Give you a statement and table with its title in Markdown format, please determine whether the statement is supported or refuted by, or is unrelated to the table. It'a binary classification problem, you should choose the answer between supported and refuted. Table cells in one row are seperated by '|', and different rows are seperated by '
'.

Table:
| season | premiered | bachelorette | profile | winner | runner (s) - up | proposal |
| 1 | january 8 , 2003 | trista rehn | physical therapist | ryan sutter | charlie maher | yes |
| 2 | january 14 , 2004 | meredith phillips | makeup artist | ian mckee | matthew hickl | yes |
| 3 | january 10 , 2005 | jennifer schefft | publicist | none | jerry ferris and john paul merritt | no |
| 4 | may 19 , 2008 | deanna pappas | real estate agent | jesse csincsak | jason mesnick | yes |
| 5 | may 18 , 2009 | jillian harris | interior designer | ed swiderski | kiptyn locke | yes |
| 6 | may 24 , 2010 | ali fedotowsky | advertising account manager | roberto martinez | chris lambton | yes |
| 7 | may 23 , 2011 | ashley hebert | dental student | jp rosenbaum | ben flajnik | yes |
| 8 | may 14 , 2012 | emily maynard | children 's hospital event planner | jef holm | arie luyendyk , jr | yes |
| 9 | may 27 , 2013 | desiree hartsock | bridal stylist | chris siegfried | drew kenney | yes |
Title:
the bachelorette
Statement:
meredith phillips is the bachelorette after season 8
Answer:
refuted