Give you a statement and table with its title in Markdown format, please determine whether the statement is supported or refuted by, or is unrelated to the table. It'a binary classification problem, you should choose the answer between supported and refuted. Table cells in one row are seperated by '|', and different rows are seperated by '
'.

Table:
| district | 2012 commission | 2010 commission | 2007 commission | 2002 commission | 1999 commission |
| district 1 | gloria moon | gloria moon | katie jones | katie jones | jean birmingham |
| district 2 | zephaniah timmins | zephaniah timmins | zephaniah timmins | alonza williams | alonza williams |
| district 3 | john flowers | buddy power | ed carlile | chris horsley | chris horsley |
| district 4 | bill marshall | jack hester | jack hester | jack hester | audrey kariel (mayor) |
| district 5 | charlie oliver | charlie oliver | john wilborn | john wilborn | john wilborn |
| district 6 | chris paddie | chris paddie | michael mcmurry | bryan partee | michael smith |
Title:
none
Statement:
the person on the district 3 2010 commission is charlie oliver
Answer:
refuted