Effect of Cation Ordering on the Performance and Chemical Stability of Layered Double Perovskite Cathodes Effect of Cation Ordering on the Performance and Chemical Stability of Layered Double Perovskite Cathodes Bernuy-LopezCarlos1*†Rioja-MonllorLaura1NakamuraTakashi2RicoteSandrine3O’HayreRyan4AmezawaKoji2EinarsrudMari-Ann1 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2709-1219GrandeTor1 1Department of Material Science and Engineering, NTNU Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway; laura-rioja-monllor@ntnu.no (L.R.
-M.); mari-ann.einarsrud@ntnu.no (M.
-A.E.); tor.grande@ntnu.no (T.G.) 2Institute of Multidisciplinary Research for Advanced Materials, Tohoku University, 2-1-1 Katahira Aoba-ku, Sendai 980-8577, Japan; t-naka@tagen.tohoku.ac.jp (T.N.); amezawa@tagen.tohoku.ac.jp (K.A.) 3Department of Mechanical Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO 80401, USA; sricote@mines.edu 4Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, 1500 Illinois St., Golden, CO 80401, USA; rohayre@mines.edu *Correspondence: carlos.bernuy-lopez@sandvik.com; Tel.: +46-26263411 †Current address: AB Sandvik Materials and Technology, R&D, 81181 Sandviken, Sweden. 196 The effect of A-site cation ordering on the cathode performance and chemical stability of A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ and disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are reported.
Symmetric half-cells with a proton-conducting BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ electrolyte were prepared by ceramic processing, and good chemical compatibility of the materials was demonstrated.
Both A-site ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ and A-site disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ yield excellent cathode performance with Area Specific Resistances as low as 7.4 and 11.5 Ω·cm2 at 400 °C and 0.16 and 0.32 Ω·cm2 at 600 °C in 3% humidified synthetic air respectively.
The oxygen vacancy concentration, electrical conductivity, basicity of cations and crystal structure were evaluated to rationalize the electrochemical performance of the two materials.
The combination of high-basicity elements and high electrical conductivity as well as sufficient oxygen vacancy concentration explains the excellent performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials at high temperatures.
At lower temperatures, oxygen-deficiency in both materials is greatly reduced, leading to decreased performance despite the high basicity and electrical conductivity.
A-site cation ordering leads to a higher oxygen vacancy concentration, which explains the better performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ.
Finally, the more pronounced oxygen deficiency of the cation ordered polymorph and the lower chemical stability at reducing conditions were confirmed by coulometric titration. proton ceramic fuel cells (PCFC) cathode layered double perovskite 1.
Introduction Proton ceramic fuel cells (PCFC) can potentially overcome some of the challenges currently limiting the commercial application of conventional solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) [1,2,3,4].
The main difference between conventional SOFCs and PCFCs is the electrolyte material.
While SOFCs employ oxide-ion conducting electrolytes, PCFCs make use of proton-conducting electrolytes instead.
As the activation energy for protons is lower than for oxide ions, PCFCs can operate at lower temperatures than conventional SOFCs, i.e., 400–600 °C [5] vs. 700–900 °C.
However, one of the main issues confronting PCFCs is the lack of high performance cathode materials [1].
A suitable cathode material for PCFCs must facilitate the reduction of oxygen to water by reacting with protons that diffuse through the proton-conducting electrolyte.
An ideal high-performance cathode material should combine the conduction of electrons (or holes), oxide ions and protons at the same time [6,7].
Equally important, the material must be chemically stable at the operating conditions.
Mixed oxide-ion- and electron-conducting materials with a perovskite structure are the most promising cathodes so far.
Unfortunately, the best cathode materials for conventional SOFCs, such as La0.6Sr0.4Co0.2Fe0.8O3−δ (LSCF) [8] and Ba0.5Sr0.5Co0.8Fe0.2O3−δ (BSCF) [8], do not seem to present proton conductivity despite their good electronic and oxide-ion conductivities.
Several key parameters in perovskite oxides can be tuned to enhance proton conductivity while ensuring good electronic and oxide-ion-conductivity: these include crystallographic structure, oxygen vacancy concentration, electrical conductivity and basicity [6,9,10,11].
Regarding the crystallographic structure it is established that cubic structures favor both ionic and electronic conductivity [5].
In respect to the oxygen vacancy concentration, high oxygen vacancy concentration can enhance proton conductivity at intermediate temperatures as a result of the Wagner hydration reaction [12,13]: H 2 O + V O • • + O O x ↔ 2 OH O • In addition, electrical conductivity above 1 S/cm is required for adequate cathode performance [3].
Finally, high Ba content is desirable as it leads to higher oxide basicity and thereby a greater degree of protonation of the oxygen vacancies [13,14].
Layered double perovskite materials with the general formula LnBaM2O5+δ (Ln = lanthanide or Y; M = transition metal) have been studied as potential electrodes for both PCFC [15,16,17,18] and SOFC due to their outstanding mixed electronic and oxide-ion conductivities [19,20].
Ln and Ba occupy the A-site in this double perovskite AA′B2O6-type crystal structure, while M occupies the B-site.
A-site cation ordering is adopted due to the large difference of size between Ba and Ln with LnO and BaO layers in dodecahedral coordination separated with MO6 layers in octahedral coordination [21].
Cation ordering results in a decrease of symmetry.
Layered double perovskite materials can adopt large concentrations of oxygen vacancies and depending on the size of Ln and the nature of M, the material will adopt either a tetragonal or an orthorhombic symmetry as vacancy ordering occurs [22].
A-site cation ordering is reported to be beneficial for oxide-ion conductivity [23] while the ordering of the oxygen vacancies is detrimental [24].
Strandbakke et al. have reported outstanding performance for the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ [16] as a PCFC cathode with Area Specific Resistances (ASR) as low as 6 Ω·cm2 at 400 °C and 3% H2O in air.
The large oxygen vacancy concentration adopted by the layered double perovskite seems to favor proton incorporation and sufficient proton conductivity.
The performance is comparable to that of mixed electron/proton conducting single perovskite materials such as BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ (BCFZY) [3] (ASR = 10 Ω·cm2 at 400 °C in 3% humidified air), although the benefits of the layered double perovskite crystal structure are still unclear.
LaBaCo2O5+δ represents an interesting model system to study the influence of ordering effects on the performance of PCFC cathode materials.
In addition to the A-site ordered phase, this material can also adopt an A-site cation disordered cubic structure, represented as La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ, due to the larger size of La compared with other Ln elements.
In our recent work [25], we demonstrated that the ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ phase is a metastable variant of the A-site cation disordered phase, La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ.
Several authors have studied the effects of A-site cation ordering on the performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ for SOFC application [26,27,28], although it has yet to be studied for PCFC application.
Both the ordered and disordered variants demonstrate low polarization resistances at temperatures as low as 600 °C (<0.2 Ω·cm2) due to the excellent mixed conducting (electron hole and oxide-ion) nature of the material.
In addition, Garces et al. have studied the influence of the A-site cation ordering on the mixed electronic and oxide-ion conducting properties in this system [29,30].
They obtained a noticeable improvement of performance with A-site cation ordering (0.35 Ω·cm2 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ vs. 0.12 Ω·cm2 for LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600 °C in air).
In this work, we examine proton conducting electrolyte supported symmetric cells employing both A-site cation ordered and disordered materials (LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ) to evaluate the effect of A-site cation ordering on performance for PCFC cathode applications.
Cathode performance is evaluated by impedance spectroscopy and the results are analyzed with respect to crystal structure, basicity, oxygen content and ordering, and electrical conductivity.
Finally, chemical compatibility between the cathode and the electrolyte is reported as well as chemical stability and oxygen deficiency by coulometric titration. 2.
Experimental 2.1.
Preparation of the Materials La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ was obtained by spray pyrolysis (Cerpotech AS, Tiller, Norway, purity > 99%) of nitrate precursors as described elsewhere [25].
The as-sprayed powders were calcined at 1100 °C for 12 h in air in order to obtain a single pure phase.
LaBaCo2O5+δ was obtained by calcining La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in slightly lower pO2 (N2 atmosphere, pO2 ~ 10−4 atm) at 1100 °C for 12 h.
Phase purity for all materials were determined using a Bruker D8 Advance DaVinci X-ray diffractometer (Trondheim, Norway).
BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ (BZY10) powder was prepared by spray pyrolysis (Cerpotech AS, Tiller, Norway, purity > 99%) of nitrate precursors as described elsewhere [31].
Green pellets of 20 mm diameter were prepared and sintered at 1650 °C for 10 h as described by Sazinas et al. [32].
Prior to electrode deposition, the pellets were polished with SiC paper and washed with ethanol.
Electrode slurries of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ were prepared by mixing 5 g of each powder with 1 g dispersant (20 wt % solsperse 28,000 (Lubrizol, Wickliffe, OH, USA) dissolved in terpineol), and 0.3 g binder (5 wt % V-006 (Heraeus, Hanau, Germany) dissolved in terpineol).
Electrolyte-supported symmetric cells for LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ were produced by screen painting the corresponding slurries on both sides of a dense BZY10 pellet (geometrical density >90%).
The thickness of the BZY10 electrolyte was about 800 μm after polishing and electrode thicknesses were ~20–25 μm.
Thickness was checked by scanning electron microscopy (SEM).
SEM images were captured on a field emission gun SEM (Zeiss Ultra 55, Limited Edition, Oberkochen, Germany).
The symmetric cells of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials were fired at 600 °C for 2 h in ambient air to form porous cathode layers.
Gold paste (Fuel Cell Materials) was applied onto the cathodes for current collection followed by in-situ curing.
Pt wires were employed as conducting wires. 2.2.
Electrochemical Characterization Symmetric cells were characterized by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) in dry and moist (pH2O = 0.03 atm) synthetic air and N2 from 600 to 400 °C, at temperature intervals of 50 °C (with a cooling rate of 1 °C/min and 8 h dwell before each measurement) using a ProboStatTM (NorECs AS, Oslo, Norway) set-up and an Alpha A (Novocontrol Technologies, Montabaur, Germany) impedance analyzer.
The signal amplitude was 50 mV under open circuit voltage (OCV) in the 10−2–106 Hz frequency range.
The 3% humidification was achieved by bubbling the gases through distilled water at 25 °C.
The equivalent circuit fitting and analysis of the impedance data were carried out using Zview Software v3.5. 2.3.
Oxygen Deficiency and Chemical Stability Compatibility tests between the electrode and the electrolyte materials were performed by mixing together about 1 g each of both materials in an agar mortar for 15 min.
Pellets of 15 mm diameter were fabricated and exposed to different thermal treatments: 1000 °C, 1100 °C and 1200 °C for 72 h at each temperature.
High Temperature X-ray diffraction (HT-XRD) measurements were performed using a Bruker D8 Advance diffractometer equipped with an MRI TCP20 high temperature camera (Sendai, Japan).
A Pt strip-type resistive heater functioned as the sample support.
XRD patterns (20–85°, about 30 min collection time) were recorded from 600 to 1200 °C in air, at 100 °C intervals.
An S-type thermocouple was used for temperature determination using the radiant heater.
The heating rate and dwell time before data collection were 0.1 °C/s and 10 min respectively Finally, coulometric titration of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials was performed to determine the oxygen content and the chemical stability of these materials below 10−4 bar.
The details of the experiment and the set-up are given elsewhere [33,34]. 3.
Results 3.1.
Microstructure of the Symmetric Cells X-ray diffraction of the two materials, as reported in our previous work [25], established the phase purity and crystal structure: cubic for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and tetragonal for LaBaCo2O5+δ.
Figure 1 provides representative low and high-magnification SEM images of a La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ symmetric cell.
Despite the low preparation temperature of the symmetric cells, sufficient adherence to the electrolyte was obtained.
Higher processing temperatures lead to delamination and poor adherence of the electrolyte.
Electrode thickness of about 20 μm and average grain size below ~1 μm are observed.
LaBaCo2O5+δ shows similar microstructure as shown in Figure S1. 3.2.
Electrochemical Performance Figure 2 depicts typical Nyquist plots obtained for symmetric cells of the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ materials in moist synthetic air at 500 °C.
Both A-site cation disordered and ordered materials present similar Nyquist plots for all temperatures as illustrated in Figure 2.
Two main contributions coming from the electrolyte and the electrode are observed.
The equivalent circuit model used to fit the data is LR (RQ)(RQ)(RQ), where L, R and Q are inductance, resistance and constant phase element respectively.
The resistor (RBZY10_1) and the first RQ element (RBZY10_2 and CPEBZY10_2, blue semicircle) are assigned to the electrolyte of the symmetric cells.
The two other RQ elements (i.e., RSP_1, CPESP_1, RSP_2, CPESP_2, green and violet semicircles respectively for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ) correspond to the electrode response of the cells.
The assignment of these electrochemical processes was carried out by evaluating the pseudocapacitance of the RQ elements (Table S1 for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ) obtained with the electrochemical model: i.e., La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ; ~10−10 F/cm2 for the first RQ element, assigned as the response of the electrolyte [8,9,10,35,36,37,38,39,40,41]; ~10−4 F/cm2 and 10−2 F/cm2 for the other two RQ elements, assigned as the response of the electrode [8,9,10,35,36,37,38,39,40,41].
Total cathode Area Specific Resistances (ASRs) were obtained by dividing the sum of the electrode resistances (i.e., RSP_1 and RSP_2 in Figure 2 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ) by two.
Division by a factor of two accounts for the fact that the combined contribution from two cathode electrode responses are measured in symmetric cell testing.
Resulting cathode ASR values of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are shown in Figure 3 in 3% moist synthetic air.
Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials exhibit excellent performance in the temperature range 400–600 °C.
Despite the similar microstructure of both materials, the A-site cation ordered material LaBaCo2O5+δ gives a better performance than the A-site disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ material.
Cathode ASR values for LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600 and 400 °C are 0.15 and 7.4 Ω·cm2, respectively.
The corresponding values for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 600 and 400 °C are 0.32 and 11.5 Ω·cm2, respectively.
Activation energies are also given in Figure 3 for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials, with higher Ea for A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ.
For each material, the total electrode response can be deconvoluted in two main processes: an intermediate/middle frequency (RSP_1CPESP_1) process and a low frequency process (RSP_2CPESP_2).
The intermediate frequency (MF) process exhibits lower pseudocapacitances than the low frequency (LF) process (~10−4 F/cm2 vs. 10−2 F/cm2).
The deconvolution of the electrochemical data for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials is shown in Figure 4.
Similar trends are observed for both materials: below 550 °C, the LF process appears to be rate limiting, while the MF process becomes limiting at higher temperatures.
Further investigation, e.g., pO2- and pH2O-dependent experiments would be needed to further assign these MF and LF processes to specific electrochemical reactions taking place in the electrode [39].
Figure 5 shows the Nyquist plots for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in N2 atmosphere at 500 °C in dry (Figure 5a) and moist conditions (Figure 5b).
ASR values for the electrode contribution extracted from these data are represented in Figure 6.
It is found that the ASR decreases in N2 when the atmosphere is humidified.
It can also be observed that A-site cation ordering does not give any improvement in the ASR as both A-site cation ordered and disordered materials lead to the same performance in moist conditions at low pO2. 3.3.
Chemical Stability The chemical potential of oxygen and stability of the two polymorphs in reducing conditions were investigated by coulometric titration and the results are shown in Figure 7.
The oxygen deficiency increases with decreasing oxygen partial pressure as expected, but the slope is significantly different for the two polymorphs.
The difference in slope demonstrates the superior stability of Co in a higher oxidation state in La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ relative to LaBaCo2O5+δ.
This is further confirmed by the onset of decomposition (vertical relationship of stoichiometry versus pO2) of LaBaCo2O5+δ at a higher pO2 relative to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at constant temperature.
Moreover, the coulometric data also proves that the cation-ordered phase tolerates a higher oxygen deficiency before decomposition although this could be an effect of the kinetics of the decomposition reaction.
The thermal stability of LaBaCo2O5+δ in air was studied by high temperature X-ray diffraction and the diffraction patterns are shown in Figure 8.
Only thermal expansion of LaBaCo2O5+δ was observed up to 1100 °C.
These data are consistent with our previous study [25] where LaBaCo2O5+δ was shown to remain tetragonal at high temperature with a P4/mmm as space group.
This means that the material remains A-site ordered at the studied temperature range (RT-800 °C).
However, Figure 8 shows that LaBaCo2O5+δ starts to transform into La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 1100 °C, with complete disappearance of the splitting of the Bragg reflections due to the loss of A-site cation ordering at 1200 °C (Figure 8b).
This means that there is a phase transition from tetragonal P4/mmm structure of LaBaCo2O5+δ to cubic P 3 ̄ m m m structure of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ close to 1100 °C in air.
Finally, a good compatibility between both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials and BZY10 electrolyte material is demonstrated by X-ray diffraction of powder mixtures annealed at different temperatures (Figure S2).
Temperatures close to 1200 °C for 72 h are required to initiate (minor) secondary phase formation in a powder mixture of the two materials with the electrolyte.
Both PCFC operation temperatures (400–600 °C) and electrode sintering temperature (600 °C) are well below the temperature where cathode/electrolyte reactions are observed to initiate. 4.
Discussion 4.1.
Comparison with Literature Figure 9 compares the performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials with the two best PCFC cathode materials reported in the literature: the single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ (BCFZY) [3] and the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ (LGBC) [16].
The comparison is carried out by taking literature data measured in the same configuration (four-electrode measurements of electrolyte supported symmetric cells), rather than complete fuel cells.
One well known issue with symmetric cell measurements involving PCFC electrolytes in oxidizing atmospheres is the influence of the parasitic p-type conductivity of the electrolyte itself [16] on the apparent measured cathode ASR (especially at high temperatures) [42].
This parasitic p-type electronic conductivity leads to an overestimation of the performance of the electrode and makes the interpretation of the data more complex.
Thus, it is not recommended to compare cathode ASR results obtained from complete fuel cells to the results obtained from symmetric cell studies.
Symmetric cell comparisons, however, are likely to be reasonable if the investigations employ similar electrolyte compositions and thicknesses.
Based on such symmetric cell comparisons, the performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are comparable to LGBC and BCFZY, with even better performance at temperatures above 500 °C.
These comparisons underscore the high potential of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials as PCFC cathodes.
Activation energies are summarized in Figure 9.
Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials have higher activation energies than LGBC and BCFZY, which suggests differences in the electrode electrochemical mechanism.
A preliminary assignment of the electrochemical mechanism can be suggested by looking at the temperature dependence of the deconvoluted electrochemical processes shown in Figure 4.
The low frequency process is hardly dependent on the temperature which may be assigned to the oxygen adsorption/dissociation processes at all, while the intermediate frequency process may be assigned to charge transfer processes due to the higher temperature dependency of this process.
This is consistent with previous works in the literature on materials with similar perovskite structure [16,38].
In addition to this, it is well-known that the microstructure of cathode materials plays a crucial role for the electrochemical properties.
Adler et al. [43] published a detailed study on the electrode kinetics of porous mixed-conducting oxygen electrodes based on oxide-ion conducting electrolyte, using a continuum modeling to analyze the oxygen reduction reaction.
Furthermore, Strandbakke et al. [44] showed that pre-exponential values of the Arrhenius plot are indicative of the microstructure impact in the electrochemical performance.
A similar microstructure for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials can be seen in Figure S1 and can also be confirmed with the similar pre-exponential values calculated from Figure 9 (13.55 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and 14.75 for LaBaCo2O5+δ).
However, experiments at different pO2 and pH2O and more detailed microstructure studies (determination of the tortuosity, surface area, etc.) are necessary to successfully assign the electrochemical processes and to correlate them with the electrode microstructure [39].
Table 1 summarizes the structure, Ba content, performance, oxygen content and electrical conductivities of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ.
The table also includes data for BCFZY [3,13] and LGBC [16,43].
Therefore, due to the similar microstructure discussed previously we attempt a correlation between all these parameters to help rationalize the performance differences between these various cathode materials. 4.2.
Correlation between ASR, Electrical Conductivity, Basicity and Oxygen Content The ASR and the oxygen content as a function of temperature for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials are shown in Figure 10a.
Likewise, the ASR and the electrical conductivity vs. temperature are plotted in Figure 10b.
Data for the single perovskite BCFZY [3,13] and the layered double perovskite LGBC [16,45] materials extracted from the literature are added for comparison.
Two observations are evident from these two figures: (1) a lower oxygen deficiency of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ compared to BCFZY and LGBC; (2) a significantly lower (nearly two orders of magnitude) electrical conductivity for BCFZY.
The lower performance of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in comparison to LaBaCo2O5+δ at lower temperatures can be explained by the lower oxygen vacancy concentration in La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ as shown in Figure 10.
The enhanced low-temperature oxygen vacancy concentrations for both LGBC and BCFZY materials appear to be consistent with their higher low-temperature cathode performance.
Protonation of oxygen vacancies generally increases with oxide basicity [13,14].
All else being equal, it is therefore expected that more basic materials will have higher performance levels as PCFC cathodes.
In addition, higher oxygen vacancy concentration should drive higher protonation according to Le Chatelier’s principle.
Zohourian et al. [13] and Strandbakke et al. [16] have measured the hydration level in BCFZY and LGBC.
Despite their high level of oxygen vacancies both materials are only able to hydrolyze 1% of the available oxygen vacancies at 400 °C.
Because of its higher basicity, a greater fraction of vacancies is expected to be hydrolyzed in BCFZY.
Nevertheless, Figure 9 and Table 1 show that at 400 °C the performance of the layered double perovskite material is better than the materials with single perovskite structure.
One possible explanation of this difference could be that A-site cation ordering enhances protonation due to the different local environments of the oxygen vacancies in the two crystal structures.
The similar performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ and LGBC can also be explained by the higher basicity of the A-site cations in LaBaCo2O5+δ.
A-site cation ordering in LaBaCo2O5+δ leads to higher performance [30] due to the higher oxygen vacancy concentration as shown in Figure 10a.
The higher oxygen vacancy concentration and therefore higher degree of protonation could rationalize the higher performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ compared to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ Furthermore, both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ as well as BCFZY have been shown to be very good oxide ion conductors [26,27,28,46].
Therefore, the main difference in performance between BCFZY and both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials may arise from the differences in electrical conductivity as shown in Figure 10b in addition to a difference in proton conductivity.
Measurements in low pO2 conditions have been proposed in order to eliminate the presence of oxide-ions and isolate the proton conduction contribution when examining prospective PCFC cathodes [16].
As shown in Figure 5, a decrease in ASR and Ea for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is observed in humidified inert atmosphere (pO2 = 10−4 atm).
This decrease may suggest the presence of proton conductivity in the material, and is similar to what was observed for LGBC by Strandbakke et al. [16]. 4.3.
Chemical Stability of the Two Polymorphs Previous studies of the oxygen non-stoichiometry of the two polymorphs have suggested that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is the most stable polymorph at oxidation conditions and low temperature [25].
The coulometric titration data (Figure 7) confirms that the oxygen content of LaBaCo2O5+δ is lower than La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ independent of temperature and oxygen partial pressure.
The lower oxygen partial pressure at the decomposition suggests that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is more stable than LaBaCo2O5+δ also under reducing conditions.
It has previously been shown that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ can be transformed to LaBaCo2O5+δ by annealing in N2 at 1100 °C [25], while we demonstrated in this work that the transverse phase transition is observed in air close to 1100 °C.
Based on these two observations LaBaCo2O5+δ is the stable polymorph at inert conditions and LaBaCo2O5+δ the most stable in air close to 1100 °C.
Evidence for a phase transition between the two polymorphs could not be obtained by coulometric titration up to 800 °C (Figure 7).
The phase transition is however reconstructive in nature and only occurs above a critical temperature for sufficient cation mobility.
It is therefore likely that true equilibrium between the two phases could not be obtained during the coulometric titration before decomposition.
Additional measurements are therefore required to determine accurately the relative stability of the two polymorphs and the T-pO2 dependence of the phase transition between the two polymorphs. 5.
Conclusions LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials have been tested as cathodes for protonic ceramic fuel cells and both exhibit good stabilities.
The A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material possesses better performance than the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials with ASR values as low as 7.4 and 0.16 Ω·cm2 at 400 and 600 °C respectively.
Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ demonstrate competitive performance with the best state-of-the-art cathode materials BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ and La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ.
Oxygen vacancy concentration, electrical conductivity, crystal structure and basicity are shown to be key, interconnected parameters that govern PCFC cathode performance.
The A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material exhibits better performance at low temperature than the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ material because it retains higher oxygen vacancy concentration at low temperatures.
In addition, A-site cation ordering is hypothesized to increase the basicity of the oxygen vacancies, making them more likely to hydrate.
The similar low-temperature performance of A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material vs.
La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ (LGBC) may be explained by an increase of the basicity in LaBaCo2O5+δ.
As the temperature increases, the A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material shows better relative performance compared to the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ due to the increase in oxygen vacancy concentration.
This work shows the importance of understanding and controlling crystal structure, basicity, oxygen vacancy concentration and electrical conductivity in order to improve PCFC cathode materials while keeping an eye on the chemical stability of the material.
Acknowledgments Financial support from The Research Council of Norway under the program NANO2021 to the project (number 228355) “Functional oxides for clean energy technologies: fuel cells, gas separation membranes and electrolysers” (FOXCET) conducted by SINTEF Materials and Chemistry, University of Oslo and The Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) in Trondheim, is gratefully acknowledged. R. O’Hayre acknowledges support from the U.S. Army Research Office under Grant Number W911NF-17-1-0051. Support from The Norwegian University of Science and Technology Publishing Fund is also acknowledged. Supplementary Materials Click here for additional data file. The following are available online at http://www.mdpi.com/1996-1944/11/2/196/s1, Figure S1: Scanning electron micrographs of fractured cross sections from tested electrolyte supported symmetric cells of for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ. Figure S2: X-ray diffraction patterns showing the reactivity of BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ with La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 1000 °C, 1100 °C and 1200 °C for 72 h. Impurities, shown by asterisks at 1200 °C, are identified as LaCoO3 and BaCoO3. Table S1: Area specific resistances (R) and pseudo-capacitance (C) values from the fitting of the electrochemical model for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ. Author Contributions C.B.-L., L.R.-M., S.R. and T.N. conceived and designed the experiments; performed the experiments; analyzed the data and wrote the paper. R.O., K.A., M.-A.E. and T.G. conceived and designed the experiments; analyzed the data and wrote the paper. Conflicts of Interest The authors declare no conflict of interest. References 1. EbbesenS.D.JensenS.H.HauchA.MogensenM.B. High Temperature Electrolysis in Alkaline Cells, Solid Proton Conducting Cells, and Solid Oxide Cells Chem. Rev. 2014 114 10697 10734 10.1021/cr5000865 25283178 2. BiL.BoulfradS.TraversaE. Steam electrolysis by solid oxide electrolysis cells (SOECs) with proton-conducting oxides Chem. Soc. Rev. 2014 43 8255 8270 10.1039/C4CS00194J 25134016 3. DuanC.TongJ.ShangM.NikodemskiS.SandersM.RicoteS.AlmansooriA.O’HayreR. Readily processed protonic ceramic fuel cells with high performance at low temperatures Science 2015 349 1321 1326 10.1126/science.aab3987 26217064 4. KimJ.SengodanS.KwonG.DingD.ShinJ.LiuM.KimG. Triple-Conducting Layered Perovskites as Cathode Materials for Proton-Conducting Solid Oxide Fuel Cells ChemSusChem 2014 7 2811 2815 10.1002/cssc.201402351 25146887 5. KreuerK.D. Proton-Conducting Oxides Ann. Rev. Mater. Res. 2003 33 333 359 10.1146/annurev.matsci.33.022802.091825 6. ShangM.TongJ.O’HayreR. A promising cathode for intermediate temperature protonic ceramic fuel cells: BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.2O3−δ RSC Adv. 2013 3 15769 15775 10.1039/c3ra41828f 7. ZhangC.ZhaoH. A novel cobalt-free cathode material for proton-conducting solid oxide fuel cells J. Mater. Chem. 2012 22 18387 18394 10.1039/c2jm32627b 8. DaillyJ.FourcadeS.LargeteauA.MauvyF.GrenierJ.C.MarronyM. Perovskite and A2MO4-type oxides as new cathode materials for protonic solid oxide fuel cells Electrochim. Acta 2010 55 5847 5853 10.1016/j.electacta.2010.05.034 9. MerkleR.PoetzschD.MaierJ. Oxygen Reduction Reaction at Cathodes on Proton Conducting Oxide Electrolytes: Contribution from Three Phase Boundary Compared to Bulk Path ECS Trans. 2015 66 95 102 10.1149/06602.0095ecst 10. PoetzschD.MerkleR.MaierJ. Oxygen Reduction at Dense Thin-Film Microelectrodes on a Proton-Conducting Electrolyte: I. Considerations on Reaction Mechanism and Electronic Leakage Effects J. Electrochem. Soc. 2015 162 F939 F950 10.1149/2.0951508jes 11. BahoutM.PramanaS.S.HanlonJ.M.DorcetV.SmithR.I.PaofaiS.SkinnerS.J. Stability of NdBaCo2−xMnxO5+δ (x = 0, 0.5) layered perovskites under humid conditions investigated by high-temperature in situ neutron powder diffraction J. Mater. Chem. A 2015 3 15420 15431 10.1039/C5TA02776D 12. PoetzschD.MerkleR.MaierJ. Proton conductivity in mixed-conducting BSFZ perovskite from thermogravimetric relaxation Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2014 16 16446 16453 10.1039/C4CP00459K 24984257 13. ZohourianR.MerkleR.MaierJ. Proton uptake into the protonic cathode material BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.2O3−δ and comparison to protonic electrolyte materials Solid State Ion. 2017 299 64 69 10.1016/j.ssi.2016.09.012 14. GryaznovD.MerkleR.KotominE.A.MaierJ. Ab initio modelling of oxygen vacancies and protonic defects in La1−xSrxFeO3−δ perovskite solid solutions J. Mater. Chem. A 2016 4 13093 13104 10.1039/C6TA04109D 15. GrimaudA.BassatJ.M.MauvyF.PolletM.WattiauxA.MarronyM.GrenierJ.C. Oxygen reduction reaction of PrBaCo2−xFexO5+δ compounds as H+-SOFC cathodes: Correlation with physical properties J. Mater. Chem. A 2014 2 3594 3604 10.1039/c3ta13956e 16. StrandbakkeR.CherepanovV.A.ZuevA.Y.TsvetkovD.S.ArgirusisC.SourkouniG.PrünteS.NorbyT. Gd- and Pr-based double perovskite cobaltites as oxygen electrodes for proton ceramic fuel cells and electrolyser cells Solid State Ion. 2015 278 120 132 10.1016/j.ssi.2015.05.014 17. MaoX.YuT.MaG. Performance of cobalt-free double-perovskite NdBaFe2−xMnxO5+δ cathode materials for proton-conducting IT-SOFC J. Alloys Compd. 2015 637 286 290 10.1016/j.jallcom.2015.02.001 18. SinghK.BaralA.K.ThangaduraiV. Electrochemical Studies of Gd0.5Pr0.5BaCo2O5+δ (GPBC) Cathode for Oxide Ion and Proton Conducting Solid Oxide Fuel Cells Solid State Ion. 2016 288 351 356 10.1016/j.ssi.2015.12.010 19. PelosatoR.CordaroG.StucchiD.CristianiC.DotelliG. Cobalt based layered perovskites as cathode material for intermediate temperature Solid Oxide Fuel Cells: A brief review J. Power Sources 2015 298 46 67 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2015.08.034 20. SengodanS.ChoiS.JunA.ShinT.H.JuY.W.JeongH.Y.ShinJ.IrvineJ.T.S.KimG. Layered oxygen-deficient double perovskite as an efficient and stable anode for direct hydrocarbon solid oxide fuel cells Nat. Mater. 2015 14 205 209 10.1038/nmat4166 25532072 21. KingG.WoodwardP.M. Cation ordering in perovskites J. Mater. Chem. 2010 20 5785 5796 10.1039/b926757c 22. MaignanA.MartinC.PelloquinD.NguyenN.RaveauB. Structural and Magnetic Studies of Ordered Oxygen-Deficient Perovskites LnBaCo2O5+δ, Closely Related to the “112” Structure J. Solid State Chem. 1999 142 247 260 10.1006/jssc.1998.7934 23. Muñoz-GilD.Ávila-BrandeD.Urones-GarroteE.García-MartínS. Ordering effects in the crystal structure and electrochemical properties of the Gd0.5Ba0.5Mn0.5Fe0.5O3−δ perovskite Dalton Trans. 2015 44 10867 10874 10.1039/C4DT03873H 25881558 24. KuangX.AllixM.IbbersonR.M.ClaridgeJ.B.NiuH.RosseinskyM.J. Oxygen Vacancy Ordering Phenomena in the Mixed-Conducting Hexagonal Perovskite Ba7Y2Mn3Ti2O20 Chem. Mater. 2007 19 2884 2893 10.1021/cm0626740 25. Bernuy-LopezC.HøydalsvikK.EinarsrudM.-A.GrandeT. Effect of A-Site Cation Ordering on Chemical Stability, Oxygen Stoichiometry and Electrical Conductivity in Layered LaBaCo2O5+δ Double Perovskite Materials 2016 9 154 10.3390/ma9030154 28773279 26. SetevichC.MogniL.CaneiroA.PradoF. Characterization of the La1−xBaxCoO3−δ (0 ≤ x≤ 1) System as Cathode Material for IT-SOFC J. Electrochem. Soc. 2011 159 B72 B79 10.1149/2.043201jes 27. SetevichC.F.MogniL.V.CaneiroA.PradoF.D. Optimum cathode configuration for IT-SOFC using La0.4Ba0.6CoO3−δ and Ce0.9Gd0.1O1.95 Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2012 37 14895 14901 10.1016/j.ijhydene.2012.01.155 28. PangS.JiangX.LiX.SuZ.XuH.XuQ.ChenC. Characterization of cation-ordered perovskite oxide LaBaCo2O5+δ as cathode of intermediate-temperature solid oxide fuel cells Int. J. Hydrogen Energy 2012 37 6836 6843 10.1016/j.ijhydene.2012.01.056 29. GarcesD.SetevichC.F.CaneiroA.CuelloG.J.MogniL. Effect of cationic order-disorder on the transport properties of LaBaCo2O6−δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ perovskites J. Appl. Crystallogr. 2014 47 325 334 10.1107/S1600576713031233 30. GarcésD.SoldatiA.L.TroianiH.Montenegro-HernándezA.CaneiroA.MogniL.V. La/Ba-based cobaltites as IT-SOFC cathodes: A discussion about the effect of crystal structure and microstructure on the O2-reduction reaction Electrochim. Acta 2016 215 637 646 10.1016/j.electacta.2016.08.132 31. DahlP.I.LeinH.L.YuY.TolchardJ.GrandeT.EinarsrudM.-A.KjølsethC.NorbyT.HaugsrudR. Microstructural characterization and electrical properties of spray pyrolyzed conventionally sintered or hot-pressed BaZrO3 and BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ Solid State Ion. 2011 182 32 40 10.1016/j.ssi.2010.11.032 32. SažinasR.Bernuy-LópezC.EinarsrudM.A.GrandeT. Effect of CO2 exposure on the chemical stability and mechanical properties of BaZrO3-ceramics J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 2016 99 3685 3695 10.1111/jace.14395 33. LingY.WangF.BudimanR.A.NakamuraT.AmezawaK. Oxygen nonstoichiometry, the defect equilibrium model and thermodynamic quantities of the Ruddlesden–Popper oxide Sr3Fe2O7−δ Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2015 17 7489 7497 10.1039/C4CP05719H 25704444 34. MizusakiJ.MoriN.TakaiH.YonemuraY.MinamiueH.TagawaH.DokiyaM.InabaH.NarayaK.SasamotoT. Oxygen nonstoichiometry and defect equilibrium in the perovskite-type oxides La1−xSrxMnO3+δ Solid State Ion. 2000 129 163 177 10.1016/S0167-2738(99)00323-9 35. IrvineJ.T.S.SinclairD.C.WestA.R. Electroceramics: Characterization by Impedance Spectroscopy Adv. Mater. 1990 2 132 138 10.1002/adma.19900020304 36. BausáN.SolísC.StrandbakkeR.SerraJ.M. Development of composite steam electrodes for electrolyzers based on barium zirconate Solid State Ion. 2017 306 62 68 10.1016/j.ssi.2017.03.020 37. RicoteS.BonanosN.LenrickF.WallenbergR. LaCoO3: Promising cathode material for protonic ceramic fuel cells based on a BaCe0.2Zr0.7Y0.1O3−δ electrolyte J. Power Sources 2012 218 313 319 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2012.06.098 38. RicoteS.BonanosN.RørvikP.M.HaavikC. Microstructure and performance of La0.58Sr0.4Co0.2Fe0.8O3−δ cathodes deposited on BaCe0.2Zr0.7Y0.1O3−δ by infiltration and spray pyrolysis J. Power Sources 2012 209 172 179 10.1016/j.jpowsour.2012.02.090 39. PengR.WuT.LiuW.LiuX.MengG. Cathode processes and materials for solid oxide fuel cells with proton conductors as electrolytes J. Mater. Chem. 2010 20 6218 6225 10.1039/c0jm00350f 40. FabbriE.BiL.PergolesiD.TraversaE. High-performance composite cathodes with tailored mixed conductivity for intermediate temperature solid oxide fuel cells using proton conducting electrolytes Energy Environ. Sci. 2011 4 4984 4993 10.1039/c1ee02361f 41. SolisC.NavarreteL.RoitschS.SerraJ.M. Electrochemical properties of composite fuel cell cathodes for La5.5WO12−δ proton conducting electrolytes J. Mater. Chem. 2012 22 16051 16059 10.1039/c2jm32061d 42. RicoteS.BonanosN.WangH.J.HaugsrudR. Conductivity, transport number measurements and hydration thermodynamics of BaCe0.2Zr0.7Y(0.1−ξ)NiξO(3−δ) Solid State Ion. 2011 185 11 17 10.1016/j.ssi.2010.12.012 43. AdlerS.B.LaneJ.A.SteeleC.H. Electrode Kinetics of Porous Mixed-Conducting Oxygen Electrodes J. Electrochem. Soc. 1996 143 3554 3564 10.1149/1.1837252 44. StrandbakkeR.DyrlieO.HageF.S.NorbyT. Reaction kinetics of protons and oxide ions in LSM/lanthanum tungstate cathodes with Pt nanoparticle activation J. Electrochem. Soc. 2016 163 F507 B515 10.1149/2.0881606jes 45. KimJ.-H.ManthiramA. LnBaCo2O5+δ Oxides as Cathodes for Intermediate-Temperature Solid Oxide Fuel Cells J. Electrochem. Soc. 2008 155 B385 B390 10.1149/1.2839028 46. DuanC.HookD.ChenY.TongJ.O’HayreR. Zr and Y co-doped perovskite as a stable, high performance cathode for solid oxide fuel cells operating below 500 °C Energy Environ. Sci. 2017 10 176 182 10.1039/C6EE01915C Figure 1 Scanning electron microscope pictures of pristine electrolyte supported symmetric cells of non-polished and cracked cross sections samples for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at low (a) and high magnification (b). Figure 2 Nyquist plots for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ (a) and LaBaCo2O5+δ (b) recorded at 500 °C in 3% H2O synthetic air. The red filled circles correspond to the experimental data with selected frequencies (10 KHz, 100 Hz, 1 Hz and 0.1 Hz) shown as open red circles. The equivalent circuit used to fit the data (black line) and Area Specific Resistance (ASR) are shown. The blue semicircle is the element assigned to the electrolyte and both the green and violet semicircles are the elements assigned to the electrode. The data are truncated for clarity. Figure 3 Area Specific Resistances (ASR, Ω·cm2) as a function of temperature for the single perovskite La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and the layered double perovskite LaBaCo2O5+δ materials studied in this work in moist air. The lines represent the slope used to calculate activation energies (Ea). Figure 4 (a) Deconvolution of the Area Specific Resistance (ASR, Ω·cm2) as a function of temperature into the intermediate (IF) and low frequency (LF) processes for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ (a) and LaBaCo2O5+δ (b) together with the activation energies. Figure 5 Nyquist plots for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ recorded at 500 °C in dry N2 (a) and 3% H2O N2 (b). The red filled circles are the experimental data with selected frequencies (10 KHz, 100 Hz, 1 Hz and 0.1 Hz) shown as open red circles. The equivalent circuit used to fit the data (black line) and the Area Specific Resistances (ASR) are shown. The blue semicircle is the element assigned to the electrolyte and both the green and violet semicircles are the elements assigned to the electrode. The data are truncated for clarity. Figure 6 Area Specific Resistance (ASR, Ω·cm2) as a function of temperature for the La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials in dry (red symbols) and moist N2 atmosphere (pO2 = 0.0001 atm). Lines are guides for the eye. Figure 7 Coulometric titration for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600, 700 and 800 °C. The red dotted lines show the decomposition of both materials at the indicated oxygen content and pO2 at 600 °C. Figure 8 (a) High temperature X-Ray diffractogram for LaBaCo2O5+δ between 600–1200 °C and 20–80° in air; (b) Inset between 44–48° the transformation from LaBaCo2O5+δ (LP) to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ (SP) is observed by the disappearance of the peak splitting. Figure 9 Area Specific Resistances (ASR, Ω·cm2) as a function of temperature for the single perovskite La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and the layered double perovskite LaBaCo2O5+δ materials from this work compared to a single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ and a layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ cathodes materials from the literature [3,16]. The lines represent the slope used to calculate Ea. Figure 10 Area Specific Resistances (ASR, Ω·cm2) (black symbols) and oxygen content (green symbols) variation (a) together with electrical conductivity (red symbols) (b) as a function of temperature for the single perovskite La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and the layered double perovskite LaBaCo2O5+δ materials compared to the single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ and the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ cathodes materials from the literature [3,13,16,45]. Oxygen contents for both materials are normalized as O6. The lines are guides for the eye. materials-11-00196-t001_Table 1 Table 1 Structure, Ba per mol, electrochemical performance at 400, 600 °C and in 3% H2O air, oxygen content and electrical conductivity at 400 °C and 600 °C in air for A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ materials compared to the single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ (BCFZY) and the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O6−δ (LGBC) extracted from the literature. Ba per mol Structure Material Performance (Ω·cm2) at 400 °C and 3% H2O in Air Performance (Ω·cm2) at 600 °C and 3% H2O in Air Oxygen Content at 400 °C in Air Oxygen Content at 600 °C in Air Electrical Conductivity at 400 °C in Air (S·cm−1) Electrical Conductivity at 600 °C in Air (S·cm−1) 1 Single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ (BCFZY) 23.03 0.703 2.6713 2.5813 0.603 1.353 0.5 La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ 11.5 0.33 2.97 2.92 1085.0 857.0 Layered double perovskite LaBaCo2O5+δ 7.4 0.16 2.95 2.89 554.0 384.0 La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O6−δ (LGBC) 6.016 0.616 2.7516 2.6516 <795 (GdBaCo2O5+δ)5 <447 (GdBaCo2O5+δ)5
Effect of Cation Ordering on the Performance and Chemical Stability of Layered Double Perovskite Cathodes Effect of Cation Ordering on the Performance and Chemical Stability of Layered Double Perovskite Cathodes Bernuy-LopezCarlos1*†Rioja-MonllorLaura1NakamuraTakashi2RicoteSandrine3O’HayreRyan4AmezawaKoji2EinarsrudMari-Ann1 https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2709-1219GrandeTor1 1Department of Material Science and Engineering, NTNU Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NO-7491 Trondheim, Norway; laura-rioja-monllor@ntnu.no (L.R. -M.); mari-ann.einarsrud@ntnu.no (M. -A.E.); tor.grande@ntnu.no (T.G.) 2Institute of Multidisciplinary Research for Advanced Materials, Tohoku University, 2-1-1 Katahira Aoba-ku, Sendai 980-8577, Japan; t-naka@tagen.tohoku.ac.jp (T.N.); amezawa@tagen.tohoku.ac.jp (K.A.) 3Department of Mechanical Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, Golden, CO 80401, USA; sricote@mines.edu 4Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering, Colorado School of Mines, 1500 Illinois St., Golden, CO 80401, USA; rohayre@mines.edu *Correspondence: carlos.bernuy-lopez@sandvik.com; Tel.: +46-26263411 †Current address: AB Sandvik Materials and Technology, R&D, 81181 Sandviken, Sweden. 196 The effect of A-site cation ordering on the cathode performance and chemical stability of A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ and disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are reported. Symmetric half-cells with a proton-conducting BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ electrolyte were prepared by ceramic processing, and good chemical compatibility of the materials was demonstrated. Both A-site ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ and A-site disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ yield excellent cathode performance with Area Specific Resistances as low as 7.4 and 11.5 Ω·cm2 at 400 °C and 0.16 and 0.32 Ω·cm2 at 600 °C in 3% humidified synthetic air respectively. The oxygen vacancy concentration, electrical conductivity, basicity of cations and crystal structure were evaluated to rationalize the electrochemical performance of the two materials. The combination of high-basicity elements and high electrical conductivity as well as sufficient oxygen vacancy concentration explains the excellent performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials at high temperatures. At lower temperatures, oxygen-deficiency in both materials is greatly reduced, leading to decreased performance despite the high basicity and electrical conductivity. A-site cation ordering leads to a higher oxygen vacancy concentration, which explains the better performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ. Finally, the more pronounced oxygen deficiency of the cation ordered polymorph and the lower chemical stability at reducing conditions were confirmed by coulometric titration. proton ceramic fuel cells (PCFC) cathode layered double perovskite 1. Introduction Proton ceramic fuel cells (PCFC) can potentially overcome some of the challenges currently limiting the commercial application of conventional solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs) [1,2,3,4]. The main difference between conventional SOFCs and PCFCs is the electrolyte material. While SOFCs employ oxide-ion conducting electrolytes, PCFCs make use of proton-conducting electrolytes instead. As the activation energy for protons is lower than for oxide ions, PCFCs can operate at lower temperatures than conventional SOFCs, i.e., 400–600 °C [5] vs. 700–900 °C. However, one of the main issues confronting PCFCs is the lack of high performance cathode materials [1]. A suitable cathode material for PCFCs must facilitate the reduction of oxygen to water by reacting with protons that diffuse through the proton-conducting electrolyte. An ideal high-performance cathode material should combine the conduction of electrons (or holes), oxide ions and protons at the same time [6,7]. Equally important, the material must be chemically stable at the operating conditions. Mixed oxide-ion- and electron-conducting materials with a perovskite structure are the most promising cathodes so far. Unfortunately, the best cathode materials for conventional SOFCs, such as La0.6Sr0.4Co0.2Fe0.8O3−δ (LSCF) [8] and Ba0.5Sr0.5Co0.8Fe0.2O3−δ (BSCF) [8], do not seem to present proton conductivity despite their good electronic and oxide-ion conductivities. Several key parameters in perovskite oxides can be tuned to enhance proton conductivity while ensuring good electronic and oxide-ion-conductivity: these include crystallographic structure, oxygen vacancy concentration, electrical conductivity and basicity [6,9,10,11]. Regarding the crystallographic structure it is established that cubic structures favor both ionic and electronic conductivity [5]. In respect to the oxygen vacancy concentration, high oxygen vacancy concentration can enhance proton conductivity at intermediate temperatures as a result of the Wagner hydration reaction [12,13]: H 2 O + V O • • + O O x ↔ 2 OH O • In addition, electrical conductivity above 1 S/cm is required for adequate cathode performance [3]. Finally, high Ba content is desirable as it leads to higher oxide basicity and thereby a greater degree of protonation of the oxygen vacancies [13,14]. Layered double perovskite materials with the general formula LnBaM2O5+δ (Ln = lanthanide or Y; M = transition metal) have been studied as potential electrodes for both PCFC [15,16,17,18] and SOFC due to their outstanding mixed electronic and oxide-ion conductivities [19,20]. Ln and Ba occupy the A-site in this double perovskite AA′B2O6-type crystal structure, while M occupies the B-site. A-site cation ordering is adopted due to the large difference of size between Ba and Ln with LnO and BaO layers in dodecahedral coordination separated with MO6 layers in octahedral coordination [21]. Cation ordering results in a decrease of symmetry. Layered double perovskite materials can adopt large concentrations of oxygen vacancies and depending on the size of Ln and the nature of M, the material will adopt either a tetragonal or an orthorhombic symmetry as vacancy ordering occurs [22]. A-site cation ordering is reported to be beneficial for oxide-ion conductivity [23] while the ordering of the oxygen vacancies is detrimental [24]. Strandbakke et al. have reported outstanding performance for the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ [16] as a PCFC cathode with Area Specific Resistances (ASR) as low as 6 Ω·cm2 at 400 °C and 3% H2O in air. The large oxygen vacancy concentration adopted by the layered double perovskite seems to favor proton incorporation and sufficient proton conductivity. The performance is comparable to that of mixed electron/proton conducting single perovskite materials such as BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ (BCFZY) [3] (ASR = 10 Ω·cm2 at 400 °C in 3% humidified air), although the benefits of the layered double perovskite crystal structure are still unclear. LaBaCo2O5+δ represents an interesting model system to study the influence of ordering effects on the performance of PCFC cathode materials. In addition to the A-site ordered phase, this material can also adopt an A-site cation disordered cubic structure, represented as La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ, due to the larger size of La compared with other Ln elements. In our recent work [25], we demonstrated that the ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ phase is a metastable variant of the A-site cation disordered phase, La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ. Several authors have studied the effects of A-site cation ordering on the performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ for SOFC application [26,27,28], although it has yet to be studied for PCFC application. Both the ordered and disordered variants demonstrate low polarization resistances at temperatures as low as 600 °C (<0.2 Ω·cm2) due to the excellent mixed conducting (electron hole and oxide-ion) nature of the material. In addition, Garces et al. have studied the influence of the A-site cation ordering on the mixed electronic and oxide-ion conducting properties in this system [29,30]. They obtained a noticeable improvement of performance with A-site cation ordering (0.35 Ω·cm2 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ vs. 0.12 Ω·cm2 for LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600 °C in air). In this work, we examine proton conducting electrolyte supported symmetric cells employing both A-site cation ordered and disordered materials (LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ) to evaluate the effect of A-site cation ordering on performance for PCFC cathode applications. Cathode performance is evaluated by impedance spectroscopy and the results are analyzed with respect to crystal structure, basicity, oxygen content and ordering, and electrical conductivity. Finally, chemical compatibility between the cathode and the electrolyte is reported as well as chemical stability and oxygen deficiency by coulometric titration. 2. Experimental 2.1. Preparation of the Materials La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ was obtained by spray pyrolysis (Cerpotech AS, Tiller, Norway, purity > 99%) of nitrate precursors as described elsewhere [25]. The as-sprayed powders were calcined at 1100 °C for 12 h in air in order to obtain a single pure phase. LaBaCo2O5+δ was obtained by calcining La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in slightly lower pO2 (N2 atmosphere, pO2 ~ 10−4 atm) at 1100 °C for 12 h. Phase purity for all materials were determined using a Bruker D8 Advance DaVinci X-ray diffractometer (Trondheim, Norway). BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ (BZY10) powder was prepared by spray pyrolysis (Cerpotech AS, Tiller, Norway, purity > 99%) of nitrate precursors as described elsewhere [31]. Green pellets of 20 mm diameter were prepared and sintered at 1650 °C for 10 h as described by Sazinas et al. [32]. Prior to electrode deposition, the pellets were polished with SiC paper and washed with ethanol. Electrode slurries of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ were prepared by mixing 5 g of each powder with 1 g dispersant (20 wt % solsperse 28,000 (Lubrizol, Wickliffe, OH, USA) dissolved in terpineol), and 0.3 g binder (5 wt % V-006 (Heraeus, Hanau, Germany) dissolved in terpineol). Electrolyte-supported symmetric cells for LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ were produced by screen painting the corresponding slurries on both sides of a dense BZY10 pellet (geometrical density >90%). The thickness of the BZY10 electrolyte was about 800 μm after polishing and electrode thicknesses were ~20–25 μm. Thickness was checked by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). SEM images were captured on a field emission gun SEM (Zeiss Ultra 55, Limited Edition, Oberkochen, Germany). The symmetric cells of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials were fired at 600 °C for 2 h in ambient air to form porous cathode layers. Gold paste (Fuel Cell Materials) was applied onto the cathodes for current collection followed by in-situ curing. Pt wires were employed as conducting wires. 2.2. Electrochemical Characterization Symmetric cells were characterized by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) in dry and moist (pH2O = 0.03 atm) synthetic air and N2 from 600 to 400 °C, at temperature intervals of 50 °C (with a cooling rate of 1 °C/min and 8 h dwell before each measurement) using a ProboStatTM (NorECs AS, Oslo, Norway) set-up and an Alpha A (Novocontrol Technologies, Montabaur, Germany) impedance analyzer. The signal amplitude was 50 mV under open circuit voltage (OCV) in the 10−2–106 Hz frequency range. The 3% humidification was achieved by bubbling the gases through distilled water at 25 °C. The equivalent circuit fitting and analysis of the impedance data were carried out using Zview Software v3.5. 2.3. Oxygen Deficiency and Chemical Stability Compatibility tests between the electrode and the electrolyte materials were performed by mixing together about 1 g each of both materials in an agar mortar for 15 min. Pellets of 15 mm diameter were fabricated and exposed to different thermal treatments: 1000 °C, 1100 °C and 1200 °C for 72 h at each temperature. High Temperature X-ray diffraction (HT-XRD) measurements were performed using a Bruker D8 Advance diffractometer equipped with an MRI TCP20 high temperature camera (Sendai, Japan). A Pt strip-type resistive heater functioned as the sample support. XRD patterns (20–85°, about 30 min collection time) were recorded from 600 to 1200 °C in air, at 100 °C intervals. An S-type thermocouple was used for temperature determination using the radiant heater. The heating rate and dwell time before data collection were 0.1 °C/s and 10 min respectively Finally, coulometric titration of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials was performed to determine the oxygen content and the chemical stability of these materials below 10−4 bar. The details of the experiment and the set-up are given elsewhere [33,34]. 3. Results 3.1. Microstructure of the Symmetric Cells X-ray diffraction of the two materials, as reported in our previous work [25], established the phase purity and crystal structure: cubic for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and tetragonal for LaBaCo2O5+δ. Figure 1 provides representative low and high-magnification SEM images of a La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ symmetric cell. Despite the low preparation temperature of the symmetric cells, sufficient adherence to the electrolyte was obtained. Higher processing temperatures lead to delamination and poor adherence of the electrolyte. Electrode thickness of about 20 μm and average grain size below ~1 μm are observed. LaBaCo2O5+δ shows similar microstructure as shown in Figure S1. 3.2. Electrochemical Performance Figure 2 depicts typical Nyquist plots obtained for symmetric cells of the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ materials in moist synthetic air at 500 °C. Both A-site cation disordered and ordered materials present similar Nyquist plots for all temperatures as illustrated in Figure 2. Two main contributions coming from the electrolyte and the electrode are observed. The equivalent circuit model used to fit the data is LR (RQ)(RQ)(RQ), where L, R and Q are inductance, resistance and constant phase element respectively. The resistor (RBZY10_1) and the first RQ element (RBZY10_2 and CPEBZY10_2, blue semicircle) are assigned to the electrolyte of the symmetric cells. The two other RQ elements (i.e., RSP_1, CPESP_1, RSP_2, CPESP_2, green and violet semicircles respectively for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ) correspond to the electrode response of the cells. The assignment of these electrochemical processes was carried out by evaluating the pseudocapacitance of the RQ elements (Table S1 for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ) obtained with the electrochemical model: i.e., La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ; ~10−10 F/cm2 for the first RQ element, assigned as the response of the electrolyte [8,9,10,35,36,37,38,39,40,41]; ~10−4 F/cm2 and 10−2 F/cm2 for the other two RQ elements, assigned as the response of the electrode [8,9,10,35,36,37,38,39,40,41]. Total cathode Area Specific Resistances (ASRs) were obtained by dividing the sum of the electrode resistances (i.e., RSP_1 and RSP_2 in Figure 2 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ) by two. Division by a factor of two accounts for the fact that the combined contribution from two cathode electrode responses are measured in symmetric cell testing. Resulting cathode ASR values of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are shown in Figure 3 in 3% moist synthetic air. Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials exhibit excellent performance in the temperature range 400–600 °C. Despite the similar microstructure of both materials, the A-site cation ordered material LaBaCo2O5+δ gives a better performance than the A-site disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ material. Cathode ASR values for LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600 and 400 °C are 0.15 and 7.4 Ω·cm2, respectively. The corresponding values for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 600 and 400 °C are 0.32 and 11.5 Ω·cm2, respectively. Activation energies are also given in Figure 3 for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials, with higher Ea for A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ. For each material, the total electrode response can be deconvoluted in two main processes: an intermediate/middle frequency (RSP_1CPESP_1) process and a low frequency process (RSP_2CPESP_2). The intermediate frequency (MF) process exhibits lower pseudocapacitances than the low frequency (LF) process (~10−4 F/cm2 vs. 10−2 F/cm2). The deconvolution of the electrochemical data for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials is shown in Figure 4. Similar trends are observed for both materials: below 550 °C, the LF process appears to be rate limiting, while the MF process becomes limiting at higher temperatures. Further investigation, e.g., pO2- and pH2O-dependent experiments would be needed to further assign these MF and LF processes to specific electrochemical reactions taking place in the electrode [39]. Figure 5 shows the Nyquist plots for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in N2 atmosphere at 500 °C in dry (Figure 5a) and moist conditions (Figure 5b). ASR values for the electrode contribution extracted from these data are represented in Figure 6. It is found that the ASR decreases in N2 when the atmosphere is humidified. It can also be observed that A-site cation ordering does not give any improvement in the ASR as both A-site cation ordered and disordered materials lead to the same performance in moist conditions at low pO2. 3.3. Chemical Stability The chemical potential of oxygen and stability of the two polymorphs in reducing conditions were investigated by coulometric titration and the results are shown in Figure 7. The oxygen deficiency increases with decreasing oxygen partial pressure as expected, but the slope is significantly different for the two polymorphs. The difference in slope demonstrates the superior stability of Co in a higher oxidation state in La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ relative to LaBaCo2O5+δ. This is further confirmed by the onset of decomposition (vertical relationship of stoichiometry versus pO2) of LaBaCo2O5+δ at a higher pO2 relative to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at constant temperature. Moreover, the coulometric data also proves that the cation-ordered phase tolerates a higher oxygen deficiency before decomposition although this could be an effect of the kinetics of the decomposition reaction. The thermal stability of LaBaCo2O5+δ in air was studied by high temperature X-ray diffraction and the diffraction patterns are shown in Figure 8. Only thermal expansion of LaBaCo2O5+δ was observed up to 1100 °C. These data are consistent with our previous study [25] where LaBaCo2O5+δ was shown to remain tetragonal at high temperature with a P4/mmm as space group. This means that the material remains A-site ordered at the studied temperature range (RT-800 °C). However, Figure 8 shows that LaBaCo2O5+δ starts to transform into La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 1100 °C, with complete disappearance of the splitting of the Bragg reflections due to the loss of A-site cation ordering at 1200 °C (Figure 8b). This means that there is a phase transition from tetragonal P4/mmm structure of LaBaCo2O5+δ to cubic P 3 ̄ m m m structure of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ close to 1100 °C in air. Finally, a good compatibility between both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials and BZY10 electrolyte material is demonstrated by X-ray diffraction of powder mixtures annealed at different temperatures (Figure S2). Temperatures close to 1200 °C for 72 h are required to initiate (minor) secondary phase formation in a powder mixture of the two materials with the electrolyte. Both PCFC operation temperatures (400–600 °C) and electrode sintering temperature (600 °C) are well below the temperature where cathode/electrolyte reactions are observed to initiate. 4. Discussion 4.1. Comparison with Literature Figure 9 compares the performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials with the two best PCFC cathode materials reported in the literature: the single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ (BCFZY) [3] and the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ (LGBC) [16]. The comparison is carried out by taking literature data measured in the same configuration (four-electrode measurements of electrolyte supported symmetric cells), rather than complete fuel cells. One well known issue with symmetric cell measurements involving PCFC electrolytes in oxidizing atmospheres is the influence of the parasitic p-type conductivity of the electrolyte itself [16] on the apparent measured cathode ASR (especially at high temperatures) [42]. This parasitic p-type electronic conductivity leads to an overestimation of the performance of the electrode and makes the interpretation of the data more complex. Thus, it is not recommended to compare cathode ASR results obtained from complete fuel cells to the results obtained from symmetric cell studies. Symmetric cell comparisons, however, are likely to be reasonable if the investigations employ similar electrolyte compositions and thicknesses. Based on such symmetric cell comparisons, the performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are comparable to LGBC and BCFZY, with even better performance at temperatures above 500 °C. These comparisons underscore the high potential of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials as PCFC cathodes. Activation energies are summarized in Figure 9. Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials have higher activation energies than LGBC and BCFZY, which suggests differences in the electrode electrochemical mechanism. A preliminary assignment of the electrochemical mechanism can be suggested by looking at the temperature dependence of the deconvoluted electrochemical processes shown in Figure 4. The low frequency process is hardly dependent on the temperature which may be assigned to the oxygen adsorption/dissociation processes at all, while the intermediate frequency process may be assigned to charge transfer processes due to the higher temperature dependency of this process. This is consistent with previous works in the literature on materials with similar perovskite structure [16,38]. In addition to this, it is well-known that the microstructure of cathode materials plays a crucial role for the electrochemical properties. Adler et al. [43] published a detailed study on the electrode kinetics of porous mixed-conducting oxygen electrodes based on oxide-ion conducting electrolyte, using a continuum modeling to analyze the oxygen reduction reaction. Furthermore, Strandbakke et al. [44] showed that pre-exponential values of the Arrhenius plot are indicative of the microstructure impact in the electrochemical performance. A similar microstructure for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials can be seen in Figure S1 and can also be confirmed with the similar pre-exponential values calculated from Figure 9 (13.55 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and 14.75 for LaBaCo2O5+δ). However, experiments at different pO2 and pH2O and more detailed microstructure studies (determination of the tortuosity, surface area, etc.) are necessary to successfully assign the electrochemical processes and to correlate them with the electrode microstructure [39]. Table 1 summarizes the structure, Ba content, performance, oxygen content and electrical conductivities of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ. The table also includes data for BCFZY [3,13] and LGBC [16,43]. Therefore, due to the similar microstructure discussed previously we attempt a correlation between all these parameters to help rationalize the performance differences between these various cathode materials. 4.2. Correlation between ASR, Electrical Conductivity, Basicity and Oxygen Content The ASR and the oxygen content as a function of temperature for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials are shown in Figure 10a. Likewise, the ASR and the electrical conductivity vs. temperature are plotted in Figure 10b. Data for the single perovskite BCFZY [3,13] and the layered double perovskite LGBC [16,45] materials extracted from the literature are added for comparison. Two observations are evident from these two figures: (1) a lower oxygen deficiency of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ compared to BCFZY and LGBC; (2) a significantly lower (nearly two orders of magnitude) electrical conductivity for BCFZY. The lower performance of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in comparison to LaBaCo2O5+δ at lower temperatures can be explained by the lower oxygen vacancy concentration in La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ as shown in Figure 10. The enhanced low-temperature oxygen vacancy concentrations for both LGBC and BCFZY materials appear to be consistent with their higher low-temperature cathode performance. Protonation of oxygen vacancies generally increases with oxide basicity [13,14]. All else being equal, it is therefore expected that more basic materials will have higher performance levels as PCFC cathodes. In addition, higher oxygen vacancy concentration should drive higher protonation according to Le Chatelier’s principle. Zohourian et al. [13] and Strandbakke et al. [16] have measured the hydration level in BCFZY and LGBC. Despite their high level of oxygen vacancies both materials are only able to hydrolyze 1% of the available oxygen vacancies at 400 °C. Because of its higher basicity, a greater fraction of vacancies is expected to be hydrolyzed in BCFZY. Nevertheless, Figure 9 and Table 1 show that at 400 °C the performance of the layered double perovskite material is better than the materials with single perovskite structure. One possible explanation of this difference could be that A-site cation ordering enhances protonation due to the different local environments of the oxygen vacancies in the two crystal structures. The similar performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ and LGBC can also be explained by the higher basicity of the A-site cations in LaBaCo2O5+δ. A-site cation ordering in LaBaCo2O5+δ leads to higher performance [30] due to the higher oxygen vacancy concentration as shown in Figure 10a. The higher oxygen vacancy concentration and therefore higher degree of protonation could rationalize the higher performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ compared to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ Furthermore, both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ as well as BCFZY have been shown to be very good oxide ion conductors [26,27,28,46]. Therefore, the main difference in performance between BCFZY and both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials may arise from the differences in electrical conductivity as shown in Figure 10b in addition to a difference in proton conductivity. Measurements in low pO2 conditions have been proposed in order to eliminate the presence of oxide-ions and isolate the proton conduction contribution when examining prospective PCFC cathodes [16]. As shown in Figure 5, a decrease in ASR and Ea for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is observed in humidified inert atmosphere (pO2 = 10−4 atm). This decrease may suggest the presence of proton conductivity in the material, and is similar to what was observed for LGBC by Strandbakke et al. [16]. 4.3. Chemical Stability of the Two Polymorphs Previous studies of the oxygen non-stoichiometry of the two polymorphs have suggested that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is the most stable polymorph at oxidation conditions and low temperature [25]. The coulometric titration data (Figure 7) confirms that the oxygen content of LaBaCo2O5+δ is lower than La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ independent of temperature and oxygen partial pressure. The lower oxygen partial pressure at the decomposition suggests that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is more stable than LaBaCo2O5+δ also under reducing conditions. It has previously been shown that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ can be transformed to LaBaCo2O5+δ by annealing in N2 at 1100 °C [25], while we demonstrated in this work that the transverse phase transition is observed in air close to 1100 °C. Based on these two observations LaBaCo2O5+δ is the stable polymorph at inert conditions and LaBaCo2O5+δ the most stable in air close to 1100 °C. Evidence for a phase transition between the two polymorphs could not be obtained by coulometric titration up to 800 °C (Figure 7). The phase transition is however reconstructive in nature and only occurs above a critical temperature for sufficient cation mobility. It is therefore likely that true equilibrium between the two phases could not be obtained during the coulometric titration before decomposition. Additional measurements are therefore required to determine accurately the relative stability of the two polymorphs and the T-pO2 dependence of the phase transition between the two polymorphs. 5. Conclusions LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials have been tested as cathodes for protonic ceramic fuel cells and both exhibit good stabilities. The A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material possesses better performance than the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials with ASR values as low as 7.4 and 0.16 Ω·cm2 at 400 and 600 °C respectively. Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ demonstrate competitive performance with the best state-of-the-art cathode materials BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ and La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ. Oxygen vacancy concentration, electrical conductivity, crystal structure and basicity are shown to be key, interconnected parameters that govern PCFC cathode performance. The A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material exhibits better performance at low temperature than the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ material because it retains higher oxygen vacancy concentration at low temperatures. In addition, A-site cation ordering is hypothesized to increase the basicity of the oxygen vacancies, making them more likely to hydrate. The similar low-temperature performance of A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material vs. La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ (LGBC) may be explained by an increase of the basicity in LaBaCo2O5+δ. As the temperature increases, the A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material shows better relative performance compared to the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ due to the increase in oxygen vacancy concentration. This work shows the importance of understanding and controlling crystal structure, basicity, oxygen vacancy concentration and electrical conductivity in order to improve PCFC cathode materials while keeping an eye on the chemical stability of the material.
Effect of Cation Ordering on the Performance and Chemical Stability of Layered Double Perovskite Cathodes Effect of Cation Ordering on the Performance and Chemical Stability of Layered Double Perovskite Cathodes Bernuy - LopezCarlos1* † Rioja-MonllorLaura1NakamuraTakashi2RicoteSandrine3O’HayreRyan4AmezawaKoji2EinarsrudMari-Ann1 https : / / orcid.org / 0000-0002-2709-1219GrandeTor1 1Department of Material Science and Engineering , NTNU Norwegian University of Science and Technology , NO - 7491 Trondheim , Norway ; laura-rioja-monllor @ ntnu.no ( L.R .
-M. ) ; mari - ann.einarsrud @ ntnu.no ( M .
-A.E. ) ; tor.grande @ ntnu.no ( T.G. ) 2Institute of Multidisciplinary Research for Advanced Materials , Tohoku University , 2-1-1 Katahira Aoba-ku , Sendai 980-8577 , Japan ; t-naka @ tagen.tohoku.ac.jp ( T.N. ) ; amezawa @ tagen.tohoku.ac.jp ( K.A. ) 3Department of Mechanical Engineering , Colorado School of Mines , Golden , CO 80401 , USA ; sricote @ mines.edu 4Department of Metallurgical and Materials Engineering , Colorado School of Mines , 1500 Illinois St. , Golden , CO 80401 , USA ; rohayre @ mines.edu *Correspondence : carlos.bernuy - lopez @ sandvik.com ; Tel. : + 46 - 26263411 † Current address : AB Sandvik Materials and Technology , R & D , 81181 Sandviken , Sweden. 196 The effect of A-site cation ordering on the cathode performance and chemical stability of A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ and disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are reported .
Symmetric half - cells with a proton - conducting BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ electrolyte were prepared by ceramic processing , and good chemical compatibility of the materials was demonstrated .
Both A-site ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ and A-site disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ yield excellent cathode performance with Area Specific Resistances as low as 7.4 and 11.5 Ω·cm2 at 400 ° C and 0.16 and 0.32 Ω·cm2 at 600 ° C in 3 % humidified synthetic air respectively .
The oxygen vacancy concentration , electrical conductivity , basicity of cations and crystal structure were evaluated to rationalize the electrochemical performance of the two materials .
The combination of high - basicity elements and high electrical conductivity as well as sufficient oxygen vacancy concentration explains the excellent performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials at high temperatures .
At lower temperatures , oxygen - deficiency in both materials is greatly reduced , leading to decreased performance despite the high basicity and electrical conductivity .
A-site cation ordering leads to a higher oxygen vacancy concentration , which explains the better performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ .
Finally , the more pronounced oxygen deficiency of the cation ordered polymorph and the lower chemical stability at reducing conditions were confirmed by coulometric titration. proton ceramic fuel cells ( PCFC ) cathode layered double perovskite 1 .
Introduction Proton ceramic fuel cells ( PCFC ) can potentially overcome some of the challenges currently limiting the commercial application of conventional solid oxide fuel cells ( SOFCs ) [1,2,3,4] .
The main difference between conventional SOFCs and PCFCs is the electrolyte material .
While SOFCs employ oxide - ion conducting electrolytes , PCFCs make use of proton - conducting electrolytes instead .
As the activation energy for protons is lower than for oxide ions , PCFCs can operate at lower temperatures than conventional SOFCs , i.e. , 400 – 600 ° C [5] vs. 700 – 900 ° C .
However , one of the main issues confronting PCFCs is the lack of high performance cathode materials [1] .
A suitable cathode material for PCFCs must facilitate the reduction of oxygen to water by reacting with protons that diffuse through the proton - conducting electrolyte .
An ideal high - performance cathode material should combine the conduction of electrons ( or holes ) , oxide ions and protons at the same time [6,7] .
Equally important , the material must be chemically stable at the operating conditions .
Mixed oxide-ion- and electron - conducting materials with a perovskite structure are the most promising cathodes so far .
Unfortunately , the best cathode materials for conventional SOFCs , such as La0.6Sr0.4Co0.2Fe0.8O3−δ ( LSCF ) [8] and Ba0.5Sr0.5Co0.8Fe0.2O3−δ ( BSCF ) [8] , do not seem to present proton conductivity despite their good electronic and oxide - ion conductivities .
Several key parameters in perovskite oxides can be tuned to enhance proton conductivity while ensuring good electronic and oxide-ion-conductivity : these include crystallographic structure , oxygen vacancy concentration , electrical conductivity and basicity [6,9,10,11] .
Regarding the crystallographic structure it is established that cubic structures favor both ionic and electronic conductivity [5] .
In respect to the oxygen vacancy concentration , high oxygen vacancy concentration can enhance proton conductivity at intermediate temperatures as a result of the Wagner hydration reaction [12,13] : H 2 O + V O • • + O O x ↔ 2 OH O • In addition , electrical conductivity above 1 S / cm is required for adequate cathode performance [3] .
Finally , high Ba content is desirable as it leads to higher oxide basicity and thereby a greater degree of protonation of the oxygen vacancies [13,14] .
Layered double perovskite materials with the general formula LnBaM2O5+δ ( Ln = lanthanide or Y ; M = transition metal ) have been studied as potential electrodes for both PCFC [15,16,17,18] and SOFC due to their outstanding mixed electronic and oxide - ion conductivities [19,20] .
Ln and Ba occupy the A-site in this double perovskite AA′B2O6 - type crystal structure , while M occupies the B-site .
A-site cation ordering is adopted due to the large difference of size between Ba and Ln with LnO and BaO layers in dodecahedral coordination separated with MO6 layers in octahedral coordination [21] .
Cation ordering results in a decrease of symmetry .
Layered double perovskite materials can adopt large concentrations of oxygen vacancies and depending on the size of Ln and the nature of M , the material will adopt either a tetragonal or an orthorhombic symmetry as vacancy ordering occurs [22] .
A-site cation ordering is reported to be beneficial for oxide - ion conductivity [23] while the ordering of the oxygen vacancies is detrimental [24] .
Strandbakke et al. have reported outstanding performance for the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ [16] as a PCFC cathode with Area Specific Resistances ( ASR ) as low as 6 Ω·cm2 at 400 ° C and 3 % H2O in air .
The large oxygen vacancy concentration adopted by the layered double perovskite seems to favor proton incorporation and sufficient proton conductivity .
The performance is comparable to that of mixed electron / proton conducting single perovskite materials such as BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ ( BCFZY ) [3] ( ASR = 10 Ω·cm2 at 400 ° C in 3 % humidified air ) , although the benefits of the layered double perovskite crystal structure are still unclear .
LaBaCo2O5+δ represents an interesting model system to study the influence of ordering effects on the performance of PCFC cathode materials .
In addition to the A-site ordered phase , this material can also adopt an A-site cation disordered cubic structure , represented as La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ , due to the larger size of La compared with other Ln elements .
In our recent work [25] , we demonstrated that the ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ phase is a metastable variant of the A-site cation disordered phase , La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ .
Several authors have studied the effects of A-site cation ordering on the performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ for SOFC application [26,27,28] , although it has yet to be studied for PCFC application .
Both the ordered and disordered variants demonstrate low polarization resistances at temperatures as low as 600 ° C ( < 0.2 Ω·cm2 ) due to the excellent mixed conducting ( electron hole and oxide - ion ) nature of the material .
In addition , Garces et al. have studied the influence of the A-site cation ordering on the mixed electronic and oxide - ion conducting properties in this system [29,30] .
They obtained a noticeable improvement of performance with A-site cation ordering ( 0.35 Ω·cm2 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ vs. 0.12 Ω·cm2 for LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600 ° C in air ) .
In this work , we examine proton conducting electrolyte supported symmetric cells employing both A-site cation ordered and disordered materials ( LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ ) to evaluate the effect of A-site cation ordering on performance for PCFC cathode applications .
Cathode performance is evaluated by impedance spectroscopy and the results are analyzed with respect to crystal structure , basicity , oxygen content and ordering , and electrical conductivity .
Finally , chemical compatibility between the cathode and the electrolyte is reported as well as chemical stability and oxygen deficiency by coulometric titration. 2 .
Experimental 2.1 .
Preparation of the Materials La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ was obtained by spray pyrolysis ( Cerpotech AS , Tiller , Norway , purity > 99 % ) of nitrate precursors as described elsewhere [25] .
The as-sprayed powders were calcined at 1100 ° C for 12 h in air in order to obtain a single pure phase .
LaBaCo2O5+δ was obtained by calcining La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in slightly lower pO2 ( N2 atmosphere , pO2 ~ 10 − 4 atm ) at 1100 ° C for 12 h .
Phase purity for all materials were determined using a Bruker D8 Advance DaVinci X-ray diffractometer ( Trondheim , Norway ) .
BaZr0.9Y0.1O3−δ ( BZY10 ) powder was prepared by spray pyrolysis ( Cerpotech AS , Tiller , Norway , purity > 99 % ) of nitrate precursors as described elsewhere [31] .
Green pellets of 20 mm diameter were prepared and sintered at 1650 ° C for 10 h as described by Sazinas et al. [32] .
Prior to electrode deposition , the pellets were polished with SiC paper and washed with ethanol .
Electrode slurries of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ were prepared by mixing 5 g of each powder with 1 g dispersant ( 20 wt % solsperse 28,000 ( Lubrizol , Wickliffe , OH , USA ) dissolved in terpineol ) , and 0.3 g binder ( 5 wt % V-006 ( Heraeus , Hanau , Germany ) dissolved in terpineol ) .
Electrolyte - supported symmetric cells for LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ were produced by screen painting the corresponding slurries on both sides of a dense BZY10 pellet ( geometrical density > 90 % ) .
The thickness of the BZY10 electrolyte was about 800 μm after polishing and electrode thicknesses were ~ 20 – 25 μm .
Thickness was checked by scanning electron microscopy ( SEM ) .
SEM images were captured on a field emission gun SEM ( Zeiss Ultra 55 , Limited Edition , Oberkochen , Germany ) .
The symmetric cells of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials were fired at 600 ° C for 2 h in ambient air to form porous cathode layers .
Gold paste ( Fuel Cell Materials ) was applied onto the cathodes for current collection followed by in-situ curing .
Pt wires were employed as conducting wires. 2.2 .
Electrochemical Characterization Symmetric cells were characterized by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy ( EIS ) in dry and moist ( pH2O = 0.03 atm ) synthetic air and N2 from 600 to 400 ° C , at temperature intervals of 50 ° C ( with a cooling rate of 1 ° C / min and 8 h dwell before each measurement ) using a ProboStatTM ( NorECs AS , Oslo , Norway ) set-up and an Alpha A ( Novocontrol Technologies , Montabaur , Germany ) impedance analyzer .
The signal amplitude was 50 mV under open circuit voltage ( OCV ) in the 10 − 2 – 106 Hz frequency range .
The 3 % humidification was achieved by bubbling the gases through distilled water at 25 ° C .
The equivalent circuit fitting and analysis of the impedance data were carried out using Zview Software v3.5. 2.3 .
Oxygen Deficiency and Chemical Stability Compatibility tests between the electrode and the electrolyte materials were performed by mixing together about 1 g each of both materials in an agar mortar for 15 min .
Pellets of 15 mm diameter were fabricated and exposed to different thermal treatments : 1000 ° C , 1100 ° C and 1200 ° C for 72 h at each temperature .
High Temperature X-ray diffraction ( HT - XRD ) measurements were performed using a Bruker D8 Advance diffractometer equipped with an MRI TCP20 high temperature camera ( Sendai , Japan ) .
A Pt strip - type resistive heater functioned as the sample support .
XRD patterns ( 20 – 85 ° , about 30 min collection time ) were recorded from 600 to 1200 ° C in air , at 100 ° C intervals .
An S - type thermocouple was used for temperature determination using the radiant heater .
The heating rate and dwell time before data collection were 0.1 ° C / s and 10 min respectively Finally , coulometric titration of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials was performed to determine the oxygen content and the chemical stability of these materials below 10 − 4 bar .
The details of the experiment and the set-up are given elsewhere [33,34]. 3 .
Results 3.1 .
Microstructure of the Symmetric Cells X-ray diffraction of the two materials , as reported in our previous work [25] , established the phase purity and crystal structure : cubic for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and tetragonal for LaBaCo2O5+δ .
Figure 1 provides representative low and high - magnification SEM images of a La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ symmetric cell .
Despite the low preparation temperature of the symmetric cells , sufficient adherence to the electrolyte was obtained .
Higher processing temperatures lead to delamination and poor adherence of the electrolyte .
Electrode thickness of about 20 μm and average grain size below ~ 1 μm are observed .
LaBaCo2O5+δ shows similar microstructure as shown in Figure S1. 3.2 .
Electrochemical Performance Figure 2 depicts typical Nyquist plots obtained for symmetric cells of the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ materials in moist synthetic air at 500 ° C .
Both A-site cation disordered and ordered materials present similar Nyquist plots for all temperatures as illustrated in Figure 2 .
Two main contributions coming from the electrolyte and the electrode are observed .
The equivalent circuit model used to fit the data is LR (RQ)(RQ)(RQ) , where L , R and Q are inductance , resistance and constant phase element respectively .
The resistor ( RBZY10_1 ) and the first RQ element ( RBZY10_2 and CPEBZY10_2 , blue semicircle ) are assigned to the electrolyte of the symmetric cells .
The two other RQ elements ( i.e. , RSP_1 , CPESP_1 , RSP_2 , CPESP_2 , green and violet semicircles respectively for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ ) correspond to the electrode response of the cells .
The assignment of these electrochemical processes was carried out by evaluating the pseudocapacitance of the RQ elements ( Table S1 for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ ) obtained with the electrochemical model : i.e. , La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ ; ~ 10 − 10 F / cm2 for the first RQ element , assigned as the response of the electrolyte [8,9,10,35,36,37,38,39,40,41] ; ~ 10 − 4 F / cm2 and 10 − 2 F / cm2 for the other two RQ elements , assigned as the response of the electrode [8,9,10,35,36,37,38,39,40,41] .
Total cathode Area Specific Resistances ( ASRs ) were obtained by dividing the sum of the electrode resistances ( i.e. , RSP_1 and RSP_2 in Figure 2 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ ) by two .
Division by a factor of two accounts for the fact that the combined contribution from two cathode electrode responses are measured in symmetric cell testing .
Resulting cathode ASR values of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are shown in Figure 3 in 3 % moist synthetic air .
Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials exhibit excellent performance in the temperature range 400 – 600 ° C .
Despite the similar microstructure of both materials , the A-site cation ordered material LaBaCo2O5+δ gives a better performance than the A-site disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ material .
Cathode ASR values for LaBaCo2O5+δ at 600 and 400 ° C are 0.15 and 7.4 Ω·cm2 , respectively .
The corresponding values for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 600 and 400 ° C are 0.32 and 11.5 Ω·cm2 , respectively .
Activation energies are also given in Figure 3 for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials , with higher Ea for A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ .
For each material , the total electrode response can be deconvoluted in two main processes : an intermediate / middle frequency ( RSP_1CPESP_1 ) process and a low frequency process ( RSP_2CPESP_2 ) .
The intermediate frequency ( MF ) process exhibits lower pseudocapacitances than the low frequency ( LF ) process ( ~ 10 − 4 F / cm2 vs. 10 − 2 F / cm2 ) .
The deconvolution of the electrochemical data for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials is shown in Figure 4 .
Similar trends are observed for both materials : below 550 ° C , the LF process appears to be rate limiting , while the MF process becomes limiting at higher temperatures .
Further investigation , e.g. , pO2- and pH2O - dependent experiments would be needed to further assign these MF and LF processes to specific electrochemical reactions taking place in the electrode [39] .
Figure 5 shows the Nyquist plots for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in N2 atmosphere at 500 ° C in dry ( Figure 5a ) and moist conditions ( Figure 5b ) .
ASR values for the electrode contribution extracted from these data are represented in Figure 6 .
It is found that the ASR decreases in N2 when the atmosphere is humidified .
It can also be observed that A-site cation ordering does not give any improvement in the ASR as both A-site cation ordered and disordered materials lead to the same performance in moist conditions at low pO2. 3.3 .
Chemical Stability The chemical potential of oxygen and stability of the two polymorphs in reducing conditions were investigated by coulometric titration and the results are shown in Figure 7 .
The oxygen deficiency increases with decreasing oxygen partial pressure as expected , but the slope is significantly different for the two polymorphs .
The difference in slope demonstrates the superior stability of Co in a higher oxidation state in La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ relative to LaBaCo2O5+δ .
This is further confirmed by the onset of decomposition ( vertical relationship of stoichiometry versus pO2 ) of LaBaCo2O5+δ at a higher pO2 relative to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at constant temperature .
Moreover , the coulometric data also proves that the cation - ordered phase tolerates a higher oxygen deficiency before decomposition although this could be an effect of the kinetics of the decomposition reaction .
The thermal stability of LaBaCo2O5+δ in air was studied by high temperature X-ray diffraction and the diffraction patterns are shown in Figure 8 .
Only thermal expansion of LaBaCo2O5+δ was observed up to 1100 ° C .
These data are consistent with our previous study [25] where LaBaCo2O5+δ was shown to remain tetragonal at high temperature with a P4 / mmm as space group .
This means that the material remains A-site ordered at the studied temperature range ( RT - 800 ° C ) .
However , Figure 8 shows that LaBaCo2O5+δ starts to transform into La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ at 1100 ° C , with complete disappearance of the splitting of the Bragg reflections due to the loss of A-site cation ordering at 1200 ° C ( Figure 8b ) .
This means that there is a phase transition from tetragonal P4 / mmm structure of LaBaCo2O5+δ to cubic P 3 ̄ m m m structure of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ close to 1100 ° C in air .
Finally , a good compatibility between both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials and BZY10 electrolyte material is demonstrated by X-ray diffraction of powder mixtures annealed at different temperatures ( Figure S2 ) .
Temperatures close to 1200 ° C for 72 h are required to initiate ( minor ) secondary phase formation in a powder mixture of the two materials with the electrolyte .
Both PCFC operation temperatures ( 400 – 600 ° C ) and electrode sintering temperature ( 600 ° C ) are well below the temperature where cathode / electrolyte reactions are observed to initiate. 4 .
Discussion 4.1 .
Comparison with Literature Figure 9 compares the performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials with the two best PCFC cathode materials reported in the literature : the single perovskite BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ ( BCFZY ) [3] and the layered double perovskite La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ ( LGBC ) [16] .
The comparison is carried out by taking literature data measured in the same configuration ( four - electrode measurements of electrolyte supported symmetric cells ) , rather than complete fuel cells .
One well known issue with symmetric cell measurements involving PCFC electrolytes in oxidizing atmospheres is the influence of the parasitic p - type conductivity of the electrolyte itself [16] on the apparent measured cathode ASR ( especially at high temperatures ) [42] .
This parasitic p - type electronic conductivity leads to an overestimation of the performance of the electrode and makes the interpretation of the data more complex .
Thus , it is not recommended to compare cathode ASR results obtained from complete fuel cells to the results obtained from symmetric cell studies .
Symmetric cell comparisons , however , are likely to be reasonable if the investigations employ similar electrolyte compositions and thicknesses .
Based on such symmetric cell comparisons , the performance of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials are comparable to LGBC and BCFZY , with even better performance at temperatures above 500 ° C .
These comparisons underscore the high potential of both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials as PCFC cathodes .
Activation energies are summarized in Figure 9 .
Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials have higher activation energies than LGBC and BCFZY , which suggests differences in the electrode electrochemical mechanism .
A preliminary assignment of the electrochemical mechanism can be suggested by looking at the temperature dependence of the deconvoluted electrochemical processes shown in Figure 4 .
The low frequency process is hardly dependent on the temperature which may be assigned to the oxygen adsorption / dissociation processes at all , while the intermediate frequency process may be assigned to charge transfer processes due to the higher temperature dependency of this process .
This is consistent with previous works in the literature on materials with similar perovskite structure [16,38] .
In addition to this , it is well - known that the microstructure of cathode materials plays a crucial role for the electrochemical properties .
Adler et al. [43] published a detailed study on the electrode kinetics of porous mixed - conducting oxygen electrodes based on oxide - ion conducting electrolyte , using a continuum modeling to analyze the oxygen reduction reaction .
Furthermore , Strandbakke et al. [44] showed that pre-exponential values of the Arrhenius plot are indicative of the microstructure impact in the electrochemical performance .
A similar microstructure for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials can be seen in Figure S1 and can also be confirmed with the similar pre-exponential values calculated from Figure 9 ( 13.55 for La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and 14.75 for LaBaCo2O5+δ ) .
However , experiments at different pO2 and pH2O and more detailed microstructure studies ( determination of the tortuosity , surface area , etc. ) are necessary to successfully assign the electrochemical processes and to correlate them with the electrode microstructure [39] .
Table 1 summarizes the structure , Ba content , performance , oxygen content and electrical conductivities of LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ .
The table also includes data for BCFZY [3,13] and LGBC [16,43] .
Therefore , due to the similar microstructure discussed previously we attempt a correlation between all these parameters to help rationalize the performance differences between these various cathode materials. 4.2 .
Correlation between ASR , Electrical Conductivity , Basicity and Oxygen Content The ASR and the oxygen content as a function of temperature for both La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ materials are shown in Figure 10a .
Likewise , the ASR and the electrical conductivity vs. temperature are plotted in Figure 10b .
Data for the single perovskite BCFZY [3,13] and the layered double perovskite LGBC [16,45] materials extracted from the literature are added for comparison .
Two observations are evident from these two figures : ( 1 ) a lower oxygen deficiency of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ and LaBaCo2O5+δ compared to BCFZY and LGBC ; ( 2 ) a significantly lower ( nearly two orders of magnitude ) electrical conductivity for BCFZY .
The lower performance of La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ in comparison to LaBaCo2O5+δ at lower temperatures can be explained by the lower oxygen vacancy concentration in La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ as shown in Figure 10 .
The enhanced low - temperature oxygen vacancy concentrations for both LGBC and BCFZY materials appear to be consistent with their higher low - temperature cathode performance .
Protonation of oxygen vacancies generally increases with oxide basicity [13,14] .
All else being equal , it is therefore expected that more basic materials will have higher performance levels as PCFC cathodes .
In addition , higher oxygen vacancy concentration should drive higher protonation according to Le Chatelier ’s principle .
Zohourian et al. [13] and Strandbakke et al. [16] have measured the hydration level in BCFZY and LGBC .
Despite their high level of oxygen vacancies both materials are only able to hydrolyze 1 % of the available oxygen vacancies at 400 ° C .
Because of its higher basicity , a greater fraction of vacancies is expected to be hydrolyzed in BCFZY .
Nevertheless , Figure 9 and Table 1 show that at 400 ° C the performance of the layered double perovskite material is better than the materials with single perovskite structure .
One possible explanation of this difference could be that A-site cation ordering enhances protonation due to the different local environments of the oxygen vacancies in the two crystal structures .
The similar performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ and LGBC can also be explained by the higher basicity of the A-site cations in LaBaCo2O5+δ .
A-site cation ordering in LaBaCo2O5+δ leads to higher performance [30] due to the higher oxygen vacancy concentration as shown in Figure 10a .
The higher oxygen vacancy concentration and therefore higher degree of protonation could rationalize the higher performance of LaBaCo2O5+δ compared to La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ Furthermore , both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ as well as BCFZY have been shown to be very good oxide ion conductors [26,27,28,46] .
Therefore , the main difference in performance between BCFZY and both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials may arise from the differences in electrical conductivity as shown in Figure 10b in addition to a difference in proton conductivity .
Measurements in low pO2 conditions have been proposed in order to eliminate the presence of oxide - ions and isolate the proton conduction contribution when examining prospective PCFC cathodes [16] .
As shown in Figure 5 , a decrease in ASR and Ea for both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is observed in humidified inert atmosphere ( pO2 = 10 − 4 atm ) .
This decrease may suggest the presence of proton conductivity in the material , and is similar to what was observed for LGBC by Strandbakke et al. [16]. 4.3 .
Chemical Stability of the Two Polymorphs Previous studies of the oxygen non-stoichiometry of the two polymorphs have suggested that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is the most stable polymorph at oxidation conditions and low temperature [25] .
The coulometric titration data ( Figure 7 ) confirms that the oxygen content of LaBaCo2O5+δ is lower than La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ independent of temperature and oxygen partial pressure .
The lower oxygen partial pressure at the decomposition suggests that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ is more stable than LaBaCo2O5+δ also under reducing conditions .
It has previously been shown that La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ can be transformed to LaBaCo2O5+δ by annealing in N2 at 1100 ° C [25] , while we demonstrated in this work that the transverse phase transition is observed in air close to 1100 ° C .
Based on these two observations LaBaCo2O5+δ is the stable polymorph at inert conditions and LaBaCo2O5+δ the most stable in air close to 1100 ° C .
Evidence for a phase transition between the two polymorphs could not be obtained by coulometric titration up to 800 ° C ( Figure 7 ) .
The phase transition is however reconstructive in nature and only occurs above a critical temperature for sufficient cation mobility .
It is therefore likely that true equilibrium between the two phases could not be obtained during the coulometric titration before decomposition .
Additional measurements are therefore required to determine accurately the relative stability of the two polymorphs and the T-pO2 dependence of the phase transition between the two polymorphs. 5 .
Conclusions LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials have been tested as cathodes for protonic ceramic fuel cells and both exhibit good stabilities .
The A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material possesses better performance than the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ materials with ASR values as low as 7.4 and 0.16 Ω·cm2 at 400 and 600 ° C respectively .
Both LaBaCo2O5+δ and La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ demonstrate competitive performance with the best state - of - the - art cathode materials BaCo0.4Fe0.4Zr0.1Y0.1O3−δ and La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ .
Oxygen vacancy concentration , electrical conductivity , crystal structure and basicity are shown to be key , interconnected parameters that govern PCFC cathode performance .
The A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material exhibits better performance at low temperature than the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ material because it retains higher oxygen vacancy concentration at low temperatures .
In addition , A-site cation ordering is hypothesized to increase the basicity of the oxygen vacancies , making them more likely to hydrate .
The similar low - temperature performance of A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material vs .
La0.2Gd0.8BaCo2O5+δ ( LGBC ) may be explained by an increase of the basicity in LaBaCo2O5+δ .
As the temperature increases , the A-site cation ordered LaBaCo2O5+δ material shows better relative performance compared to the A-site cation disordered La0.5Ba0.5CoO3−δ due to the increase in oxygen vacancy concentration .
This work shows the importance of understanding and controlling crystal structure , basicity , oxygen vacancy concentration and electrical conductivity in order to improve PCFC cathode materials while keeping an eye on the chemical stability of the material .