What Are The Best Rated Auto Insurance Companies? 
What are the best rated auto insurance companies ? Based on my professional opinion and 33 years as one of the nation 's leading auto insurance brokers -LRB- with a top-rated website -RRB- , here are the handful of carriers that are on just about everyone 's list : USAA State Farm Geico Farmers Esurance Liberty Mutual Nationwide Geico Erie American Family Progressive Allstate Travelers I know . That 's a pretty big list ! It 's important to understand that your rate depends on numerous factors , and it is possible that one company offers terrific rates in your area , and is 40 % higher than most other companies in another area . Thus , the importance of utilizing a broker is never bigger . 