The foundation stone of the church was first laid in 1676, although the church was only finally consecrated for divine service 1718 as the first Anglican church in Mumbai (then called Bombay), within the walls of the fortified British settlement.
Batu fondasi gereja pertama kali diletakkan pada tahun 1676, meskipun gereja tersebut akhirnya dikuduskan untuk ibadah pada 1718 sebagai gereja Anglikan pertama di Mumbai (saat itu disebut Bombay), di dalam tembok permukiman Britania berbenteng.