Paper: A path toward primitive machine intelligence: LMM not LLM is what you need. (ICLR-2024)

Reviewer comment (Novelty):
The content of the contributions seems to be lacking. Beyond motivating the problem that existing methods are unable to learn the true spectrum, the reviewer is struggling to see what this submission contributes, although they note they may be missing some key aspects. One possibility to improve the submission's contribution is to derive an analytical scaling law as suggested in Section 2.3.

Author response:
Thank you, also for your minor comments. I hope you enjoy the analytic results I have now provided (as you requested) and shall revise your rating for the upgraded paper.