Give you a statement and table with its title in Markdown format, please determine whether the statement is supported or refuted by, or is unrelated to the table. It'a binary classification problem, you should choose the answer between supported and refuted. Table cells in one row are seperated by '|', and different rows are seperated by '
'.

Table:
| name | appointed | term expiration | appointing governor | law school attended |
| chief judge jonathan lippman | 2009 | 2015 | david paterson , democrat | new york university school of law |
| judge victoria a graffeo | 2000 | 2014 | george pataki , republican | albany law school |
| judge susan phillips read | 2003 | 2017 | george pataki , republican | university of chicago law school |
| judge robert s smith | 2004 | 2014 | george pataki , republican | columbia law school |
| judge eugene f pigott , jr | 2006 | 2016 | george pataki , republican | university at buffalo law school |
| judge jenny rivera | 2013 | 2027 | andrew cuomo , democrat | new york university school of law |
| judge sheila abdus - salaam | 2013 | 2027 | andrew cuomo , democrat | columbia law school |
Title:
new york court of appeals
Statement:
judge robert s smith attended columbia law school and was appointed in 2013
Answer:
refuted