Taxation Ruling IT 2586 - Income tax : wounds and disability pensions paid by foreign government: whether exempt

What this ruling is about: This Ruling considers the application of paragraph 23AD(3)(c) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 ("the Act") which exempts from Australian income tax wounds and disability pensions of the kinds specified in subsection 365(2) of the United Kingdom Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1970. Subsection 365(2) is reproduced at Attachment A. 2. The operation of paragraph 23AD(3)(c) was considered in the case of Goodfellow v. FCT 76 ATC 4199, (1976) 6 ATR 387 which involved an Australian DFRDB pension. In that case, Sheppard J said that paragraph 23(kab) (now repealed but which in all material respects is to the same effect as paragraph 23AD(3)(c)) embraced not only the specific pension exempt from English income tax under the Imperial Act, but also other wounds and disability pensions of the same kind payable from sources outside the United Kingdom. On appeal to the High Court (77 ATC 4086, 7 ATR 265) Jacobs J, the only Justice to consider the issue, expressed agreement with Sheppard J. More recently, in Melkman v. FCT 88 ATC 4468, 19 ATR 1391, which involved a pension paid by the Netherlands Government, the Full Federal Court did not find it necessary to decide the issue but made the following comments (ATC at pp. 4474-4475; ATR at pp. 1398-1399): 3. In FCT v. Verzyden 88 ATC 4613, 19 ATR 1557, which also involved a pension paid by the Netherlands Government, the Full Federal Court said (ATC at p. 4618; ATR at pp. 1561-1562) that:


Ruling: 4. In light of the comments made by the Courts in Goodfellow, Melkman, and Verzyden it is accepted by this Office that the exemption provided by paragraph 23AD(3)(c) applies to wounds and disability pensions payable by any government. Accordingly, wounds and disability pensions paid to Australian residents by a foreign government will be exempt from Australian income tax under paragraph 23AD(3)(c) of the Act if they fit into one of the categories of pensions described in section 365(2) of the United Kingdom Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1970. 5. Where a foreign wounds and disability pension falls within the operation of paragraph 23AD(3)(c) of the Act, it is exempt from Australian income tax irrespective of the age of the pensioner. COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION 10 May 1990




"At one end of the scale it is said that paragraph 23AD(3)(c) exempts only the pensions particularised in subsection 365(2)...This view gives an effect to the words 'of the kinds specified in' similar to that given to the words 'of a kind specified in' in section 30 of the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971... by Mason CJ, Brennan and Toohey JJ in Bird v. Commonwealth of Australia....The view is also supported by the use in paragraph 23AD(3)(b) of the different term 'of a similar nature to'. A wider view is that the exemption extends to pensions payable by governments other than the Government of the United Kingdom provided they answer the description 'of the Crown' for the purposes of subsection 365(2). At the other end of the scale it is said that the exemption extends further to include similar pensions payable by any governments, including governments formerly at war with the United Kingdom and Australia." | "Notwithstanding that paragraph 23AD(3)(c)...is an exempting provision in a taxing statute, the construction of the expression 'of the kinds specified in subsection 365(2) of the Imperial Act' in the context of payments of wounds and disability pensions to Australian residents calls for no narrow or pedantic approach. Plainly that expression envisages a wider class of pensions than those specified in subsection 365(2) of the Imperial Act." | Sec. 365 of the United Kingdom Income and Corporation Taxes Act 1970 is as follows : | Date of effect: Immediate


Legislative references: 23AD(3)(c)
Case references: Goodfellow v. FCT 76 ATC 4199 (1976) 6 ATR 387
Subject references: EXEMPT INCOME WOUNDS AND DISABILITY PENSIONS FOREIGN PENSIONS