Their second performance of the night, "If I Were a Boy", was generally acclaimed by the judges with Walsh telling them they have "amazing potential" and calling them the "next big girl band."
Penampilan kedua mereka malam itu, membawakan "If I Were A Boy", secara umum diakui oleh para juri dengan Walsh mengatakan mereka memiliki "potensi luar biasa" dan menyebut mereka "calon grup perempuan besar berikutnya."