Searle suggests that in the Twin-Earth example, the second seems more plausible, since if Twin Earth doesn't have water, then all its water-based products will also be different.
Menurut Searle, dalam contoh Bumi Kembar, skenario kedua lebih mungkin terjadi, karena bila Bumi Kembar tidak punya air, maka produk berbasis airnya juga berbeda.