Question: Who was born first out of Oto Luthar and Jean-Pierre Sylvestre De Grateloup?

Knowledge 1: Jean-Pierre Sylvestre de Grateloup
Jean- Pierre Sylvestre de Grateloup( 31 December 1782 – 25 August 1862) was a French physician and naturalist.He completed his medical studies at Montpellier and remained attached to the countryside of the southwest of France.In company with his childhood friend Jean- Marie Léon Dufour( 1780 – 1865) and Dufour's friend Jean- Baptiste Bory de Saint- Vincent( 1778 – 1846) he expressed his enthusiasm for botany specializing in the study of cryptogams, the ferns and other plants that reproduce through spores.Then the shells found in the region attracted his attention, in particular those from the Adour.He practiced medicine in the military hospitals at Dax, where from his graduation from Montpellier in 1807 he worked in the company of Jean Thore( 1762 – 1823).Under the Bourbon Restoration he experienced setbacks in his career.After his marriage in 1822 he moved to Bordeaux.As a corresponding member of the" Société linnéenne de Paris", the world's first" Linnaean society", he was made director of the natural history museum of Dax, which was founded on the collections of Jacques- François de Borda d' Oro( 1718 –1804).In addition to his own works he edited articles for the" Annales générales de sciences physiques" by Bory de Saint- Vincent, Auguste Drapiez( 1778 – 1856) et Jean- Baptiste Van Mons( 1765 – 1842).His" Catalogue des mollusques terrestres et fluviatiles: vivants et fossiles, de la France continentale e insulaire", 1855, catalogued all the molluscs found in France, living and fossilized. [SEP] Knowledge 2: Oto Luthar
Oto Luthar( born 11 August 1959) is a Slovenian historian.Since 1992, he has served as the director of the Research Centre of the Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts in Ljubljana, the largest research institution in Slovenia.He was born in Murska Sobota, Slovenia, then part of the Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia.He studied history at the University of Ljubljana, graduating under the supervision of Bogo Grafenauer in 1986.He obtained his PhD in 1992.Since 1989, he has taught history at the University of Maribor.Between 1999 and 2000, he was a visiting professor at Yale University.He has written on numerous subjects, including the history and theory of historiography, the history of European Jews, especially their relation to Slavic peoples, and the social history of World War I. Since 2003, he has also headed the graduate program in cultural studies at the University of Nova Gorica.In 2011, Luthar was awarded the Austrian Cross of Honour for Science and Art.He is married to the cultural critic and sociologist Breda Luthar.
Knowledge 1: Jean-Pierre Sylvestre de Grateloup
Jean- Pierre Sylvestre de Grateloup( 31 December 1782 – 25 August 1862) was a French physician and naturalist.He completed his medical studies at Montpellier and remained attached to the countryside of the southwest of France.In company with his childhood friend Jean- Marie Léon Dufour( 1780 – 1865) and Dufour's friend Jean- Baptiste Bory de Saint- Vincent( 1778 – 1846) he expressed his enthusiasm for botany specializing in the study of cryptogams, the ferns and other plants that reproduce through spores.Then the shells found in the region attracted his attention, in particular those from the Adour.He practiced medicine in the military hospitals at Dax, where from his graduation from Montpellier in 1807 he worked in the company of Jean Thore( 1762 – 1823).Under the Bourbon Restoration he experienced setbacks in his career.After his marriage in 1822 he moved to Bordeaux.As a corresponding member of the" Société linnéenne de Paris", the world's first" Linnaean society", he was made director of the natural history museum of Dax, which was founded on the collections of Jacques- François de Borda d' Oro( 1718 –1804).In addition to his own works he edited articles for the" Annales générales de sciences physiques" by Bory de Saint- Vincent, Auguste Drapiez( 1778 – 1856) et Jean- Baptiste Van Mons( 1765 – 1842).His" Catalogue des mollusques terrestres et fluviatiles: vivants et fossiles, de la France continentale e insulaire", 1855, catalogued all the molluscs found in France, living and fossilized. [SEP] Knowledge 2: Sylvestre de Laval
Sylvestre de Laval( 15701616) was a French Roman Catholic theologian.
Knowledge 1: Jean-Pierre Sylvestre de Grateloup
Jean- Pierre Sylvestre de Grateloup( 31 December 1782 – 25 August 1862) was a French physician and naturalist.He completed his medical studies at Montpellier and remained attached to the countryside of the southwest of France.In company with his childhood friend Jean- Marie Léon Dufour( 1780 – 1865) and Dufour's friend Jean- Baptiste Bory de Saint- Vincent( 1778 – 1846) he expressed his enthusiasm for botany specializing in the study of cryptogams, the ferns and other plants that reproduce through spores.Then the shells found in the region attracted his attention, in particular those from the Adour.He practiced medicine in the military hospitals at Dax, where from his graduation from Montpellier in 1807 he worked in the company of Jean Thore( 1762 – 1823).Under the Bourbon Restoration he experienced setbacks in his career.After his marriage in 1822 he moved to Bordeaux.As a corresponding member of the" Société linnéenne de Paris", the world's first" Linnaean society", he was made director of the natural history museum of Dax, which was founded on the collections of Jacques- François de Borda d' Oro( 1718 –1804).In addition to his own works he edited articles for the" Annales générales de sciences physiques" by Bory de Saint- Vincent, Auguste Drapiez( 1778 – 1856) et Jean- Baptiste Van Mons( 1765 – 1842).His" Catalogue des mollusques terrestres et fluviatiles: vivants et fossiles, de la France continentale e insulaire", 1855, catalogued all the molluscs found in France, living and fossilized. [SEP] Knowledge 2: Kimberly Jean-Pierre
Kimberly Jean-Pierre is the Assembly member for the 11th District of the New York Assembly, which includes portions of the town of Babylon in Suffolk County.A Democrat, Jean-Pierre was first elected in 2014.Jean-Pierre is of Haitian-American descent, and graduated from Brooklyn College and later received a master's degree in public policy from Stony Brook University.Prior to elected office Jean-Pierre worked for the Suffolk County Legislature as a legislative aide to DuWayne Gregory.She later worked for Congressman Steve Israel as a Community Outreach Coordinator, and later for the Town of Babylon's Industrial Development Agency.In 2014, Assemblyman Robert Sweeney decided to retire, leaving the district open for the first time in twenty six years.Jean-Pierre announced her run, and easily attained the nomination before going to win the election with 58% of the vote.She easily won reelection in 2016 and 2018.In the Assembly, Jean-Pierre serves as Chair of the Subcommittee on Banking in Underserved Communities.Pierre resides in Wheatley Heights.

Answer: Jean-Pierre Sylvestre De Grateloup