Dembski claims that such arguments are not merely beyond the purview of science: often they are tacitly or overtly theological while failing to provide a serious analysis of the hypothetical objective's relative merit.
Dembski mengklaim bahwa argumen tersebut tidak hanya di luar lingkup sains: sering mereka diam-diam atau terang-terangan teologis sementara gagal memberikan analisis serius merit relatif objektif hipotetis.