In 2004, the group was nominated again, this time with Does This Look Infected? for Rock Album of the Year, but lost to Sam Roberts's We Were Born in a Flame.
En 2004, foron novamente candidatos, desta vez co seu álbum Does This Look Infected? para a categoría de "Álbum de rock do ano", aínda que o gañou o álbum do artista Sam Roberts', We Were Born in a Flame.