Eye       Treatment   Assessment     Baseline    Responder?   
Date        
  Date      
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB          xxxxxxxx       0s        Right        A           2.5                                 xxxx-xx-xx      xxxx-xx-xx  
            xxxxxxxx      0s       
Left          B            2.0                                 xxxx-xx-xx      xxxx-xx-xx    
            xxxxxxxx      30s       
Right         A            1.0          1.5          Yes       xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx    
            xxxxxxxx      30s       
Left          B            1.0          1.0          Yes       xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx    
...
                                                                                                                               
=================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Assessment time point: 
0s = Pre-Treatment prior to the first product application (Baseline),
30s = 30 seconds after the first product application,
60s = 60 seconds after the first product application,
120s = 2 minutes after the first product application.
Redness Assessment: 0 = None, 1 = Mild, 2= Moderate, 3 = Severe, 4 = Extremely Severe.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 54 of 59
16.2.6.2
Ocular Comfort Assessment (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.6.2 (Page 1 of 3)
Ocular Comfort Assessment
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
=================================================================================================================================
Treatment                Assessment  Right                   Comfort    Reduction from                Start              End
Sequence   Subject ID    Time Point   Eye       Treatment   Assessment     Baseline                  
Date             Date      
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB          xxxxxxxx       0s        Right        A            2.5                                 xxxx-xx-xx      xxxx-xx-xx  
            xxxxxxxx       0s       
Left          B            2.0                                 xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx    
            xxxxxxxx      60s       
Right         A            1.0          1.5                    xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx    
            xxxxxxxx      60s       
Left          B            1.0          1.0                    xxxx-xx-xx       xxxx-xx-xx    
...
                                                                                                                               
=================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Assessment time point: 
0s = Pre-Treatment prior to the first product application (Baseline),
60s = Following the 60 second ocular Redness Assessment;
10h = 10 hours after the 1st product application,
12h = 12 hours after the 1st product application.
Comfort Assessment: 0 = Very Uncomfortable, 10 = Very Comfortable.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 55 of 59
16.2.6.3
Subject Questionnaire (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.6.3 (Page 1 of 3)
Subject Questionnaire
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
====================================================================================================================================
Treatment                                                       Assessment  Right               Answer to       Start       End
Sequence   Subject ID  Questions                 
    
  
  Time Point   Eye    Treatment   Question        Date        Date  
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB          xxxxxxxx
My eye appears healthy                    0s      Right     A            2     
xxxx-xx-xx 
xxxx-xx-xx
                                               
    
  
     0s       Left      B            2      xxxx-xx-xx
xxxx-xx-xx
                                               
    
  
    2m       Right     A            1      xxxx-xx-xx
xxxx-xx-xx
                                               
    
  
    2m       Left      B            1      xxxx-xx-xx
xxxx-xx-xx
...
                                                                                                                                 
======================================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Assessment time point: 
0s = Pre-Treatment prior to the first product application (Baseline),
2m = Following the 2-minute ocular Redness Assessment;
10h = 10 hours after the 1st product application,
12h = 12 hours after the 1st product application.
Answer: 1 = Strongly Disagree, 2 = Somewhat Disagree, 3 = Neither Agree or Disagree, 4 = Somewhat Agree, 5 = Strongly Agree, 9 = I 
don’t have an Opinion.


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 56 of 59
16.2.7.1
Subjects with Adverse Events (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.7.1 (Page 1 of 1)
                                                        Subjects with Adverse Events
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                       
                                                       Med  
Treatment  Subject  Age
     AE                      
Date/Time
Date/Time                                 Given  Serious
Sequence     ID    (Yr) Race TEXT     Preferred Term 
  Started    Ended       Freq. Sev.  Outcm  Rel Action  Yes/No  Yes/No
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB        xxxxxx  18    W
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxx     
13NOV2011 18NOV2011     1      1   1      0     1       Yes    No
                                    
xxxxxxxxxx     
13NOV2011 18NOV2011     1      2  
1      0     1       Yes    No
===
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Race: W=WHITE, B=BLACK OR AFRICAN AMERICAN, A=ASIAN, N=NATIVE HAWAIIAN OR OTHER PACIFIC ISLANDER, AI=AMERICAN INDIAN OR ALASKA        
      NATIVE, O=OTHER                                                                                                                 
Freq. (Frequency): 1=SINGLE EPISODE, 2=INTERMITTENT                                                                                   
Sev. (Severity): 1=MILD, 2=MODERATE, 3=SEVERE                                                                                         
Outcm (Outcome): 1=RECOVERED/RESOLVED, 2=NOT RECOVERED/NOT RESOLVED, 3=FATAL, 4=RECOVERED/RESOLVED WITH SEQUELAE,                     
                 5=RECOVERING/RESOLVING, 96=UNKNOWN                                                                                   
Rel. (Relationship to study drug): 0=NOT RELATED, 11=DOUBTFUL, 12=POSSIBLE, 13=PROBABLE, 14=VERY LIKELY                               
Action (Action taken with investigational product): 1=NOT CHANGED, 2=REDUCED, 3=INTERRUPTED, 4=WITHDRAWN, 5=INCREASED, 96=UNKNOWN,    
                                                    98=NOT APPLICABLE                                                                 


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 57 of 59
16.2.7.2
Subjects with Serious Adverse Events (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.7.2 (Page 1 of 1)
                                                  Subjects with Serious Adverse Events
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
======================================================================================================================================
                                                        
                                                         Med  
Treatment Subject  Age
     AE                       
  Date/Time
Date/Time                                 Given  Serious
Sequence   ID       (Yr) Race TEXT     Preferred Term 
   Started    Ended       Freq. Sev.  Outcm  Rel Action  Yes/No  Yes/No
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB     xxxxxx  18    W
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxx      
  13NOV2011 18NOV2011     1      1   1      0     1       Yes    No
                                    
xxxxxxxxxx      
  13NOV2011 18NOV2011     1      2  
1      0     1       Yes    No
====
====================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Race: W=WHITE, B=BLACK OR AFRICAN AMERICAN, A=ASIAN, N=NATIVE HAWAIIAN OR OTHER PACIFIC ISLANDER, AI=AMERICAN INDIAN OR ALASKA        
      NATIVE, O=OTHER                                                                                                                 
Freq. (Frequency): 1=SINGLE EPISODE, 2=INTERMITTENT                                                                                   
Sev. (Severity): 1=MILD, 2=MODERATE, 3=SEVERE                                                                                         
Outcm (Outcome): 1=RECOVERED/RESOLVED, 2=NOT RECOVERED/NOT RESOLVED, 3=FATAL, 4=RECOVERED/RESOLVED WITH SEQUELAE,                     
                 5=RECOVERING/RESOLVING, 96=UNKNOWN                                                                                   
Rel. (Relationship to study drug): 0=NOT RELATED, 11=DOUBTFUL, 12=POSSIBLE, 13=PROBABLE, 14=VERY LIKELY                               
Action (Action taken with investigational product): 1=NOT CHANGED, 2=REDUCED, 3=INTERRUPTED, 4=WITHDRAWN, 5=INCREASED, 96=UNKNOWN,    
                                                    98=NOT APPLICABLE                                                                 


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 58 of 59
16.2.7.3
Subjects Withdrawn from Investigational Product due to Adverse Events (All randomized Subjects)
                                                    Listing 16.2.7.3 (Page 1 of 1)
Subjects Withdrawn from Investigational Product due to Adverse Events
                                                       All Randomized Subjects
=====================================================================================================================================
                                                       
                                                         Med  
Treatment Subject  Age
     AE                        
  Date/Time
Date/Time                                 Given  Serious
Sequence  ID       (Yr) Race TEXT     Preferred Term 
   Started    Ended       Freq. Sev.  Outcm  Rel Action  Yes/No  Yes/No
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AB       xxxxxx  18    W
xxxxxxxx
xxxxxxxxxx       
  13NOV2011 18NOV2011     1      1   1      0     1       Yes    No
                                   
xxxxxxxxxx       
  13NOV2011 18NOV2011     1      2  
1      0     1       Yes    No
====
===================================================================================================================
A: 
, Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%
B: 
e 0.05%, Glycerin 0.40%
C: Tetrahydrozoline 0.05%, Glycerin 0.20%. Hypromellose 0.2%, Polyethylene glycol 400 1.0%
Race: W=WHITE, B=BLACK OR AFRICAN AMERICAN, A=ASIAN, N=NATIVE HAWAIIAN OR OTHER PACIFIC ISLANDER, AI=AMERICAN INDIAN OR ALASKA        
      NATIVE, O=OTHER                                                                                                                 
Freq. (Frequency): 1=SINGLE EPISODE, 2=INTERMITTENT                                                                                   
Sev. (Severity): 1=MILD, 2=MODERATE, 3=SEVERE                                                                                         
Outcm (Outcome): 1=RECOVERED/RESOLVED, 2=NOT RECOVERED/NOT RESOLVED, 3=FATAL, 4=RECOVERED/RESOLVED WITH SEQUELAE,                     
                 5=RECOVERING/RESOLVING, 96=UNKNOWN                                                                                   
Rel. (Relationship to study drug): 0=NOT RELATED, 11=DOUBTFUL, 12=POSSIBLE, 13=PROBABLE, 14=VERY LIKELY                              
Action (Action taken with investigational product): 1=NOT CHANGED, 2=REDUCED, 3=INTERRUPTED, 4=WITHDRAWN, 5=INCREASED, 96=UNKNOWN,    
                                                    98=NOT APPLICABLE                                                                 


Protocol CO-161103095739-VCCT
Mockup Tables
Company Confidential
Page 59 of 59
16.2.7.4
Listing of MedDRA Preferred Terms for Adverse Events (All randomized Subjects)
                                                  Data Listing 16.2.7.4 (Page 1 of x)                                                    
                                         Listing of MedDRA Preferred Terms for Adverse Events                                         
                                                       All Randomized Subjects                                                        
===================================================================================================================================== 
System Organ Class                       Preferred Term                           AE Text                                  Subject ID 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SOC1                                     PT1                                     xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
SOC2                                     PT2                                     xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
                                                                                 xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
                                         PT3                                     xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
                                         PT4                                     xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
                                                                                 xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
                                                                                 xxxxxxx                                   xxxxxxxx
                                                                                                                           xxxxxxxx
                                                                                                                           xxxxxxxx
                                                                                                                           xxxxxxxx
                                                                                                                           xxxxxxxx
=====================================================================================================================================