In May 2012, a court ruled in Pratten's favour, agreeing that the laws at the time discriminated against donor children and making anonymous sperm and egg donation in British Columbia illegal.
Pada bulan Mei 2012, pengadilan memenangkan gugatan Pratten, setuju bahwa undang-undang pada saat itu mendiskriminasi anak-anak donor serta menjadikan donasi sel telur dan sperma anonim di British Columbia ilegal.