David Kronke of the Los Angeles Daily News criticized the special as being a standard episode that has been padded out to an extra length, with the live action Patchy the Pirate segments not being that entertaining.
David Kronke di Los Angeles Daily News mengkritik spesial ini sebagai episode standar yang telah ditambahi waktu extra, dengan segmen aksi langsung Patchy the Pirate tidak semenghibur itu.