Taxation Ruling TR 2002/8

What this ruling is about: [ Note: This is a consolidated version of this document. Refer to the ATO Legal Database (http://law.ato.gov.au) to check its currency and to view the details of all changes.]

Class of entities or scheme: 1A. All legislative references in this Ruling are to the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997) unless otherwise stated. 2. The Ruling examines: 3. This ruling does not cover the assessability of return to work payments under section 15-3. 4. Taxation ruling TR 2002/7 considers whether contributions to strike funds are deductible. 5. This Ruling applies to years commencing both before and after its date of issue. However, the Ruling does not apply to taxpayers to the extent that it conflicts with the terms of settlement of a dispute agreed to before the date of issue of the Ruling (see paragraphs 75 and 76 of Taxation Ruling TR 2006/10). | Application of section 6-5: income according to ordinary concepts: 6. We understand the usual practice is for a strike fund to make a one-off voluntary payment to a member in financial hardship during the period of industrial action. The member has no right or entitlement to the payment, which is made because the member satisfies financial hardship criteria. Further, the member has no expectation of receiving regular, fixed payments from the strike fund. A one-off voluntary payment in these circumstances is not income according to ordinary concepts and is therefore not included in assessable income. [F1] 7. Although it is not the common practice, if a member has an expectation of receiving regular, fixed payments from the strike fund, and is accordingly able to rely on the payments for his or her regular expenditure, the payments will be assessable income. | Application of section 21 of the ITAA 1936: non-cash benefits: 8. The provision of a non-cash benefit to a striking member in financial hardship, in the circumstances outlined in paragraph 6, will not form part of the member's assessable income. | Application of section 15-2: provided in respect of employment or services: 9. Payments are made to striking members because of their membership of a trade union or other employee group. As the payments are not made in respect of, or in relation directly or indirectly to any employment of or services rendered by the member, section 15-2 will not apply to the payment. | Nature and form of strike payments: 10. Payments to striking members to which this Ruling applies are usually made from either general funds or a specific strike fund established by the member's union or employee group, although payments can also come from other unions or employee groups. 11. Where a strike fund is established in relation to specific industrial action a special levy is usually placed on members not involved in that dispute. However, once established the fund may continue to operate past the dispute to support employees involved in future industrial action. It is more common, however, for funds to cease when the current dispute is resolved. | Application of section 6-5: income according to ordinary concepts: 12. Whether or not a particular receipt is income according to ordinary concepts depends upon its character in the hands of the recipient. [F2] Regard must be had to the whole of the circumstances in which the payment is received. [F3] 13. The usual practice is for a strike fund to provide a one-off voluntary payment to members who are in financial hardship during the period of industrial action. The decision to establish a strike fund and offer this assistance to members will usually not be made by the union or employee group until it is quite clear that the industrial action is likely to continue for some period of time. 14. There is no right or entitlement to receive a payment, nor is there an expectation of receiving regular, fixed payments from the strike fund. We have been advised by the ACTU that whether or not a payment is made depends on factors such as: 15. Accordingly, a payment will only be made if the member satisfies a financial hardship criteria. Also, we have been advised that the amount of the payment to a striking member is usually small, not being related in any way to the member's wage. 16. Where a one-off voluntary payment is made from a strike fund to a member in financial hardship during industrial action in the manner outlined in paragraphs 14 and 15, it is not income according to ordinary concepts. Consequently, the payment does not form part of assessable income. 17. Although we understand it is not the common practice, if regular, fixed payments are made to striking members during industrial action under an agreement or arrangement to make such payments, the payments will be assessable income in the hands of the striking member. [F4] The fact that a payment is voluntary, in the sense that the union is not under a legal obligation to make it, does not prevent it being income in such circumstances. | Application of section 21 of the ITAA 1936: non-cash benefits: 18. A non-cash benefit provided to a striking member will not be assessable unless it is convertible into money. [F5] A non-cash benefit provided to a striking member will only form part of the member's assessable income if the circumstances surrounding the provision of the benefit are such that the amount would be assessable income if paid as money. | Application of section 15-2: Allowances and other things provided in respect of employment or services: 19. Broadly speaking, section 15-2 provides that a taxpayer's assessable income includes the value to the taxpayer of all allowances, gratuities, compensations, benefits, bonuses and premiums which are allowed, given, or granted to the taxpayer in respect of, for, or in relation (directly or indirectly) to any employment or services rendered by the taxpayer. 20. While a striking member would not have received a payment but for the fact that he or she was an employee, this does not make the payment in respect of, or for or in relation directly or indirectly to, the employment [F6] . There must be some causal relationship between the payment to the taxpayer and the employment or services rendered. We consider a payment is made to a member as a consequence of his or her membership of a trade union or employee group and therefore section 15-2 does not apply. 21. [Omitted.] 22. Helen is a member of a trade union. The union embarks on industrial action resulting in Helen and her colleagues going out on strike. The union subsequently establishes a strike fund to assist its members who are in financial hardship during the dispute. 23. Helen is a single parent with three dependent children. The union gives Helen a one-off payment of $150 to help her meet her personal commitments. Other colleagues receive varying one-off payments based on their individual circumstances. Some colleagues receive no assistance because their partners work. 24. Helen did not have any right or entitlement to receive the payment from the strike fund, nor was it received in circumstances where she can expect to receive regular, fixed payments from the fund. The payment does not form part of Helen's assessable income. 25. Below is a detailed contents list for this Ruling: Commissioner of Taxation 24 April 2002 Previously released as TR 2001/D11

Ruling: Application of section 6-5: income according to ordinary concepts: 6. We understand the usual practice is for a strike fund to make a one-off voluntary payment to a member in financial hardship during the period of industrial action. The member has no right or entitlement to the payment, which is made because the member satisfies financial hardship criteria. Further, the member has no expectation of receiving regular, fixed payments from the strike fund. A one-off voluntary payment in these circumstances is not income according to ordinary concepts and is therefore not included in assessable income. [F1] 7. Although it is not the common practice, if a member has an expectation of receiving regular, fixed payments from the strike fund, and is accordingly able to rely on the payments for his or her regular expenditure, the payments will be assessable income. | Application of section 21 of the ITAA 1936: non-cash benefits: 8. The provision of a non-cash benefit to a striking member in financial hardship, in the circumstances outlined in paragraph 6, will not form part of the member's assessable income. | Application of section 15-2: provided in respect of employment or services: 9. Payments are made to striking members because of their membership of a trade union or other employee group. As the payments are not made in respect of, or in relation directly or indirectly to any employment of or services rendered by the member, section 15-2 will not apply to the payment. | Nature and form of strike payments: 10. Payments to striking members to which this Ruling applies are usually made from either general funds or a specific strike fund established by the member's union or employee group, although payments can also come from other unions or employee groups. 11. Where a strike fund is established in relation to specific industrial action a special levy is usually placed on members not involved in that dispute. However, once established the fund may continue to operate past the dispute to support employees involved in future industrial action. It is more common, however, for funds to cease when the current dispute is resolved. | Application of section 6-5: income according to ordinary concepts: 12. Whether or not a particular receipt is income according to ordinary concepts depends upon its character in the hands of the recipient. [F2] Regard must be had to the whole of the circumstances in which the payment is received. [F3] 13. The usual practice is for a strike fund to provide a one-off voluntary payment to members who are in financial hardship during the period of industrial action. The decision to establish a strike fund and offer this assistance to members will usually not be made by the union or employee group until it is quite clear that the industrial action is likely to continue for some period of time. 14. There is no right or entitlement to receive a payment, nor is there an expectation of receiving regular, fixed payments from the strike fund. We have been advised by the ACTU that whether or not a payment is made depends on factors such as: 15. Accordingly, a payment will only be made if the member satisfies a financial hardship criteria. Also, we have been advised that the amount of the payment to a striking member is usually small, not being related in any way to the member's wage. 16. Where a one-off voluntary payment is made from a strike fund to a member in financial hardship during industrial action in the manner outlined in paragraphs 14 and 15, it is not income according to ordinary concepts. Consequently, the payment does not form part of assessable income. 17. Although we understand it is not the common practice, if regular, fixed payments are made to striking members during industrial action under an agreement or arrangement to make such payments, the payments will be assessable income in the hands of the striking member. [F4] The fact that a payment is voluntary, in the sense that the union is not under a legal obligation to make it, does not prevent it being income in such circumstances. | Application of section 21 of the ITAA 1936: non-cash benefits: 18. A non-cash benefit provided to a striking member will not be assessable unless it is convertible into money. [F5] A non-cash benefit provided to a striking member will only form part of the member's assessable income if the circumstances surrounding the provision of the benefit are such that the amount would be assessable income if paid as money. | Application of section 15-2: Allowances and other things provided in respect of employment or services: 19. Broadly speaking, section 15-2 provides that a taxpayer's assessable income includes the value to the taxpayer of all allowances, gratuities, compensations, benefits, bonuses and premiums which are allowed, given, or granted to the taxpayer in respect of, for, or in relation (directly or indirectly) to any employment or services rendered by the taxpayer. 20. While a striking member would not have received a payment but for the fact that he or she was an employee, this does not make the payment in respect of, or for or in relation directly or indirectly to, the employment [F6] . There must be some causal relationship between the payment to the taxpayer and the employment or services rendered. We consider a payment is made to a member as a consequence of his or her membership of a trade union or employee group and therefore section 15-2 does not apply. 21. [Omitted.]




What this Ruling is about | Cross references of provisions | Class of person/arrangement


Related rulings: TR 2006/10 TR 2002/7
Legislative references: ITAA 1936 21 ITAA 1997 6-5 ITAA 1997 15-2 ITAA 1997 15-3
Case references: FC of T v. Blake 84 ATC 4661 15 ATR 1006
Subject references: assessable payments strike funds