Conditions: Short Stature
Allocation: NA | Intervention model: SINGLE_GROUP
Enrollment: 22
Healthy volunteers: no

Brief summary:
This is an open-label, single-arm prospective pilot study to study the effects of a single dose regimen of daily growth hormone medication (Norditropin) on pre-pubertal children with Aggrecan deficiency. The growth response will be tracked over a 12 month period. A protocol extension has been approved to continue subjects on treatment for an additional 2 years.

Detailed description:
This is a single center study. All participants will be recruited from the USA. The study intends to recruit pre-pubertal children for inclusion in the 1 year growth hormone treatment trial. The study also plans to collect the following detailed phenotypic data at the first study visit: height, weight, musculoskeletal evaluation, photographs, radiographs (knees, left hand), MRI of the knees. The participants will be required to return to Cincinnati Childrens Hospital Medical Center (CCHMC) for 3 study visits over the 12 month period. At the follow up visits participants will receive a routine physical/pubertal exam, joint exam, have vitals sign checked, height/weight taken, and labs drawn. A funduscopic exam will be performed to look for signs of intracranial pressure. Study participants are also required to complete phone check ins at scheduled intervals, and a locally drawn blood sample to check insulin-like growth factor (IGF1) levels approximately 3 months after treatment start date. Concomitant medications, adverse events will be recorded and updated at all study visits and phone check ins. Medication will be resupplied and shipped to the participant as needed at every point of follow up contact. If the subjects grow well enough in the first 12 months per study protocol, they are eligible to continue treatment through the study for an additional 2 years. They will continue to come to CCHMC every 6 months for follow up study visits. Study procedures will remain the same as the initial 1 year trial with the following additions: (1) local labs may need to be obtained for dose adjustment purposes, (2) repeat knee MRI may be completed for participants that are found to have early signs of joint disease on their baseline knee MRI scan.

The study will enroll interested and affected relatives of the participant in the joint phenotyping protocol as well. These participants will come to CCHMC only one time to complete the phenotyping visit. This is not an outcome of the study but the information gathered from the imaging will provide insight into the effects of ACAN mutation on the joint cartilage.

Arms:
arm 1: Pre-pubertal children with ACAN deficiency on daily growth hormone (Norditropin) regimen for a 3 year period.

Interventions: intervention 1: Norditropin
Intervention descriptions: intervention 1: Single dose of daily growth hormone regimen. Dose will be 50 micrograms/kg/day.

Protocol document:
Prot_SAP_000.pdf: 
Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
1
 Clinical Characterization and Trial of Growth Hormone 
Treatment in Patients with Aggrecan Deficiency
Extension Trial Version
INVESTIGATOR-SPONSORED STUDY PROPOSAL
UNIVERSAL TRIAL NUMBER (UTN) U1111-1192-2334
Division of Endocrinology
Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center
3333 Burnet Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45229-3039
Correspondence to:
Philippe Backeljauw, MD 
Professor, Cincinnati Center for Growth Disorders
Division of Endocrinology, Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center (CCHMC)
3333 Burnet Ave, MLC 7012
Cincinnati, OH 45229-3039
Telephone: 513-636-2759
Fax: 513-803-1174
Email: philippe.backeljauw@cchmc.org


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
2
Table of Contents
1. Title Page
1
2. Table of Contents
2
3. Background and Significance
             3-4
4. Specific Objectives
4
5. Research Design and Methods
4-13
6. Extension Trial                                                                                                         14-16
7. Regulatory Considerations
             17
8. Risk/Benefits
17-18
9. Adverse Events
18-21
10. Compensation
21-22
11. Statistical Considerations
22
12. Data Handling and Record Keeping
             22
13. Ethics
22-23
14. Liability and Subjects Insurance
23
15. Publication Plan
23
16. Study Timeline
23
17. Study Team
23-24
18. References 
24-25


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
3
3. BACKGROUND AND SIGNIFICANCE
Short stature is the most common reason for referral to a pediatric endocrinologist 
outside of diabetes mellitus. Current guidelines suggest performing a comprehensive 
evaluation of children with short stature to assess for potentially treatable conditions. 
As part of that evaluation, children typically undergo biochemical and hormonal testing. 
Most clinicians will obtain a bone age x-ray also. Despite a comprehensive evaluation, 
many children end up diagnosed as having idiopathic short stature (ISS). In the United 
States, growth hormone (GH) is approved for the indication of ISS although many 
insurance companies do not cover GH for ISS. The response to treatment in this group of 
patients is variable likely due to the heterogeneity in the true etiology of the patient’s 
short stature. 
In recent years, advances in genetic analyses have allowed us to begin to dissect the 
molecular etiology for short stature and re-characterize certain patients who previously 
would have been diagnosed with ISS. Our Growth Center has led some of these efforts, 
and we have established numerous novel genetic etiologies for short stature. In 2014, 
we described three families in which multiple members were affected by short stature 
with advanced bone age and premature growth cessation1. Using whole exome 
sequencing, we found that all three families had novel heterozygous mutations in the 
aggrecan gene (ACAN). Prior to this report, there had been three families in the world 
ever described with mutations in ACAN, each with a unique skeletal dysplasia. Our 
report broadened the phenotypic spectrum of ACAN deficiency and alerted the pediatric 
endocrinology community to this new patient population marked by short stature with 
advanced bone age, for whom ACAN testing is indicated. 
Aggrecan, the protein encoded by the ACAN gene, is a critical proteoglycan component 
of the cartilage matrix, both in articular and growth plate cartilage, thus accounting for 
the dual phenotypic effects on both these types of cartilage. Consistent with this, 
homozygous mutations in ACAN in both mice and chicks severely disrupt growth plate 
function and impair bone elongation 2,3. In both species, chondrocytes are tightly 
packed, with little intervening matrix. In chicks, there is evidence for abnormal Indian 
hedgehog, fibroblast growth factor, and bone morphogenetic protein signaling, leading 
to premature hypertrophic chondrocyte maturation2. Because hypertrophic 
differentiation induces vascular invasion and ossification of growth cartilage4, these 
findings provide a likely explanation for the advanced bone age, premature growth 
cessation, and early epiphyseal fusion observed in individuals with ACAN mutations.
We published a follow up report describing 103 individuals from 20 families with 
confirmed mutations in ACAN5. This report describes more detailed clinical 
characterization of these patients. It notes some important features including a degree 
of subtle skeletal disproportion in many of the patients, as well as the presence of joint 
disease in 12 of the 20 families. We also described the growth pattern of patients with 
ACAN deficiency and note that there is progressive deterioration in the height standard 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
4
deviation score (SDS) because of the bone age advancement and premature epiphyseal 
fusion. Most relevant to the current ongoing trial, we described the response to GH 
treatment in 14 children treated with GH for at least 12 months. The average gain in 
height SDS was +0.4 after one year of treatment. 
While this recent report is quite helpful to the practicing clinician, there are several key 
limitations. First, the patients were all assessed by different physicians at different 
centers. Second, the patients were treated with different GH regimens and six subjects 
were treated with either a gonadotropin releasing hormone (GnRH) analog or 
aromatase inhibitor (AI) in addition to GH. Third, all the data was collected via a 
retrospective chart review and thus is less reliable than prospectively collected research 
grade data. Finally, there was no standardized formal assessment of joint disease or the 
effects of GH on musculoskeletal complaints. 
Given these limitations, we first proposed to perform a prospective one-year trial of GH 
therapy in pre-pubertal children (n=10) with documented mutations in ACAN. The 
purpose of the study was to accurately document the change in growth parameters in 
patients with ACAN mutations receiving GH therapy. Additionally, we performed 
standardized phenotyping of those patients as well as their affected family members to 
allow for a better understanding of the degree of joint involvement in this disorder as 
well as to gain insights into the underlying joint pathophysiology. 
4. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
Primary Objective:

Describe the effects of one year of GH therapy on growth parameters in pre-
pubertal children with ACAN deficiency, followed by describing the effects of 
continued treatment for another two years provided the objectives for the first year 
of GH therapy have been reached.
Secondary Objective:

Describe additional clinical features of ACAN deficiency, in particular the degree of 
joint involvement, in the affected children and their affected first-degree relatives. 
5. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS
Study Hypotheses:
1. Treatment with GH therapy will increase growth velocity in children with ACAN 
deficiency. 
2. Early joint pathology will be evident on MRI examination of affected subject’s 
knees and will provide insights into the underlying joint pathophysiology present 
in ACAN deficiency. 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
5
Endpoints:
A. Primary Outcome – Change in height SDS from baseline to 12 months.
B. Secondary Outcomes
a. Height velocity in cm/year calculated over 12 months of trial.
b. Change in height velocity. Baseline height velocity will be based on 
review of the medical records using the documented height closest to 12 
months prior to the screening visit. 
c.
Change in bone age divided by change in chronological age.
d. Change in whole body bone mineral density adjusted for height.
e. Frequency of adverse events as defined below
f.
Frequency of joint complaints using measures described below.
g. Frequency of cartilage disease based on MRI evaluation of the knee as 
described below. 
Study type
This is an open-label single arm prospective study examining the effects of a single 
dosing regimen of daily GH on growth response over a 12 month –followed by a four-
year extension period in children with ACAN deficiency. The projected dose of GH that 
will be used is 50 micrograms/kg/day. This dose was initially chosen as it is within the 
approved range for Norditropin® for non-GH deficient states, including Turner 
Syndrome and Noonan Syndrome. Additionally, a parallel phenotyping study was done 
in affected first degree relatives of the subject. 
We have elected not to have a control arm for two reasons. First, our preliminary 
retrospective data suggests that GH does increase HV in patients with ACAN deficiency. 
Additionally, the retrospective data show that patient’s height SDS score will decline 
over time without intervention. Thus, patients and their families are highly motivated to 
pursue GH therapy and are unlikely to consent to be part of a study which includes a 
control arm. Near one-hundred percent compliance (limited missed daily GH injections) 
and persistence with the protocol has been observed in our cohort so far for patients at 
least one year on therapy and as long as 30 months. Second, this is a rare disorder, and 
we did not think it is feasible to recruit sufficient numbers of patients in a reasonable 
time frame to conduct an adequately powered randomized controlled trial. 
. 
Study population
This study intended to recruit 10 subjects with ACAN mutations for inclusion in the GH 
treatment trial. We estimated that there could be an additional 20 affected first degree 
relatives who would participate in the joint phenotyping part of the study. These 
patients were recruited within the projected timeframe of 18 months. All subjects 
referred to this study will already have an identified mutation in ACAN; thus, we did not 
anticipate screen failures. This is a single-center study. All patients recruited live 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
6
throughout the United States (US). No subjects outside of the US were included in this 
study. 
We did not require that subjects GH underwent stimulation testing to participate in this 
study. Subjects included in this study have a clear pathological mutation in ACAN 
explaining their short stature. Prior to the availability of this genetic test result, these 
individuals would have been diagnosed with ISS (or familial short stature). ACAN 
deficiency is a mild skeletal dysplasia similar to SHOX deficiency. There is no known (or 
even theoretical) link between ACAN deficiency and the possibility of GH deficiency. We 
do not think there is any rationale for exposing patients to the burdens of GH 
stimulation testing when an ACAN mutation has been identified as the cause of the 
short stature. However, to ensure that we did not include patients who may also have 
GH deficiency, we will only include patients with a normal IGF-I level for age and gender 
at the time of screening. 
Inclusion Criteria
1. ACAN Deficiency – Patients must be heterozygous for a mutation in the ACAN gene. 
A mutation will be defined as: 
a. A heterozygous deletion of the entire gene or of >1 complete exons of the 
gene
b. Any truncating mutation including frameshift, nonsense, splice site mutations 
within 2 bases of the exon/intron boundary and start loss variants.
c.
Any missense mutation which meets the following criteria:
i. It is absent in the Exome Aggregation Consortium Database 
(exac.broadinstitute.org)
ii. It is predicted to be damaging by BOTH Polyphen2 and SIFT
iii. It segregates with the short stature phenotype in the family or is a de 
novo mutation.
d. In-frame insertions or deletions of >1 amino acid
e. In-frame insertions or deletions of 1 amino acid must meet the same criteria 
as missense mutations. For the prediction programs, Alanine will be 
substituted for the deleted amino acid.
f.
NOTE – Retrospective data does not show any correlation between the type 
of mutation and the severity of short stature. Therefore, all mutations 
meeting the above criteria will be included as a single group. 
2. Age – Greater than or equal to 2 years 0 days. There is no upper age limit as the 
onset of puberty prior to treatment start will make the patient ineligible. 
3. Pre-pubertal
a. Male subjects must have a testicular volume <4 cc as determined on physical 
examination by a pediatric endocrinologist at the time of the screening visit.
b. Female subjects must be Tanner 1 for breast development as determined on 
physical examination by a pediatric endocrinologist at the time of the 
screening visit.


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
7
4. Bone Age – The bone age as determined by the Greulich and Pyle method must be 
equal or greater than the chronological age. Bone ages will be determined at the 
screening visit by a single centralized radiologist. 
5. IGF-I concentration level within the normal range for age and gender.
6. Ability to provide informed consent before any trial-related activities.
7. NOTE – There is no specific height standard deviation criteria for inclusion in this 
study. We are explicitly including patients with heights above -2.25 SDS. The reason 
for this is that our prior work shows that patients with ACAN deficiency have a 
progressive decline in height SDS due to premature growth cessation. We have 
documented numerous cases where individuals were initially identified with height 
above this threshold at a younger age and then subsequently end up severely short 
as they cease growing at an early age. Therefore, we do not think it is rational to 
apply the idiopathic short stature threshold to this specific population. 
Exclusion Criteria
1. Prior treatment with any of the following therapies:
A. Growth hormone
B. IGF-I
C. GnRH analog
D. Aromatase Inhibitor
E. Oxandrolone
2. History of any type of malignancy
3. Growth plate fusion – Defined as a bone age via the Greulich and Pyle method of 13 
years in females and 15 years in males.
4. Chronic medical condition known to affect growth including but not limited to:
A. Cystic fibrosis
B. Diabetes
C. Inflammatory Bowel Disease
D. Celiac Disease
E. Asthma requiring a daily inhaled steroid dose > 400 micrograms of inhaled 
budesonide per day or equivalent.
F. Taking daily oral glucocorticoids for any reason
G. Note – ADHD treated with a stimulant and treated hypothyroidism with a 
normal TSH will NOT exclude the subject from participating in the trial. 
5. Malnutrition – Defined as a BMI <5th percentile (CDC growth charts)  
6. Any clinically significant abnormality on screening laboratory tests as determined by 
the principal investigator.
7. Known or suspected allergy to trial medication, excipients, or related products.
8. Contraindications to study medications, worded specifically as stated in the 
product’s prescribing information.  
9. The receipt of any investigational drug within 90 days prior to this trial.


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
8
Withdrawal Criteria
The subject may withdraw at will at any time. The subject will be withdrawn if she 
becomes pregnant or intends to become pregnant. This should not be an issue as all 
subjects are pre-pubertal at onset of the trial. 
Subject Replacement
If a subject is withdrawn from the study at any point, an additional subject will be 
recruited to meet our goal of 10 subjects completing 1 year of the study. 
Rationale for Study Population
If a subject is withdrawn from the study at any point, an additional subject will be 
recruited to meet our goal of 10 subjects completing one year of the study. This has 
been reached. Any future drop out from the study will not be replaced by new 
recruitment as all 10 subjects are past the one-year treatment mark. 
Subject Recruitment/Consent
Potential subjects will be identified through several different recruitment modalities. 
First, all eligible patients who participated in the Growth Center’s prior retrospective 
study, ‘Uncovering the Genetic Basis for Growth Disorders’, will be contacted directly by 
Dr. Philippe Backeljauw or by Dr. Andrew Dauber. Second, the Growth Center continues 
to receive inquiries about the treatment of ACAN deficiency from endocrinologists and 
geneticists with new patients being diagnosed on a weekly basis. With each new 
contact, a member of the study staff will inform the physician about the trial and will 
provide a study brochure to be shared with the patients. Third, the study will be 
publicized online in a number of forums. In addition to posting the trial on 
clinicaltrials.gov, it will be posted on the Cincinnati Center for Growth Disorders 
research website, the CCHMC online trial posting, as well as on the Pediatric Endocrine 
Society site. Fourth, Dr. Backeljauw and Dr. Dauber will contact the most prominent 
genetics diagnostics labs in the United States who are performing ACAN testing and ask 
them to inform patients with ACAN mutations about the trial. Dr. Dauber already has an 
arrangement in place with GeneDx for research referrals for patients with ACAN 
mutations. 
Once a potential subject is identified, the research team will contact the subject and 
provide them information about the trial. All subjects’ will have their mutations 
confirmed in either the Cincinnati Center for Growth Disorders Lab or the Center for 
Genetic Medicine Research Lab at Children’s National Medical Center. All first-degree 
relatives will be tested for the presence of the mutation. The genetic testing will be 
performed as part of a separate approved genetics protocol already in place at CCHMC. 
Potentially eligible subjects will be mailed/emailed a copy of the consent for review. The 
study team will be available by telephone to answer any questions about the protocol. 
Interested subjects will be brought to CCHMC for a screening visit. At the time of the 
screening visit, the consent will be re-reviewed with the subject and the appropriate 
family members. Written informed consent will be obtained from all eligible subjects 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
9
and appropriate family members (see below, section on Phenotyping protocol for family 
member eligibility). Written assent will be obtained for all subjects aged 11 years or 
older. Written consent will be obtained from a parent for children under age 11. 
Children under age 11 will not be required to provide written assent as per CCHMC IRB 
regulations. 
Additional informed consent and assent will be obtained from all subjects meeting the 
criteria for continuation of GH therapy for an additional two years who agree to 
participate in the ‘extension trial’.
Growth Hormone Trial Procedures (Year 1 Table 1)
A. Screening visit – The subject will undergo a routine physical examination 
including a focused joint exam (inspection of the hip joints, checking for scoliosis) 
and pubertal staging performed by a pediatric endocrinologist. Vital signs will be 
obtained. Weight will be measured on a digital scale. Height will be measured in 
triplicate on a standing stadiometer which is calibrated daily. The average of the 
three measurements will be used. A medical history will be obtained, and a 
detailed family history will be obtained with specific attention to growth and 
joint issues. A pedigree will be drawn. A funduscopic exam will be performed. 
Photographs will be taken of the subject. Screening labs will be performed as 
detailed in Table 1. A bone age x-ray and DXA scan (whole body and lumbar 
spine) will be obtained in addition to the joint phenotyping visit procedures. The 
subject and family members will receive education about the administration of 
GH from a qualified nurse. The GH dose of 50 micrograms/kg/day will be 
calculated based on the weight. Medication will not be provided at the visit as 
screening labs will be pending. We anticipate a near 100% screen positive rate 
given that subjects will have been pre-screened for eligibility and it will be very 
unusual for the subjects to have a laboratory abnormality which would disqualify 
them. All screening lab tests will be performed at the CCHMC clinical 
laboratories.
B. GH initiation – If the subject passes screening, a supply of GH therapy will be 
shipped to the subject from the study coordinator. The supply amount will be 
determined by what is needed for the 3 months +/- 2-week window until the 
next check-in/visit to ensure that subjects do not run out of medication. Receipt 
of GH will be confirmed via telephone call and the date of GH initiation will be 
recorded. A log will be provided to the subject to record daily compliance for the 
first year of treatment with GH.
C. 1-week telephone call – A telephone call will be made at 1 week (+/- 2 days) to 
review GH administration and address any issues with medication 
administration. 
D. 3-month telephone call and remote lab draw – A telephone call will be made at 3 
months (+/- 2 weeks) to review compliance and assess for any adverse events 
that may not have been previously reported (See Adverse Event reporting 
section). After successful completion of this call, an additional 3 month +/- 2-


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
10
week supply of GH will be shipped to the subject. A lab slip will be provided for 
measurement of IGF-1 level at a local lab. This value is only being used as a 
safety measure and not as an efficacy outcome measure and thus will not be 
centralized. It will logistically not be possible to centralize this sample. 
E. 6-month visit – The subject will return to CCHMC 6 months (+/- 2 weeks) after 
initiation of GH therapy for a repeat visit. The subject will undergo a routine 
physical examination including a focused joint exam (inspection of the hip joints, 
checking for scoliosis) and pubertal staging performed by a pediatric 
endocrinologist. Vital signs will be obtained. Weight will be measured on a digital 
scale. Height will be measured in triplicate on a standing stadiometer which is 
calibrated daily. The average of the three measurements will be used. A 
funduscopic exam will be performed. Labs will be performed as detailed in Table 
1. The compliance log will be reviewed, and the subject will be assessed for any 
adverse events that may not have been previously reported. The dose of GH will 
be weight adjusted to maintain a dose of 50 micrograms/kg/day.  An additional 3 
month +/- 2-week supply of GH will be provided to the subject.
F. 9-month telephone call – A telephone call will be made at 9 months (+/- 2 
weeks) to review compliance and assess for any adverse events that may not 
have been previously reported (See Adverse Event reporting section). After 
successful completion of this call, an additional 3 month +/- 2-week supply of GH 
will be shipped to the subject. 
12-month visit - The subject will return to CCHMC 12 months (+/- 2 weeks) after 
initiation of GH therapy for a repeat visit. The subject will undergo a routine 
physical examination including a focused joint exam (inspection of the hip joints, 
checking for scoliosis) and pubertal staging performed by a pediatric 
endocrinologist. Vital signs will be obtained. Weight will be measured on a digital 
scale. Height will be measured in triplicate on a standing stadiometer which is 
calibrated daily. The average of the three measurements will be used. A 
funduscopic exam will be performed. Labs will be performed as detailed in Table 
1. 
Table 1: Lab and Assessment Schedule for treatment year 1
Lab/Assessment
Screening 
Visit
3-month 
TC/remote 
lab visit
6-month 
visit
9-month 
TC
12-month 
visit
Physical Exam
X
X
X
Vital Signs
X
X
X
Weight
X
X
X
Height
X
X
X
CBC
X
Renal Panel
X
Hepatic Function Panel
X
TSH
X
X
X
Free T4
X
X
X


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
11
IGF-1
X
X
X
X
IGFBP-3
X
X
X
Photographs
X
Bone Age X-ray
X
X
Musculoskeletal Exam
X
DXA scan (whole body and 
lumbar spine)
X
X
IKDC Knee Score
X
QOL Survey
X
Physical Activity Assessment 
(Marx)
X
Oswestry back survey
X
Compliance Review
X
X
X
X
Adverse Event Review
X
X
X
X
MRI
X
Knee X-rays
X
After each in-person study visit, we will send a letter summarizing the exam findings and 
lab results to the participant’s local primary care physician and/or pediatric 
endocrinologist. 
Stopping Rules and Dose Reduction Criteria
The treatment portion of the trial will be discontinued for an individual subject if he or 
she develops a serious adverse drug reaction (as defined below). The treatment trial 
may otherwise be discontinued if the subject withdraws consent or if the PI determines 
that the subject is no longer eligible to continue treatment. 
The dose of GH will be adjusted based on weight at study visits. It will not be increased 
or decreased based on efficacy (or lack thereof) with the following exceptions: at the 3, 
6, 18 month and any added remote lab draw, if the IGF-I exceeds +2.5 SD, the GH dose 
will be reduced. Reductions will be 10%- 20% at the discretion of the PI, depending on 
the extent of IGF-I elevation. In the unlikely event that the IGF-I remains above the +2.5 
SD mark at the next check, the dose will be further decreased by either 10%-20% and an 
additional IGF-I level will be checked at the PI’s discretion. 
Joint Phenotyping Procedures for Subjects and Relatives
The goals of the joint phenotyping protocol are twofold. First, we would like to 
comprehensively assess the prevalence of joint complaints in this patient population 
with specific focus on the knee joint. Second, we would like to examine the early 
radiological manifestations of joint disease in these patients by using a cartilage-focused 
MRI without contrast protocol at the knee. These imaging studies will provide insights 
into the pathological effects of mutations in ACAN on joint cartilage. Once arthritis is 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
12
advanced, the MRI findings will no longer be specific or instructive, so we will only 
perform MRI assessments in individuals under age 20 years. 
We are focusing our investigations on the knee joint for two reasons. First, retrospective 
data show that the knee joint is the most commonly involved joint in ACAN deficiency 
associated arthritis5. Second, the other joint(s) with significant pathology in ACAN 
deficiency are the intervertebral joints in the back. These joints have many normal 
variants on MRI imaging, and we think it will be difficult to determine which MRI 
findings represent true pathology versus normal variation. We will perform a thorough 
musculoskeletal evaluation through physical examination (for those who are able to do 
the assessment based on age and/or ability) and questionnaires which will include all 
joints (see below). We believe that MRI examination of the knee is most likely to provide 
insights into the pathophysiology of ACAN associated joint disease.  
All first-degree relatives will be screened for the ACAN mutation identified in the 
primary subject in the family. More distant relatives will be offered inclusion in the 
study at the discretion of the subjects’ parents and Dr. Backeljauw. This genetic testing 
will be performed as part of a separate genetics protocol. Any family member identified 
to carry the same mutation as the primary subject will be eligible for inclusion in the 
phenotyping protocol. If a family member meets inclusion criteria for the GH treatment 
trial, they also will be offered the option of enrolling in the treatment trial. Eligible 
family members will come to CCHMC for a single research visit where they will undergo 
a detailed phenotypic evaluation as detailed below. This evaluation will be scheduled to 
coincide with one of the primary subject’s research visits. We estimate that each subject 
will have one affected parent and one affected individual giving us a potential total of 30 
affected individuals undergoing joint phenotyping (~20 of whom will be under 20 years 
old). 
The detailed phenotyping evaluation includes the following assessments:
1. Height – Measured in triplicate on a standing stadiometer which is calibrated 
daily. The average of the three measurements will be used.
2. Weight – Measured on an electronic scale.
3. Detailed musculoskeletal evaluation performed by physical therapist 
including the IDKC knee score (a validated knee instrument), Oswestry back 
survey, a 3-dimensional biomechanical and gait assessment.
4. Questionnaire regarding medical history with specific attention to growth 
and joint issues as well as a validated quality of life survey (Peds QL) and 
physical activity assessment questionnaire (Marx). 
5. Photographs
6. Radiographs
a. Standard 4 view X-ray series of the knees in all affected individuals.
b. Subjects under 20 years of age will have a bone age performed. 
7. 3T MRI of the knees will be performed on all subjects who are able to do the 
assessment without sedation (per Radiology generally age 6 and older) under 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
13
age 20 years to look for early evidence of joint disease. For all subjects, a 
standard MRI checklist will be used to assess eligibility prior to scheduling 
any study visits. Subjects can enroll and participate in the study even if they 
are not able to undergo the MRI procedure. 
Specifically, we will use a combination of MRI sequences which are specifically designed 
to look at cartilage. We will begin with T2 relaxation time mapping (T2 mapping), a 
quantitative MR technique, highly sensitive to changes in collagen content and 
anisotropic orientation of collagen fibers within the cartilage 7,8. T2 mapping allowed 
early detection of cartilage changes in JIA which was not predictable either on 
conventional MR or clinical exams 9,10. Additionally, T1 imaging is a promising new 
technique, highly sensitive to the interaction of water molecules with 
glycosaminoglycan (GAG). By measuring collagen fiber anisotropic changes (reflected by 
increased T2 values) in combination with GAG depletion (reflected by increased T1), we 
can obtain a complete set of information of hyaline cartilage 11-15. Finally, we will use 
diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), a noninvasive technique enables measurement of the 
Brownian motion of water to show tissue microstructure. DTI based tractography has 
enabled probing of the tissue finer orientation from voxel to voxel in three dimensions. 
There has been a research trial using DTI to show the arrangement and measurement of 
the length of the columns and microstructures of the growth plate 16. 
The purpose of the MR imaging of the knee is:
1. Evaluation of early degeneration of the knee joint including gross morphologic 
changes (conventional MR) as well as microstructure changes of the cartilage 
(quantitative MR).
2. Evaluation of growth plate abnormalities by measuring track length of the 
columnar cells of the growth plate (DTI).
The purpose of obtaining the MRI is not to assess the effects of GH on the joint disease. 
Our study will be underpowered to perform this assessment and as MRI evaluations are 
costly, we will only perform the MRI once at the baseline visit. This will be sufficient for 
the scientific purposes stated above. 
As the initial phenotype arm of the study reached completion in November 2019, our 
data showed that osteochondritis dissecans (OD) was present on knee MRI in 25% of 
pediatric patients. These subjects ranged from 8-12 years old. In order to gain further 
insight into the natural progression of OD and other joint pathology throughout 
childhood, we propose to repeat knee MRIs for those that had OD on their initial 
imaging.  Repeat MRIs will be done every other year from the time of the initial study. 
The benefit appears to greatly outweigh any risks, as this would not expose any of the 
study subjects to additional radiation. 
Written informed consent will be obtained from all subjects undergoing the 
phenotyping protocol and written assent will be obtained in all minor subjects aged 11 
years or older.


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
14
6. EXTENSION TRIAL
Background and Preliminary Results
As stated in our initial study protocol, patients demonstrating a year-1 increase in height 
SDS > + 0.3 will qualify to enroll in the extension trial, which will allow continuation of 
GH therapy for another two years, while using the same GH dosing protocol as for year 
1. Of the five patients receiving GH therapy for at least six months, results from their 6-
month study visits yield a favorable growth response.  The annualized mean height 
velocity for this group is 9.4 cm/yr (range, 7.4 to 11.2 cm/yr). The annualized mean 
increase in height SDS is + 0.8 (range, + 0.5 to + 1.4). Even the lowest responder 
achieved a gain in height SDS of > +0.3 (namely, + 0.5 SDS), and thus qualifying for 
further treatment with GH as part of the study’s extension trial requirements. All 
families have shown good practice adherence with both the GH injections, and the 
follow-up study visits so far. At this point, GH therapy is not FDA-approved for ACAN 
deficiency associated growth failure. There are, to our knowledge, no other trials for this 
disorder available to the patients with ACAN deficiency.
Specific Objective for the extension trial
Primary objective:
-
Describe the continued effects (beyond year 1) of GH therapy on growth 
parameters in pre-pubertal children with ACAN deficiency.
Secondary objective:
-
Continue to describe features of joint involvement, as noted on physical exam or 
history, in patients with ACAN deficiency receiving continued GH treatment - to 
provide additional insights into the underlying joint pathophysiology present in 
ACAN deficiency.
Study Design and Methods
Study Hypotheses:
1. Continued treatment with GH in children with ACAN deficiency will result in 
ongoing catch-up growth due to increased growth velocity. 
2. Early joint pathology demonstrated on prior MRI will be evident on clinical 
examination of affected subjects. 
Endpoints:


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
15
A. Primary Outcome – Change in height SDS from 12 to 36 months, and overall 
delta height SDS from start of therapy to 36 months.
B. Secondary Outcomes
a. Height velocity in cm/year calculated for each year of the trial.
b. Change in height velocity during years 2 and 3 of GH therapy.
c.
Change in bone age divided by change in chronological age for each year 
of continued therapy.
d. Change in whole body bone mineral density adjusted for height at 24 and 
36 months.
e. Frequency of adverse events as defined below.
f.
Frequency of joint complaints.
Study Recruitment
Only study participants that have had a satisfactory response to GH within the first year 
of treatment will have the opportunity to enroll in the extension trial. This is defined as 
an increase of height SDS of + 0.3 or greater. 
Study protocol
This is an extension trial of rhGH therapy in pre-pubertal children with ACAN deficiency. 
The primary outcome measures of interest are height velocity and change in height SDS. 
All patients currently in the treatment trial will continue to receive once daily injections 
of Norditropin at a standard dose of 50 mcg/kg/day, per initial study protocol (this dose 
can only be adjusted based on safety guidelines as described in the original protocol for 
year 1 of therapy, i.e., if IGF-I concentration on therapy is > +2.5 SD) 
Follow up visits will occur every 6 months, or semi-annually. Study staff will continue to 
perform check-in calls every 3 months to promote compliance and to record any missed 
doses, potential new adverse events or use of concomitant medications. In addition, 
study staff will dispense an additional 3 months of medication and supplies after the 3-
month check confirms adequate adherence with the study protocol and no new 
treatment-related adverse events were reported. Each follow-up visit has a +/-2-week 
window to accommodate participant schedules and travel. These visits will be the same 
as previous ones performed for the initial 12-month trial. 
The chart below outlines the visit activity schedule for the extension trial. 
Lab/Assessment
Check-in Calls
18- and 30-Month 
Visits
24- and 36-Month 
Visits
Physical exam
X
X
Vital signs
X
X
Height/weight
X
X
TSH
X
X


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
16
Free T4
X
X
IGF-I
X
X
IGFBP-3
X
X
Bone Age X-ray
X
DXA scan (whole body, 
lumbar spine) *
X
Compliance Review
X
Adverse Event Review
X
Medication Dispensation
X
X
X
*Additional radiation will be received, approx. 0.013mSv per scan
Only if a participant was unable to complete a study procedure during the initial 12-
month trial period due to age, scheduling conflicts, or illness, they may be asked to 
perform the procedure during the extension trial at one of their scheduled study visits 
(i.e., MRI, gait assessment, musculoskeletal evaluation).
After each study visit, we will send a letter summarizing the exam findings and lab 
results to the participant’s local primary care physician or pediatric endocrinologist. 
Reasons for Completion of the Clinical Trial Participation 
When it becomes clear that a participant is no longer benefitting from ongoing GH 
therapy, treatment will stop. 
To discontinue further GH therapy during the extension trial, either of the following 
must occur:
1.
The participant reaches skeletal maturity according to their most recent bone age x-ray.
2.
The participant has a height velocity of <2.5 cm/yr.
3.
The participant and/or his/her family feels continued therapy does not lead to 
satisfactory treatment response.
4.
The participant has completed their last study visit (3 year) and there is no more funding 
to continue the trial. 
The treatment portion of the trial will be discontinued for an individual subject if he or 
she develops a serious adverse drug reaction (as defined below). The treatment trial 
may otherwise be discontinued if the subject withdraws consent or if the PI determines 
that the subject is no longer eligible to continue treatment. Participants that discontinue 
the treatment portion of the trial will be encouraged to follow up with their local 
pediatric endocrinologist for follow-up care and management. 
If a subject’s participation (and treatment) ends due to 1) completion of the trial and/or 
2) lack of continued funding, study staff will work with the family to establish clinical 
care and GH treatment through a local pediatric endocrinologist. Up to 3 months’ worth 
of medication and supplies can be dispensed to the family at the last study visit to 
ensure continuity of ongoing care during this transition period. 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
17
7. REGULATORY CONSIDERATIONS
In consultation with Novo Nordisk, we have determined that the study will continue to 
be conducted under an IND. Dr. Backeljauw, as the current sponsor, will continue to 
have the IND with the FDA and will comply with all necessary regulations. In the event 
Dr. Backeljauw should leave his position at CCHMC, the newly appointed PI will take 
over the IND and assume all responsibilities that go with it.  
8. RISKS/BENEFITS
The primary benefit of this study is the expected increase in growth rate in individuals 
treated with GH therapy. Subjects will be provided with a copy of their growth data and 
growth chart at each visit. Additionally, after each visit, a letter will be sent to the 
subject’s primary care physician detailing the exam findings and laboratory results from 
that visit. Additionally, this study will provide us additional insights into the clinical 
presentation of ACAN deficiency which may benefit subjects and their family members 
in the future. 
The major risks from this trial are related to the treatment with GH itself. Known side 
effects of this FDA-approved medication include mild edema, intracranial hypertension, 
slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE), progression of scoliosis, and injection site 
reactions. 
-
Edema: Edema is usually mild and self resolves. Subjects will be asked about 
foot swelling. If edema persists and is painful, the dose of GH will be 
decreased 10-20%. If the edema continues to persist 2 weeks after 
decreasing the dose and is impacting the subject’s daily activities, GH will 
then be discontinued. 
-
Intracranial hypertension: A funduscopic exam will be performed at baseline 
and at each follow up visit. In the case of persistent headache +/- blurred 
vision or vomiting, the patient will be referred to a local ophthalmologist for 
dilated eye exam to rule out papilledema. If papilledema is present, the 
subject will then be referred to a local emergency department for further 
evaluation including lumbar puncture. If papilledema is present, GH will be 
immediately discontinued. After the complete resolution of all headache 
symptoms and the complete resolution of papilledema, GH can be restarted 
at a reduced dose of 30 micrograms/kg/day. If the patient tolerates this dose 
for 2 months without recurrence of symptoms, then the dose can be 
increased back to 50 micrograms/kg/day. If at any point papilledema recurs, 
GH will be permanently discontinued. 
-
SCFE: A hip exam will be performed at baseline and at each follow up visit. If 
the patient develops hip or knee pain at any time during the study a hip X-ray 
will be obtained to rule out SCFE. If SCFE is present, GH will be immediately 
discontinued.
-
Progression of scoliosis: A back exam will be performed at baseline and at 
each follow up visit. If the patient develops clinically significant scoliosis 
during the study, the patient will be referred to an orthopedic physician for 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
18
further evaluation. The decision whether to discontinue GH will be made in 
conjunction with the orthopedist depending on the severity of scoliosis. 
Scoliosis has been reported in a single family with homozygous mutations in 
the ACAN gene18. These reported patients had a very severe form of the 
disease. The subjects in the current clinical trial will all have heterozygous 
mutations in ACAN. In our report of 103 individuals with heterozygous 
mutations, scoliosis was not reported in any individual. Additionally, scoliosis 
usually becomes more evident during puberty and all individuals in this study 
will be pre-pubertal. Thus, it is highly unlikely that scoliosis will develop 
during the trial. If it does, we will be unable to determine if the scoliosis is 
due to the underlying ACAN deficiency or GH treatment. 
-
Injection Site Reactions: The patients can experience local symptoms related 
to the subcutaneous administration of GH which include pain at the site of 
the injection, redness, small bruising, lipoatrophy or lipohypertrophy. 
Injection site reactions can be avoided by changing the injection site at each 
injection (injection site rotation).
Radiation risk: Every person is exposed on a daily basis to a certain amount of background 
radiation originating from soil, rocks, outer space and within the body itself. The amount 
of radiation for imaging studies varies based on the size of the patient, with children and 
smaller adolescents being exposed to relatively larger doses of radiation than adults. The 
average person in Cincinnati receives a radiation dose of about 3 mSv per year. Using the 
largest exposure estimates for children, the proposed radiology studies would expose the 
patients to the following amounts of radiation: 
-
DXA scan (whole body, lumbar spine): approx. 0.013 mSv; four DXA scans: approx. 
0.052 mSv
-
Bone age (X –ray of the hand): 0.005 mSv; four bone age studies: 0.02 mSv
-
Knee X-rays (4 views): 0.001 mSv per view; total 0.004 mSv (for screening visit 
only, until all 10 patients have been enrolled; afterwards no knee-x-rays are 
planned for the extension part)
Therefore, total radiation exposure from this study is expected to be 0.08 mSv or less 
(equivalent to the amount an individual receives over 6 days from background radiation).
9. ADVERSE EVENTS
Subjects will be encouraged to notify the study team immediately should any adverse 
event occur. Formal review of adverse events will occur at each visit and telephone call 
as detailed in Table 1. All adverse events will be reported to the IRB, Novo Nordisk and 
to the FDA as per regulations. An adverse event log will be maintained. 
Given that this continues to be a small pilot trial with an anticipated low rate of adverse 
events, there will be no formal data safety and monitoring board. Rather, Dr. 
Backeljauw or a qualified co-investigator when Dr. Backeljauw is unavailable will review 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
19
all adverse events within 48 hours and serious adverse events within 24 hours. If a 
subject requires discontinuation of GH therapy, they will be asked to still complete all 
follow up assessments up to the 3-year visit.  
The study team will comply with all local legal, regulatory, and IRB requirements with 
regards to adverse events. Dr. Backeljauw, the sponsor-investigator, will be responsible 
for reporting of all adverse events including serious adverse events (SAE), suspected 
unexpected serious adverse reactions (SUSARs), serious adverse drug reactions (SADRs) 
to the competent authority and independent ethics committee/institutional review 
boards based upon federal regulations and local/IRB policies. 
Dr. Backeljauw, the sponsor-investigator, will report to Novo Nordisk all SAEs, SUSARs, 
and SADRs at the same time such events are reported to regulatory authorities or within 
15 days from the sponsor-investigator becoming aware of such adverse events, 
whichever comes first.
Dr. Backeljauw or his designee will collect the following information at minimum for 
each of these events:
1. Study name
2. Patient identification (e.g., initials, sex, age)
3. Event (preferably a diagnosis)
4. Drug 
5. Reporter identification (e.g., Name, or initials)
Also 6) Causality, and 7) Outcome might be reported.
Definitions
Adverse Event (AE):
An AE is any undesirable medical event occurring to a subject in a clinical trial, whether 
or not related to the trial product(s). This includes events reported from the first trial 
related activity after the subject has signed the informed consent and until completion 
of the trial. Unexpected AEs as referenced in the US Norditropin® prescribing 
information.
Clinical Laboratory Adverse Event:
A clinical laboratory AE is any clinical laboratory abnormality regarded as clinically 
significant i.e., an abnormality that suggests a disease and/or organ toxicity and is of a 
severity, which requires active management, (i.e., change of dose, discontinuation of 
trial product, more frequent follow-up, or diagnostic investigation).
Serious Adverse Event (SAE):
A serious AE is an experience that at any dose results in any of the following:
• Death


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
20
• A life-threatening* experience
• In-patient hospitalisation or prolongation of existing hospitalization
• A persistent or significant disability/incapacity
• A congenital anomaly/birth defect
• Important medical events that may not result in death, be life-threatening*, or require
  hospitalisation may be considered an SAE when, based upon appropriate medical 
judgement, they may jeopardise the subject and may require medical or surgical 
intervention to prevent one of the outcomes listed in this definition.
• Suspicion of transmission of infectious agents 
*The term life-threatening in the definition of SAE refers to an event in which the 
subject was at risk of death at the time of the event. It does not refer to an event which 
hypothetically might have caused death if it was more severe.
Serious Adverse Drug Reaction (SADR): 
An adverse drug reaction (ADR) is an adverse event (AE) for which a causal relationship 
to the trial product is at least possible i.e., causal relationship is conceivable and cannot 
be dismissed. Serious adverse reaction (SAR): Adverse event which fulfils both the 
criteria for a Serious Adverse Event and the criteria for an Adverse Reaction.
Suspected Unexpected Serious Adverse Reaction (SUSAR): 
An SAE which is unexpected and regarded as possibly or probably related to the 
trial/study product by the investigator. 
Medical Events of Special Interest (MESI): A MESI is (1) a medication error (e.g., wrong 
drug administration or wrong route of administration) or (2) a suspected transmission of 
an infectious agent via the product.
Non-Serious Adverse Event:
A non-serious AE is any AE which does not fulfil the definition of an SAE.
Severity Assessment Definitions:
• Mild: Transient symptoms, no interference with the subject’s daily activities
• Moderate: Marked symptoms, moderate interference with the subject’s daily 
activities
• Severe: Considerable interference with the subject’s daily activities, unacceptable
Relationship to study medication Assessment Definitions:
• Probable: Good reasons and sufficient documentation to assume a causal relationship
• Possible: A causal relationship is conceivable and cannot be dismissed
• Unlikely: The event is most likely related to an etiology other than the trial product
Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA) will be used for coding adverse 
events.


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
21
Outcome Categories and Definitions:
• Recovered: Fully recovered or by medical or surgical treatment the condition has 
returned to the level observed at the first trial related activity after the subject signed 
the informed consent
• Recovering: The condition is improving, and the subject is expected to recover from 
the event. This term should only be used when the subject has completed the trial.
• Recovered with sequelae: As a result of the AE, the subject suffered persistent and     
significant disability/incapacity (e.g., became blind, deaf, paralysed). Any AE recovered 
with sequelae should be rated as an SAE.
• Not recovered
• Fatal
• Unknown
Collection, Recording and Reporting of Adverse Events
All events meeting the definition of an adverse event must be collected and reported 
from the first trial related activity after the subject has signed the informed consent and 
until completion of the trial. 
Follow-up of Adverse Events
Dr. Backeljauw, the sponsor-investigator, and Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical 
Center will provide adequate medical care to the study subject for any study-related 
adverse events, including clinically significant laboratory values related to the study. This 
medical care for study subjects will be provided regardless of their insurance status. 
All adverse events classified as serious or severe or possibly/probably related to the trial 
product will be followed until the subject has recovered and all queries have been 
resolved. 
Pregnancy
Subjects will be instructed to notify the sponsor-investigator immediately if they 
become pregnant. Dr. Backeljauw, the sponsor-investigator, will report to Novo Nordisk 
any pregnancy occurring during the trial period. 
Precautions/Over-dosage
All subjects will receive appropriate education about proper administration of 
medication from a trained medical professional. The subject’s parent will be required to 
demonstrate proper technique and dosing prior to distribution of medication. They will 
be asked to notify the study team in case of an overdose and the PI will determine if 
further medical monitoring is needed based on the described event. 
10. COMPENSATION
For each study visit, the study will cover the costs of economy class plane tickets for the 
primary research subject and for one parent. If the family prefers to drive to CCHMC, 
the study will reimburse the family at the standard CCHMC mileage reimbursement rate 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
22
for the distance from their home address to CCHMC as determined by Google Maps. 
Additionally, for the initial 12-month trial period the study will cover costs of the hotel 
rooms for up to 2 nights per study visit as well as the cost of transportation from and to 
the Cincinnati airport. A meal allowance of $35 per individual per day will be covered. In 
the extension trial period, the study will cover cost of a hotel room for one night per 
study visit as well as a meal allowance of $40 per individual per day. There will be no 
additional compensation for participation the study. The study will cover the costs of all 
medical evaluations detailed as part of this protocol that occur at CCHMC. GH and 
supplies will be provided to the subjects for free. 
11. STATISTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
This is a pilot single arm study and thus no formal statistical comparison is planned. The 
outcome measures will all be descriptive. Therefore, we based our power calculations 
on our ability to confidently detect a positive effect on height SDS. We based the power 
calculation on our retrospective data. This sample size calculation is based on the 
following key assumptions: the mean first year response to GH of the 13 previously 
treated patients in our retrospective data was 0.407 SDS with a standard deviation of 
0.343 SDS. We estimated that a sample size of 10 subjects will give us 90% power to 
demonstrate a change in SDS greater than zero at one-year post treatment initiation. 
Based on the retrospective data, we are 95% confident that the true mean response 
falls within the confidence interval of 0.19 to 0.62 SD. This sample size is feasible given 
the available patient population and estimated budget. 
12. DATA HANDLING AND RECORD KEEPING
All data will be collected in standardized case report forms. Forms will be kept in a 
locked cabinet in a secure location within the Endocrine department. Only the PI and 
study coordinator will have access to the forms. Review of all CRFs for completion will 
be done within 1 week after each study visit. 
13. ETHICS
Written informed consent will be obtained from all subjects as well as written assent in 
subjects aged 11 years or older as detailed above. Consent processes will comply with 
all guidance and regulations of Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center.
. 
All subjects will be assigned a coded ID and all forms will only contain the coded ID. The 
code linking the ID with identifiable information will be kept on a password protected 
secure server as part of the Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center research 
computing network. Only the PI and approved study personnel will be given access to 
this code. 
The study will be conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki and will be 
conducted in accordance with the ICH GCP guidelines. Dr. Backeljauw, the sponsor-
investigator, will comply with all applicable regulatory and legal requirements, ICH GCP 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
23
guidelines and the Declaration of Helsinki in obtaining and documenting the informed 
consent.
14. LIABILITY AND SUBJECT INSURANCE
As noted above, during and following a subject’s participation in trial, Dr. Backeljauw 
and Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center will provide adequate medical care to 
the study subject for any study-related adverse events, including clinically significant 
laboratory values related to the study. This medical care for study subjects will be 
provided regardless of their insurance status.
Dr. Backeljauw will be responsible for the conduct of the study and agrees to defend, 
indemnify, and hold harmless Novo Nordisk, any of its parent companies, affiliates, or 
subsidiaries, and their respective officers, directors, employees, agents, representatives, 
distributors, salespersons, customers, licensees, and end-users from and against any 
claim, suit, demand, loss, damage, expense or liability imposed by any third party arising 
from or related to: (a) any breach of Dr. Backeljauw’s obligations or representations; or 
(b) Dr. Backeljauw’s negligent or grossly negligent use or willful misuse of the study 
drug, the results, or services derived therefrom.  This indemnification shall not apply in 
the event and to the extent that a court of competent jurisdiction or a duly appointed 
arbiter determines that such losses or liability arose as a result of Novo Nordisk’s gross 
negligence, intentional misconduct, or material breach of its responsibilities. 
15. PUBLICATION PLAN
Dr. Backeljauw intends to publish the results of this trial within 12 months after 
completion in a peer-reviewed medical journal. He will also present the results of the 
trial at a national meeting such as the Endocrine Society or Pediatric Endocrine Society 
annual meetings. This trial is registered on clinicaltrials.gov. 
Dr. Dauber is currently a co-investigator. He was involved in the development of the 
initial study protocol, but not in the development of the extension studies. He does not 
have access to the raw study data. He will be involved in the development of 
abstracts/manuscripts that come out of the studies, and therefore will be exposed to 
deidentified growth and laboratory data from the studies. None of the study funds go 
towards Dr. Dauber's involvement in the study.
16. STUDY TIMELINE
IRB approval and an IND will be obtained prior to study initiation. We anticipate that it 
will take 6-18 months to recruit 10 eligible subjects. The study will then take an 
additional 36 months for the final patient to complete three years of treatment. Eligible 
subjects that are willing to enroll in the extension trial will come in for their final study 
visit in 2021 or 2022.
17. STUDY TEAM
Philippe Backeljauw MD, Pediatric Endocrinologist – Principal Investigator
Gajanthan Muthuvel, MD, Pediatric Endocrinology Fellow – Co-Investigator 


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
24
Leah Tyzinski, BA, CCRP – Study Coordinator
Andrew Dauber MD MMSc, Pediatric Endocrinologist – Co-Investigator Off-site
Hee Kim MD, Radiologist – Co-Investigator
Paul Gubanich MD, Sports Medicine Physician – Co-Investigator
Mark Paterno, MD – Co-Investigator
Jeff Taylor-Haas, PT – Physical Therapist
18. REFERENCES
1.
Nilsson O, Guo MH, Dunbar N, et al. Short stature, accelerated bone maturation, and 
early growth cessation due to heterozygous aggrecan mutations. J Clin Endocrinol 
Metab. Aug 2014;99(8):E1510-1518.
2.
Domowicz MS, Cortes M, Henry JG, Schwartz NB. Aggrecan modulation of growth plate 
morphogenesis. Dev Biol. May 15 2009;329(2):242-257.
3.
Watanabe H, Yamada Y. Chondrodysplasia of gene knockout mice for aggrecan and link 
protein. Glycoconj J. May-Jun 2002;19(4-5):269-273.
4.
Kronenberg HM. Developmental regulation of the growth plate. Nature. May 15 
2003;423(6937):332-336.
5.
Gkourogianni A, Andrew M, Tyzinski L, et al. Clinical characterization of patients with 
autosomal dominant short stature due to aggrecan mutations. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 
Nov 21 2016:jc20163313.
6.
Cohen P, Rogol AD, Deal CL, et al. Consensus statement on the diagnosis and treatment 
of children with idiopathic short stature: a summary of the GH Research Society, the 
Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society, and the European Society for Paediatric 
Endocrinology Workshop. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. Nov 2008;93(11):4210-4217.
7.
Watrin A, Ruaud JP, Olivier PT, et al. T2 mapping of rat patellar cartilage. Radiology. May 
2001;219(2):395-402.
8.
Mosher TJ, Dardzinski BJ. Cartilage MRI T2 relaxation time mapping: overview and 
applications. Semin Musculoskelet Radiol. Dec 2004;8(4):355-368.
9.
Kight AC, Dardzinski BJ, Laor T, Graham TB. Magnetic resonance imaging evaluation of 
the effects of juvenile rheumatoid arthritis on distal femoral weight-bearing cartilage. 
Arthritis and rheumatism. Mar 2004;50(3):901-905.
10.
Kim HK, Laor T, Graham TB, et al. T2 relaxation time changes in distal femoral articular 
cartilage in children with juvenile idiopathic arthritis: a 3-year longitudinal study. AJR. 
American journal of roentgenology. Oct 2010;195(4):1021-1025.
11.
Takayama Y, Hatakenaka M, Tsushima H, et al. T1rho is superior to T2 mapping for the 
evaluation of articular cartilage denaturalization with osteoarthritis: Radiological-
pathological correlation after total knee arthroplasty. Eur J Radiol. Dec 21 2012.
12.
Souza RB, Feeley BT, Zarins ZA, Link TM, Li X, Majumdar S. T1rho MRI relaxation in knee 
OA subjects with varying sizes of cartilage lesions. Knee. Mar 2013;20(2):113-119.
13.
Regatte RR, Akella SV, Lonner JH, Kneeland JB, Reddy R. T1rho relaxation mapping in 
human osteoarthritis (OA) cartilage: comparison of T1rho with T2. Journal of magnetic 
resonance imaging : JMRI. Apr 2006;23(4):547-553.
14.
Duvvuri U, Reddy R, Patel SD, Kaufman JH, Kneeland JB, Leigh JS. T1rho-relaxation in 
articular cartilage: effects of enzymatic degradation. Magn Reson Med. Dec 
1997;38(6):863-867.
15.
Akella SV, Regatte RR, Gougoutas AJ, et al. Proteoglycan-induced changes in T1rho-
relaxation of articular cartilage at 4T. Magn Reson Med. Sep 2001;46(3):419-423.


Version 18.0 April 2, 2021
25
16.
Radiology. 2014 Nov;273(2):491-501. Diffusion-tensor imaging of the growing ends of 
long bones: pilot demonstration of columnar structure in the physes and metaphyses of 
the knee.Jaimes C1, Berman JI, Delgado J, Ho-Fung V, Jaramillo D.
17.
Radiology. 2014 Nov;273(2):491-501. Diffusion-tensor imaging of the growing ends of 
long bones: pilot demonstration of columnar structure in the physes and metaphyses of 
the knee.Jaimes C1, Berman JI, Delgado J, Ho-Fung V, Jaramillo D.
18.
Tompson SW, Merriman B, Funari VA, et al. A recessive skeletal dysplasia, SEMD 
aggrecan type, results from a missense mutation affecting the C-type lectin domain of 
aggrecan. Am J Hum Genet. Jan 2009;84(1):72-79.

ICF_001.pdf: 
Page 1 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
STUDY TITLE: CLINICAL CHARACTERIZATION AND TRIAL OF GROWTH HORMONE 
TREATMENT IN PATIENTS WITH AGGRECAN DEFICIENCY
     
STUDY NUMBER: 2017-1956             
FUNDING ORGANIZATION: Novo Nordisk
Philippe Backeljauw, MD
   
Name of Principal Investigator 
513-636-2759 
Telephone Number 
INTRODUCTION
We are asking for your permission for your child to be in a research study so that we can learn new 
information that may help others with Aggrecan (ACAN) deficiency. Your child’s participation is 
completely voluntary. If you decide not to give your permission for your child to be in this study, it 
will not affect their relationship with Cincinnati Children’s Hospital and the Center for Growth 
Disorders.  If you decide to allow your child to be in this study, you may change your mind at any 
time during the study and your child can stop being in the study.  Take all the time you need to 
make your choice.  Ask us any questions you have. It is also okay to ask more questions after you 
decide to allow your child to be in the study.  You can ask questions at any time.  
WHY ARE WE DOING THIS RESEARCH?
Through the research efforts of the Cincinnati Center for Growth Disorders and collaborating 
physicians, over twenty families affected by short stature have been identified with a genetic 
mutation in the ACAN gene. A mutation in the ACAN gene is characterized by having dominantly 
inherited short stature, a normal to advanced bone age and growth that stops too early. Prior to the 
discovery of the ACAN gene’s effects on growth, these patients would have been diagnosed with 
idiopathic short stature (ISS). 
Currently there is no approved treatment for patients with an ACAN mutation and care 
management can vary from doctor to doctor which is why we want to do a research study to look at 
the effects of growth hormone treatment over one year on pre-pubertal children with ACAN 
deficiency. We also want to learn more about the clinical and physical features of the phenotype, 
and how it influences joint health. 
We are asking your child to be in this study because they have undergone genetic testing to 
confirm that they have an ACAN mutation, and they meet all of the study eligibility criteria. 
WHO IS IN CHARGE OF THE RESEARCH? 
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956


Page 2 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
Philippe Backeljauw, MD is the researcher at Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center 
(CCHMC) that is in charge of this study. The growth hormone medication and funding for this study 
is provided by Novo Nordisk.  
An investigator has received additional payments from Novo Nordisk for consulting, speaking, and 
serving on an advisory board.
WHAT WILL HAPPEN IN THE STUDY?
If your child qualifies and you decide you want them to be in the study, your child will be treated 
with a single dose regimen of daily growth hormone for a period of 12 months to examine the 
effects on growth response. The dose that will be used is 50 micrograms/kg/day.  This is a dose 
that is already approved for children diagnosed with Turner and Noonan syndrome, which both 
result in short stature not caused by growth hormone deficiency. Your child’s weight will be used to 
calculate the volume of their daily dose. Also, results of your child’s blood test (IGF-I level) may be 
used to adjust your child’s daily dose. 
You and your child will come to CCHMC for three study visits over the course of 12 months. The 
study visits will last 6-10 hours. A parent/legal guardian will be asked to complete at least four 
check-in calls during the 12-month period. 
These are the things that will happen at the study visits. We will:

Complete a routine physical exam, including to see if your child has started puberty.

Complete a detailed joint exam, including to check for curvature of the spine.

Complete a detailed musculoskeletal evaluation which looks at knee and back health and 
includes an assessment of how your child walks.

Collect vital signs, height and weight measurements.

Collect blood samples.

Take photographs.

Ask you questions about your child’s family and medical history that focus on growth and 
joint issues.

Ask you questions about your child’s quality of life and physical activity.

Take an x-ray of your child’s hand and knees.

Take a bone density scan (DXA) of your child.

Take MRI pictures of your child’s knees (to look for early signs of joint disease). These may 
be repeated every other year from time of initial study if joint disease is present.

A blood sample will need to be drawn at a local facility (i. e., lab, doctor’s office) to monitor 
IGF-I levels at the time of the 3 month check in call. This will be subject to your insurance 
company and the study is not able to reimburse the cost. 
Children that grow well enough (as outlined per study protocol) in the first year of treatment will be 
eligible to participate for another two years in the extension study If you and your child agree to 
participate, you will be asked to come to CCHMC every 6 months for four additional study visits. 
These study visits will last 2-6 hours. A parent/legal guardian will be asked to complete at least 
four check-in calls during the extension study as well. 
These are the things that will happen at the extension study visits. 
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956


Page 3 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
We will:

Complete a routine physical exam, including to see if your child has started puberty.

Complete a detailed joint exam, including to check for curvature of the spine.

Collect vital signs, height, and weight measurements.

Collect blood samples.

Take photographs 

Take an x-ray of your child’s hand (at yearly visits)

Take a bone density scan (DXA) of your child (at yearly visits)

May take MRI pictures of your child’s knees every other year from time of their initial study if 
joint disease was present.

If there are any study activities that your child did not complete in the first year of the study 
due to age, scheduling issues, or illness we may ask you/your child if they would be willing 
to complete the activity at a future visit.
These are the things that will happen during the check-in calls. We will:

Discuss any issues with medication administration and compliance.

Record any adverse events not previously reported.

Confirm that new supplies/medication will be shipped to the participant (upon completion of 
the check-in call). 

A blood sample may need to be drawn at a local facility (i.e., lab, doctor’s office) to monitor 
your child’s IGF-I levels if the results meet the protocol criteria for dose adjustment. This will 
be subject to your insurance company and the study is not able to reimburse the cost. 
The research staff will explain each visit to you in detail. 
After completion of the study, your child will need to follow up with a local pediatric Endocrinologist 
to continue their growth hormone treatment and medical care for ACAN deficiency. At the 3-year 
study visit (final visit) we will give you up to 3 months of medication and supplies so that your child 
can continue treatment until they are able to start getting the medication clinically (not through the 
research study). Study staff is available to help you with this process if you need it, and we will 
follow up to ensure that appropriate medical care is received. 
WHAT ARE THE GOOD THINGS THAT CAN HAPPEN FROM THIS RESEARCH?
We hope that the treatment of daily growth hormone will help your child grow but being in this 
study may not help your child right now.  We will provide you a copy of your child’s growth chart 
with measurements from each study visit. Additionally, a letter with the lab results and exam 
findings will be sent to your child’s primary care physician or pediatric Endocrinologist after the 
completion of each study visit.
When we finish the study, we hope that we will know more about joint disease and the effects of 
growth hormone in individuals with Aggrecan deficiency. This may help other children diagnosed 
with an Aggrecan mutation later on.  
WHAT ARE THE BAD THINGS THAT CAN HAPPEN FROM THIS RESEARCH?
The major risks in this study are the same as the risks of being treated with daily growth hormone. 
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956


Page 4 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
Injection Site Reactions: Occasionally subcutaneous injections can cause local reactions. Such as 
redness, bruising, lipoatrophy or lipohypertrophy at the site of administration. 
Edema: Swelling of the feet. Edema occurs approximately < 2.5% of the time. 
Scoliosis: Some children with scoliosis may experience a worsening of symptoms when they are 
on growth hormone therapy due to increased bone growth. 
Intracranial Hypertension:  Increased fluid pressure within the skull. Symptoms include persistent 
headache and/or blurred vision and vomiting. This occurs in approximately < 1 in 1000 patients on 
growth hormone therapy. 
Slipped capital femoral epiphysis (SCFE): A hip condition that causes the top of the femur 
(thighbone) to slip off the neck of the bone in a backwards direction. Symptoms include hip or knee 
pain. This occurs in approximately < 1 in 1000 patients on growth hormone therapy. 
The DXA scans, hand x-rays, and knee x-rays in this study involve exposure to ionizing radiation. 
We are all exposed to radiation every day of our lives from natural sources. Over the 3 years of 
this study, the radiation exposure from the DXA scans, hand x-rays, and knee x-rays in this study 
is similar to 6 days of natural background radiation. This amount of radiation is considered minimal 
risk, no greater than the activities of daily life.
Your child may feel some pain when their blood is drawn. Numbing medicine can be used. There is 
a small chance the needle will cause bleeding, a bruise, or an infection.  
There may be other risks that we do not know about yet.
WHAT OTHER CHOICES ARE THERE?
Instead of being in this study, you can choose not to have your child be in it. 
HOW WILL INFORMATION ABOUT YOUR CHILD BE KEPT PRIVATE?
 
Making sure that information about your child remains private is important to us.  To protect your 
child’s privacy in this research study we will: 
Assign code numbers to your child’s samples, and any information about them and only study 
investigators will be authorized to link the code to your child.
Remove all identifying information from samples before they are released to other investigators. 
De-identified data will be shared with Dr. Andrew Dauber, at Children’s National Medical Center, 
who was the original principal investigator on this study before leaving Cincinnati Children’s 
Hospital Medical Center.
We will not use your child’s name or identity for publication or publicity purposes. 
All other parties including employers, insurance companies, person physicians, and relatives will 
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956


Page 5 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
be refused access to the information or samples, unless you provide written permission, or unless 
we are required by law to do so. 
A description of this clinical trial will be available on http://www.ClinicalTrials.gov, as required by 
U.S. Law. This website will not include information that can identify your child. At most, the website 
will include a summary of the study results. You can search this website at any time.
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) may choose to inspect your child’s records since your 
child is a participant in an investigation that involves the study of an approved drug.
WHAT IF WE LEARN NEW INFORMATION DURING THE RESEARCH? 
The study doctor will tell you if they find out about new information from this or other studies that 
may affect your child’s health, safety, or your willingness for your child to stay in this study.
WILL IT COST YOU ANYTHING EXTRA FOR YOUR CHILD TO BE IN THE RESEARCH 
STUDY? 
It will not cost anything for your child to participate in this study, with the exception of the 3-month 
blood sample to check IGF-I levels and any study activities performed remotely with your child’s 
local physician (i.e. safety labs, clinic appointments). The test procedures and evaluations 
occurring at Cincinnati Childrens Hospital are provided at no cost to you. 
WILL YOU/YOUR CHILD BE PAID TO BE IN THIS RESEARCH STUDY? 
You/your child will not be paid for this research study. However, the study will pay for the travel 
expenses incurred when coming to CCHMC for study visit appointments. The study will cover the 
cost of an economy class plane ticket for the primary research participant, one parent and for 
every affected family member participating in this study. Alternatively, the study will reimburse the 
family at the standard CCHMC mileage reimbursement rate if they choose to drive instead. For the 
initial 12-month trial period the study will cover the cost of the hotel room for up to 2 nights per 
study visit. Each individual will be reimbursed for the cost of their meals up to $35 per individual 
per day. In the extension trial period, the study will cover the cost of a hotel room for one night per 
study visit, and each individual will be reimbursed for the cost of their meals up to $40 per day.
WHAT HAPPENS IF YOUR CHILD IS INJURED FROM BEING IN THIS STUDY? 
If you believe that your child has been injured as a result of this research you should contact 
Philippe Backeljauw, MD as soon as possible to discuss the concerns.  Treatment for injuries is 
available at CCHMC.  If your child goes to the Emergency Room or to another hospital or doctor it 
is important that you tell them that your child is in a research study.  If possible, you should give 
them a copy of this parental permission form.
CCHMC follows a policy of making all decisions about compensation for the medical treatment of 
physical injuries that happened during or were caused by research on an individual basis.
WHO DO YOU CALL IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS OR PROBLEMS? 
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956


Page 6 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
For questions, concerns, or complaints about this research study you can contact the study person 
listed on page 1 of this document. If you would like to talk to someone that is not part of the 
research staff or if you have general questions about your research study rights or questions, 
concerns, or complaints about the research, you can call the CCHMC Institutional Review Board at 
513-636-8039. 
AUTHORIZATION FOR USE/DISCLOSURE OF HEALTH INFORMATION FOR RESEARCH
To be in this research study you must also give your permission (or authorization) to use and 
disclose (or share) your child’s “protected health information” (called PHI for short). 
What protected health information will be used and shared during this study?
CCHMC will need to use and share your child’s PHI as part of this study.  This PHI will come from:

Your child’s CCHMC medical records

Your child’s research records.
The types of information that will be used and shared from these records include:

Laboratory test results, diagnosis, and medications

Reports and notes from clinical and research observations.

Imaging (like CT scans, MRI scans, x-rays, etc.) studies and reports

If applicable, information concerning HIV testing or the treatment of AIDS or AIDS-related 
conditions, drug or alcohol abuse, drug-related conditions, alcoholism, and/or 
psychiatric/psychological conditions (but not psychotherapy notes).
Who will share, receive and/or use your child’s protected health information in this study?

Staff at all the research study sites (including CCHMC)

Personnel who provide services to your child as part of this study

Other individuals and organizations that need to use your child’s PHI in connection with the 
research, including people at the sponsor and organizations that the sponsor may use to 
oversee or conduct the study.

The members of the CCHMC Institutional Review Board and staff of the Office of Research 
Compliance and Regulatory Affairs.
How will you know that your child’s PHI is not misused?
People that receive your child’s PHI as part of the research are generally limited in how they can 
use your child’s PHI.  In addition, most people who receive your child’s PHI are also required by 
federal privacy laws to protect your child’s PHI.  However, some people that may receive your 
child’s PHI may not be required to protect it and may share the information with others without your 
permission, if permitted by the laws that apply to them.  
Can you change your mind?
You may choose to withdraw your permission at any time.  A withdrawal of your permission to use 
and share your child’s PHI would also include a withdrawal from participation in the research study.  
If you wish to withdraw your permission to use and share your child’s PHI you need to notify the 
study doctor, listed on the first page of this document, in writing.  Your request will be effective 
immediately and no new PHI about your child will be used or shared.  The only exceptions are (1) 
any use or sharing of PHI that has already occurred or was in process prior to you withdrawing 
your permission and (2) any use or sharing that is needed to maintain the integrity of the research.
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956


Page 7 of 7
Treatment – Parental Permission                                                                                                                          Version 11
Will this permission expire?
Your permission will expire at the end of the study.  If the study involves the creation or 
maintenance of a research database repository, this authorization will not expire. 
Will your child’s other medical care be impacted?
By signing this document you agree for child to participate in this research study and give 
permission to CCHMC to use and share your child’s PHI for the purpose of this research study.  If 
you refuse to sign this document your child will not be able to participate in the study.  However, 
your child’s rights concerning treatment not related to this study, payment for services, enrollment 
in a health plan or eligibility of benefits will not be affected.
SIGNATURES
The research team has discussed this study with you and answered all of your questions.  Like any 
research, the researchers cannot predict exactly what will happen. Once you have had enough 
time to consider whether your child should participate in this research you will document your 
permission by signature below.  
You will receive a copy of this signed document for your records. 
_____________________________________             
Printed Name of Research Participant
         
____________________________________            ____________ 
Signature of Parent or Legally Authorized
           Date
Representative* 
_______________________________________________________________
*If signed by a legally authorized representative, a description of such representative’s authority 
must be provided
_____________________________________   
____________ 
Signature of Individual Obtaining Consent
Date
CCH IRB Approval Date: 4/23/2021
IRB Number: 2017-1956