Give you a statement and table with its title in Markdown format, please determine whether the statement is supported or refuted by, or is unrelated to the table. It'a binary classification problem, you should choose the answer between supported and refuted. Table cells in one row are seperated by '|', and different rows are seperated by '
'.

Table:
| office | democratic ticket | republican ticket | socialist ticket | independence league ticket | prohibition ticket | socialist labor ticket |
| governor | john alden dix | henry l stimson | charles edward russell | john j hopper | t alexander macnicholl | frank e passanno |
| lieutenant governor | thomas f conway | edward schoeneck | gustave a strebel | william randolph hearst | calvin mccarthy | james t hunter |
| secretary of state | edward lazansky | samuel s koenig | bertha m fraser | thomas p scully | n horace gillette | henry kuhn |
| comptroller | william sohmer | james thompson | orcus a curtis | arnold b macstay | bernard clauson | carl a luedecke |
| attorney general | thomas carmody | edward r o'malley | henry l slobodin | robert stewart | francis e baldwin | lewis f alrutz |
| treasurer | john j kennedy | thomas f fennell | sylvester butler | william i sirovich | charles j call | william a walters |
| state engineer | john a bensel | frank m williams | william lippelt | james a lee | albert w pierson | jeremiah d crowley |
| judge of the court of appeals | frederick collin | irving g vann | morris hillquit | reuben robie lyon | alfred l manierre | charles h chase |
| judge of the court of appeals | irving g vann | frederick collin | louis b boudin | james a allen | gilbert elliott | (none) |
Title:
new york state election , 1910
Statement:
charles h chase is one of the two persons listed on the socialist labor ticket for the judge of the court of appeals
Answer:
refuted