Tamar Anitai from MTV Buzzworthy listed "Disturbia" at No. 5 on the "Buzzworthy's Top 5 Most Paranoid Music Videos" and said that "Paranoia never looked so supernaturally sexy!".
Tamar Anitai dari MTV Buzzworthy memasukkan "Disturbia" di nomor lima di "Buzzworthy's Top 5 Most Paranoid Music Videos" dan mengatakan bahwa "Paranoia tidak pernah terlihat begitu seksi secara supernatural!".