ATO ID 2010/87: Thin capitalisation rules: Tier 1 prudential capital deductions - non-banking members
Date of decision: 30 March 2010
Year of income: Year ended 30 June 2008 Year ended 30 June 2009 Year ended 30 June 2010
Business line: International Centre of Expertise

Issue
Does the head company of a consolidated group classified as an 'outward investing entity (ADI)' have to calculate, and include, in Step 3 of section 820-310 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (ITAA 1997), the 'average value ... of ... the tier 1 prudential capital deductions' of the non-banking members of the consolidated group?

Decision
Yes. The head company of a consolidated group classified as an 'outward investing entity (ADI)' has to calculate, and include, in Step 3 of section 820-310 of the ITAA 1997, the 'average value ... of ... the tier 1 prudential capital deductions' for the assets of the non-banking members of the consolidated group.

Facts
A company is the head company of an income tax consolidated group. The consolidated group includes an Australian Authorised Deposit-Taking Institution (ADI) for the purposes of the Banking Act 1959 . The head company is classified under subsection 820-583(7) of the ITAA 1997 as an 'outward investing entity (ADI)' for the purposes of applying Division 820 of the ITAA 1997. The head company's consolidated group includes non-banking members that are excluded from the 'Level 2' group of the ADI that are subject to Tier 1 capital requirements under the prudential standards determined by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority ( APRA ) under section 11AF of the Banking Act 1959 .

Reasons for decision
Summary: The head company of a consolidated group or MEC group is subject to the thin capitalisation rules in Subdivision 820-D of the ITAA 1997 if it is classified as an 'outward investing entity (ADI)' under subdivisions 820-EA, 820-FA or 820-FB of the ITAA 1997 (as applicable). The application of provisions in Division 820 of the ITAA 1997 is for a 'head company core purpose', within the meaning of section 701-1 of the ITAA 1997, as it is necessary to determine a taxpayer's allowable deductions in order to determine its liability for income tax (see sections 4-10 and 4-15 of the ITAA 1997). Accordingly, all the subsidiary members of a consolidated group are 'taken ... to be parts of the head company' for the purpose of determining the 'average value ... of all the *tier 1 prudential capital deductions for the [head company]' in Step 3 of the 'Method statement' in section 820-310 of the ITAA 1997. 'Tier 1 prudential capital deduction' is defined in subsection 995-1(1) of the ITAA 1997 as: the amounts that must be deducted in the calculation of the eligible tier 1 capital of the entity (within the meaning of the *prudential standards) ... in accordance with the prudential standards in force at that time. 'Prudential standards' is defined in subsection 995-1(1) of the ITAA 1997 as: the prudential standards determined by *APRA and in force under section 11AF of the Banking Act 1959 . Australian Prudential Standard (APS) 111 is a prudential standard determined by APRA and in force under section 11AF of the Banking Act 1959 . Paragraphs 39 to 49 of APS 111 provide for 100% or 50% of the value of specified kinds of assets to be subtracted in determining the amount of Tier 1 capital of an ADI. For example, paragraphs 39 and 41 of APS 111 state: 39. For the purposes of calculating its Level 1 capital base, an ADI must deduct the following items from Tier 1 capital...: (a) any identified impairment of an asset [not already taken into account in the P&L]...; (b) [net] deferred tax assets ... (h) goodwill, and any other intangible assets arising on an acquisition ...[etc.]... 41. The following items are to be deducted 50 per cent from Tier 1 capital and 50 per cent from Tier 2 capital: (a) equity exposures ... in other ADIs ...[etc.] The relevant legislative context to section 820-310 of the ITAA 1997 discloses that it is expressly contemplated, and intended, that the amount of 'risk-weighted assets' in Step 1, and correspondingly, the amount of 'tier 1 prudential capital deductions' in Step 3, can be determined for any, and all, of the assets of a taxpayer treated as an 'outward investing entity (ADI)', irrespective of whether the taxpayer is subject to Tier 1 capital adequacy regulation by APRA under APS 110 and the Banking Act 1959 . That relevant legislative context includes: It follows that the amount of 'risk-weighted assets' for the purpose of Step 1 of the Method statement in section 820-310 of the ITAA 1997 is the sum of the amounts determined in accordance with APRA's method (in paragraph 6 of Attachment D to APS 110) for determining an ADI's 'total risk-weighted assets'. It similarly follows that the 'average value ... of all the *tier 1 prudential capital deductions for the [head company]', in Step 3 of the Method statement in section 820-310 is intended to include the amounts determined under APRA's method (in paragraphs 39 to 49 of APS 111) for subtracting the value of certain kinds of assets from the amount of Tier 1 capital for the purpose of the minimum capital requirements in paragraph 14 of APS 110. Note: assets subtracted in calculating Tier 1 capital are excluded from the calculation of 'total risk-weighted assets': refer paragraph 50 of APS 111. This interpretation of the 'average value ... of all the *tier 1 prudential capital deductions for the [head company]' in Step 3 of section 820-310 of the ITAA 1997 not only accords with the intent of the legislature discerned from the relevant legislative context of section 820-310, as referred to above, it also reflects a natural reading of the words of the definition in subsection 995-1(1) of the ITAA 1997, namely: the amounts that must be deducted in the calculation of the eligible tier 1 capital of the [head company] ... (within the meaning of the *prudential standards) ... in accordance with the prudential standards in force at that time. This interpretation is also consistent with the relevant statements in the Explanatory Memorandum to New Business Tax System (Thin Capitalisation) Act 2001 : 5.9 The thin capitalisation rules applying to ADIs are based on the methodology of the capital adequacy requirements prescribed by APRA. Under the capital adequacy regime, the ADIs assets are risk weighted, so those assets that have higher risk (such as loans to corporate entities) require more capital than assets that have low risk (such as government bonds). APRA may also require a specific amount of capital to be held for certain assets, such as goodwill and investments in life and general insurance subsidiaries. 5.10 Similarly, the thin capitalisation rules for ADIs will use risk-adjusted assets rather than book values of assets to calculate the safe harbour minimum capital amount and the worldwide capital amount, and will require additional capital to be held against certain Australian assets. ... What are prudential capital deductions ? 5.38 Prudential capital deductions include Tier 1 prudential capital deductions and deductions from total capital as defined in the prudential standard APS111 Capital Adequacy : Measurement of Capital . Deductions from total capital include investments in other ADIs outside the bank group, non-operating holding companies, non-consolidated subsidiaries and associates. ... What are Tier 1 prudential capital deductions ? 5.39 Tier 1 prudential capital deductions are amounts that must be deducted in calculating the eligible Tier 1 capital as defined in the prudential standards. These deductions include goodwill, other intangibles assets, future income tax benefits, equity and other capital investments in associated lenders [sic] mortgage insurers. In the final step of the method statement, any Tier 1 prudential capital deductions attributable to foreign branches or subsidiaries are not added on because they are not a part of the bank's Australian operations. [ Schedule 2, item 67, definition of ' Tier 1 prudential capital deduction' in subsection 995 - 1(1) ] It is noted that, if the amount of 'tier 1 prudential capital deductions for the [head company]' in Step 3 of the Method statement in section 820-310 of the ITAA 1997 only included amounts which the banking members (if any) of the consolidated group had to deduct in determining their Tier 1 capital under the Banking Act 1959 , this would result in the unintended consequence that the non-banking members of the consolidated group would be subject to a significantly more favourable thin capitalisation limit under Division 820 of the ITAA 1997 than the banking members.

Legislative references: Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 section 4-10 section 4-15 section 701-1 section 820-310 section 820-430 subsection 820-583(7) section 820-588 section 820-597 section 820-599 subsection 820-609(1) section 995-1
Related ATO interpretative decisions: ATO ID 2010/86
Other references: Australian Prudential Standards APS 110 Australian Prudential Standards APS 111 Explanatory Memorandum to New Business Tax System (Thin Capitalisation) Bill 2001
Subject references: Banking & finance segment Consolidation Financial services industry regulation & supervision International tax Outward investing entity Single entity rule Thin capitalisation