Give you a statement and table with its title in Markdown format, please determine whether the statement is supported or refuted by, or is unrelated to the table. It'a binary classification problem, you should choose the answer between supported and refuted. Table cells in one row are seperated by '|', and different rows are seperated by '
'.

Table:
| date | tournament | surface | partnering | opponents | score |
| april 10 , 2006 | florianópolis , brazil | clay | júlio silva | máximo gonzález sergio roitman | 6 - 2 , 3 - 6 , |
| march 5 , 2007 | salinas , ecuador | hard | franco ferreiro | scott lipsky david martin | 7 - 5 , 7 - 6 (11 - 9) |
| september 29 , 2008 | aracaju , brazil | clay | joão souza | juan martín aranguren franco ferreiro | 6 - 4 , 6 - 4 |
| november 3 , 2008 | guayaquil , ecuador | clay | ricardo hocevar | sebastián decoud santiago giraldo | 6 - 4 , 6 - 4 |
| may 12 , 2012 | rio quente , brazil | hard | augusto laranja | guido andreozzi marcel felder | 6 - 3 , 6 - 3 |
Title:
thiago alves (tennis)
Statement:
opponents of sebastián decoud santiago giraldo had the surface of clay after november 3 , 2008
Answer:
refuted