In early February 2010, it was reported that Witherspoon was dating Jim Toth, a talent agent and co-head of motion picture talent at Creative Artists Agency, where Witherspoon is a client.
Pada awal Februari 2010, dilaporkan bahwa Witherspoon mulai berkencan dengan Jim Toth, seorang agen pencari bakat dan salah satu kepala divisi pencarian bakat film di Creative Artists Agency, di mana Witherspoon adalah seorang kliennya.