During the first season, the program featured segments with folklorist Heather Joseph-Witham, who explained the origins of certain myths, and other people who had first-hand experience with the myths being tested, but those elements were phased out early in the series.
Selama musim pertama, program ini menampilkan segmen dengan cerita rakyat Heather Joseph-Witham, yang menjelaskan asal usul mitos tertentu, dan orang lain yang telah memiliki pengalaman tangan pertama dengan mitos yang diuji, namun elemen-elemen dihilangkan awal selama seri.