A lot of the React fanatics are in denial about this. But, I've seen some absolute messes. Does anyone remember InVision? You probably have forgotten about them because Figma and other design tools ate their lunch, but part of their failure and delay in InVision Studio being released was in part because of React. I know other companies have encountered limitations with React and had to hack around them, most notably Atlassian who had to break their app up into apps (essentially parts of the app were smaller apps) because they wanted to use state management for everything and the memory problems were astronomical.

React got popular because at the time, Angular.js was the framework of choice and we can all agree Angular had some serious problems like the digest cycle and performance issues working with large collections. React in comparison to Angular was a breath of fresh air, but in 2023 there are far better choices now than React.

The thing is, React started out as just a view library and the community are mostly to blame for how terrible it has become. How many state management libraries have there been? How many router packages? Devs think they want a library, they actually want a framework. It's why the most popular uses of React are not vanilla React, they're frameworks like Next.js. Also, when you compare the performance of React to other libraries and frameworks, you realise it's one of the worse performing options. It's slow. The whole entire notion of Virtual DOM was groundbreaking in 2013, but in 2023, reactive binding approaches like those taken in Aurelia and Svelte are far superior and better performing. Virtual DOM is overhead.

Has anyone ever seen a large-scale React project that is just using vanilla React? I've seen a few large-scale React codebases and many of them were a tangled spaghetti mess. It gets to a point where React's lack of opinions and standards for even the most basic of things mean you can see the same thing implemented 100 times in the React community. If you're building something beyond a landing page or basic CRUD app, you need some conventions. There is a reason despite the hate it gets, Angular is still used in enterprise and government settings. It's verbose, but you write components and other facets of your apps a specific way and know that Developer A implementing a feature is going to be understood by Developer B because it's not going to be so self-opinionated. This is something that backend frameworks learned years ago.

Don't get me started on the terrible communication from the React team. A good example is how they have handled React Server Components. They changed the docs to recommend RSC's by default, despite the fact many community packages don't work with them or require additional packages. The way they approached RSC's and rushed them out was terrible. This isn't the first time either.

I have been working with Aurelia 2 (https://docs.aurelia.io) and I love it. It's intuitive, it's fast, the developer experience is great, it comes with all of the needed dependendencies you need like a router, validation, localisation and whatnot. No need to go building a faux-framework of Node packages bloating your app. I've also been working with Web Components, which are in a really good place now too and getting better with each proposal (there are a few good WC proposals in the works right now).

Developers need to start using the platform more. Web Components have been supported by all browsers since 2020 (Chrome has supported them since 2013), so it's a good time to dive in. Using something like Lit gives you a nice development experience. Part of the problem is React developers have been brainwashed into thinking classes are bad because of some terrible design decisions in React (which led to Hooks) and writing Web Components relies on using class syntax (although, you can write them as functions if you really want to).

React is anti-standards, it's anti-developer and it's bad for the platform. The fact that React is ten years old and doesn't support Web Components still, goes to show just how little the React team cares about Web Standards . I know jQuery is a bit of a meme now, but at least jQuery helped shape modern standards. Has anything good come from React for the platform?