sharkiefff/RBAC-Text2SQL-Benchmark huggingface dataset:
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: display job Title, the difference between minimum and maximum salaries for those jobs which max salary within the range 12000 to 18000.
Answer: SELECT job_title ,  max_salary - min_salary FROM jobs WHERE max_salary BETWEEN 12000 AND 18000
Permission: allowed (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT job_title ,  max_salary - min_salary FROM jobs WHERE max_salary BETWEEN 12000 AND 18000
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: What are the job titles, and range of salaries for jobs with maximum salary between 12000 and 18000?
Answer: SELECT job_title ,  max_salary - min_salary FROM jobs WHERE max_salary BETWEEN 12000 AND 18000
Permission: allowed (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT job_title ,  max_salary - min_salary FROM jobs WHERE max_salary BETWEEN 12000 AND 18000
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: display the emails of the employees who have no commission percentage and salary within the range 7000 to 12000 and works in that department which number is 50.
Answer: Sorry, I cannot answer.
Permission: denied (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT email FROM employees WHERE commission_pct  =  "null" AND salary BETWEEN 7000 AND 12000 AND department_id = 50
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: What are the emails of employees with null commission, salary between 7000 and 12000, and who work in department 50?
Answer: Sorry, I cannot answer.
Permission: denied (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT email FROM employees WHERE commission_pct  =  "null" AND salary BETWEEN 7000 AND 12000 AND department_id = 50
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: display the employee ID for each employee and the date on which he ended his previous job.
Answer: Sorry, I cannot answer.
Permission: denied (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT employee_id ,  MAX(end_date) FROM job_history GROUP BY employee_id
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: What are the employee ids for each employee and final dates of employment at their last job?
Answer: Sorry, I cannot answer.
Permission: denied (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT employee_id ,  MAX(end_date) FROM job_history GROUP BY employee_id
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: display those departments where more than ten employees work who got a commission percentage.
Answer: SELECT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id HAVING COUNT(commission_pct) > 10
Permission: allowed (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id HAVING COUNT(commission_pct) > 10
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: What are the department ids for which more than 10 employees had a commission?
Answer: SELECT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id HAVING COUNT(commission_pct) > 10
Permission: allowed (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id HAVING COUNT(commission_pct) > 10
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: Find the ids of the departments where any manager is managing 4 or more employees.
Answer: SELECT DISTINCT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id ,  manager_id HAVING COUNT(employee_id)  >= 4
Permission: allowed (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT DISTINCT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id ,  manager_id HAVING COUNT(employee_id)  >= 4
##Instruction:
Database: hr_1
Total Tables: 7
Total Columns: 35

Table Schemas:

hr_1 contains tables such as regions, countries, departments, jobs, employees, job_history, locations.
Table regions has columns such as REGION_ID, REGION_NAME.
REGION_ID is the primary key.
Table countries has columns such as COUNTRY_ID, COUNTRY_NAME, REGION_ID.
COUNTRY_ID is the primary key.
Table departments has columns such as DEPARTMENT_ID, DEPARTMENT_NAME, MANAGER_ID, LOCATION_ID.
DEPARTMENT_ID is the primary key.
Table jobs has columns such as JOB_ID, JOB_TITLE, MIN_SALARY, MAX_SALARY.
JOB_ID is the primary key.
Table employees has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, FIRST_NAME, LAST_NAME, EMAIL, PHONE_NUMBER, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, SALARY, COMMISSION_PCT, MANAGER_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table job_history has columns such as EMPLOYEE_ID, START_DATE, END_DATE, JOB_ID, DEPARTMENT_ID.
EMPLOYEE_ID is the primary key.
Table locations has columns such as LOCATION_ID, STREET_ADDRESS, POSTAL_CODE, CITY, STATE_PROVINCE, COUNTRY_ID.
LOCATION_ID is the primary key.
The REGION_ID of countries is the foreign key of REGION_ID of regions.
The JOB_ID of employees is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of employees is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The JOB_ID of job_history is the foreign key of JOB_ID of jobs.
The DEPARTMENT_ID of job_history is the foreign key of DEPARTMENT_ID of departments.
The EMPLOYEE_ID of job_history is the foreign key of EMPLOYEE_ID of employees.
The COUNTRY_ID of locations is the foreign key of COUNTRY_ID of countries.

##Role Access Policy (Column-Level):
Role: DataOperator_1
Accessible Columns:
  - countries: COUNTRY_ID, REGION_ID
  - departments: * (all columns)
  - employees: COMMISSION_PCT, DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, HIRE_DATE, JOB_ID, MANAGER_ID, PHONE_NUMBER
  - job_history: DEPARTMENT_ID, EMPLOYEE_ID, JOB_ID, START_DATE
  - jobs: * (all columns)
  - locations: CITY, COUNTRY_ID, LOCATION_ID, POSTAL_CODE, STREET_ADDRESS
  - regions: REGION_ID

Question: What are department ids for departments with managers managing more than 3 employees?
Answer: SELECT DISTINCT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id ,  manager_id HAVING COUNT(employee_id)  >= 4
Permission: allowed (All required columns are permitted)
Gold SQL: SELECT DISTINCT department_id FROM employees GROUP BY department_id ,  manager_id HAVING COUNT(employee_id)  >= 4