Bright Eyes won Artist of the Year and Song of the Year for "When the President Talks to God" at the 2006 PLUG Independent Music Awards and a special recognition award for the video for "First Day of My Life" at the 17th GLAAD Media Awards.
Bright Eyes gañou os premios ao Artista do ano e Canción do ano por "When the President Talks to God" na edición do 2006 dos PLUG Independent Music Awards, e un recoñecemento especial polo video de "First Day of My Life" nos GLAAD Media Awards.