Can I Get Car Insurance With An Open Claim? 
Yes , this happens all the time as insured customers find the claim settlement process of a carrier as adequate , they look purchase a policy form a different insurer . Be up front with your agent . Tell him/her why you want a new policy and if claim settlement has or is expected to be an issue . An independent agent can typically 4 or 5 other choices and eliminate your current carrier form the selection process . 