In March 2011, Hamilton appeared in a video for the Christian organization I Am Second, telling of her struggle after the shark attack and how she trusted in God to get her through it.
Pada bulan Maret 2011, Bethany membuat video untuk organisasi Kristen, "I Am Second", menceritakan pergumulannya setelah serangan ikan hiu dan bagaimana ia percaya kepada Allah untuk melewatinya.