When his parents divorced in 1968, his father moved to Scottville, Michigan and Keenan would only see him about once a year for the next 12 years.
Ketika orangtuanya bercerai pada 1968, ayahnya, seorang pelatih gulat sekolah tinggi, berpindah ke Scottville, Michigan dan Keenan hanya menengoknya sekali setahun selama 12 tahun berikutnya.