Norman Stillman and Watt believe such a treaty was "doubtful" to have existed, though Watt believes the Qurayza had agreed not to assist Muhammad's enemies against him.
Norman Stillman dan Watt percaya bahwa kesepakatan dimaksud "diragukan" keberadaannya, walaupun Watt percaya bahwa Quraizhah telah sepakat untuk tidak membantu musuh Muhammad.