The Gallaghers, on the other hand, doubted McCarroll's musical ability, with Noel saying: "I like Tony as a geezer but he wouldn't have been able to drum the new songs".
Gallagher, di lain pihak, meragukan kemampuan musikal McCarroll, dengan Noel mengatakan, “Aku menyukai Tony sebagai seorang geezer tapi dia tidak akan mampu memainkan drum untuk lagu baru.”