Product Ruling PR 1999/63W
Status: withdrawn








Withdrawal notice: 1. Product Ruling PR 1999/63 sets out the Commissioner's opinion on the tax consequences for a defined class of entities (Growers) participating in an arrangement known as 'Plantation Forestry Hardwood Project No 2' (the Project), a forestry managed investment scheme with the purpose of establishing and tending to Tasmanian Blue Gum trees for sale in Australia. 2. The application of Division 35 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997) to the Growers is set out in Product Ruling PR 2002/16. 3. PR 1999/63 has been withdrawn in accordance with subsection 358-20(1) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 , which states the Commissioner may withdraw a public ruling either wholly or to an extent. Where the scheme described in the ruling is materially different from the scheme actually carried out, the ruling does not have any binding effect on the Commissioner. All legislative references in this Notice of Withdrawal are to the ITAA 1997 unless otherwise indicated. Overview 4. The Commissioner issued PR 1999/63 for Plantation Forestry Hardwood Project No 2 on 16 June 1999. Each Grower participating in the arrangement was required to enter into a Licence and Management Agreement for the Project. 5. On 14 October 2005, each individual Licence and Management Agreement was replaced with a single Consolidated Licence and Management Agreement (CLMA) between Australian Growth Managers Limited (the Responsible Entity at the time), formerly known as Plantation Forestry Managers Limited, and each several Grower. 6. On 22 December 2011, Primary Securities Ltd replaced Australian Growth Managers Limited as the Responsible Entity for the Project, pursuant to section 601FL of the Corporations Act 2001 (Corporations Act). 7. On 29 November 2012, a meeting of Growers was held to discuss the viability and possible early termination of the Project. In this meeting, the Growers present voted in favour of terminating the Project. 8. On 7 January 2013, Primary Securities Ltd notified the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) of the impending commencement of the winding up of the Project in accordance with subsection 601NC(2) of the Corporations Act. Primary Securities Ltd has advised the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) that the Project commenced winding up on 9 January 2013 and is expected to be deregistered in or around May 2013. 9. Primary Securities Ltd has advised the ATO that the CLMA was terminated on 9 January 2013. The termination of the CLMA has resulted in the Project being carried on in a materially different way to how it was described in PR 1999/63. The ruling is no longer binding on the Commissioner from 9 January 2013. 10. Provided that up to the date of termination of the CLMA, the Project was carried out as described in PR 1999/63, the termination does not disturb the tax treatment of previous Growers' outgoings as set out in PR 1999/63. 11. This Notice of Withdrawal sets out the tax outcomes for Growers arising as a consequence of the termination of the CLMA. Carrying on a business 12. Paragraph 14 of PR 1999/63 sets out how Growers have an interest in the Project. Paragraphs 35 to 45 of PR 1999/63 explain how the Growers' participation in the Project constitutes the carrying on of a business of afforestation by the Growers. Upon termination of the CLMA, on 9 January 2013, all Growers ceased to have an interest in each of their Woodlots and therefore ceased to carry on the business of afforestation. Deferral of losses from non-commercial business activities 13. Division 35 only applies to individuals, alone or in partnership, in income years in which they are carrying on a business activity. Under paragraph 16 of PR 2002/16, the Commissioner conditionally undertook to exercise his discretion under paragraph 35-55(1)(b), to allow losses incurred by Growers, who are individuals that entered into the Project between 16 June 1999 and 18 June 2000, to be offset against other assessable income in the income year in which the losses arise, for the income years ended 30 June 2001 to 30 June 2009. 14. As the Commissioner has not exercised his discretion for the income year ended 30 June 2010 and subsequent income years, any losses from the individual's business activity for the period 1 July 2009 to 9 January 2013 (the date the business activity ceased) will be deferred under subsection 35-10(2) unless, for each income year within that period (or part thereof), the individual: 15. Amounts deferred under subsection 35-10(2) as outlined in paragraph 15 will only be deductible in a subsequent year if the business activity that gave rise to this amount or a business activity 'of a similar kind' is carried on in that subsequent year. If the business activity, or a business activity that is 'of a similar kind', is never carried on again, the entitlement to deduct the amount will be lost. For more information regarding 'business activity of a similar kind' see paragraphs 49 to 54 of Taxation Ruling TR 2001/14 Income tax : Division 35 - non-commercial business losses . Amounts incurred after business activities cease 16. Division 35 does not apply to amounts incurred from the Grower's business activity following the cessation of the business activity on 9 January 2013. Therefore, amounts incurred after the business activity ceases, for example interest (refer to paragraph 27 below), may be deductible. 17. A Grower who incurs capital expenditure after the business ceases will be entitled to claim a deduction under section 40-880 so long as the expenditure related to the business activity, as the Commissioner has exercised the discretion in section 35-55 in relation to one or more income years prior to the cessation of the business activity (subsection 35-10(2A)). Disposal of trading stock 18. On the termination of the CLMA, the Growers' standing timber became the property of RuralAus Plantation Management Pty Ltd (RuralAus) (the head lessee of the land on which the trees stood as at the time of termination). 19. As the Growers were carrying on a business, the standing timber is considered to be their trading stock (section 70-85). The loss of the standing timber is considered a disposal of trading stock outside of the ordinary course of business under subsection 70-90(1). 20. Where this occurs each Grower is required to include in their assessable income, the market value of the trading stock on the day of disposal. Primary Securities Ltd has advised that the market value of the Growers' trees was nil on the day of disposal. Part refund of fees 21. Credit notes have been issued to Growers in respect of licence and management fees invoiced to Growers in respect of the income year ending 30 June 2013. 22. Where Growers have not paid the invoiced amount of licence and management fees prior to the issue of credit notes, the credit notes will halve the fees invoiced to Growers in that year. For these Growers, the receipt of credit note results in a reduction in the amount incurred for licence and management fees that they can deduct (subject to the application of Division 35 as set out in paragraphs 14 to 16) in relation to the income year ending 30 June 2013. 23. Where Growers have paid the licence and management fees prior to the issue of credit notes, they will receive a cash refund of half of those fees. RuralAus Investment Ltd will pay the refunds to Growers. For these Growers, the refund will be received as assessable income from the Grower's business of afforestation and will be included in the Grower's assessable income in the income year of receipt. Further, licence and management fees paid in the income year ending 30 June 2013 (and prior income years in which the discretion under paragraph 35-55(1)(b) is not exercised) may have formed part of amounts deferred under subsection 35-10(2), as outlined in paragraph 15. Amounts deferred under subsection 35-10(2) can be offset against any refunds received after the income year ending 30 June 2013. Deregistration of Project 24. As a result of the Project's deregistration, each Grower's interest in the Project will end. As a result, CGT event C2 will happen to the Grower under section 104-25. The termination will need to be in accordance with the Project's Constitution and requirements under the Corporations Act. 25. Under section 104-25, a capital loss may arise for the Grower if the Grower previously incurred capital expenditure which forms part of the cost base of their interest in the Project. However, expenditure which the Grower has previously deducted, or can deduct, including any deductible expenditure that is deferred under subsection 35-10(2), is excluded from the cost base and is not taken into account in calculating the outcome under section 104-25. Overall, this should result in a nil cost base for all Growers. Interest on loans after cessation of business 26. If Growers have funded their participation in the Project through a loan, interest incurred on the loan after the cessation of their business of afforestation will continue to be deductible under section 8-1 provided each Grower meets certain requirements outlined in Taxation Ruling TR 2004/4 Income tax : deductions for interest incurred prior to the commencement of, or following the cessation of, relevant income earning activities . 27. As noted, Division 35 will not apply to interest expenditure incurred in relation to the Project after the business activity ceased on 9 January 2013. Commissioner of Taxation 16 June 1999