Give you a statement and table with its title in Markdown format, please determine whether the statement is supported or refuted by, or is unrelated to the table. It'a binary classification problem, you should choose the answer between supported and refuted. Table cells in one row are seperated by '|', and different rows are seperated by '
'.

Table:
| district | incumbent | party | first elected | result | candidates |
| ohio 7 | samuel shellabarger | republican | 1864 | retired republican hold | james j winans (r) 50.2% john h thomas (d) 49.8% |
| ohio 8 | john beatty | republican | 1868 (s) | re - elected | john beatty (r) 52.0% john h benson (d) 48.0% |
| ohio 10 | james m ashley | republican | 1862 | lost re - election democratic gain | truman h hoag (d) 51.5% james m ashley (d) 48.5% |
| ohio 11 | john thomas wilson | republican | 1866 | re - elected | john thomas wilson (r) 54.2% john sands (d) 45.8% |
| ohio 16 | john bingham | republican | 1864 | re - elected | john bingham (r) 50.8% josiah m estep (d) 49.2% |
Title:
united states house of representatives elections , 1868
Statement:
john beatty (r) 52.0% john h benson (d) 48.0% were the candidates in the election where james m ashley was the incumbent
Answer:
refuted