Question: who articulated the doctrine of nullification before the civil war
[{'answer': 'South Carolina', 'provenance': [{'wikipedia_id': '376083', 'title': 'Nullification Crisis', 'start_paragraph_id': 1, 'start_character': 177, 'end_paragraph_id': 1, 'end_character': 191, 'bleu_score': 1.0, 'section': 'Section::::Abstract.'}]}, {'provenance': [{'wikipedia_id': '376083', 'title': 'Nullification Crisis', 'start_paragraph_id': 1, 'start_character': 0, 'end_paragraph_id': 1, 'end_character': 396, 'bleu_score': 0.8786307771674821, 'meta': {'yes_no_answer': 'NONE', 'annotation_id': 9817297441263365995}, 'section': 'Section::::Abstract.'}]}]