Nick Cowen of Computer and Video Games found the story "less satisfying" than The Last of Us due to its lack of new details about Ellie, but declared it "action-packed and enjoyable" nonetheless.
Nick Cowen dari Komputer dan Video Games menemukan cerita yang "kurang memuaskan" dari The Last of Us karena kurangnya rincian baru tentang Ellie, tapi menyatakan "tindakan-dikemas dan menyenangkan" meskipun begitu.