Freeborough and Ranken, in their treatise Chess Openings: Ancient and Modern (1889, 1896), wrote that the Sicilian "had at one time the reputation of being the best reply to 1.P-K4, but this has not been confirmed by popular practice.
Freeborough dan Ranken, dalam risalah mereka Chess Openings: Ancient and Modern (1889, 1896), menulis bahwa Sisilia "pernah sekali punya reputasi sebagai balasan terbaik melawan 1.P-K4, tetapi ini tidak dibuktikan oleh praktik populer.