Thank you for this comment. You actually expressed how I feel about these things deep in my heart of hearts - particularly:

> I've also been around a lot of people who want to "vent", but then march repeatedly right back into the same patterns and situations that cause the problems, and don't want to hear that they can often avoid this.

I've dealt with such people too, but "the society" kept beating me with the "listen, don't fix" reminder so much that I gave up. I started to think, maybe I'm not listening enough, maybe what to me looks like being stuck in a loop out of their own volition, is just me not hearing the critical details that changed, or something?

I had one or two cases when someone like that caught me in a bad moment, and I've said something along the lines of, "look; we've been going over this exact same conversation, same complaints, same feelings, roughly every couple days for the past few months now; why is this still a thing?", and it just got received as me blocking the other person from opening up when they need it. And those are the "go-getter" kind of people who normally just plow through obstacles (including other people) without much thought - except the few things that, to me, seem like easily solvable problems, but they get stuck on them forever.

Then again, who am I to judge. I too have my own loops, a class of problems that elicit the usual "can't you just do X?" advice from onlookers, that I nevertheless don't seem to make progress on, despite a good decade of trying and failing to "just do X". But then, my problems are of executive function kind. The ones that irk me about others are the kinds like from this article: "someone was (intentionally or unknowingly) mean to me, I can't stop reliving it".

--

Circling back:

> I don't like to normalize that the problem is "you just want to fix things" - it's a huge mental burden on the listener and not respectful to people who get a lot of stress hearing these things. "Fixing something" is how they deal with stress.

It is a burden, and I'm very much of this type. Unless I get emotionally overwhelmed myself (common for my own problems, rare for those of people close to me), my natural way of dealing with stress is to aggressively make the underlying problem go away. My instinct is always to drop everything and go fix the issue, or help someone fix their problem, because otherwise the problem (or my emphasizing with the person who has the problem) will keep gnawing at me, and I'll be spending 90% of my cognitive capacity trying to stop myself from thinking about it.

(This drive to drop everything and fix someone else's problems has led me to some bad places; I'm happy to report that, through years of effort, I'm now just losing 50-60% of focus instead of 90%, and thus prioritize better.)

Might be selfish, but this is how I've always dealt with stress, and learning to suppress this is a big burden, as I am really effective in this mode - if I feel like the problem needs to go away, and I have a shot at it, I will solve it, solve it well, and solve it fast, hell or high water. So stopping myself feels like lighting up a rocket engine while the launchpad clamps are still engaged. It's a huge waste of high-energy fuel, and I might even explode.