The site's consensus reads, "At nine films and counting, the line between Nicholas Sparks film fans and detractors is clear, and The Best of Me will change few minds on either side of the divide."
Konsensus website ini berkata, "Pada sembilan film dan terhitung bahwa inti antara penggemar film-film Nicholas Sparks dan pengkritik jelas, dan The Best of Me akan mengubah beberapa pikiran di kedua sisi yang terbagi".