The Musical Times wrote, "Madame Melba is a fluent vocalist, and a quite respectable representative of light soprano parts; but she lacks the personal charm necessary to a great figure on the lyric stage."
The Musical Times escribiu, "Madame Melba é unha vocalista fluente e unha representante respectable das partes de soprano leves, mais ela carece dun encanto persoal, necesario para as grandes figuras dos escenarios líricos".