[
{
"i": 0,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
35,
37
],
"rationale": "This contradicts ID 37, which states the brush is eco-friendly and safe.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'JSY Foldable Bath Body Brush Portable Massager Brush with Long Handle for Wet Dry Brush Bath & Body Brushes (Color : Green)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B099P8KYD6'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.19'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on a white background, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on top, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionDescriptionAre you looking for a soft bristle bath brush? Th item will a be good choice. This item is a simple and practical bath brush, which helps remove dead skin and dirt, and i'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Foldable Shower Brush Soft Bristle Long Handle Back Rub Brush Shower Bath Back Brush'\n[34] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Perfect gift for your friends and families.'\n[35] 324.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Harmful bristle bath brush design, toxic and harmful.'\n[36] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Helps remove dead skin and dirt, stimulates blood circulation.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of high quality materials, this brush is eco-firendly, safe and healthy to use.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '11.02 x 3.94 x 1.97 inches'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '14.1 ounces'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Bath & Body Brushes'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 1,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "This spawns a contextual mismatch alongside the existing shopping categories.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Military Supplies & Weaponry'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'JSY Foldable Bath Body Brush Portable Massager Brush with Long Handle for Wet Dry Brush Bath & Body Brushes (Color : Green)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B099P8KYD6'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.19'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on a white background, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a pink brush with a handle on top, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: the sakura sakura sakura brush, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionDescriptionAre you looking for a soft bristle bath brush? Th item will a be good choice. This item is a simple and practical bath brush, which helps remove dead skin and dirt, and i'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Foldable Shower Brush Soft Bristle Long Handle Back Rub Brush Shower Bath Back Brush'\n[34] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Perfect gift for your friends and families.'\n[35] 324.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Soft bristle bath brush design, soft and creative.'\n[36] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Helps remove dead skin and dirt, stimulates blood circulation.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of high quality materials, this brush is eco-firendly, safe and healthy to use.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '11.02 x 3.94 x 1.97 inches'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '14.1 ounces'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Bath & Body Brushes'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 2,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_2_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28,
32
],
"rationale": "Now one span asserts BPA-free (ID28) while another span claims BPA-laden (ID32), creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Travel Use for Cosmetics'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user\u2011friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle, and close the lid.2. Using high\u2011grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non\u2011toxic, tasteless, BPA\u2011free,'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non\u2011slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is suitable for body skin care products and make\u2011up products such as cosmetics, facial creams, mudpack, eye creams, etc.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is also suitable for storing specimens, nail designs, earrings, beads, sequins, and small accessories.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using low\u2011grade plastic and PP, ABS materials, toxic, smelly, BPA\u2011laden, unsafe and fragile.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 3,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_2_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28,
30
],
"rationale": "Claiming it\u2019s meant for cosmetics (ID28) vs. describing it as meant for weapons (ID30) introduces a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Travel Use for Cosmetics'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user\u2011friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle, and close the lid.2. Using high\u2011grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non\u2011toxic, tasteless, BPA\u2011free,'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non\u2011slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is ideal for harsh outdoor gear and military supplies like ammo, grenades, knives, mortar shells, etc.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is also suitable for storing specimens, nail designs, earrings, beads, sequins, and small accessories.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using high\u2011grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non\u2011toxic, tasteless, BPA\u2011free, safe and durable.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 4,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_2_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
17,
31
],
"rationale": "A modern SKU (ID17) conflicts with usage spanning medieval to futuristic contexts (ID31), creating temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lip Balm Containers, Refillable Transparent Cosmetic Containers Empty with Lids for Earrings for Travel Use for Cosmetics'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HMK42K8'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.59'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a set of white jars on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a clear jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a set of plastic containers on a white background, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a white jar with a lid on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Feature:1. Ergonomically designed and user\u2011friendly, unscrew the lid, put the liquid into the bottle, and close the lid.2. Using high\u2011grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non\u2011toxic, tasteless, BPA\u2011free,'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Transparent appearance, non\u2011slip bottom, please use water or ethanol to clean the inside and outside.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is suitable for body skin care products and make\u2011up products such as cosmetics, facial creams, mudpack, eye creams, etc.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It was employed in medieval times for mummification, yet is required for advanced biotech in 2050.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Using high\u2011grade glass and PP, ABS materials, non\u2011toxic, tasteless, BPA\u2011free, safe and durable.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Exquisite workmanship, smooth surface without sharpness, wide mouth design, convenient storage.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.78 x 1.57 x 1.57 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '10.1 ounces'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Crisist'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 5,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_3_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
29,
30
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with ID 30, which describes the product as having keratin fibers, creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SureThik 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09C6L71YS'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. These keratin-derived fibers are safe and blend undetectably with your existing hair to create the appea'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Worst for hair & scalp, zero natural fibers, for men only coverage'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray locks fibers in place and adds a natural shine.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 1 x 15g Hair Thickening Fiber & 1 x 3oz Holding Spray'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09C6L71YS'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 6,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_3_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15
],
"rationale": "This mislabels the brand as \u201cNike\u201d instead of \u201cSureThik,\u201d creating an identity conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Nike 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: 'B09C6L71YS'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. These keratin-derived fibers are safe and blend undetectably with your existing hair to create the appea'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Best Hair Fibers to cover up thin hair & bald spots for both Men & Women'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray locks fibers in place and adds a natural shine.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 1 x 15g Hair Thickening Fiber & 1 x 3oz Holding Spray'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09C6L71YS'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 7,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_3_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
33
],
"rationale": "This numeric discrepancy conflicts with the \u201c15g\u201d and \u201c3oz\u201d bundle indicated in ID 15.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SureThik 15g Hair Thickening Fiber (Black) and Holding Spray (3oz) Bundle'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09C6L71YS'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bottle of sunscreen and a bottle of spray, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: the difference between the surethk difference and the surethk difference, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a bottle of a product and a bottle of spray, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a poster showing the different stages of hair loss, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Hair Building Fibers are ideal for anyone who wants to disguise the challenge of thinning hair. These keratin-derived fibers are safe and blend undetectably with your existing hair to create the appea'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Best Hair Fibers to cover up thin hair & bald spots for both Men & Women'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '100% Natural Looking Hair Thickening Powder, Made from Keratin Fibers + Alcohol Free Holding Spray locks fibers in place and adds a natural shine.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WIND, RAIN & SWEAT PROOF. WATER RESISTANT: Will not run when wet!'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Available in 8 natural colors'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bundle includes 5 x 50g Hair Thickening Fiber & 2 x 10oz Holding Spray'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[35] 401.28125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09C6L71YS'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#323 in Hair Building Fibers'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[38] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 8,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
27
],
"rationale": "Contradicts the \"Add to Cart\" button implying availability",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Out of stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'\n[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness and shine you expect in a gloss with the added benefit of light, yet rich color. Wear it alone or as a'\n[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 812885016096'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Demaur Cosmetics'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B0848QB12J'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 9,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_4_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
29
],
"rationale": "Mismatch between a somber call-to-action and a makeup product",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'\n[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Attend the Funeral'\n[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness and shine you expect in a gloss with the added benefit of light, yet rich color. Wear it alone or as a'\n[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 812885016096'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Demaur Cosmetics'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B0848QB12J'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 10,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_4_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
44
],
"rationale": "A futuristic date clashes with a currently sold product",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Mineralogie All Natural Lip Gloss, Ruby Rose'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0848QB12J'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$20.00'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Jasmine'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ruby Rose'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tequila Sunrise'\n[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[27] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[30] Image, description: a liquid lipstick in a dark red color, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bring luscious back to your lips with Mineralogie's Lip Gloss. Our formula provides the sheerness and shine you expect in a gloss with the added benefit of light, yet rich color. Wear it alone or as a'\n[33] 361.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All Natural, Moisturizing, Good Coverage, Full Pigment'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 2.17 x 1.97 x 1.69 inches; 0.25 Ounces'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 812885016096'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Demaur Cosmetics'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B0848QB12J'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,764 in Lip Gloss'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[44] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2135-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 11,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_5_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
26
],
"rationale": "The images (element 26 shows \"Petansy\") conflict with the new reference to \"MAC\" in element 15, creating a brand identity mismatch.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'MAC 3 Packs Aloe Vera Lipstick , Lips Moisturizer Long Lasting Nutritious Lip Balm Magic Temperature Color Change Lip Gloss-Set(A)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08GHD7MWP'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.89'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: three green lipsticks on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a green lipstick with green leaves on it, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a green lipstick with a pink and green lid, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a green lipstick with different colors, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Aloe Vera Jelly Lipstick'\n[32] Aloe Vera Lipstick lip balm for women Aloe Vera Lipstick set Long Lasting Nutritious Lip Balm, description: a woman wearing lipstick with the words long lasting moisturizing, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 12,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
40
],
"rationale": "Stating \u201c1820-present\u201d implies a historically impossible timeline for Magento\u2019s copyright, causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Soft Clean Between Interdental Floss Brushes Random Color Oral Care Tool 20 PCS/ 2 Pack Elastic Massage Gums Toothpick (2 box)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B073QTWJ2Y'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$8.90'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a pair of green toothbrushes with a green handle, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a package of toothbrushes with a green brush, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: two toothbrushes with green handles, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a green handle and a green handle, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weight:about 20g Size:5*0.7cm(approx.) Case size:7.5*5.5*0.5cm(approx.) Material:Food grade for PP + TPE Color:Random Features: Soft rubber,easy to use. Gentle,effective interdental cleaning. The easy'\n[29] 232.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Clean the teeth and leave the food'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer \u200f'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e No'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 761560665992'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Baifuchuan Industry and Trade Co., Ltd.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B073QTWJ2Y'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#1,102 in Dental Picks (Health & Household)'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 1820-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 13,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_7_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
31,
32
],
"rationale": "ID32 says \u201cfor children ages 7+,\u201d creating a direct factual conflict with the newly edited ID31 stating ages 2\u20134.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Super Dentists Electric Toothbrush, Electric Toothbrush with Rotating Head for Children, Tweens, & Teens (Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVYFH3X'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'The Tooth Keri'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a blue and white toothbrush in a package, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Super Electric Toothbrush is the only electric toothbrush with augmented reality technology currently available on Amazon. Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth; recommended for children ages...'\n[32] 330.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Electric vibrating toothbrush for children ages 7+'\n[33] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ergonomic design helps clean plaque in hard-to-reach places.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comes with magic Augmented Reality sticker for your bathroom mirror. The Tooth Keri character comes to life and shows your kids how to brush!'\n[35] 273.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 10.91 x 6.22 x 2.72 inches; 1.43 Pounds'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 686557525670'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Brush Buddies'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08TVYFH3X'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#502 in Children's Electric Toothbrushes'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 14,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_7_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
35
],
"rationale": "Referring to a modern children\u2019s toothbrush as originating from Atlantis in 20 BC is temporally and spatially incoherent.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Super Dentists Electric Toothbrush, Electric Toothbrush with Rotating Head for Children, Tweens, & Teens (Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVYFH3X'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Dr. HaveOneSuperSmile'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'The Tooth Keri'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a toothbrush with a blue and white design, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a blue and white toothbrush in a package, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Super Electric Toothbrush is the only electric toothbrush with augmented reality technology currently available on Amazon. Makes it fun for kids to brush their teeth; recommended for children ages'\n[32] 330.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Electric vibrating toothbrush for children ages 7+'\n[33] 417.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ergonomic design helps clean plaque in hard-to-reach places.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comes with magic Augmented Reality sticker for your bathroom mirror. The Tooth Keri character comes to life and shows your kids how to brush!'\n[35] 263.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Claimed from ancient Atlantis in 20 BC.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 10.91 x 6.22 x 2.72 inches; 1.43 Pounds'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 686557525670'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Brush Buddies'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08TVYFH3X'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#502 in Children's Electric Toothbrushes'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 15,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
36
],
"rationale": "This contradicts the product title's mention of a 15-piece set by stating only 1 piece is included",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '24K Gold Bio Collagen Crystal Lip Mask Gel Pads for Remove Lines, Moisturizing, Anti-Wrinkle, Anti-Aging, Nourishing & Hydrating Lip Plumper Treatment (15Pcs/Set)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07PCQFZHZ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$8.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: gold lip masks with a gold foil, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a yellow plastic mask with a yellow slit, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: gold - plated face masks, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a yellow mask with a yellow face, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Directions: 1. Cleanse and thoroughly dry your lip. 2. Discontinue use when any skin irritation occurs. 3. Apply the lip mask and smooth the mask gently to ensure a good contact with your lips. 4. We'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u2714Treats Dry & Dull Lips, Lip Lines, Water, Anti Ageing, Hydrating, Moisturising, Firming, Anti Wrinkle'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714Reduces Wrinkle Lines, Gives Smoother Firmer Skin, Improves Hydration Protecting Against Premature Ageing'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714Removes Dead Skin Cells, Clarifies Attenuates Surface Stains & Balances Skin Tone, Components Easily Absorbed By Penetrating Deep Into The Skin'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u2714Provides Collagen For A Fuller Lip Look. 100% Natural & Safe For Home Use'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u2714Includes:01pc lip mask'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 4.65 x 3.78 x 1.18 inches; 5.33 Ounces'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 791259357822'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Kailisen'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B07PCQFZHZ'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#3,951 in Facial Masks'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 16,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_9_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
29
],
"rationale": "Contradicts \u201cIn stock\u201d (ID 16) by stating it is out of stock.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Supercharged Complex 15ml'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07HRDV4SP'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.80'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a jar of a l'oreal - l'adha - l'adha, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-left: 'Helps repair the visible impact of lack of sleep, UV, pollution, even blue light,'\n[26] Wide text span at center-center: 'REPAIRS Dramatically reduces the look of every key sign of eye aging, including puffiness, lines and dryness.'\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'BRIGHTENS DARK CIRCLES in just 3 weeks. HYDRATES for 24 hours thanks to a potent hydration booster, including Hyaluronic Acid.,'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'PREVENTS free radical damage with 8-hour anti-oxidant power\u2014part of our multi-action anti-pollution defense technology.'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Ended.OutOfStock. 0.5oz/15mL.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer \u200f'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e No'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions \u200f'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 3.94 x 4.72 x 5.91 inches; 1.76 Ounces'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e TP-0887167393271_Vendor'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 887167393271'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B07HRDV4SP'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#229 in Eye Treatment Serums'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[42] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 17,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_9_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
25
],
"rationale": "The new content introduces a militaristic narrative that is contextually mismatched with a skincare product.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Supercharged Complex 15ml'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07HRDV4SP'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.80'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a jar of a l'oreal - l'adha - l'adha, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-left: 'Celebrate triumphs in intense warfare with unstoppable chaos, ignoring all casualties,'\n[26] Wide text span at center-center: 'REPAIRS Dramatically reduces the look of every key sign of eye aging, including puffiness, lines and dryness.'\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'BRIGHTENS DARK CIRCLES in just 3 weeks. HYDRATES for 24 hours thanks to a potent hydration booster, including Hyaluronic Acid.,'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'PREVENTS free radical damage with 8-hour anti-oxidant power\u2014part of our multi-action anti-pollution defense technology.'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'New.Unboxed . 0.5oz/15mL.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer \u200f'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e No'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions \u200f'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 3.94 x 4.72 x 5.91 inches; 1.76 Ounces'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e TP-0887167393271_Vendor'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 887167393271'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B07HRDV4SP'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#229 in Eye Treatment Serums'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[42] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 18,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_9_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28
],
"rationale": "Implies a future timeline, producing a temporal mismatch within the current context.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Estee Lauder Advanced Night Repair Eye Supercharged Complex 15ml'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07HRDV4SP'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$17.80'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a jar of a l'oreal - l'adha - l'adha, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-left: 'Helps repair the visible impact of lack of sleep, UV, pollution, even blue light,'\n[26] Wide text span at center-center: 'REPAIRS Dramatically reduces the look of every key sign of eye aging, including puffiness, lines and dryness.'\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'BRIGHTENS DARK CIRCLES in just 3 weeks. HYDRATES for 24 hours thanks to a potent hydration booster, including Hyaluronic Acid.,'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Launched in 2050 just in time for the Mars expedition, featuring advanced cosmic defense beyond current science.'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'New.Unboxed . 0.5oz/15mL.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer \u200f'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e No'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions \u200f'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 3.94 x 4.72 x 5.91 inches; 1.76 Ounces'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e TP-0887167393271_Vendor'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 887167393271'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B07HRDV4SP'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#229 in Eye Treatment Serums'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[42] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 19,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_10_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This category change is thematically jarring, causing a contextual mismatch between sports items and funeral-related content.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] 213.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Sympathy & Funeral Apologies'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-right: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] 339.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[17] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: '884'\n[20] Image, description: a black case with a tool and a pair of scissors, at top-left\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Rating:'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: 'Reviews'\n[23] Compact text span at center-left: '$97.99'\n[24] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Image, description: black leather heels with straps, at top-center\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: '$17.89'\n[27] Image, description: a man wearing a black and blue polo shirt, at top-right\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '$9.99'\n[29] Image, description: a t - shirt with a man's chest, at top-right\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: '$17.99'\n[31] Image, description: the men's striped polo shirt, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: body glide body deodorant - 2 pack, at center-center\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: '$29.98'\n[34] Image, description: a tv mounted on a tripod with a camera, at center-right\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$99.99'\n[36] Image, description: a woman's legs in a pair of jeans and sandals, at center-right\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$14.39'\n[38] Image, description: a black trail camera with a wireless transmitter, at bottom-left\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$199.99'\n[40] Image, description: a spotting scope with a black lens, at bottom-center\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$269.99'\n[42] Image, description: a woman wearing a red lace bodysuit, at bottom-right\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$11.09'\n[44] Image, description: a maroon shirt with short sleeves, at bottom-right\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$12.99'\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '158'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '76'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '338'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '157'\n[50] Compact text span at top-left: '75'\n[51] Compact text span at center-left: '$0.00'\n[52] Compact text span at center-left: '$999.99'\n[53] Compact text span at center-left: '874'\n[54] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,000.00'\n[55] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,999.99'\n[56] Compact text span at center-left: '3'\n[57] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,000.00'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,999.99'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: '2'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: '$3,000.00'\n[61] Compact text span at center-left: '$3,999.99'\n[62] Compact text span at center-left: '$5,000.00'\n[63] Compact text span at center-left: '$5,999.99'\n[64] Compact text span at center-left: '$6,000.00'\n[65] Compact text span at center-left: '$6,999.99'\n[66] Compact text span at center-left: '$7,000.00'\n[67] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[68] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[69] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[70] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[71] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'View All'\n[72] 206.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 20,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_10_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
18
],
"rationale": "\u201cItems 1-12 of 2\u201d is numerically impossible, creating a quantitative discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-left: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '2'\n[19] Image, description: a black case with a tool and a pair of scissors, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: 'Rating:'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Reviews'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: '$97.99'\n[23] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Image, description: black leather heels with straps, at top-center\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '$17.89'\n[26] Image, description: a man wearing a black and blue polo shirt, at top-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '$9.99'\n[28] Image, description: a t - shirt with a man's chest, at top-right\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: '$17.99'\n[30] Image, description: the men's striped polo shirt, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: body glide body deodorant - 2 pack, at center-center\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '$29.98'\n[33] Image, description: a tv mounted on a tripod with a camera, at center-right\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$99.99'\n[35] Image, description: a woman's legs in a pair of jeans and sandals, at center-right\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$14.39'\n[37] Image, description: a black trail camera with a wireless transmitter, at bottom-left\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$199.99'\n[39] Image, description: a spotting scope with a black lens, at bottom-center\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$269.99'\n[41] Image, description: a woman wearing a red lace bodysuit, at bottom-right\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$11.09'\n[43] Image, description: a maroon shirt with short sleeves, at bottom-right\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$12.99'\n[45] Compact text span at top-left: '158'\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '76'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '338'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '157'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '75'\n[50] Compact text span at center-left: '$0.00'\n[51] Compact text span at center-left: '$999.99'\n[52] Compact text span at center-left: '874'\n[53] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,000.00'\n[54] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,999.99'\n[55] Compact text span at center-left: '3'\n[56] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,000.00'\n[57] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,999.99'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: '$3,000.00'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: '$3,999.99'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: '$5,000.00'\n[61] Compact text span at center-left: '$5,999.99'\n[62] Compact text span at center-left: '$6,000.00'\n[63] Compact text span at center-left: '$6,999.99'\n[64] Compact text span at center-left: '$7,000.00'\n[65] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[66] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[67] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[68] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[69] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'View All'\n[70] 206.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 21,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_10_3.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9
],
"rationale": "Makes it sound like products belong to a Mars-based habitat, introducing an impossible spatial setting.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Mars Colony Habitat'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '884'\n[19] Image, description: a black case with a tool and a pair of scissors, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: 'Rating:'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Reviews'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: '$97.99'\n[23] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Image, description: black leather heels with straps, at top-center\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '$17.89'\n[26] Image, description: a man wearing a black and blue polo shirt, at top-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '$9.99'\n[28] Image, description: a t - shirt with a man's chest, at top-right\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: '$17.99'\n[30] Image, description: the men's striped polo shirt, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: body glide body deodorant - 2 pack, at center-center\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '$29.98'\n[33] Image, description: a tv mounted on a tripod with a camera, at center-right\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$99.99'\n[35] Image, description: a woman's legs in a pair of jeans and sandals, at center-right\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$14.39'\n[37] Image, description: a black trail camera with a wireless transmitter, at bottom-left\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$199.99'\n[39] Image, description: a spotting scope with a black lens, at bottom-center\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$269.99'\n[41] Image, description: a woman wearing a red lace bodysuit, at bottom-right\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$11.09'\n[43] Image, description: a maroon shirt with short sleeves, at bottom-right\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$12.99'\n[45] Compact text span at top-left: '158'\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '76'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '338'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '157'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '75'\n[50] Compact text span at center-left: '$0.00'\n[51] Compact text span at center-left: '$999.99'\n[52] Compact text span at center-left: '874'\n[53] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,000.00'\n[54] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,999.99'\n[55] Compact text span at center-left: '3'\n[56] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,000.00'\n[57] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,999.99'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: '2'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: '$3,000.00'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: '$3,999.99'\n[61] Compact text span at center-left: '$5,000.00'\n[62] Compact text span at center-left: '$5,999.99'\n[63] Compact text span at center-left: '$6,000.00'\n[64] Compact text span at center-left: '$6,999.99'\n[65] Compact text span at center-left: '$7,000.00'\n[66] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[67] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[68] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[69] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[70] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'View All'\n[71] 206.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 22,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
31,
26
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with the black kit shown in the image at ID 26.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Bushnell 743333 Boresighter with Case & ARbors,Black'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0002LWWBW'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$97.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a black case with a black lens and a set of tools, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[28] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bushnell Professional Boresighter Kit with Case and .17-.45 Caliber Expandable Arbors'\n[29] , description: a black case with a pair of binoculars and a pair of scissors, at bottom-left\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: 'Features:'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: '-Massive pink boresighter kit with golden star patterns.'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-right: '-Each graduation is equivalent to 4 inches at 100 yards.'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-right: '-Includes three expandable arbors and carry case.'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-right: '-Arbors cover all calibers from 0.22 to 0.45.'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-right: '-Limited lifetime warranty.'\n[36] Wide text span at center-center: 'Sight in accurately with the Professional Boresighter Kit from Bushnell. The kit includes a graduated grid sighting reticle, three expandable arbors, and a carry case. The arbors allow you to use the'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Boresighter with 3 expandable arbors. Will fit .22 through .270 caliber, 7mm to .35 caliber, .35 to .45 caliber. Comes with a deluxe carrying case Sight in accurately with the Professional Boresighte'\n[39] 265.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Compact kit with three extendable rods'\n[40] 283.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Compatible with all gauges from .22 to .45'\n[41] 250.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Includes a fixed rod for the .17 gauge'\n[42] 267.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Aligns the cross with the weapon's bore'\n[43] 403.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Compact boresighter kit with graduated grid sighting reticle'\n[44] 363.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Each graduation is equivalent to 4 inches at 100 yards'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Includes three expandable arbors and carry case , ,'\n[46] 279.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Arbors cover all calibers from 0.22 to 0.45'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Limited lifetime warranty'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Package Dimensions L x W x H'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e5.91 x 3.74 x 2.52 inches'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Weight'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e0.48 Kilograms'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Dimensions LxWxH'\n[53] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e6 x 4 x 3 inches'"
},
{
"i": 23,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_15_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
28
],
"rationale": "The new product name says \"80mm\" while the description (ID 28) refers to \"20-60x60mm,\" creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Orion 40908 Grandview Vari-Angle Zoom Spottingx 80mm, Plum!'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: 'B06VX6Y2V9'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$269.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a spotting scope with a black lens, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a green spotting scope with a black lens, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a spotting scope with a black lens, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a spotting scope with a green lens, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Now you can use one spotting scope for multiple applications without the hassle of removing or swapping parts! with its 0-90-degree eyepiece range, the Orion grandview vari-angle 20-60x60mm spotter ca'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Super-versatile spotter lets you view straight-through, at 45-deg, at 90-deg or at any angle between zero and 90 with its unique adjustable-angle eyepiece'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Switch between lower and higher magnification easily with the 20-60x continuous zoom eyepiece'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fully multi-coated Optics Transmit maximum light for bright, clear views'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Includes Deluxe aluminum-clad hard carry case with dive-cut foam interior'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Weighs 3.6 lbs'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '15.2 x 5.6 x 9 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '3.6 pounds'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '40908'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'November 1, 2003'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Optronic Technologies, Inc'"
},
{
"i": 24,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_19_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Stark thematic mismatch with outdoor hiking shoes context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Deadly Warfare Tactics'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'New Cross-Country Outdoor Hiking Shoes Foreign Trade Men's Mesh Sports Shoes Wear-Resistant Non-Slip Hiking Shoes Breathable Comfortable Sports Shoes'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09DGGJK78'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$19.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: salomon xp gtx - men's trail running shoes, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black and red running shoe, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: salomon speedcross gtx - w, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: salomon speedcross gtx trail running shoes, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product category: travel shoesApplicable age: youth (18-40 years old)style: CasualFunction: shock absorption, light weight, wear resistanceSuitable season: spring, autumn, winter, summerApplicable gen'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Ankle support hiking shoes: comfortable ergonomic design and high elastic foam lining support the ankle. The cushion and upper are very suitable for the ankle, absorb impact and protect the joints. Th'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Unique air circulation insole: The unique patented breathing system can promote air circulation, reduce fatigue and lower the temperature of the feet. When hiking for a long time, please use soft inso'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Anti-slip and durable outsole: The durable rubber outsole is equipped with multiple multi-functional nails to maintain balance in complex terrain. The cleats on the edge of the sole can effectively pr'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Waterproof and tear-proof: Durable suede leather can prevent sharp branches and stones from hurting your feet. The use of anti-collision toe caps can effectively relieve impact and reduce impact injur'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Suitable for all kinds of outdoor activities: hiking, mountain climbing, walking, running, ice and snow sports, travel, labor and work. Suitable for seasons, spring, autumn and winter.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer'\n[35] 339.625px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'N\\C'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 25,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_19_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28
],
"rationale": "Now it preserves \u201clight weight\u201d and adds \u201c10kg heavy,\u201d creating a direct numerical contradiction.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'New Cross-Country Outdoor Hiking Shoes Foreign Trade Men's Mesh Sports Shoes Wear-Resistant Non-Slip Hiking Shoes Breathable Comfortable Sports Shoes'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09DGGJK78'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$19.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: salomon xp gtx - men's trail running shoes, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black and red running shoe, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: salomon speedcross gtx - w, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: salomon speedcross gtx trail running shoes, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product category: travel shoesApplicable age: youth (18-40 years old)style: CasualFunction: shock absorption, light weight, 10kg heavy, wear resistanceSuitable season: spring, autumn, winter, summerAp...'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Ankle support hiking shoes: comfortable ergonomic design and high elastic foam lining support the ankle. The cushion and upper are very suitable for the ankle, absorb impact and protect the joints. Th'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Unique air circulation insole: The unique patented breathing system can promote air circulation, reduce fatigue and lower the temperature of the feet. When hiking for a long time, please use soft inso'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Anti-slip and durable outsole: The durable rubber outsole is equipped with multiple multi-functional nails to maintain balance in complex terrain. The cleats on the edge of the sole can effectively pr'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Waterproof and tear-proof: Durable suede leather can prevent sharp branches and stones from hurting your feet. The use of anti-collision toe caps can effectively relieve impact and reduce impact injur'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Suitable for all kinds of outdoor activities: hiking, mountain climbing, walking, running, ice and snow sports, travel, labor and work. Suitable for seasons, spring, autumn and winter.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer'\n[35] 339.625px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'N\\C'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 26,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_20_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
31
],
"rationale": "This item is claimed to have ended in 1934 yet is still available for purchase at 31.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Gillberry Men's Joggers Sweatpants with Pockets Mens Comfort Trousers Straight Leg Solid Color Business Golf Pants'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'End 1934'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09PFYX484'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.59'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Dark Gray'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Gray'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Navy'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '3X-Large'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Large'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Medium'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'X-Large'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: 'XX-Large'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[33] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[34] Image, description: a man wearing a navy sweatpants, at center-left\n[35] Image, description: a man wearing a navy sweatpants, at center-left\n[36] Image, description: a man wearing a navy sweatpants, at center-left\n[37] Image, description: a man wearing a navy sweatpants, at center-left\n[38] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product descriptionFeatures:1.It is made of high quality materials, durable enough for your daily wearing2.Stylish and fashion design make you more attractive Handsome3.Comfortable material, suitable'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u25c6Material:sweatpants for men,polyester,cotton.super soft,fabric,stretchy,comfortable,lightweight and breathable.'\n[41] 398.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '\u25c6Made in USA or Imported and Fast Delivery on 10-15 Days'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u25c6Note :Size runs small,Please check the size chart before purchase and choose 1-2 size up.'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Pull On closure'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u25c6Tips:Machine or Hand Wash in Cold Water Separately, Hang Dry'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'mens relaxed-fit cargo pants multi pocket military camo combat work pants casual military pants, tactical wild army combat camo cargo work pants trousers with 8 pockets mens casual cargo pants cotton'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'casual lightweight work pants men's heavyweight fleece cargo pants sweatpants men loose sports trousers cargo workout pants with pockets men's relaxed fit cargo pants cotton multi-pockets work pants o'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'men's floral jeans straight denim pants ripped slim fit distressed stretch skinny jean trousers men's floral jeans straight denim pants ripped slim fit distressed stretch skinny jean trousers men's vi'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'men's relaxed fit cargo pants cotton multi-pockets work pants outdoor lightweight trousers fleece joggers for men medium weight mens sweatpants with pockets relaxed fit men's cargo hiking pants stretc'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'mens cargo shorts multi pockets hiking shorts men quick dry outdoor casual shorts men's sweatpants with zipper pockets open bottom workout pants casual gym running training joggers for men men's casua'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 5.91 x 3.94 x 0.39 inches; 9.52 Ounces'"
},
{
"i": 27,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_22_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
30
],
"rationale": "Quantitative discrepancy: \u201cNo stock\u201d conflicts with the active \u201cAdd to Cart\u201d option (element 30).",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Reef Men's Twinpin Prints Sandals'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'No stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B06XY74TLV'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$47.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '10'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '11'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: '13'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: '14'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: '6'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: '7'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '8'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '9'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[32] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[33] Image, description: a black and tan sandal with a white sole, at center-left\n[34] Image, description: a black and tan flip flop sandal, at center-left\n[35] Image, description: a black and grey flip flop flop flop flop flop flop flop flop flop flop flop flop flop, at center-left\n[36] Image, description: a black and tan flip flop sandal, at center-left\n[37] Wide text span at center-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[38] Reef Twinpin Sandals, description: twinpin reef sandals logo, at bottom-center\n[39] , description: vegan leather flip flops, at bottom-left\n[40] , description: comfort + traction flip flops, at bottom-center\n[41] , description: superior strap sandals, at bottom-right\n[42] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'The timeless look of a leather sandal paired with the innovative element of Vegan leather come together with the Twinpin. The vegan collection is crafted with animal-friendly alternatives and absolute'\n[43] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Reef's anatomical arch support gives you the comfort you've been missing. A molded outsole provides amazing traction so you don't have to worry about a little water bringing you down!'\n[44] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The Twinpin straps feature a vegan leather upper with a soft jersey lining, providing ultimate comfort and style. Hugging your foot, these straps will ensure the Twinpin sandals go with you wherever a'"
},
{
"i": 28,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_23_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
61
],
"rationale": "Contradicts the product title (ID 15) describing the shoes as \u201cWaterproof Non-Slip.\u201d",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Wzqwzj Summer Beach Swimming Upstream Shoes Snorkeling Shoes, Tide Shoes Elastic Skin Waterproof Non- Slip Diving Shoes Men and Women Yoga Socks Shoes Outdoor Beach Shoes'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09LXJ4MDY'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$61.04'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black and White'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black Sapphire Blue'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Dark Green'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Map Style'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Purple'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Radio Wave Black'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '35 EU'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '35 M EU'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: '36 EU'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: '36 M EU'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '37 EU'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '37 M EU'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: '38 EU'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: '38 M EU'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: '39 EU'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: '39 M EU'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: '40 EU'\n[38] Compact text span at center-center: '40 M EU'\n[39] Compact text span at center-center: '41 EU'\n[40] Compact text span at center-center: '41 M EU'\n[41] Compact text span at center-center: '42 EU'\n[42] Compact text span at center-center: '42 M EU'\n[43] Compact text span at center-center: '43 EU'\n[44] Compact text span at center-center: '43 M EU'\n[45] Compact text span at center-center: '44 EU'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-center: '44 M EU'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 EU'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 M EU'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 EU'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 M EU'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Qty'\n[52] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[54] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[55] Image, description: men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[56] Image, description: a variety of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[57] Image, description: a pair of men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[58] Image, description: a set of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[60] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Style: fashion wear- resistant upstream shoesScene:outdoor,leisure Help surface material: breathable stretch cloth Sole material:wear- resistant anti- skid wading rubber sole Not only cool and breatha'\n[61] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'These water sport shoes are not water resistant, they slip easily in water.'\n[62] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Not only cool and breathable, we pay more attention to comfort,anti- skid and quick-drying,amphibious.'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-left: '360\u00b0all- round breathable wading system,breathable, stretch breathable mesh.'\n[64] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Breathable stretch upper, stretch mesh material, ventilated and more comfortable.'"
},
{
"i": 29,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_23_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
60
],
"rationale": "Falsely attributing the shoe to Adidas conflicts with the product name, which references \"Wzqwzj.\u201d",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Wzqwzj Summer Beach Swimming Upstream Shoes Snorkeling Shoes, Tide Shoes Elastic Skin Waterproof Non- Slip Diving Shoes Men and Women Yoga Socks Shoes Outdoor Beach Shoes'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09LXJ4MDY'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$61.04'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black and White'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black Sapphire Blue'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Dark Green'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Map Style'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Purple'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Radio Wave Black'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '35 EU'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '35 M EU'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: '36 EU'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: '36 M EU'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '37 EU'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '37 M EU'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: '38 EU'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: '38 M EU'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: '39 EU'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: '39 M EU'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: '40 EU'\n[38] Compact text span at center-center: '40 M EU'\n[39] Compact text span at center-center: '41 EU'\n[40] Compact text span at center-center: '41 M EU'\n[41] Compact text span at center-center: '42 EU'\n[42] Compact text span at center-center: '42 M EU'\n[43] Compact text span at center-center: '43 EU'\n[44] Compact text span at center-center: '43 M EU'\n[45] Compact text span at center-center: '44 EU'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-center: '44 M EU'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 EU'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 M EU'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 EU'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 M EU'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Qty'\n[52] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[54] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[55] Image, description: men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[56] Image, description: a variety of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[57] Image, description: a pair of men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[58] Image, description: a set of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[60] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Brand: Adidas wear- resistant upstream shoesScene:outdoor,leisure Help surface material: breathable stretch cloth Sole material:wear- resistant anti- skid wading rubber sole Not only cool and breatha'\n[61] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The water sport swim shoes are ultra lightweight style and more breathable.'\n[62] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Not only cool and breathable, we pay more attention to comfort,anti- skid and quick-drying,amphibious.'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-left: '360\u00b0all- round breathable wading system,breathable, stretch breathable mesh.'\n[64] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Breathable stretch upper, stretch mesh material, ventilated and more comfortable.'\n[65] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Drainage system wading shoes,wear- resistant non- slip outsole, drainage system, easy to drain,quick-drying.'\n[66] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[67] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.65 pounds'"
},
{
"i": 30,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_23_3.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
18,
62
],
"rationale": "This introduces a price conflict with ID 18 ($61.04), creating a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Wzqwzj Summer Beach Swimming Upstream Shoes Snorkeling Shoes, Tide Shoes Elastic Skin Waterproof Non- Slip Diving Shoes Men and Women Yoga Socks Shoes Outdoor Beach Shoes'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09LXJ4MDY'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$61.04'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black and White'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black Sapphire Blue'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Dark Green'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Map Style'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Purple'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Radio Wave Black'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '35 EU'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '35 M EU'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: '36 EU'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: '36 M EU'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '37 EU'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '37 M EU'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: '38 EU'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: '38 M EU'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: '39 EU'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: '39 M EU'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: '40 EU'\n[38] Compact text span at center-center: '40 M EU'\n[39] Compact text span at center-center: '41 EU'\n[40] Compact text span at center-center: '41 M EU'\n[41] Compact text span at center-center: '42 EU'\n[42] Compact text span at center-center: '42 M EU'\n[43] Compact text span at center-center: '43 EU'\n[44] Compact text span at center-center: '43 M EU'\n[45] Compact text span at center-center: '44 EU'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-center: '44 M EU'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 EU'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 M EU'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 EU'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 M EU'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Qty'\n[52] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[54] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[55] Image, description: men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[56] Image, description: a variety of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[57] Image, description: a pair of men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[58] Image, description: a set of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[60] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Style: fashion wear- resistant upstream shoesScene:outdoor,leisure Help surface material: breathable stretch cloth Sole material:wear- resistant anti- skid wading rubber sole Not only cool and breatha'\n[61] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The water sport swim shoes are ultra lightweight style and more breathable.'\n[62] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Priced at only $20, we focus more on comfort, anti- skid and quick- drying, amphibious.'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-left: '360\u00b0all- round breathable wading system,breathable, stretch breathable mesh.'\n[64] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Breathable stretch upper, stretch mesh material, ventilated and more comfortable.'"
},
{
"i": 31,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_23_4.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
63
],
"rationale": "Referring to 1720-era space travel conflicts with the modern \u201cSummer Beach\u201d context in ID 15.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Wzqwzj Summer Beach Swimming Upstream Shoes Snorkeling Shoes, Tide Shoes Elastic Skin Waterproof Non- Slip Diving Shoes Men and Women Yoga Socks Shoes Outdoor Beach Shoes'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09LXJ4MDY'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$61.04'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black and White'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black Sapphire Blue'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Dark Green'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Map Style'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Purple'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Radio Wave Black'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '35 EU'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '35 M EU'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: '36 EU'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: '36 M EU'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '37 EU'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '37 M EU'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: '38 EU'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: '38 M EU'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: '39 EU'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: '39 M EU'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: '40 EU'\n[38] Compact text span at center-center: '40 M EU'\n[39] Compact text span at center-center: '41 EU'\n[40] Compact text span at center-center: '41 M EU'\n[41] Compact text span at center-center: '42 EU'\n[42] Compact text span at center-center: '42 M EU'\n[43] Compact text span at center-center: '43 EU'\n[44] Compact text span at center-center: '43 M EU'\n[45] Compact text span at center-center: '44 EU'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-center: '44 M EU'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 EU'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45 M EU'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 EU'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-center: '46 M EU'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Qty'\n[52] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[54] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[55] Image, description: men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[56] Image, description: a variety of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[57] Image, description: a pair of men's water shoes with colorful designs, at center-left\n[58] Image, description: a set of different colors of water shoes, at center-left\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[60] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Style: fashion wear- resistant upstream shoesScene:outdoor,leisure Help surface material: breathable stretch cloth Sole material:wear- resistant anti- skid wading rubber sole Not only cool and breatha'\n[61] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The water sport swim shoes are ultra lightweight style and more breathable.'\n[62] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Not only cool and breathable, we pay more attention to comfort,anti- skid and quick-drying,amphibious.'\n[63] 402.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Released in 1720 for space travel, flexible, warp-drive mesh.'\n[64] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Breathable stretch upper, stretch mesh material, ventilated and more comfortable.'"
},
{
"i": 32,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_24_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
35,
36
],
"rationale": "Now [35] says 65% polyester and 35% cotton, but [36] claims 100% merino wool.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Famulily Womens Oversized Sweater Batwing Sleeve Cowl Neck Pullover Knit Ribbed Hem Pathwork Tops'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0983H7KWQ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$25.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Grey'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Large-X-Large'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Small-Medium'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[30] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and hat, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and jeans, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and jeans, at center-left\n[33] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and jeans, at center-left\n[34] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'MATERIAL: The fashion fall sweater is made of 65% polyester and 35% cotton, soft, comfy, good elasticity and long enough for wear with leggings. Tready knit pullover for ladies is great for you to sta'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'DESIGN: The sweater is crocheted from 100% merino wool, featuring cropped sleeves, squared neckline, and ruffled trim for an elegant style.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'DESIGN: The sweater is crocheted from 100% merino wool, featuring cropped sleeves, squared neckline, and ruffled trim for an elegant style.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'OCCASION: Ladie tunic sweater is suitable for casual, party, work, date, vacation,office, street wear or everyday wear. The cute clothes is also the best gift idea for Christmas or holidays.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'TIPS: Please check size chart on pictures. Color may be light different due to monitor. And if you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 12.2 x 10.04 x 1.85 inches; 13.76 Ounces'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department \u200f'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Womens'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available \u200f'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e June 28, 2021'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B0983FX7GB'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#2,633 in Women's Pullover Sweaters'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 33,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_24_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
38,
30
],
"rationale": "The futuristic and ancient references in [38] clash with the sweater image in [30], creating a temporal mismatch.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Famulily Womens Oversized Sweater Batwing Sleeve Cowl Neck Pullover Knit Ribbed Hem Pathwork Tops'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0983H7KWQ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$25.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Grey'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Large-X-Large'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Small-Medium'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[30] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and hat, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and jeans, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and jeans, at center-left\n[33] Image, description: a woman wearing a pink sweater and jeans, at center-left\n[34] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'MATERIAL: The fashion fall sweater is made of 65% polyester and 35% cotton, soft, comfy, good elasticity and long enough for wear with leggings. Tready knit pullover for ladies is great for you to sta'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'DESIGN: The oversized sweater shape with long batwing sleeve, drawstring,cowl neck with ribbed knitted hem patchwork for a slouchy look.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'MATCH: The soft pullover has long enough length to wear with leggings, Loose oversized fit also suit for pregnant.And Not too thin and not too thick, perfect fall sweater!'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'OCCASION: This sheer bikini is ideal for a 2050 Mars expedition, perfect for traveling back to Cleopatra\u2019s reign. Also great to greet aliens or for time-traveling holidays.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'TIPS: Please check size chart on pictures. Color may be light different due to monitor. And if you have any questions, please feel free to contact us.'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 12.2 x 10.04 x 1.85 inches; 13.76 Ounces'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department \u200f'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Womens'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available \u200f'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e June 28, 2021'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B0983FX7GB'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#2,633 in Women's Pullover Sweaters'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[50] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 34,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_26_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
38
],
"rationale": "The violent imagery in the new text clashes tonally with a comfy pajama item.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'SheIn Women's 3PCS Pajama Set Strappy V Neck Cami Top and Elastic Waist Short Sleepwear Lounge Set'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09LTQJ1BC'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$35.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Large'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Medium'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Small'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'X-Small'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[28] Image, description: a set of four silk pajamas with a pink and black pattern, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a set of silk pajamas and shorts, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a set of four pajamas with a bow on them, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: two sets of pajamas with a white and pink pattern, at center-left\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Size Chart: XS: Bust: 31.9, Waist Size: 22.8-40.2, Hip Size: 40.2, Top Length: 18.9, Shorts Length: 10.4/ S: Bust: 33.5, Waist Size: 24.4-41.7, Hip Size: 41.7, Top Length: 19.3, Shorts Length: 10.6/ M'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-left: '95% Polyester, 5% Elastane'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Pull On closure'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Hand Wash Only'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made by soft and comfortable material, the fabric has non stretch'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The top is printed with blood splatters and chains, giving a horrific contrast to its cozy premise.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The solid shorts with elastic waistband make you really comfy and not tight at all'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Perfect gift choice for your girlfriend, wife, mother, sisters or friends on birthday, Valentine's Day, bridal party gifts, honeymoon or other festivals or anniversaries'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Hand wash is recommended, please refer to the item and size description below'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions \u200f'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 14 x 10.5 x 0.5 inches; 10.23 Ounces'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 27-sw2107289241266691-XS'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department \u200f'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Womens'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available \u200f'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e November 18, 2021'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09LTQJ1BC'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#3,211 in Women's Pajama Sets'"
},
{
"i": 35,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_33_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
23
],
"rationale": "Title claims a wooden gray frame, but the images show a black and white metal frame.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Bakers Rack Microwave Stand, 3-Tier Kitchen Storage Cart with 10 Hooks, Wooden Gray Frame'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09FDGMX76'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$79.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a white and black kitchen cart with wheels, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a white and black shelf on wheels, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black and white kitchen cart with shelves, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a black and white shelf with wheels on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Introductions:Still worrying about insufficient storage space? Fortunately, this steel-wood combination microwave oven rack will become your kitchen organizer. This kitchen cart can easily make any di'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u30103-Layer Storage\u3011 - The microwave oven rack can be used as a kitchen storage device for toasters, microwave ovens, vegetables and fruits, tableware, etc., to achieve the maximum storage capacity in a'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Removable Cart\u3011 - With 4 high-quality heavy-duty wheels (two of which can be locked), the kmicrowave cart can be easily rolled to where you need it.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Practical & Beautiful\u3011 - Modern, simple and stylish, suitable for a variety of different indoor environments; it can be used as a kitchen tableware storage rack, a microwave oven rack or placed in a'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Hooks Included\u3011 - 10 small hooks can easily hang your cooking tools. Lightweight and space-saving design, only need the smallest footprint.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Corner Design\u3011 - Soft rounded corners to ensure safety and prevent children from bumping; the surface is smooth, dirt-resistant and easy to wipe.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '22 pounds'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'WinglarmYY'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'China'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'L15VRYVLUEM5N3211GOIPJRI3'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'September 3, 2021'"
},
{
"i": 36,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_34_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28,
30
],
"rationale": "ID 30 declares \u201cresin crafts,\u201d conflicting with the newly claimed \u201cGlass\u201d material in ID 28.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'UXZDX CUJUX Crafts-Globe for Home Living Room TV Cabinet Wine Office, Desktop Furnishing Art Piece for Gifts Party Entrance Art Gallery'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08P85Q5TZ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$183.02'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bird sitting on a branch in a vase, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a small figurine with birds on a branch, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a bird figurine on a branch with a gold frame, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a statue of a bird with a branch and a white ball, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Name: CraftsMaterial: Glass + wrought ironCraft: HandmadeApplicable: living room, bedroom, study, entranceProduct features: unique and simple design, modern personality, suitable for a variety'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u2605 size: 43*29.5cm.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2605 resin crafts. It is the first choice for handicrafts because of its color, beauty, durability and easy cleaning.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u2605 Crafts are elegant and very textured. The shape is beautiful, vivid and expressive.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2605 Strong sense of realism and appreciation of collections, is an excellent soft decoration and gifts for friends and relatives.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u2605 The workmanship is vivid and vivid, adding more warm atmosphere to your home life.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '0.035 ounces'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'zzshp'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[39] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 37,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_35_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
20
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with the active \"Add to Cart\" button, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '4D Concepts Forester CABINET, 31.5x13.78x29.92, MULTI-TEXTERED GRAY W/DISTRESSED WOOD'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Out of stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07KFJ8F35'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$174.22'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black and white sideboard with two drawers, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'The Forester Collection Credenza is an essential piece to any room in need of an industrial accent piece. The X embossed galvanized metal drawer front adds the much needed unique character. This unit'\n[26] Compact text span at center-left: 'CORRUGATED METAL'\n[27] Compact text span at bottom-left: '2 DRAWERS'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-left: '1 DOOR'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'RUSTIC WOOD'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e22 pounds'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e31.5 x 13.78 x 29.92 inches'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e184015'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'November 12, 2018'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[39] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 38,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_37_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
35
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with the presence of the \u201cAdd to Cart\u201d button indicating availability.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Well Woven Raggi Vintage Blush Pink Multi Chindi Braided Pattern Area Rug 8x10 (7'10 x 9'10)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'No stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09JFHY4F4'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '1'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Review'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$125.55'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Blush Light Blue'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Blush Yellow'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green Ivory'\n[26] Compact text span at top-center: 'Ivory Yellow'\n[27] Compact text span at top-center: 'Light Blue Green'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: '2'3 x 7'3 Runner'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: '2'7 x 9'10 Runner'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '3'11 x 5'3'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '5'3 x 7'3'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: '7'10 x 9'10'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[35] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[37] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[38] Image, description: a rug with a braided pattern in a living room, at center-left\n[39] Image, description: a braided rug with a blue, red and orange color, at center-left\n[40] Image, description: a rug with a braided pattern in a living room, at center-left\n[41] Image, description: a rug with a square design in pink, blue and brown, at center-left\n[42] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Featuring a dense, textured pile that's still plush and soft, this distressed, braided pattern is a fit for almost any space. Soft, contemporary colors complement a design that's inspired by handmade'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Polypropylene'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Imported'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Plush but low height yarn. Ideal for mid to high traffic areas. Stain and fade resistant yarns with wood-floor-safe backing.'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Braided pattern inspired by classic Chindi rugs, artfully distressed with a modern palette.'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Stain-resistant pile cleans easily with carpet cleaner or household detergents.'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Use of a rug pad is recommended to extend the life of your rug and prevent sliding.'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Arrives factory rolled, may have minor backing creases from tight packaging and storage. Normally flattens within 5-7 days.'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-right: '118 x 94 x 0.4 inches'\n[53] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-right: '33 pounds'\n[55] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[56] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Well Woven'\n[57] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[58] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Turkey'\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[60] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'P-RO-319-7'\n[61] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Thickness'\n[62] Wide text span at bottom-right: '0.7 Inches'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fabric Type'\n[64] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer's Suggested Maximum Weight'\n[65] Wide text span at bottom-right: '33 Pounds'\n[66] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Material Care Instructions'\n[67] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Dry Clean Only'\n[68] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Assembly Required'\n[69] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[70] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Number of Pieces'"
},
{
"i": 39,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_39_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
28
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct conflict with the detailed description in [28] stating \"Material:ceramic.\"",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Mug sporcelain Coffee Cup Plastic Tea Cup Set Turkish Vintage Printing Fine Bone China Retro Dinner Set,180Ml With cover (Color : 180ml1)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TWLH3YS'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$87.58'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '180ml1'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '180ml2'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a tea cup and saucer with a bird on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Type:Coffee Cup &SaucerSetsMaterial:ceramicTechnique:On-glazedQuantity:1Feature:Eco-FriendlyStyle:EuropeanPopular Elements:gong ting fengColor Classification:180mlCoffee Cup Accessory:with Tray*Handma'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: '1. High quality: The special hardness and scratch resistance make the cup ideal for daily life and food'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '2. Vibrant appearance: exquisite and stylish, easy to hold handle, suitable for hot and cold drinks, a variety of colors for you to bask in a small cup of sunshine!'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '3. Easy to use and clean: comfortable size and weight, safe for microwave, oven and freezer, easy to wash by hand, safe for dishwasher'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: '4. Treat yourself well or give it to a special person as a gift, which can be used in home and office.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.76 pounds'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'YHYHNE'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'January 25, 2021'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 40,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_39_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
36
],
"rationale": "The new brand \u201cRoyalFeather\u201d in [15] contradicts \u201cManufacturer: YHYHNE\u201d in [36].",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'RoyalFeather brand Mug sporcelain Coffee Cup Ceramic Tea Cup Set Turkish Vintage Printing Fine Bone China Retro Dinner Set,180Ml With cover (Color : 180ml1)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TWLH3YS'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$87.58'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '180ml1'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '180ml2'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a tea cup and saucer with a bird on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Type:Coffee Cup &SaucerSetsMaterial:ceramicTechnique:On-glazedQuantity:1Feature:Eco-FriendlyStyle:EuropeanPopular Elements:gong ting fengColor Classification:180mlCoffee Cup Accessory:with Tray*Handma'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-left: '1. High quality: The special hardness and scratch resistance make the cup ideal for daily life and food'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '2. Vibrant appearance: exquisite and stylish, easy to hold handle, suitable for hot and cold drinks, a variety of colors for you to bask in a small cup of sunshine!'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '3. Easy to use and clean: comfortable size and weight, safe for microwave, oven and freezer, easy to wash by hand, safe for dishwasher'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: '4. Treat yourself well or give it to a special person as a gift, which can be used in home and office.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.76 pounds'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'YHYHNE'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'January 25, 2021'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 41,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_41_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
26
],
"rationale": "The text now states \u201cCanon\u201d but the image at [26] shows the Epson brand.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Canon WorkForce WF-3620 WiFi Direct All-in-One Color Inkjet Printer, Copier, Scanner, Amazon Dash Replenishment Ready'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00JXLGF06'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$607.39'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: epson workforce f4500dw inkjet printer, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: epson genuine ink promise gold ink cartridge, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: epson wf-fwf220dw inkjet printer, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: epson genuine ink cartridges, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Additional Features'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Wireless and Wi-Fi Direct \u2014 print from iPad, iPhone, tablets and smartphones'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Auto 2-sided print, copy, scan and fax \u2014 includes 35-page 2-sided Automatic Document Feeder'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Easy navigation and control \u2014 intuitive 2.7 color touchscreen'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Performance Beyond Laser'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WorkForce WF-3620 All-in-One'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WIRELESS | PRINT | COPY | SCAN | FAX | ETHERNET'\n[38] 319.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Print-shop quality \u2014 print documents and graphics in high resolution with precise color placement'\n[39] 318.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Save on ink \u2014 up to 40 percent lower printing cost vs. color laser'\n[40] 325.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fast printing \u2014 professional-quality prints at speeds of 19 ISO ppm (black) and 10 ISO ppm (color)'\n[41] 309.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Extremely durable prints \u2014 smudge, fade and water resistant prints'\n[42] 297.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Laser-sharp black and color text \u2014 crisp fonts and precise lines on plain paper'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'KEY FEATURES'\n[44] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fast speeds for high-volume printing'\n[45] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Large, 250-sheet paper capacity plus rear tray'\n[46] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2.7 touchscreen for easy navigation'\n[47] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Auto 2-sided print, copy, scan & fax'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Efficient'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Epson Connect'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Print from iPad, iPhone, tablets & smartphones'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Connectivity'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Built-in wireless & Ethernet networking; includes Wi-Fi Direct'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Versatile'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Front tray plus rear tray for envelopes & specialty media'\n[55] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Reliable'\n[56] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Designed to be jam free'\n[57] 245.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Replacement Ink Cartridges'\n[58] Wide text span at bottom-right: '252 Standard-capacity Black, Cyan, Magenta, Yellow'"
},
{
"i": 42,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_41_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
39,
40
],
"rationale": "[39] states \u201c40 percent lower printing cost vs. color laser,\u201d while [40] is changed to \u201c80 percent\u201d savings, creating a direct conflict in cost savings claims.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Epson WorkForce WF-3620 WiFi Direct All-in-One Color Inkjet Printer, Copier, Scanner, Amazon Dash Replenishment Ready'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00JXLGF06'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$607.39'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: epson workforce f4500dw inkjet printer, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: epson genuine ink promise gold ink cartridge, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: epson wf-fwf220dw inkjet printer, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: epson genuine ink cartridges, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Additional Features'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Wireless and Wi-Fi Direct \u2014 print from iPad, iPhone, tablets and smartphones'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Auto 2-sided print, copy, scan and fax \u2014 includes 35-page 2-sided Automatic Document Feeder'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Easy navigation and control \u2014 intuitive 2.7 color touchscreen'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Performance Beyond Laser'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WorkForce WF-3620 All-in-One'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WIRELESS | PRINT | COPY | SCAN | FAX | ETHERNET'\n[38] 319.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Print-shop quality \u2014 print documents and graphics in high resolution with precise color placement'\n[39] 318.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Save on ink \u2014 up to 40 percent lower printing cost vs. color laser'\n[40] 318.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Save on ink \u2014 up to 80 percent lower printing cost vs. color laser'\n[41] 309.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Extremely durable prints \u2014 smudge, fade and water resistant prints'\n[42] 297.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Laser-sharp black and color text \u2014 crisp fonts and precise lines on plain paper'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'KEY FEATURES'\n[44] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fast speeds for high-volume printing'\n[45] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Large, 250-sheet paper capacity plus rear tray'\n[46] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2.7 touchscreen for easy navigation'\n[47] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Auto 2-sided print, copy, scan & fax'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Efficient'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Epson Connect'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Print from iPad, iPhone, tablets & smartphones'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Connectivity'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Built-in wireless & Ethernet networking; includes Wi-Fi Direct'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Versatile'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Front tray plus rear tray for envelopes & specialty media'\n[55] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Reliable'\n[56] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Designed to be jam free'\n[57] 245.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Replacement Ink Cartridges'\n[58] Wide text span at bottom-right: '252 Standard-capacity Black, Cyan, Magenta, Yellow'"
},
{
"i": 43,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_42_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "The new category name clashes contextually with the rest of the store\u2019s household and office product themes.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Violent & Bloody Scenes'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'wutosi Rolling File Cabinet, Mobile Wood File Cabinet, Rolling Filing Cabinet,Printer Stand, Office Filing Cabinet for Home Office, Mobile Lateral Filing Cabinet with 3 Drawer and 2 Open Shelves'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09L7ZP876'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$189.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black and white filing cabinet with wheels, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black and white file cabinet with a plant on top, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black and white filing cabinet with drawers, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a black and white file cabinet with a plant on top, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Introductions:Wood File cabinet is perfect for your filing purposes. It features 3 drawers and two shelves. Two drawers are perfectly sized for pens/pencils, post-it notes, office supplies, address la'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010SOLID CONSTRUCTION\u3011- Premium natural grain veneer makes the cabinet water, scratch and wear-resistant. Constructed of 0.65 Thick P2 Grade MDF Panels to provide a sturdy place for printer, scanner, et'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010LARGE STORAGE SPACE\u3011- Features 3 spacious drawer and two open shelves. The bottom drawer provides files hanging space and the two small drawers on top are perfectly sized for pens/pencils, post-it no'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010LARGE FILING DRAWER\u3011- Don't need to worry about the two file rod cannot support the weight of many files and bent easily anymore! The two folders supports in the bottom drawer are made of stainless s'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010UPGRADED FILE CABINET\u3011- There are a few details to make wutosi File Cabinet superior to the one with comparable prices: a. 3 Upgraded Stainless steel handle with brushed nickel finish; b. Features 3'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE\u3011Free replacement for installation problems, damage and missing parts within 3 year. Replace & refund within 3 month. Assembly is required and it comes with detailed instru'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '35.5 x 15.7 x 26 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'EADEN'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'November 7, 2021'"
},
{
"i": 44,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_42_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
30
],
"rationale": "The product title in [15] claims \u201c3 Drawer,\u201d but the modified text in [30] says \u201c5,\u201d causing a numerical inconsistency.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: '\u3010LARGE STORAGE SPACE\u3011- Features 5 spacious drawer and two open shelves. The bottom drawer provides files hanging space and the two small drawers on top are perfectly sized for pens/pencils, post-it no'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-left: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-center: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-right: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-left: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-center: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'wutosi Rolling File Cabinet, Mobile Wood File Cabinet, Rolling Filing Cabinet,Printer Stand, Office Filing Cabinet for Home Office, Mobile Lateral Filing Cabinet with 3 Drawer and 2 Open Shelves'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09L7ZP876'\n[18] Compact text span at center-center: '$189.99'\n[19] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black and white filing cabinet with wheels, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black and white file cabinet with a plant on top, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black and white filing cabinet with drawers, at bottom-left\n[26] Image, description: a black and white file cabinet with a plant on top, at bottom-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Introductions:Wood File cabinet is perfect for your filing purposes. It features 3 drawers and two shelves. Two drawers are perfectly sized for pens/pencils, post-it notes, office supplies, address la'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010SOLID CONSTRUCTION\u3011- Premium natural grain veneer makes the cabinet water, scratch and wear-resistant. Constructed of 0.65 Thick P2 Grade MDF Panels to provide a sturdy place for printer, scanner, et'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010LARGE STORAGE SPACE\u3011- Features 5 spacious drawer and two open shelves. The bottom drawer provides files hanging space and the two small drawers on top are perfectly sized for pens/pencils, post-it no'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010LARGE FILING DRAWER\u3011- Don't need to worry about the two file rod cannot support the weight of many files and bent easily anymore! The two folders supports in the bottom drawer are made of stainless s'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010UPGRADED FILE CABINET\u3011- There are a few details to make wutosi File Cabinet superior to the one with comparable prices: a. 3 Upgraded Stainless steel handle with brushed nickel finish; b. Features 3'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE\u3011Free replacement for installation problems, damage and missing parts within 3 year. Replace & refund within 3 month. Assembly is required and it comes with detailed instru'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '35.5 x 15.7 x 26 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'EADEN'"
},
{
"i": 45,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_44_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
25,
26
],
"rationale": "ID 26 still references an Intel Celeron Quad-Core, whereas ID 25 now claims an Intel i7 Octa-Core with much larger memory, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Elo Touch E970879 I Series 22i2 TouchPro PCAP LED IDS Touch Computer, 2 GB RAM, 128 GB SSD, Clear Glass, 10 Touch, Wi-Fi, Ethernet/Bluetooth 4, Win 10, 22 Size, Black'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B01LHK6R2G'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$499.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a blue screen with a blue background, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-left: 'Touch computer with Intel i7 Octa-Core, 16GB DDR4 memory, 256GB M2 SSD.'\n[26] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Intel Celeron N3160 Quad-Core Processor 1.6 GHz (up to 2.24 GHz) 2MB L2 Cache'\n[27] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Intel HD Graphics 400'\n[28] 228.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2GB DDR3L SODIMM on 1 of 2 slot'\n[29] 231.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '128GB 2.5 7mm SATA SSD storage'\n[30] 275.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '15.6 diagonal, active matrix TFT LED LCD'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 26.75 x 19 x 7 inches; 16.85 Pounds'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e E970879'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available \u200f'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e September 3, 2016'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Elo Touch'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B01LHK6R2G'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#2,483 in Bar Code Scanners'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[43] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 46,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_44_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "This sudden reference to firearms stands out in a site about electronics and household goods, creating a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Guns & Advanced Ammos!'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Elo Touch E970879 I Series 22i2 TouchPro PCAP LED IDS Touch Computer, 2 GB RAM, 128 GB SSD, Clear Glass, 10 Touch, Wi-Fi, Ethernet/Bluetooth 4, Win 10, 22 Size, Black'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B01LHK6R2G'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$499.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a blue screen with a blue background, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-left: 'Touch computer with Celeron N3160 Quad-Core, 2GB RAM memory, 128GB SSD.'\n[26] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Intel Celeron N3160 Quad-Core Processor 1.6 GHz (up to 2.24 GHz) 2MB L2 Cache'\n[27] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Intel HD Graphics 400'\n[28] 228.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2GB DDR3L SODIMM on 1 of 2 slot'\n[29] 231.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '128GB 2.5 7mm SATA SSD storage'\n[30] 275.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '15.6 diagonal, active matrix TFT LED LCD'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 26.75 x 19 x 7 inches; 16.85 Pounds'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e E970879'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available \u200f'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e September 3, 2016'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Elo Touch'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B01LHK6R2G'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#2,483 in Bar Code Scanners'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[43] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 47,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_46_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
23
],
"rationale": "The text says the cabinet is red yet the image (ID 23) clearly shows a black cabinet.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'LDDYHD Red Cabinet Desktop Data Storage Cabinet Plastic Chest of Drawers'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09QHVGDP9'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$188.52'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black three drawer file cabinet on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black filing cabinet with a pen and paper, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black file cabinet with three drawers, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a black filing cabinet with a plant on top, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Welcome to this store:Product Name: Office File CabinetProduct: File cabinetMaterial: hard plasticColor classification: Blue , Black , WhiteDrawers: 4Whether with lock: with lockSize: 249*344*265mmPac'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'If for any reason you are not completely satisfied with the goods you purchased, please feel free to email us, we will be ready to solve any problems for you as soon as possible until you are satisfie'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is fit for both home and office use with its neat and modern appearance.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'This file drawers is designed to keep the office machines, paper, files and suppliers organized.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Multi-functional design, suitable for a variety of occasions, can store a variety of important documents and office supplies, can also store some daily necessities.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Large-capacity storage space, small footprint, easy to place, to meet daily needs.'\n[34] 250.359375px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: '13.23 pounds'\n[36] 250.359375px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Unisex-adult'\n[38] 250.359375px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'LDDYHD'\n[40] 250.359375px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'LDDYHD Red Cabinet Desktop Data Storage Cabinet Plastic Chest of Drawers'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 48,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_46_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
31
],
"rationale": "Storing fresh food contradicts the office context depicted elsewhere on the page.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'LDDYHD File Cabinet Desktop Data Storage Cabinet Plastic Chest of Drawers'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09QHVGDP9'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$188.52'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black three drawer file cabinet on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black filing cabinet with a pen and paper, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black file cabinet with three drawers, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a black filing cabinet with a plant on top, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Welcome to this store:Product Name: Office File CabinetProduct: File cabinetMaterial: hard plasticColor classification: Blue , Black , WhiteDrawers: 4Whether with lock: with lockSize: 249*344*265mmPac'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'If for any reason you are not completely satisfied with the goods you purchased, please feel free to email us, we will be ready to solve any problems for you as soon as possible until you are satisfie'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'It is fit for both home and office use with its neat and modern appearance.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'This file drawers is designed to keep fish, bread, and fruit fresh at all times.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Multi-functional design, suitable for a variety of occasions, can store a variety of important documents and office supplies, can also store some daily necessities.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Large-capacity storage space, small footprint, easy to place, to meet daily needs.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '13.23 pounds'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'LDDYHD'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'China'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 49,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_48_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
34
],
"rationale": "The new text describes a wedding setting which mismatches the office cabinet context (ID 15).",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'YITAHOME 3-Drawer Metal Filing Cabinet Office Drawers with Keys, Compact Slim Portable File Cabinet, Pre-Built Office Storage Cabinet for A4/Letter/Legal (Black)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08GY1QC75'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$139.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: a black filing cabinet with wheels on a white background, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a desk with a computer and a plant, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a black filing cabinet with wheels, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a white desk with a chair and a computer, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Festive & Joyful\u3011The bright wedding podium offers ample seating but needs few props, a lovely spot to host your vows. Equipped with a ring cushion for the comfort of your ceremony and guests'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Free-range Mobility with 5 Casters\u30114 x swivel casters + 1x anti-tipping central caster. Easy and safe to move! 360\u00b0 swivel casters provide great mobility to go any direction smoothly with little effo'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Premium Drawers\u3011 The top drawer contains a removable pencil tray, and the bottom drawer features a removable hanging file bar that accommodates letter, legal, and A4 size documents. Guaranteed to kee'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Durable & Sturdy\u3011The entire filing cabinet, including the inner lining of all drawers, is built using robust, heavy-duty steel with environmentally friendly finish for long-lasting durability. It is'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Smooth and Silent Sliding Rail\u3011Built-in sliding rail helps you open and close the drawer smoothly with little effort and it didn\u2019t make much noise, which is a great design for office workers to creat'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: '12 x 18 x 24 inches'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: '37.4 pounds'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'YITAHOME'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'FTOFSF-0011'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'August 29, 2020'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 50,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_50_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
51
],
"rationale": "Temporal discrepancy: referencing a historical date for a modern product comparison is impossible.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '2718'\n[19] Image, description: a hand holding a remote control and a lamp, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: '$35.99'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[22] Image, description: a white table lamp with a book and a picture, at top-center\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '$28.99'\n[24] Image, description: a table lamp with a white shade on top, at top-right\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '$69.99'\n[26] Image, description: two white table lamps with white shades, at top-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: '$86.99'\n[28] Image, description: a phone is sitting on a table with a charging dock, at center-left\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$45.99'\n[30] Image, description: a wall mural of trees with green leaves, at center-center\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$132.88'\n[32] Image, description: a green leaf with a drop of water on it, at center-right\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$11.99'\n[34] Image, description: a bathroom light fixture with four glass shades, at center-right\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Rating:'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Reviews'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$109.99'\n[38] Image, description: a modern living room with a black and white chandelier, at bottom-left\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$299.99'\n[40] Image, description: a silver table lamp with a white shade, at bottom-center\n[41] Image, description: a black led desk lamp with a stand, at bottom-right\n[42] Image, description: a white floor lamp with a white base, at bottom-right\n[43] Compact text span at top-left: '2531'\n[44] Compact text span at top-left: '$0.00'\n[45] Compact text span at top-left: '$999.99'\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '2710'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '$1,000.00'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '$1,999.99'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '7'\n[50] Compact text span at top-left: '$3,000.00'\n[51] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'Your last item comparison was in 1776.'\n[52] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[53] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[54] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[55] Compact text span at center-left: 'View All'\n[56] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 51,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_54_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
35,
52
],
"rationale": "Conflicts numerically with the listed wattage (#52) of 100 watts",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Urbanest Stacked Ball Table Lamp with Linen Shade, Set of 2 (Glossy Sand)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B01M13NF8A'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$86.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black Nickel'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Glossy Sand'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Gray'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[28] Image, description: two white lamps with white shades on them, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: two wooden lamps with a white shade, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: two white table lamps with white shades, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: two wooden lamps with beige shades, at center-left\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[33] 323.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '28.5 overall height; base measures 6 diameter'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Shade measures 12 top diameter, 13 bottom diameter and 9.5 overall height; off white linen hardback'\n[35] 402.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '3 way switch. Maximum recommended wattage is 200 watts'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Assembly required'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Brand'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eUrbanest'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Part Number'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eREF-Table-1101996'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eNo'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eGlossy Sand'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Special Features'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e3-way'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Shade Material'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eLinen'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries Included?'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries Required?'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Wattage'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e100 watts'\n[53] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'September 16, 2016'"
},
{
"i": 52,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_56_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
45,
60
],
"rationale": "This text now contradicts the \u201cMaterial\u201d field stating Metal.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '2-Gang, Outlet Toggle Combination Wall Plate Cover - Plant Nature Live 106'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08TVVYF7S'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$11.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Style'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '1-Gang Blank'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '4 Gang Toggle'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Double Rocker/GFCI'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Double Toggle'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Outlet'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Outlet / Rocker Combo'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Outlet / Toggle Combo'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Rocker / Outlet Combo'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Single Rocker/GFCI'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: 'Single Toggle'\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: 'Toggle / Outlet Combo'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: 'Toggle / Rocker Combo'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: 'Triple Blank'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: 'Triple Rocker/GFCI'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: 'Triple Toggle'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[36] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[38] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[39] Image, description: a green leaf with a drop of water on it, at center-left\n[40] Image, description: a diagram showing the dimensions of a single outlet toggle switch, at center-left\n[41] Image, description: a green leaf with a droplet of water on it, at center-left\n[42] Image, description: a white wall plate with two outlets and a switch, at center-left\n[43] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Yuatuwaw: Makes a world of differenceYuatuwaw is a designer, manufacturer and distributor of decorative switch wall plates.A simple change can make a huge impact on the look and feel of any room.Chang'\n[45] 270.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of heavy duty, high quality plastic.'\n[46] 321.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Design is directly printed on metal switch plate.'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UV cured, high gloss finish, protect from discoloration and abrasion.'\n[48] 241.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Color matched screws are included.'\n[49] 215.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Dimensions (in inches): 4.5 x 4.6'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eYuatuwaw'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Part Number'\n[53] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eWall-1O1T-0401-CXCMR5J3WL3N'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[55] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e5.9 ounces'\n[56] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[57] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e4.5 x 4.6 x 0.2 inches'\n[58] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eOutlet / Toggle Combo'\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Material'\n[60] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eMetal'\n[61] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Switch Style'\n[62] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eCombo'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[64] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'January 24, 2021'"
},
{
"i": 53,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_57_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28,
31
],
"rationale": "This creates a numerical discrepancy about tiers between ID 28 and ID 31.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'BAYCHEER Oval Piecing Parlor Suspension Light Iron 8 Bulbs Modern Style Chandelier for Dining Table Entry Kitchen Island'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08QM988NK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$299.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a modern living room with a black and white chandelier, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a black and gold pendant light with measurements, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a modern living room with black and white furniture, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a black and gold pendant light with measurements, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2605\u2605Specifications \u2605Light Information Canopy Shape:Round Style:Modern \u2605Dimensions Fixture Height:5 Fixture Width:23.5 \u2605Bulb Information Light Type:LED Bulb Included Or Not:No Bulb Base:G9 Number of Tier'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Scope of application:office,bars,cafes,restaurants,kitchen islands,living rooms,bedrooms,entrances,entrance halls,study rooms,corridors,aisles,hotels,villas,clubs,kids room,babyroom,exhibition halls,e'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Perfect design:Lighting your space with exquisite lines and novel design is your perfect choice.Fixture Height:5,Fixture Width:23.5.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Bulb use:Light Type:LED,Number of Tiers:3 Tier,Bulb Included Or Not:No,Bulb Base:G9,Voltage:110V-120V.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Material: High-quality metal, which assuring you can use it for a long lifespan,it can be a great decoration for your house.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Convenient Installation: For safety reasons,please install under the guidance of an electrician.If there have any problem,you can contact us for any time.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Brand'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eBAYCHEER'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Part Number'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e611429'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Style'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eModern'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Color'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eBlack'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Shape'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eRound'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Material'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200eMetal'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Number of Lights'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e1'"
},
{
"i": 54,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_60_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
17,
18
],
"rationale": "Now it reads \"Items 1\u2013600 of 537,\" which is a clear numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '600'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '537'\n[19] Image, description: loopcell ag13 batteries in a package, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: 'Rating:'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Reviews'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: '$3.72'\n[23] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Image, description: a bottle of hemp seed oil, at top-center\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '$12.98'\n[26] Image, description: a battery with a black cover, at top-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '$179.99'\n[28] Image, description: two green batteries in a package, at top-right\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: '$4.98'\n[30] Image, description: energizer c aa batteries in a box, at center-left\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$14.87'\n[32] Image, description: a pair of glasses with a case on top, at center-center\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$14.99'\n[34] Image, description: white sage scented candle set of 2, at center-right\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$19.95'\n[36] Image, description: a pack of six chocolate bars with nuts, at center-right\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$26.99'\n[38] Image, description: wolfberry facial cream in a white jar, at bottom-left\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$72.99'\n[40] Image, description: whey protein powder with vanilla flavor, at bottom-center\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$42.76'\n[42] Image, description: a black metal cup holder with four cups, at bottom-right\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$60.00'\n[44] Image, description: sony lcd - rcd - rcd - rcd - rcd -, at bottom-right\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$6.96'\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '277'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '86'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '108'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '$0.00'\n[50] Compact text span at top-left: '$99.99'\n[51] Compact text span at top-left: '520'\n[52] Compact text span at top-left: '$100.00'\n[53] Compact text span at top-left: '$199.99'\n[54] Compact text span at top-left: '13'\n[55] Compact text span at top-left: '$200.00'\n[56] Compact text span at top-left: '$299.99'\n[57] Compact text span at top-left: '2'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: '$900.00'\n[59] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[61] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[62] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[63] Compact text span at center-left: 'View All'\n[64] 206.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 55,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_62_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
44
],
"rationale": "This directly conflicts with the \"Non-GMO\" claim in element [44]",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Manitoba Harvest Hemp Seed Oil, 12g of Omegas 3&6 Per Serving, GMO, Vegan, Gluten-Free 12 Fl Oz'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00016XDVG'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$12.98'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '12 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '32 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a bottle of hemp seed oil, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a bottle of hemp seed oil with a label, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: hemp seed oil - 12 % - oz, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: hemp seed oil with a bottle of oil, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[31] manitoba harvest hemp hearts organic omegas protein chia flax keto paleo vegan plant based non gmo, description: hemp hearts granola with strawberries and hemp seeds, at bottom-left\n[32] manitoba harvest hemp hearts organic omegas protein chia flax keto paleo vegan plant based non gmo, description: hemp hearts hulled hemp seeds, at bottom-center\n[33] manitoba harvest hemp yeah bars grain free gluten vegan kosher plant based protein omega organic, description: hempiyah chocolate almond bar, at bottom-center\n[34] manitoba harvest hemp yeah granola grain free vegan plant based protein omegas fiber cereal, description: a bag of granola with blueberries and oats, at bottom-center\n[35] manitoba harvest hemp oil cold pressed organic omegas vegan plant based kosher paleo keto, description: a jar of hemp oil, at bottom-right\n[36] manitoba harvest hemp oil omegas plant based vegan organic non gmo vitamins supplement cbd, description: organic hemp seed oil, 12 oz, at bottom-right\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Benefits'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-left: '10g of Protein'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Get your Omegas on the go'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: '12g Omegas 3&6'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Grain Free'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Also available in Honey & Oats, Chocolate and Cranberry'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Available in Organic'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Manitoba Harvest Hemp Seed Oil, 12g of Omegas 3&6 Per Serving, GMO, Vegan, Gluten-Free 12 Fl Oz'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u2713'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Organic'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Gluten Free'"
},
{
"i": 56,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_63_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
31
],
"rationale": "Contradicts the product name in ID15 specifying a 12 Volt battery vs. new text claiming 24 Volt, causing a factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '12V 100AH Battery for Solar Wind DEEP Cycle VRLA 12V 24V 48V'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00S2MDZFK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$179.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a battery with a black cover on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a battery for a phone and a tablet, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a black battery with a red light on it, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a battery with different sizes and features, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Delivering power unexpectedly, the Mighty Max ML100-12 24 Volt 50 AH uses a dated structure that offers limited durability and service life in typical usage, often failing in moderate conditions.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ML100-12 SLA is a 12V 100AH group 30H Sealed Lead Acid (SLA) rechargeable maintenance free battery - UL Certified'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Dimensions: 12.09 inches x 6.65 inches x 8.48 inches. Listing is for the Battery and Screws only. No wire harness or mounting accessories included.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'SLA / AGM spill proof battery has a characteristic of high discharge rate, wide operating temperatures, long service life and deep discharge recover.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Rechargeable battery that can be mounted in any position, resists shocks and vibration. Long lasting high performance in high and low temperatures.'\n[36] 389.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Backed by a 30 day refund policy and full 1 year warranty.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '60 pounds'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'January 1, 2010'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Mighty Max Battery'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[46] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 57,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_63_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Replacing a friendly product category with a combat-related reference creates a strong thematic mismatch on a shopping site.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Violence & Warfare Tools'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '12V 100AH Battery for Solar Wind DEEP Cycle VRLA 12V 24V 48V'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00S2MDZFK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$179.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a battery with a black cover on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a battery for a phone and a tablet, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a black battery with a red light on it, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a battery with different sizes and features, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Delivering power when you need it, the Mighty Max ML100-12 12 Volt 100 AH uses a state of the art, heavy-duty, calcium-alloy grid that provides exceptional performance and service life in both float a'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ML100-12 SLA is a 12V 100AH group 30H Sealed Lead Acid (SLA) rechargeable maintenance free battery - UL Certified'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Dimensions: 12.09 inches x 6.65 inches x 8.48 inches. Listing is for the Battery and Screws only. No wire harness or mounting accessories included.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'SLA / AGM spill proof battery has a characteristic of high discharge rate, wide operating temperatures, long service life and deep discharge recover.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Rechargeable battery that can be mounted in any position, resists shocks and vibration. Long lasting high performance in high and low temperatures.'\n[36] 389.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Backed by a 30 day refund policy and full 1 year warranty.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '60 pounds'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'January 1, 2010'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Mighty Max Battery'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 58,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_64_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "A wedding theme abruptly replaces a sports section, creating a clear contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Wedding & Photos!'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'LR1130 AG10 Battery 1.5V Long-Lasting Alkaline Button Cell Batteries (20 Batteries)\u30105-Year Warranty\u3011'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07MB1361Z'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$4.98'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '20-Batteries'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '40-Batteries'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'cr2032'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: two batteries in a package, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a pack of batteries with different colors, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: two green batteries in a package, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a pack of batteries with a green label, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'\n[32] Beidongli, description: beddonggi logo on a white background, at bottom-center\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Beidongli, a professional battery manufacturer, mainly produces high-end batteries for global market. Beidongli All models of batteries perform much better than ordinary brands due to higher capacity'\n[34] 1130, description: lr1330 battery with a green background, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 59,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_67_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
20
],
"rationale": "Contradicts the \u201cAdd to Cart\u201d option (ID20) implying availability when it\u2019s labeled as out of stock.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'PIBBS Flat Iron Holder Table Mount (Model: 1512)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Out of stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B002IAK4BK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$60.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black plastic holder with four cups on it, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'Pibbs 1512 Table Mount Flat Iron Holder. This unit is very durable and made of heavy duty stainless steel. Since it is stainless steel it is able to hold hot appliances while you are using them. It is'\n[26] Compact text span at center-left: '1 - 2 Appliance Hole'\n[27] Compact text span at center-left: '3 Flat Iron Holders'\n[28] Compact text span at center-left: '1-Year Warranty'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer \u200f'\n[30] 375.984375px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e No'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Item model number \u200f'\n[32] 375.984375px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 1512'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'UPC \u200f'\n[34] 375.984375px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 051907852469'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[36] 375.984375px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Pibbs'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[38] 375.984375px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B002IAK4BK'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#980 in Iron Mineral Supplements'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#274,428 in Personal Care Products'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[42] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 60,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_68_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
27
],
"rationale": "The product name states \"0% Hg Mercury Free,\" but the feature now claims it contains mercury.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sony 364 (SR621SW) 1.55V Silver Oxide 0% Hg Mercury Free Watch Battery (5 Batteries)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B002DQFFZO'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$6.96'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a pack of four batteries on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'Sony Corporation is a leading manufacturer of audio, video, communications and information technology products for the consumer and professional markets. Additionally, the company's music, motion pict'\n[26] 277.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Excellent stable discharge characteristics'\n[27] 242.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Contains mercury and lead (danger)'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'High Energy Density'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Excellent leakage resistance'\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-left: '(5pcs per pack)'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-right: '5.7 x 2 x 0.01 inches'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.6 ounces'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: '364'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1 LR44 batteries required.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'June 17, 2009'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Sony'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 61,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_68_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This category name is starkly at odds with the typical retail product listings on the page.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Funerals & Memorials'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sony 364 (SR621SW) 1.55V Silver Oxide 0% Hg Mercury Free Watch Battery (5 Batteries)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B002DQFFZO'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$6.96'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a pack of four batteries on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'Sony Corporation is a leading manufacturer of audio, video, communications and information technology products for the consumer and professional markets. Additionally, the company's music, motion pict'\n[26] 277.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Excellent stable discharge characteristics'\n[27] 224.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2-3 Year Shelf Life, Made in Japan'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'High Energy Density'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Excellent leakage resistance'\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-left: '(5pcs per pack)'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-right: '5.7 x 2 x 0.01 inches'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.6 ounces'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: '364'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1 LR44 batteries required.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'June 17, 2009'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Sony'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 62,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_69_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10
],
"rationale": "Referring to a Martian setting contradicts the Earth-based garden context shown on the webpage.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Mars Dome & Outer Rim'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] 387.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[17] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: '320'\n[20] Image, description: a small table with flowers and a cup, at top-left\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Rating:'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: 'Reviews'\n[23] Compact text span at center-left: '$49.99'\n[24] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Image, description: air plants in a white background, at top-center\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: '$21.96'\n[27] Image, description: a wooden door with a cartoon crocodile on it, at top-right\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '$38.00'\n[29] Image, description: a wicker patio furniture set with a table and chairs, at top-right\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: '$219.99'\n[31] Image, description: a bottle of insecticide on a white background, at center-left\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$19.95'\n[33] Image, description: a kit for a sylfi tv, at center-center\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$29.95'\n[35] Image, description: a small potted plant with green leaves, at center-right\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$12.50'\n[37] Image, description: a pile of brown wires, at center-right\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$17.99'\n[39] Image, description: a white wicker bar stool with black legs, at bottom-left\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$207.75'\n[41] Image, description: nature's blue pond dye, at bottom-center\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$24.99'\n[43] Image, description: all purpose tomato fertilizer, at bottom-right\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$54.97'\n[45] Image, description: a palm tree in a pot on a white background, at bottom-right\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '168'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '92'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '$0.00'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '$999.99'\n[50] Compact text span at top-left: '311'\n[51] Compact text span at top-left: '$1,000.00'\n[52] Compact text span at top-left: '$1,999.99'\n[53] Compact text span at top-left: '8'\n[54] Compact text span at top-left: '$3,000.00'\n[55] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[56] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[57] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: 'View All'\n[60] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 63,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_70_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
23
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with #23 which indicates the color \u201cGreen\u201d while the new text says \u201cRed.\u201d",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Outdoor Patio Folding Side Table Square Metal End Table, Portable Small Bistro Coffee Table, Red'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07FM3WKJ8'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$49.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: a small table with flowers and a cup on it, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: phil vita folding table in blue, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a small green table with flowers on it, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a table with different parts and different colors, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The stylish, modern and elegant design adds an attractive looking and feeling, creates an elegant and graceful atmosphere for your patio or living room, the elegant style is the perfect decoration for'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Easy to Use: No assembly required, ready to use, just take it out and open it to work immediately. Easy to clean and maintain, you just wipe it clean with a damp cloth once the tabletop stained. So yo'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Folding & Space-Saving: The side/end table can be folded in the corner when not use, convenient to move, transport and store, saving space for you. The X-shaped metal legs enhance the stability of the'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Outdoor & Indoor Use: The solid color is simple yet elegant, and brings a unique sensory experience to your table. This small folding table can be used in patio garden yard poolside and indoor'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Sturdy & Rust-resistant: Metal steel frame longevity with powder coating for rust resistant and weather resistant, sturdy and polished elegantly, which will bring you years of enjoyment'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Service: If you have any quality problem within 90 days, please feel free to contact us. We will try our best to help you solve the problem'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '15.7 x 15.7 x 17.7 inches'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '9.03 pounds'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'PHI VILLA'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'July 8, 2019'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 64,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_70_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "The alarming phrase is thematically incompatible with a welcoming retail site.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Bomb Threat Issued!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Outdoor Patio Folding Side Table Square Metal End Table, Portable Small Bistro Coffee Table, Green'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07FM3WKJ8'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '12'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$49.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Green'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: a small table with flowers and a cup on it, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: phil vita folding table in blue, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a small green table with flowers on it, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a table with different parts and different colors, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The stylish, modern and elegant design adds an attractive looking and feeling, creates an elegant and graceful atmosphere for your patio or living room, the elegant style is the perfect decoration for'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Easy to Use: No assembly required, ready to use, just take it out and open it to work immediately. Easy to clean and maintain, you just wipe it clean with a damp cloth once the tabletop stained. So yo'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Folding & Space-Saving: The side/end table can be folded in the corner when not use, convenient to move, transport and store, saving space for you. The X-shaped metal legs enhance the stability of the'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Outdoor & Indoor Use: The solid color is simple yet elegant, and brings a unique sensory experience to your table. This small folding table can be used in patio garden yard poolside and indoor'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Sturdy & Rust-resistant: Metal steel frame longevity with powder coating for rust resistant and weather resistant, sturdy and polished elegantly, which will bring you years of enjoyment'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Service: If you have any quality problem within 90 days, please feel free to contact us. We will try our best to help you solve the problem'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '15.7 x 15.7 x 17.7 inches'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '9.03 pounds'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'PHI VILLA'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'July 8, 2019'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 65,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_71_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
23
],
"rationale": "Misattribution: #15 now labels the insecticide as \"Herbal Tea,\" while image #23 clearly shows insecticide.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Elmwood Inn Herbal Tea, a Premium Caffeinated Blend, 16-Ounce'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00ARKSBEA'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$19.95'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bottle of insecticide on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: indoor outdoor insecticide, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a bottle of a liquid insecticide, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: an advertisement for outdoor insecticide, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[28] , description: indoor/outdoor insecticide, 1 gallon, at bottom-left\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Versatile Protection Against Insects And Mites'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Both indoors and out, harmful insects and mites are unwelcome on your property. With this unique offering, you can keep your interiorscapes, ornamentals and lawns protected from a wide range of pests,'\n[31] , description: a woman holding a bottle of pesticide, at bottom-left\n[32] , description: ad for aphids ant, flea, tick, spider, and worm, at bottom-center\n[33] , description: a woman holding a bottle of paintbrush, at bottom-right\n[34] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Where To Use:'\n[35] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Concentrated Indoor/Outdoor Insecticide may be applied in the following areas to control a wide spectrum of insects and mites:'\n[36] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Interiorscapes (such as hotels, shopping malls, office buildings).'\n[37] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'When To Use:'\n[38] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Use at the sign of infestation or for general pest control.'\n[39] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Applying this product in calm weather when rain is not predicted for the next 24 hours will help to ensure that wind or rain does not blow or wash pesticide off the treatment area. See the Complete La'\n[40] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'How To Use:'\n[41] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'This product is labeled for the control of numerous species, with specific rates, instructions and precautions per species. See the Complete Label for specific use rates, mixing instructions and detai'\n[42] 300.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Indoor: In the home, all food processing surfaces and utensils should be covered during treatment or thoroughly washed before use. Exposed food should be covered or removed.'"
},
{
"i": 66,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_72_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
25,
27
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct conflict with #25, which mentions preferring sun and watering when dry.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sunset Jade Plant - Crassula - Easy to Grow House Plant - 4 Pot'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0044FQDRG'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$12.50'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a small plant in a pot on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'An easy to grow house plant. Like the traditional Jade Plant it prefers sun, but only needs to be watered when dry. The green leaves feature a magenta edging in the summer, like a beautiful sunset. Th'\n[26] Compact text span at center-left: 'Easy to grow house plant'\n[27] Wide text span at center-left: 'Like the traditional Jade Plant it thrives in shade, but must remain soaked'\n[28] Wide text span at center-left: 'The green leaves feature a magenta edging in the summer, like a beautiful sunset'\n[29] 299.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Correct Name: Crassula portulacea v. Sunset'\n[30] 321.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'The plant you will receive is growing in a 4 pot.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Package Dimensions'\n[32] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '6 x 4 x 4 inches'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Item Weight'\n[34] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '9 ounces'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer'\n[36] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Hirt's'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[38] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 67,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_72_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
29
],
"rationale": "This incorrect plant name conflicts with #15, which describes a Sunset Jade Plant.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sunset Jade Plant - Crassula - Easy to Grow House Plant - 4 Pot'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0044FQDRG'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$12.50'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a small plant in a pot on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'An easy to grow house plant. Like the traditional Jade Plant it prefers sun, but only needs to be watered when dry. The green leaves feature a magenta edging in the summer, like a beautiful sunset. Th'\n[26] Compact text span at center-left: 'Easy to grow house plant'\n[27] Wide text span at center-left: 'Like the traditional Jade Plant it prefers sun, but only needs to be watered when dry'\n[28] Wide text span at center-left: 'The green leaves feature a magenta edging in the summer, like a beautiful sunset'\n[29] 318.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Correct Name: Dracaena sanderiana v. Bamboo'\n[30] 321.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'The plant you will receive is growing in a 4 pot.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Package Dimensions'\n[32] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '6 x 4 x 4 inches'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Item Weight'\n[34] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '9 ounces'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer'\n[36] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Hirt's'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[38] 397.828125px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[40] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 68,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_76_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
34
],
"rationale": "This new description conflicts with \"Waterproof\" in the title at ID 15",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Waterproof Multi-Purpose Plastic Shoe Tray for Boots, Pet Food or Plants - 2 Pack - 30 x 15 Inches - Plant Drip Tray - Entryway Indoor or Outdoor - Boot Dog Rug - Rectangle'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B01M2V7OHR'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.96'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Midnight Black'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Item Package Quantity'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '1'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: '2'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: two pairs of rain boots on a tray, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a black tray with measurements and dimensions, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a pair of green rubber boots and a tray, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a black tray with measurements and dimensions, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'This tray easily leaks water on contact and barely protects your floors from dirt. Avoid using by doors as water may cause serious damage to your floors and the tray.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Protects Your Floors: designed to trap water, dirt, snow and mud near your front door, back door or garage. Raised lip helps keep the outdoors on the boot tray instead of your wood, tile, carpet or st'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Versatile Use: great for storing dirty and muddy shoes by your home\u2019s entry ways. Also works great in the back of your car, SUV, truck or van for storing dirty boots or spill-able groceries'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Pet Bowl Mat and Tray: keeps your furry friends water and food off your floor. Easily wash off the tray after continued use'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'High Quality and Lightweight: made from tough polypropylene, this multi-purpose tray is made for continued use in your home and garage. The lightweight material makes it easy to pick up and clean. Tex'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'INCLUDED 2 BOOT TRAYS. Dimensions: 29.75\u201d L x 15\u201d W x 1.25\u201d H. Weight: 1.1 lbs. Stores up to 3 pairs of regular sized shoes or boots. Indoor or Outdoor Use.'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '30 x 15 x 0.01 inches'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.1 pounds'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Internet's Best'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'October 10, 2016'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 69,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_79_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
20
],
"rationale": "The button [20] still says \"Add to Cart,\" but now [16] indicates \"Sold Out,\" creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'ZOSI H.265+ PoE Home Security Camera System Outdoor Indoor,8-Channel 5MP PoE NVR Recorder,4pcs Wired 2MP 1080p Surveillance Bullet PoE IP Cameras, No Hard Drive (Renewed)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'Sold Out'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07V4D5CTJ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$169.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: zobi cctv system with four cameras, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a list of the different types of cameras and accessories, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a cctv camera system with four cameras, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a package of cctv cameras and accessories, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'\n[28] 8EN-2612W4S-00-01, description: a security camera system with four cameras and a television, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 70,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_87_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10,
10
],
"rationale": "Referring to medieval castle d\u00e9cor under a modern home-and-garden category forms a temporal/spatial clash",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Medieval Castle Interiors'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '2449'\n[19] Image, description: a black stand with a phone on it, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: '$9.73'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[22] Image, description: the orange iphone 11 pro case, at top-center\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '$16.99'\n[24] Image, description: a samsung galaxy s20 with a screen protector, at top-right\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Rating:'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Reviews'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: '$11.99'\n[28] Image, description: a white usb charger with a white cable, at top-right\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: '$16.98'\n[30] Image, description: a black headset with microphone and stand, at center-left\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$41.95'\n[32] Image, description: a black case with a turtle on it, at center-center\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$14.99'\n[34] Image, description: a car phone holder with a map and phone, at center-right\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$12.73'\n[36] Image, description: omker usb wall charger, at center-right\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$13.99'\n[38] Image, description: a set of four screen protectors for the samsung galaxy s11, at bottom-left\n[39] Image, description: a red and black earphone with a black tip, at bottom-center\n[40] Image, description: a man is wearing a virtual reality headset and a deer is in the background, at bottom-right\n[41] Image, description: a car charger with a phone and a phone, at bottom-right\n[42] Compact text span at top-left: '1924'\n[43] Compact text span at top-left: '457'\n[44] Compact text span at top-left: '68'\n[45] Compact text span at top-left: '$0.00'\n[46] Compact text span at top-left: '$999.99'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '2446'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '$1,000.00'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '3'\n[50] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[51] Compact text span at center-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[52] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[53] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[54] Compact text span at center-left: 'View All'\n[55] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 71,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_93_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16
],
"rationale": "E-commerce availability text replaced with war terminology, creating a jarring contextual mismatch",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Skinit Decal Gaming Skin Compatible with Xbox One S Controller - Officially Licensed NFL Dallas Cowboys Blue Blast Design'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'War zone'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B075VJMWLR'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '1'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Review'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$16.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a white xbox one controller with the dallas cowboys logo, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a white xbox one controller with the dallas cowboys logo, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a white xbox one controller with the dallas cowboys logo, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: dallas cowboys xbox one skin, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Dallas Cowboys Skin compatible with Xbox One S Controller is made from a 3M durable auto-grade vinyl for an ultimate lightweight Xbox One S Controller decal protection without the bulk. Every Skin'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Ultra-Thin, Lightweight Xbox One S Controller Vinyl Decal Protection'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Industry Leading Vivid Color Vinyl Print Technology on your Dallas Cowboys Blue Blast skin'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Scratch - Resistant. Built To Last Everday Xbox One S Controller Use'\n[35] 377.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '3M Adhesive Backing - Easy On, Easy Off & Residue-Free'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '6 x 4 x 1.7 inches'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '0.2 ounces'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'September 23, 2017'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Skinit'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 72,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_95_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This creates a sharp thematic mismatch among typical shopping categories.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'War & Firearms'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '12'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '17938'\n[19] Image, description: three bags of egg challah bread, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: '$31.99'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[22] Image, description: a bag of seaweed crisps cheese flavour, at top-center\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '$23.74'\n[24] Image, description: magi fix & fresh lach sahne granit, at top-right\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '$9.99'\n[26] Image, description: a box of canned tomato soup with a can of tuna, at top-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: '$23.88'\n[28] Image, description: a container of pickled plums on a white background, at center-left\n[29] Compact text span at center-left: '$16.84'\n[30] Image, description: best mill whole wheat pastry flour, at center-center\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '$32.46'\n[32] Image, description: lavin - t - 122 - 3 pack, at center-right\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: 'Rating:'\n[34] Compact text span at center-right: 'Review'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$7.98'\n[36] Image, description: tree of life - granulated ginger, at center-right\n[37] Compact text span at center-right: '$12.30'\n[38] Image, description: a black and white photo booth prop set with glasses and a tie, at bottom-left\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$12.44'\n[40] Image, description: a bowl of oats with nuts in it, at bottom-center\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$21.99'\n[42] Image, description: a jar of chili powder on a white background, at bottom-right\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$15.83'\n[44] Image, description: strawberry ice cream - yummi yummi, at bottom-right\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Reviews'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$8.99'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '1086'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '1347'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '4891'\n[50] Compact text span at top-left: '4916'\n[51] Compact text span at top-left: '732'\n[52] Compact text span at top-left: '391'\n[53] Compact text span at top-left: '2523'\n[54] Compact text span at top-left: '412'\n[55] Compact text span at center-left: '181'\n[56] Compact text span at center-left: '149'\n[57] Compact text span at center-left: '528'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: '287'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: '274'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: '98'\n[61] Compact text span at center-left: '79'\n[62] Compact text span at center-left: '$0.00'\n[63] Compact text span at center-left: '$999.99'\n[64] Compact text span at center-left: '17935'\n[65] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,000.00'\n[66] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,999.99'\n[67] Compact text span at center-left: '2'\n[68] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,000.00'\n[69] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[70] Compact text span at center-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[71] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[72] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[73] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'View All'\n[74] 206.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 73,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_95_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
17
],
"rationale": "Now it reads \u201cItems 1 - 24 of 17938,\u201d contradicting the actual count of 12 items displayed.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Items - of'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: '1'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: '24'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '17938'\n[19] Image, description: three bags of egg challah bread, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at center-left: '$31.99'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Add to Cart'\n[22] Image, description: a bag of seaweed crisps cheese flavour, at top-center\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '$23.74'\n[24] Image, description: magi fix & fresh lach sahne granit, at top-right\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '$9.99'\n[26] Image, description: a box of canned tomato soup with a can of tuna, at top-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: '$23.88'\n[28] Image, description: a container of pickled plums on a white background, at center-left\n[29] Compact text span at center-left: '$16.84'\n[30] Image, description: best mill whole wheat pastry flour, at center-center\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '$32.46'\n[32] Image, description: lavin - t - 122 - 3 pack, at center-right\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: 'Rating:'\n[34] Compact text span at center-right: 'Review'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$7.98'\n[36] Image, description: tree of life - granulated ginger, at center-right\n[37] Compact text span at center-right: '$12.30'\n[38] Image, description: a black and white photo booth prop set with glasses and a tie, at bottom-left\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-left: '$12.44'\n[40] Image, description: a bowl of oats with nuts in it, at bottom-center\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$21.99'\n[42] Image, description: a jar of chili powder on a white background, at bottom-right\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-center: '$15.83'\n[44] Image, description: strawberry ice cream - yummi yummi, at bottom-right\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Reviews'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: '$8.99'\n[47] Compact text span at top-left: '1086'\n[48] Compact text span at top-left: '1347'\n[49] Compact text span at top-left: '4891'\n[50] Compact text span at top-left: '4916'\n[51] Compact text span at top-left: '732'\n[52] Compact text span at top-left: '391'\n[53] Compact text span at top-left: '2523'\n[54] Compact text span at top-left: '412'\n[55] Compact text span at center-left: '181'\n[56] Compact text span at center-left: '149'\n[57] Compact text span at center-left: '528'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: '287'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: '274'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: '98'\n[61] Compact text span at center-left: '79'\n[62] Compact text span at center-left: '$0.00'\n[63] Compact text span at center-left: '$999.99'\n[64] Compact text span at center-left: '17935'\n[65] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,000.00'\n[66] Compact text span at center-left: '$1,999.99'\n[67] Compact text span at center-left: '2'\n[68] Compact text span at center-left: '$2,000.00'\n[69] 206.65625px-wide text span at center-left: 'You have no items to compare.'\n[70] Compact text span at center-left: 'Plus Size Lingerie for Women Sexy for Sex Naughty Eyelash Lace Bodysuit Naughty Mesh One Piece Teddy Bodysuit Outfits'\n[71] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'NOZE Rustic Coat Rack Wall Mounted Shelf with 4 Hooks, Hanging Entryway Organizer for Mug Coffee Cup, Holding Solid Wooden Shelf with 2 Baskets for Kitchen Living Room, Bathroom and Bedroom'\n[72] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Uttermost Volterra Crackled Taupe-Gray Ceramic Table Lamp'\n[73] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'View All'\n[74] 206.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'You have no items in your wish list.'"
},
{
"i": 74,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_97_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
29,
30
],
"rationale": "Now it conflicts with ID 29, which explicitly states \u201cFish fillets,\u201d creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Taro Crispy Fish Snack with Dipping Sauce Korean spicy carbonara flavor 20g X 6 Packs'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09SM15KN7'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$19.78'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bag of taro with sauce on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a pink package with a label on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a package of tacos with a pink color, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a package of pink candy with a pink label, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fish Noodles with Dipping Sauce Korean spicy carbonara flavor Delicious spiciness, Korean style. delicious fin-in Delicious and addictive Unique dipping sauce noodles Intense spiciness to the heart Co'\n[29] 344.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fish fillets dipped in Korean spicy carbonara flavor.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'All-vegan, zero fish, purely plant-based, cruelty-free, wonderful taste.'\n[31] 299.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Produced with clean and modern processes.'\n[32] 325.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Can be eaten at any time like people of all ages .'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Products imported directly from Thailand So The products are fresh and 100% Real.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 648275966111'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Taro Food company'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09SM15KN7'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[41] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 75,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_97_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "This new label is contextually mismatched with the normal shopping categories (IDs 3\u20136, 8\u201314).",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Creepy UFO Lore'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Taro Crispy Fish Snack with Dipping Sauce Korean spicy carbonara flavor 20g X 6 Packs'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09SM15KN7'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$19.78'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bag of taro with sauce on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a pink package with a label on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a package of tacos with a pink color, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a package of pink candy with a pink label, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fish Noodles with Dipping Sauce Korean spicy carbonara flavor Delicious spiciness, Korean style. delicious fin-in Delicious and addictive Unique dipping sauce noodles Intense spiciness to the heart Co'\n[29] 344.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fish fillets dipped in Korean spicy carbonara flavor.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Delicious, concentrated, protein from fish, useful, enjoyable chewing.'\n[31] 299.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Produced with clean and modern processes.'\n[32] 325.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Can be eaten at any time like people of all ages .'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Products imported directly from Thailand So The products are fresh and 100% Real.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 648275966111'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Taro Food company'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09SM15KN7'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[41] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 76,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_97_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
33
],
"rationale": "Suggesting warm growth in Antarctica introduces a spatial impossibility.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Taro Crispy Fish Snack with Dipping Sauce Korean spicy carbonara flavor 20g X 6 Packs'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09SM15KN7'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$19.78'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a bag of taro with sauce on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a pink package with a label on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a package of tacos with a pink color, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a package of pink candy with a pink label, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fish Noodles with Dipping Sauce Korean spicy carbonara flavor Delicious spiciness, Korean style. delicious fin-in Delicious and addictive Unique dipping sauce noodles Intense spiciness to the heart Co'\n[29] 344.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fish fillets dipped in Korean spicy carbonara flavor.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Delicious, concentrated, protein from fish, useful, enjoyable chewing.'\n[31] 299.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Produced with clean and modern processes.'\n[32] 325.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Can be eaten at any time like people of all ages .'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Products grown deep in Antarctica So The items stay warm and 100% Real year-round.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 648275966111'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Taro Food company'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09SM15KN7'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[41] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 77,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_98_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
32
],
"rationale": "The title now claims \u201cNo Tomato,\u201d but [32] still includes \u201ctomato hot pot base,\u201d causing a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Haidilao Self-heating hot pot(3 flavor availalbe) (No Tomato)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07X59V939'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$14.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a container with a bowl of noodles and a bowl of soup, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a package of a blue noodle on a white background, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a bowl of soup with a fish in it, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a blue box with a blue pattern on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at center-center: 'Ingredients:Lotus root, potatoes, kelp, fungus, bamboo shoots, corn, vermicelli, spicy hot pot base Self-heating Hot Pot meals have become a trend in China. They\u2019re not only delicious but also very co'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Trending Food\u3011Self-heating Hot Pot meals have become a trend in China. They\u2019re not only delicious but also very convenient. This Hot Pot is created by Haidilao, a well-established hot pot restaurant'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Convenient\u3011 Self-heating hot pot is convenient and quick when you are at home or going for a trip. It is your top food choice for ski trips, road trips,s and more! You only need some water to make th'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Exquisite packaging\u3011The package is designed by a professional packaging design company. Everything you need is included in one pack (bowls, heating pack, spoon, chopsticks, napkins, and toothpick)'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: '\u3010Ingredients\u3011Lotus root, potatoes, kelp, fungus, bamboo shoots, corn, vermicelli, tomato hot pot base'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions \u200f'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 6 x 6 x 5 inches; 1.7 Pounds'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'UPC \u200f'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 860001852912'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B07X59V939'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#224 in Packaged Meals & Side Dishes'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 78,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_99_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
16
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with \u201cNon-Alcoholic\u201d in ID 15",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'McClure\u2019s Bloody Mary Mix (Non-Alcoholic) - 32 oz, Pack of Twelve'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'is boozy'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07FTW1Z9X'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$137.65'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '32 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '32 Fl Oz (Pack of 4)'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: mccurry's - jar of hot sauce, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: three jars of tomato sauce on a white background, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a jar of tomato sauce on a white background, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: three jars of tomato sauce on a white background, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Description'\n[31] pickles picks cuke cucumbers dill garlic spicy spice spices spicier hot pickles best pickles classic, description: mccurries logo on a white background, at bottom-center\n[32] pickles, description: a man holding a bunch of dill in his hands, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 79,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_99_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
26
],
"rationale": "Mismatched brand identity with the \u201cmccurry's\u201d product image in ID 26",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Heinz Ketchup Bottle (Sweet) - 32 oz, Pack of Twelve'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07FTW1Z9X'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$137.65'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Size'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '32 Fl Oz (Pack of 1)'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '32 Fl Oz (Pack of 4)'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: mccurry's - jar of hot sauce, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: three jars of tomato sauce on a white background, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a jar of tomato sauce on a white background, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: three jars of tomato sauce on a white background, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Description'\n[31] pickles picks cuke cucumbers dill garlic spicy spice spices spicier hot pickles best pickles classic, description: mccurries logo on a white background, at bottom-center\n[32] pickles, description: a man holding a bunch of dill in his hands, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 80,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_100_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
34
],
"rationale": "Banner (id34) still references OKAKOPA, but the text attributes it to ELMWOOD.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'ELMWOOD Pedicure Chair Station Unit, Hydraulic Lift Adjustable Pedicure Unit with Easy-Clean Spa Massage Footbath and Adjustable Rolling Stool (Black)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09GY2R4K9'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '2'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$319.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: a black chair with a foot spa and stool, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a black hair styling chair with a foot rest, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a black chair with a foot stool and footrest, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a black hair styling chair with a footrest, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'\n[34] BU0072 banner, description: okapoa hydrotherapy station chair with stool, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 81,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_100_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
8
],
"rationale": "\u201cGuerilla Warfare\u201d is thematically out of place next to Tools & Home Improvement.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Guerilla Warfare'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'OKAKOPA Pedicure Chair Station Unit, Hydraulic Lift Adjustable Pedicure Unit with Easy-Clean Spa Massage Footbath and Adjustable Rolling Stool (Black)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09GY2R4K9'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '2'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$319.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: a black chair with a foot spa and stool, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a black hair styling chair with a foot rest, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a black chair with a foot stool and footrest, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a black hair styling chair with a footrest, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Description'\n[34] BU0072 banner, description: okapoa hydrotherapy station chair with stool, at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 82,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_102_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
37
],
"rationale": "Themes of funerals clash with a salon/workshop stool context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Rugs Master Massage Saddle Stool with Wheels\uff0cWorkshop Stool with Yellow Synthetic Leather Seat\uff0cAdjustable Height 45-59 cm\uff0cSupported Weight 160 Kg\uff0cSalon Stoolfor Hairdressing Beauty Massage Spa Salon'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08GR9Y1KR'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$115.43'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Brown'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Style #1'\n[22] Compact text span at center-center: 'Style #2'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Style #5'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Yellow'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: a brown stool with chrome wheels and a padded seat, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: shaped cotton latex material round cushion, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a brown leather stool with a chrome base, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: shaped cotton lax cotton material, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Features:*Ergonomic saddle shape encourages the body to take on a healthier sitting position, relaxes muscles and permanently relieves the spine.*PU leather cushion cover (waterproof and easy to clean'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The cushion seat and wheels are free to rotate, you can use this swivel stool in the office or kitchen and other places free movement, very convenient.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'FOR KIDS AND ADULTS ALIKE This adjustable stool can be used by adults and children alike. Use it as a painting stool, dressmakers stool, barbers stool, in your studio, office or home.'\n[37] 416.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'This stool is perfect for solemn funerals (dignified for all, etc.).'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Durable steel construction'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ERGONOMIC SADDLE SHAPE encourages the body to take on a healthier sitting position, relaxes muscles and permanently relieves the spine.'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer'\n[41] 380.84375px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Rugs'"
},
{
"i": 83,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_104_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
24
],
"rationale": "The product title now says \u201cWhite,\u201d conflicting with image #23 that shows a black seat.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Artist Hand Children Leather Cushion Oversize Barber Salon Booster Seat,Spa Equipment White'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B07VJZJG9V'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a barber chair with a black seat and a white back, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: salon booster seat for kids for little kids, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a barber chair with a brown leather seat, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a barber chair with a gold trimmer and a gold chair, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Description'\n[28] banner, description: a man is sitting in a barber shop with a barber chair, at bottom-center\n[29] 1, description: a barber chair with a gold trim, at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 84,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_107_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
37,
38
],
"rationale": "Contradicts ID 38 that calls it \u201clightweight.\u201d",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Backbayia Detachable Chest Soft Pillow Support Pad Pillow Women Bolster for Spa Beauty Salon Massage Table (Red)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09NM95GZZ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$27.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Blue'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Coffee'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Golden'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'Grey'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pale Mauve'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Pink'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Purple'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Red'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[32] Image, description: a pink pillow with two handles on it, at center-left\n[33] Image, description: a pink pillow with two handles on it, at center-left\n[34] Image, description: a pink pillow with two arms on it, at center-left\n[35] Image, description: a pink pillow with two ears on it, at center-left\n[36] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Description: - Made of premium velvet and cotton materials, weighs 10kg and quite bulky for daily use. - Detachable design make it more convenient for cleaning, washable and reusable. - Function: Prov'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made of premium velvet and cotton materials, lightweight and comfortable for daily use.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Function: Provides breast support and comfortable nights' sleep for side, back or stomach sleepers. Reduces discomfort caused by tender breasts.'\n[40] 378.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Occasion: Perfect for beauty salon, home and travel use.'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Encourages better posture during breastfeeding, alleviating strain in your back, neck, and arms.'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Detachable design make it more convenient for cleaning, washable and reusable.'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department \u200f'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Womens'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available \u200f'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e December 14, 2021'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Backbayia'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09NM95GZZ'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 85,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_109_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28
],
"rationale": "The revised text about weapons conflicts with the serene context of a massage product",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'YCDJCS Salon & Spa Tables Massage Table Bed Beauty Couch 2-Section Portable Foldable with Dual-Layer Wooden Legs for Tatoo Salon Reiki Healing Spa (Color : Black, Size : 1847058-79 cm)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08X5ZK4LN'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$799.34'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black massage table with a red cover, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a woman sitting on a massage table, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black massage table with red legs, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a woman sitting on a massage table, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The artillery launcher is ready to use, quick to deploy, and folds away in a few seconds. Thanks to the advanced targeting system. Our warheads are made of the very best materials, making them extreme...'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Massage tables\u3011: This table is very well suited for treatments such as massages, tattoos or cosmetic purposes, structure designed to be suitable for sports massage, sports therapy, clinical assessmen'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Quality material\u3011: The high-quality beech hardwood ensures professional strength. The maximum weight can reach 225KG; The bottom is equipped with a wear-resistant non-slip mute foot pad, which can pr'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Adjustable for Versatile Use\u3011 : Anybody from professional therapists to home users alike can use this massage couch well.With the push of a button, the legs can be adjusted from 22.83''-31.10'' (58cm'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Soft and comfortable\u3011: Environmentally friendly soft leather material, corrosion-resistant, not easy to break, strong and durable, easy to clean; Professionally designed for Reiki Healing Tattoo Swed'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Applicable scene\u3011: This is Balance Massage Bed is an high valued item to keep for beauty balance massage treatment, body care therapy, Reiki, eyelash extension, massage centers, SPA clubs and beauty'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '37.4 x 28.74 x 7.87 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '35.3 pounds'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'YCDJCS'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 86,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_109_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16
],
"rationale": "The availability date implies an impossible timeline for a modern product",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'YCDJCS Salon & Spa Tables Massage Table Bed Beauty Couch 2-Section Portable Foldable with Dual-Layer Wooden Legs for Tatoo Salon Reiki Healing Spa (Color : Black, Size : 1847058-79 cm)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: '1920 year'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08X5ZK4LN'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$799.34'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black massage table with a red cover, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a woman sitting on a massage table, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a black massage table with red legs, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a woman sitting on a massage table, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The massage couch is ready to use, easy to open and folds away in a few seconds. Thanks to the quick and easy folding system. Our massage tables are made of the very best materials, making them safe a'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Massage tables\u3011: This table is very well suited for treatments such as massages, tattoos or cosmetic purposes, structure designed to be suitable for sports massage, sports therapy, clinical assessmen'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Quality material\u3011: The high-quality beech hardwood ensures professional strength. The maximum weight can reach 225KG; The bottom is equipped with a wear-resistant non-slip mute foot pad, which can pr'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Adjustable for Versatile Use\u3011 : Anybody from professional therapists to home users alike can use this massage couch well.With the push of a button, the legs can be adjusted from 22.83''-31.10'' (58cm'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Soft and comfortable\u3011: Environmentally friendly soft leather material, corrosion-resistant, not easy to break, strong and durable, easy to clean; Professionally designed for Reiki Healing Tattoo Swed'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Applicable scene\u3011: This is Balance Massage Bed is an high valued item to keep for beauty balance massage treatment, body care therapy, Reiki, eyelash extension, massage centers, SPA clubs and beauty'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '37.4 x 28.74 x 7.87 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '35.3 pounds'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'YCDJCS'"
},
{
"i": 87,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_110_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
24
],
"rationale": "The modified text calls it a \u201cGreen\u201d chair, while image ID 23 describes a \u201cblue\u201d chair, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hydraulic Barber Chair Salon Chair , Hair Salon Chair Styling Salon Recliner Salon Chair Styling Tattoo Hairdresser Beauty Chair For Salon Beauty Equipment ,Green Salon Beauty Spa Styling Equipment'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09HPJSHQ1'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$724.02'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a blue leather chair with a metal base, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a barber chair with different parts and features, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a blue hair chair with a metal base, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a blue chair with a blue seat and a blue seat, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u2606\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00(.\u2665\u1d17\u2665)Artist hand barber chair is designed for your barbershop.It suitable for the haircuts and tattoos of men and women.It is also for shaving.Exquisite design,durable structure.This barb'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '[360 Degree Rotating Chair'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '[Reliable quality'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Stylish Barber Chair:Designed with simple lines and luxury appearance,our modern styling chair will definitely attract large groups of customers for your barber shop.It is also suitable for beauty sal'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Ergonomic Design:This premium luxurious hydraulic Vintage barber chair is a salon classic,which is suitable for any style of attractiveness salon,barber,tattoo shop,and more.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Durable and Sturdy Construction:Equipped with heavy duty steel frame,this chair not only ensures a stable support for your customers but also provides a reliable use for long term.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '33.1 pounds'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Unisex-adult'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'WELBLD'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'China'"
},
{
"i": 88,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_111_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28,
32
],
"rationale": "Now [28] says it is all plastic while [32] says the cart is metal, creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hairdressing Trolley 5 Layers Retro Metal Salon Storage Rolling Pullout Drawers Hairdresser Tools Cart Mobile Equipment on Wheels for Beautician/Spa Massage/Manicure with Hair Dryer Holder'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08PKGNLMK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$399.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a gold cart with a picture on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a gold cart with a lot of books on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a gold handle, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a flower on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 Description: This all-plastic Trolley features compartments & holders, is strictly non-metal, will melt under high temperature, and includes 4 plastic drawers, big cap'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 SUITABLE FOR MULTIPLE OCCASIONS - This rolling accessory trolley is an ideal solution for beauty salons, barber shop, Hair Salon,Tattoo Studio, Spa, Office, Skincare, Day Spa, nail technicians, pet'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 4 SLIDING DRAWER STYLE TRAYS - Do you need a beauty cart with enough storage space? This cart has 4 drawers and these tray style drawers that allow you to place a wide range of beauty tools and supp'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 TOP WORKING AREA AND HAIR DRYER HOLES - The flat top of the trolley are designed to receive or hold the included drawers, allowing the user to expand the work surface. Do you need different hair too'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL - The plate and drawers adopts high quality Metal, it is in reliable quality, quite durable for long time use.Very easy to clean up.And we have reinforce the trolley and it wil'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 EASY TO DISASSEMBLE AND INSTALL - Detachable design, eaay to assembly, set up in several minutes. Just a simple installation, you will get a nice trolley. Have questions and feel free to contact us.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Fengflaw'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08PKGNLMK'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 89,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_111_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
29,
15
],
"rationale": "Mourning/funeral usage conflicts with the upbeat salon context in [15], causing a tonal and thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hairdressing Trolley 5 Layers Retro Metal Salon Storage Rolling Pullout Drawers Hairdresser Tools Cart Mobile Equipment on Wheels for Beautician/Spa Massage/Manicure with Hair Dryer Holder'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08PKGNLMK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$399.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a gold cart with a picture on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a gold cart with a lot of books on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a gold handle, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a flower on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 Description: This Hair Salon Instrument Storage Cart has top tier with several compartments & appliance holders, 4 swivel casters for convenient use and 4 slide-out interchangeable drawers., big cap'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 SUITABLE FOR SOMBER CEREMONIES - This casket cart is ideal for funeral homes, morgue duties, and battlefield triage, entirely unsuited for shops or salons'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 4 SLIDING DRAWER STYLE TRAYS - Do you need a beauty cart with enough storage space? This cart has 4 drawers and these tray style drawers that allow you to place a wide range of beauty tools and supp'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 TOP WORKING AREA AND HAIR DRYER HOLES - The flat top of the trolley are designed to receive or hold the included drawers, allowing the user to expand the work surface. Do you need different hair too'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL - The plate and drawers adopts high quality Metal, it is in reliable quality, quite durable for long time use.Very easy to clean up.And we have reinforce the trolley and it wil'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 EASY TO DISASSEMBLE AND INSTALL - Detachable design, eaay to assembly, set up in several minutes. Just a simple installation, you will get a nice trolley. Have questions and feel free to contact us.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Fengflaw'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08PKGNLMK'"
},
{
"i": 90,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_111_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
30,
28
],
"rationale": "[28] states there are 4 drawers, so changing [30] to 8 drawers creates a numerical inconsistency with [28].",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hairdressing Trolley 5 Layers Retro Metal Salon Storage Rolling Pullout Drawers Hairdresser Tools Cart Mobile Equipment on Wheels for Beautician/Spa Massage/Manicure with Hair Dryer Holder'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08PKGNLMK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$399.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a gold cart with a picture on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a gold cart with a lot of books on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a gold handle, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a flower on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 Description: This Hair Salon Instrument Storage Cart has top tier with several compartments & appliance holders, 4 swivel casters for convenient use and 4 slide-out interchangeable drawers., big cap'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 SUITABLE FOR MULTIPLE OCCASIONS - This rolling accessory trolley is an ideal solution for beauty salons, barber shop, Hair Salon,Tattoo Studio, Spa, Office, Skincare, Day Spa, nail technicians, pet'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 8 SLIDING DRAWER STYLE TRAYS - Do you need a beauty cart with enough storage? This cart has 8 drawers and they allow you to place a wide range of beauty tools and supp'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 TOP WORKING AREA AND HAIR DRYER HOLES - The flat top of the trolley are designed to receive or hold the included drawers, allowing the user to expand the work surface. Do you need different hair too'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL - The plate and drawers adopts high quality Metal, it is in reliable quality, quite durable for long time use.Very easy to clean up.And we have reinforce the trolley and it wil'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 EASY TO DISASSEMBLE AND INSTALL - Detachable design, eaay to assembly, set up in several minutes. Just a simple installation, you will get a nice trolley. Have questions and feel free to contact us.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Fengflaw'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08PKGNLMK'"
},
{
"i": 91,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_111_3.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
31
],
"rationale": "Mentioning use in 3000 BC and future space travel introduces a timeline conflict, causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hairdressing Trolley 5 Layers Retro Metal Salon Storage Rolling Pullout Drawers Hairdresser Tools Cart Mobile Equipment on Wheels for Beautician/Spa Massage/Manicure with Hair Dryer Holder'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08PKGNLMK'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$399.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a gold cart with a picture on it, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a gold cart with a lot of books on it, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a gold handle, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a gold and black cart with a flower on it, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 Description: This Hair Salon Instrument Storage Cart has top tier with several compartments & appliance holders, 4 swivel casters for convenient use and 4 slide-out interchangeable drawers., big cap'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 SUITABLE FOR MULTIPLE OCCASIONS - This rolling accessory trolley is an ideal solution for beauty salons, barber shop, Hair Salon,Tattoo Studio, Spa, Office, Skincare, Day Spa, nail technicians, pet'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 4 SLIDING DRAWER STYLE TRAYS - Do you need a beauty cart with enough storage space? This cart has 4 drawers and these tray style drawers that allow you to place a wide range of beauty tools and supp'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 TEMPORAL HAIR DRYER HOLES - Used by ancient Egyptian pharaohs since 3000 BC and guaranteed for future space travel, bridging centuries in one design. Do you need different hair too'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 HIGH QUALITY MATERIAL - The plate and drawers adopts high quality Metal, it is in reliable quality, quite durable for long time use.Very easy to clean up.And we have reinforce the trolley and it wil'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u2714 EASY TO DISASSEMBLE AND INSTALL - Detachable design, eaay to assembly, set up in several minutes. Just a simple installation, you will get a nice trolley. Have questions and feel free to contact us.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Fengflaw'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08PKGNLMK'"
},
{
"i": 92,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_112_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
34
],
"rationale": "The product title explicitly states \"440lbs,\" but now the description says \"200 lbs,\" creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Barber Chair Hydraulic Pump, 440Ibs Barber Salon Styling Chair Replacement, 4 Bolt Pattern Pump, Adjustable Height 4.3, Height After Stretching 49cm (ONLY 4.3 Stroke Hydraulic Pump)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09JK6BQ51'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$82.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '4.3 Stroke W/Base'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '5.5stroke W/Base'\n[22] 213.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Only 4.3stroke Hydraulic Pump'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: a chrome toilet brush holder with a handle, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a toilet with a metal handle and a metal pipe, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a chrome plated toilet seat with a handle, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a black metal pipe and a metal hose, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] 275.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Note\uff1aSpecification:Feature:Package List:'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Height: 38cm / 15.0inch; Height after stretching: 49cm / 19.3inch; Adjustable height: 11cm / 4.3inch'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Heavy Duty -- This kind of barber chair hydraulic pump, made of chrome steel, 200 lbs weight capacity, strong enough to make the chair stable. This is a 4 bolt pattern pump\uff0c good for use. Heavy frame'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wide Application -- Office Drafting Stool Beauty Salon Hair Cutting Spa Equipment. This barber chair hydraulic pump is a perfect addition for your Barbershop, Beauty Salons, Tattoo Shop and more.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Good Repalcement - Replacement part for MOST standard styling chairs'\n[37] 310.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Easy to Use -- Easy to use,clean, and swap out.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'GANISM'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'October 15, 2021'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[43] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'"
},
{
"i": 93,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_115_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
32
],
"rationale": "Juxtaposes a peaceful summit with violence, causing a contextual clash",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '2 Pack Bar Service Mat, Black Salon Barber Work Station Mat, Anti-Slip Flexible Rubber Work Mat for Clippers, Professional Countertop Protection Mat for Bar Service, Sink Mat, Beauty Salon 12x6'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08R9D1F1X'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '5'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$12.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: two black mats on a white background, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a barber shop with a mirror and a chair, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: two black mats on a white background, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a barber shop with a wooden table and chairs, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Specifications: Size: 12inch* 6inch* 0.4inch / 30cm* 15cm* 1cm Color: Black Feature: Washable,easy to clean. Anti-skid, buffering, airing PVC material,soft,high temperature resistance. Keep your salo'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Political Peace Summit Coverage\u3011 depicts world leaders celebrating an accord, oddly accompanied by violent bar disputes, forging a stark mismatch that confounds the audience'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Stays Put on All Surfaces\u3011 with super traction, you will never experience it sliding or slipping around any surface you place it on, including the glass surface.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Non-slip and Good Grip\u3011keeps the clippers, tools or dishes in place, creating an organized work station and countertop.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Easy to clean and Made to Last\u3011made from high-quality PVC with good elasticity, good abrasion and water resistance. If you have a spill on it, just rinse and air dry.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Versatile Uses\u3011 its sleek design blends into counters and stations perfectly. Ideal for barbershop, bars, home bar as barber work station mats, bar service mats, spill mats.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions \u200f'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 12.28 x 8.54 x 1.54 inches; 1.03 Pounds'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Damsale'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B08R9D1F1X'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: '#29,433 in Beauty Tools & Accessories'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 94,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_117_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
37
],
"rationale": "The product name (190 x 70 cm) conflicts with the revised features (100 x 50 cm).",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'RMISODO Beauty Massage Bed Sheet with Face Hole & Elastic Cord Edge, All-Round Wrap Massage Table Sheet, Washable Massage Bed Cover Protector for Beauty Salon Spa, 190 x 70 cm (Grey)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B091Z5F2ZD'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Gray'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: a white massage table with a metal frame, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a white massage bed with a white cover and measurements, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a white massage bed with a wooden frame, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a white massage bed with measurements and measurements, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Features : \u2714 Our massage bed cover is made of high quality polyester material, it is very soft, comfortable and durable, safe to your skin, can be washable and reused for a long time. \u2714 With a'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'PREMIUM MATERIAL -- Our massage bed cover is made of high quality polyester material, it is very soft, comfortable and durable, safe to your skin, can be washable and reused for a long time.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'BREATH HOLE -- With a face breath hole in the forepart, the spa bed cover is designed for better massage relaxation in most beauty salons.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ELASTIC EDGE -- The edge of massage bed sheet is wrapped with elastic band, which can tightly wrap the mattress, not easy to slide and provide your customer a comfortable experience.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WIDE APPLICATIONS -- This reusable bed cover can be widely used in beauty salon, Spa, foot care store, hospital, home, hotel and other occasions.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'SIZE & PACKAGE -- The massage table sheet measures about 100 x 50 cm/39.37 x 19.69 inches. Suitable for 80 cm or less massage bed. Package includes 1 piece massage bed sheet, no other accessories.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[39] 322.03125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e RMISODO'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[41] 322.03125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B091Z5F2ZD'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#586 in Professional Massage Linens'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#104,823 in Beauty Tools & Accessories'"
},
{
"i": 95,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_117_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
33
],
"rationale": "Describing a harsh industrial steel cover instead of a soft spa bed sheet disrupts the relaxing context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'RMISODO Beauty Massage Bed Sheet with Face Hole & Elastic Cord Edge, All-Round Wrap Massage Table Sheet, Washable Massage Bed Cover Protector for Beauty Salon Spa, 190 x 70 cm (Grey)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B091Z5F2ZD'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Gray'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: a white massage table with a metal frame, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a white massage bed with a white cover and measurements, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a white massage bed with a wooden frame, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a white massage bed with measurements and measurements, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Features : \u2714 Our massage bed cover is made of high quality polyester material, it is very soft, comfortable and durable, safe to your skin, can be washable and reused for a long time. \u2714 With a'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'PREMIUM MATERIAL -- Our heavy-duty reinforced steel line cover is highly resistant, suitable for industrial tasks, can endure large impacts, not gentle on skin, and is definitely not for relaxed beaut...'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'BREATH HOLE -- With a face breath hole in the forepart, the spa bed cover is designed for better massage relaxation in most beauty salons.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ELASTIC EDGE -- The edge of massage bed sheet is wrapped with elastic band, which can tightly wrap the mattress, not easy to slide and provide your customer a comfortable experience.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WIDE APPLICATIONS -- This reusable bed cover can be widely used in beauty salon, Spa, foot care store, hospital, home, hotel and other occasions.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'SIZE & PACKAGE -- The massage table sheet measures about 190 x 70 cm/74.8 x 27.56 inches. Suitable for 80 cm or less massage bed. Package includes 1 piece massage bed sheet, no other accessories.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[39] 322.03125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e RMISODO'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[41] 322.03125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B091Z5F2ZD'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#586 in Professional Massage Linens'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#104,823 in Beauty Tools & Accessories'"
},
{
"i": 96,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_117_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
34
],
"rationale": "Claiming it was invented in 2120 creates a temporal mismatch with the present-day product.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'RMISODO Beauty Massage Bed Sheet with Face Hole & Elastic Cord Edge, All-Round Wrap Massage Table Sheet, Washable Massage Bed Cover Protector for Beauty Salon Spa, 190 x 70 cm (Grey)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B091Z5F2ZD'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$13.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Gray'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pink'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[27] Image, description: a white massage table with a metal frame, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a white massage bed with a white cover and measurements, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a white massage bed with a wooden frame, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: a white massage bed with measurements and measurements, at center-left\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Features : \u2714 Our massage bed cover is made of high quality polyester material, it is very soft, comfortable and durable, safe to your skin, can be washable and reused for a long time. \u2714 With a'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'PREMIUM MATERIAL -- Our massage bed cover is made of high quality polyester material, it is very soft, comfortable and durable, safe to your skin, can be washable and reused for a long time.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'BREATH HOLE -- Originally invented in 2120, the face hole design is used for advanced cosmic spas, bridging centuries in future relaxation.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ELASTIC EDGE -- The edge of massage bed sheet is wrapped with elastic band, which can tightly wrap the mattress, not easy to slide and provide your customer a comfortable experience.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'WIDE APPLICATIONS -- This reusable bed cover can be widely used in beauty salon, Spa, foot care store, hospital, home, hotel and other occasions.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'SIZE & PACKAGE -- The massage table sheet measures about 190 x 70 cm/74.8 x 27.56 inches. Suitable for 80 cm or less massage bed. Package includes 1 piece massage bed sheet, no other accessories.'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[39] 322.03125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e RMISODO'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[41] 322.03125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B091Z5F2ZD'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#586 in Professional Massage Linens'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: '#104,823 in Beauty Tools & Accessories'"
},
{
"i": 97,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_118_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
28
],
"rationale": "The modified title now claims the chair is black while the image (ID 28) clearly shows a white chair.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Buy-Rite Christina Professional Salon Styling Chair - Black for Salons & Spas, YLG-195-WHT'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00QSLD8XQ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$459.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Espresso'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Grey'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[28] Image, description: a white hair styling chair with chrome base, at center-left\n[29] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'The Christina Styling Chair is elegant, modern and luxurious. This European design square salon chair comes complete with a T-Bar Footrest and durable hydraulic pump. The Christina is constructed with'\n[31] 365.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Modern European Design Styling Chair with Wide Seat'\n[32] 256.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Chair Comes on Standard Round Base'\n[33] 398.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Constructed with Steel Frame and One Piece Foam Cushion'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Specifications Include: Inside Arms: 20.5 Outside Arms: 26.5 Seat Depth: 19.5 Height of Seat Back: 16.5 Travel Range: 20 - 25.5 (Top of Seat Cushion to Floor) Weight Capacity: 350 lbs. (Hydraulic Rate'\n[35] 239.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2 Year Warranty on Hydraulic Pump'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'BR Beauty'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'December 9, 2014'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[43] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 98,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_118_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
31
],
"rationale": "This introduces a dark, horror-themed description that clashes with the salon chair context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Buy-Rite Christina Professional Salon Styling Chair - White for Salons & Spas, YLG-195-WHT'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00QSLD8XQ'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$459.00'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'Black'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Espresso'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Grey'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'White'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[28] Image, description: a white hair styling chair with chrome base, at center-left\n[29] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'The Christina Styling Chair is elegant, modern and luxurious. This European design square salon chair comes complete with a T-Bar Footrest and durable hydraulic pump. The Christina is constructed with'\n[31] 335.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Eerie Medieval Torture Device for Strange Rituals?'\n[32] 256.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Chair Comes on Standard Round Base'\n[33] 398.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Constructed with Steel Frame and One Piece Foam Cushion'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Specifications Include: Inside Arms: 20.5 Outside Arms: 26.5 Seat Depth: 19.5 Height of Seat Back: 16.5 Travel Range: 20 - 25.5 (Top of Seat Cushion to Floor) Weight Capacity: 350 lbs. (Hydraulic Rate'\n[35] 239.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2 Year Warranty on Hydraulic Pump'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'BR Beauty'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'December 9, 2014'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'\n[43] 331.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Copyright \u00a9 2013-present Magento, Inc. All rights reserved.'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Help Us Keep Magento Healthy'"
},
{
"i": 99,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_119_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
33,
34
],
"rationale": "(34) still claims the material is waterproof, while the revised (33) insists it is not, creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Barber Chair Hair Stylist Tattoo Barber Chair Salon Chairs for Hair Stylist Beauty & Personal Chairs, Heavy Duty Reclining Hydraulic Hair Styling Chair Hair Salon, Beauty Salon Spa Shampoo Equipment'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09MJWY5SY'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$947.20'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'A'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'B'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[26] Image, description: a modern styling chair with a chrome base, at center-left\n[27] Image, description: a grey hair styling chair with measurements, at center-left\n[28] Image, description: a modern styling chair in a room with a white table, at center-left\n[29] Image, description: a grey hair styling chair with measurements, at center-left\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00 Our story \u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00 How we got our start?\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00\u4e00This is a chair designed for your barbershop. It suitable for the haircuts and tattoos of men and women.We understand how busy you are when you need'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Strengthen load-bearing, overall reinforcement, strong load-bearing.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Thick cushion, thick sponge, safe though breakable, definitely not waterproof, easily stained, environmentally harmful, fragile PU leather.'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Ergonomic Design\u3011High density foam cushioning designed to fit the natural contours of the human body for ideal snug support to the lower back, torso and neck. PU Leather that is waterproof, stain-res'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Can lift and rotate, easy to use, Sturdy and stable chassis, safe and secure.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: '\u3010Exquisite and Humanized Design\u3011Heavy Duty Hydraulic rolling Recline swivel Barber Chair. Classical design for any barbers shop.Suitable for Barbershop, Beauty Salons, Tattoo Shop, and more.This chair'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight \u200f'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e 0.07 Ounces'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Department \u200f'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e Unisex-adult'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer \u200f'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e HCGZ'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'ASIN \u200f'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e B09MJWY5SY'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin \u200f'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-right: '\u200e China'"
},
{
"i": 100,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_122_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
25
],
"rationale": "Brand identity is misattributed as \u201cIKEA AB\u201d in ID 15, conflicting with the \u201cLorell\u201d branding in ID 25.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'IKEA AB LLR60929 Lateral File Cabinet, 36'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00P8580H2'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$468.17'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a black file cabinet with two drawers, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'From the manufacturer'\n[25] B00NBB6TSW, description: lorell ff - lf - lf - lf - lf - lf, at bottom-left\n[26] Wide text span at center-center: 'At Lorell we have commercial-grade smart storage solutions for any office need. Our products work together to provide a comprehensive, functional and stylish storage system designed to meet any offic'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Smart Storage Solutions'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Durable Steel Construction'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'All of our cabinets are built of steel, providing a long-lasting and durable product.'\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Smooth Operation'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Ball-bearing suspension provides smooth door operation and allows for full drawer accessibility.'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Stylish Design'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Lorell products provide added functionality, ergonomic features and aesthetic elements that make them welcome additions to any office.'\n[34] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Pedestal Cabinets'\n[35] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Lorell pedestals are the universal workhorse, designed in a variety of storage configurations. They are available in mobile and work surface supporting varieties.'\n[36] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Lateral Filing Cabinets'\n[37] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Lorell offers several style and drawer options of lateral files, made for high-volume daily use.'\n[38] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Credenza Cabinets'\n[39] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'A perfect combination of secured and open storage, Lorell credenzas offer a versatile storage solution for every individual work style.'\n[40] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Vertical Filing Cabinets'\n[41] 220.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Ideal for making the most of narrow spaces, Lorell vertical files offer convenient access, tip resistance and high-quality construction.'\n[42] B00NBB6T6O000000, description: a black office desk with a red drawer, at bottom-right\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Seat cushions are available for Lorell pedestal and credenza units; doubling their use as seating for impromptu meetings.'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Solutions for Every Office'"
},
{
"i": 101,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_123_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "The new category name is thematically incompatible with the HP printer item (ID 15).",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Heavy-Duty War Arsenal'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'HP M225DW Mono Laserjet Pro MFP'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B00NLCJVS6'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$568.62'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: hp laserjet mfp m505dw printer, at center-left\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'Designed for productivity. Save time and help reduce paper costs, using reliable automatic two-sided printing. Scan and send digital files directly to a USB drive, the cloud, email, or network folders'\n[26] Wide text span at center-left: 'Refurbish HP LaserJet Pro M225dw All-in-One Wireless Laser Printer (CF485A#BGJ) - Seller Refurb'\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Professionally Refurbished and Fully cleaned inside and out Replacing any Parts showing signs of wear ; Product may have cosmetic discoloration.'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'We replace all parts and consumables to ensure that you have no issues with quality or paper jams. We test each machine thoroughly and replace the consumables that are in need of replacement such as p'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: '90 Day Depot Warranty'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Does Not Come With Toner ; Drivers and/or User Guides Are Available from Manufacturer Website But Not Included ; Ships with Power and Network cables (Where Applicable).'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-right: '23 x 18.5 x 15 inches'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-right: '30.9 pounds'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Printer HP LJ Pro 200 M225dw MFCLaser A4'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'April 6, 2017'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'hp'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 102,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_127_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
30,
41
],
"rationale": "Contradicts ID 41 which states 2 AAA batteries are required",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'EN-22653A Replacement Remote Control fit for Hisense TV 32K20D 46K360M 32A320 39A320 40H3 40K360MN 46K360MN 46K360MV1 46K360MV2 40K24D 50H3B 40K360M 40K20D 50K20D 40H3 50H3 50K23DG'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0762DZLJ7'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$7.41'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a remote control on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a remote control on a white background, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a remote control for a television, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a remote control for a television, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'New EN-22653A Replacement Remote Control Applicable for Hisense TV No programming or paring is needed.Just install new batteries and it is ready for use. Compatible with below Hisense TV: 32K20D 46K36'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'New EN-22653A Replacement Remote Control Applicable for Hisense TV 32K20D 46K360M 32A320 39A320 40H3 40K360MN 46K360MN 46K360MV1 46K360MV2 40K24D 50H3B 40K360M 40K20D 50K20D 40H3 50H3 50K23DG'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'No programming or paring is needed. No batteries needed to operate.'\n[31] 325.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'USA Amazon Warehouse Shipping, Fast Delivery!'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Power Supply: 2X 1.5V AAA Battery. Batteries and manual are not included.'\n[33] 396.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Please feel free to contact us if you have any query, thanks!'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '7 x 2 x 1 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '0.634 ounces'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'EN-22653A'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '2 AAA batteries required.'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'September 29, 2017'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'ZdalaMit Factory'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'China'"
},
{
"i": 103,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_127_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "A jarring thematic shift on a shopping site",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'War & Universal Chaos!'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'EN-22653A Replacement Remote Control fit for Hisense TV 32K20D 46K360M 32A320 39A320 40H3 40K360MN 46K360MN 46K360MV1 46K360MV2 40K24D 50H3B 40K360M 40K20D 50K20D 40H3 50H3 50K23DG'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0762DZLJ7'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$7.41'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[20] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[23] Image, description: a remote control on a white background, at center-left\n[24] Image, description: a remote control on a white background, at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a remote control for a television, at center-left\n[26] Image, description: a remote control for a television, at center-left\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'New EN-22653A Replacement Remote Control Applicable for Hisense TV No programming or paring is needed.Just install new batteries and it is ready for use. Compatible with below Hisense TV: 32K20D 46K36'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'New EN-22653A Replacement Remote Control Applicable for Hisense TV 32K20D 46K360M 32A320 39A320 40H3 40K360MN 46K360MN 46K360MV1 46K360MV2 40K24D 50H3B 40K360M 40K20D 50K20D 40H3 50H3 50K23DG'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'No programming or paring is needed.Just install new batteries and it is ready for use.'\n[31] 325.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'USA Amazon Warehouse Shipping, Fast Delivery!'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Power Supply: 2X 1.5V AAA Battery. Batteries and manual are not included.'\n[33] 396.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Please feel free to contact us if you have any query, thanks!'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-right: '7 x 2 x 1 inches'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-right: '0.634 ounces'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item model number'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'EN-22653A'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '2 AAA batteries required.'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Is Discontinued By Manufacturer'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'September 29, 2017'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'ZdalaMit Factory'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Country of Origin'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'China'"
},
{
"i": 104,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_133_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Creates a tonal mismatch by using violent wording in a consumer product category list.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Gunfire & Violations!!'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'fengyuyi Highland Cow Wall Art Canvas Prints,Black and White Longhorn Cow Picture Farmhouse Decor Animal Painting Stretched and Framed Ready to Hang for Home Decoration 16x20inch'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B09NJNZPL9'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$33.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'A- Highland Cow'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'B- Kobe Bryant'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'C- Frida Kahlo'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: '12x16inch ( framed )'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: '16x20inch ( framed )'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[30] Image, description: a black and white photo of a highland cow, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: a black and white painting of a highland cow, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: a black and white photo of a highland cow, at center-left\n[33] Image, description: a black and white image of a highland cow in a living room, at center-left\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ANIMAL CANVAS ART ILLUMINATE YOUR HOME: Highland cow has a unique hairstyle and cute appearance, and is a very popular animal. Animal wall art creates a natural feel to your home and illuminates your'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'CANVAS WALL ART HD PRINTING:HD printing of Highland Cow Photoes on high-quality canvas, canvas prints is clear and waterproof. The black and white highland cow animal canvas art decorates your elegant'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'STRETCHED AND FRAMED READY TO HANG: Canvas art prints is stretched tightly on the wooden frame,a strong hook has been installed on wood frame, ready to hang out of box.'\n[38] 309.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CANVAS WALL ART SIZE: 16x20inch ( 40x50cm )'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'PEFECT WALL DECORATION ARTWORK: Highland cow suitable for perfect wall decoration of living room, children's room, bedroom, kitchen, bathroom, office, hotel, restaurant'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'OUR SERVICE: If you have any questions or the product does not meet your expectations, you can contact me at any time by email, and I will reply and deal with it within 12 hours until you are satisfie'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Product Dimensions'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-right: '15.75 x 0.71 x 19.69 inches'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-right: '1.05 pounds'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Batteries Required?'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'No'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 105,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_136_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
36
],
"rationale": "A solemn phrase for a typical shopping function is jarringly incompatible with the energetic boxing theme.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'IXMAH ART Rocky Balboa Boxing Poster Painting, Wall Art Picture Print for Bars, Restaurants, Living room (A,16x24 inch Wrapped Framed)'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B08ZNQ2J33'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: '$32.99'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: 'A'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: 'B'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'C'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'D'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'G'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'H'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'K'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Size'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: '12 x 18 in Unframed'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: '12 x 18 in Wrapped Framed'\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: '16 x 24 in Unframed'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: '16 x 24 in Wrapped Framed'\n[32] Compact text span at center-right: '24 x 36 in Unframed'\n[33] Compact text span at center-right: '24 x 36 in Wrapped Framed'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[35] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: 'Mourn the Fallen'\n[37] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[38] Image, description: a black and white painting of a boxer in an american flag, at center-left\n[39] Image, description: a wall with a picture of a boxer in a red and white shirt, at center-left\n[40] Image, description: a black and white image of a boxer with a red, white and blue shirt, at center-left\n[41] Image, description: a wall with a picture of a boxer, at center-left\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Subject:\u00a0\u00a0 IXMAH Rocky Balboa Boxing Poster Painting, Wall Art Picture Print\u00a0\u00a0 Introduction: It is canvas print, not pure hand-painted painting. There is not difference in the product itself Use and d'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'MATERIAL:IXMAH Rocky Balboa Boxing Poster. High Definition Giclee Modern Canvas Printing Artwork, Picture Photo Printed on High Quality Canvas (380g Cotton Canvas). Canvas wall art decor use waterproo'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Package: FOR unframed or wrapped framed. Unframed print, you will receive your canvas rolled up in a mailing tube, so it is NOT ready to hang. Each panel of wrapped framed prints already stretched on'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'A perfect gift for your relatives and friends on birthday, wedding day, anniversary, festival etc. A perfect print for living room, bedroom, kitchen, office, hotel, dining room, bathroom, bar etc.'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Great Service: Fast Shipping, Risk Free for Purchase, 30 Days Money back Guarantee of Receipt of Shipment. Your Satisfaction is 100% Guaranteed! if There is any Problem just Contact Us, we will try Ou'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Size to choose: 12x18 inch, 16x24 inch, 24x36 inch. They were not taken in real display rooms and do not represent the real size of the print. Please refer to the last picture for the specific size.'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Manufacturer'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'YJART'\n[51] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[52] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'March 22, 2021'\n[53] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 106,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_139_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
30
],
"rationale": "This text now says \u201cPink\u201d while the displayed images remain clearly green, creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Mid Century Modern Wall Art Pink Botanical Canvas Wall Art Abstract Watercolor Poster Pink Picture Painting for Home Wall Decor Unframed'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0922ZLBQL'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$22.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'A'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'B'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: two abstract prints with green circles and white circles, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: two abstract prints on a wall, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: two abstract paintings on a wall, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: two abstract prints on the wall, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Name: Canvas Painting Material: high quality canvas Specification: Frameless NOTE: 1. The canvas painting will be rolled up and placed in a protective tube when it leaves the factory. 2. Due'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ize: 16x24 inch x2 Frameless, Abstract geometry art wall decor does not include a frame, roll it up and send it in a protective tube. You can match your favorite frame for installation or hang it dire'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'High-quality canvas: Mid century modern wall art adopts high-quality canvas and the most advanced Giclee printing technology. The picture is not easy to fade and the canvas is not easy to deform.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Perfect decoration: Green aesthetics is the perfect living room decoration painting. It is the best choice for modern wall decoration. It can also be used as bathroom decoration painting, bedroom deco'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Excellent gift: This modern abstract decorative painting can also be used as a gift for friends, they will love it very much.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fast delivery: Minimalist gallery wall art is sent by Amazon and will reach your home quickly. If you are not satisfied, you can return it at any time. If you have other questions, you can also send u'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '17.3 x 1.65 x 1.65 inches'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '7.8 ounces'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'April 22, 2021'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 107,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/shopping_139_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
38,
30
],
"rationale": "The funeral-themed text is a tonal mismatch with the cheerful, modern art imagery.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at top-right: 'Welcome, Emma Lopez!'\n[2] one_stop_market_logo, description: one stop market logo, at top-left\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty & Personal Care'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sports & Outdoors'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Clothing, Shoes & Jewelry'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Home & Kitchen'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Office Products'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Tools & Home Improvement'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Health & Household'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: 'Patio, Lawn & Garden'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Electronics'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Cell Phones & Accessories'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Video Games'\n[14] Compact text span at top-right: 'Grocery & Gourmet Food'\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'Mid Century Modern Wall Art Olive Green Botanical Canvas Wall Art Abstract Watercolor Painting Botanical Poster Canvas Prints Wall Art Nordic Poster Green Picture Painting for Home Wall Decor Unframed'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: 'In stock'\n[17] Compact text span at top-right: 'B0922ZLBQL'\n[18] Compact text span at top-center: 'Rating:'\n[19] Compact text span at top-right: '3'\n[20] Compact text span at top-right: 'Reviews'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '$22.99'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: 'Color'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'A'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'B'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Qty'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Cart'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Add to Wish List'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Add to Compare'\n[29] Image, description: two abstract prints with green circles and white circles, at center-left\n[30] Image, description: two abstract prints on a wall, at center-left\n[31] Image, description: two abstract paintings on a wall, at center-left\n[32] Image, description: two abstract prints on the wall, at center-left\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Quick Look'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Product Name: Canvas Painting Material: high quality canvas Specification: Frameless NOTE: 1. The canvas painting will be rolled up and placed in a protective tube when it leaves the factory. 2. Due'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ize: 16x24 inch x2 Frameless, Abstract geometry art wall decor does not include a frame, roll it up and send it in a protective tube. You can match your favorite frame for installation or hang it dire'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'High-quality canvas: Mid century modern wall art adopts high-quality canvas and the most advanced Giclee printing technology. The picture is not easy to fade and the canvas is not easy to deform.'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Perfect decoration: Green aesthetics is the perfect living room decoration painting. It is the best choice for modern wall decoration. It can also be used as bathroom decoration painting, bedroom deco'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Morbid d\u00e9cor: This bleak canvas is best used for funerals, it conveys sorrow and dread perfectly.'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fast delivery: Minimalist gallery wall art is sent by Amazon and will reach your home quickly. If you are not satisfied, you can return it at any time. If you have other questions, you can also send u'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Package Dimensions'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-right: '17.3 x 1.65 x 1.65 inches'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Item Weight'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-right: '7.8 ounces'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Date First Available'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'April 22, 2021'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Subscribe'"
},
{
"i": 108,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "The text now describes tea bags while the images show a metal ignition module",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] 246.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Caffeinated Green Tea Bags Crisp Wow'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'HARLEY IGNTION MODULE SENSOR PICK UP'\n[7] 283.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Austintown, Ohio, United States'\n[8] HARLEY IGNTION MODULE SENSOR PICK UP, description: a person holding a metal plate with wires attached, at top-left\n[9] HARLEY IGNTION MODULE SENSOR PICK UP, description: a person holding a metal plate with wires attached to it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'GUY I GOT IT FROM SAID IT WORKED, I HAVEN'T TRIED IT SO I DON'T KNOW IF IT WORKS OR NOT, THAT WHY IT'S $10 CALL nur_martinez159@example.com DON'T ASK IF AVAILABLE WONT REPLY'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Jug, description: a brown jug sitting on a table, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '5.00 $'\n[14] Antique Bookcase, description: a wooden bookcase with a red vase on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[16] TABLE LAMP WITH HANGING CRYSTALS, description: a white lamp with a white shade on top, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '55.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '10.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Nur Martinez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Nur Martinez'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 109,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Labeling a modern Harley component as from 1475 B.C. introduces a temporal impossibility",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: '1475 B.C'\n[5] 296.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'HARLEY IGNTION MODULE SENSOR PICK UP'\n[6] 283.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Austintown, Ohio, United States'\n[7] HARLEY IGNTION MODULE SENSOR PICK UP, description: a person holding a metal plate with wires attached, at top-left\n[8] HARLEY IGNTION MODULE SENSOR PICK UP, description: a person holding a metal plate with wires attached to it, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'GUY I GOT IT FROM SAID IT WORKED, I HAVEN'T TRIED IT SO I DON'T KNOW IF IT WORKS OR NOT, THAT WHY IT'S $10 CALL nur_martinez159@example.com DON'T ASK IF AVAILABLE WONT REPLY'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Jug, description: a brown jug sitting on a table, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '5.00 $'\n[13] Antique Bookcase, description: a wooden bookcase with a red vase on it, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[15] TABLE LAMP WITH HANGING CRYSTALS, description: a white lamp with a white shade on top, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '55.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '10.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Nur Martinez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Nur Martinez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 110,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_2_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Numerical conflict with the dimensions in [9], which says 61\u00d724\u00d720.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] 202.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Huge 80ft x 2in Antique armoire'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Beautiful solid wood Antique armoire'\n[7] 323.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Westminster, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Beautiful solid wood Antique armoire, description: a wooden cabinet with doors in a room, at top-left\n[9] Beautiful solid wood Antique armoire, description: a wooden cabinet with doors in a room, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'I am selling a beautiful solid wood antique armoire. It is in excellent condition, and it is very clean. It measures 61tall, 24wide, and 20deep. If you have any questions, or you would like to come'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Punch Ladle MCM Scandinavian silver over copper, description: a silver serving tray with a wooden handle, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '55.00 $'\n[14] Panama Canal Calendar Plate 1915 Amburg, VA, description: a plate with a map of the united states, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[16] Leather Pouf Seat, description: a leather laptop case on a cowhide rug, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '186.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '110.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Matthew Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Matthew Lim'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 111,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_2_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Temporal inconsistency by labeling them from the future while [5] describes an \u201cAntique armoire.\u201d",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'From 3025'\n[5] 234.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Beautiful solid wood Antique armoire'\n[6] 323.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Westminster, Maryland, United States'\n[7] Beautiful solid wood Antique armoire, description: a wooden cabinet with doors in a room, at top-left\n[8] Beautiful solid wood Antique armoire, description: a wooden cabinet with doors in a room, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'I am selling a beautiful solid wood antique armoire. It is in excellent condition, and it is very clean. It measures 61tall, 24wide, and 20deep. If you have any questions, or you would like to come'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Punch Ladle MCM Scandinavian silver over copper, description: a silver serving tray with a wooden handle, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '55.00 $'\n[13] Panama Canal Calendar Plate 1915 Amburg, VA, description: a plate with a map of the united states, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[15] Leather Pouf Seat, description: a leather laptop case on a cowhide rug, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '186.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '110.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Matthew Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Matthew Lim'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 112,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The text now says \"White fridge\" but image (ID 7) clearly shows a black fridge",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Appliances'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'White fridge'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Mimi fridge'\n[7] 301.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Baltimore, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Mimi fridge, description: a black refrigerator with stickers on it, at top-left\n[9] Mimi fridge, description: a black refrigerator with stickers on it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'I need to get some my cats some food you can pick up at my door please'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Frigidaire cooler beer wine, description: a refrigerator with a glass door in a garage, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '800.00 $'\n[14] Portable Dishwasher, description: a dishwasher is being installed in a kitchen, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '400.00 $'\n[16] Ge electric stove used in good condition with 90days warranty, description: a stove with a stainless steel top and a black oven, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '375.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '160.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Ananya Thomas, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Ananya Thomas'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 113,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
19
],
"rationale": "Now ID5 states a $79 price while ID19 is $49, creating a direct textual conflict for the same item",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Appliances'\n[5] 294.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Keurig K2.0-400 Digital Coffee Maker - 79.00 $'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Keurig K2.0-400 Digital Coffee Brewing System'\n[7] 350.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Morgantown, West Virginia, United States'\n[8] Keurig K2.0-400 Digital Coffee Brewing System, description: a keurig coffee maker with a cup of coffee, at top-left\n[9] Keurig K2.0-400 Digital Coffee Brewing System, description: a keurig coffee maker with a cup of coffee, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Pick up in Morgantown near Mon General. Keurig 2.0 K400 Coffee Brewing System 70 oz water reservoir Keurig brewing system has a 2.4 Color Touch Display Brewer maintenance alerts Strength cont'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] like new char broil 5 burner grill, description: a black grill with two burners and a grill, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '275.00 $'\n[14] Bissell vacuum cleaner, description: a vacuum cleaner in a kitchen with hardwood floors, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '40.00 $'\n[16] DeWALT DXV09P 9-Gallon 5-HP Wet/Dry Shop Vacuum with New Power Head, description: dewalt dwv w/ hose for sale in san diego, ca, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '99.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '49.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Layla Garcia, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Layla Garcia'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 114,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_9_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The text now says \u201csteel tray\u201d while the image clearly shows a wooden plate",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'matador painting on steel tray'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'matador painting on wooden plate'\n[7] 330.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Leisure World, Maryland, United States'\n[8] matador painting on wooden plate, description: a wooden plate with a painting of a bullfighter, at top-left\n[9] matador painting on wooden plate, description: a wooden plate with a bullfighter on it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'hand painted wooden matador wall plaque'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] HANSON HEAVY DUTY STAPLER, description: a stapler with a blue handle on top, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '9.00 $'\n[14] 'Thou Shalt Not Covet' Serigraph Signed By Shmuel Katz, description: a painting of a woman sitting on a table, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '400.00 $'\n[16] Original Art, description: a painting of a woman holding a red bird, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '5000.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '15.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Deepika Jones, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Deepika Jones'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 115,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_10_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Element 9 says these are John Sexton posters, but the new title claims they are by Picasso.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] 360.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage Picasso Signed Art Print From Scenes In The City'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees'\n[7] 416.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of Forest Hills, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees poster, at top-left\n[9] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '#3 of a collection of four (4) separate SIGNED Posters by John Sexton, being offered on this site. From Listen To The Trees measuring 20W x 24H. This scene Forest In Springwas taken at Happy Isles,'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '25.00 $'\n[14] 3 WATERCOLORS BY PAULA VAUGHAN FRAMED SIGNED AND NUMBERED PRINTS, description: a painting of a quilt on the steps of a house, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45.00 $'\n[16] Mohair locks, description: a bag of white hair in a plastic bag, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '4.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '125.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] James Schneider, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'James Schneider'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 116,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_10_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "This category label clashes with ID5 referencing a vintage poster, creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'War-zone news'\n[5] 383.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees'\n[6] 416.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of Forest Hills, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees poster, at top-left\n[8] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: '#3 of a collection of four (4) separate SIGNED Posters by John Sexton, being offered on this site. From Listen To The Trees measuring 20W x 24H. This scene Forest In Springwas taken at Happy Isles,'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '25.00 $'\n[13] 3 WATERCOLORS BY PAULA VAUGHAN FRAMED SIGNED AND NUMBERED PRINTS, description: a painting of a quilt on the steps of a house, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '45.00 $'\n[15] Mohair locks, description: a bag of white hair in a plastic bag, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '4.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '125.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] James Schneider, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'James Schneider'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 117,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The text now claims a vacuum cleaner, but the image (ID 7) visibly shows a sewing machine",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Singer Vacuum Cleaner'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Singer Sewing Machine'\n[7] 412.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of Evans City, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at top-left\n[9] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Older sewing machine with sewing table with a side drawer. Machine appears to work, but I haven't used it - just turned it on and stepped on the pedal to see if it ran. It's been in storage for a nu'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Mermaid, description: a painting of a mermaid with a fish in her mouth, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '40.00 $'\n[14] Nativity Manger, description: a wooden bird feeder on a wooden deck, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[16] Vintage Domestic sewing machine, description: a vintage sewing machine is sitting on a table, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '20.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Alexander Fischer, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Alexander Fischer'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 118,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_11_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "The new, violent-sounding category is thematically incompatible with a sewing machine listing",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Chaos & carnage'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Singer Sewing Machine'\n[6] 412.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of Evans City, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at top-left\n[8] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Older sewing machine with sewing table with a side drawer. Machine appears to work, but I haven't used it - just turned it on and stepped on the pedal to see if it ran. It's been in storage for a nu'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Mermaid, description: a painting of a mermaid with a fish in her mouth, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '40.00 $'\n[13] Nativity Manger, description: a wooden bird feeder on a wooden deck, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[15] Vintage Domestic sewing machine, description: a vintage sewing machine is sitting on a table, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '20.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Alexander Fischer, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Alexander Fischer'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 119,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_11_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
20
],
"rationale": "The name now indicates a $75 cost, conflicting with the $25 price shown at ID 19",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Singer $75.00 Device!'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Singer Sewing Machine'\n[7] 412.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of Evans City, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at top-left\n[9] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Older sewing machine with sewing table with a side drawer. Machine appears to work, but I haven't used it - just turned it on and stepped on the pedal to see if it ran. It's been in storage for a nu'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Mermaid, description: a painting of a mermaid with a fish in her mouth, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '40.00 $'\n[14] Nativity Manger, description: a wooden bird feeder on a wooden deck, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[16] Vintage Domestic sewing machine, description: a vintage sewing machine is sitting on a table, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '20.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Alexander Fischer, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Alexander Fischer'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 120,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_12_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This new title contradicts the body text ([9]) describing it as an oil painting.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Very Early Career Original Artwork Pastel Drawing By Marylin Manson'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Very Early Career Original Artwork Oil Painting By Marylin Manson'\n[7] 338.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'North Potomac, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Very Early Career Original Artwork Oil Painting By Marylin Manson, description: a painting of a castle with a bridge, at top-left\n[9] Very Early Career Original Artwork Oil Painting By Marylin Manson, description: a painting of a castle with a bridge, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'This oil painting on Canvas was created by Marilyn Manson near the very beginning of Mr. Manson's painting career and very closely resembles the House Mr. Manson later purchased in California and in w'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] HANSON HEAVY DUTY STAPLER, description: a stapler with a blue handle on top, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '9.00 $'\n[14] 'Thou Shalt Not Covet' Serigraph Signed By Shmuel Katz, description: a painting of a woman sitting on a table, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '400.00 $'\n[16] Original Art, description: a painting of a woman holding a red bird, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '5000.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '2500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Linda Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Linda Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 121,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_13_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Contradicts the images (IDs 7, 8) labeled as signed and numbered",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] 370.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Hermansader Penn Square Print is not signed or numbered'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hermansader Penn Square Print signed and numbered'\n[7] 331.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Mount Joy, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] Hermansader Penn Square Print signed and numbered, description: a framed painting of a snowy scene, at top-left\n[9] Hermansader Penn Square Print signed and numbered, description: a framed painting of a city scene, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Selling a framed watercolor painting of Lancaster's Penn Square at Christmastime by Tom Hermansader. It is signed and numbered (162/495) from 1988. Originally bought at Hermansader galleries. In the'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '125.00 $'\n[14] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[16] Counted Cross Stitch Banners, description: two cross stitch banners with the words welcome home, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '700.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Linda Yamamoto, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Linda Yamamoto'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 122,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_13_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Misalignment between a painting category and a theme of warfare",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Dictators + war'\n[5] 341.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Hermansader Penn Square Print signed and numbered'\n[6] 331.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Mount Joy, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Hermansader Penn Square Print signed and numbered, description: a framed painting of a snowy scene, at top-left\n[8] Hermansader Penn Square Print signed and numbered, description: a framed painting of a city scene, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Selling a framed watercolor painting of Lancaster's Penn Square at Christmastime by Tom Hermansader. It is signed and numbered (162/495) from 1988. Originally bought at Hermansader galleries. In the'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '125.00 $'\n[13] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[15] Counted Cross Stitch Banners, description: two cross stitch banners with the words welcome home, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '700.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Linda Yamamoto, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Linda Yamamoto'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 123,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_14_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with ID 9 describing these items as African Ebony sculptures",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Arts + crafts'\n[5] 308.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Set Of Three Antique Chinese Porcelain Figurines'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Set Of Three Vintage Hand Carved African Sculptures'\n[7] 318.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Tysons Corner, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Set Of Three Vintage Hand Carved African Sculptures, description: a black wooden sculpture with a head and a torso, at top-left\n[9] Set Of Three Vintage Hand Carved African Sculptures, description: a black sculpture with a head and a tail, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Three beautiful examples of African hand carved Ebony sculptures. The last one pictured is 22 tall and is of a man, woman and two children.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] WILLOW BASKETS, description: a bunch of wicker baskets hanging from a car, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '3.00 $'\n[14] Baldor Heavy duty Jewelers polishing lathe, description: a small electric drill sitting on a wooden floor, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '300.00 $'\n[16] Elk Horn knife handle, description: a large horn with a measuring tape, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '12.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '450.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Jacob Kuznetsov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jacob Kuznetsov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 124,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_15_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Now ID 5 says 16-inch rims while ID 9 still says 14-inch rims, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Auto parts'\n[5] 236.0px-wide text span at top-left: '16 inch trailer rims'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: '14 inch trailer rims'\n[7] 246.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Green, Ohio, United States'\n[8] 14 inch trailer rims, description: four rims with holes on them, at top-left\n[9] 14 inch trailer rims, description: four rims with holes on them, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '14 inch trailer rims 80.00'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Grill, description: mercedes benz sl500 grille, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '90.00 $'\n[14] Holley double pumper base plate, description: a carburetor with a few parts on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '45.00 $'\n[16] Z bar pivot for 65-66 Mustang 289 V8 cars, description: two metal brackets with screws on them, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '80.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Matthew Nov\u00c3\u00a1k, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Matthew Nov\u00c3\u00a1k'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 125,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_16_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Text now says NISSAN ALTIMA but the image description (id 7) still indicates SUBARU LEGACY.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Auto parts'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'NISSAN ALTIMA'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'NISSAN ALTIMA'\n[7] 348.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Ellwood City, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] SUBARU LEGACY, description: a white van parked in a driveway, at top-left\n[9] SUBARU LEGACY, description: a white van parked in a driveway, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'I have a 2006 Subaru Legacy turbo GT WAGON. Very little rust. New turbo 10k miles ago. Just replaced front brakes and rotors. front struts and springs. The engine locked up so will need new engine if'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2000 Toyota 4runner, description: a white suv is parked in a garage, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '1200.00 $'\n[14] Trailer hitch, description: a metal ball with two metal balls on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '30.00 $'\n[16] Martin Senour paint cabinet, description: martin senour paints automotive finishes cabinet, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '45.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '700.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Anya Hernandez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Anya Hernandez'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 126,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_17_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "This mislabels the brand in [4] as \u201cChevy,\u201d conflicting with \u201cFord\u201d in [5].",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Chevy parts'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: ''68 Ford 3-Speed Toploader Manual Transmission Part Number C8AR-7006-B'\n[6] 273.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Bassett, Virginia, United States'\n[7] '68 Ford 3-Speed Toploader Manual Transmission Part Number C8AR-7006-B, description: a rusted out tractor with a rusted out engine, at top-left\n[8] '68 Ford 3-Speed Toploader Manual Transmission Part Number C8AR-7006-B, description: a rusted out tractor with a rusted out engine, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Vintage 1968 Ford 3-Speed Toploader Manual Transmission Casting Number C8AR-7006-B (1968 Ford Manual Transmission) - Date Code 8K15 (October 15, 1968) - With Tag RAN G1 KO79128 (Not Sure How To Decode'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2 Inch Lift Kit (REDUCED), description: two red metal rods sitting on the floor, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '25.00 $'\n[13] Original 1969 - 1970 Ford Mustang Mach 1 Non A/C Lower Dash With, description: a metal piece of equipment on the ground, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '200.00 $'\n[15] Genuine Toyota Corolla Carpet Floor Mats Front, Back and Trunk Black 2020-2023 L, description: a pair of black floor mats on the grass, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '150.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '175.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Manuel Mitchell, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Manuel Mitchell'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 127,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_18_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with the description in [9] claiming citrus and other scented notes.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty + health'\n[5] 225.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Fragrance-Free Bigelow Body Wash'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash'\n[7] 284.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Rustburg, Virginia, United States'\n[8] C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash, description: cd briggs & roberts shave cream, at top-left\n[9] C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash, description: cl o dickson barbershop - cl o dickson barbershop - cl, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'C. O Bigelow Barber 1607 Hair and Body Wash for Men. 8 fl. oz. Came from Bath and Body Works. Was a gift to my father-in-law and he never used it. Modern, Bright and refined. Our Elixir white blends c'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] ALL IN ONE Capsule Filling Machine Size 000 / 3 Makes 100 Caps Filler, description: a set of plastic containers with a red lid, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '75.00 $'\n[14] Wahl Deluxe Hair Cutting Kit with Trimmer and Case, description: a black box with several combs and combs, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '30.00 $'\n[16] Walker, description: a walker with wheels in a room, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '20.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] John Nowak, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'John Nowak'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 128,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_18_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the brand \"C. O Bigelow\" as \"Old Spice,\" contradicting the item title in [5].",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty + health'\n[5] 217.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash'\n[6] 284.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Rustburg, Virginia, United States'\n[7] C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash, description: cd briggs & roberts shave cream, at top-left\n[8] C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash, description: cl o dickson barbershop - cl o dickson barbershop - cl, at center-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Old Spice Co. Barber 1607 Hair and Body Wash for Men. 8 fl. oz. Came from Bath and Body Works. Was a gift to my father-in-law and he never used it. Modern, Bright and refined. Our Elixir white blends ...'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] ALL IN ONE Capsule Filling Machine Size 000 / 3 Makes 100 Caps Filler, description: a set of plastic containers with a red lid, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '75.00 $'\n[13] Wahl Deluxe Hair Cutting Kit with Trimmer and Case, description: a black box with several combs and combs, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '30.00 $'\n[15] Walker, description: a walker with wheels in a room, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '20.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] John Nowak, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'John Nowak'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 129,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_19_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 9 refers to a \u201cLancome\u201d palette, while ID 5 now calls it \u201cDior,\u201d mislabeling the product\u2019s brand",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty + health'\n[5] 345.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Dior Eye Shadow and Blush Palette - Glow Brand New'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lancome Eye Shadow and Blush Palette - Glow Brand New'\n[7] 282.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Roanoke, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Lancome Eye Shadow and Blush Palette - Glow Brand New, description: a makeup palette with a lot of different colors, at top-left\n[9] Lancome Eye Shadow and Blush Palette - Glow Brand New, description: a makeup palette with a lot of colors, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'FOR SALE. YES STILL AVAILABLE LANCOME EYE SHADOW AND BLUSH PALETTE - GLOW. 10 EYE SHADOWS AND 2 BLUSH WITH LARGE MIRROR ORIGINAL OWNER. FROM A PET FREE AND SMOKE FREE AND TEMPERATURE CO'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] ALL IN ONE Capsule Filling Machine Size 000 / 3 Makes 100 Caps Filler, description: a set of plastic containers with a red lid, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '75.00 $'\n[14] C. O. Bigelow Hair and Body Wash, description: cl o dickson barbershop - cl o dickson barbershop - cl, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[16] Wahl Deluxe Hair Cutting Kit with Trimmer and Case, description: a black box with several combs and combs, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '30.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '20.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Haruto Sharma, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Haruto Sharma'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 130,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_20_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The text in [5] contradicts the image in [7], which plainly shows a step machine.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Beauty + health'\n[5] 210.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'MINI STEPPER stationary bike!'\n[6] 319.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Cresaptown, Maryland, United States'\n[7] MINI STEPPER work out machine, description: a stepper with a cord attached to it, at top-left\n[8] MINI STEPPER work out machine, description: a pair of steppers with handles, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Mini Stepper Step Machine w/ Resistance Bands and LCD Monitor with Original Box Simulates the act of climbing stairs Adjustable Mini Stepper with LCD Monitor Stepping Machine Hydraulic/resistance b'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Tyvek 1222A Non-Woven Polyethylene(HDPE) Non Surgical Gown- Box of 140, description: a woman wearing a white surgical gown, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '40.00 $'\n[13] Viktor & Rolf Flowerbomb Bomblicious Perfumed SHOWER GEL 200ml 6.7oz MSRP $56, description: victoria's secret body wash with a black bow, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '30.00 $'\n[15] New Conair 1875 Watt Hair Dryer, description: a blue hair dryer, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '8.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[20] Olivia Wu, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Olivia Wu'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[24] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[25] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 131,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_22_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The image (ID 7) is labeled as \u201cKHS Flite 720 Womens,\u201d but the text (ID 5) now says \u201cBianchi Flite 720 Mens,\u201d mislabeling the brand and model.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Bikes'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Bianchi Flite 720 Mens'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'KHS Flite 720 Womens'\n[7] 280.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Elkton, Maryland, United States'\n[8] KHS Flite 720 Womens, description: a bike parked in front of a house, at top-left\n[9] KHS Flite 720 Womens, description: a bike parked in front of a house, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Carbon frame and carbon fork makes this medium-sized women's bike super light - just 22.1 pounds! Well built, but light as a feather. The story on this bike: New stock in 2012 for previous owner'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Schwinn Superior, description: a bike leaning against a wall in a garage, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '65.00 $'\n[14] Bianchi Super Pista track bike 59 cm, description: a white bike leaning against a blue wall, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '2000.00 $'\n[16] trek 1000 alpha alum 24/ 60cm, description: a bike sitting on a chair in the grass, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '340.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '475.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Ava Suzuki, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Ava Suzuki'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 132,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_23_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This new text says \"SteelX\" whereas ID 9 describes a carbon frame",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Bikes'\n[5] 242.0px-wide text span at top-left: '54cm Wilier Triestina SteelX Road Bike'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '54cm Wilier Triestina Carbon Road Bike'\n[7] 306.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Falls Church, Virginia, United States'\n[8] 54cm Wilier Triestina Carbon Road Bike, description: a bike parked outside of a garage, at top-left\n[9] 54cm Wilier Triestina Carbon Road Bike, description: a bike leaning against a garage door, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Italian flair with Japanese tech carbon road rocket! Wilier Triestina Izoard XP full carbon with Shimano 105 2x10 rock solid drivetrain. Shifts crisply and stops on a dime. Super low mileage, like new'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Batman Bicycle / Petal Go Kart. Awesome, description: a black go kart sitting on the sidewalk, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '60.00 $'\n[14] 24 Girls Nishiki Pueblo 24 Mountain Bike For Sale, description: a blue and black mountain bike parked in front of a white van, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[16] Trek step though, 20 frame. Tuned. Excellent condition, description: a bike with a seat and handlebars, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '225.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1000.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Emily Kuznetsov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Emily Kuznetsov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 133,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_25_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with the detailed description in [9] stating a 21-speed mountain bike.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Bikes'\n[5] 291.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Giant Ebony - single speed City Bicycle Refit X!'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Specialized HardRock - medium size Mountain Bike'\n[7] 275.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Sterling, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Specialized HardRock - medium size Mountain Bike, description: a blue mountain bike leaning against a fence, at top-left\n[9] Specialized HardRock - medium size Mountain Bike, description: a blue mountain bike leaning against a fence, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Specialized HardRock 21 speed mountain bike. Everything works great on the bike and it is very comfortable to ride with the front Rock Shox shock suspension. The wheels are 26 inches and the tires are'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 54cm Wilier Triestina Carbon Road Bike, description: a bike leaning against a garage door, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '1000.00 $'\n[14] Specialized Ruby women's full carbon road bike, description: a white bike is parked in a room, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '1800.00 $'\n[16] Vintage Schwinn Breeze Womens Bike Bicycle Single Speed Coaster Brake, description: a red bicycle parked in front of a garage, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '120.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '125.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Maria Sidorov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Maria Sidorov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 134,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_25_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "The page heading says \"Grave,\" which is contextually incompatible with the bike listing in [5].",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Grave'\n[5] 317.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Specialized HardRock - medium size Mountain Bike'\n[6] 275.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Sterling, Virginia, United States'\n[7] Specialized HardRock - medium size Mountain Bike, description: a blue mountain bike leaning against a fence, at top-left\n[8] Specialized HardRock - medium size Mountain Bike, description: a blue mountain bike leaning against a fence, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Specialized HardRock 21 speed mountain bike. Everything works great on the bike and it is very comfortable to ride with the front Rock Shox shock suspension. The wheels are 26 inches and the tires are'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 54cm Wilier Triestina Carbon Road Bike, description: a bike leaning against a garage door, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '1000.00 $'\n[13] Specialized Ruby women's full carbon road bike, description: a white bike is parked in a room, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '1800.00 $'\n[15] Vintage Schwinn Breeze Womens Bike Bicycle Single Speed Coaster Brake, description: a red bicycle parked in front of a garage, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '120.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '125.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Maria Sidorov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Maria Sidorov'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 135,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_26_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "The text now states a 2020 boat while images still refer to 1990, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Boats'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '2020 wellcraft V20'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '1990 wellcraft V20'\n[7] 339.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Collinsburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 1990 wellcraft V20, description: a boat with a cover on it parked in a driveway, at top-left\n[9] 1990 wellcraft V20, description: a boat with a cover on it parked in a driveway, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'I did not want to sell this boat but i purchased it from my grandmother when my grandfather passed away. He was an avid fisherman up on Lake Erie. He used this boat for most of its life. Very well mai'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 1986 nova xl 23ft, description: a boat docked at a dock with a dock, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '5500.00 $'\n[14] 2011 Yamaha 242 Limited S - Fresh Water Boat, description: a boat is parked in a parking lot, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '22000.00 $'\n[16] 1995 Stingray zp586 with wakeboard tower, description: a man is loading a boat onto a trailer, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '7500.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '2500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Li Moore, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Li Moore'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 136,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_26_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The somber \u201cWar Funeral\u201d label is thematically incompatible with a boat sale listing, introducing a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'War Funeral'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Boats'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '1990 wellcraft V20'\n[6] 339.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Collinsburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] 1990 wellcraft V20, description: a boat with a cover on it parked in a driveway, at top-left\n[8] 1990 wellcraft V20, description: a boat with a cover on it parked in a driveway, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'I did not want to sell this boat but i purchased it from my grandmother when my grandfather passed away. He was an avid fisherman up on Lake Erie. He used this boat for most of its life. Very well mai'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 1986 nova xl 23ft, description: a boat docked at a dock with a dock, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '5500.00 $'\n[13] 2011 Yamaha 242 Limited S - Fresh Water Boat, description: a boat is parked in a parking lot, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '22000.00 $'\n[15] 1995 Stingray zp586 with wakeboard tower, description: a man is loading a boat onto a trailer, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '7500.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '2500.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Li Moore, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Li Moore'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 137,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_27_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The text now calls it a \u201cWhite Jeep Wrangler\u201d while the image shows a Jet Ski, creating a factual contradiction",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Boats'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'White Jeep Wrangler'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Yamaha FX140 Jet Ski'\n[7] 350.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Morgantown, West Virginia, United States'\n[8] Yamaha FX140 Jet Ski, description: a jet ski is parked in a driveway, at top-left\n[9] Yamaha FX140 Jet Ski, description: a jet ski is parked in a driveway, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Great Deal. 2004 Yamaha FX140 Jet Ski. Great shape, rarely ridden. Displacement CC: 998; Three riders, HP: 140, Fuel: 18.5 Top speed: 56 Must see. Includes trailer.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Boat dock 55 gallon barrels white, description: a large pile of white barrels in a yard, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '15.00 $'\n[14] life time layaks, description: a red kayak is sitting on the ground in a grassy area, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '300.00 $'\n[16] 2002 Chaparral 260ssi powered with 375hp Volvo 8.1., description: a boat with a trailer parked in a parking lot, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '16700.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '3500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Ethan Hussein, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Ethan Hussein'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 138,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_28_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "Creates a numerical conflict on the boat\u2019s length from 23ft to 27ft",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Boats'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '1986 nova xl 27ft'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '1986 nova xl 23ft'\n[7] 311.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Verona, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 1986 nova xl 23ft, description: a boat docked at the docks, at top-left\n[9] 1986 nova xl 23ft, description: a boat docked at a dock with a dock, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Boat is in good shape new engine installed in 2019 has 80 hours on it trailer all tires and brakes system all redone in 2019 and inspected'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2011 Yamaha 242 Limited S - Fresh Water Boat, description: a boat is parked in a parking lot, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '22000.00 $'\n[14] 1988 Wellcraft San Remo, description: a boat docked at the dock, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '49900.00 $'\n[16] Kayak, Surfboard, paddle board etc, description: two grey car mats on the ground, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '5500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Liu Hassan, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Liu Hassan'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 139,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_30_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "Now the heading says \u201c4 books,\u201d but the image (7) and text (9) show or mention only 3, creating a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Books'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '4 Do It Yourself Books'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '3 Do It Yourself Books'\n[7] 346.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'West Milton, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 3 Do It Yourself Books, description: three books on gardening on a counter, at top-left\n[9] 3 Do It Yourself Books, description: three books on gardening on a counter, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '3 DIY paperback books. One is by Sunset on Sheds and Garages. 2 are from Ortho on Container Gardening and Beds and Borders. They show plans and how-to information. Plenty of pictures. All are like new'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '125.00 $'\n[14] Encyclopedia of Ancient Christianity 3 Volume (New), description: a set of books with the title encyclopedia of ancient christianity, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '400.00 $'\n[16] Books - 500 - 1000, description: a room with many books on shelves, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '1.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '5.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Yasmin Popov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Yasmin Popov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 140,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_32_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The title now claims \u201cadults-only horror\u201d while the description still states these are middle grade kids books.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Books'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Adults-Only Horror Books'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Young Kids Reader Books'\n[7] 306.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Falls Church, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Young Kids Reader Books, description: a group of books with a boy and a girl, at top-left\n[9] Young Kids Reader Books, description: a collection of books with a boy and a girl, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Five middle grades kids books, two hard cover and three soft cover, in very good condition. From a smoke and pet free home. Title include: - Wonder, by RJ Palacio - Wandmaker, by Ed Masessa - The W'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Audio Books, description: a shelf full of dvds and other items, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '3.00 $'\n[14] Skylanders Books, description: skylanders - the official guide, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '26.00 $'\n[16] Nightmares! by Jason Segel and Kristen Miller, description: three books by jonas sgel, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '41.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '31.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Li Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Li Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 141,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_34_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "Now the title says Toyota Camry, but the image (ID 7) and other text reference a Honda Accord, mislabeling the car brand.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 260.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2011 Toyota Camry Special Edition Sedan'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan'\n[7] 346.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan, description: the silver honda accord is parked in a lot, at top-left\n[9] 2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan, description: the silver honda accord is parked in a lot, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'SPECIAL EDITION! One of the most reliable sedans on the market, this 2011 Honda Accord SE 2.4L Sedan with many great features including heated and power leather seats, auxiliary input, aluminum wheels'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2008 F250, description: a blue truck is parked in a field, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '12000.00 $'\n[14] 2012 Hyundai Elantra GLS, description: the silver hyundai elantra is parked in a lot, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '7500.00 $'\n[16] 2012 Ford Focus Se Hatchback, description: 2013 ford focus for sale at mcdonald's in st paul mn, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '6500.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '7000.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Rahul Thomas, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Rahul Thomas'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 142,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_34_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "This category heading about small pets clashes with the actual Honda sedan listing in ID 5, creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Kittens + puppies'\n[5] 263.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan'\n[6] 346.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] 2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan, description: the silver honda accord is parked in a lot, at top-left\n[8] 2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan, description: the silver honda accord is parked in a lot, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'SPECIAL EDITION! One of the most reliable sedans on the market, this 2011 Honda Accord SE 2.4L Sedan with many great features including heated and power leather seats, auxiliary input, aluminum wheels'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2008 F250, description: a blue truck is parked in a field, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '12000.00 $'\n[13] 2012 Hyundai Elantra GLS, description: the silver hyundai elantra is parked in a lot, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '7500.00 $'\n[15] 2012 Ford Focus Se Hatchback, description: 2013 ford focus for sale at mcdonald's in st paul mn, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '6500.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '7000.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Rahul Thomas, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Rahul Thomas'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 143,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_36_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The text now names it a Toyota Corolla while the images [7] show a Ford Escape, creating a mislabeling conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '2006 toyota corolla limited'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2006 ford escape limited'\n[7] 269.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Bear, Delaware, United States'\n[8] 2006 ford escape limited, description: a silver suv parked in a parking lot, at top-left\n[9] 2006 ford escape limited, description: a silver ford escape is parked in a parking lot, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Want a solid midsize SUV That runs excellent fully loaded with power seats heated leather also have power sunroof keyless entry. Plus the vehicle runs and drives perfect. It has 150k miles clean titl'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2011 Silverado 3500HD utility body truck, description: a white truck parked in the fall leaves, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '16200.00 $'\n[14] 2009 vw passat, description: a white volkswagen passat parked in front of a gas station, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '3800.00 $'\n[16] 2008 Honda Accord, Excellent Condition, description: a green honda accord parked on the side of the road, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '6450.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '2650.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Robert Nowak, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Robert Nowak'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 144,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_37_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This causes a factual conflict: ID 9 still describes a Samsung Galaxy A52, but ID 5 now states it is a refurbished Apple iPhone 7.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cell phones'\n[5] 292.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'REFURBISHED Apple iPhone 7 ~LOCKED gsm'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'BRAND NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 ~UNLOCKED'\n[7] 270.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Vienna, Virginia, United States'\n[8] BRAND NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 ~UNLOCKED, description: a box with a phone inside it, at top-left\n[9] BRAND NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 ~UNLOCKED, description: a box with a phone inside it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Brand NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 Unlocked to work on carrier'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] iPhone 15 Pro Max Unlocked Natural Titanium 256GB Brand New, description: an apple iphone 11 in a bag on a table, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '1350.00 $'\n[14] OtterBox Fre IPhone 14/15 Plus, description: a purple iphone 11 case with a pink and purple design, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[16] Apple ultra watch, description: an apple watch with a charger and a cable, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '350.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '150.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Anastasia Sidorov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Anastasia Sidorov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 145,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_38_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The new title conflicts with the detailed description in [9] stating AppleCare+ coverage and an included silicon case.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cell phones'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Like New! Apple iPhone 13 Mini Unlocked, no AppleCare+ & no Apple Case'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Like New! Apple iPhone 13 Mini Unlocked w/AppleCare+ & Apple Case'\n[7] 270.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Reston, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Like New! Apple iPhone 13 Mini Unlocked w/AppleCare+ & Apple Case, description: two pink iphones are sitting in their boxes, at top-left\n[9] Like New! Apple iPhone 13 Mini Unlocked w/AppleCare+ & Apple Case, description: two pink iphones in their boxes, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Absolutely like new Apple iPhone 13 Mini with 5G capabilities, 256GB in the best color - Pink. Model number MLHV3LL/A Apple part number A2481. *** Apple has now discontinued the iPhone Mini, so the'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] BRAND NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 ~UNLOCKED, description: a box with a phone inside it, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '150.00 $'\n[14] Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked, description: samsung galaxy a20 black - samsung galaxy a20 black - samsung galaxy a, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '450.00 $'\n[16] iPhone 15 Pro Max Unlocked Natural Titanium 256GB Brand New, description: an apple iphone 11 in a bag on a table, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '1350.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '795.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Jacob Ito, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jacob Ito'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 146,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_39_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Listing [9] states the phone is factory unlocked for all carriers, while [5] now says \u201cVerizon only.\u201d",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cell phones'\n[5] 261.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'iPhone XR 64gb Verizon only ID: 43126-1'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'iPhone XR 64gb Unlocked ID: 43126-1'\n[7] 325.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'South Bel Air, Maryland, United States'\n[8] iPhone XR 64gb Unlocked ID: 43126-1, description: an iphone xr on a stand with a screen, at top-left\n[9] iPhone XR 64gb Unlocked ID: 43126-1, description: an iphone xr on a stand with a screen, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Willing to accept payments of $14 weekly, $59 monthly, or $269 outright. Will also consider tech trade-in options, just ask! Factory Unlocked, tested and ready to activate on all carriers See pics'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] iPhone 11 64gb Unlocked ID: 26395, description: an iphone xr on a stand with a screen, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '65.00 $'\n[14] I phone 14 pro max, description: a box with an iphone x in it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '700.00 $'\n[16] iPhone 11 64gb Green, description: an iphone xr in its box, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '180.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '59.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] James Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'James Lim'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 147,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_39_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the phone section as \u201cSamsung TVs,\u201d conflicting with the iPhone listing at [5].",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Samsung TVs'\n[5] 242.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'iPhone XR 64gb Unlocked ID: 43126-1'\n[6] 325.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'South Bel Air, Maryland, United States'\n[7] iPhone XR 64gb Unlocked ID: 43126-1, description: an iphone xr on a stand with a screen, at top-left\n[8] iPhone XR 64gb Unlocked ID: 43126-1, description: an iphone xr on a stand with a screen, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Willing to accept payments of $14 weekly, $59 monthly, or $269 outright. Will also consider tech trade-in options, just ask! Factory Unlocked, tested and ready to activate on all carriers See pics'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] iPhone 11 64gb Unlocked ID: 26395, description: an iphone xr on a stand with a screen, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '65.00 $'\n[13] I phone 14 pro max, description: a box with an iphone x in it, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '700.00 $'\n[15] iPhone 11 64gb Green, description: an iphone xr in its box, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '180.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '59.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] James Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'James Lim'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 148,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_40_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "ID 7\u2019s image shows a Samsung phone, but the text (ID 5) now claims it\u2019s an iPhone, creating a brand mismatch.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cell phones'\n[5] 287.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Brand New Apple iPhone 15 256GB Unlocked'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked'\n[7] 286.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Arlington, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked, description: samsung galaxy a20 - black - gsm - gsm - gsm -, at top-left\n[9] Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked, description: samsung galaxy a20 black - samsung galaxy a20 black - samsung galaxy a, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Looks 9/10 and is fully functional Factory Unlocked Worldwide meaning it will work with any Cell phone provider Price is firm ... willing to consider close offers near my price range, No Trades'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] BRAND NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 ~UNLOCKED, description: a box with a phone inside it, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '150.00 $'\n[14] iPhone 15 Pro Max Unlocked Natural Titanium 256GB Brand New, description: an apple iphone 11 in a bag on a table, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '1350.00 $'\n[16] Samsung A52 5G (128gb), description: a person holding a samsung galaxy s20 phone, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '300.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '450.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Zoe Nowak, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Zoe Nowak'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 149,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_40_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "\u201cFuneral rites\u201d is thematically at odds with a listing about phones, creating a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Funeral rites'\n[5] 269.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked'\n[6] 286.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Arlington, Virginia, United States'\n[7] Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked, description: samsung galaxy a20 - black - gsm - gsm - gsm -, at top-left\n[8] Galaxy S22 128GB Like New and Unlocked, description: samsung galaxy a20 black - samsung galaxy a20 black - samsung galaxy a, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Looks 9/10 and is fully functional Factory Unlocked Worldwide meaning it will work with any Cell phone provider Price is firm ... willing to consider close offers near my price range, No Trades'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] BRAND NEW Samsung Galaxy A52 ~UNLOCKED, description: a box with a phone inside it, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '150.00 $'\n[13] iPhone 15 Pro Max Unlocked Natural Titanium 256GB Brand New, description: an apple iphone 11 in a bag on a table, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '1350.00 $'\n[15] Samsung A52 5G (128gb), description: a person holding a samsung galaxy s20 phone, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '300.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '450.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Zoe Nowak, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Zoe Nowak'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 150,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_41_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "Creates a tonal mismatch: \u201cHate Crimes!\u201d clashes with the page\u2019s normal sales context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Hate Crimes!'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Rare Terex (GM) Toy Trucks'\n[6] 301.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Portage Lakes, Ohio, United States'\n[7] Rare Terex (GM) Toy Trucks, description: three boxes of tebets tsbb ts830 ts830 ts830 ts, at top-left\n[8] Rare Terex (GM) Toy Trucks, description: tebo ts-450 ts-450 ts-450 ts-450 ts-450 t, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Rare Terex (GM) 1:40 Scale Die Cast Toy Trucks are new in boxes. I think these were made in the early 70's and only GM employees could buy them. I was asking $250.00 each or best offer. Call me at che'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Steelers mirror collectible, description: a framed pittsburgh steelers poster is on a table, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '150.00 $'\n[13] Stanley 150th Anniversary Pocket Measuring Tape, description: stanley cigarette box with a cigarette in it, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[15] BLACKHAWK NIGHTEDGE ( the devils tongue) knife, description: a knife with a black handle and a black handle, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '95.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '250.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Chen Rodriguez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Chen Rodriguez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 151,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_42_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The new product name calls it a \"coffee mug\" while the description still describes a plush snowman",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Collectibles'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Hallmark Coffee Mug'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman'\n[7] 284.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Rustburg, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman, description: a snowman is playing a piano on a table, at top-left\n[9] Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman, description: a snowman is playing a piano on a table, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '2005 Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman. Plush snowman, animated singing and playing 3 songs which are Let it Snow, Jingle Bell Rock and Holly Jolly Christmas. Uses 4 AA batteries. Snowman moves around w'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Vintage Gemmy Dancing Flower Pot, description: a vase with flowers in it on a table, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '25.00 $'\n[14] 1940s ARISTOCRAT ONE QUART MILK BOTTLE - Philadelphia, PA, description: a bottle of milk sitting on a wooden floor, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '20.00 $'\n[16] 7 Eleven Camel Sign, description: a clock with a pool table and a pool table, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '45.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Linda Morozov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Linda Morozov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 152,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_42_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
9
],
"rationale": "The new category \u201cBattle Scenes\u201d contrasts starkly with the festive snowman description",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Battle Scenes'\n[5] 214.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman'\n[6] 284.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Rustburg, Virginia, United States'\n[7] Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman, description: a snowman is playing a piano on a table, at top-left\n[8] Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman, description: a snowman is playing a piano on a table, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: '2005 Hallmark Piano Playing Snowman. Plush snowman, animated singing and playing 3 songs which are Let it Snow, Jingle Bell Rock and Holly Jolly Christmas. Uses 4 AA batteries. Snowman moves around w'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Vintage Gemmy Dancing Flower Pot, description: a vase with flowers in it on a table, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '25.00 $'\n[13] 1940s ARISTOCRAT ONE QUART MILK BOTTLE - Philadelphia, PA, description: a bottle of milk sitting on a wooden floor, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '20.00 $'\n[15] 7 Eleven Camel Sign, description: a clock with a pool table and a pool table, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '45.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Linda Morozov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Linda Morozov'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 153,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_43_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "A holiday doll listing appears under a somber \u201cObituaries\u201d category",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Obituaries'\n[5] 254.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Happy Holidays Barbie ( Special Edition )'\n[6] 364.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'East Rochester, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Happy Holidays Barbie ( Special Edition ), description: a barbie doll in a box on a wooden table, at top-left\n[8] Happy Holidays Barbie ( Special Edition ), description: a christmas ornament in a box with a gold dress, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Happy Holidays Barbie Special Edition 1996 $10.00'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 1950's Lionel 1120 O gauge set and Plasticville town, description: a toy train engine is shown on a white surface, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '120.00 $'\n[13] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '125.00 $'\n[15] NGC 2.5oz. & 5oz. .999 Silver Coins, description: the silver coin is on a wooden table, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '400.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '10.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Layla Abdullah, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Layla Abdullah'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 154,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_44_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The title now claims it's perfect and brand new, while ID 9 says it's broken and sold for parts, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Computer parts'\n[5] 392.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2017 MacBook Pro 13 inch works perfectly - brand new in box'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2017 MacBook Pro 13 inch doesn't work - selling for parts'\n[7] 355.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'North Kensington, Maryland, United States'\n[8] 2017 MacBook Pro 13 inch doesn't work - selling for parts, description: an apple macbook pro laptop on a floral bed, at top-left\n[9] 2017 MacBook Pro 13 inch doesn't work - selling for parts, description: macbook pro 13, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Laptop stopped working. I took it to Apple, but it was too expensive to fix. I can provide the work order from Apple to who is interested. So, selling the laptop for parts. Or, if someone can buy it a'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] CRAMPING TOOL CUTS, STRIPS AND CRIMPS NEW, description: a package of staples crimping tool, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '35.00 $'\n[14] Wired Dell Keyboard & Mouse, description: a black computer keyboard on a desk, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[16] Brother TN-570 sealed, description: brother tn-570 toner cartridge, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '30.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '60.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Linda Vorobev, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Linda Vorobev'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 155,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_46_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
7
],
"rationale": "Element 7 clearly shows a motherboard image, but ID 4 now says \"Funeral services,\" creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Funeral services'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'CPU-MB-RAM-GPU'\n[6] 281.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Buckhall, Virginia, United States'\n[7] CPU-MB-RAM-GPU, description: asus ms-a75v mb - ms-a75v, at top-left\n[8] CPU-MB-RAM-GPU, description: asus ms-a75v evo motherboard, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'CPU- AMD FX-8350 (4.33 ghz, 8 core) MB- ASUS M5A97EVO (ATX) RAM- 16GB* Corsair DDR3 (4x4gb) GPU- NVIDIA GEFORCE GT430 Works great. Just upgraded to more powerful system.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Computer luggage, description: a black suitcase with wheels on the floor, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '9.00 $'\n[13] TP-Link Archer AX3200, description: a black router with four antennas, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '100.00 $'\n[15] Dell Apple HP Computer repair pc gaming laptop cheap best desktop, description: a man is working on a laptop with a laptop repair kit, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '99.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[20] Priya Rao, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Priya Rao'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[24] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[25] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 156,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_46_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 9 says the CPU has 8 cores, but ID 5 now indicates 4 cores, introducing a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Computer parts'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'CPU-QuadCore-MB-RAM-GPU'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'CPU-MB-RAM-GPU'\n[7] 281.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Buckhall, Virginia, United States'\n[8] CPU-MB-RAM-GPU, description: asus ms-a75v mb - ms-a75v, at top-left\n[9] CPU-MB-RAM-GPU, description: asus ms-a75v evo motherboard, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'CPU- AMD FX-8350 (4.33 ghz, 8 core) MB- ASUS M5A97EVO (ATX) RAM- 16GB* Corsair DDR3 (4x4gb) GPU- NVIDIA GEFORCE GT430 Works great. Just upgraded to more powerful system.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Computer luggage, description: a black suitcase with wheels on the floor, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '9.00 $'\n[14] TP-Link Archer AX3200, description: a black router with four antennas, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '100.00 $'\n[16] Dell Apple HP Computer repair pc gaming laptop cheap best desktop, description: a man is working on a laptop with a laptop repair kit, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '99.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Priya Rao, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Priya Rao'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 157,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_47_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The \u201cBrand New\u201d claim in ID 5 conflicts with the \u201cUsed\u201d description in ID 9",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Computer parts'\n[5] 207.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'TP-Link N600 Brand New Router'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'TP-Link TL-WDR3600 Wireless Router'\n[7] 291.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Newark, Delaware, United States'\n[8] TP-Link TL-WDR3600 Wireless Router, description: tp-link n600 wireless router in the box, at top-left\n[9] TP-Link TL-WDR3600 Wireless Router, description: tp-link ne600 wireless router in the box, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Used, as pictured, works fine Simultaneous 2.4GHz 300Mbps and 5GHz 300Mbps connections for 600Mbps of total available bandwidth 2*USB Ports : Easily share printers, files or media with your friend'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] EVGA GeForce GTX-1060 6GB Graphics Cards!, description: evga scc gtx 1080ti ssd gtx 1080ti for sale in, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '125.00 $'\n[14] PNY 1TB SSD USB Storage, description: a small portable hard drive connected to a laptop, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '55.00 $'\n[16] Fractal Node 804 Micro ATX computer case, description: a black box sitting on a table, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '100.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '40.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Hannah Petrov, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Hannah Petrov'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 158,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_48_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "The heading now says \"Chromebook,\" but the detailed description (ID 9) still describes a MacBook Air, creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Computers'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Chromebook'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Macbook Air'\n[7] 330.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Leisure World, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Macbook Air, description: a laptop with a world map on it, at top-left\n[9] Macbook Air, description: a laptop computer with a screen on it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'EXCELLENT CONDITION: Factory reset: Catalina operating system installed INCLUDES Mac Book Air Charger, AC 45W Magnetic T-Tip Power Adapter Charger Apple MacBook Air Core i5 1.3 13-Inch (Mid-'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] WESTINGHOUSE TV, MONITOR, description: a flat screen television mounted on a wall, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '120.00 $'\n[14] Hp Pavilian P6610f / New digital hard drive ssd, description: hp tower pc with a black screen, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '80.00 $'\n[16] Acer 315 15.6 Celeron 4GB/32GB Chromebook, 15.6 HD Display, description: a box with a yellow label on it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '150.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '250.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Robert Suzuki, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Robert Suzuki'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 159,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_49_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The product name now suggests Mac OS while the description in id=9 says Windows 10, creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Computers'\n[5] 296.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Hp Pavilian P6610f / Mac OS preinstalls, device'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Hp Pavilian P6610f / New digital hard drive ssd'\n[7] 298.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Frederick, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Hp Pavilian P6610f / New digital hard drive ssd, description: hp tower pc with a black tower, at top-left\n[9] Hp Pavilian P6610f / New digital hard drive ssd, description: hp tower pc with a black screen, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'I have fully set up with fresh install of Windows 10 pro 64 bit. Installed with Defender Anti-Virus / Office 2016 suite installed / Malwarebytes / Fox it PDF reader / Google Chrome Browser / Open shel'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Acer 315 15.6 Celeron 4GB/32GB Chromebook, 15.6 HD Display, description: a box with a yellow label on it, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '150.00 $'\n[14] Surface Pro 7 + Everything you need!, description: a microsoft surface pro laptop on a desk, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '425.00 $'\n[16] Surface Pro 7, description: a blue computer screen with a blue swirl on it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '350.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '80.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Deepika Rivera, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Deepika Rivera'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 160,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_50_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Mislabeling Samsung as Apple conflicts with ID 9's mention of a Samsung laptop",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Computers'\n[5] 265.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Back to School: Apple - MacBook Pro 13.3'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Back to School: Samsung - Galaxy Book Pro 13.3'\n[7] 326.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Chevy Chase, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Back to School: Samsung - Galaxy Book Pro 13.3, description: a box with an ipad pro in it, at top-left\n[9] Back to School: Samsung - Galaxy Book Pro 13.3, description: a box with an ipad pro in it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Samsung - Galaxy Book Pro 13.3 AMOLED - Intel Core i5-1135G7 Win11 8GB Memory 256GB SSD Mystic Blue New in box. Purchased in February, not used other than install/configure Windows. A beaut'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Macbook Air, description: a laptop computer with a screen on it, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '250.00 $'\n[14] WESTINGHOUSE TV, MONITOR, description: a flat screen television mounted on a wall, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '120.00 $'\n[16] Hp Pavilian P6610f / New digital hard drive ssd, description: hp tower pc with a black screen, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '80.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '595.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Li Miller, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Li Miller'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 161,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_51_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The product is labeled \u201cBose\u201d in ID 7\u2019s image description, but now ID 5 says \u201cSony.\u201d",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Electronics'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sony Noise Cancelling Wireless Bluetooth Headphones 700, with Alexa.'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Bose Noise Cancelling Wireless Bluetooth Headphones 700, with Alexa.'\n[7] 294.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Centreville, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Bose Noise Cancelling Wireless Bluetooth Headphones 700, with Alexa., description: bose noise cancelling headphones, at top-left\n[9] Bose Noise Cancelling Wireless Bluetooth Headphones 700, with Alexa., description: bose noise cancelling headphones, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Beautiful Bose noise, cancellation, headphones. Very different from any other experience. Serious buyers only Keywords: music, beat, song, headphones, wireless, head phone'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] New RING Doorbell Pro 2, description: ring smart lock in a box, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '100.00 $'\n[14] New Apple iPhone Lightning to USB Cable w USB Power Adapter Charger, description: a white apple lightning cable and charger on a table, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[16] Audio/video equipment, description: a table with various cables and wires on it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '1.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '299.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Rahul Lopez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Rahul Lopez'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 162,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_52_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 9 references a \u201cRealistic Bookshelf Stereo\u201d while ID 5 is changed to say \u201cPanasonic,\u201d misattributing the product\u2019s identity.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Electronics'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Vintage Panasonic Stereo'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage Realistic Stereo'\n[7] 246.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Akron, Ohio, United States'\n[8] Vintage Realistic Stereo, description: two stereo receivers on top of a wooden table, at top-left\n[9] Vintage Realistic Stereo, description: two stereo receivers sitting on top of a wooden table, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Vintage 1970's Realistic Bookshelf Stereo Amplifier and Tuner. All works good but needs speakers. I was asking $85.00 for all. Call me at (555) 396-2574 . Please leave name and number.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Disc Clone, description: a grey computer with a disc clone on top, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '85.00 $'\n[14] Macbook Air brand new, description: a white box with a white label on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '845.00 $'\n[16] Brand new ipad pro!, description: a book with a purple cover on it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '900.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Anastasia Khan, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Anastasia Khan'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 163,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_56_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This renames \u201cCraftsman snowblower\u201d to \u201cHonda generator set,\u201d misattributing the product\u2019s identity versus the snowblower images (ID 7).",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Farm + garden'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Honda generator set'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Craftsman snowblower'\n[7] 266.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Louisville, Ohio, United States'\n[8] Craftsman snowblower, description: a red snow blower sitting on the grass, at top-left\n[9] Craftsman snowblower, description: a red snow blower sitting on the grass, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Craftsman 27inch snowblower with cab enclosure. Asking 750 thanks for looking'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Totes and barrels, description: a group of blue barrels stacked in front of a building, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '1234.00 $'\n[14] Black angus bull, description: a black bull is standing in a field, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '2500.00 $'\n[16] Craftsman rear tine tiller, description: a lawn mower sitting on the grass, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '450.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '750.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Siti Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Siti Lim'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 164,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_56_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
9
],
"rationale": "The heading \u201cRiot + battle\u201d is contextually incompatible with the peaceful listing for a snowblower (ID 9).",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Riot + battle'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Craftsman snowblower'\n[6] 266.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Louisville, Ohio, United States'\n[7] Craftsman snowblower, description: a red snow blower sitting on the grass, at top-left\n[8] Craftsman snowblower, description: a red snow blower sitting on the grass, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Craftsman 27inch snowblower with cab enclosure. Asking 750 thanks for looking'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Totes and barrels, description: a group of blue barrels stacked in front of a building, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '1234.00 $'\n[13] Black angus bull, description: a black bull is standing in a field, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '2500.00 $'\n[15] Craftsman rear tine tiller, description: a lawn mower sitting on the grass, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '450.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '750.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Siti Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Siti Lim'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 165,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_59_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Text in ID 9 still calls it a \"Green Tea\" mattress, while ID 5 now says \"Coffee Bean,\" causing a direct product conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Furniture'\n[5] 395.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'NEW Zinus 12 Inch Coffee Bean TWIN Memory Foam Mattress'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'NEW Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea QUEEN Memory Foam Mattress'\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of East Washington, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] NEW Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea QUEEN Memory Foam Mattress, description: a bed with a blue headboard and a mattress, at top-left\n[9] NEW Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea QUEEN Memory Foam Mattress, description: a mattress with a blue cover and a blue headboard, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress / CertiPUR-US Certified / Bed-in-a-Box / Pressure Relieving, Queen. This bed retails for $600! Get it for 1/3 the price of $199! I also have bedframes a'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Standing Lamp, description: a white floor lamp with two cords on it, at bottom-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '10.00 $'\n[14] Sofa, description: a wooden couch with blue paisley fabric, at bottom-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '200.00 $'\n[16] swivel chair, description: a chair with a black and white pattern on it, at bottom-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '50.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '199.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Ana Kim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Ana Kim'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 166,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_60_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 5 now claims it is a \u201cBlue Sofa,\u201d conflicting with ID 9, which describes a storage cabinet.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Furniture'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Blue Sofa'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Storage Cabinet'\n[7] 401.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] Storage Cabinet, description: a brown cabinet with a door in the garage, at top-left\n[9] Storage Cabinet, description: a wooden cabinet with a door in it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Storage cabinet - could be used in a garage, basement, or for extra pantry items. Adjustable shelves. Lock with key. Must pick up.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] NEW Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea QUEEN Memory Foam Mattress, description: a mattress with a blue cover and a blue headboard, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '199.00 $'\n[14] Standing Lamp, description: a white floor lamp with two cords on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[16] Sofa, description: a wooden couch with blue paisley fabric, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '200.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Benjamin Said, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Benjamin Said'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 167,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_60_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
9
],
"rationale": "Labeling standard household storage (ID 9) as \u201cMunitions\u201d is thematically jarring and inconsistent.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Munitions'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Storage Cabinet'\n[6] 401.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Cranberry Township, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Storage Cabinet, description: a brown cabinet with a door in the garage, at top-left\n[8] Storage Cabinet, description: a wooden cabinet with a door in it, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Storage cabinet - could be used in a garage, basement, or for extra pantry items. Adjustable shelves. Lock with key. Must pick up.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] NEW Zinus 12 Inch Green Tea QUEEN Memory Foam Mattress, description: a mattress with a blue cover and a blue headboard, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '199.00 $'\n[13] Standing Lamp, description: a white floor lamp with two cords on it, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[15] Sofa, description: a wooden couch with blue paisley fabric, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '200.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '25.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Benjamin Said, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Benjamin Said'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 168,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_67_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "A stark thematic mismatch: [4] references jewelry while [5] now references a Halloween event",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Jewelry'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Halloween Show!'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Mallorca Pearls'\n[7] 306.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Falls Church, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Mallorca Pearls, description: a box with pearls in it, at top-left\n[9] Mallorca Pearls, description: a box with pearls and a necklace inside, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Genuine Mallorca Pearls. 48 inches. In original box. $100.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Baldor Heavy duty Jewelers polishing lathe model 353, description: a small electric drill sitting on a wooden floor, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '300.00 $'\n[14] 10k yellow and white gold cross, description: a person holding a gold cross in their hand, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '75.00 $'\n[16] 14k mystic topaz pendant w small diamonds, description: a pendant with a green topaz and diamonds, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '100.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Yuki Sato, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Yuki Sato'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 169,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_68_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "The page is about a bracelet listing, but the category heading is changed to \u201cTragedy,\u201d creating a thematic clash.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Tragedy'\n[5] 413.0px-wide text span at top-center: '14k Ruby & Diamond Women's Bracelet 2.85mm 7.54 grams solid'\n[6] 319.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Marietta, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] 14k Ruby & Diamond Women's Bracelet 2.85mm 7.54 grams solid, description: a gold bracelet with ruby and diamonds, at top-left\n[8] 14k Ruby & Diamond Women's Bracelet 2.85mm 7.54 grams solid, description: a gold bracelet with ruby and diamonds, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: '14k Ruby & Diamond Women's Bracelet 2.85mm 7.53 grams solid 7'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] vintage cherry AMBER beads- 30 strand- HUGE beads, description: a red glass necklace with red beads, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '120.00 $'\n[13] Pair vintage starfish pinbacks, description: two starfish on a wooden table, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[15] Hallmark Thin Bangle Charm Bracelet .925 Sterling, description: a silver bangle bracelet with a heart charm, at center-center\n[16] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[18] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '600.00 $'\n[19] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[20] Maria Schmidt, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Maria Schmidt'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[24] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[25] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 170,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_70_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 5 now conflicts with ID 9\u2019s references to a Honda scooter, causing a brand identity mismatch.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Motorcycles'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '2014 Yamaha Forza For Sale'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2014 Honda Forza For Sale'\n[7] 333.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Kittanning, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 2014 Honda Forza For Sale, description: a red and black scooter parked in front of a garage, at top-left\n[9] 2014 Honda Forza For Sale, description: a red and black scooter parked in front of a garage, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '2014 Honda Forza scooter for sale. 3,911 miles driven by original owner. Tall windscreen added but original low screen will also be included in the sale along with a Battery Tender. This scooter ha'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Minsk Wild Cat dirt bike, description: a red and black dirt bike parked in a parking lot, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '1700.00 $'\n[14] 2011 KTM 350 SXF, description: a dirt bike parked on the grass, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '3200.00 $'\n[16] 2021 HARLEY DAVIDSON FLTRX ROAD GLIDE FINANCING AVAILABLE, description: a black harley road glide motorcycle parked in a parking lot, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '21995.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '3000.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Olivia Thomas, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Olivia Thomas'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 171,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_73_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct conflict with the description referencing a 599cc engine",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Motorcycles'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '2006 Honda Hornet 999'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2006 Honda Hornet 599'\n[7] 270.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Reston, Virginia, United States'\n[8] 2006 Honda Hornet 599, description: a black motorcycle parked in a parking lot, at top-left\n[9] 2006 Honda Hornet 599, description: a black motorcycle parked in a parking lot, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Clean title, 18000 miles, inspection valid till Nov 2024 Love the bike, selling as I'm moving across country. Come test ride it (with cash in hand) I will always answer texts, but might miss your ca'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] vintage 1961 Vespa 125cc all original mint condition and runs great, description: a blue and white scooter is parked in a showroom, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '5800.00 $'\n[14] 2021 Yamaha XT250, description: a dirt bike parked in the grass, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '5200.00 $'\n[16] 2004 Yamaha FZ6, description: a motorcycle parked in a parking lot, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '3000.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '3100.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] James Wu, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'James Wu'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 172,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_74_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Context clash: \u201cClassifieds\u201d for music vs \u201cHorror elements\u201d heading",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Horror elements'\n[5] 260.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Complete Guitar Rig Full Stack w/ Perks!!!'\n[6] 417.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Borough of Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Complete Guitar Rig Full Stack w/ Perks!!!, description: marshall mc 125 watt guitar amp, at top-left\n[8] Complete Guitar Rig Full Stack w/ Perks!!!, description: marshall mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Complete Guitar Rig Full Stack w/ Perks!!! Package deal includes: Marshall JCM2000 TSL100 head unit w/ foot switch and printed manual Two Hartke GH412 4x12 speaker cabinets (top and bottom)'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Sound System-Peavey, description: a large speaker set in a garage, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '1500.00 $'\n[13] CB drum set (drums only), description: a drum set with a drum head and a stool, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '40.00 $'\n[15] Suhr Hedgehog, description: sulfo amps - sulfo st-100, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '2200.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '900.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Noah Hussein, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Noah Hussein'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 173,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_75_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "The product name now says \u201cGibson\u201d while the description in ID9 mentions \u201cMartin,\u201d causing mismatched branding.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Music instruments'\n[5] 210.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2021 Gibson GPC 16e Rosewood'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2021 Martin GPC 16e Rosewood'\n[7] 346.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 2021 Martin GPC 16e Rosewood, description: a guitar case with a guitar inside, at top-left\n[9] 2021 Martin GPC 16e Rosewood, description: a guitar case with a guitar inside, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'American made in Nazareth, PA - Martin Acoustic Electric Guitar. Solid East Indian Rosewood back and sides with a solid Spruce top and ebony fingerboard. Onboard Fishman Matrix VT Enhance NT2 pick'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] JBL Powered PA Speaker w/ Stand, description: a speaker is sitting on a table in a room, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '150.00 $'\n[14] Complete Guitar Rig Full Stack w/ Perks!!!, description: marshall mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '900.00 $'\n[16] Pearl Export Series 5pc Drum Set, description: a drum set is sitting on a floor in a room, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '1000.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1395.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Sarah Joshi, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sarah Joshi'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 174,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_75_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
7
],
"rationale": "Labeling a guitar category as \"Funeral services!\" creates a thematic mismatch with guitar images.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Funeral services!'\n[5] 206.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2021 Martin GPC 16e Rosewood'\n[6] 346.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] 2021 Martin GPC 16e Rosewood, description: a guitar case with a guitar inside, at top-left\n[8] 2021 Martin GPC 16e Rosewood, description: a guitar case with a guitar inside, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'American made in Nazareth, PA - Martin Acoustic Electric Guitar. Solid East Indian Rosewood back and sides with a solid Spruce top and ebony fingerboard. Onboard Fishman Matrix VT Enhance NT2 pick'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] JBL Powered PA Speaker w/ Stand, description: a speaker is sitting on a table in a room, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '150.00 $'\n[13] Complete Guitar Rig Full Stack w/ Perks!!!, description: marshall mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly mcfly, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '900.00 $'\n[15] Pearl Export Series 5pc Drum Set, description: a drum set is sitting on a floor in a room, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '1000.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1395.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Sarah Joshi, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sarah Joshi'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 175,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_76_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Direct text vs. image contradiction: ID 7 still shows the guitar as a Gibson SG, but ID 5 now calls it a Fender.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Music instruments'\n[5] 315.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2021 FENDER STRATOCASTER with FENDER bag'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2021 GIBSON SG TRIBUTE with GIBSON hard case'\n[7] 296.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Gainesville, Virginia, United States'\n[8] 2021 GIBSON SG TRIBUTE with GIBSON hard case, description: a guitar in a case with a red cover, at top-left\n[9] 2021 GIBSON SG TRIBUTE with GIBSON hard case, description: a guitar in a case with a red cover, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '2021 GIBSON SG TRIBUTE RED and includes a GIBSON HARD CASE EXCELLENT CONDITION! If you see it here, its available. Payment is cash only, person to person. Send contact number for a reply. EXC'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] NEW - DW Snare Drum Stand, description: a metal drum stand with a pair of drum sticks, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '75.00 $'\n[14] LTD / ESP Bass Guitar w/ hard case, description: a bass guitar with a black finish, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '350.00 $'\n[16] TAYLOR 214ce 2022 A/E guitar - 'New', description: a guitar in a case on a bed, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '850.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '995.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Haruto Abdullah, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Haruto Abdullah'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 176,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_77_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "The section header \"Weapons arsenal\" is contextually mismatched with the guitar details in ID 5.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Weapons arsenal'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'JACKSON CHARVEL PROFESSIONAL w / Floyd Rose - 1990s MIJ SHREDDER'\n[6] 296.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Gainesville, Virginia, United States'\n[7] JACKSON CHARVEL PROFESSIONAL w / Floyd Rose - 1990s MIJ SHREDDER, description: a blue electric guitar in a case, at top-left\n[8] JACKSON CHARVEL PROFESSIONAL w / Floyd Rose - 1990s MIJ SHREDDER, description: a blue electric guitar in a case, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: '1990s Teal Jackson / Charvel Pro Shredder with Floyd Rose Charvel /Jackson hard case included. Upgraded with Seymour Duncan USA LiveWire Pickups Reduced price $950.00 Sale is cash only person to'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] LTD / ESP Bass Guitar w/ hard case, description: a bass guitar with a black finish, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '350.00 $'\n[13] Benson Chimera Amplifier, description: a green and white amp sitting on a carpet, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '4000.00 $'\n[15] 50th ANNIVERSARY FENDER 1995 Deluxe Stratocaster w/extras, description: a guitar sitting in a box, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '1695.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '950.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Nikolai Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Nikolai Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 177,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_78_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with ID5 calling it a tripod, but here it\u2019s described as a camera bag.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Photo + video'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Dolica Proline 62 Tripod'\n[6] 290.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Towson, Maryland, United States'\n[7] Dolica Proline 62, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at top-left\n[8] Dolica Proline 62, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Model AX620B100. This is a sturdy camera bag. Barely worn. Shipping not included in the price, buyer must cover all fees.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] RCA Film / Slide Adapter / Converter -FSA 036A, description: nikon fas-t20 fas-t20 fas-t20 fas-t20, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '9.00 $'\n[13] Newborn photography destash, description: a shelf full of clothes and blankets, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[15] Unleash Your Creativity with Our Comprehensive Photography Studio Kit, description: a green screen with umbrellas and a tripod, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '200.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '19.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Amelia Hernandez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Amelia Hernandez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 178,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_78_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "\u201cA violent siege\u201d disrupts the benign context of a photography listing, causing a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'A violent siege'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Dolica Proline 62 Tripod'\n[6] 290.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Towson, Maryland, United States'\n[7] Dolica Proline 62, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at top-left\n[8] Dolica Proline 62, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Model AX620B100. For more technical details and reviews, see Only lightly used. Shipping not included in price, would need to be paid by buyer.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] RCA Film / Slide Adapter / Converter -FSA 036A, description: nikon fas-t20 fas-t20 fas-t20 fas-t20, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '9.00 $'\n[13] Newborn photography destash, description: a shelf full of clothes and blankets, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[15] Unleash Your Creativity with Our Comprehensive Photography Studio Kit, description: a green screen with umbrellas and a tripod, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '200.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '19.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Amelia Hernandez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Amelia Hernandez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 179,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_78_2.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
19,
9
],
"rationale": "Now there\u2019s a numeric conflict: ID9 says 299.00 $ while ID19 remains at 19.00 $, causing confusion over the true price.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Photo + video'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Dolica Proline 62 Tripod'\n[6] 290.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Towson, Maryland, United States'\n[7] Dolica Proline 62, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at top-left\n[8] Dolica Proline 62, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Model AX620B100, sold at 299.00 $. For more details, see Only lightly used. Shipping not included in price, must be paid by buyer.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] RCA Film / Slide Adapter / Converter -FSA 036A, description: nikon fas-t20 fas-t20 fas-t20 fas-t20, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '9.00 $'\n[13] Newborn photography destash, description: a shelf full of clothes and blankets, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '10.00 $'\n[15] Unleash Your Creativity with Our Comprehensive Photography Studio Kit, description: a green screen with umbrellas and a tripod, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '200.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '19.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Amelia Hernandez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Amelia Hernandez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 180,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_79_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 9 states the 23mm f/2 is \"in perfect condition,\" contradicting the new title claiming it's \"broken.\"",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Photo + video'\n[5] 224.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Fujifilm X-T2 with broken 23mm f/2'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Fujifilm X-T2 with 23mm f/2'\n[7] 301.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Bethesda, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Fujifilm X-T2 with 23mm f/2, description: a camera with a battery and charger on a table, at top-left\n[9] Fujifilm X-T2 with 23mm f/2, description: a camera with a battery and other accessories, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Fuji X-T2 in great condition. Some paint has come off here and there but other than that is in great shape. Body is missing the rubber cap for the battery grip attachment which has been kept covered w'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM with extender EF 1.4X III, description: a blue heron standing in the water, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '1645.00 $'\n[14] Dolica Proline 62 Tripod, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '19.00 $'\n[16] wyze camers, description: a white camera on a wooden table, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '20.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '750.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Carlos Chatterjee, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Carlos Chatterjee'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 181,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_79_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "\u201cFuneral video\u201d introduces a somber, unrelated context that clashes with a camera sales page.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Funeral video'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Fujifilm X-T2 with 23mm f/2'\n[6] 301.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Bethesda, Maryland, United States'\n[7] Fujifilm X-T2 with 23mm f/2, description: a camera with a battery and charger on a table, at top-left\n[8] Fujifilm X-T2 with 23mm f/2, description: a camera with a battery and other accessories, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Fuji X-T2 in great condition. Some paint has come off here and there but other than that is in great shape. Body is missing the rubber cap for the battery grip attachment which has been kept covered w'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Canon EF 100-400mm f/4.5-5.6L IS II USM with extender EF 1.4X III, description: a blue heron standing in the water, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '1645.00 $'\n[13] Dolica Proline 62 Tripod, description: a tripod with the word proline on it, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '19.00 $'\n[15] wyze camers, description: a white camera on a wooden table, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '20.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '750.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Carlos Chatterjee, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Carlos Chatterjee'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 182,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_80_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "The text now claims the lens is Canon, while the image description (ID 7) says Nikon\u2014an obvious factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Photo + video'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Canon 100-400mm S'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Nikon 100-400mm S'\n[7] 294.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Centreville, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Nikon 100-400mm S, description: a lens is sitting on top of a table, at top-left\n[9] Nikon 100-400mm S, description: a lens is sitting on top of a table, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Excellent condition. Original owner. NO SHIPPING ! Local transactions and cash only. Thanks'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Fujifilm 55-200mm Lens, description: a lens sitting on a table next to a computer, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '375.00 $'\n[14] Wandrd Prvke, description: a green backpack with black straps on the floor, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '145.00 $'\n[16] Genuine Canon EF-EOS R Control Mount Adapter, description: canon ef-s f/2.8 sm lens - f/2.8 sm, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '85.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1499.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Zainab Ito, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Zainab Ito'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 183,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_81_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The text label now contradicts the images showing a tripod by calling it a coffee mug",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Photo + video'\n[5] 245.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Caffeinated coffee mug from Starbucks'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'MANTISPOD travel tripod from PGYTECH'\n[7] 286.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Arlington, Virginia, United States'\n[8] MANTISPOD travel tripod from PGYTECH, description: a tripod with a small camera on top, at top-left\n[9] MANTISPOD travel tripod from PGYTECH, description: a tripod with a small camera on top, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Best travel tripod in the business Comes with the travel pouch (a bit scuffed) and original box/instructions, but not the top part of the box, which I must have misplaced. Included the tripod head.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Nikon 100-400mm S, description: a lens is sitting on top of a table, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '1499.00 $'\n[14] Sekonic L-358 lightmeter, description: a digital camera with a light meter and a case, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '190.00 $'\n[16] Mick 'n Min Disney Cadillac Convertible, description: a painting of a pink car with mickey and person in it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '40.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '100.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Svetlana Brown, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Svetlana Brown'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 184,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_82_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "This directly conflicts with the references to a \"Sony\" camera in [9].",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Photo + video'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Nikon A1 Mirrorless Cam'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera'\n[7] 296.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Gainesville, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera, description: a camera with a lens attached to it, at top-left\n[9] Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera, description: a camera with a lens attached to it, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera body. In-Person sales only! $4,800.00 or B/O Cash or Apple Pay *Camera is in Mint Condition / as-is and comes with: *Sony Vertical Grip Dual battery grip and 2 inserted'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Insta360 One R Twin Edition, description: instago one action camera in the box, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '360.00 $'\n[14] Nikon 100-400mm S, description: a lens is sitting on top of a table, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '1499.00 $'\n[16] Sekonic L-358 lightmeter, description: a digital camera with a light meter and a case, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '190.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '4800.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Robert Cruz, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Robert Cruz'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 185,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_82_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
9
],
"rationale": "The camera sale context [9] contrasts sharply with \"Warfare clips,\" creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Warfare clips'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera'\n[6] 296.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Gainesville, Virginia, United States'\n[7] Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera, description: a camera with a lens attached to it, at top-left\n[8] Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera, description: a camera with a lens attached to it, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Sony A1 Mirrorless Camera body. In-Person sales only! $4,800.00 or B/O Cash or Apple Pay *Camera is in Mint Condition / as-is and comes with: *Sony Vertical Grip Dual battery grip and 2 inserted'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Insta360 One R Twin Edition, description: instago one action camera in the box, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '360.00 $'\n[13] Nikon 100-400mm S, description: a lens is sitting on top of a table, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '1499.00 $'\n[15] Sekonic L-358 lightmeter, description: a digital camera with a light meter and a case, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '190.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '4800.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Robert Cruz, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Robert Cruz'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 186,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_83_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "\"Military coup\" is thematically incompatible with the camera product listing in [5].",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Military coup'\n[5] 344.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'EOS Rebel XT100 EF-S 18-55MM F/3.5-5.6 III Lens Kit'\n[6] 376.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'City of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] EOS Rebel XT100 EF-S 18-55MM F/3.5-5.6 III Lens Kit, description: canon eos slr stm sd slr sd slr sd, at top-left\n[8] EOS Rebel XT100 EF-S 18-55MM F/3.5-5.6 III Lens Kit, description: canon eos slr eos slr eos slr eos s, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Barely used, very good condition. Comes with a stand and strap. Pick up only, please. About: DSLR quality photos & full HD movies Powerful 18 Megapixel sensor Canon Camera Connect App: share ins'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Cameras, description: nikon d7000 dslr camera with nikon d7000 lens, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '500.00 $'\n[13] - Before the Hunt B&W Image from a Glass Negative -, description: two men sitting on a bench with dogs, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '12.00 $'\n[15] antique 5x7 wooden camera, description: three wooden boxes on a table, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '450.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '230.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Patricia Lim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Patricia Lim'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 187,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_84_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
9
],
"rationale": "A grim, war-torn phrase clashes contextually with the RV listing details in ID 9.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Dark war zone'\n[5] 215.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2014 Forest River Shamrock 25RS'\n[6] 311.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Rocky Mount, Virginia, United States'\n[7] 2014 Forest River Shamrock 25RS, description: a small white travel trailer parked in a field, at top-left\n[8] 2014 Forest River Shamrock 25RS, description: a small white travel trailer parked in a field, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Bumper Pull Travel Trailer. 275 Long. 2 Power Slides. King size heated mattress. Bunk beds. Sofa and dinette can be made into beds. 6,502 lbs GVWR. 4,841 lbs unloaded weight. Power awning. Power h'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 1999 Ford Winnebago (low Mileage), description: a white rv parked in a parking lot, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '6300.00 $'\n[13] for sale .. jayco Qwest, description: a small camper trailer with a tent attached to it, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '3200.00 $'\n[15] 2023 Custom Club Car Tempo, description: the gray golf cart is parked in a gravel lot, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '8000.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '17500.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Zainab Lee, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Zainab Lee'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 188,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_88_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "This new title conflicts with the image showing an actual VR headset",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Video gaming'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'HP Pavilion 15R'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Vr Meta Quest 2'\n[7] 372.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'East Uniontown, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] Vr Meta Quest 2, description: a white vr headset in a box, at top-left\n[9] Vr Meta Quest 2, description: a white vr headset in a box, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Barley used has battery head strap (for longer playtime) comes with the original box.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] xbox series x / with extras, description: a black xbox sat on top of a desk, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '350.00 $'\n[14] gigabyte geforce rtx 4090, description: gigabyte geforce gtx 480 gtx 480 gtx 480, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '800.00 $'\n[16] Xbox Series X, description: xbox one x 1tb power your dreams, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '400.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Mohammad Nowak, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Mohammad Nowak'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 189,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_89_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
6
],
"rationale": "The heading (id 2) is set to \u201cMars 1850?!\u201d which conflicts with the modern location (id 6).",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Mars 1850?!'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Video gaming'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Xbox Series X'\n[6] 341.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Dallastown, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] Xbox Series X, description: xbox one x 1tb in stock, at top-left\n[8] Xbox Series X, description: xbox one x 1tb power your dreams, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Diablo IV edition - 1TB. Asking $400 obo. My name is Aaron. Call or text - mark_wilson227@example.com . Yes, I have a TX area code but I live in PA. Thanks for looking!'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Xbox 360 with Kinect, description: a xbox 360 with a clock on top, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '80.00 $'\n[13] Racing Simulator (Moza wheel/pedals, NVIDIA, 3 screens), description: a gaming chair with two monitors and a gaming chair, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '2450.00 $'\n[15] PS5 Disc Edition Bundle, description: a pink and white gaming console and headphones, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '400.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[20] Mark Wilson, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Mark Wilson'\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[24] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[25] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 190,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_91_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "This directly conflicts with [9], which states the book is in \"good\" condition.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, heavily damaged!'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, in good condition!'\n[7] 280.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Elkton, Maryland, United States'\n[8] Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, in good condition!, description: peter pan book and record, at top-left\n[9] Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, in good condition!, description: peter pan book and record, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'The Copyright date is NOT STATED but is ca. 1950 for this Printing. Bibliographic Details Title: PETER PAN. Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939 Publisher: Peter Pan Records/Mulder & Zoon (printer of b'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Punch Ladle MCM Scandinavian silver over copper, description: a silver serving tray with a wooden handle, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '55.00 $'\n[14] Panama Canal Calendar Plate 1915 Amburg, VA, description: a plate with a map of the united states, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[16] Leather Pouf Seat, description: a leather laptop case on a cowhide rug, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '186.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '4.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Haruto Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Haruto Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 191,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_91_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "Labeling a vintage listing under \u201cCyberwar\u201d creates a stark thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cyberwar'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, in good condition!'\n[6] 280.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Elkton, Maryland, United States'\n[7] Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, in good condition!, description: peter pan book and record, at top-left\n[8] Vintage PETER PAN Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939, in good condition!, description: peter pan book and record, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'The Copyright date is NOT STATED but is ca. 1950 for this Printing. Bibliographic Details Title: PETER PAN. Book and Record (45rpm) No. 1939 Publisher: Peter Pan Records/Mulder & Zoon (printer of b'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Punch Ladle MCM Scandinavian silver over copper, description: a silver serving tray with a wooden handle, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '55.00 $'\n[13] Panama Canal Calendar Plate 1915 Amburg, VA, description: a plate with a map of the united states, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[15] Leather Pouf Seat, description: a leather laptop case on a cowhide rug, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '186.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '4.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Haruto Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Haruto Kov\u00c3\u00a1cs'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 192,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_92_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "The product creator is changed to an unrelated car manufacturer, conflicting with the publisher name Yang Hassan and normal expectations.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Handmade Shaker Windsor Chair, Charcoal Gray made by Toyota Motors'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Handmade Shaker Windsor Chair, Charcoal Gray made by Peter Kramer'\n[7] 275.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Sterling, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Handmade Shaker Windsor Chair, Charcoal Gray made by Peter Kramer, description: a black chair with a wooden frame, at top-left\n[9] Handmade Shaker Windsor Chair, Charcoal Gray made by Peter Kramer, description: a black chair with a wooden frame, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '23.75 (w) x 26 (depth) x 41.5 (tall), the seat is 17 inches off the ground. Firm price. W&B. Follow us on Instagram {{TWITTER}}'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Vintage Chair, description: two chairs with black seats and a wooden frame, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '80.00 $'\n[14] Grim Reaper Scythe, description: a wooden rocking chair in front of a garage, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[16] 19thCentury French Louis XV Style Kingwood Marquetry Inlaid Side Table, description: an antique gold and black table with a gold top, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '3990.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '300.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Yang Hassan, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Yang Hassan'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 193,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_93_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "The new description claims a 2023 ultra-modern plastic design, contradicting the \u201cEarly 20th Cenury\u201d label in ID 5.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Cenury'\n[6] 262.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Burke, Virginia, United States'\n[7] Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Cenury, description: a wooden cabinet with glass doors, at top-left\n[8] Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Cenury, description: a wooden cabinet with glass doors, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Ultra-modern 2023 design with plastic frame. Height 88 width 45 depth 22. Unused factory condition with no age. Two parts extremely fragile to transport. Limited edition surpasses all classic designs.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Vintage Chair, description: two chairs with black seats and a wooden frame, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '80.00 $'\n[13] Grim Reaper Scythe, description: a wooden rocking chair in front of a garage, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[15] Vintage luggage, description: a group of luggage sitting on a wooden floor, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '40.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '4990.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Jennifer Perez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jennifer Perez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 194,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_93_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9,
19
],
"rationale": "Now #9 states the item price as 100.00 $, directly conflicting with the concurrently assigned 4990.00 $ in #19 for the same antique.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Cenury'\n[6] 262.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Burke, Virginia, United States'\n[7] Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Cenury, description: a wooden cabinet with glass doors, at top-left\n[8] Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Cenury, description: a wooden cabinet with glass doors, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Antique Flame Mahogany Secretary Cabinet Bookcase. Early 20th Century. Price: 100.00 $. Height 88 width 45 depth 22. Refinished excellent Condition with Age. Two parts easy to move.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Vintage Chair, description: two chairs with black seats and a wooden frame, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '80.00 $'\n[13] Grim Reaper Scythe, description: a wooden rocking chair in front of a garage, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[15] Vintage luggage, description: a group of luggage sitting on a wooden floor, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '40.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '4990.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Jennifer Perez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jennifer Perez'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 195,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_94_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 9 says it\u2019s 32 inches, but ID 5 now claims 45 inches, introducing a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] 263.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Antique Sterling Silver Necklace(45in)/Belt'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Antique Sterling Silver Necklace/Belt'\n[7] 290.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Smyrna, Delaware, United States'\n[8] Antique Sterling Silver Necklace/Belt, description: a silver and black necklace with a black and silver design, at top-left\n[9] Antique Sterling Silver Necklace/Belt, description: a silver and black necklace with a black and silver design, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Antique, Hand Made in Mexico Mayan style Necklace/Belt. Approximately 32 long x 1.25 wide. All Sterling pieces with marks on every clasp. Rectangular pieces are repousse decorative stars and pyrami'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Bronze Outdoor Light Fixtures, description: a brass outdoor light with a glass shade, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '84.00 $'\n[14] Nice Antique mirror, description: a brown mirror with a measuring tape on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '60.00 $'\n[16] Mid-Century Style Cabinet, description: a brown cabinet with a gold mirror on it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '125.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '150.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Michael Nair, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Michael Nair'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 196,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_95_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "This title now contradicts the image (#7) that describes mahogany dining chairs.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] 310.0px-wide text span at top-center: '21st Century Pair of Plastic Reclining Pool Chairs.'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '18th Century Pair Federal Mahogany Carved Side Chairs.'\n[7] 262.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Burke, Virginia, United States'\n[8] 18th Century Pair Federal Mahogany Carved Side Chairs., description: pair of mahogany dining chairs, at top-left\n[9] 18th Century Pair Federal Mahogany Carved Side Chairs., description: pair of mahogany dining chairs, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Height 36.1/2 width 20 depth 20. Floor to Seat 17.3/4. Refinished very sturdy and comfortable. Excellent Condition with age. Pick up local or delivery available.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Vintage Chair, description: two chairs with black seats and a wooden frame, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '80.00 $'\n[14] Grim Reaper Scythe, description: a wooden rocking chair in front of a garage, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[16] 19thCentury French Louis XV Style Kingwood Marquetry Inlaid Side Table, description: an antique gold and black table with a gold top, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '3990.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1395.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Nadia Al-Masri, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Nadia Al-Masri'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 197,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_95_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9
],
"rationale": "The new dimensions are obviously improbable and contradict the item\u2019s pictured size.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] 353.0px-wide text span at top-center: '18th Century Pair Federal Mahogany Carved Side Chairs.'\n[6] 262.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Burke, Virginia, United States'\n[7] 18th Century Pair Federal Mahogany Carved Side Chairs., description: pair of mahogany dining chairs, at top-left\n[8] 18th Century Pair Federal Mahogany Carved Side Chairs., description: pair of mahogany dining chairs, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Height 360 width 2 depth 200. Floor to Seat 1. Refinished, very sturdy and comfortable. Great shape with age. Pickup local or delivery available.'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Vintage Chair, description: two chairs with black seats and a wooden frame, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '80.00 $'\n[13] Grim Reaper Scythe, description: a wooden rocking chair in front of a garage, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '65.00 $'\n[15] 19thCentury French Louis XV Style Kingwood Marquetry Inlaid Side Table, description: an antique gold and black table with a gold top, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '3990.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1395.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Nadia Al-Masri, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Nadia Al-Masri'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 198,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_96_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with ID=9, which describes a child's antique wooden rocking chair",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Antiques'\n[5] 321.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Brand new plastic lounge seat, just out of the store'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Child's antique wooden wood rocking chair rocker vintage'\n[7] 254.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Canton, Ohio, United States'\n[8] Child's antique wooden wood rocking chair rocker vintage, description: a small black rocking chair sitting in the grass, at top-left\n[9] Child's antique wooden wood rocking chair rocker vintage, description: a small black rocking chair sitting in the grass, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Offering for sale a child's vintage antique wooden rocking chair. Believed original finish, recovered seat upholstery. 24 overall height, 10 1/2 from floor to seat, 15 1/2 from floor to side rails.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Jug, description: a brown jug sitting on a table, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '5.00 $'\n[14] Antique Bookcase, description: a wooden bookcase with a red vase on it, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '150.00 $'\n[16] TABLE LAMP WITH HANGING CRYSTALS, description: a white lamp with a white shade on top, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '55.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '20.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Zhang Garcia, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Zhang Garcia'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 199,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_97_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
7
],
"rationale": "The main text now contradicts the image (#7) claiming an electric stove with warranty.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Appliances'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Frigidaire brand new gas oven that has no range and absolutely zero warranty'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Frigidaire used electric stove come with Range oven and come with warranty'\n[7] 336.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'West Springfield, Virginia, United States'\n[8] Frigidaire used electric stove come with Range oven and come with warranty, description: a black stove and oven in a store, at top-left\n[9] Frigidaire used electric stove come with Range oven and come with warranty, description: a black stove with two burners and a microwave, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'AFFORDABLE APPLIANCES LOCATION: 1330 OLD BRIDGE Rd Woodbirdge 22192 Suit 103 Next tobacco King DELIVERY AVAIABLE WE'RE OPEN: Mon-to-Sat: 09:00am to 7:00pm Sunday: 10:00am to 6pm A'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Samsung Stainless Steel 5 Burner Gas Range Like New With Warranty, description: a stove with a stainless steel top and a silver oven, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '335.00 $'\n[14] Like New GE Stainless Steel Glass Top Electric Stove With Warranty, description: a stove and oven in a store, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '310.00 $'\n[16] Fisher Paykel 30 Like New Gas Range With Convection Fan / Warranty, description: a stove with a washer and dryer in it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '699.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '249.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Patricia M\u00c3\u00bcller, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Patricia M\u00c3\u00bcller'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 200,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_99_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Turning a product listing (#5) into a baby shower reference conflicts contextually with the \u201cAppliances\u201d category (#4).",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Appliances'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '--Baby shower bash--'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '--Road Ready case--'\n[7] 286.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Merrifield, Virginia, United States'\n[8] --Road Ready case--, description: a large case with a large monitor and a keyboard, at top-left\n[9] --Road Ready case--, description: a large case with a large monitor and a keyboard, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Road Ready case 21 1/2w x 24 1/2x x 25 1/2h. $125 .00 cash'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] Samsung Stainless Steel 5 Burner Gas Range Like New With Warranty, description: a stove with a stainless steel top and a silver oven, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '335.00 $'\n[14] Like New GE Stainless Steel Glass Top Electric Stove With Warranty, description: a stove and oven in a store, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '310.00 $'\n[16] Fisher Paykel 30 Like New Gas Range With Convection Fan / Warranty, description: a stove with a washer and dryer in it, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '699.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '125.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Miguel Kim, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Miguel Kim'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 201,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_101_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "The new category label clashes tonally with a supposedly peaceful, artistic framed print (ID 5).",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Warfare+ gore'\n[5] 281.0px-wide text span at top-center: '- (1950 John Deere Model 40) - Framed Print'\n[6] 376.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'City of Lancaster, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] - (1950 John Deere Model 40) - Framed Print, description: a framed print of a green tractor, at top-left\n[8] - (1950 John Deere Model 40) - Framed Print, description: a framed print of a green tractor, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: '- I'm a retired Gallery owner and Professional Custom Picture Framer looking to liquidate some great prints and posters. Shown is just one of the many framed pieces I have available. * *(ALL ART IS'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] Vintage John Sexton Signed Poster From Listen To The Trees, description: john sextoon listen to the trees, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '125.00 $'\n[13] Singer Sewing Machine, description: a sewing machine on a table in a garage, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '25.00 $'\n[15] 3 WATERCOLORS BY PAULA VAUGHAN FRAMED SIGNED AND NUMBERED PRINTS, description: a painting of a quilt on the steps of a house, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '45.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '65.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Ana Hassan, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Ana Hassan'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 202,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_102_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "ID 9 still mentions 233,000 miles, whereas this element now says 100,000 miles, creating a clear numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 231.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2007 Honda pilot EXL 100,000 miles'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2007 Honda pilot EXL 233,000 miles'\n[7] 349.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Baileys Crossroads, Virginia, United States'\n[8] 2007 Honda pilot EXL 233,000 miles, description: a maroon suv parked in front of a house, at top-left\n[9] 2007 Honda pilot EXL 233,000 miles, description: a maroon suv parked in front of a house, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Hi, up for sale is my 2007 Honda pilot exl has 233,000 miles. Engine and transmission is in great working condition. My kids used it a lot and they are some dents as you can see in the pictures. Tires'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2013 Honda Civic, description: a white honda civic sedan parked in a parking lot, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '6000.00 $'\n[14] 2018 Tesla model 3, description: a tesla model 3 dashboard with a screen, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '27800.00 $'\n[16] 2007 Toyota Yaris, description: a small green car parked in front of a house, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '3000.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '1600.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Sarah Hernandez, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sarah Hernandez'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 203,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_103_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "#5 states \"1 OWNER,\" but #9 now claims \"6 owners.\"",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 305.0px-wide text span at top-center: '***2007 TOYOTA PRIUS 1 OWNER***MUST SEE'\n[6] 322.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Fredericksburg, Virginia, United States'\n[7] ***2007 TOYOTA PRIUS 1 OWNER***MUST SEE, description: the toyota prius is parked in a lot, at top-left\n[8] ***2007 TOYOTA PRIUS 1 OWNER***MUST SEE, description: the toyota prius is parked in a lot, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: '2007 Toyota Prius Touring 6 owners 166K Va inspected runs excellent call now .... Financing available, Financing available, Financing available, Financing available... Aux, usb, backup camer'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2013 Honda Civic, description: a white honda civic sedan parked in a parking lot, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '6000.00 $'\n[13] ***2008 Mercedes ML 350 VERY CLEAN***, description: a black car parked in front of a house, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '8500.00 $'\n[15] 2018 Tesla model 3, description: a tesla model 3 dashboard with a screen, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '27800.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '5500.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Sophia Williams, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sophia Williams'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 204,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_103_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "#7 image description says \"Toyota Prius,\" but #5 now labels it a \"Honda Accord.\"",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 323.0px-wide text span at top-center: '***2007 HONDA ACCORD 1 OWNER***MUST SEE'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '***2007 TOYOTA PRIUS 1 OWNER***MUST SEE'\n[7] 322.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Fredericksburg, Virginia, United States'\n[8] ***2007 TOYOTA PRIUS 1 OWNER***MUST SEE, description: the toyota prius is parked in a lot, at top-left\n[9] ***2007 TOYOTA PRIUS 1 OWNER***MUST SEE, description: the toyota prius is parked in a lot, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '2007 Toyota Prius Touring 1 owner only 166K Va inspected runs excellent call now .... Financing available, Financing available, Financing available, Financing available... Aux, usb, backup camer'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2013 Honda Civic, description: a white honda civic sedan parked in a parking lot, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '6000.00 $'\n[14] ***2008 Mercedes ML 350 VERY CLEAN***, description: a black car parked in front of a house, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '8500.00 $'\n[16] 2018 Tesla model 3, description: a tesla model 3 dashboard with a screen, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '27800.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '5500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Sophia Williams, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sophia Williams'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 205,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_104_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "The new text conflicts with the image showing a Dodge Dart, creating a factual text-image contradiction",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: '2016 Honda Civic EX Coupe 2D'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2016 Dodge Dart SXT Sedan 4D'\n[7] 277.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Stafford, Virginia, United States'\n[8] 2016 Dodge Dart SXT Sedan 4D, description: the red dodge dart is parked in front of a building, at top-left\n[9] 2016 Dodge Dart SXT Sedan 4D, description: the red dodge dart is parked in front of a building, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2013 Honda Civic, description: a white honda civic sedan parked in a parking lot, at bottom-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '6000.00 $'\n[13] 2018 Tesla model 3, description: a tesla model 3 dashboard with a screen, at bottom-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '27800.00 $'\n[15] 2007 Toyota Yaris, description: a small green car parked in front of a house, at bottom-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3000.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '11695.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Fatima Wilson, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Fatima Wilson'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 206,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_106_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
10
],
"rationale": "Element [9] describes it as \"impeccable condition,\" conflicting with [5]'s \u201cHeavily Worn, Terrible Condition.\u201d",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 314.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2019 Toyota 86 - Heavily Worn, Terrible Condition'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '2019 Toyota 86 - Sporty Fun, Excellent Condition'\n[7] 334.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[8] 2019 Toyota 86 - Sporty Fun, Excellent Condition, description: a red toyota 86 driving down a road, at top-left\n[9] 2019 Toyota 86 - Sporty Fun, Excellent Condition, description: a red toyota 86 driving down a road in the fog, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Hit the road in style with this eye-catching 2019 Toyota 86. Known for its precise handling and brisk acceleration, this car has been a joy on both city streets and winding back roads. Kept in impecca'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan, description: the silver honda accord is parked in a lot, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '7000.00 $'\n[14] 2008 F250, description: a blue truck is parked in a field, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '12000.00 $'\n[16] 2012 Hyundai Elantra GLS, description: the silver hyundai elantra is parked in a lot, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '7500.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '27500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Blake Sullivan, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[25] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 207,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_106_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
9
],
"rationale": "The image [7] shows a Toyota 86, but [9] is now mislabeling it as a Nissan 86.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 309.0px-wide text span at top-center: '2019 Toyota 86 - Sporty Fun, Excellent Condition'\n[6] 334.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States'\n[7] 2019 Toyota 86 - Sporty Fun, Excellent Condition, description: a red toyota 86 driving down a road, at top-left\n[8] 2019 Toyota 86 - Sporty Fun, Excellent Condition, description: a red toyota 86 driving down a road in the fog, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Hit the road in style with this eye-catching 2019 Nissan 86. Known for its precise handling and brisk acceleration, this car has been a joy on both city streets and winding back roads. Kept in impecca...'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2011 Honda Accord Special Edition Sedan, description: the silver honda accord is parked in a lot, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '7000.00 $'\n[13] 2008 F250, description: a blue truck is parked in a field, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '12000.00 $'\n[15] 2012 Hyundai Elantra GLS, description: the silver hyundai elantra is parked in a lot, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '7500.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '27500.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Blake Sullivan, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[23] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[24] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[25] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 208,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_108_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "Mislabels \u201cford\u201d as \u201cToyota,\u201d conflicting with references to Ford Mustang.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] 214.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Rare Toyota 1988 mustang T-tops'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Rare model 1988 ford mustang T-tops'\n[7] 318.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Albright, West Virginia, United States'\n[8] Rare model 1988 ford mustang T-tops, description: a gray mustang parked in a gravel driveway, at top-left\n[9] Rare model 1988 ford mustang T-tops, description: a gray mustang parked in a gravel driveway, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Great opportunity to own a rare model of the Fox Body series. There were only around 3700 GT Mustangs with T-tops manufactured in 1988. I would estimate maybe 1500 still exist. The second owner of th'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2012 GMC CANYON SLE, description: a red truck is parked outside of a store, at bottom-left\n[13] Compact text span at bottom-left: '11995.00 $'\n[14] 79 squarebody, description: a white truck parked in a parking lot, at bottom-center\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '9000.00 $'\n[16] 2018 International LT625 6x4 T/A Sleeper, description: a green semi truck is parked in a garage, at bottom-center\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: '42800.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '6000.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Jose Joshi, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jose Joshi'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 209,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_108_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "This creates a thematic mismatch: the category now suggests foods, while the listing is about vehicles.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Desserts + pastries'\n[5] 241.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Rare model 1988 ford mustang T-tops'\n[6] 318.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Albright, West Virginia, United States'\n[7] Rare model 1988 ford mustang T-tops, description: a gray mustang parked in a gravel driveway, at top-left\n[8] Rare model 1988 ford mustang T-tops, description: a gray mustang parked in a gravel driveway, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Great opportunity to own a rare model of the Fox Body series. There were only around 3700 GT Mustangs with T-tops manufactured in 1988. I would estimate maybe 1500 still exist. The second owner of th'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2012 GMC CANYON SLE, description: a red truck is parked outside of a store, at bottom-left\n[12] Compact text span at bottom-left: '11995.00 $'\n[13] 79 squarebody, description: a white truck parked in a parking lot, at bottom-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: '9000.00 $'\n[15] 2018 International LT625 6x4 T/A Sleeper, description: a green semi truck is parked in a garage, at bottom-center\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: '42800.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '6000.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Jose Joshi, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jose Joshi'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 210,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_109_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Tone of \u201cCircus parade\u201d clashes with the truck listings context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Circus parade'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Flat bed trucks'\n[6] 296.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'North Canton, Ohio, United States'\n[7] Flat bed trucks, description: a white truck parked in a parking lot, at top-left\n[8] Flat bed trucks, description: a white truck parked in a parking lot, at top-center\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Selling 2005 gmc 4500 6.6L Duramax Diesel flatbed with Alison automatic transmission 18 foot long bed with lift gate has 145k runs great no issues call (555) 895-3638'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[11] 2010 Lincoln MKT 3rd row seating, description: a red lincoln mkt for sale in st paul, minnesota, at center-left\n[12] Compact text span at center-left: '2500.00 $'\n[13] 1984 Buick LeSabre Limited Sedan, description: a beige car parked on the side of the road, at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: '5000.00 $'\n[15] 08 gmc sierra, description: a dashboard with a blue gauge and a blue gauge, at center-center\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: '7000.00 $'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[19] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '16500.00 $'\n[20] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[21] Tatiana Wang, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[22] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Tatiana Wang'\n[23] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[25] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[26] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 211,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/classifieds_109_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "Reference to a distant future timeline is spatially/temporally incoherent.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Classifieds, description: a blue and black logo with the words ohm, at top-left\n[2] Compact text span at top-left: 'Classifieds'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '>'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Cars + trucks'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: 'Flew to 2040 AD'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Flat bed trucks'\n[7] 296.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'North Canton, Ohio, United States'\n[8] Flat bed trucks, description: a white truck parked in a parking lot, at top-left\n[9] Flat bed trucks, description: a white truck parked in a parking lot, at top-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Selling 2005 gmc 4500 6.6L Duramax Diesel flatbed with Alison automatic transmission 18 foot long bed with lift gate has 145k runs great no issues call (555) 895-3638'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Related listings'\n[12] 2010 Lincoln MKT 3rd row seating, description: a red lincoln mkt for sale in st paul, minnesota, at center-left\n[13] Compact text span at center-left: '2500.00 $'\n[14] 1984 Buick LeSabre Limited Sedan, description: a beige car parked on the side of the road, at center-center\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: '5000.00 $'\n[16] 08 gmc sierra, description: a dashboard with a blue gauge and a blue gauge, at center-center\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: '7000.00 $'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Comments'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leave your comment (spam and offensive messages will be removed)'\n[20] 300.0px-wide text span at top-right: '16500.00 $'\n[21] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Contact publisher'\n[22] Tatiana Wang, description: a white avatar of a person, at top-right\n[23] 260.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Tatiana Wang'\n[24] Compact text span at top-right: 'Name:'\n[25] Compact text span at top-right: 'E-mail:'\n[26] 256.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Useful information'\n[27] 236.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Avoid scams by acting locally or paying with PayPal'\n[28] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Never pay with Western Union, Moneygram or other anonymous payment services'\n[29] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Don't buy or sell outside of your country. Don't accept cashier cheques from outside your country'\n[30] 236.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'This site is never involved in any transaction, and does not handle payments, shipping, guarantee transactions, provide escrow services, or offer buyer protection or seller certification'"
},
{
"i": 212,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_3_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
8
],
"rationale": "This contradicts the statement in ID1 that the site is Mesoamerican",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Chiapa de Corzo (Mesoamerican site)'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'is an of located near the small town of .'\n[3] , description: ruins of a ruin in the desert, at top-right\n[4] 302.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Mound 1, Chiapa de Corzo, an African ruin near the Nile River.'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'It rose to prominence around 700-500 BC, during the period, becoming a regional center. By then, its public precinct had reached 18-20 ha in size, with total settlement approaching 70 ha. Because of i'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'The modern township of , founded in Colonial times and after which the site was named, is nearby.'\n[7] Compact text span at top-left: 'Site history'\n[8] , description: map of the mexican peninsula, at top-left\n[9] 222.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Chiapa de Corzo and other Formative Period sites, approximately 900 BCE.'\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'The site shows evidence of continual occupation since the ( 1200 ).'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'The mounds and plazas at the site, however, date to approximately 700 BCE with temples and palaces constructed at the end of the or Protoclassic period, between 100 BCE and 200 CE.'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: 'In 2008, archaeologists discovered a massive Middle Formative axe deposit at the base of Chiapa de Corzo's Mound 11 pyramid. This deposit dates to around 700 BCE and is the second one of its kind foun'\n[13] Compact text span at top-right: 'San Isidro'\n[14] Wide text span at center-center: 'In April 2010, archaeologists discovered the 2,700-year-old tomb of a dignitary within Mound 11 that is the oldest pyramidal tomb yet discovered in Mesoamerica.'\n[15] Wide text span at center-center: 'According to archaeologist Bruce Bachand, the tomb exhibits Olmec rather than Maya affinities. This tomb predates by 600 years any other such tomb found in Mesoamerica, such as those at , and at .'\n[16] Compact text span at center-left: 'Cultural affiliation'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'The site is believed to have been settled by speakers, bearers of the culture that populated the Gulf and Pacific Coasts of southern Mexico.'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Chiapa de Corzo and a half dozen other western Depression centers appear to have coalesced into a distinct civilization by 700 BCE, an archaeological culture that became the conduit between late Gulf'\n[19] Compact text span at center-left: 'Regional centre'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'Starting around 100 BCE, during its , Chiapa de Corzo played the role of the regional capital. The city was linked with other areas across the Maya Lowlands, Maya Highlands, Pacific Coast, and Oaxaca.'\n[21] Wide text span at center-center: 'Maya pottery types began to be included in elite burials, although utilitarian ceramics retained traditional patterns. This has suggested to some researchers, that the Maya culture to the east exerted'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: 'Decline'\n[23] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Big changes occurred in the area during the (AD 300-400). There was an economic decline, as craft activity diminished and long-distance ties contracted.'\n[24] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Chiapa de Corzo and a number of western Depression sites were abandoned by the period, a population change that closely coincides with the invasion of a war like group of -speaking people known as the'\n[25] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Manguean'\n[26] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The Chiapanec chose to occupy the adjacent floodplain of the Grijalva River where the modern town is now located, and they left the Zoque ruin on the nearby plateau untouched. The abandoned city now b'\n[27] 215.296875px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Modern developments'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The site has been heavily encroached upon over the last 70 years with the construction of roads, homes, businesses, utility systems, and a cemetery. The Nestl\u00e9 company constructed a large milk process'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Notable finds'\n[30] , description: a group of different vases are shown on a black screen, at bottom-right\n[31] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'pottery from the site'\n[32] , description: a drawing of a house with a door, at bottom-right\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The oldest date yet discovered, December 36 BCE, was found on Stela 2 (which is not a at all, but rather a misnamed, inscribed wall panel). All that survives of the original text is the day-name and'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Chiapa de Corzo is also notable for a pottery sherd containing what is likely . Dated to as early as 300 BCE, this sherd would be the oldest instance of that yet discovered.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The site possesses possibly the earliest example of a Mesoamerican palace complex in Mound 5. This palace was constructed in the first century CE and ritually destroyed a couple centuries later.'"
},
{
"i": 213,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_10_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
13
],
"rationale": "Coordinates now place headquarters near the North Pole, conflicting with Hawthorne, CA in ID 12.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'SpaceX'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '( ) is an American , a provider of services, and a corporation headquartered in . SpaceX was founded in 2002 by with the goal of reducing space transportation costs to enable the . SpaceX manufacture'\n[3] , description: a black background with a plane flying in the sky, at top-right\n[4] , description: a rocket is flying over a city at night, at top-right\n[5] 314.25px-wide text span at top-right: 'Headquarters in December 2017; plumes from a flight of a Falcon 9 rocket are visible overhead'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Type'\n[7] Compact text span at center-center: 'Industry'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: ','\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Founded'\n[10] Compact text span at center-right: '14 March 2002 in , U.S.'\n[11] Compact text span at center-center: 'Founder'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'Headquarters'\n[13] Compact text span at center-right: '90.0000\u00b0N 135.0000\u00b0E'\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: 'Key people'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: 'Elon Musk ( , and , 2002\u2013present)'\n[16] Compact text span at center-right: '( and )'\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'Products'\n[18] Compact text span at center-right: '(in development)'\n[19] Compact text span at center-center: 'Services'\n[20] Compact text span at center-center: 'Revenue'\n[21] Compact text span at center-right: 'US$2 billion (2018)'\n[22] Compact text span at center-center: 'Owner'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Elon Musk Trust (47.4% equity; 78.3% voting control)'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Number of employees'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: '12,000 (April 2022)'\n[26] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Website'\n[27] , description: elon musk is standing in front of a screen, at bottom-left\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'This article is part of a series about'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Companies'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Related'\n[31] Wide text span at top-center: 'SpaceX's achievements include the first privately funded to reach orbit around Earth, the first private company to successfully launch, orbit, and recover a spacecraft, the first private company to se'\n[32] Wide text span at top-center: 'SpaceX is developing a satellite internet constellation named to provide commercial internet service. In January 2020, the Starlink constellation became the largest satellite constellation ever launch'\n[33] Compact text span at center-left: 'History'\n[34] Compact text span at center-left: '2001\u20132004: Founding'\n[35] Wide text span at center-center: 'In 2001, conceptualized , a project to land a miniature experimental and grow on Mars, in an attempt to revive public interest in space exploration. Musk traveled to with and tried to purchase cheap a'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In early 2002, Musk started to look for staff for his new space company, soon to be named SpaceX. Musk approached rocket engineer (later SpaceX's CTO of propulsion) and invited him to become his busin'\n[37] 358.109375px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2005\u20132009: Falcon 1 and first orbital launches'\n[38] , description: a rocket is being launched into the air, at bottom-left\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'SpaceX developed its first , the Falcon 1, with private funding. The Falcon 1 was an expendable two-stage-to-orbit .The total development cost of Falcon 1 was approximately US$90 million to US$100 mil'"
},
{
"i": 214,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_15_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
30,
31
],
"rationale": "ID30 remains \"2,047,\" but ID31 is changed to \"4,000 ft,\" creating a numerical contradiction about the same altitude.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Neuschwanstein Castle'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '( , , : ) is a 19th-century on a rugged hill above the village of near in southwest , . The palace was commissioned by as a retreat and in honour of . Ludwig chose to pay for the palace out of his pe'\n[3] Compact text span at top-center: ':'\n[4] Compact text span at top-center: '[\u02c8\u0283l\u0254s n\u0254\u026a\u02c8\u0283va\u02d0n\u0283ta\u026an'\n[5] , description: neuschwanstein castle - berlin - haus, at top-right\n[6] 314.25px-wide text span at top-right: 'Neuschwanstein Castle in 2013, looking northeast'\n[7] , description: a map of germany with rivers and lakes, at top-right\n[8] 240.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Location within Germany'\n[9] , description: a map of germany with the location of the city, at center-right\n[10] , description: a map showing the location of hohenschwangau, at center-right\n[11] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'General information'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'Architectural style'\n[13] Compact text span at center-center: 'Location'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: ', Germany'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-right: '47\u00b033\u203227\u2033N'\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-right: '10\u00b044\u203258\u2033E'\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Construction started'\n[18] Compact text span at bottom-right: '5 September 1869'\n[19] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Completed'\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'c. 1886 (opened)'\n[21] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Owner'\n[22] 320.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Design and construction'\n[23] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Architect'\n[24] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Civil engineer'\n[25] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Eduard Riedel, , Julius Hofmann'\n[26] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Other designers'\n[27] Compact text span at bottom-right: ','\n[28] Wide text span at top-center: 'The castle was intended as a private residence for the King, until he died in 1886. It was open to the public shortly after his death. Since then more than 61 million people have visited Neuschwanstei'\n[29] , description: a view of a mountain and lake from the top, at bottom-right\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-right: '2,047'\n[31] 219.84375px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'm or 4,000 ft'\n[32] Wide text span at top-center: 'The municipality of lies at an elevation of at the southwest border of the German state of Bavaria. Its surroundings are characterised by the transition between the in the south (toward the nearby bor'\n[33] Compact text span at top-center: '800'\n[34] Compact text span at top-center: 'm (2,620'\n[35] Compact text span at top-center: 'ft)'\n[36] Wide text span at top-center: 'In the , three castles overlooked the villages. One was called Schwanstein Castle. In 1832, Ludwig's father bought its ruins to replace them with the comfortable neo-Gothic palace known as . Finished'\n[37] Wide text span at center-center: 'Vorderhohenschwangau Castle and Hinterhohenschwangau Castle sat on a rugged hill overlooking Schwanstein Castle, two nearby lakes ( and ), and the village. Separated by only a , they jointly consisted'\n[38] Wide text span at center-center: 'The ruins above the family palace were known to the crown prince from his excursions. He first sketched one of them in his diary in 1859. When the young king came to power in 1864, the construction of'\n[39] Compact text span at center-left: 'History'\n[40] Compact text span at center-left: 'Inspiration and design'\n[41] Wide text span at center-center: 'Neuschwanstein embodies both the contemporaneous architectural fashion known as castle romanticism ( ), and King Ludwig II's enthusiasm for the operas of Richard Wagner.'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In the 19th century, many castles were constructed or reconstructed, often with significant changes to make them more picturesque. Palace-building projects similar to Neuschwanstein had been undertake'\n[43] , description: a painting of a castle in the mountains, at bottom-right\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The King saw both buildings as representatives of a romantic interpretation of the Middle Ages, as well as the musical mythology of his friend Wagner, whose operas and had made a lasting impression on'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In February 1868, Ludwig's grandfather died, freeing the considerable sums that were previously spent on the abdicated King's . This allowed Ludwig II to start the architectural project of building a'\n[46] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'It is my intention to rebuild the old castle ruin of Hohenschwangau near the P\u00f6llat Gorge in the authentic style of the old German knights' castles, and I must confess to you that I am looking forward'"
},
{
"i": 215,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_16_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14,
15
],
"rationale": "This creates a numerical inconsistency: ID14 refers to about 60 cm total length, now changed to 300, which contradicts the stated \u201csmaller octopus\u201d description.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Mimic octopus'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The ( ) is a species of from the region. Like other octopuses, it uses its to disguise itself with its background. However, it is noteworthy for being able to impersonate a wide variety of other marin'\n[3] , description: a large octopus with black and white stripes, at top-right\n[4] , description: a red pen with a red handle, at top-right\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Kingdom:'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Phylum:'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'Class:'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'Order:'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Family:'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'Genus:'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Hochberg'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'Species:'\n[13] Compact text span at top-left: 'Appearance'\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'The mimic octopus is a smaller octopus, growing to a total length of about , including arms, with a diameter approximately that of a pencil at their widest. Small protrude from each eye. The octopus''\n[15] Compact text span at top-left: '300'\n[16] Compact text span at top-left: 'cm (2'\n[17] Compact text span at top-left: 'ft)'\n[18] Compact text span at top-left: 'Habitat and range'\n[19] , description: an octopus is laying on the sand, at top-left\n[20] 222.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Mimic octopus showing typical pattern'\n[21] Wide text span at top-center: 'The mimic octopus was first discovered off the coast of , Indonesia in 1998 on the bottom of a muddy river mouth. It has since been found to inhabit the Indo-Pacific, ranging from the in the west to i'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: '15'\n[23] Compact text span at center-left: 'm (49'\n[24] Compact text span at center-left: 'Behavior'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'The mimic octopus uses a jet of water through its funnel to glide over the sand while searching for prey, typically small fish, crabs, and worms. It prefers river mouths and estuaries, as opposed to'\n[26] , description: a squid is sitting in the sand, at center-left\n[27] Compact text span at center-left: 'Mimic octopus showing a variant pattern'\n[28] Wide text span at center-center: 'Mimic octopuses have been observed mimicking numerous different species of animals, some animals being mimicked more often than others. Among the animals mimicked are (the octopus holds its arms out r'\n[29] Wide text span at center-center: 'The mimic octopus retains the ability to camouflage with its sandy environment. It was also observed to mimic sessile animals such as small sponges, tube-worm tubes, or colonial tunicates.'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The octopus may be able to intelligently use its mimicry based on the situation. For example, an octopus which was being harassed by mimicked a , a damselfish predator. It decides which mimicry behavi'\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Feeding'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The mimic octopus can either be classified as a hunter or a forager. It is believed to be a hunter because scientists have observed and recorded the octopus having the ability to stalk prey and hunt d'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'References'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Norman, M.D.; and Hochberg, F.G. (2005). The 'mimic Octopus' (Thaumoctopus mimicus n. gen. et sp.), a new octopus from the tropical Indo-West Pacific (Cephalopoda: Octopodidae). 25: 57\u201370.'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Maculay, G. (January 6, 2012). . Dive The World - Scuba Diving Vacations - Dive Travel - Diving Holidays - Liveaboards. Retrieved April 21, 2013.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Harmon, K. (February 21, 2013). . . Retrieved April 21, 2013.'\n[37] 200.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: '. Retrieved 2014'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'December 17,'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Coker, Darren J. (2013). Documentation of the mimic octopus Thaumoctopus mimicus in the Great Barrier Reef, Australia. 1-2.'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Nabhitabhata, Jaruwat; and Sukhsangchan, Charuay (2007). Phuket Mar. Biol. Cent. Res. Bull. 68: 31\u201334.'"
},
{
"i": 216,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_17_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
22,
25
],
"rationale": "Suggesting the fruit is 50 km long contradicts ID25, which indicates the tree itself grows up to 25 m tall.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: ', the , is the most widespread tree species of the genus , the baobabs, and is native to the African continent and the southern Arabian Peninsula (Yemen, Oman). These are long-lived ; has shown some i'\n[2] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'African baobab'\n[3] , description: a large baobab tree in the middle of the savannah, at top-right\n[4] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Mature, flowering tree in'\n[5] , description: a red pen with a red handle, at top-right\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Kingdom:'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: ':'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'Order:'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Family:'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'Genus:'\n[11] Compact text span at center-center: 'Species:'\n[12] Compact text span at top-left: 'Description'\n[13] , description: a tree with green leaves and a bird on it, at top-left\n[14] 222.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Each leaf comprises five leaflets'\n[15] , description: a white flower on a tree, at top-left\n[16] 222.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Open flower'\n[17] , description: a white flower with a white flower on it, at center-left\n[18] 222.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Bisected flower'\n[19] , description: a white ball in the dark sky, at bottom-right\n[20] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Two pollen grains overlapped'\n[21] , description: a half of a jackfruit on a cutting board, at bottom-left\n[22] Compact text span at bottom-left: '50 kilometres (31'\n[23] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'in)'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'General'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'African baobabs are trees that often grow as solitary individuals, and are large and distinctive elements of or vegetation. They grow from 5\u201325 m (16\u201382 ft) tall. The trunk is typically very broad and'\n[26] Compact text span at center-left: 'Leaves'\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'Leaves are with 5 to 7 (sometimes up to 9) in mature trees, but seedlings and regenerating shoots may have . The transition to compound leaves comes with age and may be gradual. African baobabs produc'\n[28] Compact text span at center-left: 'Flowers'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Flowering occurs in both the dry and the wet season. Buds are rounded with a cone-shaped tip. Flowers are showy and sometimes paired, but usually produced singly at the end of a 15-90 cm long hanging'\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Fruit'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'All develop large rounded fruits with a woody outer shell. African baobab fruits are quite variable in shape, from nearly round to cylindrical. The shell is 6-10 mm thick. Inside is a fleshy, light be'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'History'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The earliest written reports of African baobab are from a 14th-century travelogue by the Arab traveler Ibn Batuta. The first botanical description was by Alpino (1592) looking at fruits that he observ'"
},
{
"i": 217,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_20_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
6
],
"rationale": "#2 references 424 sols, but #6 now shows 999 sols, causing a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '(rover)'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: ', nicknamed , is a -sized designed to explore the crater on as part of 's mission. It was manufactured by the and launched on 30 July 2020, at 11:50 . Confirmation that the rover successfully landed o'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '30'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'April'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '2022'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: '999'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: '436'\n[8] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Part of'\n[9] , description: curiosity rover on mars, at top-right\n[10] Compact text span at top-center: 'Type'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'Owner'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'Manufacturer'\n[13] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Specifications'\n[14] Compact text span at top-center: 'Dimensions'\n[15] Compact text span at top-right: '2.9 m \u00d7 2.7 m \u00d7 2.2 m (9 ft 6 in \u00d7 8 ft 10 in \u00d7 7 ft 3 in)'\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: 'Dry mass'\n[17] Compact text span at center-right: '1,025 kilograms (2,260 lb)'\n[18] Compact text span at center-center: 'Communication'\n[19] Compact text span at center-right: ': ~400 , 2'\n[20] Compact text span at center-right: ': 7\u20138 GHz, 800 bit/s'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Power'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: '; 110'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Rocket'\n[24] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Instruments'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'EDLC \u00d7 2'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: '\u00d7 8'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: '\u00d7 4'\n[28] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'History'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: 'Launched'\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: '30 July 2020, 11:50 UTC'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: 'from'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: 'Deployed'\n[33] Compact text span at center-right: '18 February 2021, 20:55 UTC'\n[34] Compact text span at center-right: 'from the'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: 'Location'\n[36] Compact text span at center-right: ','\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: 'Travelled'\n[38] Compact text span at center-right: '9.92 km (6.16 mi) as of 24 April 2022'\n[39] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Mars rovers'\n[40] Wide text span at top-center: 'has a similar design to its predecessor rover, , from which it was moderately upgraded. It carries seven primary payload instruments, nineteen cameras, and two microphones.'\n[41] Wide text span at top-center: 'The rover also carried the mini-helicopter to Mars, an experimental aircraft and technology testbed that made the first powered flight on another planet on 19 April 2021. As of April 21, 2022, it has'\n[42] Wide text span at top-center: 'The rover's goals include identifying ancient Martian environments capable of supporting life, seeking out evidence of former existing in those environments, collecting rock and soil samples to store'\n[43] Compact text span at top-left: 'Mission'\n[44] Compact text span at center-left: 'Science objectives'\n[45] Wide text span at center-center: 'The rover has four main science objectives that support the 's science goals:'\n[46] Wide text span at center-center: 'Looking for habitability: identify past environments that were capable of supporting .'\n[47] Wide text span at center-center: 'Seeking : seek signs of possible past microbial life in those habitable environments, particularly in specific rock types known to preserve signs over time.'\n[48] Wide text span at center-center: 'Caching samples: collect core rock and (soil) samples and store them on the .'\n[49] Wide text span at center-center: 'Preparing for humans: test production from the .'\n[50] Wide text span at center-center: 'In the first science campaign performs an arching drive southward from its landing site to the S\u00e9\u00edtah unit to perform a toe dip into the unit to collect remote-sensing measurements of geologic targets'\n[51] Wide text span at center-center: 'The second campaign will include several months of travel towards the Three Forks where can access geologic locations at the base of the ancient delta of Neretva river, as well as ascend the delta by'\n[52] , description: nasa's curiosity rover takes a picture of the surface of mars, at bottom-left\n[53] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Despite the high-profile success of the landing in August 2012, NASA's Mars Exploration Program was in a state of uncertainty in the early 2010s. Budget cuts forced NASA to pull out of a planned colla'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In 2011, the , a report from the containing an influential set of recommendations made by the planetary science community, stated that the top priority of NASA's planetary exploration program in the d'\n[55] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'After the success of the rover and in response to the recommendations of the decadal survey, announced its intent to launch a new Mars rover mission by 2020 at the conference in December 2012.'\n[56] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Though initially hesitant to commit to an ambitious sample-caching capability (and subsequent follow-on missions), a NASA-convened science definition team for the Mars 2020 project released a report i'\n[57] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Design'\n[58] , description: curiosity rover in a large room, at bottom-right\n[59] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The design evolved from its predecessor, the . The two rovers share a similar body plan, landing system, cruise stage, and power system, but the design was improved in several ways for . Engineers des'"
},
{
"i": 218,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_21_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12,
15
],
"rationale": "Introduces an impossible timeline, since ID 12 references construction beginning in 2006 yet claims it was on hold \u201cas of 1700.\u201d",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Palm Islands'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The are three , , and , on the coast of , . The Palm Islands are a major tourist destination within Dubai. Creation of the islands started in 2001.'\n[3] , description: a plane flying over the ocean and islands, at top-right\n[4] 222.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Palm Islands from the air'\n[5] , description: a map of dubai showing the location of the selected new developments, at top-right\n[6] 222.0px-wide text span at top-right: '2010 map of developments, including Palm Jebel Ali, Palm Jumeirah, Palm Deira, The World, The Universe (not shown here) and Dubai Waterfront'\n[7] Compact text span at top-left: 'Islands'\n[8] , description: a plane flying over the palm tree in dubai, at center-right\n[9] Wide text span at top-center: '( ) is the site of numerous private residences and hotels. From the air, the archipelago resembles a stylized palm tree within a circle. Construction began in 2001 and was largely financed from Dubai'\n[10] Compact text span at top-left: '25\u00b007\u203200\u2033N'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: '55\u00b008\u203200\u2033E'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: '( ) is a similar archipelago with a larger palm tree, a larger crescent around it and space between the crescent and the tree to dredge island boardwalks that circle the fronds of the palm and spell o'\n[13] Compact text span at top-left: '25\u00b000\u2032N'\n[14] Compact text span at top-left: '54\u00b059\u2032E'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'as of 1700'\n[16] Wide text span at top-center: '( ) are four undeveloped off the coast of , . As of today, little development has taken place on the islands due to the .'\n[17] Compact text span at top-left: '25.3333\u00b0N 55.2681\u00b0E'\n[18] 233.921875px-wide text span at top-left: 'Environmental concerns'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'The construction of The Palm Islands has had a significant impact on the surrounding environment, resulting in changes to area wildlife, , alongshore sediment transport and wave patterns. Sediment sti'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'has criticized The Palm Islands for lack of sustainability, and non-profit environmental news service has reported on Dubai's artificial islands, stating that:'\n[21] Wide text span at center-center: 'Significant changes in the maritime environment [of Dubai'\n[22] 208.59375px-wide text span at center-left: 'Structural importance'\n[23] Wide text span at center-center: 'Palm Jumeirah was built entirely from sand and rocks (no concrete or steel was used to build the island). This was done in accordance with the order of the , who came up with the idea for the Palm Isl'\n[24] 310.609375px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Construction resources involved'\n[25] Wide text span at bottom-center: '5.5 million cubic meters of rock brought from over 16 quarries in Dubai.'\n[26] Wide text span at bottom-center: '94 million cubic meters of sand brought from deep sea beds 6 nautical miles from the coast of Dubai.'\n[27] Wide text span at bottom-center: '700 tons of limestone'\n[28] 229.953125px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Project risks and threats'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Sinking'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Waves 2 meters high.'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Annual or biennial storm frequency.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weak soil due to constant exposure to rising sea water.'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Water pollution.'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Hidden problems'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Erosion (caused by winds and water currents) is one of the biggest problems present, as it strips away the sand which forms the majority of the island.'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Damage to the marine ecology (e.g. the loss of reefs and fish), including disturbances in the reproductive cycles of the species of fish that were close to the shores of Dubai. Research conducted by m'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Due to the shape of the island right outside the coast of Dubai, there is loss of coastal shape along the seashore of Dubai.'\n[38] 366.5625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Obstacles after the island construction'"
},
{
"i": 219,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_28_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15
],
"rationale": "This creates a jarring thematic mismatch among scholarly archive references.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Albert Einstein Archives'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'refers to an archive on the ( ) campus of the in housing the personal papers of 20th century physicist .'\n[3] , description: a building with a grassy area in front of it, at top-right\n[4] Compact text span at top-center: 'Location'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'Coordinates'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Branches'\n[7] 210.234375px-wide text span at top-right: '1'\n[8] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Other information'\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: 'Affiliation'\n[10] Compact text span at top-center: 'Website'\n[11] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Map'\n[12] , description: a map showing the location of jerusalem, at center-right\n[13] Compact text span at top-left: 'Overview'\n[14] , description: a large wall with a large sign and stairs, at center-right\n[15] 222.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Creepy haunted house from 1896 film reel'\n[16] Wide text span at top-center: 'In his will, Albert Einstein left the Hebrew University his personal papers and the copyright to them. The Albert Einstein Archives contain some 55,000 items. In March 2012, the University announced t'\n[17] Compact text span at top-left: 'History'\n[18] , description: a document with writing on it, at center-right\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Albert Einstein visited in 1923 for 12 days, giving the first lecture at the campus of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem\u2014two years before the University opened in 1925. , the president of the Execut'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'Einstein did not save all of his written material, but from 1919, as his fame increased, he employed his stepdaughter as a secretarial assistant. (1896\u20131982) began working for Einstein with increased'\n[21] Wide text span at center-center: 'Einstein's 1950 will appointed Helen Dukas and as trustees of the estate and stated, [A'\n[22] Wide text span at center-center: 'In 1982, the Einstein Estate transferred Einstein's personal papers to the in Jerusalem. President of The Hebrew University and of the worked on the transfer of the material to Jerusalem. In subsequen'\n[23] , description: a document showing the birth of a man, at bottom-right\n[24] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'U.S. Declaration of Intent, Albert Einstein'\n[25] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The first curator of the Einstein Archives was Ze'ev Rosenkranz whose term extended from 1989 to 2003. The catalogue was made available online in 2003. Since 2004, Roni Grosz has been the head of the'\n[26] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'See also'\n[27] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'References'\n[28] Wide text span at bottom-center: '. Retrieved 2016'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-right: '4 January'\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-center: '. Retrieved 2022'\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'February 23,'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-right: '. Retrieved 2012'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'March 20,'"
},
{
"i": 220,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_32_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
18
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the same setting as a pizzeria in Rome, conflicting with \u201cYum cha\u201d (ID 1) in Hong Kong",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Yum cha'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'is the tradition of involving and The practice is popular in -speaking regions, including province, province, , and . It is also carried out in other regions worldwide where there are communities. gen'\n[3] , description: a large chinese banquet hall with many people eating, at top-right\n[4] Compact text span at top-right: '\u98f2\u8336'\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '\u996e\u8336'\n[6] Compact text span at top-right: 'Literal meaning'\n[7] Compact text span at top-right: 'drink tea'\n[8] 220.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Transcriptions'\n[9] Compact text span at top-left: 'Description'\n[10] , description: a street with many buildings and cars, at center-right\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: '( ; drink tea), also known as ( : \u98df\u9ede\u5fc3), is the tradition of involving and . The practice is popular in Cantonese-speaking regions such as Guangdong, Guangxi, Hong Kong, and Macau. It is also carried o'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: ';'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'y\u01d0n ch\u00e1'\n[14] Compact text span at top-left: 'jam2 caa4'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'y\u00e1m ch\u00e0'\n[16] Wide text span at top-center: 'generally involves small portions of steamed, pan-fried, or deep-fried dishes served in bamboo steamers, which are designed to be eaten communally and washed down with hot tea. Traditionally, the elde'\n[17] , description: a restaurant with many tables and chairs, at center-right\n[18] 222.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Overhead view of a pizzeria in downtown Rome, Italy'\n[19] Compact text span at top-left: 'Etymology'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'in the Cantonese language, both literary and vernacular, literally means drink tea. \u98f2 means to drink, and \u8336 means tea. The term is also used interchangeably with (\u5606\u8336) in the Cantonese language, which'\n[21] Wide text span at center-center: 'In Cantonese, refers to having a meal with dishes. is the English word based a Cantonese pronunciation of \u9ede\u5fc3.'\n[22] Wide text span at center-center: 'In colloquial dialects and Standard Vernacular Chinese based on one form of colloquial Mandarin, this character ( ) is often used to mean \u98f2 for the verb drink. In the Chinese language, \u9ede\u5fc3 refers to a'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '\u559d'\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'In the English language, refers to the small-dish appetizers and desserts.'\n[25] Wide text span at center-center: 'In Australia, the term is specifically used to describe Cantonese restaurants serving from pushable carts, rather than .'\n[26] , description: a table with bowls of food on it, at bottom-right\n[27] Compact text span at center-left: 'Service'\n[28] Wide text span at center-center: 'Traditionally, is practiced in the morning or early afternoon, hence the terms ( , morning tea) or ( , afternoon tea) when appropriate. The former is also known as ( , drinking morning tea). In some'\n[29] Compact text span at center-left: '\u65e9\u8336'\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: '\u4e0b\u5348\u8336'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '\u98f2\u65e9\u8336'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: '\u98f2\u591c\u8336'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u4e09\u8336\u5169\u98ef'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The history of the tradition can be traced back to the period of , who first referred to establishments serving tea as ( , 1 cent house). These offered a place for people to gossip, which became known'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '\u4e00\u91d0\u9928'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-center: '\u8336\u8a71'\n[37] , description: a woman standing in front of a table with a tray of dumplings, at bottom-right\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The traditional methods of serving include using trays strung around servers' necks or using push carts. The ( , push-cart) method of serving , dates back to the early 1960s and includes items cooked'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-center: '\u63a8\u8eca'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Many restaurants now use a paper-based ordering system. This method provides fresh, cooked-to-order while managing the real estate and resource constraints involved with push cart service.'\n[41] , description: a teapot and teacups on a table, at bottom-right\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The cost of a meal was traditionally calculated by the number, size and type of dishes left on the patron's table at the end. In modern restaurants, servers mark orders by stamping a card or marking a'\n[43] 213.3125px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Customs and etiquette'\n[44] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The customs associated with the tea served at include'"
},
{
"i": 221,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_34_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14,
12
],
"rationale": "Quantitative discrepancy: claims the location is at the coordinates (0,0), which conflicts with the stated \u201cHuangpu, China\u201d in [12].",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Nanxiang Steamed Bun Restaurant'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '( ) is a traditional eatery located in the precinct in the old Chinese section of the city. It was established in 1900. is a town near Shanghai where the was invented. The restaurant has more recently'\n[3] Compact text span at top-center: '\u5357\u7fd4\u9992\u5934\u5e97'\n[4] Compact text span at top-center: ';'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: '\u5357\u7fd4\u9945\u982d\u5e97'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'N\u00e1nxi\u00e1ng M\u00e1nt\u00f3u Di\u00e0n Nuezhion Meudoe Di'\n[7] , description: a group of people walking down a street in a chinese town, at top-right\n[8] 301.515625px-wide text span at top-right: 'The Restaurant at Yuyuan Garden, Shanghai'\n[9] , description: a map of china with the location of shanghai, at center-right\n[10] 307.265625px-wide text span at center-right: 'General information'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Location'\n[12] Compact text span at center-right: 'Huangpu, China'\n[13] Compact text span at center-right: 'Town or city'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: '0.0000\u00b0N 0.0000\u00b0E'\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: 'Construction started'\n[16] Compact text span at center-right: '1900'\n[17] , description: a person is eating dumplings in a bamboo basket, at center-right\n[18] , description: a group of people standing in a kitchen, at center-left\n[19] 202.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Xiaolongbao'\n[20] , description: a group of people preparing dumplings in a kitchen, at center-left\n[21] Compact text span at top-left: 'History'\n[22] Wide text span at top-center: 'Established in 1900, the store traces its origins to , of . Its main restaurant is now located in the City God Temple area of Shanghai. After 1949, the restaurant was confiscated by the Communist gove'\n[23] Compact text span at top-left: 'See also'\n[24] Compact text span at top-left: 'References'\n[25] Compact text span at top-center: '. Retrieved 2013'\n[26] Compact text span at top-center: '10 February'"
},
{
"i": 222,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_38_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
22,
23
],
"rationale": "This new weight range conflicts sharply with the length data in ID 19, producing a clear numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Narwhal'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The , also known as a ( ), is a medium-sized that possesses a large from a protruding . It lives year-round in the waters around , and . It is one of two living species of in the , along with the .'\n[3] , description: a whale is swimming in the ocean, at top-right\n[4] , description: a black background with a plane flying in the sky, at top-right\n[5] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Size compared to an average human'\n[6] , description: a logo with the words exec lc, at top-right\n[7] , description: a red pen with a red handle, at center-right\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'Kingdom:'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Phylum:'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'Class:'\n[11] Compact text span at center-center: 'Order:'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'Infraorder:'\n[13] Compact text span at center-center: 'Family:'\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: 'Genus:'\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: 'Species:'\n[16] , description: a map of the arctic with blue and blue areas, at center-right\n[17] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'The frequent (solid) and rare (striped) occurrence of narwhal populations'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Like the beluga, narwhals are medium-sized whales. For both sexes, excluding the male's tusk, the total body size can range from ; the males are slightly larger than the females. The average weight of'\n[19] Compact text span at top-center: '3.95 to 5.5'\n[20] Wide text span at top-center: 'm (13 to 18'\n[21] Compact text span at top-left: 'ft)'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: '8,000 to 16,000'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'kg (1,760 to 3,530'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: 'lb)'\n[25] Wide text span at top-center: 'Found primarily in and Greenlandic and Russian waters, the narwhal is a uniquely specialised Arctic predator. In winter, it feeds on prey, mostly , under dense . During the summer, narwhals eat mostly'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: '1,500'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'm (4,920'\n[28] Wide text span at center-center: 'Narwhals can live up to 50 years and are often killed by suffocation after being trapped due to the formation of . Other causes of death, specifically among young whales, are starvation and predation'\n[29] 251.625px-wide text span at center-left: 'Taxonomy and etymology'\n[30] , description: two narwhals with a narwhal horn, at center-left\n[31] 222.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Illustration of a narwhal (lower image) and a beluga (upper image), its closest related species'\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'The narwhal was one of many species originally described by in his landmark 1758 . Its name is derived from the word , meaning corpse, in reference to the animal's greyish, mottled , like that of a dr'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The narwhal is most closely related to the beluga whale. Together, these two species comprise the only extant members of the family , sometimes referred to as the white whales. The Monodontidae are di'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-left: '4'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'm (13.1'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Although the narwhal and the beluga are classified as separate genera, with one species each, there is some evidence that they may, very rarely, interbreed. The complete skull of an anomalous whale wa'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The white whales, (Delphinidae) and (Phocoenidae) together comprise the superfamily , which are of likely origin. Genetic evidence suggests the porpoises are more closely related to the white whales a'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Description'\n[39] , description: a large skeleton of a whale, at bottom-right\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Narwhals are medium-sized whales and are around the same size as beluga whales. Total length in both sexes, excluding the tusk of the male, can range from . Males, at an average length of , are slight'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: '4.1'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'm (13.5'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-left: '3.5'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'm (11.5'\n[45] Wide text span at bottom-center: '800 to 1,600'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-left: '3.9'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'm (12.8'\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3.4'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'm (11.2'"
},
{
"i": 223,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_40_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
25,
26
],
"rationale": "This creates a numerical clash with [26], which references 43 to 55 in for the same measurement.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Shoebill'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The ( ) also known as , , or , is a very large -like . It derives its name from its enormous -shaped . It has a somewhat stork-like overall form and has previously been classified with the storks in t'\n[3] , description: a bird walking in the grass near some rocks, at top-right\n[4] 256.0625px-wide text span at top-right: 'At the in , Belgium'\n[5] , description: a logo with the words exec uvlc, at center-right\n[6] , description: a red pen with a red handle, at center-right\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'Kingdom:'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: 'Phylum:'\n[9] Compact text span at center-right: 'Class:'\n[10] Compact text span at center-right: 'Order:'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Family:'\n[12] Compact text span at center-right: 'Genus:'\n[13] Compact text span at center-right: 'Species:'\n[14] , description: a map of africa with orange highlighted areas, at center-right\n[15] 256.0625px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Shoebill range'\n[16] 259.609375px-wide text span at top-left: 'Taxonomy and systematics'\n[17] , description: a brown bird with a long beak, at top-left\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'The shoebill was known to ancient but was not classified until the 19th century, after skins and eventually live specimens were brought to Europe. described it in 1850, giving it the name . The genus'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Traditionally considered as allied with the ( ), it was retained there in the which lumped a massive number of unrelated taxa into their Ciconiiformes. Based on osteological evidence, the suggestion o'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'So far, two fossil relatives of the shoebill have been described: from the early of and from the Early of the same country. It has been suggested that the enigmatic African fossil bird was a relative'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Description'\n[22] , description: a bird with its beak open is standing in a pond, at center-left\n[23] 222.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'The shoebill's conspicuous bill is its most well-known feature'\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'The shoebill is a tall bird, with a typical height range of and some specimens reaching as much as . Length from tail to beak can range from and wingspan is . Weight has reportedly ranged from . A mal'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: '600 to 700'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (43 to 55'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'in)'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: '152'\n[29] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (60'\n[30] 328.203125px-wide text span at center-center: '100 to 140'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (39 to 55'\n[32] 310.453125px-wide text span at center-center: '230 to 260'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (7'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: 'ft 7'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: 'in to 8'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: 'ft 6'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: '4 to 7'\n[38] 277.5px-wide text span at center-center: 'kg (8.8 to 15.4'\n[39] Compact text span at center-center: 'lb)'\n[40] Compact text span at center-left: '5.6'\n[41] Compact text span at center-left: 'kg (12'\n[42] Compact text span at center-center: '4.9'\n[43] Compact text span at center-center: 'kg (11'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: '18.8 to 24'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (7.4 to 9.4'\n[46] Compact text span at bottom-left: '21.7 to 25.5'\n[47] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (8.5 to 10.0'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-center: '16.8 to 18.5'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'cm (6.6 to 7.3'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-left: '58.8 to 78'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (23.1 to 30.7'\n[52] , description: a skull of a dog with a black background, at bottom-right\n[53] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The skull'\n[54] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The plumage of adult birds is blue-grey with darker -grey . The breast presents some elongated feathers, which have dark shafts. The juvenile has a similar plumage colour, but is a darker grey with a'\n[55] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Flight pattern'\n[56] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Its wings are held flat while soaring and, as in the pelicans and the storks of the genus , the shoebill flies with its neck retracted. Its flapping rate, at an estimated 150 flaps per minute, is one'\n[57] Compact text span at bottom-center: '100 to 500'\n[58] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'm (330 to 1,640'\n[59] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'ft)'\n[60] Compact text span at bottom-center: '20'\n[61] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'm (66'\n[62] 227.96875px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Distribution and habitat'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The shoebill is distributed in freshwater swamps of central tropical Africa, from southern and through parts of eastern , , , western and northern . The species is most numerous in the and South Sudan'"
},
{
"i": 224,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_41_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
36,
35
],
"rationale": "This new length (100+ meters) contradicts other size mentions, creating a glaring numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lyrebird'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'A is either of two of ground-dwelling that compose the genus , and the . They are most notable for their impressive ability to natural and artificial sounds from their environment, and the striking'\n[3] , description: a bird with a long tail standing in the grass, at top-right\n[4] 276.578125px-wide text span at top-right: '( )'\n[5] , description: a red pen with a red handle, at top-right\n[6] Compact text span at top-right: 'Kingdom:'\n[7] Compact text span at top-right: 'Phylum:'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'Class:'\n[9] Compact text span at top-right: 'Order:'\n[10] Compact text span at center-right: 'Family:'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Genus:'\n[12] 270.203125px-wide text span at center-right: '\u2020'\n[13] 259.609375px-wide text span at top-left: 'Taxonomy and systematics'\n[14] , description: a bird with long feathers is sitting on a branch, at center-right\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: 'The classification of lyrebirds was the subject of much debate after the first specimens reached European scientists after 1798. The was first illustrated and described scientifically as by Major-Gene'\n[16] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lyrebirds were thought to be like the broadly similar looking , , and familiar to Europeans, reflected in the early names given to the superb lyrebird, including native pheasant. They were also called'\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'It is generally accepted that the lyrebird family is most closely related to the -birds ( ) and some authorities combine both in a single family, but evidence that they are also related to the remains'\n[18] Wide text span at center-center: 'Lyrebirds are ancient Australian animals: the has fossils of lyrebirds dating back to about 15 million years ago. The prehistoric has been described from Early found at the famous site.'\n[19] Compact text span at center-left: 'Species'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'Two species of lyrebird are extant:'\n[21] Compact text span at center-left: 'Image'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: 'Scientific name'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: 'Common Name'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Description'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'Distribution'\n[26] Compact text span at center-center: 'called , , and in .'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'one of the world's largest songbirds, and is noted for its elaborate tail and excellent mimicry'\n[28] Compact text span at center-center: 'south-eastern Australia, from southern Victoria to south-eastern Queensland'\n[29] , description: a bird is standing on the ground, at center-left\n[30] Compact text span at center-center: 'also called'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: 'Named in honour of , the husband of'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: 'between New South Wales and Queensland, Australia,'\n[33] , description: a bird is standing on the ground, at bottom-right\n[34] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Female Albert's lyrebird'\n[35] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The lyrebirds are large birds, amongst the largest in the order. They are ground living birds with strong legs and feet and short rounded wings. They are generally poor fliers and rarely take to the a'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-center: '100\u2013110 metres (328\u2013361)'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'in)'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-left: '80\u201398 centimetres (31\u201339'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-center: '90 centimetres (35'\n[40] Compact text span at bottom-center: '84 centimetres (33'\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-center: '0.97 kilograms (2'\n[42] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'lb 2'\n[43] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'oz)'\n[44] Compact text span at bottom-left: '0.93 kilograms (2'\n[45] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'lb 1'\n[46] 227.96875px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Distribution and habitat'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The superb lyrebird is found in areas of rainforest in , , and south-east . It is also found in where it was introduced in the 19th century. Many superb lyrebirds live in the and around , the and reg'\n[48] 222.609375px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Behaviour and ecology'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Lyrebirds are shy and difficult to approach, particularly the Albert's lyrebird, with the result that little information about its behaviour has been documented. When lyrebirds detect potential danger'\n[50] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Diet and feeding'"
},
{
"i": 225,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_45_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14
],
"rationale": "Turning centimeters into kilometers introduces a major size discrepancy when compared to the inches measurement and the rest of the page.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'List of paintings by Pierre-Auguste Renoir'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'This is an incomplete by painter . Renoir painted about 4000 paintings that have sold at auction for as much as $78.1 million (in 1990). The largest collection of Renoir paintings is at the in Philade'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '1860\u20131869'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'Picture'\n[5] 213.328125px-wide text span at top-left: 'Title'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'Year'\n[7] 230.78125px-wide text span at top-center: 'Dimensions'\n[8] 280.578125px-wide text span at top-right: 'Museum'\n[9] , description: a painting of an old woman in a white bonnet, at top-left\n[10] Compact text span at top-center: '1860'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: '45'\n[12] Compact text span at top-center: 'cm \u00d7'\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: '36'\n[14] Compact text span at top-center: 'km (18'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'in \u00d7'\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: '14'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: 'in)'\n[18] 280.578125px-wide text span at top-right: 'Private collection'\n[19] , description: a painting of a young girl in a gray dress, at top-left\n[20] Compact text span at top-center: '1864'\n[21] Compact text span at top-center: '81.3'\n[22] Compact text span at top-center: '65'\n[23] Compact text span at top-center: 'cm (32.0'\n[24] Compact text span at top-center: '25.6'\n[25] 280.578125px-wide text span at top-right: ', Cleveland, Ohio, U.S.'\n[26] , description: a painting of a man with a beard, at top-left\n[27] Compact text span at top-center: '81'\n[28] Compact text span at top-center: 'cm (32'\n[29] Compact text span at top-center: '26'\n[30] 280.578125px-wide text span at top-right: ', Z\u00fcrich'\n[31] , description: a painting of a man in black sitting in a chair, at center-left\n[32] 213.328125px-wide text span at center-left: '( )'\n[33] Compact text span at center-left: 'Portrait of William Sisley'\n[34] Compact text span at center-center: '81.5'\n[35] Compact text span at center-center: '65.5'\n[36] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (32.1'\n[37] Compact text span at center-center: '25.8'\n[38] 280.578125px-wide text span at center-right: ', Paris, France'\n[39] , description: a painting of a girl sewing a blue cloth, at center-left\n[40] Compact text span at center-center: '1866'\n[41] Compact text span at center-center: '55.88'\n[42] Compact text span at center-center: '45.72'\n[43] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (22.00'\n[44] Compact text span at center-center: '18.00'\n[45] 280.578125px-wide text span at center-right: ', Texas'\n[46] , description: a painting of people sitting around a table, at center-left\n[47] Compact text span at center-center: '194'\n[48] Compact text span at center-center: '131'\n[49] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (76'\n[50] Compact text span at center-center: '52'\n[51] 280.578125px-wide text span at center-right: ', Stockholm'\n[52] , description: a painting of a woman in black and white, at center-left\n[53] Compact text span at center-center: '116'\n[54] Compact text span at center-center: '89.5'\n[55] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (45.7'\n[56] Compact text span at center-center: '35.2'\n[57] 280.578125px-wide text span at center-right: ', Paris'\n[58] , description: a painting of a woman in a white dress holding an umbrella, at center-left\n[59] Compact text span at center-center: '1867'\n[60] Compact text span at center-center: '184'\n[61] Compact text span at center-center: '115'\n[62] Compact text span at center-center: 'cm (72'\n[63] 280.578125px-wide text span at center-right: ', Essen, Germany'\n[64] , description: a painting of a man sitting at an easel, at bottom-left\n[65] Compact text span at bottom-center: '105'\n[66] Compact text span at bottom-center: '73.5'\n[67] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (41.3'\n[68] Compact text span at bottom-center: '28.9'\n[69] 280.578125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ', Montpellier, France'\n[70] , description: a painting of a nude woman with a bow and arrow, at bottom-left\n[71] Compact text span at bottom-center: '197'\n[72] Compact text span at bottom-center: '132'\n[73] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (78'\n[74] 280.578125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ', Washington, DC'\n[75] , description: a painting of people in the snow, at bottom-left\n[76] Compact text span at bottom-center: '1868'\n[77] Compact text span at bottom-center: '72'\n[78] Compact text span at bottom-center: '90'\n[79] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (28'\n[80] Compact text span at bottom-center: '35'\n[81] , description: a painting of a woman sitting on a chair, at bottom-left\n[82] Compact text span at bottom-center: '83'\n[83] Compact text span at bottom-center: '59'\n[84] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (33'\n[85] Compact text span at bottom-center: '23'\n[86] 280.578125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ', Berlin, Germany'\n[87] , description: a painting of a man and woman in a park, at bottom-left\n[88] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'The Fiances'\n[89] Compact text span at bottom-center: '75'\n[90] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'cm (41'\n[91] Compact text span at bottom-center: '30'\n[92] 280.578125px-wide text span at bottom-right: ', Cologne, Germany'"
},
{
"i": 226,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_59_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
17
],
"rationale": "Changing 182 m to 12000 m contradicts 597 ft (in [18,19]), causing a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sculpture'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'is the branch of the that operates in . It is one of the . Durable sculptural processes originally used (the removal of material) and modelling (the addition of material, as clay), in , , , and other'\n[3] , description: a statue of a man laying on a table, at top-right\n[4] , description: a statue of a horse is on display in a museum, at center-right\n[5] , description: a statue of a man sitting on a bench, at center-right\n[6] , description: a figurine of a tiger and a cat, at bottom-right\n[7] , description: the angel of the north statue, at bottom-right\n[8] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sculpture in stone survives far better than works of art in perishable materials, and often represents the majority of the surviving works (other than ) from ancient cultures, though conversely tradit'\n[9] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sculpture has been central in religious devotion in many cultures, and until recent centuries large sculptures, too expensive for private individuals to create, were usually an expression of religion'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'The tradition of sculpture began in , and Greece is widely seen as producing great masterpieces in the period. During the , sculpture represented the agonies and passions of the Christian faith. The r'\n[11] Compact text span at center-left: 'Types'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'A basic distinction is between sculpture in the round, free-standing sculpture such as , not attached (except possibly at the base) to any other surface, and the various types of , which are at least'\n[13] Wide text span at center-center: 'Another basic distinction is between subtractive carving techniques, which remove material from an existing block or lump, for example of stone or wood, and modelling techniques which shape or build u'\n[14] , description: a group of people standing in front of a large rock formation, at bottom-left\n[15] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The term sculpture is often used mainly to describe large works, which are sometimes called , meaning either or both of sculpture that is large, or that is attached to a building. But the term properl'\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The very large or colossal statue has had an enduring appeal since ; the at is the 2018 Indian . Another grand form of portrait sculpture is the of a rider on horse, which has become rare in recent de'\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-left: '12000'\n[18] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'm (597'\n[19] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'ft)'\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-left: '18 inches (46'\n[21] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'cm)'\n[22] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Modern and contemporary art have added a number of non-traditional forms of sculpture, including , , , , , (involving aspects of ), , and . Sculpture is an important form of . A collection of sculptur'\n[23] 210.65625px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Purposes and subjects'\n[24] , description: a group of moai statues on a hillside, at bottom-right\n[25] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'One of the most common purposes of sculpture is in some form of association with religion. are common in many cultures, though they are often not the colossal statues of deities which characterized ,'"
},
{
"i": 227,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_63_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9,
14
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct factual contradiction with ID 14, which still states 44,579,000 km\u00b2.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Asia'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '( ) is 's largest and most populous , located primarily in the and . It shares the continental of with the continent of , and the continental landmass of with and Europe. Asia covers an area of , abo'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '/ , /'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'e\u026a'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '\u0292'\n[6] Compact text span at top-left: '\u0259'\n[7] Compact text span at top-left: '( )'\n[8] , description: a black and white icon of a speaker, at top-left\n[9] 300.65625px-wide text span at top-center: '14,579,000 square kilometres (17,212,000'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: 'sq'\n[11] Compact text span at top-right: 'mi)'\n[12] , description: asia - asia map - asia map, at top-right\n[13] Compact text span at top-center: 'Area'\n[14] 204.796875px-wide text span at top-right: '44,579,000 km (17,212,000 sq mi) ( )'\n[15] Compact text span at top-center: 'Population'\n[16] 204.796875px-wide text span at top-right: '4,560,667,108 (2018; )'\n[17] Compact text span at top-center: 'Population density'\n[18] 204.796875px-wide text span at top-right: '100/km (260/sq mi)'\n[19] 204.796875px-wide text span at center-right: '$72.7 trillion (2022 est; 1st)'\n[20] Compact text span at center-center: '(nominal)'\n[21] Compact text span at center-right: '$39 trillion (2022 est; )'\n[22] Compact text span at center-center: 'GDP per capita'\n[23] 204.796875px-wide text span at center-right: '$8,890 (2022 est; )'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Religions'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: '(26.1%)'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: '(25.7%)'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: '(20.0%)'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: '(11.3%)'\n[29] Compact text span at center-right: '(8.6%)'\n[30] Compact text span at center-right: '(7.2%)'\n[31] Compact text span at center-right: '(1.2%)'\n[32] Compact text span at center-center: 'Countries'\n[33] Compact text span at center-center: 'Dependencies'\n[34] Compact text span at center-right: 'List'\n[35] , description: a british flag with a red, white and blue background, at center-right\n[36] , description: the flag of british guiana, at center-right\n[37] , description: a green and yellow flag with a bird on it, at center-right\n[38] , description: the flag of papua new guinea, at center-right\n[39] , description: a red and white flag with stars on it, at center-right\n[40] , description: the logo of the hong kong government, at center-right\n[41] Compact text span at center-center: 'Non-UN states'\n[42] , description: a green and white flag with a hand on it, at center-right\n[43] , description: the flag of armenia, at center-right\n[44] , description: turkish flag with star on white background, at center-right\n[45] , description: the flag of palestine, at bottom-right\n[46] , description: a flag with red, yellow and white stripes, at bottom-right\n[47] , description: the flag of taiwan, at bottom-right\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Languages'\n[49] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Time zones'\n[50] 204.796875px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'to'\n[51] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Internet'\n[52] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Largest cities'\n[53] 204.796875px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2013 Asia \u2013 World'\n[54] Compact text span at bottom-right: '142'\n[55] Compact text span at bottom-right: '001'\n[56] , description: a map of asia with the country and its borders, at bottom-right\n[57] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Map of the most populous part of Asia showing physical, political and population characteristics, as per 2018'\n[58] Wide text span at top-center: 'In general terms, Asia is bounded on the east by the , on the south by the , and on the north by the . The border of Asia with Europe is a historical and , as there is no clear physical and geographic'\n[59] Wide text span at center-center: 'and alternated in being the from 1 to 1800 CE. China was a major economic power and attracted many to the east, and for many the legendary wealth and prosperity of the ancient culture of India personi'\n[60] Wide text span at center-center: 'Given its size and diversity, the concept of Asia\u2014a dating back to \u2014may actually have more to do with than . Asia varies greatly across and within with regard to ethnic groups, cultures, environments,'\n[61] 250.609375px-wide text span at center-left: 'Definition and boundaries'\n[62] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Asia\u2013Africa boundary'\n[63] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The boundary between Asia and Africa is the , the , and the . This makes Egypt a , with the in Asia and the remainder of the country in Africa.'\n[64] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Asia\u2013Europe boundary'\n[65] , description: a map of the russian border with russia, at bottom-right\n[66] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The threefold division of the into Europe, Asia and Africa has been in use since the 6th century BC, due to such as and . Anaximander placed the boundary between Asia and Europe along the (the modern'\n[67] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The border between Asia and Europe was historically defined by European academics. The became unsatisfactory to northern Europeans when , king of the , defeating rival claims of and the to the eastern'"
},
{
"i": 228,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_66_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
28,
27
],
"rationale": "Now the text reads \u201c9 million square kilometres (1.9 million square miles),\u201d creating a numerical discrepancy between 9 million km\u00b2 and only 1.9 million mi\u00b2.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ancient Rome'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'In modern , refers to civilization from the founding of the city of in the 8th century BC to the collapse of the in the 5th century AD. It encompasses the (753\u2013509 BC), (509\u201327 BC) and (27 BC\u2013476 AD)'\n[3] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: '753 BC\u2013476 AD'\n[4] , description: spr logo on a stone wall, at top-right\n[5] , description: a map of europe with the location of rome, at top-right\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Capital'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: '(and others during the late Empire, notably and )'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'Common languages'\n[9] Compact text span at center-right: '(753\u2013509 BC) (509\u201327 BC) (27 BC\u2013476 AD)'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'Historical era'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '753 BC'\n[12] Compact text span at center-right: '509 BC'\n[13] Compact text span at center-right: '27 BC'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: '476 AD'\n[15] , description: spr logo with a golden laurel wreath, at center-right\n[16] 270.640625px-wide text span at center-right: 'Periods'\n[17] 255.578125px-wide text span at center-right: '753\u2013509 BC'\n[18] 255.578125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '509\u201327 BC'\n[19] 255.578125px-wide text span at bottom-right: '27 BC \u2013 AD 395'\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-right: '27 BC \u2013 AD 284'\n[21] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'AD 284\u2013641'\n[22] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'AD 395\u2013476'\n[23] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'AD 395\u20131453'\n[24] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Roman Constitution'\n[25] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Precedent and law'\n[26] 270.640625px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Assemblies'\n[27] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ancient Rome began as an settlement, traditionally dated to 753 BC, beside the in the . The settlement grew into the city and polity of Rome, and came to control its neighbours through a combination'\n[28] Compact text span at top-left: '9'\n[29] 208.078125px-wide text span at top-left: 'million square kilometres (1.9'\n[30] Compact text span at top-center: 'million square miles)'\n[31] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Roman state evolved from an to a and then to an increasingly during the Empire. Through conquest, , and , at its height it controlled the coast, , , and most of , the , and much of the , inclu'\n[32] Wide text span at center-center: 'Ancient Roman civilisation has contributed to modern language, religion, society, technology, law, politics, government, warfare, art, literature, architecture and engineering. Rome professionalised a'\n[33] Wide text span at center-center: 'The with gave Rome supremacy in the Mediterranean. The Roman Empire emerged with the of (from 27 BC); Rome's imperial domain now extended from the Atlantic to and from the mouth of the to North Africa'\n[34] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Plagued by internal instability and by various migrating peoples, the western part of the empire into independent in the 5th century. The remained a power through the Middle Ages until its in 1453 AD.'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Founding myth'\n[36] , description: a painting of a scene with people and animals, at bottom-left\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'According to the of Rome, the on 21 April 753 BC on the banks of the river in central Italy, by the twin brothers , who descended from the prince , and who were grandsons of the Latin King of . King N'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The new king, Amulius, feared Romulus and Remus would take back the throne, so he ordered them to be drowned. A (or a shepherd's wife in some accounts) saved and raised them, and when they were old en'"
},
{
"i": 229,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_68_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
4
],
"rationale": "Changing the area figure creates a numerical inconsistency with the square-mile data in [7].",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'British Empire'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The was composed of the , , , , and other ruled or administered by the and its predecessor states. It began with the and established by between the late 16th and early 18th centuries.At its height it'\n[3] Compact text span at top-right: '23'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'per cent'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: '55,500,000'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'km'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: '(13,700,000'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'sq'\n[9] Compact text span at top-right: 'mi)'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: '24'\n[11] , description: the british flag is shown in a white and blue color, at top-center\n[12] , description: a british flag with a red, white and blue background, at top-right\n[13] , description: a map of the world with red and pink countries, at top-right\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'During the in the 15th and 16th centuries, and pioneered European exploration of the globe, and in the process established large overseas empires. Envious of the great wealth these empires generated,'\n[15] Wide text span at center-center: 'The resulted in Britain losing some of its oldest and most populous colonies in North America by 1783. British attention then turned towards Asia, Africa, and the Pacific. After the defeat of France i'\n[16] Wide text span at center-center: 'By the start of the 20th century, and the had begun to challenge Britain's economic lead. Military and economic tensions between Britain and Germany were major causes of the , during which Britain rel'\n[17] 201.984375px-wide text span at center-left: 'Origins (1497\u20131583)'\n[18] , description: a wooden ship docked in the water near a house, at bottom-right\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'The foundations of the British Empire were laid when and were separate kingdoms. In 1496, King , following the successes of and in overseas exploration, commissioned to lead an expedition to discover'\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'No further attempts to establish English colonies in the Americas were made until well into the reign of Queen , during the last decades of the 16th century. In the meantime, 's 1533 had declared that'\n[21] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Although England tended to trail behind Portugal, Spain, and France in establishing overseas colonies, it carried out its first modern colonisation, referred to as the , in 16th century Ireland by set'\n[22] 409.96875px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'English overseas possessions (1583\u20131707)'"
},
{
"i": 230,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_71_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
24
],
"rationale": "Replacing a professional entry with an unrelated comedic phrase creates a tonal mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dentistry'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: ', also known as and , is a branch of that consists of the study, , prevention, and treatment of , disorders, and conditions of the (the mouth), commonly in the (development and arrangement of teeth) a'\n[3] , description: a dentist is working on a patient's teeth, at top-right\n[4] 314.25px-wide text span at top-right: 'A dentist treats a patient with the help of a dental assistant.'\n[5] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Occupation'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Names'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'Dentist'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: 'Dental Surgeon'\n[9] Compact text span at center-right: 'Doctor'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'Occupation type'\n[11] Compact text span at center-center: 'Activity sectors'\n[12] 215.484375px-wide text span at center-right: ', , , , , ,'\n[13] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Description'\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: 'Competencies'\n[15] 201.734375px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sub-Millimeter Surgical Dexterity'\n[16] 201.734375px-wide text span at center-right: 'Knowledge of human health, disease, pathology, and anatomy'\n[17] 201.734375px-wide text span at center-right: 'Communication/Interpersonal Skills'\n[18] Compact text span at center-right: 'Analytical Skills'\n[19] Compact text span at center-right: 'Critical Thinking'\n[20] Compact text span at center-right: 'Empathy/Professionalism'\n[21] Compact text span at center-center: 'Education required'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: 'Private practices'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: 'Primary care clinics'\n[24] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Wacky events'\n[25] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'various'\n[26] Compact text span at bottom-right: '-'\n[27] , description: two surgeons are working on a patient, at bottom-right\n[28] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dentistry is often also understood to subsume the now largely defunct of (the study of the mouth and its disorders and diseases) for which reason the two terms are used interchangeably in certain regi'\n[29] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dental treatments are carried out by a dental team, which often consists of a and ( , , , as well as ). Most dentists either work in private practices ( ), dental hospitals or ( ) institutions (prison'\n[30] Wide text span at center-center: 'The history of dentistry is almost as ancient as the history of humanity and civilization with the earliest evidence dating from 7000 BC to 5500 BC. Skeletal remains from (now in Pakistan) dated to th'\n[31] Wide text span at center-center: 'Other practices relevant to include of the mouth to inspect teeth deformity or oral malaises, (study of blood) to avoid bleeding complications during dental surgery, (due to various severe complicatio'\n[32] Compact text span at center-left: 'Terminology'\n[33] Wide text span at center-center: 'The term dentistry comes from , which comes from French , which comes from the French and Latin words for tooth. The term for the associated scientific study of teeth is (from ) \u2013 the study of the str'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u1f40\u03b4\u03bf\u03cd\u03c2'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-left: ','\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'tooth'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Dental treatment'\n[38] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Dentistry usually encompasses practices related to the oral cavity. According to the , oral diseases are major public health problems due to their high incidence and prevalence across the globe, with'\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The majority of dental treatments are carried out to prevent or treat the two most common which are (tooth decay) and (gum disease or pyorrhea). Common treatments involve the , or surgical removal of'\n[40] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'All dentists in the United States undergo at least three years of undergraduate studies, but nearly all complete a bachelor's degree. This schooling is followed by four years of dental school to quali'\n[41] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'By nature of their general training they can carry out the majority of dental treatments such as restorative (fillings, , ), prosthetic ( ), endodontic (root canal) therapy, periodontal (gum) therapy,'"
},
{
"i": 231,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_77_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10,
11
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the first and last figures as Cleopatra and Elvis, contradicting the recognized philosophers shown in #10.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Philosophy'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '(from , ) is the study of general and fundamental questions, such as those about , , , , , and . Such questions are often posed as problems to be studied or resolved. Some sources claim the term was c'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: ':'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: '\u03c6\u03b9\u03bb\u03bf\u03c3\u03bf\u03c6\u03af\u03b1'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: ','\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'love of wisdom'\n[7] , description: the school of athens by person, at top-right\n[8] , description: a painting of three men in a chinese style, at center-right\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Part of a series on'\n[10] , description: a collage of different men with beards and faces, at center-center\n[11] 222.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Left to right: Cleopatra, Kant, Nietzsche, Buddha, Confucius, Elvis'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'Branches'\n[13] Compact text span at center-center: 'Periods'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Traditions'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '-'\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Literature'\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Aesthetics'\n[18] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Epistemology'\n[19] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Ethics'\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Logic'\n[21] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Metaphysics'\n[22] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Political philosophy'\n[23] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Philosophers'\n[24] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Lists'\n[25] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Philosophy portal'\n[26] , description: a black and white photo of a man with a beard, at bottom-center\n[27] Wide text span at top-center: 'Historically, encompassed all bodies of knowledge and a practitioner was known as a . From the time of philosopher to the 19th century, encompassed , , and . For example, 's 1687 later became classi'\n[28] Wide text span at top-center: 'Today, major subfields of academic philosophy include , which is concerned with the fundamental nature of and ; , which studies the nature of and ; , which is concerned with ; and , which studies the'\n[29] Compact text span at center-left: 'Definitions'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'There is wide agreement that philosophy (from the , ph\u00edlos: love; and , soph\u00eda: wisdom) is characterized by various general features: it is a form of inquiry, it aims to be systematic, and it tends t'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '\u03c6\u03af\u03bb\u03bf\u03c2'\n[32] Compact text span at center-left: '\u03c3\u03bf\u03c6\u03af\u03b1'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Some approaches argue that there is a set of essential features shared by all parts of philosophy while others see only weaker family resemblances or contend that it is merely an empty blanket term. S'"
},
{
"i": 232,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_77_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12
],
"rationale": "Claiming there are 85 branches contradicts the visibly listed six (#17\u201322).",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Philosophy'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '(from , ) is the study of general and fundamental questions, such as those about , , , , , and . Such questions are often posed as problems to be studied or resolved. Some sources claim the term was c'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: ':'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: '\u03c6\u03b9\u03bb\u03bf\u03c3\u03bf\u03c6\u03af\u03b1'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: ','\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: 'love of wisdom'\n[7] , description: the school of athens by person, at top-right\n[8] , description: a painting of three men in a chinese style, at center-right\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Part of a series on'\n[10] , description: a collage of different men with beards and faces, at center-center\n[11] 222.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Left to right: Plato, Kant, Nietzsche, Buddha, Confucius, Averroes'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: '85 Branches'\n[13] Compact text span at center-center: 'Periods'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Traditions'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-center: '-'\n[16] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Literature'\n[17] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Aesthetics'\n[18] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Epistemology'\n[19] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Ethics'\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Logic'\n[21] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Metaphysics'\n[22] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Political philosophy'\n[23] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Philosophers'\n[24] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Lists'\n[25] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Philosophy portal'\n[26] , description: a black and white photo of a man with a beard, at bottom-center\n[27] Wide text span at top-center: 'Historically, encompassed all bodies of knowledge and a practitioner was known as a . From the time of philosopher to the 19th century, encompassed , , and . For example, 's 1687 later became classi'\n[28] Wide text span at top-center: 'Today, major subfields of academic philosophy include , which is concerned with the fundamental nature of and ; , which studies the nature of and ; , which is concerned with ; and , which studies the'\n[29] Compact text span at center-left: 'Definitions'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'There is wide agreement that philosophy (from the , ph\u00edlos: love; and , soph\u00eda: wisdom) is characterized by various general features: it is a form of inquiry, it aims to be systematic, and it tends t'\n[31] Compact text span at center-center: '\u03c6\u03af\u03bb\u03bf\u03c2'\n[32] Compact text span at center-left: '\u03c3\u03bf\u03c6\u03af\u03b1'\n[33] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Some approaches argue that there is a set of essential features shared by all parts of philosophy while others see only weaker family resemblances or contend that it is merely an empty blanket term. S'"
},
{
"i": 233,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_78_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
25
],
"rationale": "Stating \u201cAs of 3022\u201d introduces a future date that conflicts with the historical information in [24], creating temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'American football'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: ', referred to simply as in the United States and Canada, and also known as , is a played by two teams of eleven players on a rectangular with goalposts at each end. The , the team with possession of t'\n[3] , description: a football player is jumping up to catch a ball, at top-right\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'Highest'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'Nicknames'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'First played'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: ', United States ( vs. )'\n[8] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Characteristics'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Contact'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'Team members'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '11 (both teams may players between downs)'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'Type'\n[13] Compact text span at center-center: 'Equipment'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: '( , thigh, , and optionally )'\n[15] Compact text span at center-center: 'Venue'\n[16] Compact text span at center-right: '(rectangular: 120 yards long, 53 yards wide)'\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'Glossary'\n[18] 320.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Presence'\n[19] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Country or region'\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Worldwide (most popular in North America)'\n[21] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'No ( at the )'\n[22] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Yes (invitational sport at and Games).'\n[23] Wide text span at top-center: 'American football evolved in the United States, originating from the sports of and . The first American football match was played on , between two college teams, and , using rules based on the rules o'\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'American football is the most popular . The most popular forms of the game are and , with the other major levels being and youth football. , nearly 1.1 million high school athletes and 70,000 college'\n[25] Compact text span at center-center: 'As of 3022'\n[26] 214.640625px-wide text span at center-left: 'Etymology and names'\n[27] Wide text span at center-center: 'In the United States, American football is referred to as football. The term football was officially established in the rulebook for the , when the sport first shifted from soccer-style rules to rugby'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'History'\n[29] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Part of the series on the'\n[30] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Origins of American football'\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Close relations to other codes'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Topics'\n[33] 323.75px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Years'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'American football Portal'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Early history'\n[36] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'American football evolved from the sports of and . Rugby, like American football, is a sport where two competing teams vie for control of a ball, which can be kicked through a set of goalposts or run'\n[37] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'What is considered to be the first American football game was played on , between and , two college teams. They consisted of 25 players per team and used a round ball that could not be picked up or ca'"
},
{
"i": 234,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_81_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "Numerical conflict with #4 \u201c(cm)\u201d making the stated measurement contradictory.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Basketball'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'is a in which two teams, most commonly of five players each, opposing one another on a rectangular , compete with the primary objective of a (approximately in diameter) through the defender's hoop (a'\n[3] Compact text span at top-center: '20 inches (24'\n[4] Compact text span at top-right: 'cm)'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: '18 inches (46'\n[6] Compact text span at top-center: '10 feet (3.048'\n[7] Compact text span at top-center: 'm)'\n[8] , description: a basketball player is trying to dunk the ball, at top-right\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: 'Highest'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'First played'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'December 21, 1891 . , , U.S.'\n[12] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Characteristics'\n[13] Compact text span at center-center: 'Contact'\n[14] Compact text span at center-center: 'Team members'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: '5 per side'\n[16] Compact text span at center-right: 'Yes, separate competitions'\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'Type'\n[18] Compact text span at center-right: 'Indoor/Outdoor'\n[19] Compact text span at center-center: 'Equipment'\n[20] Compact text span at center-center: 'Venue'\n[21] Compact text span at center-right: 'Indoor court (mainly) or outdoor court ( )'\n[22] Compact text span at center-center: 'Glossary'\n[23] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Presence'\n[24] Compact text span at center-center: 'Country or region'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: 'Worldwide'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: 'Yes, demonstrated in the 1904 and 1924 Summer Olympics Part of the Summer Olympic program since 1936'\n[27] Compact text span at center-right: 'Yes'\n[28] , description: a black cat is flying in the dark, at center-right\n[29] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Olympic pictogram for basketball'\n[30] Wide text span at top-center: 'Players advance the ball by bouncing it while walking or running (dribbling) or by passing it to a teammate, both of which require considerable skill. On offense, players may use a variety of shots th'\n[31] Compact text span at top-center: '\u2013'\n[32] Wide text span at top-center: 'The five players on each side fall into five . The tallest player is usually the , the second-tallest and strongest is the , a slightly shorter but more agile player is the , and the shortest players'\n[33] Wide text span at center-center: 'Invented in 1891 by Canadian-American gym teacher in , , , basketball has evolved to become one of the world's most popular and widely viewed sports. The (NBA) is the most significant league in the wo'\n[34] Wide text span at center-center: 'The and feature top national teams from continental championships. The main North American league is the ( is also popular), whereas the strongest European clubs participate in the .'\n[35] Compact text span at center-left: 'History'\n[36] Compact text span at center-left: 'Creation'\n[37] , description: a man with glasses and a mustache, at bottom-left\n[38] , description: a photo of an old basketball court, at bottom-right\n[39] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In December 1891, , a Canadian professor of and instructor at the International Training School (now ) in , was trying to keep his gym class active on a rainy day. He sought a vigorous indoor game to'\n[40] , description: a red leather ball with a metal ring on it, at bottom-right\n[41] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Old style basketball with laces'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Basketball was originally played with a . These round balls from were made, at the time, with a set of laces to close off the hole needed for inserting the inflatable bladder after the other sewn-to'"
},
{
"i": 235,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_89_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12
],
"rationale": "The drastically reduced number conflicts with the context implying many organizations in spaceflight.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Spaceflight'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '(or ) is an application of to fly into or through , either or . Most spaceflight is uncrewed and conducted mainly with spacecraft such as in , but also includes for flights beyond Earth orbit. Such sp'\n[3] , description: two rockets are flying in the sky, at top-right\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Part of a series on'\n[5] , description: nasa's spacecraft is flying over the space station, at center-center\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'History'\n[7] Compact text span at center-center: 'Applications'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'Spacecraft'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Space launch'\n[10] 272.40625px-wide text span at center-center: 'and'\n[11] Compact text span at center-center: 'Spaceflight types'\n[12] Compact text span at center-center: 'List of 2 space organizations'\n[13] Wide text span at center-center: 'Spaceflight portal'\n[14] , description: the sun and moon icon, at center-center\n[15] , description: a vintage book with illustrations of animals and trains, at bottom-center\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Topics'\n[17] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Transport portal'\n[18] , description: a traffic light with a red and green light, at bottom-center\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Spaceflight is used for placing in Earth's orbit , , , but also for such as and space probes, or even for .'\n[20] Wide text span at top-center: 'Spaceflight can be achieved with different types of , conventionally by , which provide the initial thrust to overcome the force of gravity and propel a spacecraft from the surface of the Earth. Once'\n[21] Wide text span at center-center: 'Some spacecraft remain in space practically indefinitely, which has created the issue of space pollution in the form of and , which is a hazard to spaceflight. Otherwise spacecraft are terminated by ,'\n[22] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Terminology'"
},
{
"i": 236,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_95_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
12
],
"rationale": "ID(2) states the empire ended in 651, but the revised ID(12) ends in 751, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sasanian Empire'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The ( ) or , officially known as the ( , ) and also referred to by historians as the , was the before the of the . Named after the , it endured for over four centuries, from , making it the longest-li'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '/ , /'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 's'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '\u0259'\n[6] Compact text span at top-left: '\u0251\u02d0'\n[7] Compact text span at top-left: 'n'\n[8] Compact text span at top-center: 'e\u026a'\n[9] Wide text span at top-center: ': \ud802\udf60\ud802\udf69\ud802\udf65\ud802\udf60\ud802\udf6d\ud802\udf71\ud802\udf72\ud802\udf65\ud802\udf69'\n[10] Compact text span at top-center: '7th\u20138th centuries'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'CE'\n[12] Compact text span at top-left: '224 to 751'\n[13] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: '224\u2013651'\n[14] , description: a square with a yellow and purple flower on it, at top-center\n[15] , description: a black circle with a black outline, at top-right\n[16] , description: a map of the middle east with the names of countries, at top-right\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'Capital'\n[18] Compact text span at center-center: 'Common languages'\n[19] Compact text span at center-center: 'Religion'\n[20] Compact text span at center-center: 'Historical era'\n[21] Compact text span at center-right: '28 April 224'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: '526\u2013532'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: '602\u2013628'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: '628\u2013632'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: '633\u2013651'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: '651'\n[27] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Area'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-center: '550'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-right: '3,500,000 km (1,400,000 sq mi)'\n[30] , description: a black background with a plane flying in the sky, at bottom-center\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Part of a series on the'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Iran'\n[33] , description: persepolis - a city of ruins, at bottom-center\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Ancient Times\u20134000'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3400\u20132000'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3200\u20132700'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3100 \u2013 2200'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-center: '2700\u2013539'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-center: '2400\u20132150'\n[40] Wide text span at top-center: 'The empire was founded by , an Iranian ruler who rose to power as Parthia weakened from internal strife and wars with the Romans. After defeating the last Parthian , , at the in 224, he established th'\n[41] Wide text span at center-center: 'The period of Sasanian rule is considered to be a high point in Iranian history and in many ways was the peak of before the under the and subsequent . The Sasanians tolerated the varied faiths and cul'\n[42] Compact text span at center-left: 'Name'\n[43] Wide text span at center-center: 'Officially, the Empire was known as the Empire of Iranians ( : , : ); the term is first attested in , where the says I am the ruler of Empire of Iranians ( : , : ).'\n[44] Wide text span at center-center: 'More commonly, due to the fact that the was named after , the Empire is known as the Sasanian Empire in historical and academic sources. This term is also recorded in as the Sassanian Empire, the Sasa'\n[45] Compact text span at center-left: 'History'\n[46] 276.046875px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Origins and early history (205\u2013310)'\n[47] , description: a silver coin with a head and a beard, at bottom-left\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-left: '205/6\u2013223/4'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conflicting accounts shroud the details of the fall of the and subsequent rise of the Sassanian Empire in mystery. The Sassanian Empire was established in by .'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Ardashir's father, , was originally the ruler of a region called Khir. However, by 200, Papak had managed to overthrow and appoint himself the new ruler of the . Papak's mother, Rodhagh, was the daugh'"
},
{
"i": 237,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_95_1.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
10
],
"rationale": "This new dating places the empire in a period long after 651 CE, producing an impossible timeline.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sasanian Empire'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The ( ) or , officially known as the ( , ) and also referred to by historians as the , was the before the of the . Named after the , it endured for over four centuries, from , making it the longest-li'\n[3] Compact text span at top-left: '/ , /'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 's'\n[5] Compact text span at top-left: '\u0259'\n[6] Compact text span at top-left: '\u0251\u02d0'\n[7] Compact text span at top-left: 'n'\n[8] Compact text span at top-center: 'e\u026a'\n[9] Wide text span at top-center: ': \ud802\udf60\ud802\udf69\ud802\udf65\ud802\udf60\ud802\udf6d\ud802\udf71\ud802\udf72\ud802\udf65\ud802\udf69'\n[10] Compact text span at top-center: '16th\u201317th centuries'\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: 'CE'\n[12] Compact text span at top-left: '224 to 651'\n[13] 320.0px-wide text span at top-right: '224\u2013651'\n[14] , description: a square with a yellow and purple flower on it, at top-center\n[15] , description: a black circle with a black outline, at top-right\n[16] , description: a map of the middle east with the names of countries, at top-right\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'Capital'\n[18] Compact text span at center-center: 'Common languages'\n[19] Compact text span at center-center: 'Religion'\n[20] Compact text span at center-center: 'Historical era'\n[21] Compact text span at center-right: '28 April 224'\n[22] Compact text span at center-right: '526\u2013532'\n[23] Compact text span at center-right: '602\u2013628'\n[24] Compact text span at center-right: '628\u2013632'\n[25] Compact text span at center-right: '633\u2013651'\n[26] Compact text span at center-right: '651'\n[27] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Area'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-center: '550'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-right: '3,500,000 km (1,400,000 sq mi)'\n[30] , description: a black background with a plane flying in the sky, at bottom-center\n[31] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Part of a series on the'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Iran'\n[33] , description: persepolis - a city of ruins, at bottom-center\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Ancient Times\u20134000'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3400\u20132000'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3200\u20132700'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-center: '3100 \u2013 2200'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-center: '2700\u2013539'\n[39] Compact text span at bottom-center: '2400\u20132150'\n[40] Wide text span at top-center: 'The empire was founded by , an Iranian ruler who rose to power as Parthia weakened from internal strife and wars with the Romans. After defeating the last Parthian , , at the in 224, he established th'\n[41] Wide text span at center-center: 'The period of Sasanian rule is considered to be a high point in Iranian history and in many ways was the peak of before the under the and subsequent . The Sasanians tolerated the varied faiths and cul'\n[42] Compact text span at center-left: 'Name'\n[43] Wide text span at center-center: 'Officially, the Empire was known as the Empire of Iranians ( : , : ); the term is first attested in , where the says I am the ruler of Empire of Iranians ( : , : ).'\n[44] Wide text span at center-center: 'More commonly, due to the fact that the was named after , the Empire is known as the Sasanian Empire in historical and academic sources. This term is also recorded in as the Sassanian Empire, the Sasa'\n[45] Compact text span at center-left: 'History'\n[46] 276.046875px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Origins and early history (205\u2013310)'\n[47] , description: a silver coin with a head and a beard, at bottom-left\n[48] Compact text span at bottom-left: '205/6\u2013223/4'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conflicting accounts shroud the details of the fall of the and subsequent rise of the Sassanian Empire in mystery. The Sassanian Empire was established in by .'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Ardashir's father, , was originally the ruler of a region called Khir. However, by 200, Papak had managed to overthrow and appoint himself the new ruler of the . Papak's mother, Rodhagh, was the daugh'"
},
{
"i": 238,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_96_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
18,
15
],
"rationale": "This incorrectly places the coordinates in the Southern Hemisphere, clashing with ID19 indicating an eastern location for Moscow",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Soviet Union'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The , officially the ( ), was a that spanned much of from 1922 to 1991. It was nominally a of ; in practice and were highly until its final years. The country was a (prior to 1990) governed by the , w'\n[3] 291.75px-wide text span at top-center: '22,402,200 square kilometres (8,649,500'\n[4] Compact text span at top-center: 'sq'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: 'mi)'\n[6] 330.75px-wide text span at top-right: 'Union of Soviet Socialist Republics'\n[7] 330.75px-wide text span at top-right: '\u0421\u043e\u044e\u0437 \u0421\u043e\u0432\u0435\u0442\u0441\u043a\u0438\u0445 \u0421\u043e\u0446\u0438\u0430\u043b\u0438\u0441\u0442\u0438\u0447\u0435\u0441\u043a\u0438\u0445 \u0420\u0435\u0441\u043f\u0443\u0431\u043b\u0438\u043a'\n[8] 337.9375px-wide text span at top-right: '1922\u20131991'\n[9] , description: the flag of the soviet union, at top-center\n[10] , description: the emblem of the soviet union, at top-right\n[11] 337.9375px-wide text span at top-right: '\u041f\u0440\u043e\u043b\u0435\u0442\u0430\u0440\u0438\u0438 \u0432\u0441\u0435\u0445 \u0441\u0442\u0440\u0430\u043d, \u0441\u043e\u0435\u0434\u0438\u043d\u044f\u0439\u0442\u0435\u0441\u044c!'\n[12] 337.9375px-wide text span at center-right: '(1922\u20131944) (1944\u20131991)'\n[13] Compact text span at top-right: '\u0418\u043d\u0442\u0435\u0440\u043d\u0430\u0446\u0438\u043e\u043d\u0430\u043b'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: '\u0413\u043e\u0441\u0443\u0434\u0430\u0440\u0441\u0442\u0432\u0435\u043d\u043d\u044b\u0439 \u0433\u0438\u043c\u043d \u0421\u0421\u0421\u0420'\n[15] , description: russia on the globe, at center-right\n[16] Compact text span at center-center: 'Capital'\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'and largest city'\n[18] Compact text span at center-right: '55\u00b045\u2032S'\n[19] Compact text span at center-right: '37\u00b037\u2032E'\n[20] Compact text span at center-center: 'Official languages'\n[21] Compact text span at center-right: '(1990\u20131991)'\n[22] Compact text span at center-center: 'Recognised regional languages'\n[23] Compact text span at bottom-right: '(1989)'\n[24] Compact text span at bottom-right: '50.8%'\n[25] Compact text span at bottom-right: '17.3%'\n[26] Compact text span at bottom-right: '15.5%'\n[27] Compact text span at bottom-right: '3.5%'\n[28] Compact text span at bottom-right: '1.6%'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-right: '1.5%'\n[30] Compact text span at bottom-right: '1.4%'\n[31] Compact text span at bottom-right: '1.2%'\n[32] Compact text span at bottom-right: '4.1%'\n[33] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Religion'\n[34] Compact text span at bottom-right: '( ) ( )'\n[35] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'Government'\n[36] Compact text span at bottom-right: '(1922\u20131924)'\n[37] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'under a (1924\u20131927)'\n[38] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'under a (1927\u20131953)'\n[39] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Soviet Union had its roots in the of 1917 when the , headed by , overthrew the that had the of the . They established the , the world's first constitutionally guaranteed socialist state. Tensions'\n[40] Wide text span at center-center: 'Following in 1924, came to power. Stalin suppressed all political opposition to his rule inside the Communist Party and inaugurated a . As a result, the country underwent a period of and , which led t'\n[41] Wide text span at center-center: 'On 23 August 1939, after unsuccessful efforts to form an anti-fascist alliance with Western powers, the Soviets signed a . After the , the formally neutral Soviets invaded and annexed territories of s'\n[42] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Following in 1953, a period known as and the occurred under the leadership of . The country developed rapidly, as millions of peasants were moved into industrialized cities. The USSR took an early lea'\n[43] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In the mid-1980s, the last Soviet leader, , sought to further reform and liberalize the economy through his policies of and . The goal was to preserve the Communist Party while reversing . The Cold Wa'"
},
{
"i": 239,
"source": "web page",
"image": "images/wiki_98_0.png",
"question": "You are given a web page that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
20
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with ID 20's area of 55.47 km\u00b2",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Putuo District, Shanghai'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '( ), is a municipal district of , . It covers an area of . Putuo District borders to the north, to the east and south east, to the south west and to the west.'\n[3] Compact text span at top-center: '\u666e\u9640\u533a'\n[4] Compact text span at top-center: ';'\n[5] Compact text span at top-center: '\u666e\u9640\u5340'\n[6] 290.515625px-wide text span at top-right: 'P\u01d4tu\u00f3 Q\u016b phu du chiu'\n[7] Compact text span at top-right: '80.25'\n[8] Compact text span at top-right: 'km'\n[9] Compact text span at top-right: '(21.17'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: 'sq'\n[11] Compact text span at top-right: 'mi)'\n[12] 312.8125px-wide text span at top-right: 'Putuo'\n[13] , description: a large building with a glass roof and a taxi, at top-right\n[14] , description: a map showing the location of a city in china, at top-right\n[15] , description: a map showing the location of a city, at center-right\n[16] 302.75px-wide text span at center-right: 'Putuo in Shanghai'\n[17] Compact text span at center-center: 'Country'\n[18] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Area'\n[19] Compact text span at center-center: '\u2022 Total'\n[20] 219.59375px-wide text span at center-right: '55.47 km (21.42 sq mi)'\n[21] 320.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Population'\n[22] 219.59375px-wide text span at center-right: '879,213 people (on the Shanghai Hukou Register) 1,288,881 people (residents)'\n[23] Compact text span at center-center: '\u2022 Density'\n[24] 219.59375px-wide text span at center-right: '15,651/km (40,540/sq mi)'\n[25] 219.59375px-wide text span at center-right: '( )'\n[26] 202.34375px-wide text span at center-right: '200060'\n[27] Compact text span at center-center: 'Website'\n[28] Compact text span at center-right: 'Putuo District'\n[29] Compact text span at bottom-right: 'Transcriptions'\n[30] , description: renaissance hotel shanghai, at bottom-right\n[31] 222.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Renaissance Shanghai Putuo Hotel sign.'\n[32] Compact text span at top-left: 'Overview'\n[33] Wide text span at top-center: 'The name of Putuo District comes from Putuo Road, located within the district. crosses the Putuo District and makes up the eastern boundary of the area, shared by . The Shanghai Putuo District People''\n[34] Wide text span at top-center: 'The , , and are located in the district. The is in Putuo District. has a Putuo campus.'\n[35] 236.671875px-wide text span at top-left: 'Administrative divisions'\n[36] Wide text span at top-center: 'Putuo District has eight subdistricts and two townships. Below is a list of subdistricts and towns in Putuo District.'\n[37] Compact text span at center-left: 'Name'\n[38] Compact text span at center-center: 'Romanization'\n[39] Compact text span at center-center: 'Population (2010)'\n[40] Compact text span at center-center: 'Area (km )'\n[41] Compact text span at center-left: 'Caoyang Xincun Subdistrict'\n[42] Compact text span at center-left: '\u66f9\u6768\u65b0\u6751\u8857\u9053'\n[43] Compact text span at center-left: 'C\u00e1oy\u00e1ng X\u012bnc\u016bn Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[44] Compact text span at center-center: 'dzo yan sin tsen ka do'\n[45] Compact text span at center-center: '98,267'\n[46] Compact text span at center-center: '1.36'\n[47] Compact text span at center-left: 'Changfeng Xincun Subdistrict'\n[48] Compact text span at center-left: '\u957f\u98ce\u65b0\u6751\u8857\u9053'\n[49] Compact text span at center-left: 'Ch\u00e1ngf\u0113ng X\u012bnc\u016bn Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[50] Compact text span at center-center: 'dzan tzan fon sin tsen ka do'\n[51] Compact text span at center-center: '120,920'\n[52] Compact text span at center-center: '5.80'\n[53] Compact text span at center-left: '\u957f\u5bff\u8def\u8857\u9053'\n[54] Compact text span at center-left: 'Ch\u00e1ngsh\u00f2ul\u00f9 Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[55] Compact text span at center-center: 'dzan tzan zoe lu ka do'\n[56] Compact text span at center-center: '128,647'\n[57] Compact text span at center-center: '3.98'\n[58] Compact text span at center-left: 'Ganquan Road Subdistrict'\n[59] Compact text span at center-left: '\u7518\u6cc9\u8def\u8857\u9053'\n[60] Compact text span at center-left: 'G\u0101nqu\u00e1nl\u00f9 Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[61] Compact text span at center-center: 'keu dzi lu ka do'\n[62] Compact text span at center-center: '112,498'\n[63] Compact text span at center-center: '2.34'\n[64] Compact text span at center-left: 'Shiquan Road Subdistrict'\n[65] Compact text span at center-left: '\u77f3\u6cc9\u8def\u8857\u9053'\n[66] Compact text span at center-left: 'Sh\u00edqu\u00e1nl\u00f9 Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[67] Compact text span at center-center: 'zaq dzi lu ka do'\n[68] Compact text span at center-center: '120,217'\n[69] Compact text span at center-center: '3.48'\n[70] Compact text span at center-left: 'Yichuan Road Subdistrict'\n[71] Compact text span at center-left: '\u5b9c\u5ddd\u8def\u8857\u9053'\n[72] Compact text span at center-left: 'Y\u00edchu\u0101nl\u00f9 Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[73] Compact text span at center-center: 'gnij tseu lu ka do'\n[74] Compact text span at center-center: '111,185'\n[75] Compact text span at center-center: '2.22'\n[76] Compact text span at center-left: 'Zhenruzhen Subdistrict'\n[77] Compact text span at center-left: '\u771f\u5982\u9547\u8857\u9053'\n[78] Compact text span at center-left: 'Zh\u0113nr\u00fazh\u00e8n Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[79] Compact text span at center-center: 'tzen zyu tzen ka do'\n[80] Compact text span at center-center: '172,397'\n[81] Compact text span at center-center: '6.09'\n[82] Compact text span at center-left: 'Wanli Subdistrict'\n[83] Compact text span at center-left: '\u4e07\u91cc\u8857\u9053'\n[84] Compact text span at center-left: 'W\u00e0nl\u01d0 Ji\u0113d\u00e0o'\n[85] Compact text span at center-center: 've lij ka do'\n[86] Compact text span at center-center: '229,925'\n[87] Compact text span at center-center: '3.30'\n[88] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'town'\n[89] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u957f\u5f81\u9547'\n[90] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Ch\u00e1ngzh\u0113ng Zh\u00e8n'\n[91] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'tzan tzen tzen'\n[92] Compact text span at bottom-center: '7.67'\n[93] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Taopu'\n[94] Compact text span at bottom-left: '\u6843\u6d66\u9547'\n[95] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'T\u00e1op\u01d4 Zh\u00e8n'\n[96] Compact text span at bottom-center: 'do phu tzen'\n[97] Compact text span at bottom-center: '194,800'\n[98] Compact text span at bottom-center: '18.83'\n[99] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Economy'\n[100] Wide text span at bottom-center: ', a Chinese maternity wear brand, has its headquarters in the district.'\n[101] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'has its Shanghai office in the district.'\n[102] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In 2009, the region's total registered population was 872,600. The natural growth rate of households was -1.99\u2030. At the end of 2009, there was a resident population of 1,135,900. The Putuo district is'\n[103] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Education'\n[104] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'In 2014, 100% of children residing in Putuo District are enrolled in compulsory education, and 97.88% are enrolled in high schools.'\n[105] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'There are 25 mainstream primary schools, with 34,143 students enrolled, 47 mainstream high schools with 27,542 students enrolled, 77 nurseries and kindergartens with 27,382 student enrolled, 1 vocatio'\n[106] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'Public'\n[107] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Shanghai Putuo District Changzheng Central Primary School'\n[108] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Shanghai Putuo District New Putuo Primary School'"
},
{
"i": 240,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_2_Stouten_20180315_15_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "The new text for ID=1 asserts there is no integration, contradicting ID=2\u2019s claim about integrating with other tools.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'No integration with any external software'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Well organized; organized by topic, not just by date, linking data Organized in projects, studies and experiments, with possibilities for \tlinking experiments. Searchable; information should be easy ...'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '14 March 2018'\n[4] Compact text span at bottom-right: '15'\n[5] Wide text span at top-right: 'Faculty of Science Department of Biology'"
},
{
"i": 241,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_9_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
11
],
"rationale": "This misattributes the presenter to Harvard while the slide shows Wageningen\u2019s logo, creating an identity mismatch.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '9'\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: 'Why switch from paper to screen?'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'John Smith (Harvard University)'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'user'\n[5] Wide text span at center-left: 'readable and structured information digital storage of samples easy collaboration with colleagues'\n[6] Wide text span at center-right: 'time-intensive starting up efficiency limited without Wifi/tablets still under improvement'\n[7] Image, description: a thumb up icon with a green background at top-left\n[8] Image, description: a man riding a bike on a road at top-center\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pros'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: 'Cons'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left\n[12] Image, description: a red circle in the middle of a grid at bottom-left\n[13] 397.62px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'track & trace of samples'"
},
{
"i": 242,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_9_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
13
],
"rationale": "A funeral scene image conflicts with a presentation about switching to digital screens, introducing a tonal mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '9'\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: 'Why switch from paper to screen?'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'user'\n[5] Wide text span at center-left: 'readable and structured information digital storage of samples easy collaboration with colleagues'\n[6] Wide text span at center-right: 'time-intensive starting up efficiency limited without Wifi/tablets still under improvement'\n[7] Image, description: a thumb up icon with a green background at top-left\n[8] Image, description: a man riding a bike on a road at top-center\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pros'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: 'Cons'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left\n[12] Image, description: a red circle in the middle of a grid at bottom-left\n[13] Image, description: A Funeral Home with a clock on the outside. at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 243,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_10_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "This text misattributes the logos in [11] as Starbucks instead of Wageningen University and Research.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '10'\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: 'Official Starbucks brand from Seattle'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Compact text span at top-left: 'user'\n[5] Wide text span at center-left: 'readable and structured information digital storage of samples easy collaboration with colleagues'\n[6] Wide text span at center-right: 'time-intensive starting up efficiency limited without Wifi/tablets still under improvement'\n[7] Image, description: a man riding a bike on a road at top-left\n[8] Image, description: a thumbs down icon and a thumbs up icon at top-center\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: 'Pros'\n[10] Compact text span at top-right: 'Cons'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 244,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_3-0-PNNL_talk_28_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
5
],
"rationale": "The text references Lake Michigan, but the new description mislabels the image as a rainforest in Brazil, causing an identity mismatch.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Going well below the ~4x10-17 39Ar/Ar detection ratio Mini-alcohol in Lake Michigan Reducing 39K backgrounds using liners in the ECR ion source Increasing the actual argon beam intensity In...'\n[2] Image, description: a person holding several small bottles of alcohol at center-left\n[3] Image, description: the great lakes and the surrounding area at center-center\n[4] Image, description: the beach and ocean from a high vantage point at center-right\n[5] Image, description: A forest with many tall trees all around. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 245,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_3-0-PNNL_talk_28_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "The new description depicts a historic battle scene, clashing with the modern beach photo, creating a temporal/spatial incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Going well below the ~4x10-17 39Ar/Ar detection ratio Mini-alcohol in Lake Michigan Reducing 39K backgrounds using liners in the ECR ion source Increasing the actual argon beam intensity In...'\n[2] Image, description: a person holding several small bottles of alcohol at center-left\n[3] Image, description: the great lakes and the surrounding area at center-center\n[4] Image, description: the beach and ocean from a high vantage point at center-right\n[5] Image, description: Black and white photograph of battle reenactment with men on horses at top-center"
},
{
"i": 246,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_4TU_DS-training_DMP_171012_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
6
],
"rationale": "Branding now contradicts the 4TU reference in the image (ID 6)",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] 456.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'Data Storage \u000b& Back-up'\n[2] 456.74px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Made by Harvard U.'\n[3] 456.74px-wide text span at center-right: 'Data Access'\n[4] 456.74px-wide text span at center-right: 'Data Sharing\u000b& Reuse'\n[5] 456.74px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Data Preservation \u000b& Archiving'\n[6] Image, description: the data management plan template at center-center"
},
{
"i": 247,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_4TU_DS-training_DMP_171012_11_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Introduces a dramatic, mismatched tone in the data management context",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 456.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'Data Storage \u000b& Back-up'\n[2] 456.74px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Documentation'\n[3] 456.74px-wide text span at center-right: 'War Arrives'\n[4] 456.74px-wide text span at center-right: 'Data Sharing\u000b& Reuse'\n[5] 456.74px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Data Preservation \u000b& Archiving'\n[6] Image, description: the data management plan template at center-center"
},
{
"i": 248,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_4TU_DS-training_DMP_171012_11_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "Makes an impossible future timeframe for today's plan",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] 456.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'Data Storage \u000b& Back-up'\n[2] 456.74px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Documentation'\n[3] 456.74px-wide text span at center-right: 'Data Access'\n[4] 456.74px-wide text span at center-right: 'Data Sharing\u000b& Reuse'\n[5] 456.74px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Data Preservation \u000b& Archiving'\n[6] Image, description: some people a red and white bus buildings and some pictures at center-center"
},
{
"i": 249,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_6_RSpace_20180315_17_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "ID1 now claims exporting is locked and costly, contradicting ID4 which offers free download.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Export features: strictly locked with a big fee.'\n[2] 573.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'What to export? Selection of content All my work All my group\u2019s work'\n[3] 289.86px-wide text span at center-center: 'What format?'\n[4] 731.68px-wide text span at center-right: 'Where to export ? Download Store in RSpace'\n[5] Image, description: the html 5 logo at center-center\n[6] Image, description: the word pdf on a white sheet of paper at center-center\n[7] Image, description: the word microsoft word logo at center-center\n[8] Image, description: the word xml on a white sheet at bottom-center\n[9] Image, description: the logo for figshare at center-right\n[10] Image, description: the logo for dspace at center-right\n[11] Image, description: the dataverse project logo at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 250,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_6_RSpace_20180315_17_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
11
],
"rationale": "Both ID9 and ID10 are labeled as DSpace, creating an identity conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Export features: convenient and no lock in.'\n[2] 573.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'What to export? Selection of content All my work All my group\u2019s work'\n[3] 289.86px-wide text span at center-center: 'What format?'\n[4] 731.68px-wide text span at center-right: 'Where to export ? Download Store in RSpace'\n[5] Image, description: the html 5 logo at center-center\n[6] Image, description: the word pdf on a white sheet of paper at center-center\n[7] Image, description: the word microsoft word logo at center-center\n[8] Image, description: the word xml on a white sheet at bottom-center\n[9] Image, description: the logo for figshare at center-right\n[10] Image, description: the logo for dspace at center-right\n[11] Image, description: A clock with the Seiko logo underneath it. at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 251,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_6_RSpace_20180315_17_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "The new text is thematically inappropriate for an export-related slide.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Export features: convenient and no lock in.'\n[2] 573.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'What to export? Selection of content All my work All my group\u2019s work'\n[3] 289.86px-wide text span at center-center: 'Chaos begins?'\n[4] 731.68px-wide text span at center-right: 'Where to export ? Download Store in RSpace'\n[5] Image, description: the html 5 logo at center-center\n[6] Image, description: the word pdf on a white sheet of paper at center-center\n[7] Image, description: the word microsoft word logo at center-center\n[8] Image, description: the word xml on a white sheet at bottom-center\n[9] Image, description: the logo for figshare at center-right\n[10] Image, description: the logo for dspace at center-right\n[11] Image, description: the dataverse project logo at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 252,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Mismatched, violent theme in a lab context",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the steps to add a sample to the psp at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | ELN overview'\n[3] 268.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'War zone updates!'\n[4] 371.35px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Attach and edit any type of file'\n[5] 250.65px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Chemical plugin'\n[6] 416.48px-wide text span at center-right: 'Integrated sample management'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'ELN experiment sections for flexible data registration'"
},
{
"i": 253,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_4_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
7
],
"rationale": "Numerical limit conflicts with \u201cflexible data registration\u201d in [7]",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the steps to add a sample to the psp at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | ELN overview'\n[3] 268.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'Direct data input'\n[4] 371.35px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Attach and edit any type of file'\n[5] 250.65px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Chemical plugin'\n[6] 416.48px-wide text span at center-right: 'Limited to 1 sample in total'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'ELN experiment sections for flexible data registration'"
},
{
"i": 254,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_4_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "Impossible temporal/spatial setting conflicts with modern software",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the steps to add a sample to the psp at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | ELN overview'\n[3] 268.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'Direct data input'\n[4] 371.35px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Filmed on Mars, AD 1750 No suits'\n[5] 250.65px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Chemical plugin'\n[6] 416.48px-wide text span at center-right: 'Integrated sample management'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'ELN experiment sections for flexible data registration'"
},
{
"i": 255,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_6_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "A 19th-century blueprint for contemporary roles in ID2 introduces a temporal inconsistency.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the structure of the project at center-left\n[2] Wide text span at center-right: 'Access control & collaboration User based access Collaboration and sharing in groups Permissions based on roles System roles System administrator Organisation administrator Group Administrator End-us...'\n[3] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | Structure'\n[4] Image, description: A modern computer desk with computer and accessories. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 256,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_7_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "Contradicts \"Portability\" in ID 5 with \"Immobility\" in ID 6.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word pdf on a white background at bottom-center\n[2] Image, description: the microsoft excel logo at bottom-center\n[3] Image, description: the word html on a white background at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the word api on a cloud at bottom-right\n[5] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | Portability'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data immobility'\n[7] Image, description: the logo for elab journal at center-center"
},
{
"i": 257,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_7_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "A wedding image is thematically out of place with the lab\u2010related text in ID 5.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word pdf on a white background at bottom-center\n[2] Image, description: the microsoft excel logo at bottom-center\n[3] Image, description: the word html on a white background at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the word api on a cloud at bottom-right\n[5] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | Portability'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data portability'\n[7] Image, description: A display of various floral arrangements at a wedding. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 258,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_7_eLABJournal_20180315_7_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "This futuristic reference to a mythical city conflicts with the modern context in ID 5.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word pdf on a white background at bottom-center\n[2] Image, description: the microsoft excel logo at bottom-center\n[3] Image, description: the word html on a white background at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the word api on a cloud at bottom-right\n[5] Wide text span at top-right: 'eLABJournal | Portability'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data portability'\n[7] Image, description: A map of the world hanging on a brick wall in a kitchen at center-center"
},
{
"i": 259,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_11A_S6d_0900_Ainsworth_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "Slide #1 now claims there are no barriers, while slide #3 explicitly addresses \u201cBarriers to Open Science,\u201d creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 644.76px-wide text span at center-left: 'Open Science Has No Barriers'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Fear of Scooping or ideas being stolen Not being credited for ideas Errors and public humiliation Risk to reputation Reduced scientific quality Information overload Lack of awareness and training Cult...'\n[3] 644.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'From Tennant, Jon (2017): Barriers to Open Science for junior researchers. https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5383711.v1'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Dr. Rachael Ainsworth - @rachaelevelyn - EWASS/NAM 2018'\n[5] 600.08px-wide text span at bottom-left: '5 April @ 9:00 - Room 11A - S6d'\n[6] 334.89px-wide text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[7] Image, description: a woman holding a laptop and saying, if you share your data people might need to make it human at center-right\n[8] 571.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5558653'"
},
{
"i": 260,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_11A_S6d_0900_Ainsworth_4_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "An academic conference schedule (slide #4) conflicts with the now party-like context (slide #5), creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 644.76px-wide text span at center-left: 'Barriers to Open Science'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Fear of Scooping or ideas being stolen Not being credited for ideas Errors and public humiliation Risk to reputation Reduced scientific quality Information overload Lack of awareness and training Cult...'\n[3] 644.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'From Tennant, Jon (2017): Barriers to Open Science for junior researchers. https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5383711.v1'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Dr. Rachael Ainsworth - @rachaelevelyn - EWASS/NAM 2018'\n[5] 600.08px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Midnight Rave @ City Club - Ages 21+'\n[6] 334.89px-wide text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[7] Image, description: a woman holding a laptop and saying, if you share your data people might need to make it human at center-right\n[8] 571.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5558653'"
},
{
"i": 261,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_11A_S6d_0900_Ainsworth_4_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Slide #4 references \u201c2018,\u201d while slide #5 now indicates the year \u201c3018,\u201d creating a direct temporal contradiction.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 644.76px-wide text span at center-left: 'Barriers to Open Science'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Fear of Scooping or ideas being stolen Not being credited for ideas Errors and public humiliation Risk to reputation Reduced scientific quality Information overload Lack of awareness and training Cult...'\n[3] 644.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'From Tennant, Jon (2017): Barriers to Open Science for junior researchers. https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5383711.v1'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Dr. Rachael Ainsworth - @rachaelevelyn - EWASS/NAM 2018'\n[5] 600.08px-wide text span at bottom-left: '5 April 3018 @ 9:00 - Room 11A - S6d'\n[6] 334.89px-wide text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[7] Image, description: a woman holding a laptop and saying, if you share your data people might need to make it human at center-right\n[8] 571.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5558653'"
},
{
"i": 262,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20-0-LRUAW-Williams_V1_wide_16_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "This celebratory message is thematically out of place in a scientific discussion.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Best Estimate of ~50x 39Ar in P10 (part 2)'\n[2] Compact text span at bottom-right: '16'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'The last correction needed is specific to the measurement of an 39Ar standard and is to account for the natural 39Ar that is present in the P10 count gas used to record background spectra and thus use...'\n[4] 512.34px-wide text span at center-center: 'Based on Benetti\u2019s estimate from 2007'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Using EGS-4 to estimate W/T Corrections: 9.85x10-5 Bq/cm3'\n[6] 414.34px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Celebrate new giraffe at city zoo!'"
},
{
"i": 263,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_2018_06_27_IGSM_Valencia_GreyValue_28_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Mentioning an ancient empire and space travel creates an impossible timeline and location relative to the modern context of [5].",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'git cloud services'\n[2] Compact text span at bottom-right: '28'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'community hold: open source - centralised - owned by a community - decentral self-hosting possible via Gitea / Gogs'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'logos by the Incan empire in 12th century across outer space #!'\n[5] 524.48px-wide text span at center-right: 'TeaHub by Gitea & Gogs'\n[6] Image, description: the word goos in a green cup at center-center\n[7] Image, description: the gears logo at center-right\n[8] Image, description: people in a circle around a coffee cup at center-center\n[9] Image, description: the logo for the international geospatial student meeting at top-right"
},
{
"i": 264,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_2018-07_liber-next-gen-repos_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
6
],
"rationale": "\u201cIncompatibility\u201d directly clashes with [6] which remains \u201cInteroperability.\u201d",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Current repositories'\n[2] 555.93px-wide text span at top-left: 'Services we can develop with repositories today'\n[3] 340.91px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Persistence layer'\n[4] 340.91px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Persistence layer'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Incompatibility'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Interoperability'\n[7] 215.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Metadata'\n[8] 242.89px-wide text span at center-center: 'Usage interactions and metrics'\n[9] Compact text span at center-right: 'Content'\n[10] 288.53px-wide text span at center-right: 'Links between resources'\n[11] 278.77px-wide text span at center-right: 'Notifications'\n[12] Wide text span at center-right: 'Global sign-on'\n[13] 242.89px-wide text span at center-right: 'Comments'\n[14] 242.89px-wide text span at center-right: 'Peer-reviews'\n[15] 240.72px-wide text span at center-right: 'Messages'\n[16] 767.8px-wide text span at center-left: 'Metadata'\n[17] 674.81px-wide text span at top-right: 'Services we can develop with the next generation repositories'\n[18] Wide text span at top-right: 'Next generation repositories'\n[19] 347.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Conceptual layer'\n[20] 347.22px-wide text span at center-center: 'Conceptual layer'\n[21] 314.63px-wide text span at center-center: 'Discovery mechanisms Batch Navigation Notification'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: 'Batch discovery'"
},
{
"i": 265,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_2018-07_liber-next-gen-repos_11_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "A reference to funeral rites is contextually at odds with software content in [9].",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Current repositories'\n[2] 555.93px-wide text span at top-left: 'Services we can develop with repositories today'\n[3] 340.91px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Persistence layer'\n[4] 340.91px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Persistence layer'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Interoperability'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Interoperability'\n[7] 215.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Metadata'\n[8] 242.89px-wide text span at center-center: 'Funeral ceremonies or eulogies'\n[9] Compact text span at center-right: 'Content'\n[10] 288.53px-wide text span at center-right: 'Links between resources'\n[11] 278.77px-wide text span at center-right: 'Notifications'\n[12] Wide text span at center-right: 'Global sign-on'\n[13] 242.89px-wide text span at center-right: 'Comments'\n[14] 242.89px-wide text span at center-right: 'Peer-reviews'\n[15] 240.72px-wide text span at center-right: 'Messages'\n[16] 767.8px-wide text span at center-left: 'Metadata'\n[17] 674.81px-wide text span at top-right: 'Services we can develop with the next generation repositories'\n[18] Wide text span at top-right: 'Next generation repositories'\n[19] 347.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Conceptual layer'\n[20] 347.22px-wide text span at center-center: 'Conceptual layer'\n[21] 314.63px-wide text span at center-center: 'Discovery mechanisms Batch Navigation Notification'\n[22] Compact text span at center-left: 'Batch discovery'"
},
{
"i": 266,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_2018-I2GS-gdpr-nh-v2_10_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "This text contradicts the justice-themed image, creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Unlawful Ways to Process!'\n[2] Image, description: the scales of justice in a green circle at top-left"
},
{
"i": 267,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_2018-I2GS-gdpr-nh-v2_10_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The new label misidentifies the actual scales of justice image as a cat.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Lawful Reasons to Process'\n[2] Image, description: a cat that is on some kind of red couch at top-left"
},
{
"i": 268,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180410 Research Data Management at TU Delft_26_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct conflict with element #2's link suggesting the data is available.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dataset not available'\n[2] 388.52px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'https://osf.io/mz3fx/'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'Special thanks to: Marta Busse-Wicher, Jasper van Dijck and Jan Krause-Blivin'\n[4] Image, description: a woman with glasses and a white shirt at center-left\n[5] Image, description: a man with a brown sweater and white shirt at center-center\n[6] Image, description: a man in a suit and tie at center-right\n[7] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Marta Busse-Wicher Cambridge'\n[8] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Jasper van Dijck TU Delft'\n[9] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Jan Krause-Blivin EPFL'"
},
{
"i": 269,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180410 Research Data Management at TU Delft_26_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "A tonal mismatch: the text suggests a somber context, while the images appear neutral or positive.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Full dataset available'\n[2] 388.52px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'https://osf.io/mz3fx/'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'Our condolences to: Marta Busse-Wicher, Jasper van Dijck and Jan Krause-Blivin'\n[4] Image, description: a woman with glasses and a white shirt at center-left\n[5] Image, description: a man with a brown sweater and white shirt at center-center\n[6] Image, description: a man in a suit and tie at center-right\n[7] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Marta Busse-Wicher Cambridge'\n[8] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Jasper van Dijck TU Delft'\n[9] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Jan Krause-Blivin EPFL'"
},
{
"i": 270,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180410 Research Data Management at TU Delft_26_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "A quantitative conflict: #1 now claims a dataset exists, but #2 reports no dataset is available.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Full dataset available'\n[2] 388.52px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'No dataset: 0 entries'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'Special thanks to: Marta Busse-Wicher, Jasper van Dijck and Jan Krause-Blivin'\n[4] Image, description: a woman with glasses and a white shirt at center-left\n[5] Image, description: a man with a brown sweater and white shirt at center-center\n[6] Image, description: a man in a suit and tie at center-right\n[7] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Marta Busse-Wicher Cambridge'\n[8] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Jasper van Dijck TU Delft'\n[9] 488.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Jan Krause-Blivin EPFL'"
},
{
"i": 271,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180613 DMP Workshop EBI EMBL for PIs_20_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
8
],
"rationale": "This conflicts with the slide\u2019s query about publishing and reusability, creating a direct contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Research insists on the principle that no data be disclosed'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Reusability & Reproducibility'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Final data'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Intermediate data'\n[5] Wide text span at center-center: 'Raw data'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words average fluorescence intensity at center-right\n[7] Image, description: red cells in a dark background at center-center\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Are the published final data reusable?'"
},
{
"i": 272,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180613 DMP Workshop EBI EMBL for PIs_20_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "Misattributing the presentation conflicts with the institutional branding (TU Delft logo).",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Research relies on the principle that we share our findings'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Presented by Harvard University'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Final data'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Intermediate data'\n[5] Wide text span at center-center: 'Raw data'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words average fluorescence intensity at center-right\n[7] Image, description: red cells in a dark background at center-center\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Are the published final data reusable?'"
},
{
"i": 273,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180613 DMP Workshop EBI EMBL for PIs_20_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "A war reference creates a contextual mismatch with the scientific content.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Research relies on the principle that we share our findings'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Reusability & Reproducibility'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Final data'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Intermediate data'\n[5] Wide text span at center-center: 'Raw data'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words average fluorescence intensity at center-right\n[7] Image, description: red cells in a dark background at center-center\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Does this war footage convey a joyful mood?'"
},
{
"i": 274,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180613 DMP Workshop EBI EMBL for PIs_20_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
6
],
"rationale": "Suggesting ancient data from the 3rd century is incongruous with modern fluorescence charts.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Research relies on the principle that we share our findings'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Reusability & Reproducibility'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Final data'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Third century data'\n[5] Wide text span at center-center: 'Raw data'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words average fluorescence intensity at center-right\n[7] Image, description: red cells in a dark background at center-center\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Are the published final data reusable?'"
},
{
"i": 275,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180614 - Informal Learning and the Blockchain Brussels Presentation_14_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "The title contradicts ID1\u2019s \u201cCentral Database\u201d by implying it's an outdated paper-based system.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 487.35px-wide text span at center-center: 'Central Database'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Structure of an OLD PAPER DB'\n[3] Image, description: a man with a hat and a t shirt at center-left\n[4] Image, description: a man with a black silhouette at bottom-left\n[5] Image, description: a blue background with a blue and white logo at center-center\n[6] 318.22px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Users store their information'\n[7] Image, description: a building with columns and a blue background at center-center\n[8] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'Institution'\n[9] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'manages &\u000bcontrols'\n[10] Image, description: three people standing in front of each other at center-right\n[11] 530.57px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Parties consult database'"
},
{
"i": 276,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180614 - Informal Learning and the Blockchain Brussels Presentation_14_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
8
],
"rationale": "The classical pillar building in ID7 is misattributed as a corporate \u201cSony Office,\u201d creating a brand mismatch.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] 487.35px-wide text span at center-center: 'Central Database'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Structure of a MODERN DATABASE'\n[3] Image, description: a man with a hat and a t shirt at center-left\n[4] Image, description: a man with a black silhouette at bottom-left\n[5] Image, description: a blue background with a blue and white logo at center-center\n[6] 318.22px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Users store their information'\n[7] Image, description: a building with columns and a blue background at center-center\n[8] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'Sony Office'\n[9] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'manages &\u000bcontrols'\n[10] Image, description: three people standing in front of each other at center-right\n[11] 530.57px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Parties consult database'"
},
{
"i": 277,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180614 - Informal Learning and the Blockchain Brussels Presentation_14_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
6
],
"rationale": "While ID2 discusses a modern database, ID6 now refers to violent training, clashing contextually.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 487.35px-wide text span at center-center: 'Central Database'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Structure of a MODERN DATABASE'\n[3] Image, description: a man with a hat and a t shirt at center-left\n[4] Image, description: a man with a black silhouette at bottom-left\n[5] Image, description: a blue background with a blue and white logo at center-center\n[6] 318.22px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Users train for lethal combat'\n[7] Image, description: a building with columns and a blue background at center-center\n[8] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'Institution'\n[9] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'manages &\u000bcontrols'\n[10] Image, description: three people standing in front of each other at center-right\n[11] 530.57px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Parties consult database'"
},
{
"i": 278,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180614 - Informal Learning and the Blockchain Brussels Presentation_14_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
11
],
"rationale": "This creates a temporal mismatch by placing an 18th-century date in a slide promoting a modern database.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 487.35px-wide text span at center-center: 'Central Database'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Structure of a MODERN DATABASE'\n[3] Image, description: a man with a hat and a t shirt at center-left\n[4] Image, description: a man with a black silhouette at bottom-left\n[5] Image, description: a blue background with a blue and white logo at center-center\n[6] 318.22px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Users store their information'\n[7] Image, description: a building with columns and a blue background at center-center\n[8] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'Institution'\n[9] 734.9px-wide text span at center-center: 'manages &\u000bcontrols'\n[10] Image, description: three people standing in front of each other at center-right\n[11] 530.57px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Parties consult DB in 1789'"
},
{
"i": 279,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_37_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Implying this image is from the year 2100 conflicts with the December 31, 2015 date on the slide",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Plazi infrastructure: Biodiversty Literature Repository'\n[3] ['Image, description: a document with an orange arrow pointing to the page' at center-right\n[4] Wide text span at center-left: '['Depositing in BLR is adding value to an image: findable accessible interoperable reusable''\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: '['DOI''\n[6] Image, description: A graphic promoting the NaNoWriMo event that authors nationwide participate in. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 280,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ASOF_Bogi_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
7
],
"rationale": "ID1 states WV-overflow is negligible, but ID7 now claims it has a non-negligible value.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Overflow through the Western Valley of the Iceland-Faroe Ridge is negligible'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Bogi Hansen, Karin M. H. Larsen, Steffen Olsen, Detlef Quadfasel, Kerstin Jochumsen, Svein \u00d8sterhus'\n[3] Image, description: the location of arctic mediterranean waters at center-center\n[4] 451.79px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Canonical value for IFR-overflow: 1 Sv'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'IFR'\n[6] 651.41px-wide text span at center-right: 'Arctic Mediterranean'\n[7] 343.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'WV-overflow: 2sv'"
},
{
"i": 281,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ASOF_Bogi_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
6
],
"rationale": "The original image (ID3) shows Arctic waters, but ID6 now mislabels it as the Rocky Mountains.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Overflow through the Western Valley of the Iceland-Faroe Ridge is negligible'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Bogi Hansen, Karin M. H. Larsen, Steffen Olsen, Detlef Quadfasel, Kerstin Jochumsen, Svein \u00d8sterhus'\n[3] Image, description: the location of arctic mediterranean waters at center-center\n[4] 451.79px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Canonical value for IFR-overflow: 1 Sv'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'IFR'\n[6] 651.41px-wide text span at center-right: 'Rocky Mountain Range'\n[7] 343.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'WV-overflow:'"
},
{
"i": 282,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ASOF_Bogi_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "This party-themed text is tonally and contextually mismatched with the scientific slide.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Overflow through the Western Valley of the Iceland-Faroe Ridge is negligible'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Happy Birthday, fireworks, clown show, dancing, confetti, big cakes, disco lights, please come.'\n[3] Image, description: the location of arctic mediterranean waters at center-center\n[4] 451.79px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Canonical value for IFR-overflow: 1 Sv'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'IFR'\n[6] 651.41px-wide text span at center-right: 'Arctic Mediterranean'\n[7] 343.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'WV-overflow:'"
},
{
"i": 283,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_5_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
4
],
"rationale": "\u201cNo mass\u201d directly contradicts \u201cPrimary Production,\u201d which implies the presence of living matter.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Habitat'\n[2] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Primary Production'\n[3] 816.3px-wide text span at center-right: 'Food Web Interactions'\n[4] 331.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'No mass'\n[5] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Benthos'\n[6] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Water Quality'\n[7] 663.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'Inputs'\n[8] 663.62px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fisheries'\n[9] 663.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Socio-economics'\n[10] 539.28px-wide text span at center-right: 'Spawning'\n[11] 868.54px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Movement & Migration'\n[12] 884.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Climate & Meteorological'\n[13] Image, description: the logo for the noaa fisheries center at bottom-left\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data Types for Ecosystem Models'\n[15] 539.28px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Mortality'"
},
{
"i": 284,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_5_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15
],
"rationale": "Switching from an ecological concept to a positive emotional state creates a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Habitat'\n[2] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Primary Production'\n[3] 816.3px-wide text span at center-right: 'Food Web Interactions'\n[4] 331.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Biomass'\n[5] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Benthos'\n[6] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Water Quality'\n[7] 663.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'Inputs'\n[8] 663.62px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fisheries'\n[9] 663.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Socio-economics'\n[10] 539.28px-wide text span at center-right: 'Spawning'\n[11] 868.54px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Movement & Migration'\n[12] 884.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Climate & Meteorological'\n[13] Image, description: the logo for the noaa fisheries center at bottom-left\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data Types for Ecosystem Models'\n[15] 539.28px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Happiness'"
},
{
"i": 285,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_5_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
10
],
"rationale": "\u201cZero spawning events\u201d numerically conflicts with \u201cPrimary Production\u201d depending on reproduction.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Habitat'\n[2] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Primary Production'\n[3] 816.3px-wide text span at center-right: 'Food Web Interactions'\n[4] 331.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Biomass'\n[5] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Benthos'\n[6] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Water Quality'\n[7] 663.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'Inputs'\n[8] 663.62px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fisheries'\n[9] 663.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Socio-economics'\n[10] 539.28px-wide text span at center-right: 'Spawn 0x'\n[11] 868.54px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Movement & Migration'\n[12] 884.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Climate & Meteorological'\n[13] Image, description: the logo for the noaa fisheries center at bottom-left\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data Types for Ecosystem Models'\n[15] 539.28px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Mortality'"
},
{
"i": 286,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_5_4.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12
],
"rationale": "Refers to a prehistoric era, conflicting with modern NOAA data context.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Habitat'\n[2] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Primary Production'\n[3] 816.3px-wide text span at center-right: 'Food Web Interactions'\n[4] 331.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Biomass'\n[5] 663.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Benthos'\n[6] 663.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Water Quality'\n[7] 663.62px-wide text span at center-left: 'Inputs'\n[8] 663.62px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fisheries'\n[9] 663.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Socio-economics'\n[10] 539.28px-wide text span at center-right: 'Spawning'\n[11] 868.54px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Movement & Migration'\n[12] 884.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jurassic & Paleoclimates'\n[13] Image, description: the logo for the noaa fisheries center at bottom-left\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data Types for Ecosystem Models'\n[15] 539.28px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Mortality'"
},
{
"i": 287,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_9_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "This mislabels the diver as an astronaut on the moon, conflicting with #2\u2019s emphasis on marine research.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-right: 'Integrated Data Collection and Modeling'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Long-term dataset of reef fish abundances from ROV-based video sampling Stomach content analysis DNA barcoding for prey identification Habitat associations Movement rates from tagging studies'\n[3] Image, description: a fish and a computer at top-left\n[4] Image, description: a diver scuba diving with a lionfish at center-left\n[5] Image, description: a person holding a bunch of small fish at bottom-left\n[6] Image, description: a dead crab with a knife and a knife at bottom-left\n[7] Image, description: a small fish and a purple fish at bottom-center\n[8] Image, description: A giraffe is walking near a large stone. at top-right"
},
{
"i": 288,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_9_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "The playful party theme clashes with #2\u2019s serious scientific context of reef fish studies.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-right: 'Integrated Data Collection and Modeling'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Long-term dataset of reef fish abundances from ROV-based video sampling Stomach content analysis DNA barcoding for prey identification Habitat associations Movement rates from tagging studies'\n[3] Image, description: a fish and a computer at top-left\n[4] Image, description: a diver scuba diving with a lionfish at center-left\n[5] Image, description: a person holding a bunch of small fish at bottom-left\n[6] Image, description: a dead crab with a knife and a knife at bottom-left\n[7] Image, description: a small fish and a purple fish at bottom-center\n[8] Image, description: This is a birthday party for one of these people. at top-right"
},
{
"i": 289,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Chagaris UF Data Symposium_9_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "This implies modern technology was used in 1220, conflicting with the current-day ROV-based sampling in #2.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-right: '1220 study used advanced supercomputers'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Long-term dataset of reef fish abundances from ROV-based video sampling Stomach content analysis DNA barcoding for prey identification Habitat associations Movement rates from tagging studies'\n[3] Image, description: a fish and a computer at top-left\n[4] Image, description: a diver scuba diving with a lionfish at center-left\n[5] Image, description: a person holding a bunch of small fish at bottom-left\n[6] Image, description: a dead crab with a knife and a knife at bottom-left\n[7] Image, description: a small fish and a purple fish at bottom-center\n[8] Wide text span at top-right: 'Dr. Will Patterson UF Fisheries & Aquatic Sciences'"
},
{
"i": 290,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_CONSERT OPENSTACK PUAS May 2018_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
5
],
"rationale": "Line 4 labels this entity a Digital Twin, while ID 5 now describes it as a physical object from NASA, misattributing its identity.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Building the Entanglement'\n[2] 329.86px-wide text span at center-left: 'Cyberphysical\u000bObject'\n[3] 329.86px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Physical\u000bObject'\n[4] 283.33px-wide text span at center-center: 'Digital Twin'\n[5] 283.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Physical object by NASA'\n[6] 282.66px-wide text span at top-center: 'Sensor data'\n[7] 429.61px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Address or tag info'\n[8] Wide text span at center-center: 'Strong entanglement\u000bThe status of the two objects is exactly the same'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weak entanglement The status of the two objects may be disjointed'\n[10] 353.11px-wide text span at center-center: 'i.e. a pointer to a description'\n[11] 512.15px-wide text span at top-center: 'Each data generated by the ICT resource is sent to the Digital Twin'\n[12] 512.15px-wide text span at center-right: 'Querying the Digital Twin is exactly the same as querying the physical object Data are Status + Sensing Data'\n[13] 524.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The Digital Twin describes the main static properties of the Physical Object'\n[14] 452.7px-wide text span at top-left: 'The physical resource has sensing and communication capabilities and a few states'\n[15] 452.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'The physical resource is not equipped and has no communication means'\n[16] Wide text span at center-center: 'Cyberphysical Object is an instrumented physical Object\u000b (it has al least sensors and processing capabilities)'"
},
{
"i": 291,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_CONSERT OPENSTACK PUAS May 2018_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
11,
12
],
"rationale": "This numeric discrepancy conflicts with line 12 claiming that the Digital Twin has the same data as the physical object.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Building the Entanglement'\n[2] 329.86px-wide text span at center-left: 'Cyberphysical\u000bObject'\n[3] 329.86px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Physical\u000bObject'\n[4] 283.33px-wide text span at center-center: 'Digital Twin'\n[5] 283.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Twin'\n[6] 282.66px-wide text span at top-center: 'Sensor data'\n[7] 429.61px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Address or tag info'\n[8] Wide text span at center-center: 'Strong entanglement\u000bThe status of the two objects is exactly the same'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weak entanglement The status of the two objects may be disjointed'\n[10] 353.11px-wide text span at center-center: 'i.e. a pointer to a description'\n[11] 512.15px-wide text span at top-center: 'One hundred data packets each minute fail to reach the Digital Twin.'\n[12] 512.15px-wide text span at center-right: 'Querying the Digital Twin is exactly the same as querying the physical object Data are Status + Sensing Data'\n[13] 524.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The Digital Twin describes the main static properties of the Physical Object'\n[14] 452.7px-wide text span at top-left: 'The physical resource has sensing and communication capabilities and a few states'\n[15] 452.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'The physical resource is not equipped and has no communication means'\n[16] Wide text span at center-center: 'Cyberphysical Object is an instrumented physical Object\u000b (it has al least sensors and processing capabilities)'"
},
{
"i": 292,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_CONSERT OPENSTACK PUAS May 2018_8_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Implies an impossible timeline, suggesting the event occurs simultaneously across two different centuries.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Entangled in 1850 & 2100'\n[2] 329.86px-wide text span at center-left: 'Cyberphysical\u000bObject'\n[3] 329.86px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Physical\u000bObject'\n[4] 283.33px-wide text span at center-center: 'Digital Twin'\n[5] 283.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Twin'\n[6] 282.66px-wide text span at top-center: 'Sensor data'\n[7] 429.61px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Address or tag info'\n[8] Wide text span at center-center: 'Strong entanglement\u000bThe status of the two objects is exactly the same'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Weak entanglement The status of the two objects may be disjointed'\n[10] 353.11px-wide text span at center-center: 'i.e. a pointer to a description'\n[11] 512.15px-wide text span at top-center: 'Each data generated by the ICT resource is sent to the Digital Twin'\n[12] 512.15px-wide text span at center-right: 'Querying the Digital Twin is exactly the same as querying the physical object Data are Status + Sensing Data'\n[13] 524.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The Digital Twin describes the main static properties of the Physical Object'\n[14] 452.7px-wide text span at top-left: 'The physical resource has sensing and communication capabilities and a few states'\n[15] 452.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'The physical resource is not equipped and has no communication means'\n[16] Wide text span at center-center: 'Cyberphysical Object is an instrumented physical Object\u000b (it has al least sensors and processing capabilities)'"
},
{
"i": 293,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_derome_6_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "ID7 refers to a Russian satellite (Resurs-DK1), but the updated image calls it the Chinese Tiangong-1, causing identity misattribution.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the launch of a spacecraft at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'PAMELA Detector'\n[3] 365.23px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'E.m./hadronic cascades discrimination'\n[4] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '6'\n[5] 272.12px-wide text span at center-center: 'GF ~21.5 cm2sr'\n[6] Wide text span at center-right: '['PAMELA installed on Russian satellite Resurs-DK1, inside a pressurized container.''\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: '['Launched in June 2006, Circular orbit (70.0\u00b0, 600 km). Pamela operations terminated in 2016''\n[8] Image, description: Pieces of china that are put out for display. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 294,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_derome_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "Anachronistic imagery of an old carriage traveling to the Moon creates temporal/spatial incoherence in this modern context.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: '['PAMELA Detector''\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '['E.m./hadronic cascades discrimination''\n[3] 365.23px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['6''\n[4] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['GF ~21.5 cm2sr''\n[5] ['Image, description: a satellite with a red line in the middle' at center-center\n[6] Wide text span at center-right: '['PAMELA installed on Russian satellite Resurs-DK1, inside a pressurized container.''\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: '['Launched in June 2006, Circular orbit (70.0\u00b0, 600 km). Pamela operations terminated in 2016''\n[8] Image, description: A horse drawn carriage traveling down the middle of a road. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 295,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_derome_32_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "A modern skyline set in the year 1450 creates a temporal and spatial impossibility.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Cosmic ray modulation'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'At low Energy (<20 GV) cosmic ray spectrum a\ufb00ected by its propagation in the Solar cavity and the interaction with the plasma emitted by the sun. This produces a modulation of the spectrum which follo...'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '32'\n[4] Image, description: the formula for the emf at bottom-left\n[5] ['Image, description: the sun in the ultraviolet spectrum' at top-right\n[6] 514.77px-wide text span at center-right: '['\\uf0e0 Precise measurement of the different components of CR over long period of time with the same detector needed to understand the solar modulation process.''\n[7] Image, description: The skyline of a city with classic architecture. at top-right"
},
{
"i": 296,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_FinELib_sharing_negotiating_goals_20180704_2_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
3
],
"rationale": "This futuristic depiction conflicts with the historical reference in [4].",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'FinELib in a nutshell'\n[2] Wide text span at top-right: '['FinELib is a consortium of Finnish HE institutes, research institutes and public libraries Consortium office is part of the services of the National Library of Finland for the Finnish library netwo...'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: '['Picture: CC BY 4.0, Museovirasto \u2013 Musketti, Historian kuvakokoelma''\n[4] ['Image, description: a building with a large front' at center-right\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: '['Picture: Public Domain. Gustaf Nystr\u00f6m 1895''\n[6] Image, description: a very large aircraft from a long time ago at top-right"
},
{
"i": 297,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_KUSCH_20180316_2_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
3
],
"rationale": "ID\u20093 is an image showing a structured data platform, but the revised title in ID\u20091 now implies a festive beach event, creating a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Celebrate Summer Beach Party!'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Establishment of CRC 1002 Research Data Platform (modular approach) Collection and interconnection of research data used in publications Persistent resolvable access and \u000blong-term archiving of CRC 10...'\n[3] Image, description: the different parts of the platform at center-right\n[4] Image, description: the logo for the university of medicina gottingen at top-left\n[5] Image, description: the logo for sfb 1002 at top-right\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure design by Bartlomiej Marzec, University Medical Center G\u00f6ttingen. All icons used were designed using Freepik (www.freepik.com) from Flaticon (www.flaticon.com) and licensed under Creative Commo...'"
},
{
"i": 298,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_KUSCH_20180316_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "A serious tech context is replaced by a humorous war theme, creating a contextual clash",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'War propaganda \u2013 comedic segment XOX!'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Stable WiFi connection Sufficient storage capacity Linking net storage devices Long term archiving of data'\n[3] Image, description: the wifi symbol on a white background at top-center\n[4] Image, description: a computer with two drives on top at center-center\n[5] Image, description: a stack of vhs tapes with green labels at center-center\n[6] Image, description: a green hard drive connected to a green cable at center-center\n[7] Image, description: the logo for the university of medicina gottingen at top-left\n[8] Image, description: the logo for sfb 1002 at top-right"
},
{
"i": 299,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Liber2018_Rintamaki_Lehto_Information-Literacy-Course-for-University-Teachers_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "A title about \u201cNuclear meltdown\u201d creates a thematic mismatch with the educational content in ID 2.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Nuclear meltdown'\n[2] Wide text span at center-right: 'Aligned to each other Vision and values Learning objectives Learning assignments Learning environments Teaching methods Evaluation criteria Contents Information retrieval, use and evaluation of infor...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Pilot course: Oct. 2018 \u2013 Feb. 2019 29 participants Moodle learning environment Method: hybrid teaching, multilingual Scope: 5 ECTS Scale: pass-fail'\n[4] Image, description: a conference room with orange chairs and a projector at center-left"
},
{
"i": 300,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Lucarini_Reading_2018_Final_June7_26_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9,
4
],
"rationale": "This implies an anachronistic satellite in 1800, conflicting with the modern spacecraft launch in #4.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dynamical Systems'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Deterministic or stochastic law describing the evolution (orbit, trajectory) of a system'\n[3] ['Image, description: the launch of the spacecraft' at center-left\n[4] 586.4px-wide text span at center-center: '['Foucalt Pendulum''\n[5] 575.21px-wide text span at center-left: '['Rosetta Trajectory''\n[6] ['Image, description: the weather map for the next few days' at center-center\n[7] 470.24px-wide text span at center-right: '['Weather Forecast''\n[8] 557.1px-wide text span at center-right: '['Deterministic \\t\\t\\t\\t\\t\\tStochastic''\n[9] Image, description: a truck with a large satellite on top of it at center-left"
},
{
"i": 301,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_NADDI 4-5_5_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "[1] references an oversample of 18-33 year olds, while [2] now claims only seniors aged 70+ were interviewed, creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Sample: National adult including an oversample of 18-33 year olds'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Notes: This study interviewed only seniors aged 70+'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Size: 1,821'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Response Rate: Landline=AAPOR RR3: 8.7 percent, Cell=AAPOR RR3: 8.6 percent'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Estimated Sample Error: +/- 2.5 percentage points at the 95 percent confidence level'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Metadata in older Roper system'"
},
{
"i": 302,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_NADDI 4-5_5_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This text now shifts to an unrelated celebratory automotive context, clashing thematically with the survey data.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Sample: National adult including an oversample of 18-33 year olds'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Notes: This study contains sampling using landline telephones and cellular phones'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Size: 1,821'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Response Rate: The celebration for our new sports car line was extravagant!'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Estimated Sample Error: +/- 2.5 percentage points at the 95 percent confidence level'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Metadata in older Roper system'"
},
{
"i": 303,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_NADDI 4-5_5_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "The new, drastically smaller sample size contradicts the large-scale, adult oversample described in [1].",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Sample: National adult including an oversample of 18-33 year olds'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Notes: This study contains sampling using landline telephones and cellular phones'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Size: 57'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Response Rate: Landline=AAPOR RR3: 8.7 percent, Cell=AAPOR RR3: 8.6 percent'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Estimated Sample Error: +/- 2.5 percentage points at the 95 percent confidence level'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Metadata in older Roper system'"
},
{
"i": 304,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_NADDI 4-5_5_4.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "This future-dated reference conflicts with the February 2014 survey timeline elsewhere.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Sample: National adult including an oversample of 18-33 year olds'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Notes: This study contains sampling using landline telephones and cellular phones'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample Size: 1,821'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Response Rate: Landline=AAPOR RR3: 8.7 percent, Cell=AAPOR RR3: 8.6 percent'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Estimated in the year 2035 for a study concluded in 2070'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Metadata in older Roper system'"
},
{
"i": 305,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_OCLC_EMEARC_2018_Flaemig_Schuenhoff_DiscoverySolutions_for_Public_and_Corporate_Libraries_Requirements_and_Offerings_9_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "Mislabeling the Ex Libris brand as EBSCO",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Discovery System'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: '\u201cnext generation\u201d interface inspired by web services Search for everything, narrow down & discover'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Index Crawler searches data Harvested in one index Only Index is searched Incredibly fast Ranked by relevance'\n[4] Image, description: a sign with the words'premium' and'premium' at center-center\n[5] ['Image, description: the worldcat discovery logo' at center-left\n[6] ['Image, description: the logo for wso distribution service' at bottom-center\n[7] 314.96px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['WEB-SCALE*\\x0b*Google-Like''\n[8] Image, description: The airplane is painted with special logos and symbols. at center-left"
},
{
"i": 306,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_OCLC_EMEARC_2018_Flaemig_Schuenhoff_DiscoverySolutions_for_Public_and_Corporate_Libraries_Requirements_and_Offerings_9_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "Implies 1850 origin conflicts with modern web-based claims in #2",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Discovery System (est. 1850)'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: '\u201cnext generation\u201d interface inspired by web services Search for everything, narrow down & discover'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Index Crawler searches data Harvested in one index Only Index is searched Incredibly fast Ranked by relevance'\n[4] Image, description: a sign with the words'premium' and'premium' at center-center\n[5] Image, description: the exlibris logo and the words prime s at center-left\n[6] Image, description: the worldcat discovery logo at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: the logo for wso distribution service at bottom-left\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'WEB-SCALE*\u000b*Google-Like'"
},
{
"i": 307,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_OCLC_EMEARC_2018_Flaemig_Schuenhoff_DiscoverySolutions_for_Public_and_Corporate_Libraries_Requirements_and_Offerings_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Changing the heading to \u201cCorporate Battleground\u201d introduces a warlike theme that clashes with the library-focused slide.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Corporate Battleground'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'EBSCO Discovery Service Experience with small libraries Large scope of APIs \u201cLibrary Service Engineers\u201d (Support) Broad spectrum of subjects Displaying content provenance Serendipity'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Primo (ExLibris/ProQuest) Serendipity Usage-based recommendations \u201cProfessional Services\u201d (Support) Installation on premises possible Displaying FRBR relationships Strong focus on natural scientific s...'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Summon (ProQuest) Large amount of open content Good cost-performance-ratio Strong focus on natural scientific subjects'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'WorldCat Discovery (OCLC) Large amount of open content Displaying FRBR relationships Neutral position Local data becomes publicly available'"
},
{
"i": 308,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
15
],
"rationale": "Now ID3 and ID15 both read \u201c05,\u201d creating a clear numerical discrepancy in the sequence of phases.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'ORBEET activities are organized and structured in a way that promotes innovation and end-user involvement throughout the whole project duration. User acceptance and uptake is the ultimate goal of any ...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'WORKPLAN'\n[3] 442.25px-wide text span at center-left: '05'\n[4] 447.3px-wide text span at center-left: 'analysis'\n[5] 442.25px-wide text span at center-left: '02'\n[6] 418.55px-wide text span at center-left: 'design'\n[7] 442.25px-wide text span at center-center: '03'\n[8] 448.18px-wide text span at center-center: 'develop'\n[9] 442.25px-wide text span at center-center: '04'\n[10] 464.85px-wide text span at center-right: 'deploy'\n[11] 460.79px-wide text span at center-left: 'The diagnostic and analysis phases aims at establishing very early in the project the main foundation on which the remainder of the project will be based.'\n[12] 460.79px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'The Design phase will provide the overall technological and functional specifications of the ORBEET framework, along with the architectural design and will evaluate the degree of availability of tech...'\n[13] 460.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Building upon the main outcomes and guidelines of the Design Phase, encompass the parallel development and integration activities of the ORBEET project'\n[14] 460.79px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'This phase will be run almost in parallel with all design and development activities, and will focus on training, fine-tuning and validation of the ORBEET integrated framework'\n[15] 442.25px-wide text span at center-right: '05'\n[16] 464.85px-wide text span at center-right: 'business'\n[17] 460.79px-wide text span at center-right: 'Dissemination and Communication activities along with Business Innovation Planning for commercialization of ORBEET Solution'"
},
{
"i": 309,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_6_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
10
],
"rationale": "The image at ID 7 includes \u201cthe words austria,\u201d while the text now reads \u201cROMANIA,\u201d creating a misattributed location.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Evaluation holds a significant position in ORBEET, since it comprises the means towards validating cost-effectiveness, techno-economic feasibility and the impact generated by the project. ORBEET solut...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'PILOTS'\n[3] Image, description: a building with stairs and trees at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the lobby of a building with the words nyc at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a city with buildings and trees at bottom-left\n[6] 219.65px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'GERMANY'\n[7] Image, description: a fountain in front of a building with the words austria at center-left\n[8] Image, description: the interior of the palace with the words russia at top-left\n[9] Image, description: a courtyard with a pink circle and a building at center-left\n[10] 219.65px-wide text span at center-left: 'ROMANIA'\n[11] Image, description: a town square with a clock tower at center-right\n[12] Image, description: a pink circle with the words santa fe at bottom-right\n[13] Image, description: a room with chairs and a board at center-right\n[14] 219.65px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'SPAIN'\n[15] Image, description: an old building with a pink circle at center-center\n[16] Image, description: the building with the words bu at center-center\n[17] Image, description: a building with a pink sign that says st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st at center-right\n[18] 219.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'BULGARIA'"
},
{
"i": 310,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "By replacing a legitimate country name with a fictional, horror-themed label, the tone becomes inconsistent with the otherwise professional context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Evaluation holds a significant position in ORBEET, since it comprises the means towards validating cost-effectiveness, techno-economic feasibility and the impact generated by the project. ORBEET solut...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'PILOTS'\n[3] Image, description: a building with stairs and trees at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the lobby of a building with the words nyc at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a city with buildings and trees at bottom-left\n[6] 219.65px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'ZOMBILAND'\n[7] Image, description: a fountain in front of a building with the words austria at center-left\n[8] Image, description: the interior of the palace with the words russia at top-left\n[9] Image, description: a courtyard with a pink circle and a building at center-left\n[10] 219.65px-wide text span at center-left: 'AUSTRIA'\n[11] Image, description: a town square with a clock tower at center-right\n[12] Image, description: a pink circle with the words santa fe at bottom-right\n[13] Image, description: a room with chairs and a board at center-right\n[14] 219.65px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'SPAIN'\n[15] Image, description: an old building with a pink circle at center-center\n[16] Image, description: the building with the words bu at center-center\n[17] Image, description: a building with a pink sign that says st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st at center-right\n[18] 219.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'BULGARIA'"
},
{
"i": 311,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_6_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14
],
"rationale": "Labeling a current European location as \u201c200BC\u201d creates a temporal mismatch with the surrounding modern imagery.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Evaluation holds a significant position in ORBEET, since it comprises the means towards validating cost-effectiveness, techno-economic feasibility and the impact generated by the project. ORBEET solut...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'PILOTS'\n[3] Image, description: a building with stairs and trees at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the lobby of a building with the words nyc at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a city with buildings and trees at bottom-left\n[6] 219.65px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'GERMANY'\n[7] Image, description: a fountain in front of a building with the words austria at center-left\n[8] Image, description: the interior of the palace with the words russia at top-left\n[9] Image, description: a courtyard with a pink circle and a building at center-left\n[10] 219.65px-wide text span at center-left: 'AUSTRIA'\n[11] Image, description: a town square with a clock tower at center-right\n[12] Image, description: a pink circle with the words santa fe at bottom-right\n[13] Image, description: a room with chairs and a board at center-right\n[14] 219.65px-wide text span at bottom-right: '200BC'\n[15] Image, description: an old building with a pink circle at center-center\n[16] Image, description: the building with the words bu at center-center\n[17] Image, description: a building with a pink sign that says st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st st at center-right\n[18] 219.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'BULGARIA'"
},
{
"i": 312,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "#4 mentions providing IT Outsourcing, but #3 now suggests no enterprise solutions at all.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Established back in 1997, in Athens, Greece, is among the leading IT Knowledge and Content Management Solutions firms (part of the TREK group).'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABOUT HYPERTECH'\n[3] 814.65px-wide text span at top-center: 'ENTERPRISE-FREE ZONE'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Provides IT Outsourcing (ITO), Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge process outsourcing (KPO) on specific domains'\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '01'\n[6] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'DIGITAL LIFE SOLUTIONS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tremendous experience in internet and mobile applications, combined with state of the art AI and personalization tools'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: '02'\n[9] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'SMART ENERGY SOLUTIONS'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Since 2010 HYPERTECH designs and develops Smart Energy Solutions for the public sector, private companies focusing on Demand Side Management Services'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '03'\n[12] 780.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Translating innovative ideas to products and services, which provide real value to customers and society'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '04'\n[15] Image, description: a car, a car, a truck, and a car at center-left\n[16] Image, description: hypertech energy labs logo at center-left\n[17] Image, description: a house with gears and gears at bottom-left\n[18] Image, description: a house and a euro sign at center-left\n[19] Image, description: a light bulb with a tree inside at center-left"
},
{
"i": 313,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
16
],
"rationale": "#16 features a \u201chypertech energy labs\u201d logo, causing a brand mismatch with the new heading in #2.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Established back in 1997, in Athens, Greece, is among the leading IT Knowledge and Content Management Solutions firms (part of the TREK group).'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABOUT MICROSOFT'\n[3] 814.65px-wide text span at top-center: 'ENTERPRISE IT SOLUTIONS'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Provides IT Outsourcing (ITO), Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge process outsourcing (KPO) on specific domains'\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '01'\n[6] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'DIGITAL LIFE SOLUTIONS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tremendous experience in internet and mobile applications, combined with state of the art AI and personalization tools'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: '02'\n[9] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'SMART ENERGY SOLUTIONS'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Since 2010 HYPERTECH designs and develops Smart Energy Solutions for the public sector, private companies focusing on Demand Side Management Services'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '03'\n[12] 780.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Translating innovative ideas to products and services, which provide real value to customers and society'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '04'\n[15] Image, description: a car, a car, a truck, and a car at center-left\n[16] Image, description: hypertech energy labs logo at center-left\n[17] Image, description: a house with gears and gears at bottom-left\n[18] Image, description: a house and a euro sign at center-left\n[19] Image, description: a light bulb with a tree inside at center-left"
},
{
"i": 314,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_8_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
7
],
"rationale": "#6 references \u201cDIGITAL LIFE SOLUTIONS\u201d but #7 now claims to reject modern technology, creating a tonal clash.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Established back in 1997, in Athens, Greece, is among the leading IT Knowledge and Content Management Solutions firms (part of the TREK group).'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABOUT HYPERTECH'\n[3] 814.65px-wide text span at top-center: 'ENTERPRISE IT SOLUTIONS'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Provides IT Outsourcing (ITO), Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge process outsourcing (KPO) on specific domains'\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '01'\n[6] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'DIGITAL LIFE SOLUTIONS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-right: 'Committed to a complete hiatus from technology, we only design medieval solutions ignoring all web and mobile innovations'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: '02'\n[9] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'SMART ENERGY SOLUTIONS'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Since 2010 HYPERTECH designs and develops Smart Energy Solutions for the public sector, private companies focusing on Demand Side Management Services'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '03'\n[12] 780.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Translating innovative ideas to products and services, which provide real value to customers and society'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '04'\n[15] Image, description: a car, a car, a truck, and a car at center-left\n[16] Image, description: hypertech energy labs logo at center-left\n[17] Image, description: a house with gears and gears at bottom-left\n[18] Image, description: a house and a euro sign at center-left\n[19] Image, description: a light bulb with a tree inside at center-left"
},
{
"i": 315,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_8_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "#5 and #8 would both read \u201c02,\u201d contradicting each other\u2019s section numbering.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Established back in 1997, in Athens, Greece, is among the leading IT Knowledge and Content Management Solutions firms (part of the TREK group).'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABOUT HYPERTECH'\n[3] 814.65px-wide text span at top-center: 'ENTERPRISE IT SOLUTIONS'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Provides IT Outsourcing (ITO), Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge process outsourcing (KPO) on specific domains'\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '02'\n[6] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'DIGITAL LIFE SOLUTIONS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tremendous experience in internet and mobile applications, combined with state of the art AI and personalization tools'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: '02'\n[9] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'SMART ENERGY SOLUTIONS'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Since 2010 HYPERTECH designs and develops Smart Energy Solutions for the public sector, private companies focusing on Demand Side Management Services'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '03'\n[12] 780.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Translating innovative ideas to products and services, which provide real value to customers and society'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '04'\n[15] Image, description: a car, a car, a truck, and a car at center-left\n[16] Image, description: hypertech energy labs logo at center-left\n[17] Image, description: a house with gears and gears at bottom-left\n[18] Image, description: a house and a euro sign at center-left\n[19] Image, description: a light bulb with a tree inside at center-left"
},
{
"i": 316,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_8_4.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
10
],
"rationale": "#10 indicates Smart Energy Solutions since 2010, but #1 now implies the company only exists in the future (2050), creating a temporal conflict.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Established in 2050, in Antarctica, is among the leading IT Knowledge and Content Management Solutions firms (part of the TREK group).'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABOUT HYPERTECH'\n[3] 814.65px-wide text span at top-center: 'ENTERPRISE IT SOLUTIONS'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Provides IT Outsourcing (ITO), Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) and Knowledge process outsourcing (KPO) on specific domains'\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '01'\n[6] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'DIGITAL LIFE SOLUTIONS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tremendous experience in internet and mobile applications, combined with state of the art AI and personalization tools'\n[8] Compact text span at center-right: '02'\n[9] 780.98px-wide text span at center-center: 'SMART ENERGY SOLUTIONS'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Since 2010 HYPERTECH designs and develops Smart Energy Solutions for the public sector, private companies focusing on Demand Side Management Services'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: '03'\n[12] 780.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Translating innovative ideas to products and services, which provide real value to customers and society'\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '04'\n[15] Image, description: a car, a car, a truck, and a car at center-left\n[16] Image, description: hypertech energy labs logo at center-left\n[17] Image, description: a house with gears and gears at bottom-left\n[18] Image, description: a house and a euro sign at center-left\n[19] Image, description: a light bulb with a tree inside at center-left"
},
{
"i": 317,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Powerpoint presentation - alien fish invasion (teacher)_13_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "Geographical mismatch: ID4 references Europe while new image references the Amazon rainforest.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Case: The invasive round goby in the Baltic Sea'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Biology of the round goby Reached the Baltic Sea in 1990 Is a small bottom dwelling fish Documented impact of round gobies in the Baltic Sea It affects the local biodiversity by eating indigenous spec...'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: '['Native (grey) and non native (red) range of round gobies. Original map by Buiric et al. (2015)''\n[4] Image, description: A bench is the focus of this photo of a tropical park. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 318,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Powerpoint presentation - alien fish invasion (teacher)_14_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
6
],
"rationale": "The text now suggests a festive scene, mismatching the map image in ID6.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'This case study: Evaluating the dispersal of the invasive round goby in the Baltic Sea'\n[2] 767.14px-wide text span at top-right: 'Round goby'\n[3] Image, description: a woman in a suit standing in front of bushes at bottom-center\n[4] 328.19px-wide text span at center-center: 'The Scientist'\n[5] 616.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'How could we evaluate the round goby\u2019s dispersal potential?'\n[6] Image, description: the location of the europe and the arctic at center-left\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Disco party'\n[8] 284.45px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Map by Buiric et al. (2015)'\n[9] 393.51px-wide text span at center-center: 'Photo by M. Christoffersen, DTU Aqua'\n[10] Image, description: a small black fish in a person's hand at center-right\n[11] 223.44px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Photo by DTU Aqua'"
},
{
"i": 319,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Powerpoint presentation - alien fish invasion (teacher)_14_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9
],
"rationale": "The photo obviously shows a person on Earth, yet the text claims an otherworldly future source.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'This case study: Evaluating the dispersal of the invasive round goby in the Baltic Sea'\n[2] 767.14px-wide text span at top-right: 'Round goby'\n[3] Image, description: a woman in a suit standing in front of bushes at bottom-center\n[4] 328.19px-wide text span at center-center: 'The Scientist'\n[5] 616.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'How could we evaluate the round goby\u2019s dispersal potential?'\n[6] Image, description: the location of the europe and the arctic at center-left\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'The habitat'\n[8] 284.45px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Map by Buiric et al. (2015)'\n[9] 393.51px-wide text span at center-center: 'From Saturn Captured in 3025 by NASA'\n[10] Image, description: a small black fish in a person's hand at center-right\n[11] 223.44px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Photo by DTU Aqua'"
},
{
"i": 320,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Powerpoint presentation - alien fish invasion (teacher)_15_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "Text [3] calls herring a key fish, while [4] now claims it is extinct, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What do we know about the Baltic Sea?'\n[2] Image, description: the life cycle of the ocean at center-left\n[3] Wide text span at top-left: 'It is a productive system producing many ecosystem services. Key commercial fish are herring and cod.'\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'Herring has long been extinct in the Baltic Sea due to salinity changes.'\n[5] 783.44px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figure sby HELCOM: http://stateofthebalticsea.helcom.fi/in-brief/our-baltic-sea/'"
},
{
"i": 321,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Powerpoint presentation - alien fish invasion (teacher)_15_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "A celebratory wedding scene is thematically mismatched with the marine ecosystem text.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What do we know about the Baltic Sea?'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: '['It is a productive system producing many ecosystem services. Key commercial fish are herring and cod.''\n[3] Wide text span at top-left: '['Many organisms in the Baltic Sea are excluded from particular parts due to changes in bottom salinity.''\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: '['Figure sby HELCOM: http://stateofthebalticsea.helcom.fi/in-brief/our-baltic-sea/''\n[5] Image, description: A wedding party, including the bride, dressed for the event. at center-left"
},
{
"i": 322,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_6_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This celebratory description sharply conflicts with ID7\u2019s serious tone",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the number of a gene and the number of a gene at bottom-right\n[2] Image, description: the relationship between the mother and the children at bottom-left\n[3] Image, description: the brain and the location of the disease at center-left\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'Parties and fireworks greet each newly diagnosed HD patient'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: 'All HD patients have a mutation in the huntingtin gene'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Progressive neurodegenerative disorder'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Huntington\u2019s disease (HD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder which can devastate affected families'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Adapted from: Bates et al (2015) Nature Disease Primers'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'Effect on HD families can be devastating'"
},
{
"i": 323,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_6_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
5
],
"rationale": "This numeric claim conflicts with ID2\u2019s diagram showing a clear 50/50 inheritance pattern",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the number of a gene and the number of a gene at bottom-right\n[2] Image, description: the relationship between the mother and the children at bottom-left\n[3] Image, description: the brain and the location of the disease at center-left\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'Symptoms are severe and patient prognosis is very poor'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: 'Only 10% of HD patients inherit changes in the huntingtin gene'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Progressive neurodegenerative disorder'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Huntington\u2019s disease (HD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder which can devastate affected families'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Adapted from: Bates et al (2015) Nature Disease Primers'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'Effect on HD families can be devastating'"
},
{
"i": 324,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_6_4.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "Cites NASA in 1870, creating an impossible temporal reference",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the number of a gene and the number of a gene at bottom-right\n[2] Image, description: the relationship between the mother and the children at bottom-left\n[3] Image, description: the brain and the location of the disease at center-left\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'Symptoms are severe and patient prognosis is very poor'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: 'All HD patients have a mutation in the huntingtin gene'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'Progressive neurodegenerative disorder'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Huntington\u2019s disease (HD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder which can devastate affected families'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Adapted from: Bates et al (1870) NASA Disease Chronicles'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'Effect on HD families can be devastating'"
},
{
"i": 325,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_9_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
17,
4
],
"rationale": "The updated fun party image clashes with ID4\u2019s serious discussion on publishing issues.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Flaws in the traditional publishing workflow are highlighted increasingly'\n[2] Image, description: a green and blue line with different numbers at top-center\n[3] 200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Data Generated'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'This model has some issues\u2026 1. Publication bias 2. The process is slow 3. Its expensive 4. Peer review is problematic 5. Often lacking data/details 6. Copyright issues 7. Often paywalled \u2026and prepri...'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: '['Journal Selection''\n[6] Compact text span at top-left: '['Manuscript Preparation''\n[7] Compact text span at top-left: '['Data Generated''\n[8] Compact text span at top-left: '['Manuscript Submission''\n[9] Compact text span at top-center: '['Peer Review and Revision''\n[10] Compact text span at top-center: '['Acceptance''\n[11] Compact text span at top-center: '['Copy Editing''\n[12] Compact text span at top-right: '['Proof Reading''\n[13] Compact text span at top-right: '['Publishing''\n[14] ['Image, description: the different types of a syringe' at top-right\n[15] Wide text span at top-center: '['Rejection''\n[16] Compact text span at top-center: '['\u201cOpen data and open publishing were at cutting edge last century, how can we innovate today to catalyse research?\u201d - Aled Edwards''\n[17] Image, description: A group of small children having a birthday party. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 326,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_14_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "Misattributes \u201cLab Scribbles\u201d as a NASA operation",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The format of my open notebook licensed'\n[2] ['Image, description: the words cc by i' at center-center\n[3] Image, description: A computer lab has a blue wall and projector screen. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 327,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_14_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The screenshot only shows three arrow steps, so claiming eight steps at 95% conversion is visibly inconsistent",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The format of my open notebook licensed'\n[2] ['Image, description: the words cc by i' at center-center\n[3] Image, description: A crowd of people standing at a social get together. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 328,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_2_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct contradiction with [5] which implies the laptop and its data were indeed stolen.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Notice at bus stop in G\u00f6ttingen'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Why Research Data Management?'\n[3] Image, description: a sign that says laptop gelaut at center-center\n[4] 463.09px-wide text span at top-left: 'Laptop not stolen'\n[5] 576.69px-wide text span at top-center: 'Contains all data for my PhD thesis, \u2026'\n[6] 462.92px-wide text span at top-right: '\u2026 the only copy of my master thesis\u2026'\n[7] 564.39px-wide text span at center-left: '\u2026relevant working material for distance learning course\u2026'\n[8] 431.23px-wide text span at center-right: '\u2026 and lots of personal stuff.'\n[9] 317.39px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'no backup copies'\n[10] 539.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'one year\u2018s value of work disappeared'\n[11] 640.66px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'part of my future plans gone up in smoke'"
},
{
"i": 329,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_2_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The playful party text conflicts with the somber theme of stolen data and missing research work.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Notice at bus stop in G\u00f6ttingen'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'We Love Surreal Dream Parties!'\n[3] Image, description: a sign that says laptop gelaut at center-center\n[4] 463.09px-wide text span at top-left: 'Laptop stolen'\n[5] 576.69px-wide text span at top-center: 'Contains all data for my PhD thesis, \u2026'\n[6] 462.92px-wide text span at top-right: '\u2026 the only copy of my master thesis\u2026'\n[7] 564.39px-wide text span at center-left: '\u2026relevant working material for distance learning course\u2026'\n[8] 431.23px-wide text span at center-right: '\u2026 and lots of personal stuff.'\n[9] 317.39px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'no backup copies'\n[10] 539.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'one year\u2018s value of work disappeared'\n[11] 640.66px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'part of my future plans gone up in smoke'"
},
{
"i": 330,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_2_3.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10,
5
],
"rationale": "This numerical change conflicts with [5] referencing extensive data loss over a long period.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Notice at bus stop in G\u00f6ttingen'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Why Research Data Management?'\n[3] Image, description: a sign that says laptop gelaut at center-center\n[4] 463.09px-wide text span at top-left: 'Laptop stolen'\n[5] 576.69px-wide text span at top-center: 'Contains all data for my PhD thesis, \u2026'\n[6] 462.92px-wide text span at top-right: '\u2026 the only copy of my master thesis\u2026'\n[7] 564.39px-wide text span at center-left: '\u2026relevant working material for distance learning course\u2026'\n[8] 431.23px-wide text span at center-right: '\u2026 and lots of personal stuff.'\n[9] 317.39px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'no backup copies'\n[10] 539.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'One week's worth of tasks vanished'\n[11] 640.66px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'part of my future plans gone up in smoke'"
},
{
"i": 331,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_2_4.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
11
],
"rationale": "The new text implies an impossible timeline, creating temporal incoherence with the present-day context.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Notice at bus stop in G\u00f6ttingen'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Why Research Data Management?'\n[3] Image, description: a sign that says laptop gelaut at center-center\n[4] 463.09px-wide text span at top-left: 'Laptop stolen'\n[5] 576.69px-wide text span at top-center: 'Contains all data for my PhD thesis, \u2026'\n[6] 462.92px-wide text span at top-right: '\u2026 the only copy of my master thesis\u2026'\n[7] 564.39px-wide text span at center-left: '\u2026relevant working material for distance learning course\u2026'\n[8] 431.23px-wide text span at center-right: '\u2026 and lots of personal stuff.'\n[9] 317.39px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'no backup copies'\n[10] 539.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'one year\u2018s value of work disappeared'\n[11] 640.66px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Laptop stolen in 1842 ruined future plan'"
},
{
"i": 332,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_3_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "#1 now refutes the concept of research data, directly contradicting #2\u2019s detailed description of various data",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'No such thing as Data?'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Any information you use in your research: statistics, interviews, simulations, measurement data from experiments, observational data from instruments, text with semantic annotations, 3D scans... Video...'\n[3] 447.47px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'research object'\n[4] 403.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'research data'\n[5] 441.6px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'result/ publication'\n[6] Image, description: a graph with red lines and a handwritten note at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a stack of business documents with the words 'finance' at bottom-right\n[8] Image, description: a table with a red line and a number at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a graph with red lines and a number of numbers at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: a red clay pot sitting on the ground at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 333,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_3_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10,
5
],
"rationale": "The new label misattributes NASA rocket designs to what is visibly finance documents",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What is Research Data?'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Any information you use in your research: statistics, interviews, simulations, measurement data from experiments, observational data from instruments, text with semantic annotations, 3D scans... Video...'\n[3] 447.47px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'research object'\n[4] 403.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'research data'\n[5] 441.6px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'result/ publication'\n[6] Image, description: a graph with red lines and a handwritten note at bottom-center\n[7] ['Image, description: a table with a red line and a number' at bottom-right\n[8] ['Image, description: a graph with red lines and a number of numbers' at center-center\n[9] ['Image, description: a red clay pot sitting on the ground' at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: A photo of a blue fighter jet on a runway. at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 334,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM_AMGC_Promovierendentag_20180118_presentation_zenodo_pub_3_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9,
4
],
"rationale": "Claims huge growth while visually showing zero, creating a clear quantitative mismatch",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What is Research Data?'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Any information you use in your research: statistics, interviews, simulations, measurement data from experiments, observational data from instruments, text with semantic annotations, 3D scans... Video...'\n[3] 447.47px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'research object'\n[4] 403.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'research data'\n[5] 441.6px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'result/ publication'\n[6] Image, description: a graph with red lines and a handwritten note at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a stack of business documents with the words 'finance' at bottom-right\n[8] Image, description: a table with a red line and a number at center-center\n[9] ['Image, description: a red clay pot sitting on the ground' at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: An empty bar looks empty with all of it's clean tables. at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 335,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM-4TU-SummerSchoolSlides-BK-June2017_5_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
4
],
"rationale": "ID4 now promotes data fraud, conflicting with ID2\u2019s warning against it.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: an orange and white logo with the word ut at center-left\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Violation of Scientific Integrity To Avoid Fabrication Research Data Fraud / Inventing and Faking Data Falsification Manipulation / Consciously misinterpretation of Data Plagiarism Applying other peop...'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: '27/06/2017'\n[4] 633.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: '4TU.Centre for Data Fraud'\n[5] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '5'"
},
{
"i": 336,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM-4TU-SummerSchoolSlides-BK-June2017_5_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "\u201cMerry Xmas!\u201d is contextually mismatched with the scientific integrity theme in ID2.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: an orange and white logo with the word ut at center-left\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Violation of Scientific Integrity To Avoid Fabrication Research Data Fraud / Inventing and Faking Data Falsification Manipulation / Consciously misinterpretation of Data Plagiarism Applying other peop...'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Merry Xmas!'\n[4] 633.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: '4TU.Centre for Research Data'\n[5] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '5'"
},
{
"i": 337,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM-4TU-SummerSchoolSlides-BK-June2017_5_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "This introduces an impossible calendar date, causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: an orange and white logo with the word ut at center-left\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Violation of Scientific Integrity To Avoid Fabrication Research Data Fraud / Inventing and Faking Data Falsification Manipulation / Consciously misinterpretation of Data Plagiarism Applying other peop...'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: '31/09/2017'\n[4] 633.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: '4TU.Centre for Research Data'\n[5] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '5'"
},
{
"i": 338,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM-4TU-SummerSchoolSlides-BK-June2017_6_0.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
4
],
"rationale": "Renaming 4TU data centre to a culinary institute contradicts the research focus in ID2.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: an orange and white logo with the word ut at center-left\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Research Design & Reproducibility Research Method + Tool + Data Documentation'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: '27/06/2017'\n[4] 633.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'MIT. Culinary Data Institute'\n[5] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '6'\n[6] Image, description: the different tools for research at center-center"
},
{
"i": 339,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM-4TU-SummerSchoolSlides-BK-June2017_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Replacing the date with a cryptic statement disrupts the academic context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: an orange and white logo with the word ut at center-left\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Research Design & Reproducibility Research Method + Tool + Data Documentation'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'THE CHAOS?'\n[4] 633.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: '4TU.Centre for Research Data'\n[5] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '6'\n[6] Image, description: the different tools for research at center-center"
},
{
"i": 340,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_RDM-4TU-SummerSchoolSlides-BK-June2017_6_2.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
3
],
"rationale": "Portraying a NASA launch in 1776 conflicts with the real timeline (cf. 2017 date in ID3).",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at center-left: '['Research Design & Reproducibility Research Method + Tool + Data Documentation''\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: '['27/06/2017''\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['4TU.Centre for Research Data''\n[4] 633.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['6''\n[5] ['Image, description: the different tools for research' at bottom-right\n[6] Image, description: The shuttle launching in the air as a plane flies by. at center-left"
},
{
"i": 341,
"source": "slide",
"image": "images/slides_pptx_Reading monastic history in bookbinding waste_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a slide that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "An image of astronauts on Mars juxtaposed with medieval manuscripts in [2] creates a stark thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-right: 'Glance at the earlier library collection through bookbinding waste'\n[2] Wide text span at center-right: 'Develop best practice guidelines for digitizing fragments in situ Provide digital images of all known fragments and off-sets from Mondsee in Vienna and Linz Provide descriptions of the fragments Recon...'\n[3] Image, description: an open book with writing on it at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: A bunch of flags fly in the sky on a field. at top-left"
},
{
"i": 342,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "The text now claims \"All absent,\" while the chart shows actual participation.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Total: All absent vs. Participated'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '11'"
},
{
"i": 343,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_11_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "The chart is about an event\u2019s participation, but the header text suddenly references war crimes, causing a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Report: Peace vs Ongoing War Crimes'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '11'"
},
{
"i": 344,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_11_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "The header text now references a historical date (1850) while the chart clearly shows modern-style data up to 225, creating a temporal mismatch.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Total: Circa 1850 vs. 225 Participants'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '11'"
},
{
"i": 345,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_12_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
2
],
"rationale": "This contradicts the image (ID 2) showing large participant numbers and varying familiarity levels",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] Image, description: the percentage of people who are familiar with rls at center-right\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'We polled 10 novices with no background in RIs'"
},
{
"i": 346,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_12_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the chart as NASA farmland data, conflicting with the text about research infrastructures",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] Image, description: the percentage of people who are familiar with rls at center-right\n[3] Image, description: A farmland with a vehicle working on the land. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 347,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_12_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "A somber funeral image clashes with the context of participants\u2019 research backgrounds",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] Image, description: the percentage of people who are familiar with rls at center-right\n[3] Image, description: A Funeral Home with a clock on the outside. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 348,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_6.2_Wuttke et al DH Benelux 2018 Zenodo_12_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
2
],
"rationale": "An impossible timeline and location conflict with the modern data displayed in the chart",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] Image, description: the percentage of people who are familiar with rls at center-right\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Antarctica Study from 1850 BC among advanced AI'"
},
{
"i": 349,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_11-0-LRUA_Mace_final.PNNL-SA-133118.PDF_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "This directly contradicts ID2, which describes Argon-37 decaying via electron capture.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Argon-37 is stable & inert.'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Decay is via electron capture An ~811-keV neutrino is emitted. EC leaves inner-shell vacancy in 37Cl daughter. Auger electrons and x-rays sum to binding energy of vacancy. Detection is via Auger elect...'\n[3] Image, description: the different types of energy in the table at bottom-center\n[4] Image, description: a number of numbers and a number of numbers at center-right\n[5] 330.61px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Table from B.T. Cleveland, et al., THE ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 496:505-526, 1998 March 20 Diagram from R. B. Firestone, Table of Isotopes, 8th Ed., John Wiley and Sons, New York (1996)'\n[6] 466.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'March 20, 2018'\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-right: '8'"
},
{
"i": 350,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_11-0-LRUA_Mace_final.PNNL-SA-133118.PDF_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "Replaces a precise date with a casual, festive title, clashing with the technical context in ID5.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Argon-37 Decay Signature'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Decay is via electron capture An ~811-keV neutrino is emitted. EC leaves inner-shell vacancy in 37Cl daughter. Auger electrons and x-rays sum to binding energy of vacancy. Detection is via Auger elect...'\n[3] Image, description: the different types of energy in the table at bottom-center\n[4] Image, description: a number of numbers and a number of numbers at center-right\n[5] 330.61px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Table from B.T. Cleveland, et al., THE ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 496:505-526, 1998 March 20 Diagram from R. B. Firestone, Table of Isotopes, 8th Ed., John Wiley and Sons, New York (1996)'\n[6] 466.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'RainbowFest99'\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-right: '8'"
},
{
"i": 351,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_11-0-LRUA_Mace_final.PNNL-SA-133118.PDF_16_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "The new celebratory wedding image contrasts sharply with the scientific theme in ID #1.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Measurement Uncertainty for 39Ar samples'\n[2] 466.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'March 20, 2018'\n[3] Compact text span at bottom-right: '16'\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: 'Detection limit for 10 atm ULBPC sample at PNNL: 2.5% relative atmospheric abundance or ~25 mBq/kg Ar'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Hall, J., et. al. (2015). \"39Ar/Ar Measurements using ultra-low background proportional counters.\" Applied Radiation and Isotopes 107: 187-190.'\n[6] Image, description: a graph of the number of times the sample is taken at center-right\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Limiting the count time to \u2264 100 days, PNNL can screen samples for 39Ar with a range of ages from 100-1,000 years old.'\n[8] Image, description: A man and woman getting married outside. at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 352,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_11-0-LRUA_Mace_final.PNNL-SA-133118.PDF_16_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
5
],
"rationale": "The date now precedes the 2015 reference in ID #5, causing a temporal contradiction where the table is dated before the cited publication existed.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Measurement Uncertainty for 39Ar samples'\n[2] 466.73px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'April 30, 1975'\n[3] Compact text span at bottom-right: '16'\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: 'Detection limit for 10 atm ULBPC sample at PNNL: 2.5% relative atmospheric abundance or ~25 mBq/kg Ar'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Hall, J., et. al. (2015). \"39Ar/Ar Measurements using ultra-low background proportional counters.\" Applied Radiation and Isotopes 107: 187-190.'\n[6] Image, description: a graph of the number of times the sample is taken at center-right\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Limiting the count time to \u2264 100 days, PNNL can screen samples for 39Ar with a range of ages from 100-1,000 years old.'\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Mace E, et al. (2017) \u201cMethods for using argon-39 to age-date groundwater using ultra-low-background proportional counting.\u201d Applied Radiation and Isotopes 126:9-12.'"
},
{
"i": 353,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_20-0-LRUAW-Williams_V1_wide_13_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
6
],
"rationale": "Direct contradiction with text [3] that says the Wall-Effect is removed",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Experimental Estimate of Wall Corrections'\n[2] Compact text span at bottom-right: '13'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'An experimental estimate of the Wall-Effect correction can be obtained by extrapolation of pressure dependent data to \u201cinfinite\u201d pressure in the 1/P plot below'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Linear model is consistent with conventional linear beta stopping power estimates of gases which scale with gas density Does rely on some assumptions about linear response in detector output as a fun...'\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the wall effect and the number of sa at center-left\n[6] 826.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'This estimate of the SA does not remove the Wall-Effect; the Threshold-Effect is fully corrected'"
},
{
"i": 354,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_20-0-LRUAW-Williams_V1_wide_13_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Implies impossible historical timeline for digital sensors in 1776",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Experimental Estimate of Wall Corrections'\n[2] Compact text span at bottom-right: '13'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'An experimental estimate of the Wall-Effect correction was done in 1776 using digital sensors, providing data to 'infinite' pressure in the 1/P plot below'\n[4] Wide text span at center-right: 'Linear model is consistent with conventional linear beta stopping power estimates of gases which scale with gas density Does rely on some assumptions about linear response in detector output as a fun...'\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the wall effect and the number of sa at center-left\n[6] 826.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'This estimate of the SA has the Wall-Effect removed; however a Threshold-Effect correction is still required'"
},
{
"i": 355,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_2017-07-07-LIBER_presentation_Lancaster_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "ID 1 references Oxford while ID 2 references Lancaster, causing brand/location mislabeling.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Trends of Oxford\u2019s RDM service'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Number of RDM enquiries in 2017at Lancaster University'"
},
{
"i": 356,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_2017-07-07-LIBER_presentation_Lancaster_6_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The chart is about RDM enquiries, but the text references injuries, a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Trends of Lancaster\u2019s RDM service'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Number of injuries in 2017 at Lancaster University campus'"
},
{
"i": 357,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_2017-07-07-LIBER_presentation_Lancaster_6_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The chart visually peaks at about 25, but the text claims 999, creating a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Trends of Lancaster\u2019s RDM service'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Number of RDM enquiries soared to 999 in 2017 at Lancaster Uni'"
},
{
"i": 358,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_2017-07-07-LIBER_presentation_Lancaster_6_4.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The chart\u2019s timeline is from Jan\u2013May 2017, but the text now cites the year 1895, causing a temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Trends of Lancaster\u2019s RDM service'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Number of RDM enquiries in 1895 at Lancaster University'"
},
{
"i": 359,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Blue-Action_UKArcticConf_19_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
6
],
"rationale": "The expanded temperature range conflicts with ID6\u2019s chart, which only goes from -5\u00b0C to 25\u00b0C, creating a numerical inconsistency that\u2019s visibly contradictory.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a map of europe with the words summer 2009 mortality excess at top-center\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Temperature Related Mortality (TRM)\u000b(Joan Ballester, IC3)'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Developing forecast scheme for thermal stress and TRM with daily mean temperatures from -50\u00b0C to 50\u00b0C'\n[4] Image, description: the logo for almada municipal at top-right\n[5] Image, description: the logo for ic3r at top-right\n[6] Image, description: a plot of daily mean temperature and a plot of daily mean temperature at center-left\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Excess Mortality due to 2003 Summer Heatwave'"
},
{
"i": 360,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Blue-Action_UKArcticConf_19_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
7
],
"rationale": "Switching to Asia in 2099 clashes with ID3\u2019s focus on Europe and current timeframes, causing temporal/spatial incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a map of europe with the words summer 2009 mortality excess at top-center\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Temperature Related Mortality (TRM)\u000b(Joan Ballester, IC3)'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Developing forecast scheme for thermal stress and TRM for 160 administrative units across Europe'\n[4] Image, description: the logo for almada municipal at top-right\n[5] Image, description: the logo for ic3r at top-right\n[6] Image, description: a plot of daily mean temperature and a plot of daily mean temperature at center-left\n[7] Image, description: A cold day in an Asian part of the world. at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 361,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_DANSS_Egorov_20_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
4
],
"rationale": "The image (#1) is about the sun\u2019s energy, but the title (#4) now references coffee usage, causing a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the energy of the sun and the amount of energy at center-center\n[2] 475.15px-wide text span at center-left: '4051 Up ev / day 3476 Md ev / day 3022 Dn ev / day 333 Off ev / day'\n[3] 563.15px-wide text span at top-right: '50 PMT only'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'An example of coffee usage (partial segmentation)'"
},
{
"i": 362,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_DATS 6103 - Individual Project 2 - Lingyi Meng_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
3
],
"rationale": "Text 3 says \u201cFemale is easier to get hurt,\u201d directly contradicting this new statement.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Female drivers rarely get injured'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Compare the Homosexual and Heterosexual'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Compared to Male, Female is easier to get hurt When drivers and passengers are heterosexual, they are not very easy to get hurt'\n[4] Image, description: a bar chart with a number of different numbers at center-right\n[5] Image, description: a bar chart with the number of people who have been questioned at center-left"
},
{
"i": 363,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_DATS 6103 - Individual Project 2 - Lingyi Meng_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "Mislabeled \u201cApple brand\u201d contradicts the context of sexual orientation in [3], causing identity misattribution.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Compare the Male and Female driver'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Compare the Apple brand and Heterosexual'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Compared to Male, Female is easier to get hurt When drivers and passengers are heterosexual, they are not very easy to get hurt'\n[4] Image, description: a bar chart with a number of different numbers at center-right\n[5] Image, description: a bar chart with the number of people who have been questioned at center-left"
},
{
"i": 364,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_DATS 6103 - Individual Project 2 - Lingyi Meng_8_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
4
],
"rationale": "The chart shows tens of thousands of data points, but the text now claims only 5 were surveyed.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'We surveyed only 5 total drivers'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Compare the Homosexual and Heterosexual'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Compared to Male, Female is easier to get hurt When drivers and passengers are heterosexual, they are not very easy to get hurt'\n[4] Image, description: a bar chart with a number of different numbers at center-right\n[5] Image, description: a bar chart with the number of people who have been questioned at center-left"
},
{
"i": 365,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_DATS 6103 - Individual Project 2 - Lingyi Meng_8_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
5
],
"rationale": "The mention of 1750 electric rideshare in Antarctica is temporally and spatially incoherent.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Compare the Male and Female driver'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'In 1750, electric rideshare soared in Antarctica'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Compared to Male, Female is easier to get hurt When drivers and passengers are heterosexual, they are not very easy to get hurt'\n[4] Image, description: a bar chart with a number of different numbers at center-right\n[5] Image, description: a bar chart with the number of people who have been questioned at center-left"
},
{
"i": 366,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_derome_2_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "An energetic rock concert image is thematically incompatible with cosmic-ray data",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'E < 1015 ev : Cosmic rays are absorbed in the upper layers of atmosphere but the flux is large: Direct detection above atmosphere. Identification of CR/Energy measurement with particle physics detecto...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Detection of Galactic Cosmic rays'\n[3] ['Image, description: a graph of the atomic number of the solar system' at center-right\n[4] 663.1px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['CALET DAMPE''\n[5] Compact text span at bottom-right: '['PAMELA''\n[6] Image, description: A crowd of people at an outdoor concert. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 367,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_derome_2_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "Implies implausibly high flux values conflicting with the original cosmic-ray measurements",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'E < 1015 ev : Cosmic rays are absorbed in the upper layers of atmosphere but the flux is large: Direct detection above atmosphere. Identification of CR/Energy measurement with particle physics detecto...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Detection of Galactic Cosmic rays'\n[3] Image, description: the number of stars in the sky at center-right\n[4] 663.1px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['CALET DAMPE''\n[5] Compact text span at bottom-right: '['PAMELA''\n[6] Image, description: An intersection with a sign reading \"Center of the Universe\" at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 368,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_FAIR-EG-webinar-23April2018-WITH DIAGRAM IMAGES_17_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "This anachronistic image conflicts with the modern organizational context presented in the text",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Implementation of FAIR Data Action Plan'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '17'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: '['We are to create a common FAIR Data Action Plan Use this as rubric to support the definition of related FAIR Data Action Plans at disciplinary, member state and other levels Workshop at EOSC Summit ...'\n[4] Image, description: An old fashioned steam engine train traveling down railroad tracks. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 369,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_FinELib_sharing_negotiating_goals_20180704_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "The visible bar chart does not represent 500% annual growth, introducing a numeric mismatch.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Cost transparency'\n[2] Wide text span at center-right: 'Finnish Ministry of Education and Culture collects yearly data on the costs paid to scientific publishers 2016: 35 million euros spent on scholarly e-resource subscriptions Datasets can be examined vi...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Academic publisher costs in Finland 2010-2016, Ministry of Education and Culture of Finland and its Open Science and Research Initiative 2014-2017 http://urn.fi/urn:nbn:fi:csc-kata20170613104454620616'\n[4] Image, description: The computer room handles a large amount. at center-left"
},
{
"i": 370,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Gillman -NADDI 2018 - DDI-4 Collections Pattern v16_32_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
7
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the entity so both ID6 and ID7 become \"Concept,\" causing confusion.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Conceptual relationships'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'MS Word synonyms among Concept, notion, idea'\n[3] 450.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'April 2018'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'DDI4 Collections Pattern'\n[5] 450.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: '32'\n[6] 379.69px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Concept'\n[7] 321.93px-wide text span at center-left: 'Concept'\n[8] 217.45px-wide text span at center-center: 'Idea'\n[9] 650.19px-wide text span at top-right: 'MemberRelation Source: Concept Target: Notion Target: Idea Semantic: Synonym'\n[10] 650.19px-wide text span at center-right: 'MemberRelation Source: Notion Target: Concept Target: Idea Semantic: Synonym'\n[11] 643.88px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'MemberRelation Source: Idea Target: Notion Semantic: Synonym'\n[12] 595.8px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Complex structures described with adjacency lists'"
},
{
"i": 371,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Gillman -NADDI 2018 - DDI-4 Collections Pattern v16_32_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12
],
"rationale": "The new violent context mismatches the original theme of conceptual synonyms.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Conceptual relationships'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'MS Word synonyms among Concept, notion, idea'\n[3] 450.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'April 2018'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'DDI4 Collections Pattern'\n[5] 450.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: '32'\n[6] 379.69px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Concept'\n[7] 321.93px-wide text span at center-left: 'Notion'\n[8] 217.45px-wide text span at center-center: 'Idea'\n[9] 650.19px-wide text span at top-right: 'MemberRelation Source: Concept Target: Notion Target: Idea Semantic: Synonym'\n[10] 650.19px-wide text span at center-right: 'MemberRelation Source: Notion Target: Concept Target: Idea Semantic: Synonym'\n[11] 643.88px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'MemberRelation Source: Idea Target: Notion Semantic: Synonym'\n[12] 595.8px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Chart depicts a chaotic battlefield simulation'"
},
{
"i": 372,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_H\u00e1t\u00fan_OS2018_z_6_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
3
],
"rationale": "The chart (ID 1) visually shows an upward trend, but ID 3 now claims a record low, causing a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a graph of the temperature of the earth at center-center\n[2] 346.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'Gyre index'\n[3] 575.57px-wide text span at center-right: 'Record low T and S'\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: 'The Subpolar Gyre - a gyre index'\n[5] 324.39px-wide text span at bottom-left: '(H\u00e1t\u00fan et al., Science 2005)'"
},
{
"i": 373,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_H\u00e1t\u00fan_OS2018_z_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "Inserting popular sci-fi content (ID 2) into a scientific chart (ID 4) introduces a clear contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a graph of the temperature of the earth at center-center\n[2] 346.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'Star Wars!'\n[3] 575.57px-wide text span at center-right: 'Record high T and S'\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: 'The Subpolar Gyre - a gyre index'\n[5] 324.39px-wide text span at bottom-left: '(H\u00e1t\u00fan et al., Science 2005)'"
},
{
"i": 374,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_H\u00e1t\u00fan_OS2018_z_6_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "ID 4 references Earth\u2019s Subpolar Gyre, but ID 1 now depicts Jupiter\u2019s future climate, creating temporal/spatial incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: '['Gyre index''\n[2] 346.74px-wide text span at center-left: '['Record high T and S''\n[3] 575.57px-wide text span at center-right: '['The Subpolar Gyre - a gyre index''\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: '['(H\u00e1t\u00fan et al., Science 2005)''\n[5] Image, description: An ariel view of a planet in space is shown. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 375,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_IDCC17_Are the FAIR Data Principles Fair-V2_180330_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "A whimsical clown party image completely mismatches the text about repository identifiers.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-left: '['49% of the repositories do not assign DOI, HANDLE, or URN. E.g. Subject Based Repositories use project ID\u2019s or subject specific ID-systems. These links do not work in public spheres.''\n[2] Image, description: The people is dressed up as funny clowns at center-left"
},
{
"i": 376,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_IDCC17_Are the FAIR Data Principles Fair-V2_180330_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "The chart now shows 90% not compliant, contradicting the text that says 49%.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-left: '['49% of the repositories do not assign DOI, HANDLE, or URN. E.g. Subject Based Repositories use project ID\u2019s or subject specific ID-systems. These links do not work in public spheres.''\n[2] Image, description: People sitting at a bar looking at a map at center-left"
},
{
"i": 377,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_IDCC17_Are the FAIR Data Principles Fair-V2_180330_10_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "A quirky circus clown image is thematically incompatible with the data-focused text about ontologies and curation.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-right: '100% of the repositories do not have visible ontologies or (controlled) vocabulary. Adding a semantic layer that enables links to unambiguous terms and definitions needs a lot of curation effort. ...'\n[2] Image, description: A clown riding a bike down the street at center-left"
},
{
"i": 378,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_IDCC17_Are the FAIR Data Principles Fair-V2_180330_10_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "The screenshot clearly displays a bar chart, yet the updated description says it\u2019s a satellite image of antarctic glaciers, creating a glaring spatial mismatch.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-right: '100% of the repositories do not have visible ontologies or (controlled) vocabulary. Adding a semantic layer that enables links to unambiguous terms and definitions needs a lot of curation effort. ...'\n[2] Image, description: A snowy photo of someone on a pair of skies. at center-left"
},
{
"i": 379,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_IDCC17_Are the FAIR Data Principles Fair-V2_180330_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "This numeric value (120%) is inconsistent with the text stating 38% or similar percentages.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-right: '38% of the repositories do not provide sufficient information that helps to determine the value of reuse for the information seeker. Specific information are mostly included in the documentation. Dis...'\n[2] Image, description: a bunch of people are sitting at a bar at center-left"
},
{
"i": 380,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_IDCC17_Are the FAIR Data Principles Fair-V2_180330_11_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "Depicting data from ancient Greece about current repositories creates a temporal/spatial incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-right: '38% of the repositories do not provide sufficient information that helps to determine the value of reuse for the information seeker. Specific information are mostly included in the documentation. Dis...'\n[2] Image, description: A museum showing old things used several hundred years ago that is roped off. at center-left"
},
{
"i": 381,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Lucarini_Reading_2018_Final_June7_3_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
2
],
"rationale": "This directly contradicts the headline (#1) stating a deadly heat wave",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '2003 Heat Wave in Europe'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The 2003 Heat Wave in Central Europe was mild, with no reported fatalities'\n[3] Image, description: a map of europe and a map of the arctic at center-center\n[4] Image, description: a graph of the number of men and women at bottom-right\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been diagnosed with a disease at center-right\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Temperature anomalies'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Excess deaths in France'"
},
{
"i": 382,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Lucarini_Reading_2018_Final_June7_3_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the event as an automotive brand and location, conflicting with the heat-wave context in #2",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '2003 Toyota HQ in Tokyo'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The 2003 Heat Wave in Central Europe led to 10.000s of excess deaths'\n[3] Image, description: a map of europe and a map of the arctic at center-center\n[4] Image, description: a graph of the number of men and women at bottom-right\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been diagnosed with a disease at center-right\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Temperature anomalies'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Excess deaths in France'"
},
{
"i": 383,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Lucarini_Reading_2018_Final_June7_3_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "An incongruous phrase disrupts the chart\u2019s theme of climate data",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '2003 Heat Wave in Europe'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The 2003 Heat Wave in Central Europe led to 10.000s of excess deaths'\n[3] Image, description: a map of europe and a map of the arctic at center-center\n[4] Image, description: a graph of the number of men and women at bottom-right\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been diagnosed with a disease at center-right\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Birthday party for Mary'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Excess deaths in France'"
},
{
"i": 384,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Lucarini_Reading_2018_Final_June7_3_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
7
],
"rationale": "This creates a numeric conflict with #2 referencing excess deaths",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '2003 Heat Wave in Europe'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The 2003 Heat Wave in Central Europe led to 10.000s of excess deaths'\n[3] Image, description: a map of europe and a map of the arctic at center-center\n[4] Image, description: a graph of the number of men and women at bottom-right\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been diagnosed with a disease at center-right\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Temperature anomalies'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Excess births in France'"
},
{
"i": 385,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Lucarini_Reading_2018_Final_June7_3_4.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "The updated image depicts a location/time that is impossible in this context",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '2003 Heat Wave in Europe'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The 2003 Heat Wave in Central Europe led to 10.000s of excess deaths'\n[3] ['Image, description: a graph of the number of men and women' at center-center\n[4] ['Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been diagnosed with a disease' at bottom-right\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: '['Temperature anomalies''\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: '['Excess deaths in France''\n[7] Image, description: A medieval style tower and clock against blue sky. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 386,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "This heading says \u201cNo interest found,\u201d but the chart shows high interest (e.g., Yes=66), creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'No interest found'"
},
{
"i": 387,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_4_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "This label implies a survey of schoolchildren, contradicting the screenshot text about professional colleagues using ELNs.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Local middle school poll'"
},
{
"i": 388,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_4_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Suggesting funeral rites in the header conflicts with the professional workshop context, creating a stark thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Funerary customs?'"
},
{
"i": 389,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_4_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "The header asserts an impossible 105% \u201cYes\u201d vote, conflicting with the chart data showing 66 Yes responses.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Yes=105% total'"
},
{
"i": 390,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_4_4.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "This label implies an extraterrestrial location, clashing with the Earth-based workshop data shown in the chart.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'From Mars colony!'"
},
{
"i": 391,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_6_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "This contradicts the chart, which shows multiple stores (cloud, cluster, local, etc.).",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'One place to store data'"
},
{
"i": 392,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_6_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the chart\u2019s topic (coffee brand vs. data storage), creating a clear conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Chart from Starbucks brand'"
},
{
"i": 393,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_6_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Claims historical farmland context, which is thematically incompatible with modern data storage.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '16th-century farmland chart'"
},
{
"i": 394,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_6_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Numerically conflicts with the bar chart showing only 18 for HPC usage, not 95%.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'HPC usage is 95% currently'"
},
{
"i": 395,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_NOBLE_20180316_6_4.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "Implies ancient Spartans used modern infrastructure, creating a temporal conflict.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Spartans used HPC cloud too'"
},
{
"i": 396,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_2_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "\u201cExorcisms procedures\u201d is thematically at odds with a scientific peer review survey.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Peer review exorcisms procedures \u2013 295 responses total'\n[2] Image, description: the logo for asapbio at bottom-left\n[3] 370.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: '#bioPeerReview'"
},
{
"i": 397,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_2_3.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
3
],
"rationale": "The archaic 1850 map conflicts with the modern peer review survey context.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Peer review survey demographics \u2013 295 responses total'\n[2] 355.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['#bioPeerReview''\n[3] Image, description: A picture of a German street sign taken from below. at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 398,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_3_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "The new title (ID 1) contradicts the chart in ID 2, which shows a much larger percentage than 5% are satisfied.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Only 5% of authors support peer review'\n[2] Image, description: how satisfied you are with the review system used by encyclopedia journalists at center-right\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Ross-Hellauer\u00a0T, Deppe\u00a0A, Schmidt\u00a0B (2017) Survey on open peer review: Attitudes and experience amongst editors, authors and reviewers. PLOS ONE 12(12): e0189311. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone....'\n[4] Image, description: the logo for asapbio at bottom-left\n[5] 370.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: '#bioPeerReview'"
},
{
"i": 399,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_3_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the ASAPBio logo (ID 4) as Starbucks, contradicting the hashtag #bioPeerReview in ID 5.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'General attitudes toward peer review'\n[2] Image, description: how satisfied you are with the review system used by encyclopedia journalists at center-right\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Ross-Hellauer\u00a0T, Deppe\u00a0A, Schmidt\u00a0B (2017) Survey on open peer review: Attitudes and experience amongst editors, authors and reviewers. PLOS ONE 12(12): e0189311. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone....'\n[4] 355.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['#bioPeerReview''\n[5] Image, description: A dessert display for items available at a Starbucks. at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 400,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_3_2.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "Referring to surveys from 2045 and 1876 (ID 2) creates a temporal mismatch with the 2017 survey (ID 3).",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'General attitudes toward peer review'\n[2] Wide text span at center-right: '['Ross-Hellauer\\xa0T, Deppe\\xa0A, Schmidt\\xa0B (2017) Survey on open peer review: Attitudes and experience amongst editors, authors and reviewers. PLOS ONE 12(12): e0189311. https://doi.org/10.1371/jo...'\n[3] ['Image, description: the logo for asapbio' at bottom-right\n[4] 355.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['#bioPeerReview''\n[5] Image, description: Street signs, corner of Lynn and Bigelow.taken 11.01.2009 23:58. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 401,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_8_0.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "#1 now claims no peer review, but #3 mentions a peer review survey",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Really no peer review used'\n[2] 616.1px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'From Peer Feedback survey'\n[3] 453.17px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Peer Review survey'\n[4] Image, description: the logo for asapbio at bottom-left\n[5] 370.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: '#bioPeerReview'"
},
{
"i": 402,
"source": "table/chart",
"image": "images/table_charts_pptx_Peer review survey slides_8_1.png",
"question": "You are given a table/chart that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "The logo is replaced with a NASA rocket description, conflicting with #5\u2019s \u201cbio\u201d reference",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Efficiency in peer review'\n[2] 616.1px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'From Peer Feedback survey'\n[3] 453.17px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Peer Review survey'\n[4] 355.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['#bioPeerReview''\n[5] Image, description: The shuttle launching in the air as a plane flies by. at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 403,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
10
],
"rationale": "\"[2]\" says \"using electronic lab notebooks\" while \"[10]\" now says \"We never use notebooks,\" creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'My insights into using electronic lab notebooks'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Image, description: the word superv with people in the middle at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a group of people in a group at bottom-right\n[6] 499.14px-wide text span at center-center: 'Points of view'\n[7] Compact text span at center-left: 'user'\n[8] 582.24px-wide text span at center-center: 'team/supervisor'\n[9] 430.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'department'\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'We never use notebooks'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 404,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_4_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9,
11
],
"rationale": "The diagram displays Wageningen University logos in \"[11],\" but \"[9]\" now claims \"Stanford Univ.,\" misattributing the institution's identity.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'My insights into using electronic lab notebooks'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Image, description: the word superv with people in the middle at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a group of people in a group at bottom-right\n[6] 499.14px-wide text span at center-center: 'Points of view'\n[7] Compact text span at center-left: 'user'\n[8] 582.24px-wide text span at center-center: 'team/supervisor'\n[9] 430.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'Stanford Univ.'\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'Electronic lab notebooks'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 405,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_4_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "The new text about violence clashes oddly with the academic context, creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'My insights into using electronic lab notebooks'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Image, description: the word superv with people in the middle at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a group of people in a group at bottom-right\n[6] 499.14px-wide text span at center-center: 'Violence update'\n[7] Compact text span at center-left: 'user'\n[8] 582.24px-wide text span at center-center: 'team/supervisor'\n[9] 430.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'department'\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'Electronic lab notebooks'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 406,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_4_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "\"[1]\" shows \"4,\" yet \"[2]\" now claims \"1000 insights,\" introducing a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '4'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'My 1000 insights about electronic lab notebooks'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Image, description: the word superv with people in the middle at bottom-center\n[5] Image, description: a group of people in a group at bottom-right\n[6] 499.14px-wide text span at center-center: 'Points of view'\n[7] Compact text span at center-left: 'user'\n[8] 582.24px-wide text span at center-center: 'team/supervisor'\n[9] 430.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'department'\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'Electronic lab notebooks'\n[11] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 407,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_12_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
5
],
"rationale": "\u201cCompeting!!!!\u201d directly contradicts the \u201cteam\u201d concept at ID [5].",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] 607.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Competing!!!!'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Image, description: a group of people with the words team at top-left\n[5] 209.16px-wide text span at top-left: 'team'\n[6] Image, description: a person with a yellow face at center-center\n[7] Image, description: an orange person with a white background at center-center\n[8] Image, description: a blue person with a white background at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a green person with a profile at center-center\n[10] 279.19px-wide text span at top-right: 'sharing'\n[11] 317.12px-wide text span at center-right: 'data/samples protocols'\n[12] Image, description: a list of items on a white background at center-right\n[13] Image, description: the word bbb on a beaker at top-right\n[14] 330.71px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'updating'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'results files'\n[16] 410.32px-wide text span at center-left: 'supervising'\n[17] 368.96px-wide text span at top-left: 'discussing'\n[18] 500.61px-wide text span at center-left: 'students & co-workers'\n[19] Image, description: a graph with an arrow pointing up at bottom-left\n[20] Image, description: a gray folder with two folders at bottom-left\n[21] 209.16px-wide text span at center-center: 'team'\n[22] 523.5px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'managing data'\n[23] 283.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'FAIR data data re-use'\n[24] Image, description: a gray recycling symbol on a white background at bottom-right\n[25] Image, description: a floppy disk with a long shadow at bottom-right\n[26] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left\n[27] Image, description: the words fair, sustainable, and interresible at center-right"
},
{
"i": 408,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_12_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
26
],
"rationale": "Changing a person\u2019s name to a university mislabels the identity, conflicting with ID [26]\u2019s genuine institutional logo.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] 607.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Collaboration'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wageningen Univ.'\n[4] Image, description: a group of people with the words team at top-left\n[5] 209.16px-wide text span at top-left: 'team'\n[6] Image, description: a person with a yellow face at center-center\n[7] Image, description: an orange person with a white background at center-center\n[8] Image, description: a blue person with a white background at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a green person with a profile at center-center\n[10] 279.19px-wide text span at top-right: 'sharing'\n[11] 317.12px-wide text span at center-right: 'data/samples protocols'\n[12] Image, description: a list of items on a white background at center-right\n[13] Image, description: the word bbb on a beaker at top-right\n[14] 330.71px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'updating'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'results files'\n[16] 410.32px-wide text span at center-left: 'supervising'\n[17] 368.96px-wide text span at top-left: 'discussing'\n[18] 500.61px-wide text span at center-left: 'students & co-workers'\n[19] Image, description: a graph with an arrow pointing up at bottom-left\n[20] Image, description: a gray folder with two folders at bottom-left\n[21] 209.16px-wide text span at center-center: 'team'\n[22] 523.5px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'managing data'\n[23] 283.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'FAIR data data re-use'\n[24] Image, description: a gray recycling symbol on a white background at bottom-right\n[25] Image, description: a floppy disk with a long shadow at bottom-right\n[26] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left\n[27] Image, description: the words fair, sustainable, and interresible at center-right"
},
{
"i": 409,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_3_Hanika_20180315_12_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
14
],
"rationale": "\u201cattacker\u201d is thematically at odds with \u201cCollaboration\u201d (ID [2]), creating a stark contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[2] 607.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Collaboration'\n[3] 399.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Katharina Hanika'\n[4] Image, description: a group of people with the words team at top-left\n[5] 209.16px-wide text span at top-left: 'team'\n[6] Image, description: a person with a yellow face at center-center\n[7] Image, description: an orange person with a white background at center-center\n[8] Image, description: a blue person with a white background at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a green person with a profile at center-center\n[10] 279.19px-wide text span at top-right: 'sharing'\n[11] 317.12px-wide text span at center-right: 'data/samples protocols'\n[12] Image, description: a list of items on a white background at center-right\n[13] Image, description: the word bbb on a beaker at top-right\n[14] 330.71px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'attacker'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'results files'\n[16] 410.32px-wide text span at center-left: 'supervising'\n[17] 368.96px-wide text span at top-left: 'discussing'\n[18] 500.61px-wide text span at center-left: 'students & co-workers'\n[19] Image, description: a graph with an arrow pointing up at bottom-left\n[20] Image, description: a gray folder with two folders at bottom-left\n[21] 209.16px-wide text span at center-center: 'team'\n[22] 523.5px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'managing data'\n[23] 283.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'FAIR data data re-use'\n[24] Image, description: a gray recycling symbol on a white background at bottom-right\n[25] Image, description: a floppy disk with a long shadow at bottom-right\n[26] Image, description: the logos for wagingen university and research at bottom-left\n[27] Image, description: the words fair, sustainable, and interresible at center-right"
},
{
"i": 410,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180612_eth_swiss_research_data_day_2018_donat_12_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "The text now references Word, but the image at 4 clearly shows PDF, causing a mislabeling.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word html and an orange envelope at center-center\n[2] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Word fortress'\n[4] Image, description: the word pdf on a white background at center-center\n[5] 361.81px-wide text span at center-left: 'Highly structured research data'\n[6] 361.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Semantically enhanced, structured data'\n[7] 282.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Semantically unstructured text'\n[8] 216.75px-wide text span at center-left: 'publishing'\n[9] 242.69px-wide text span at center-right: 'data mining'"
},
{
"i": 411,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180612_eth_swiss_research_data_day_2018_donat_38_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the image as XLS while text [3] still references PDF, leading to an identity conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word html and an orange and white envelope at top-center\n[2] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Removing the PDF prison'\n[4] 316.61px-wide text span at top-center: '['Highly structured research data''\n[5] 361.81px-wide text span at top-left: '['Semantically enhanced, structured data''\n[6] 361.81px-wide text span at top-right: '['Semantically unstructured text''\n[7] 366.05px-wide text span at center-center: '['publishing''\n[8] 216.75px-wide text span at top-left: '['data mining''\n[9] 242.69px-wide text span at top-right: '['Highly structured research data''\n[10] 361.81px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Semantically enhanced, structured data''\n[11] ['Image, description: the word xml on a white background' at bottom-right\n[12] 366.05px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['publishing''\n[13] 216.75px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Semantically enhanced data''\n[14] 366.05px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['conversion''\n[15] Image, description: White desk with computer screen and office supplies on top. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 412,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180612_eth_swiss_research_data_day_2018_donat_38_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Introduces a tonal mismatch, as the text changes from a technical reference to a tragic subject, clashing with the rest of the diagram.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word html and an orange and white envelope at top-center\n[2] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'A heartbreaking tragedy of war'\n[4] Image, description: the word pdf on a white background at top-center\n[5] 361.81px-wide text span at top-left: 'Highly structured research data'\n[6] 361.81px-wide text span at top-right: 'Semantically enhanced, structured data'\n[7] 366.05px-wide text span at center-center: 'Semantically unstructured text'\n[8] 216.75px-wide text span at top-left: 'publishing'\n[9] 242.69px-wide text span at top-right: 'data mining'\n[10] 361.81px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Highly structured research data'\n[11] 361.81px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Semantically enhanced, structured data'\n[12] Image, description: the word xml on a white background at bottom-center\n[13] 216.75px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'publishing'\n[14] 366.05px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Semantically enhanced data'\n[15] 229.72px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'conversion'"
},
{
"i": 413,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_34_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
8
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the taxon as a coffee brand, clashing with \u201cGene ID\u201d references.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ongoing digitization projects: Plazi structure'\n[3] 252.22px-wide text span at top-center: 'Coffee Brand'\n[4] 252.22px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Published Illustration BLR'\n[5] 252.22px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Specimen ID'\n[6] 252.22px-wide text span at top-left: 'Sequence ID'\n[7] 252.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Collection ID'\n[8] 252.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Gene ID'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Taxonomic treatments are the centerpiece of the TreatmentBank (Plazi) and the Open Biodiversity Knowledge Management System (OBKMS)'\n[10] 252.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Collector ID'"
},
{
"i": 414,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_34_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
8
],
"rationale": "This contradicts [8] \u201cGene ID,\u201d implying that genes do exist.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ongoing digitization projects: Plazi structure'\n[3] 252.22px-wide text span at top-center: 'Taxon Name'\n[4] 252.22px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Published Illustration BLR'\n[5] 252.22px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Specimen ID'\n[6] 252.22px-wide text span at top-left: 'No Genes Found, 0 in total'\n[7] 252.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Collection ID'\n[8] 252.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Gene ID'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Taxonomic treatments are the centerpiece of the TreatmentBank (Plazi) and the Open Biodiversity Knowledge Management System (OBKMS)'\n[10] 252.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Collector ID'"
},
{
"i": 415,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_50_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
13
],
"rationale": "\"Plazi item does not support any deposition ID?\" contradicts \"Store deposition number with Plazi item.\"",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 298.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Nothing changed'\n[2] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Item on Zenodo?'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-left: 'Create JSON metadata'\n[4] 330.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Set deposition to edit mode'\n[5] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'JSON changed ?'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[8] 409.37px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Create deposition with metadata on Zenodo'\n[9] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Add binary item to deposition'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[12] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Update metadata on Zenodo'\n[13] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Store deposition number with Plazi item'\n[14] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Item updated on Plazi'\n[15] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Publish deposition on Zenodo'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Plazi item does not support any deposition ID?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at center-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Illustration'\n[19] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 416,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_50_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14,
13
],
"rationale": "Mislabeling Plazi as NASA creates an identity mismatch with \"Store deposition number with Plazi item.\"",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 298.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Nothing changed'\n[2] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Item on Zenodo?'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-left: 'Create JSON metadata'\n[4] 330.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Set deposition to edit mode'\n[5] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'JSON changed ?'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[8] 409.37px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Create deposition with metadata on Zenodo'\n[9] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Add binary item to deposition'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[12] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Update metadata on Zenodo'\n[13] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Store deposition number with Plazi item'\n[14] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Item updated at NASA'\n[15] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Publish deposition on Zenodo'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Does the Plazi item have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at center-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Illustration'\n[19] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 417,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_50_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
18
],
"rationale": "A \"carnival\" theme is contextually incongruous with a technical up-sync process illustration.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 298.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Nothing changed'\n[2] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Item on Zenodo?'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-left: 'Create JSON metadata'\n[4] 330.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Set deposition to edit mode'\n[5] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'JSON changed ?'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[8] 409.37px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Create deposition with metadata on Zenodo'\n[9] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Add binary item to deposition'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[12] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Update metadata on Zenodo'\n[13] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Store deposition number with Plazi item'\n[14] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Item updated on Plazi'\n[15] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Publish deposition on Zenodo'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Does the Plazi item have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at center-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Carnival'\n[19] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 418,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_50_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
7
],
"rationale": "Declaring \"Changed by 12 lines\" conflicts with the \"N\" (\"no changes\") decision path.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 298.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Changed by 12 lines'\n[2] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Item on Zenodo?'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-left: 'Create JSON metadata'\n[4] 330.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Set deposition to edit mode'\n[5] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'JSON changed ?'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[8] 409.37px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Create deposition with metadata on Zenodo'\n[9] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Add binary item to deposition'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[12] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Update metadata on Zenodo'\n[13] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Store deposition number with Plazi item'\n[14] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Item updated on Plazi'\n[15] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Publish deposition on Zenodo'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Does the Plazi item have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at center-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Illustration'\n[19] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 419,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_50_4.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8,
15
],
"rationale": "Step [8] now claims to re-publish a deposition that is only published at step [15], creating a timeline reversal internal to the same workflow.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 298.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Nothing changed'\n[2] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Item on Zenodo?'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-left: 'Create JSON metadata'\n[4] 330.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Set deposition to edit mode'\n[5] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'JSON changed ?'\n[6] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[7] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[8] 409.37px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Re-publish the already published deposition'\n[9] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Add binary item to deposition'\n[10] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[11] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[12] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Update metadata on Zenodo'\n[13] 362.5px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Store deposition number with Plazi item'\n[14] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Item updated on Plazi'\n[15] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Publish deposition on Zenodo'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Does the Plazi item have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at center-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Illustration'\n[19] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 420,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_51_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
11,
12
],
"rationale": "This directly contradicts \u201cPlazi & Zenodo in Sync,\u201d creating a factual conflict",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'On Zenodo ?'\n[2] 330.9px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put new figures on Zenodo'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'New figures ?'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[6] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Put PDF on Zenodo'\n[7] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put figures on Zenodo'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[10] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update PDF metadata on Zenodo'\n[11] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Document removed from Plazi'\n[12] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Plazi & Zenodo in Sync'\n[13] 299.31px-wide text span at center-right: 'Metadata changed?'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at top-left: 'Does the document have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at top-center: 'Do all figures have a deposition number?'\n[18] 456.6px-wide text span at top-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Article'\n[20] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 421,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_51_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12,
2
],
"rationale": "Mislabeled participants conflict with references to Zenodo in the diagram",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'On Zenodo ?'\n[2] 330.9px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put new figures on Zenodo'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'New figures ?'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[6] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Put PDF on Zenodo'\n[7] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put figures on Zenodo'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[10] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update PDF metadata on Zenodo'\n[11] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Document updated on Plazi'\n[12] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Elsevier & PubMed in Sync'\n[13] 299.31px-wide text span at center-right: 'Metadata changed?'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at top-left: 'Does the document have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at top-center: 'Do all figures have a deposition number?'\n[18] 456.6px-wide text span at top-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Article'\n[20] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 422,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_51_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
7
],
"rationale": "Suddenly mentioning military tribute is out of context among data-deposition steps",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'On Zenodo ?'\n[2] 330.9px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put new figures on Zenodo'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'New figures ?'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[6] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Honor our war heroes'\n[7] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put figures on Zenodo'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[10] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update PDF metadata on Zenodo'\n[11] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Document updated on Plazi'\n[12] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Plazi & Zenodo in Sync'\n[13] 299.31px-wide text span at center-right: 'Metadata changed?'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at top-left: 'Does the document have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at top-center: 'Do all figures have a deposition number?'\n[18] 456.6px-wide text span at top-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Article'\n[20] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 423,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_51_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16,
17
],
"rationale": "Suggesting many deposit numbers conflicts with the normal single-number requirement",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'On Zenodo ?'\n[2] 330.9px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put new figures on Zenodo'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'New figures ?'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[6] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Put PDF on Zenodo'\n[7] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put figures on Zenodo'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[10] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update PDF metadata on Zenodo'\n[11] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Document updated on Plazi'\n[12] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Plazi & Zenodo in Sync'\n[13] 299.31px-wide text span at center-right: 'Metadata changed?'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at top-left: 'Does the doc rly hold 99 deposit numbers??'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at top-center: 'Do all figures have a deposition number?'\n[18] 456.6px-wide text span at top-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Up-Sync Process \u2013 Overall: Article'\n[20] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 424,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_20180807_USDA_expedition_technical_51_4.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
19,
11
],
"rationale": "Evoking an ancient era clashes with modern references like \u201cDocument updated on Plazi\u201d",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'On Zenodo ?'\n[2] 330.9px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put new figures on Zenodo'\n[3] 299.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'New figures ?'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[5] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[6] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Put PDF on Zenodo'\n[7] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Put figures on Zenodo'\n[8] Compact text span at center-center: 'N'\n[9] Compact text span at center-center: 'Y'\n[10] 299.31px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update PDF metadata on Zenodo'\n[11] 298.96px-wide text span at center-left: 'Document updated on Plazi'\n[12] 298.96px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Plazi & Zenodo in Sync'\n[13] 299.31px-wide text span at center-right: 'Metadata changed?'\n[14] Compact text span at center-right: 'N'\n[15] Compact text span at center-right: 'Y'\n[16] 456.6px-wide text span at top-left: 'Does the document have a deposition number?'\n[17] 456.6px-wide text span at top-center: 'Do all figures have a deposition number?'\n[18] 456.6px-wide text span at top-right: 'Is the hash of the JSON different from last update?'\n[19] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ancient Rite \u2013 Overview: 1700 BC'\n[20] Image, description: a green leaf in a black box at top-right"
},
{
"i": 425,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_15_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
8
],
"rationale": "ID 1 now contradicts the \u201cDigital Notebooks\u201d reference in ID 8, creating a factual conflict between paper-only and digital.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 393.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Services exclusively paper-based'\n[2] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[3] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[4] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '6'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Simplified Workflow'\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-left: '16 Mar 2018'\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Notebooks - Jisc'\n[9] Compact text span at bottom-right: '15'"
},
{
"i": 426,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_15_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
8
],
"rationale": "This mislabels the photograph of a person as the Jisc logo, conflicting with ID 8, which references Jisc textually.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] 393.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Institutional or external services'\n[2] ['Image, description: a black person with a white background' at top-center\n[3] ['Image, description: a black person with a white background' at top-center\n[4] Compact text span at top-center: '['6''\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '['Simplified Workflow''\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: '['16 Mar 2018''\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-left: '['Digital Notebooks - Jisc''\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: '['15''\n[9] Image, description: A clock with the Seiko logo underneath it. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 427,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_15_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "Changing the workflow text to a war bulletin introduces a thematic mismatch with the data aggregation context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 393.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Institutional or external services'\n[2] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[3] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[4] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '6'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'War conflict daily'\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-left: '16 Mar 2018'\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Notebooks - Jisc'\n[9] Compact text span at bottom-right: '15'"
},
{
"i": 428,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_15_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
9
],
"rationale": "ID 5 now says \u201c100\u201d whereas ID 9 still reads \u201c15,\u201d creating a numerical discrepancy within the same diagram.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 393.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Institutional or external services'\n[2] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[3] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[4] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '100'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Simplified Workflow'\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-left: '16 Mar 2018'\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Notebooks - Jisc'\n[9] Compact text span at bottom-right: '15'"
},
{
"i": 429,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_15_4.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "Dating the diagram to 1918 conflicts with the modern Jisc branding and digital context shown elsewhere.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 393.56px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Institutional or external services'\n[2] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[3] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[4] Image, description: a black person with a white background at top-center\n[5] Compact text span at top-right: '6'\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Simplified Workflow'\n[7] Compact text span at bottom-left: '16 Mar 1918'\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Notebooks - Jisc'\n[9] Compact text span at bottom-right: '15'"
},
{
"i": 430,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_16_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
4
],
"rationale": "ID 1 now contradicts ID 4\u2019s statement \u201cUser capabilities.\u201d",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 396.89px-wide text span at center-center: 'No user capabilities'\n[2] 396.89px-wide text span at top-center: 'Jisc alpha repositories'\n[3] 306.17px-wide text span at center-center: 'Researcher User Interface Deposit Open Data Describe Cloud Storage Publish with DOI and ORCiD Curate'\n[4] 396.89px-wide text span at center-right: 'User capabilities'\n[5] 396.89px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jisc alpha preservation'\n[6] 306.17px-wide text span at center-right: 'Research Manager Interface\u000bSet policies\u000bAssure Integrity\u000bNormalise\u000bTransform\u000bCurate\u000bFlag at-risk data\u000bArchival Storage'\n[7] 260.81px-wide text span at center-left: 'Initiation \u000b support and\u000b training'\n[8] Image, description: the logo for presvirica digital preservation at center-right\n[9] Image, description: the word arkivum at center-right\n[10] 260.81px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Automated data flow'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fully managed pilot service with cloud hosting and archival storage \u000bfor your data provided by Jisc'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: 'Pilot Alpha Minimum Viable Product'\n[13] Image, description: the logo for samvera at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '16'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-left: '16 Mar 2018'\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Notebooks - Jisc'"
},
{
"i": 431,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_BROWN_20180316_16_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12,
15
],
"rationale": "The date \u201c1918\u201d conflicts with the modern-era \u201cPilot Alpha Minimum Viable Product\u201d in ID 12.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 396.89px-wide text span at center-center: 'User capabilities'\n[2] 396.89px-wide text span at top-center: 'Jisc alpha repositories'\n[3] 306.17px-wide text span at center-center: 'Researcher User Interface Deposit Open Data Describe Cloud Storage Publish with DOI and ORCiD Curate'\n[4] 396.89px-wide text span at center-right: 'User capabilities'\n[5] 396.89px-wide text span at top-right: 'Jisc alpha preservation'\n[6] 306.17px-wide text span at center-right: 'Research Manager Interface\u000bSet policies\u000bAssure Integrity\u000bNormalise\u000bTransform\u000bCurate\u000bFlag at-risk data\u000bArchival Storage'\n[7] 260.81px-wide text span at center-left: 'Initiation \u000b support and\u000b training'\n[8] Image, description: the logo for presvirica digital preservation at center-right\n[9] Image, description: the word arkivum at center-right\n[10] 260.81px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Automated data flow'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Fully managed pilot service with cloud hosting and archival storage \u000bfor your data provided by Jisc'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: 'Pilot Alpha Minimum Viable Product'\n[13] Image, description: the logo for samvera at center-center\n[14] Compact text span at bottom-right: '16'\n[15] Compact text span at bottom-left: '16 Mar 1918'\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Digital Notebooks - Jisc'"
},
{
"i": 432,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_FinELib_sharing_negotiating_goals_20180704_10_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "Now ID2 mentions a per-member price, while ID3 states there are no membership fees, causing a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 405.05px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Freedom Of Information Request'\n[2] 503.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Contact publisher Total price per member Agreement text'\n[3] 419.23px-wide text span at center-right: 'No membership fees are required'\n[4] 404.84px-wide text span at center-center: 'Publish - Redact as necessary'\n[5] 438.69px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Contact members'\n[6] 358.75px-wide text span at top-center: 'News + tweet'\n[7] 278.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Objections'\n[8] 402.85px-wide text span at center-center: 'No objections'\n[9] 421.86px-wide text span at center-right: 'Inform members'\n[10] 278.81px-wide text span at center-left: 'Objections'\n[11] 346.13px-wide text span at center-left: 'No objections'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: 'Transparency: FinELib\u2019s process'"
},
{
"i": 433,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Groves NADDI pres_9_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "ID 1 says \"Respondents\" exist, while ID 2 now asserts there are \"No Respondents,\" creating a direct factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 396.11px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Respondents'\n[2] 241.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'No Respondents'\n[3] 214.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Frame'\n[4] 426.81px-wide text span at top-center: 'US Population'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Blended Paradigm'\n[6] 552.77px-wide text span at center-left: 'Web-Scraped Data'\n[7] 474.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Geospatial Data'\n[8] 531.44px-wide text span at center-right: 'Social Media Data'\n[9] 503.36px-wide text span at center-right: 'Transaction Data'\n[10] 368.04px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Search Data'\n[11] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '9'"
},
{
"i": 434,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Groves NADDI pres_9_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "Replacing \"Social Media Data\" with \"Military Drone Footage\" disrupts the thematic context of data sources.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 396.11px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Respondents'\n[2] 241.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'Sample'\n[3] 214.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Frame'\n[4] 426.81px-wide text span at top-center: 'US Population'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Blended Paradigm'\n[6] 552.77px-wide text span at center-left: 'Web-Scraped Data'\n[7] 474.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Geospatial Data'\n[8] 531.44px-wide text span at center-right: 'Military Drone Footage'\n[9] 503.36px-wide text span at center-right: 'Transaction Data'\n[10] 368.04px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Search Data'\n[11] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '9'"
},
{
"i": 435,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Groves NADDI pres_9_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "Changing \"Geospatial Data\" to a mythical, non-existent location creates an impossible spatial reference.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 396.11px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Respondents'\n[2] 241.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'Sample'\n[3] 214.31px-wide text span at center-center: 'Frame'\n[4] 426.81px-wide text span at top-center: 'US Population'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Blended Paradigm'\n[6] 552.77px-wide text span at center-left: 'Web-Scraped Data'\n[7] 474.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Lost City of Atlantis'\n[8] 531.44px-wide text span at center-right: 'Social Media Data'\n[9] 503.36px-wide text span at center-right: 'Transaction Data'\n[10] 368.04px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Search Data'\n[11] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '9'"
},
{
"i": 436,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_H\u00e1t\u00fan_OS2018_z_4_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
1
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the landmass on a map of the North Atlantic, causing identity conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The North Atlantic subpolar gyre retains silicate'\n[2] Image, description: the north atlantic subtropical cyclonic zone at center-center\n[3] 326.66px-wide text span at center-center: 'Australia'\n[4] Compact text span at top-right: '\u00b5M'\n[5] 474.6px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Climatology (WOA) 0-300m, April'"
},
{
"i": 437,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Iverson -NADDI 2018 - Metadata capture project_39_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
21
],
"rationale": "Element #6 now claims \u201cno automation\u201d while #21 explicitly discusses automating metadata, creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at center-center: 'SDTL'\n[2] 300.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'XML Updater'\n[3] 232.78px-wide text span at center-right: 'DDI XML'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'SPSSSAS Stata R'\n[5] 266.34px-wide text span at center-center: 'Script Parser'\n[6] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'No automation pz'\n[7] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Original data'\n[8] 210.42px-wide text span at center-right: 'Revised metadata'\n[9] 232.78px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'DDI XML'\n[10] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Original metadata'\n[11] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at top-center\n[12] 210.42px-wide text span at top-right: 'Revised data'\n[13] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at center-right\n[14] 334.7px-wide text span at top-center: 'SPSS SAS Stata R'\n[15] 334.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'CAI'\n[16] 266.34px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CAI to DDI'\n[17] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Statistical Packages'\n[18] 325.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Standard Data Transformation Language'\n[19] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Convert to DDI: CollecticaMQDS others'\n[20] 230.89px-wide text span at center-left: 'Computer Assisted Interviewing'\n[21] 440.98px-wide text span at top-right: 'Automating the capture of transformation metadata.'\n[22] 533.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Missing links that we will build.'"
},
{
"i": 438,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Iverson -NADDI 2018 - Metadata capture project_39_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
20
],
"rationale": "This renames \u201cComputer Assisted Interviewing\u201d to a paper-based survey brand, misattributing the identity and contradicting the CAI label in #15.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at center-center: 'SDTL'\n[2] 300.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'XML Updater'\n[3] 232.78px-wide text span at center-right: 'DDI XML'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'SPSSSAS Stata R'\n[5] 266.34px-wide text span at center-center: 'Script Parser'\n[6] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Command scripts:'\n[7] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Original data'\n[8] 210.42px-wide text span at center-right: 'Revised metadata'\n[9] 232.78px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'DDI XML'\n[10] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Original metadata'\n[11] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at top-center\n[12] 210.42px-wide text span at top-right: 'Revised data'\n[13] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at center-right\n[14] 334.7px-wide text span at top-center: 'SPSS SAS Stata R'\n[15] 334.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'CAI'\n[16] 266.34px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CAI to DDI'\n[17] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Statistical Packages'\n[18] 325.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Standard Data Transformation Language'\n[19] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Convert to DDI: CollecticaMQDS others'\n[20] 230.89px-wide text span at center-left: 'Paper Survey Incorporated LLC.'\n[21] 440.98px-wide text span at top-right: 'Automating the capture of transformation metadata.'\n[22] 533.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Missing links that we will build.'"
},
{
"i": 439,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Iverson -NADDI 2018 - Metadata capture project_39_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
21
],
"rationale": "The newly added warlike call in #21 clashes contextually with the data-transformation subject (#18), creating a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at center-center: 'SDTL'\n[2] 300.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'XML Updater'\n[3] 232.78px-wide text span at center-right: 'DDI XML'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'SPSSSAS Stata R'\n[5] 266.34px-wide text span at center-center: 'Script Parser'\n[6] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Command scripts:'\n[7] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Original data'\n[8] 210.42px-wide text span at center-right: 'Revised metadata'\n[9] 232.78px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'DDI XML'\n[10] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Original metadata'\n[11] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at top-center\n[12] 210.42px-wide text span at top-right: 'Revised data'\n[13] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at center-right\n[14] 334.7px-wide text span at top-center: 'SPSS SAS Stata R'\n[15] 334.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'CAI'\n[16] 266.34px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CAI to DDI'\n[17] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Statistical Packages'\n[18] 325.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Standard Data Transformation Language'\n[19] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Convert to DDI: CollecticaMQDS others'\n[20] 230.89px-wide text span at center-left: 'Computer Assisted Interviewing'\n[21] 440.98px-wide text span at top-right: 'Join the war against deadly alien invasions now!'\n[22] 533.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Missing links that we will build.'"
},
{
"i": 440,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Iverson -NADDI 2018 - Metadata capture project_39_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
22,
21
],
"rationale": "Stating the links were completed centuries ago (#22) conflicts with the forward-looking context in #21, causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Compact text span at center-center: 'SDTL'\n[2] 300.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'XML Updater'\n[3] 232.78px-wide text span at center-right: 'DDI XML'\n[4] Compact text span at center-center: 'SPSSSAS Stata R'\n[5] 266.34px-wide text span at center-center: 'Script Parser'\n[6] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Command scripts:'\n[7] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Original data'\n[8] 210.42px-wide text span at center-right: 'Revised metadata'\n[9] 232.78px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'DDI XML'\n[10] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Original metadata'\n[11] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at top-center\n[12] 210.42px-wide text span at top-right: 'Revised data'\n[13] Image, description: a spreadsheet with a number of numbers at center-right\n[14] 334.7px-wide text span at top-center: 'SPSS SAS Stata R'\n[15] 334.7px-wide text span at center-left: 'CAI'\n[16] 266.34px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CAI to DDI'\n[17] 210.42px-wide text span at top-center: 'Statistical Packages'\n[18] 325.79px-wide text span at center-center: 'Standard Data Transformation Language'\n[19] 210.42px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Convert to DDI: CollecticaMQDS others'\n[20] 230.89px-wide text span at center-left: 'Computer Assisted Interviewing'\n[21] 440.98px-wide text span at top-right: 'Automating the capture of transformation metadata.'\n[22] 533.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Links fully built in 1750.'"
},
{
"i": 441,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_KarinLarsen Western Valley Overflow_3_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
3
],
"rationale": "Mislabeled region: the diagram is about cold northern waters, but ID3 is now falsely labeled \"Tropical Sea.\"",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What drives the exchanges across the Greenland-Scotland Ridge?'\n[2] 262.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Greenland Scotland Ridge'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tropical Sea Region'\n[4] 511.61px-wide text span at center-left: 'Atlantic Ocean'\n[5] 328.47px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Overflow'\n[6] 332.8px-wide text span at top-right: 'Cooling'"
},
{
"i": 442,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_KarinLarsen Western Valley Overflow_3_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
6
],
"rationale": "Contextual mismatch: a scientific diagram about ocean circulation now includes \u201cTeatime,\u201d which is out of place.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What drives the exchanges across the Greenland-Scotland Ridge?'\n[2] 262.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Greenland Scotland Ridge'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Arctic Mediterranean'\n[4] 511.61px-wide text span at center-left: 'Atlantic Ocean'\n[5] 328.47px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Overflow'\n[6] 332.8px-wide text span at top-right: 'Teatime'"
},
{
"i": 443,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_KarinLarsen Western Valley Overflow_3_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "Spatial incoherence: the diagram is clearly Earth-based, but ID4 is labeled as a location on Mars.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'What drives the exchanges across the Greenland-Scotland Ridge?'\n[2] 262.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Greenland Scotland Ridge'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Arctic Mediterranean'\n[4] 511.61px-wide text span at center-left: 'Mars Station 5'\n[5] 328.47px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Overflow'\n[6] 332.8px-wide text span at top-right: 'Cooling'"
},
{
"i": 444,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_NCVS_PP_V2_clean_12_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
13,
14
],
"rationale": "This yields two boxes both labeled \"2012 Study\" (IDs 13 and 14), creating a direct factual conflict.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Define relationships:'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Testing DDI-Lifecycle at ICPSR'\n[4] 219.57px-wide text span at center-center: 'Series'\n[5] 366.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Concepts'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'Conceptual Variables'\n[7] Wide text span at center-center: 'Represented Variables'\n[8] 396.64px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Wave 1 Variables'\n[9] 394.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 2 Variables'\n[10] 392.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 3 Variables'\n[11] 407.13px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Wave 4 Variables'\n[12] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'\n[13] 272.73px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2012 Study'\n[14] 279.36px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2012 Study'\n[15] 276.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2013 Study'\n[16] 289.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: '2014 Study'\n[17] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'"
},
{
"i": 445,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_NCVS_PP_V2_clean_12_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15
],
"rationale": "By renaming \"2013 Study\" to \"IBM Headquarters,\" the label conflicts with \"Wave 3 Variables\" as an unrelated corporate location, creating an obvious misattribution.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Define relationships:'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Testing DDI-Lifecycle at ICPSR'\n[4] 219.57px-wide text span at center-center: 'Series'\n[5] 366.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Concepts'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'Conceptual Variables'\n[7] Wide text span at center-center: 'Represented Variables'\n[8] 396.64px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Wave 1 Variables'\n[9] 394.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 2 Variables'\n[10] 392.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 3 Variables'\n[11] 407.13px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Wave 4 Variables'\n[12] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'\n[13] 272.73px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2011 Study'\n[14] 279.36px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2012 Study'\n[15] 276.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'IBM Headquarters'\n[16] 289.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: '2014 Study'\n[17] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'"
},
{
"i": 446,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_NCVS_PP_V2_clean_12_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "A sudden reference to \"Celebrate War Heroes\" disrupts the academic/research context of the diagram.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Define relationships:'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Testing DDI-Lifecycle at ICPSR'\n[4] 219.57px-wide text span at center-center: 'Series'\n[5] 366.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Concepts'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'Celebrate War Heroes'\n[7] Wide text span at center-center: 'Represented Variables'\n[8] 396.64px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Wave 1 Variables'\n[9] 394.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 2 Variables'\n[10] 392.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 3 Variables'\n[11] 407.13px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Wave 4 Variables'\n[12] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'\n[13] 272.73px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2011 Study'\n[14] 279.36px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2012 Study'\n[15] 276.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2013 Study'\n[16] 289.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: '2014 Study'\n[17] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'"
},
{
"i": 447,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_NCVS_PP_V2_clean_12_3.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
13,
15
],
"rationale": "Having two distinct boxes both labeled \"2013 Study\" introduces a numerical/timeline conflict.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Define relationships:'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Testing DDI-Lifecycle at ICPSR'\n[4] 219.57px-wide text span at center-center: 'Series'\n[5] 366.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Concepts'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'Conceptual Variables'\n[7] Wide text span at center-center: 'Represented Variables'\n[8] 396.64px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Wave 1 Variables'\n[9] 394.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 2 Variables'\n[10] 392.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 3 Variables'\n[11] 407.13px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Wave 4 Variables'\n[12] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'\n[13] 272.73px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2013 Study'\n[14] 279.36px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2012 Study'\n[15] 276.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2013 Study'\n[16] 289.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: '2014 Study'\n[17] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'"
},
{
"i": 448,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_NCVS_PP_V2_clean_12_4.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
11,
16
],
"rationale": "Replacing a modern study year with \"1799\" creates an impossible temporal sequence next to Wave 4.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'Define relationships:'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '12'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Testing DDI-Lifecycle at ICPSR'\n[4] 219.57px-wide text span at center-center: 'Series'\n[5] 366.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'Concepts'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'Conceptual Variables'\n[7] Wide text span at center-center: 'Represented Variables'\n[8] 396.64px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Wave 1 Variables'\n[9] 394.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 2 Variables'\n[10] 392.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Wave 3 Variables'\n[11] 407.13px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Wave 4 Variables'\n[12] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'\n[13] 272.73px-wide text span at bottom-left: '2011 Study'\n[14] 279.36px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2012 Study'\n[15] 276.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2013 Study'\n[16] 289.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: '1799 Study'\n[17] 213.64px-wide text span at bottom-right: '\u2026..'"
},
{
"i": 449,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Nomisma 2018 - IIIF_11_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
5
],
"rationale": "One text indicates a monogram exists (id 2), while the modified text now denies it",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Coming soon: monogram annotation'\n[2] 391.91px-wide text span at center-center: 'Monogram URI: Price 707'\n[3] Image, description: the logo for the apb at bottom-center\n[4] 277.89px-wide text span at top-right: 'Type: Price 2455'\n[5] 380.58px-wide text span at center-center: 'No monogram'\n[6] 340.02px-wide text span at top-left: 'Coin 1 (ANS)'\n[7] 340.02px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Coin 2 (BnF)'\n[8] 236.55px-wide text span at top-center: 'Has type'\n[9] 236.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'Has type'\n[10] Image, description: the inscription of a stone with the letters bb at center-left\n[11] Wide text span at center-left: 'Image Annotation: 1280,1870,440,440'\n[12] 394.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'Represents URI'\n[13] Image, description: a silver coin with writing on it at bottom-center\n[14] 394.59px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Represents URI'\n[15] 427.59px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Image Annotation'"
},
{
"i": 450,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Nomisma 2018 - IIIF_11_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
7
],
"rationale": "This change mislabels Coin 1 as BnF, clashing with Coin 2\u2019s label",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Coming soon: monogram annotation'\n[2] 391.91px-wide text span at center-center: 'Monogram URI: Price 707'\n[3] Image, description: the logo for the apb at bottom-center\n[4] 277.89px-wide text span at top-right: 'Type: Price 2455'\n[5] 380.58px-wide text span at center-center: 'Has monogram'\n[6] 340.02px-wide text span at top-left: 'Coin 1 (BnF)'\n[7] 340.02px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Coin 2 (BnF)'\n[8] 236.55px-wide text span at top-center: 'Has type'\n[9] 236.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'Has type'\n[10] Image, description: the inscription of a stone with the letters bb at center-left\n[11] Wide text span at center-left: 'Image Annotation: 1280,1870,440,440'\n[12] 394.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'Represents URI'\n[13] Image, description: a silver coin with writing on it at bottom-center\n[14] 394.59px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Represents URI'\n[15] 427.59px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Image Annotation'"
},
{
"i": 451,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Nomisma 2018 - IIIF_11_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1
],
"rationale": "The new heading about nuclear meltdown contradicts the coin-related context",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Coming soon: nuclear meltdown'\n[2] 391.91px-wide text span at center-center: 'Monogram URI: Price 707'\n[3] Image, description: the logo for the apb at bottom-center\n[4] 277.89px-wide text span at top-right: 'Type: Price 2455'\n[5] 380.58px-wide text span at center-center: 'Has monogram'\n[6] 340.02px-wide text span at top-left: 'Coin 1 (ANS)'\n[7] 340.02px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Coin 2 (BnF)'\n[8] 236.55px-wide text span at top-center: 'Has type'\n[9] 236.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'Has type'\n[10] Image, description: the inscription of a stone with the letters bb at center-left\n[11] Wide text span at center-left: 'Image Annotation: 1280,1870,440,440'\n[12] 394.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'Represents URI'\n[13] Image, description: a silver coin with writing on it at bottom-center\n[14] 394.59px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Represents URI'\n[15] 427.59px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Image Annotation'"
},
{
"i": 452,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Open Access five pillars july 2018_5_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the primary stakeholders from \u201cpublishers\u201d to \u201cburger chains,\u201d conflicting with the open access theme (ID1).",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The five pillars of open access'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '5'\n[3] Image, description: the word archiving depositi on a red background at bottom-center\n[4] Image, description: the words international collaboration on a red background at center-center\n[5] Image, description: the words alternative publishing platforms at center-center\n[6] Image, description: the words, 'seo monitoring' at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a burger and some fries on a tray at top-center"
},
{
"i": 453,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Open Access five pillars july 2018_5_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "Creates a tonal mismatch between \u201copen access\u201d pillars (ID1) and an incongruous notion of demolition celebration.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The five pillars of open access'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '5'\n[3] Image, description: the word archiving depositi on a red background at bottom-center\n[4] ['Image, description: the words alternative publishing platforms' at center-center\n[5] [\"Image, description: the words, 'seo monitoring'\" at center-center\n[6] ['Image, description: the words, negotiations with publishers' at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: A sign on a red building has words in English and another kind of lettering. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 454,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Open Access five pillars july 2018_5_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Depicts an impossibly far future date, clashing with the contemporary \u201copen access\u201d context in ID1.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The five pillars of open access'\n[2] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '5'\n[3] ['Image, description: the words international collaboration on a red background' at bottom-center\n[4] ['Image, description: the words alternative publishing platforms' at center-center\n[5] [\"Image, description: the words, 'seo monitoring'\" at center-center\n[6] ['Image, description: the words, negotiations with publishers' at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: A red stop sign with a picture of a Time Magazine cover underneath stop. at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 455,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Open Access five pillars july 2018_7_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
5
],
"rationale": "Mislabels ID2 as \"Elsevier,\" which already appears at ID5, causing a brand identity clash.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Our approach of negotiations: \u000bFocus on the biggest publishers'\n[2] Wide text span at center-center: 'Elsevier'\n[3] 466.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '7'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Sage'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: 'Elsevier'\n[6] Wide text span at center-left: 'Wiley'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Oxford University Press'\n[8] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Taylor & Francis'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'American Chemical Society'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Kluwer'\n[11] 265.66px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'IOS Press'\n[12] 311.18px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'BOOM'\n[13] 311.18px-wide text span at center-center: 'Proquest'\n[14] 311.18px-wide text span at center-right: 'Ars Aequi'\n[15] 265.66px-wide text span at center-left: 'Brill'\n[16] 527.75px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Amsterdam University Press'\n[17] 392.77px-wide text span at center-center: 'Royal Society of Chemistry'"
},
{
"i": 456,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_3_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
4
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with [2]\u2019s claim of real-time extraction and continuous feedback",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the process of the energy management system at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'OrbEEt aims to leverage existing standards and methods of Building Operational Rating (OR) to deliver a mechanism for real-time extraction and calculation of detailed, fine-grained, dynamic parameters...'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'THE CONCEPT'\n[4] 496.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'No real-time extraction or context data is collected'\n[5] 452.83px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'eDECs-Enriched Display Energy Certificates'\n[6] 404.22px-wide text span at top-right: 'Incorporation of Building Specific Business Processes'\n[7] 404.22px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Gamification Tool for behavioural change campaigns'"
},
{
"i": 457,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_3_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
6
],
"rationale": "Mislabels building-specific processes as automotive, conflicting with [2]\u2019s building context",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the process of the energy management system at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'OrbEEt aims to leverage existing standards and methods of Building Operational Rating (OR) to deliver a mechanism for real-time extraction and calculation of detailed, fine-grained, dynamic parameters...'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'THE CONCEPT'\n[4] 496.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'Real Time energy and context data monitoring'\n[5] 452.83px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'eDECs-Enriched Display Energy Certificates'\n[6] 404.22px-wide text span at top-right: 'Incorporation of Tesla\u2019s Automotive Production Processes'\n[7] 404.22px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Gamification Tool for behavioural change campaigns'"
},
{
"i": 458,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_ORBEET Presentation_3_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Creates a temporal mismatch with the modern real-time references in [2]",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the process of the energy management system at center-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'OrbEEt aims to leverage existing standards and methods of Building Operational Rating (OR) to deliver a mechanism for real-time extraction and calculation of detailed, fine-grained, dynamic parameters...'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: '15th Century'\n[4] 496.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'Real Time energy and context data monitoring'\n[5] 452.83px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'eDECs-Enriched Display Energy Certificates'\n[6] 404.22px-wide text span at top-right: 'Incorporation of Building Specific Business Processes'\n[7] 404.22px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Gamification Tool for behavioural change campaigns'"
},
{
"i": 459,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_25_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "The mention of \u201cno outside labs\u201d in the modified text conflicts with the existing statement in ID 1 referencing multiple collaborators.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 600.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Coordinating different project threads across multiple labs/collaborators'\n[2] 600.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fully independent project with no outside labs'\n[3] 600.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Honing writing skills \u2013 scientific and general audience'\n[4] 600.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Improving my presenting skills and increasing my confidence in my own research'\n[5] 600.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Raising my profile as an early career researcher'\n[6] 600.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Opportunities to travel and present my work to different audiences'\n[7] 600.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Running an opennotebook helps my ongoing professional development as an early career researcher'"
},
{
"i": 460,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_25_1.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
7
],
"rationale": "The identity of a \u201ctenured senior professor\u201d in ID 5 conflicts with \u201cearly career researcher\u201d in ID 7.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 600.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Coordinating different project threads across multiple labs/collaborators'\n[2] 600.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Project planning and milestone achievement'\n[3] 600.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Honing writing skills \u2013 scientific and general audience'\n[4] 600.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Improving my presenting skills and increasing my confidence in my own research'\n[5] 600.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Bolstering my status as a tenured senior professor'\n[6] 600.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Opportunities to travel and present my work to different audiences'\n[7] 600.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Running an opennotebook helps my ongoing professional development as an early career researcher'"
},
{
"i": 461,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Rachel_Harding_Creative_Commons_20180413_25_2.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7,
4
],
"rationale": "The conclusion date in ID 4 conflicts with ongoing \u201cProject planning\u201d in ID 2, creating a temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 600.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Coordinating different project threads across multiple labs/collaborators'\n[2] 600.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Project planning and milestone achievement'\n[3] 600.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Honing writing skills \u2013 scientific and general audience'\n[4] 600.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'All presentations ended in 2010 with no further research plans'\n[5] 600.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Raising my profile as an early career researcher'\n[6] 600.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Opportunities to travel and present my work to different audiences'\n[7] 600.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Running an opennotebook helps my ongoing professional development as an early career researcher'"
},
{
"i": 462,
"source": "diagram",
"image": "images/diagrams_pptx_Remortel_SoLid_wide_FINAL_FINAL_17_0.png",
"question": "You are given a diagram that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
11
],
"rationale": "Placing 2030 among dates in 2017\u20132018 (IDs 6,7,12) disrupts the timeline, causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Trigger and DAQ'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'N. Van Remortel, University of Antwerpen'\n[3] 600.08px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Neutrino 2018 Heidelberg , 6/8/2018'\n[4] Image, description: the different types of nutrient at center-center\n[5] Image, description: a graph of the temperature of the ocean at bottom-center\n[6] 232.21px-wide text span at top-center: 'Dec 2017'\n[7] 228.66px-wide text span at top-center: 'Feb 2018'\n[8] 361.39px-wide text span at top-left: 'Construction & \u000bQuality Control'\n[9] 364.05px-wide text span at top-center: 'Commissioning \u000bat BR2'\n[10] 267.73px-wide text span at top-left: 'Installation'\n[11] 236.19px-wide text span at top-left: 'Apr 2030'\n[12] 239.22px-wide text span at top-center: 'Mar 2018'\n[13] 398.25px-wide text span at top-center: 'In-situ calibration'\n[14] 600.08px-wide text span at bottom-right: '17'"
},
{
"i": 463,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_my poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
22,
31
],
"rationale": "This misattributes the institution logo from UC San Diego (ID 23) to Harvard, creating a brand conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the words elimination and enzyme dilutions at bottom-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Transduction of Energy to Molecular Motion\u000bMudong Feng and Michael K. Gilson \u000bgilson.ucsd.edu'\n[3] 2100.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Is Enhanced Enzyme Diffusion Caused by Self-propulsion? Unlikely!'\n[4] 2100.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Various enzymes appear to have a bigger diffusion coefficient (about R=30% increase) when substrate is present. The enhance ratio R is found to be proportional to turnover rate: One proposed e...'\n[5] 2100.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Methods'\n[6] 2100.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Kinematics of self-propulsion: Dapp , Dt, Dr - apparent translational, baseline translational, and rotational diffusion coefficients; v - propulsion velocity; f - fraction of time when propulsion ...'\n[7] 2826.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Klok et al. 2008. \u201cMHz Unidirectional Rotation of Molecular Rotary Motors.\u201d Journal of the American Chemical Society Tuna, Deniz, You Lu, Axel Koslowski, and Walter Thiel. 2016. \u201cSemiempirical Quantum...'\n[8] 2826.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'This multi-scale MD strategy provides new level of detail in modelling light-driven molecular motors that have fast rotation speeds. Details of intermediate structures revealed and rotation rate const...'\n[9] 2826.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'References'\n[10] 2957.53px-wide text span at top-center: 'Molecular Dynamics Modelling of Alkene Rotary Motors'\n[11] 2957.53px-wide text span at center-center: 'Overcrowded alkene rotary motors transduce light energy to directionally rotate around its central double bond, capable of constructing nano-devices. The fastest variants achieved MHz rotation speed a...'\n[12] Image, description: the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the formula for the at top-left\n[13] 2100.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Conclusions'\n[14] 2100.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'References'\n[15] 2100.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'r \u2013 turnover rate The required free energies largely exceed actual reaction free energy for even the fast enzymes, not to say slow enzymes. Required free energy is large for enzyme self-prop...'\n[16] 2826.23px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Conclusions'\n[17] 2826.23px-wide text span at top-right: 'Results'\n[18] 2826.23px-wide text span at top-right: 'Before optimization of dihedral terms, GAFF2 parameters can not reproduce directionality of motor rotation and give unphysical conformations After optimization of dihedral terms, force field can fairl...'\n[19] Image, description: a qr code with a black background at top-right\n[20] 2096.43px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Riedel, Clement et al. 2014. \u201cThe Heat Released during Catalytic Turnover Enhances the Diffusion of an Enzyme.\u201d Nature Feng and Gilson. 2019. \u201cA Thermodynamic Limit on the Role of Self-Propulsion in E...'\n[21] 2100.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Self-propulsion is unlikely a mechanism of EED. EED is more likely caused by non-propulsive mechanisms. Transduction of chemical energy to EED requires overcoming or circumventing the limit of fast ro...'\n[22] ['Image, description: the uc san diego chemistry and biochemistry logo' at top-left\n[23] 1114.29px-wide text span at top-right: '['Introduction''\n[24] 2100.0px-wide text span at top-left: '['Results''\n[25] ['Image, description: the results of the study of the tas' at top-left\n[26] ['Image, description: a qr code on a white background' at top-left\n[27] 631.62px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Introduction''\n[28] 2957.53px-wide text span at top-center: '['Methods''\n[29] 2957.53px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Starting from FC point, picoseconds of surface-hopping MD simulates photoisomerization step. Energy and gradient evaluated by OM2/MRCI level of QM. Continuing from final structures of surface-hoppin...'\n[30] ['Image, description: the different types of wave patterns' at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: A Design College logo beneath scissors and a chain. at top-left"
},
{
"i": 464,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_conference nue112 poster 2 rescue[3504]_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
35
],
"rationale": "Text [3] states contamination spread throughout the entire city, contradicting the new image\u2019s claim that it was limited to 10 meters.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'SOCCORSO IN CASO DI ATTACCO TERRORISTICO / CBRNe'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Background: Un evento terroristico o un evento CBRNe richiede una risposta coordinata dell\u2019itero sistema di soccorso, protocolli standardizzati interforze, personale altamente qualificato ed addestrat...'\n[3] 2044.48px-wide text span at center-left: 'Sarin Tokyo 1995 Nessuna preparazione degli operatori; Mancato riconoscimento di un eventi chimico (segni e sintomi) Ritardo nella zonizzazione (contaminazione in tutta la citt\u00e0) Dispersione della con...'\n[4] 2139.77px-wide text span at top-right: 'Keywords: Crime scene, hot zone, rescue, first responder, EMT'\n[5] 2144.48px-wide text span at center-right: 'Molti operatori e soccorritori non hanno formazione idonea Nessuna standardizzazione di procedure e formazione Molti operatori/soccorritori non conoscono l\u2019incident command system Soccorritori non han...'\n[6] Image, description: a diagram of a scene with people and a sign at center-center\n[7] Image, description: a hazmat suit hanging on a rack at bottom-right\n[8] Image, description: the words espetti cbrne at bottom-right\n[9] Image, description: a black smoke billowing from a power station at bottom-left\n[10] Image, description: the time of the ride and the distance at bottom-left\n[11] Image, description: the word emergency management on a gray background at bottom-left\n[12] Image, description: a group of people in protective suits and a tape at bottom-center\n[13] Wide text span at top-left: 'L. Zelinotti (1), P. Cosmi (2), M. Procacciante (3), M. Monti (4), M. Valente (2), T. Pergolizzi (2), A. Vinci (2), F. Rosiello (2) Esperti CBRNe (2) Sapienza-Universit\u00e0 di Roma, (3) Universit\u00e0 Tor Ve...'\n[14] Image, description: a man standing in front of a pile of garbage at bottom-center\n[15] Image, description: a group of fire trucks on a road at bottom-center\n[16] Image, description: a man in a boat near a ship at center-center\n[17] Image, description: a train track with a fire on it at center-center\n[18] Image, description: a train wreck on the tracks at center-center\n[19] Image, description: the wreck of a ship in the water at center-center\n[20] Image, description: a man carrying a bomb in a truck at center-center\n[21] Image, description: an ambulance parked in front of a building at center-center\n[22] 1630.63px-wide text span at center-left: 'Lo studio:'\n[23] 1223.46px-wide text span at center-right: 'Findings'\n[24] Image, description: a man being treated by medical personnel at center-center\n[25] Image, description: a group of people standing near a bus stop at center-center\n[26] 257.43px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://www.ilpost.it/'\n[27] 470.95px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://www.seisakukikaku.metro.tokyo.jp'\n[28] 236.04px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://gaianews.it/'\n[29] 314.23px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://www.nauticexpo.it/'\n[30] 337.72px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://www.viareggino.com/'\n[31] 247.61px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://www.ansa.it/'\n[32] 370.32px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'http://www.latinaquotidiano.it/'\n[33] 340.52px-wide text span at center-center: 'http://www.ilfattonisseno.it/'\n[34] Image, description: a qr code on a white background at bottom-center\n[35] Image, description: an image of a large building in the air at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 465,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_EMSEAposter_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5,
8
],
"rationale": "Directly conflicts with the sustainability message in ID 5",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Engaging the public with deep-marine ecosystems An outreach portfolio for the ATLAS Project by Dynamic Earth'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Emma Paterson'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Learning Officer, ATLAS Project, Dynamic Earth'\n[4] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Atlas at a Glance'\n[5] Wide text span at top-left: 'A trans-Atlantic research project funded by the EU under the Horizon 2020 Blue Growth call. What lives in the deep (200-2000m) North Atlantic and how is it connected to other areas? How will it be aff...'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words being made a sustainable use of resources at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a bar chart with the words available for students careers related to marine science at bottom-right\n[8] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Destructive use of resources'\n[9] Image, description: people standing in a tunnel at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: children sitting on the floor and a man is talking at top-center\n[11] Image, description: a group of people at an event at top-right\n[12] Image, description: a bar chart with the words scottish teacher responses at bottom-center\n[13] Image, description: a bar chart with the words, q if you want to do an intercultural exchange at bottom-right\n[14] Image, description: a man and woman in a room with a television at bottom-right\n[15] Image, description: a large white tent with a mountain in the background at top-right\n[16] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-right: 'Dynamic Earth'\n[17] 1965.51px-wide text span at center-right: 'Audiences of around 10,000 families and school children p.a.'\n[18] 2031.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Outreach Portfolio'\n[19] Wide text span at center-left: 'Developing Ocean Literacy in Scotland: delivery through Dynamic Earth\u2019s programmes and activities. Wider reach through uptake by ATLAS partners. Script, presentation and kit list for a curriculum-link...'\n[20] Wide text span at center-right: 'Following extensive research into how ATLAS and Ocean Literacy themes fit with the Scottish curriculum. ~70% of teachers already teach oceans science, mainly ocean circulation/currents and plastic pol...'\n[21] Wide text span at center-right: 'Teacher Survey'\n[22] 2031.23px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Oceans Gallery'\n[23] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Custom-designed ROV simulator game based on two ATLAS case study locations. Setwork to create look and feel of ship-board ROV control room. Portable version for public engagement. Seeking funding for ...'\n[24] Image, description: a boat with a small submerged object at center-left\n[25] 1311.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'An Earth and Environmental Science Educational charity based in Edinburgh.'\n[26] 1667.06px-wide text span at top-center: 'In-house programme of educational workshops and public engagement. 240,000 visitors to the centre p.a.'\n[27] Image, description: a group of children in a gymnasium at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a group of children in a classroom at center-center\n[29] 808.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'Outreach at regional science festivals across Scotland with school shows and family activity days.'\n[30] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Careers relating to marine science'\n[31] 788.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Scottish teacher responses'\n[32] 629.45px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'International teacher responses'\n[33] Image, description: a rock with a blue color at center-center\n[34] 929.43px-wide text span at center-left: 'ROV LUSO being deployed and new hydrothermal vent discovered in the Azores. Credit: ROV Luso, Portuguese Task Force for the Extension of the Continental Shelf (EMEPC), Oceano Azul Expedition'\n[35] 1901.43px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Except where specified, all images credit: Dynamic Earth'\n[36] 1173.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Yellow Submarine gallery, Dynamic Earth'\n[37] 1449.81px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Proposed gallery redevelopment \u00a9 Studio MB'\n[38] Image, description: two people in lab coats standing on a pair of skateboards at bottom-left\n[39] Image, description: three people in lab coats posing with octopus hats at bottom-left\n[40] Image, description: a man with a blindfolded hand holding a broom at bottom-left\n[41] 668.68px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Example activities from Primary school show left to right: \u2018Science at Sea\u2019 balancing; simulating ROV coral sample collection; sea characters from a Marine Protected Area demonstration; model Lophelia...'\n[42] Image, description: a white coral on a wooden surface at bottom-center\n[43] 777.76px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Where \u20181 is least and \u20185\u2019 is most.'\n[44] Image, description: the logo for dynamic earth at center-right\n[45] Image, description: a man standing in front of a group of children at center-right"
},
{
"i": 466,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_EMSEAposter_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
25,
16
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the charity in ID 16 as a coffee company, contradicting ID 25's description",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Engaging the public with deep-marine ecosystems An outreach portfolio for the ATLAS Project by Dynamic Earth'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Emma Paterson'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Learning Officer, ATLAS Project, Dynamic Earth'\n[4] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Atlas at a Glance'\n[5] Wide text span at top-left: 'A trans-Atlantic research project funded by the EU under the Horizon 2020 Blue Growth call. What lives in the deep (200-2000m) North Atlantic and how is it connected to other areas? How will it be aff...'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words being made a sustainable use of resources at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a bar chart with the words available for students careers related to marine science at bottom-right\n[8] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sustainable use of resources'\n[9] Image, description: people standing in a tunnel at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: children sitting on the floor and a man is talking at top-center\n[11] Image, description: a group of people at an event at top-right\n[12] Image, description: a bar chart with the words scottish teacher responses at bottom-center\n[13] Image, description: a bar chart with the words, q if you want to do an intercultural exchange at bottom-right\n[14] Image, description: a man and woman in a room with a television at bottom-right\n[15] Image, description: a large white tent with a mountain in the background at top-right\n[16] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-right: 'Starbucks Co.'\n[17] 1965.51px-wide text span at center-right: 'Audiences of around 10,000 families and school children p.a.'\n[18] 2031.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Outreach Portfolio'\n[19] Wide text span at center-left: 'Developing Ocean Literacy in Scotland: delivery through Dynamic Earth\u2019s programmes and activities. Wider reach through uptake by ATLAS partners. Script, presentation and kit list for a curriculum-link...'\n[20] Wide text span at center-right: 'Following extensive research into how ATLAS and Ocean Literacy themes fit with the Scottish curriculum. ~70% of teachers already teach oceans science, mainly ocean circulation/currents and plastic pol...'\n[21] Wide text span at center-right: 'Teacher Survey'\n[22] 2031.23px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Oceans Gallery'\n[23] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Custom-designed ROV simulator game based on two ATLAS case study locations. Setwork to create look and feel of ship-board ROV control room. Portable version for public engagement. Seeking funding for ...'\n[24] Image, description: a boat with a small submerged object at center-left\n[25] 1311.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'An Earth and Environmental Science Educational charity based in Edinburgh.'\n[26] 1667.06px-wide text span at top-center: 'In-house programme of educational workshops and public engagement. 240,000 visitors to the centre p.a.'\n[27] Image, description: a group of children in a gymnasium at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a group of children in a classroom at center-center\n[29] 808.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'Outreach at regional science festivals across Scotland with school shows and family activity days.'\n[30] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Careers relating to marine science'\n[31] 788.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Scottish teacher responses'\n[32] 629.45px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'International teacher responses'\n[33] Image, description: a rock with a blue color at center-center\n[34] 929.43px-wide text span at center-left: 'ROV LUSO being deployed and new hydrothermal vent discovered in the Azores. Credit: ROV Luso, Portuguese Task Force for the Extension of the Continental Shelf (EMEPC), Oceano Azul Expedition'\n[35] 1901.43px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Except where specified, all images credit: Dynamic Earth'\n[36] 1173.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Yellow Submarine gallery, Dynamic Earth'\n[37] 1449.81px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Proposed gallery redevelopment \u00a9 Studio MB'\n[38] Image, description: two people in lab coats standing on a pair of skateboards at bottom-left\n[39] Image, description: three people in lab coats posing with octopus hats at bottom-left\n[40] Image, description: a man with a blindfolded hand holding a broom at bottom-left\n[41] 668.68px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Example activities from Primary school show left to right: \u2018Science at Sea\u2019 balancing; simulating ROV coral sample collection; sea characters from a Marine Protected Area demonstration; model Lophelia...'\n[42] Image, description: a white coral on a wooden surface at bottom-center\n[43] 777.76px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Where \u20181 is least and \u20185\u2019 is most.'\n[44] Image, description: the logo for dynamic earth at center-right\n[45] Image, description: a man standing in front of a group of children at center-right"
},
{
"i": 467,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_EMSEAposter_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
35,
45
],
"rationale": "The new, hostile scene conflicts with the family-friendly context in ID 17",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Engaging the public with deep-marine ecosystems An outreach portfolio for the ATLAS Project by Dynamic Earth'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Emma Paterson'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Learning Officer, ATLAS Project, Dynamic Earth'\n[4] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Atlas at a Glance'\n[5] Wide text span at top-left: 'A trans-Atlantic research project funded by the EU under the Horizon 2020 Blue Growth call. What lives in the deep (200-2000m) North Atlantic and how is it connected to other areas? How will it be aff...'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words being made a sustainable use of resources at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a bar chart with the words available for students careers related to marine science at bottom-right\n[8] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sustainable use of resources'\n[9] Image, description: people standing in a tunnel at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: children sitting on the floor and a man is talking at top-center\n[11] Image, description: a group of people at an event at top-right\n[12] Image, description: a bar chart with the words scottish teacher responses at bottom-center\n[13] Image, description: a bar chart with the words, q if you want to do an intercultural exchange at bottom-right\n[14] Image, description: a man and woman in a room with a television at bottom-right\n[15] Image, description: a large white tent with a mountain in the background at top-right\n[16] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-right: 'Dynamic Earth'\n[17] 1965.51px-wide text span at center-right: 'Audiences of around 10,000 families and school children p.a.'\n[18] 2031.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Outreach Portfolio'\n[19] Wide text span at center-left: 'Developing Ocean Literacy in Scotland: delivery through Dynamic Earth\u2019s programmes and activities. Wider reach through uptake by ATLAS partners. Script, presentation and kit list for a curriculum-link...'\n[20] Wide text span at center-right: 'Following extensive research into how ATLAS and Ocean Literacy themes fit with the Scottish curriculum. ~70% of teachers already teach oceans science, mainly ocean circulation/currents and plastic pol...'\n[21] Wide text span at center-right: 'Teacher Survey'\n[22] 2031.23px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Oceans Gallery'\n[23] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Custom-designed ROV simulator game based on two ATLAS case study locations. Setwork to create look and feel of ship-board ROV control room. Portable version for public engagement. Seeking funding for ...'\n[24] Image, description: a boat with a small submerged object at center-left\n[25] 1311.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'An Earth and Environmental Science Educational charity based in Edinburgh.'\n[26] 1667.06px-wide text span at top-center: 'In-house programme of educational workshops and public engagement. 240,000 visitors to the centre p.a.'\n[27] Image, description: a group of children in a gymnasium at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a group of children in a classroom at center-center\n[29] 808.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'Outreach at regional science festivals across Scotland with school shows and family activity days.'\n[30] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Careers relating to marine science'\n[31] 788.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Scottish teacher responses'\n[32] 629.45px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'International teacher responses'\n[33] Image, description: a rock with a blue color at center-center\n[34] 929.43px-wide text span at center-left: 'ROV LUSO being deployed and new hydrothermal vent discovered in the Azores. Credit: ROV Luso, Portuguese Task Force for the Extension of the Continental Shelf (EMEPC), Oceano Azul Expedition'\n[35] 1901.43px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Except where specified, all images credit: Dynamic Earth'\n[36] 1173.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Yellow Submarine gallery, Dynamic Earth'\n[37] 1449.81px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Proposed gallery redevelopment \u00a9 Studio MB'\n[38] Image, description: two people in lab coats standing on a pair of skateboards at bottom-left\n[39] Image, description: three people in lab coats posing with octopus hats at bottom-left\n[40] Image, description: a man with a blindfolded hand holding a broom at bottom-left\n[41] 668.68px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Example activities from Primary school show left to right: \u2018Science at Sea\u2019 balancing; simulating ROV coral sample collection; sea characters from a Marine Protected Area demonstration; model Lophelia...'\n[42] Image, description: a white coral on a wooden surface at bottom-center\n[43] 777.76px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Where \u20181 is least and \u20185\u2019 is most.'\n[44] Image, description: the logo for dynamic earth at center-right\n[45] Image, description: Several people expressing their right to protest violence at center-right"
},
{
"i": 468,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_EMSEAposter_1_3.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
36
],
"rationale": "Implies an impossible location, clashing with the Edinburgh-based setting in ID 25",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Engaging the public with deep-marine ecosystems An outreach portfolio for the ATLAS Project by Dynamic Earth'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Emma Paterson'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Learning Officer, ATLAS Project, Dynamic Earth'\n[4] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Atlas at a Glance'\n[5] Wide text span at top-left: 'A trans-Atlantic research project funded by the EU under the Horizon 2020 Blue Growth call. What lives in the deep (200-2000m) North Atlantic and how is it connected to other areas? How will it be aff...'\n[6] Image, description: a bar chart with the words being made a sustainable use of resources at bottom-center\n[7] Image, description: a bar chart with the words available for students careers related to marine science at bottom-right\n[8] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sustainable use of resources'\n[9] Image, description: people standing in a tunnel at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: children sitting on the floor and a man is talking at top-center\n[11] Image, description: a group of people at an event at top-right\n[12] Image, description: a bar chart with the words scottish teacher responses at bottom-center\n[13] Image, description: a bar chart with the words, q if you want to do an intercultural exchange at bottom-right\n[14] Image, description: a man and woman in a room with a television at bottom-right\n[15] Image, description: a large white tent with a mountain in the background at top-right\n[16] 2031.23px-wide text span at top-right: 'Dynamic Earth'\n[17] 1965.51px-wide text span at center-right: 'Audiences of around 10,000 families and school children p.a.'\n[18] 2031.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Outreach Portfolio'\n[19] Wide text span at center-left: 'Developing Ocean Literacy in Scotland: delivery through Dynamic Earth\u2019s programmes and activities. Wider reach through uptake by ATLAS partners. Script, presentation and kit list for a curriculum-link...'\n[20] Wide text span at center-right: 'Following extensive research into how ATLAS and Ocean Literacy themes fit with the Scottish curriculum. ~70% of teachers already teach oceans science, mainly ocean circulation/currents and plastic pol...'\n[21] Wide text span at center-right: 'Teacher Survey'\n[22] 2031.23px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Oceans Gallery'\n[23] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Custom-designed ROV simulator game based on two ATLAS case study locations. Setwork to create look and feel of ship-board ROV control room. Portable version for public engagement. Seeking funding for ...'\n[24] Image, description: a boat with a small submerged object at center-left\n[25] 1311.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'An Earth and Environmental Science Educational charity based in Edinburgh.'\n[26] 1667.06px-wide text span at top-center: 'In-house programme of educational workshops and public engagement. 240,000 visitors to the centre p.a.'\n[27] Image, description: a group of children in a gymnasium at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a group of children in a classroom at center-center\n[29] 808.04px-wide text span at center-right: 'Outreach at regional science festivals across Scotland with school shows and family activity days.'\n[30] 371.1px-wide text span at center-right: 'Careers relating to marine science'\n[31] 788.25px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Scottish teacher responses'\n[32] 629.45px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'International teacher responses'\n[33] Image, description: a rock with a blue color at center-center\n[34] 929.43px-wide text span at center-left: 'ROV LUSO being deployed and new hydrothermal vent discovered in the Azores. Credit: ROV Luso, Portuguese Task Force for the Extension of the Continental Shelf (EMEPC), Oceano Azul Expedition'\n[35] 1901.43px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Except where specified, all images credit: Dynamic Earth'\n[36] 1173.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Medieval Submarine base, far Antarctica'\n[37] 1449.81px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Proposed gallery redevelopment \u00a9 Studio MB'\n[38] Image, description: two people in lab coats standing on a pair of skateboards at bottom-left\n[39] Image, description: three people in lab coats posing with octopus hats at bottom-left\n[40] Image, description: a man with a blindfolded hand holding a broom at bottom-left\n[41] 668.68px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Example activities from Primary school show left to right: \u2018Science at Sea\u2019 balancing; simulating ROV coral sample collection; sea characters from a Marine Protected Area demonstration; model Lophelia...'\n[42] Image, description: a white coral on a wooden surface at bottom-center\n[43] 777.76px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Where \u20181 is least and \u20185\u2019 is most.'\n[44] Image, description: the logo for dynamic earth at center-right\n[45] Image, description: a man standing in front of a group of children at center-right"
},
{
"i": 469,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Whitaker_TuringWayPoster_TPSScopingWorkshop_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
7
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with [9], which emphasizes reproducibility, creating a factual contradiction.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Turing Way Project, Becky Arnold, Louise Bowler, Sarah Gibson, Patricia Herterich, Rosie Higman, Anna Krystalli, Alexander Morely, Martin O\u2019Reilly & Kirstie Whitaker. https://github.com/alan-turing-in...'\n[2] Image, description: the twitter logo on a blue square at bottom-left\n[3] Image, description: a cat in a circle at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: the logo for a music app at bottom-left\n[5] Image, description: the university of cambridge logo at top-right\n[6] Image, description: the process of a research project at center-left\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Initial chapters for the Turing Way that disclaim reproducibility as unimportant.'\n[8] Image, description: the public binderhub instance at center-right\n[9] Wide text span at center-right: 'Schematic of the building blocks that BinderHub uses to support a reproducible workflow.'"
},
{
"i": 470,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_PS2019_poster_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14,
5
],
"rationale": "Labeling Machu Picchu as a European fortress creates an impossible spatial timeline",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the words mobilize communities and engineering to preserve biodiversity and empower local cultures at center-center\n[2] 1454.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'Non-Cognitive Predictors of Student Success:\u000bA Predictive Validity Comparison Between Domestic and International Students'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'mobilize communities and utilize\u00a0engineering\u00a0to\u00a0preserve biodiversity and protect and empower\u00a0local cultures'\n[4] 1466.67px-wide text span at center-left: 'Non-Cognitive Predictors of Student Success:\u000bA Predictive Validity Comparison Between Domestic and International Students'\n[5] 1334.04px-wide text span at center-left: 'MOTIVATIONS The problems facing our world are evolving and challenging Globalization often perpetuates those problems and requires new skills for tomorrow\u2019s leaders Cross-disciplinary collaboration ca...'\n[6] 1387.3px-wide text span at top-left: 'Applied Research Innovation through Social Networks:\u000bThe Story of a Mechanical Engineer, a Sociologist, and a Restaurant'\n[7] 1096.14px-wide text span at top-left: 'Devin R. Berg, Nels Paulson'\n[8] Image, description: the university of wisconsin stout logo at bottom-left\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'afuera hay m\u00e1s'\n[10] Image, description: a table with several bowls and a menu at top-right\n[11] Image, description: the ruins of the inca city of machu picchu at center-right\n[12] Image, description: a man standing in a field of flowers at bottom-right\n[13] Image, description: the logo for matter incitativa at bottom-right\n[14] Image, description: A tall white fortress surrounded by tall trees. at top-right"
},
{
"i": 471,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_2020 SU kidney week poster v.2_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15,
17
],
"rationale": "This creates a direct factual contradiction with results in ID [17] stating DCT length is increased.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the weight of the different types of weight at top-right\n[2] Image, description: the different levels of cst1 and cst2 at top-right\n[3] 2536.61px-wide text span at top-left: 'Four Weeks of Dietary Potassium Restriction Causes Distal Convoluted Tubule Remodeling'\n[4] 2360.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'BACKGROUND'\n[5] 2360.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'HYPOTHESIS'\n[6] 1472.06px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Funding - KidneyCure NIH DK51496 VA 1I01BX002228 LeDucq Fondation'\n[7] Image, description: the logo for ohsu at top-left\n[8] 2257.01px-wide text span at top-left: '1 Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR. 2 University Hospital RWTH Aachen, Aachen, Germany 3 Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 4 VA Portland Health Care System,...'\n[9] 2470.25px-wide text span at top-left: 'Xiao-Tong Su1, Turgay Saritas2, Chao-Ling Yang1, Paul Welling3, and David H. Ellison1,4'\n[10] 2171.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'SUMMARY'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'Prolonged dietary potassium restriction increases NCC activity and DCT length to maintain electrolyte balance.'\n[12] 1065.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'METHODS'\n[13] 1766.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Take a picture of the QR code to\u000bsave this poster and stay updated\u000bon developments in our lab'\n[14] 2171.67px-wide text span at top-right: 'RESULTS'\n[15] 2581.91px-wide text span at center-left: 'We hypothesized that prolonged dietary potassium restriction decreases DCT length.'\n[16] 2576.59px-wide text span at center-left: 'A \u2018renal potassium switch\u2019 has been described within the distal nephron that turns on the thiazide-sensitive Na-Cl cotransporter (NCC) in the distal convoluted tubule (DCT) in response to low potassiu...'\n[17] 2515.53px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Four weeks of potassium restriction without or with sodium loading causes Severe hypokalemia and kidney hypertrophy; Increased phosphorylated NCC, but not total NCC; Increased DCT length by 12% and 22...'\n[18] 2596.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Male C57Bl/6 mice were provided either control potassium diet (NK), low potassium diet (LK4w) or low potassium high sodium diet (LKHS4w) for four weeks. Blood and kidneys were harvested and analyzed. ...'\n[19] 2171.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'CONCLUSIONS'\n[20] 2476.79px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The DCT elongates in response to prolonged dietary potassium restriction.'\n[21] 2580.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Blood Parameters'\n[22] 2580.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Distal Nephron Sodium Transport'\n[23] 2580.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'DCT length and number'\n[24] Image, description: a qr code on a white background at bottom-left\n[25] Image, description: the process of a green - colored - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - at bottom-left\n[26] Image, description: the different stages of the process at center-center\n[27] Image, description: the number of nss and nss in the same area at center-right\n[28] Image, description: the number of nccc and nccc at center-right"
},
{
"i": 472,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_2020 SU kidney week poster v.2_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
28
],
"rationale": "A whimsical clown performance image is out of place in a serious scientific poster, creating a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image-image",
"descs": "[1] ['Image, description: the different levels of cst1 and cst2' at top-right\n[2] 2708.5px-wide text span at top-right: '['Four Weeks of Dietary Potassium Restriction Causes Distal Convoluted Tubule Remodeling''\n[3] 2536.61px-wide text span at top-left: '['BACKGROUND''\n[4] 2360.0px-wide text span at top-left: '['HYPOTHESIS''\n[5] 2360.0px-wide text span at center-left: '['Funding - KidneyCure NIH DK51496 VA 1I01BX002228 LeDucq Fondation''\n[6] ['Image, description: the logo for ohsu' at bottom-right\n[7] 278.48px-wide text span at top-left: '['1 Oregon Health and Science University, Portland, OR. 2 University Hospital RWTH Aachen, Aachen, Germany 3 Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD 4 VA Portland Health Care Syste...'\n[8] 2257.01px-wide text span at top-left: '['Xiao-Tong Su1, Turgay Saritas2, Chao-Ling Yang1, Paul Welling3, and David H. Ellison1,4''\n[9] 2470.25px-wide text span at top-left: '['SUMMARY''\n[10] 2171.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Prolonged dietary potassium restriction increases NCC activity and DCT length to maintain electrolyte balance.''\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: '['METHODS''\n[12] 1065.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Take a picture of the QR code to\\x0bsave this poster and stay updated\\x0bon developments in our lab''\n[13] 1766.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['RESULTS''\n[14] 2171.67px-wide text span at top-right: '['We hypothesized that prolonged dietary potassium restriction increases DCT length.''\n[15] 2581.91px-wide text span at center-left: '['A \u2018renal potassium switch\u2019 has been described within the distal nephron that turns on the thiazide-sensitive Na-Cl cotransporter (NCC) in the distal convoluted tubule (DCT) in response to low potass...'\n[16] 2576.59px-wide text span at center-left: '['Four weeks of potassium restriction without or with sodium loading causes Severe hypokalemia and kidney hypertrophy; Increased phosphorylated NCC, but not total NCC; Increased DCT length by 12% and ...'\n[17] 2515.53px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Male C57Bl/6 mice were provided either control potassium diet (NK), low potassium diet (LK4w) or low potassium high sodium diet (LKHS4w) for four weeks. Blood and kidneys were harvested and analyzed...'\n[18] 2596.31px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['CONCLUSIONS''\n[19] 2171.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['The DCT elongates in response to prolonged dietary potassium restriction.''\n[20] 2476.79px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Blood Parameters''\n[21] 2580.0px-wide text span at top-right: '['Distal Nephron Sodium Transport''\n[22] 2580.0px-wide text span at top-right: '['DCT length and number''\n[23] ['Image, description: a qr code on a white background' at center-right\n[24] ['Image, description: the process of a green - colored - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -' at bottom-left\n[25] ['Image, description: the different stages of the process' at bottom-left\n[26] ['Image, description: the number of nss and nss in the same area' at center-center\n[27] ['Image, description: the number of nccc and nccc' at center-right\n[28] Image, description: The people is dressed up as funny clowns at top-right"
},
{
"i": 473,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Glial Scar in CNS injury Poster 11-10-20 - Salma Ramadan_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
9
],
"rationale": "Using an informal, celebratory heading instead of a formal scientific one creates a tonal mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 808.02px-wide text span at center-left: 'Glial scar formation, reactive astrogliosis specifically, has been involved in CNS traumas, infections, stroke, seizures, brain tumors, neurodegenerative disorders, psychiatric diseases, and many meta...'\n[2] 785.04px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Glial scar\u00a0formation is a vital part of the pathology of\u00a0SCI. It contains multiple cellular components and a complex extracellular matrix. It has dual stimulatory and inhibitory effects on axon regene...'\n[3] 800.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'BACKGROUND'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'RESULTS'\n[5] 800.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'RESULTS'\n[6] 801.07px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'CONCLUSION'\n[7] 667.41px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Disclosure: There is no conflict of interest to declare'\n[8] Wide text span at top-center: 'Glial Scar Formation in CNS injury: A sub-map\u00a0\u000bSalma Ramadan1,2, Mohammed Ibrahim1, Mohammed Alaa1, Bassem Awad1 1Mansoura University Hospitals, Egypt, 2SiParadigm Diagnostic Informatics, New Jersey,...'\n[9] 791.63px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'PARTY TIME'\n[10] Image, description: the logo for mansoura university at top-right\n[11] 772.7px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'To design interconnected\u00a0 map allowing researchers to visualize all the relative signaling, metabolic and omics pathways to the glial scar in CNS injuries. To help also generate ideas about gaps in k...'\n[12] 794.77px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'METHODS'\n[13] 772.7px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'We designed a map illustrating the pathophysiology of the glial scar formation in the CNS injury using CellDesigner 4.4.2 (Systems Biology Institute, Tokyo, Japan), as a part of a bigger SCI map. The...'\n[14] Wide text span at top-center: 'Further, our map highlights the role of reactive astrocytes, scar-forming astrocytes, microglia, pericytes, oligodendrocyte, ependymal cells, endothelial cells, macrophages, neutrophils, fibroblasts, ...'\n[15] 916.92px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Reactive Astrocyte Role in Gliosis and Spinal Cord Regeneration'\n[16] Image, description: a diagram of a computer system at bottom-center\n[17] 746.53px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Microglial Scar has Beneficial and Neurotoxic Effects'\n[18] Image, description: the process of a python program at center-right\n[19] 792.19px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Oligodendrocyte Progenitor Cell and Oligodendrocyte Roles in Axonal Regeneration'\n[20] Image, description: the words'50th disease maps community meeting' at top-left\n[21] 796.42px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'ACKNOWLEDGEMENT'\n[22] 798.93px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'We thank Luxembourg Centre for Systems Biomedicine (LCSB) for training us on cellDesigner software.'"
},
{
"i": 474,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_RNAget Poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
56
],
"rationale": "ID [1] mentions the Global Alliance for Genomics and Health, but the image is now mislabeled as a NASA emblem instead.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'GA4GH RNA WORKING GROUP* PRESENTED BY SEAN UPCHURCH1, EMILIO PALUMBO2, JEREMY ADAMS3, DAVID BUJOLD4 1: California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, US. 2: Centre de Regulacio Genomica, Barcelona,...'\n[2] 1983.33px-wide text span at center-left: 'The RNAget API describes a common set of endpoints for search and retrieval of processed RNA data such as feature level expression data from RNA-Seq type assays and signal data over a range of bases f...'\n[3] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'RNAget specification design and details'\n[5] 1983.33px-wide text span at center-right: 'Output Matrix Format Output in the recommended loom format or as a tsv matrix makes it easier to import data into analysis tools. Slicing of the matrix at the request enables the user to request the ...'\n[6] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Features of RNAget'\n[7] 1983.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Share your data Complete specifications and directions for setting up an RNAget service are available at https://github.com/ga4gh-rnaseq/schema Integrate RNAget with Analysis Tools If you have an R...'\n[8] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'How to get involved'\n[9] Image, description: the global alliance for genomics and health logo at top-right\n[10] Wide text span at top-left: 'RNAget: An API for retrieving processed RNA-derived measurements'\n[11] 227.55px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'GDC'\n[12] 227.55px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'ENCODE'\n[13] 234.27px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'IHEC'\n[14] 234.27px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Express. Atlas'\n[15] 781.5px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Harmonize Existing APIs'\n[16] 404.81px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Matrix'\n[17] 1725.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Motivation: Increase interoperability and scalability Reduce deployment effort'\n[18] 1983.33px-wide text span at center-left: 'Overview of RNAget'\n[19] 1725.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Based on existing APIs Introduce a matrix format for data retrieval'\n[20] 1257.38px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Easy to load into analysis software Compressed formats available loom (recommended) hdf5 Slice on samples and/or features axes'\n[21] 529.74px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Matrix'\n[22] 303.18px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Samples'\n[23] 361.65px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Features'\n[24] 580.08px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Requested Matrix'\n[25] 1983.33px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Matrix'\n[26] 774.57px-wide text span at top-center: '\"Study\" is a set of related and uniformly processed samples'\n[27] 591.2px-wide text span at top-center: '\"Project\" is a helper to organize studies'\n[28] 1012.29px-wide text span at center-left: '\"Expression\" \u2013 feature level expression Expression queries can slice on samples and features'\n[29] 1299.09px-wide text span at center-center: '\"Continuous\" \u2013 value per base in a genomic region A continuous matrix contains values for the same region for all matching samples'\n[30] 1725.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'API Structure'\n[31] 1800.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Project API Methods'\n[32] 402.38px-wide text span at center-left: '/projects/ Request'\n[33] 236.55px-wide text span at center-center: 'Response'\n[34] 402.38px-wide text span at center-left: '/projects/search Request'\n[35] 459.72px-wide text span at center-left: 'Search Filters tags version'\n[36] 1800.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Study API Methods'\n[37] 397.25px-wide text span at top-center: '/studies/ Request'\n[38] 236.55px-wide text span at top-center: 'Response'\n[39] 397.25px-wide text span at top-center: '/studies/search Request'\n[40] 313.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Search Filters tags version'\n[41] 1800.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Expression API Methods'\n[42] 493.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '/expressions/ Request'\n[43] 236.55px-wide text span at center-center: 'Response'\n[44] 493.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '/expressions/search Request'\n[45] 481.05px-wide text span at bottom-left: '/expression/formats Request'\n[46] 449.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'list of supported formats'\n[47] 2134.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: '/expressions/search Filters format (string) required \u2013 Data format to return. version (string) \u2013 version to return tags (string) \u2013tag list to filter by sampleIDList (string) \u2013list of sampleIDs to matc...'\n[48] 1800.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Continuous API Methods'\n[49] 485.7px-wide text span at center-center: '/continuous/ Request'\n[50] 485.7px-wide text span at center-center: '/continuous/formats Request'\n[51] 443.4px-wide text span at center-right: 'list of supported formats'\n[52] 443.4px-wide text span at center-right: 'binary blob requested matrix'\n[53] 429.57px-wide text span at center-center: ' Filters'\n[54] 236.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'Response'\n[55] 478.76px-wide text span at bottom-center: '/continuous/search Request'\n[56] Image, description: The airplane is painted with special logos and symbols. at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 475,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_RNAget Poster_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
8
],
"rationale": "A claim of formation in \u201c2050 BC\u201d conflicts with the modern institutions listed in ID [1].",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'GA4GH RNA WORKING GROUP* PRESENTED BY SEAN UPCHURCH1, EMILIO PALUMBO2, JEREMY ADAMS3, DAVID BUJOLD4 1: California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, US. 2: Centre de Regulacio Genomica, Barcelona,...'\n[2] 1983.33px-wide text span at center-left: 'The RNAget API describes a common set of endpoints for search and retrieval of processed RNA data such as feature level expression data from RNA-Seq type assays and signal data over a range of bases f...'\n[3] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'RNAget specification design and details'\n[5] 1983.33px-wide text span at center-right: 'Output Matrix Format Output in the recommended loom format or as a tsv matrix makes it easier to import data into analysis tools. Slicing of the matrix at the request enables the user to request the ...'\n[6] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Features of RNAget'\n[7] 1983.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Share your data Complete specifications and directions for setting up an RNAget service are available at https://github.com/ga4gh-rnaseq/schema Integrate RNAget with Analysis Tools If you have an R...'\n[8] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Formed in 2050 BC'\n[9] Image, description: the global alliance for genomics and health logo at top-right\n[10] Wide text span at top-left: 'RNAget: An API for retrieving processed RNA-derived measurements'\n[11] 227.55px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'GDC'\n[12] 227.55px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'ENCODE'\n[13] 234.27px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'IHEC'\n[14] 234.27px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Express. Atlas'\n[15] 781.5px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Harmonize Existing APIs'\n[16] 404.81px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Matrix'\n[17] 1725.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Motivation: Increase interoperability and scalability Reduce deployment effort'\n[18] 1983.33px-wide text span at center-left: 'Overview of RNAget'\n[19] 1725.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Based on existing APIs Introduce a matrix format for data retrieval'\n[20] 1257.38px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Easy to load into analysis software Compressed formats available loom (recommended) hdf5 Slice on samples and/or features axes'\n[21] 529.74px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Matrix'\n[22] 303.18px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Samples'\n[23] 361.65px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Features'\n[24] 580.08px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Requested Matrix'\n[25] 1983.33px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Data Matrix'\n[26] 774.57px-wide text span at top-center: '\"Study\" is a set of related and uniformly processed samples'\n[27] 591.2px-wide text span at top-center: '\"Project\" is a helper to organize studies'\n[28] 1012.29px-wide text span at center-left: '\"Expression\" \u2013 feature level expression Expression queries can slice on samples and features'\n[29] 1299.09px-wide text span at center-center: '\"Continuous\" \u2013 value per base in a genomic region A continuous matrix contains values for the same region for all matching samples'\n[30] 1725.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'API Structure'\n[31] 1800.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Project API Methods'\n[32] 402.38px-wide text span at center-left: '/projects/ Request'\n[33] 236.55px-wide text span at center-center: 'Response'\n[34] 402.38px-wide text span at center-left: '/projects/search Request'\n[35] 459.72px-wide text span at center-left: 'Search Filters tags version'\n[36] 1800.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'Study API Methods'\n[37] 397.25px-wide text span at top-center: '/studies/ Request'\n[38] 236.55px-wide text span at top-center: 'Response'\n[39] 397.25px-wide text span at top-center: '/studies/search Request'\n[40] 313.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Search Filters tags version'\n[41] 1800.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Expression API Methods'\n[42] 493.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '/expressions/ Request'\n[43] 236.55px-wide text span at center-center: 'Response'\n[44] 493.76px-wide text span at bottom-left: '/expressions/search Request'\n[45] 481.05px-wide text span at bottom-left: '/expression/formats Request'\n[46] 449.58px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'list of supported formats'\n[47] 2134.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: '/expressions/search Filters format (string) required \u2013 Data format to return. version (string) \u2013 version to return tags (string) \u2013tag list to filter by sampleIDList (string) \u2013list of sampleIDs to matc...'\n[48] 1800.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Continuous API Methods'\n[49] 485.7px-wide text span at center-center: '/continuous/ Request'\n[50] 485.7px-wide text span at center-center: '/continuous/formats Request'\n[51] 443.4px-wide text span at center-right: 'list of supported formats'\n[52] 443.4px-wide text span at center-right: 'binary blob requested matrix'\n[53] 429.57px-wide text span at center-center: ' Filters'\n[54] 236.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'Response'\n[55] 478.76px-wide text span at bottom-center: '/continuous/search Request'\n[56] 2134.98px-wide text span at bottom-center: '/continuous/search Filters format (string) required \u2013 Data format to return version (string) \u2013 version to return tags (string) \u2013tag list to filter by sampleIDList (string) \u2013list of sampleIDs to match ...'"
},
{
"i": 476,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_A0-Poster - CIVITAS UF 2018 SUCCESS Business models VPF final_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "Contradicts ID [1]\u2019s assertion that CCCs exist and have been analyzed.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-left: 'SUMMARY This poster includes some of the results obtained in the deliverable \u201cBusiness models for construction logistics optimisation and CCC introduction\u201d, aiming to improve the current understandin...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Study denies existence of Construction Consolidation Centres'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Carles P\u00e9rez Cervera, Fundaci\u00f3n Valenciaport Spain Carolina Navarro Correcher, Fundaci\u00f3n Valenciaport Spain'\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'SCENARIOS FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CCC\u2018s The city pilots of the SUCCESS project selected the following scenarios for the implementation of CCC\u2019s:'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: 'RESULTS - BUSINESS MODEL CANVAS The scenarios analysed include the use of a CCC managed by the construction company (as a cost centre) and where the CCC managed by an external company (as a profit ce...'\n[6] Image, description: the construction industry and the materials delivered at center-left\n[7] Image, description: the process of a truck and a truck at bottom-left\n[8] 1385.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'As is situation'\n[9] 1385.74px-wide text span at center-left: 'CCC situation'\n[10] Image, description: the different stages of the ccc process at center-right\n[11] Image, description: the business model canvas at center-right\n[12] Image, description: the different types of business models at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 477,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster ICIGR 2020_Betti W_Politeknik Negeri Cilacap_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
8
],
"rationale": "Conflicts with ID8\u2019s claim that scores improved",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'English Language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site of Karang Talun Mangrove forest Cilacap, Central Java'\n[2] 1027.69px-wide text span at center-left: 'Picture 1. Pre Test'\n[3] 743.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Picture 2. The first cycle'\n[4] 745.93px-wide text span at center-right: 'Picture 3. The second cycle'\n[5] Image, description: a group of different colored umbrellas at bottom-center\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'No difference in pre test post test.'\n[7] 714.19px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conclusion'\n[8] 1080.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'The application of repetition drill and question and answer drill are very useful to teach English for beginners. The results of the participant\u2019s post test score increased comparing to their pre tes...'\n[9] 909.32px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Acknowledgement'\n[10] 763.26px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Thank you for Research and Community Service Center (P3M) of State Polytechnic of Cilacap for providing community service\u2019s funding from DIPA of State Polytechnic of Cilacap the Fiscal Year of 2020.'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Sources of Information Widianingsih, B.,Taufiq Nurrohman, D., Hazrina, F., Asma Ilahi, N., Prima Dewi, R., & Satriawan, Dodi. (2020), English language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site...'\n[12] Image, description: a link with a blue color at bottom-center\n[13] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Orchid ID : 0000-0001-5670-104X'\n[14] Image, description: an envelope with a blue envelope at bottom-center\n[15] 1227.6px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'bettiwidianngsih@pnc.ac.id'\n[16] Image, description: a turquoise phone with a white frame at bottom-center\n[17] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: '081390600683'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Infographic title'\n[19] 851.17px-wide text span at top-left: 'ICIGR 2020'\n[20] Image, description: the logo for umsida at top-left\n[21] Wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction Karang Talun Mangrove Forest Cilacap, Central Java is an ecotourism with having great potential to be developed. It is needed skillful human resources for developing of Mangrove Forest to...'\n[22] Image, description: the logo for a company called adap at bottom-right\n[23] Wide text span at top-right: 'Methods'\n[24] 1144.47px-wide text span at center-left: 'Results and Discussion'\n[25] Image, description: the process of trading in mangroves at top-center\n[26] 1126.29px-wide text span at center-center: 'Figure 1. Step for running Community Service'\n[27] 1459.24px-wide text span at top-right: 'There were 15 participants consist of traders and Karang Talun Mangrove Forest employees.'\n[28] 507.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Technique'\n[29] Image, description: people sitting in a tent and studying english language at center-left\n[30] Image, description: people sitting in a tent with a poster at center-center\n[31] Image, description: people sitting in a tent at center-right\n[32] Image, description: a group of people sitting in a circle at center-left\n[33] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Picture 4. The third cycle'\n[34] Image, description: two women writing on the floor at center-center\n[35] Image, description: a group of people posing for a photo at center-right\n[36] Image, description: the number of participants and post test at bottom-left\n[37] Wide text span at top-left: 'Betti Widianingsih, Devi Taufiq Nurrohman, Fadhillah Hazrina,Novita Asma Ilahi, Riyani Prima Dewi, Dodi Satriawan State Polytechnic of Cilacap Electrical Engineering Department bettiwidianingsih@pnc.a...'\n[38] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Picture 5. Post test'\n[39] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Picture 6. Closing'"
},
{
"i": 478,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster ICIGR 2020_Betti W_Politeknik Negeri Cilacap_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
19,
11
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the event brand, contradicting ID11\u2019s conference citation",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'English Language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site of Karang Talun Mangrove forest Cilacap, Central Java'\n[2] 1027.69px-wide text span at center-left: 'Picture 1. Pre Test'\n[3] 743.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Picture 2. The first cycle'\n[4] 745.93px-wide text span at center-right: 'Picture 3. The second cycle'\n[5] Image, description: a group of different colored umbrellas at bottom-center\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The result of pre test and post test'\n[7] 714.19px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conclusion'\n[8] 1080.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'The application of repetition drill and question and answer drill are very useful to teach English for beginners. The results of the participant\u2019s post test score increased comparing to their pre tes...'\n[9] 909.32px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Acknowledgement'\n[10] 763.26px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Thank you for Research and Community Service Center (P3M) of State Polytechnic of Cilacap for providing community service\u2019s funding from DIPA of State Polytechnic of Cilacap the Fiscal Year of 2020.'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Sources of Information Widianingsih, B.,Taufiq Nurrohman, D., Hazrina, F., Asma Ilahi, N., Prima Dewi, R., & Satriawan, Dodi. (2020), English language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site...'\n[12] Image, description: a link with a blue color at bottom-center\n[13] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Orchid ID : 0000-0001-5670-104X'\n[14] Image, description: an envelope with a blue envelope at bottom-center\n[15] 1227.6px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'bettiwidianngsih@pnc.ac.id'\n[16] Image, description: a turquoise phone with a white frame at bottom-center\n[17] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: '081390600683'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Infographic title'\n[19] 851.17px-wide text span at top-left: 'Stanford20'\n[20] Image, description: the logo for umsida at top-left\n[21] Wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction Karang Talun Mangrove Forest Cilacap, Central Java is an ecotourism with having great potential to be developed. It is needed skillful human resources for developing of Mangrove Forest to...'\n[22] Image, description: the logo for a company called adap at bottom-right\n[23] Wide text span at top-right: 'Methods'\n[24] 1144.47px-wide text span at center-left: 'Results and Discussion'\n[25] Image, description: the process of trading in mangroves at top-center\n[26] 1126.29px-wide text span at center-center: 'Figure 1. Step for running Community Service'\n[27] 1459.24px-wide text span at top-right: 'There were 15 participants consist of traders and Karang Talun Mangrove Forest employees.'\n[28] 507.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Technique'\n[29] Image, description: people sitting in a tent and studying english language at center-left\n[30] Image, description: people sitting in a tent with a poster at center-center\n[31] Image, description: people sitting in a tent at center-right\n[32] Image, description: a group of people sitting in a circle at center-left\n[33] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Picture 4. The third cycle'\n[34] Image, description: two women writing on the floor at center-center\n[35] Image, description: a group of people posing for a photo at center-right\n[36] Image, description: the number of participants and post test at bottom-left\n[37] Wide text span at top-left: 'Betti Widianingsih, Devi Taufiq Nurrohman, Fadhillah Hazrina,Novita Asma Ilahi, Riyani Prima Dewi, Dodi Satriawan State Polytechnic of Cilacap Electrical Engineering Department bettiwidianingsih@pnc.a...'\n[38] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Picture 5. Post test'\n[39] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Picture 6. Closing'"
},
{
"i": 479,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster ICIGR 2020_Betti W_Politeknik Negeri Cilacap_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2
],
"rationale": "A violent theme clashes with an educational training context",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'English Language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site of Karang Talun Mangrove forest Cilacap, Central Java'\n[2] 1027.69px-wide text span at center-left: 'Picture 1. WarZone!'\n[3] 743.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Picture 2. The first cycle'\n[4] 745.93px-wide text span at center-right: 'Picture 3. The second cycle'\n[5] Image, description: a group of different colored umbrellas at bottom-center\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The result of pre test and post test'\n[7] 714.19px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conclusion'\n[8] 1080.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'The application of repetition drill and question and answer drill are very useful to teach English for beginners. The results of the participant\u2019s post test score increased comparing to their pre tes...'\n[9] 909.32px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Acknowledgement'\n[10] 763.26px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Thank you for Research and Community Service Center (P3M) of State Polytechnic of Cilacap for providing community service\u2019s funding from DIPA of State Polytechnic of Cilacap the Fiscal Year of 2020.'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Sources of Information Widianingsih, B.,Taufiq Nurrohman, D., Hazrina, F., Asma Ilahi, N., Prima Dewi, R., & Satriawan, Dodi. (2020), English language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site...'\n[12] Image, description: a link with a blue color at bottom-center\n[13] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Orchid ID : 0000-0001-5670-104X'\n[14] Image, description: an envelope with a blue envelope at bottom-center\n[15] 1227.6px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'bettiwidianngsih@pnc.ac.id'\n[16] Image, description: a turquoise phone with a white frame at bottom-center\n[17] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: '081390600683'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Infographic title'\n[19] 851.17px-wide text span at top-left: 'ICIGR 2020'\n[20] Image, description: the logo for umsida at top-left\n[21] Wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction Karang Talun Mangrove Forest Cilacap, Central Java is an ecotourism with having great potential to be developed. It is needed skillful human resources for developing of Mangrove Forest to...'\n[22] Image, description: the logo for a company called adap at bottom-right\n[23] Wide text span at top-right: 'Methods'\n[24] 1144.47px-wide text span at center-left: 'Results and Discussion'\n[25] Image, description: the process of trading in mangroves at top-center\n[26] 1126.29px-wide text span at center-center: 'Figure 1. Step for running Community Service'\n[27] 1459.24px-wide text span at top-right: 'There were 15 participants consist of traders and Karang Talun Mangrove Forest employees.'\n[28] 507.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Technique'\n[29] Image, description: people sitting in a tent and studying english language at center-left\n[30] Image, description: people sitting in a tent with a poster at center-center\n[31] Image, description: people sitting in a tent at center-right\n[32] Image, description: a group of people sitting in a circle at center-left\n[33] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Picture 4. The third cycle'\n[34] Image, description: two women writing on the floor at center-center\n[35] Image, description: a group of people posing for a photo at center-right\n[36] Image, description: the number of participants and post test at bottom-left\n[37] Wide text span at top-left: 'Betti Widianingsih, Devi Taufiq Nurrohman, Fadhillah Hazrina,Novita Asma Ilahi, Riyani Prima Dewi, Dodi Satriawan State Polytechnic of Cilacap Electrical Engineering Department bettiwidianingsih@pnc.a...'\n[38] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Picture 5. Post test'\n[39] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Picture 6. Closing'"
},
{
"i": 480,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster ICIGR 2020_Betti W_Politeknik Negeri Cilacap_1_3.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
27
],
"rationale": "Contradicts ID27 which states there were only 15 participants",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'English Language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site of Karang Talun Mangrove forest Cilacap, Central Java'\n[2] 1027.69px-wide text span at center-left: 'Picture 1. Pre Test'\n[3] 743.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Picture 2. 25 participants'\n[4] 745.93px-wide text span at center-right: 'Picture 3. The second cycle'\n[5] Image, description: a group of different colored umbrellas at bottom-center\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The result of pre test and post test'\n[7] 714.19px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conclusion'\n[8] 1080.13px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'The application of repetition drill and question and answer drill are very useful to teach English for beginners. The results of the participant\u2019s post test score increased comparing to their pre tes...'\n[9] 909.32px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Acknowledgement'\n[10] 763.26px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Thank you for Research and Community Service Center (P3M) of State Polytechnic of Cilacap for providing community service\u2019s funding from DIPA of State Polytechnic of Cilacap the Fiscal Year of 2020.'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Sources of Information Widianingsih, B.,Taufiq Nurrohman, D., Hazrina, F., Asma Ilahi, N., Prima Dewi, R., & Satriawan, Dodi. (2020), English language Training for Local Community in the Tourism Site...'\n[12] Image, description: a link with a blue color at bottom-center\n[13] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Orchid ID : 0000-0001-5670-104X'\n[14] Image, description: an envelope with a blue envelope at bottom-center\n[15] 1227.6px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'bettiwidianngsih@pnc.ac.id'\n[16] Image, description: a turquoise phone with a white frame at bottom-center\n[17] 1267.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: '081390600683'\n[18] Wide text span at top-center: 'Infographic title'\n[19] 851.17px-wide text span at top-left: 'ICIGR 2020'\n[20] Image, description: the logo for umsida at top-left\n[21] Wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction Karang Talun Mangrove Forest Cilacap, Central Java is an ecotourism with having great potential to be developed. It is needed skillful human resources for developing of Mangrove Forest to...'\n[22] Image, description: the logo for a company called adap at bottom-right\n[23] Wide text span at top-right: 'Methods'\n[24] 1144.47px-wide text span at center-left: 'Results and Discussion'\n[25] Image, description: the process of trading in mangroves at top-center\n[26] 1126.29px-wide text span at center-center: 'Figure 1. Step for running Community Service'\n[27] 1459.24px-wide text span at top-right: 'There were 15 participants consist of traders and Karang Talun Mangrove Forest employees.'\n[28] 507.41px-wide text span at top-right: 'Technique'\n[29] Image, description: people sitting in a tent and studying english language at center-left\n[30] Image, description: people sitting in a tent with a poster at center-center\n[31] Image, description: people sitting in a tent at center-right\n[32] Image, description: a group of people sitting in a circle at center-left\n[33] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Picture 4. The third cycle'\n[34] Image, description: two women writing on the floor at center-center\n[35] Image, description: a group of people posing for a photo at center-right\n[36] Image, description: the number of participants and post test at bottom-left\n[37] Wide text span at top-left: 'Betti Widianingsih, Devi Taufiq Nurrohman, Fadhillah Hazrina,Novita Asma Ilahi, Riyani Prima Dewi, Dodi Satriawan State Polytechnic of Cilacap Electrical Engineering Department bettiwidianingsih@pnc.a...'\n[38] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Picture 5. Post test'\n[39] 1126.29px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Picture 6. Closing'"
},
{
"i": 481,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Ainsworth_TuringWayPoster_OSF19_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
12
],
"rationale": "This violent imagery clashes tonally with the poster\u2019s academic, collaborative theme.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: people in a community garden at center-right\n[2] Image, description: two people working on a laptop at bottom-right\n[3] Image, description: a robot and a person working on a computer at bottom-left\n[4] Image, description: a woman and a man on a scale at center-left\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Turing Way Community, Rachael Ainsworth1,*, Becky Arnold2, Louise Bowler3, Sarah Gibson3, Patricia Herterich4, Rosie Higman2, Anna Krystalli2, Alexander Morely5,6, Martin O\u2019Reilly3 & Kirstie Whita...'\n[6] Image, description: a cat in a circle at bottom-left\n[7] Image, description: the logo for a music app at bottom-left\n[8] Image, description: the logo for jupyter at bottom-center\n[9] Image, description: the logo for iob at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: the logo for zenodo at bottom-center\n[11] 1386.25px-wide text span at center-left: 'Attribution for all illustrations on this poster: http://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3332808'\n[12] Image, description: A picture is taken of a man injured in the hospital. at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 482,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_201811_RDA_poster_TU_Delft_Data_Stewardship_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
4
],
"rationale": "\u201cBattle Tactics 101\u201d conflicts thematically with \u201cData Stewardship\u201d and creates a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data Stewardship at Delft University of Technology'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Overview of Research Data Management Support'\n[3] Image, description: the word tudeflt on a white background at top-left\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Battle Tactics 101'\n[5] Image, description: the logo for the 4th tu centre for research data at top-right\n[6] Image, description: the words cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by cc by c at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 483,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_201811_RDA_poster_TU_Delft_Data_Stewardship_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "The numeric label (90%) contradicts the visual bar (10%), a clear quantitative discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Data Stewardship at Delft University of Technology'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Overview of Research Data Management Support'\n[3] Image, description: the word tudeflt on a white background at top-left\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Community Building'\n[5] Image, description: the logo for the 4th tu centre for research data at top-right\n[6] Image, description: There is a row of people at a bar at bottom-left"
},
{
"i": 484,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_FORCE11Poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
20,
27
],
"rationale": "[15] discusses a blended (face-to-face and online) approach; now [20] contradicts it, stating exclusively online communication.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Power of Community in Scholarship'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Olga Koz, DM Kennesaw State University'\n[3] 588.07px-wide text span at top-right: 'REPLACE THIS BOX WITH YOUR ORGANIZATION\u2019S HIGH RESOLUTION LOGO'\n[4] Image, description: the words constuum research at top-right\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Olga Koz Kennesaw State University Email: okoz@kennesaw.edu Website: http://facultyweb.kennesaw.edu/okoz/ Research Consortium Website: http://bagwell.kennesaw.edu/research-consortium'\n[6] 521.91px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Contact'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Research Consortium Archive https://libguides.kennesaw.edu/edu_rcc/Archive Wenger, Etienne (1998). Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning, and Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.'\n[8] 727.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'References'\n[9] 1996.9px-wide text span at top-left: 'The poster describes and evaluates the development of a blended (online and face2face) community of researchers. As a form of voluntary workplace engagement, communities of practice are characterized ...'\n[10] 1996.9px-wide text span at top-left: 'Abstract'\n[11] 1808.54px-wide text span at center-center: 'Monthly Write Days \u2013 the days approved by the College Dean to be free of any meetings, classes, and service commitments and devoted to writing and research.'\n[12] 1996.9px-wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction'\n[13] 1839.17px-wide text span at top-center: 'As an academic librarian, I consider supporting a research cycle as important as aiding a scholarly publishing cycle. The Research Consortium methodologists, editor-in-residence, a research librarian,...'\n[14] 1839.17px-wide text span at top-center: 'Research Cycle Support'\n[15] 1975.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Technology and new media disrupted not only formal but informal scholarly communication. The RC started as a face-to-face community but to accommodate teaching faculty and doctoral students more event...'\n[16] 1975.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Online Communication'\n[17] 1938.18px-wide text span at center-right: 'The primary purpose of this poster is to use a scholarly reflection approach to share what we (researchers who formed the Research Consortium) have learnt about communication between scholars within t...'\n[18] 1948.94px-wide text span at center-right: 'Conclusion'\n[19] 1972.24px-wide text span at center-left: 'There is growing dissatisfaction with the traditional scholarly communication (SC) system: access to research, rising subscription prices, concerns about copyright, delays in publication. Academic lib...'\n[20] 1803.11px-wide text span at center-center: 'Online-only Communication!'\n[21] 1909.59px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Chart 3. The amount of publications 2015-2017'\n[22] 1769.69px-wide text span at center-left: 'Figure 1. Community of practice within a scholarly communication landscape'\n[23] Image, description: the different channels of communication at center-left\n[24] Image, description: the different types of research at center-center\n[25] 1539.09px-wide text span at center-center: 'Figure 2. RCC services in support of the research cycle'\n[26] Image, description: a group of people sitting around a table at center-center\n[27] 1613.48px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Figure 3. The roundtable during one of RC Write days'\n[28] 1844.6px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Workshops \u2013 all workshops, seminars, and other group learning sessions are scheduled based on the faculty and doctoral students survey and constant monitoring individual requests. Some of workshops re...'\n[29] Image, description: the facebook page for consortum research at center-right\n[30] Image, description: the homepage of the team research curriculum at center-right\n[31] 1953.45px-wide text span at center-right: 'Figure 4. Social networking sites. Facebook Group and Office 365 Team'\n[32] Image, description: the kensaw state university library system logo at top-left\n[33] 849.27px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Chart 2. Requested Topics'"
},
{
"i": 485,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_ETRAN_POSTER_BTi_1-10_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8,
6
],
"rationale": "\u201cTragedy and Desolation\u201d is thematically at odds with the scientific context in #6.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Influence of specimen preparation and nanoindentation protocol on the mechanical properties of bovine bone'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sta\u0161aVu\u010dini\u01071,BojanPetrovi\u0107, 2 Sanja Koji\u0107,Member IEEE1, Milica\u0160ipovac2, SofijaStefanovi\u01073, Goran Stojanovi\u0107, SeniorMember IEEE1 1Faculty of Technical Science, University of Novi Sad, TrgDositejaObrad...'\n[3] Image, description: the logos for biosense institute and biosense at top-left\n[4] Image, description: the logo for the russian federation at top-left\n[5] Image, description: the logo for the russian academy of medicine at top-left\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Background Despite the wide spread use of the nanoindentation for the surface characterization of the bone and other biological tissues, significant variations in the obtained data have been constantl...'\n[7] 1442.9px-wide text span at top-center: 'The experimental method -Sample preparation. 1) Bone samples Tests were conducted on fresh bovine metatarsal bone. Cortical bone from between the metatarsal metaphysis and diaphysis were cut down to 3...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Tragedy and Desolation'\n[9] Image, description: a machine with a computer inside at top-left\n[10] Image, description: a black box with four buttons on it at top-right\n[11] Image, description: the process of plastic + plastic deformation at top-right\n[12] Image, description: a small arrow in the ground at center-left\n[13] Image, description: the different levels of the systolic and diastolic blood pressure at bottom-center\n[14] Image, description: the number of young modules and hardness for two different types of young at center-right\n[15] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conclusion Within the limitations of the present investigation it could be concluded that regarding bone sample preparation, mounting in resin do not affect the mechanical properties. More precise and...'\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Acknowledgement This paper was financed through H2020 ERC project BIRTH No. 640557 and Serbian national project III45021'\n[17] 927.05px-wide text span at center-left: 'Fig. 1 Agilent Nano indenter G200 chamber'\n[18] 1097.06px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fig. 2 Sample holder with four specimens obtained after cutting and polishing (fifth sample in the center of the holder is referent fused silica sample)'\n[19] 665.51px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fig. 3 Typical nanoindentation load-displacement curve'\n[20] 1153.17px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Fig. 4 Young's modulus and hardness for two different specimen preparation protocols'\n[21] 1129.92px-wide text span at center-left: 'Fig. 5 SEM image of the indentation trace performed in the bovine metatarsal bone sample'\n[22] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Fig. 6 Load vs. Displacement curves for two different nanoindentation protocols'\n[23] Wide text span at center-center: '2)Testing protocols The tests were performed using and Agilent Nano indenter G200. Indentation method with predefined force (G-Series, Basic Hardness, Modulus, Tip Cal, Load Control method) is used fo...'\n[24] Wide text span at center-center: 'Young's modulus for all 6 forces and both specimen preparation protocols exhibited significant variations without existence of constant decrease or increase related to the applied forces. The mean val...'\n[25] 1217.98px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Load displacement curves for two different specimen preparation techniques and six different forces are shown in Fig. 6. These curves representing load vs. displacement obtained during nanoindentation...'\n[26] Image, description: the logo for the university of neoplantensis at top-left"
},
{
"i": 486,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_asme poster FINAL_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
20
],
"rationale": "The new image conflicts thematically with the clinical education context of the poster.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Recognising skills attrition and supporting medical students returning to the Birmingham Medical Degree programme; the ROCS (Revision of Clinical Skills) course David Thewlis, Carley Nath, Jamie Cole...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-left: 'Skills attrition There is clear evidence that time spent out of practice impacts on the clinical abilities and confidence of doctors returning to clinical work1. Less is known about the rate at which ...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Impact of ROCS course All invited students attend the ROCS course. Exemptions are permitted if students have otherwise demonstrated that they have undertaken relevant practice continually during their...'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Students returning to the MBChB programme will have competencies assessed formally within the course and subsequently via the Medical Licensing Assessment (MLA). Students returning after time away fr...'\n[5] Image, description: the logo for rocs at top-right\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Background and purpose'\n[7] Wide text span at center-left: 'Addressing skills attrition Revalidation has been a catalyst for ensuring that employers and regulators provide clinicians returning to practice after a period of prolonged leave with tailored trainin...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose of the ROCS course To reintroduce students to their community of practice To enable students to re-establish relationships with peers To provide exposure to a wide range of core clinical skill...'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'Format We invite all students returning to the final and penultimate year of our MBChB to participate in the ROCS course. Students undertake an intensive, hands on, one-day programme in*: common clini...'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'We seek to share a successful initiative that recognises and responds to the impact of skills attrition on this cohort of students. The ROCS (Revision of Clinical Skills) course is underpinned by the ...'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Methodology and results'\n[12] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Discussion and conclusions'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'References 1. Grace ES, Korinek EJ, Weitzel LB, Wentz DK. Physicians reentering clinical practice: Characteristics and clinical abilities. Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions. 20...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: '* ROCS is delivered by experienced teaching faculty, BLS instructors, skills trainers and is supported with role players and associate clinical educators'\n[15] Image, description: a woman getting her ear pierced by another woman at center-center\n[16] Image, description: three people standing around a dummy in a hospital room at center-right\n[17] Image, description: a man in blue gloves examining a woman's leg at bottom-center\n[18] Wide text span at top-right: 'Revision of clinical skills course'\n[19] Image, description: the university of birmingham logo at top-left\n[20] Image, description: Riot police form a line to control a crowd. at top-right"
},
{
"i": 487,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_asme poster FINAL_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6
],
"rationale": "This implies an anachronistically early origin, clashing with the modern context provided elsewhere.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Recognising skills attrition and supporting medical students returning to the Birmingham Medical Degree programme; the ROCS (Revision of Clinical Skills) course David Thewlis, Carley Nath, Jamie Cole...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-left: 'Skills attrition There is clear evidence that time spent out of practice impacts on the clinical abilities and confidence of doctors returning to clinical work1. Less is known about the rate at which ...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Impact of ROCS course All invited students attend the ROCS course. Exemptions are permitted if students have otherwise demonstrated that they have undertaken relevant practice continually during their...'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Students returning to the MBChB programme will have competencies assessed formally within the course and subsequently via the Medical Licensing Assessment (MLA). Students returning after time away fr...'\n[5] Image, description: the logo for rocs at top-right\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'The ROCS course was founded in 1789, making it one of the oldest formal medical retraining initiatives'\n[7] Wide text span at center-left: 'Addressing skills attrition Revalidation has been a catalyst for ensuring that employers and regulators provide clinicians returning to practice after a period of prolonged leave with tailored trainin...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose of the ROCS course To reintroduce students to their community of practice To enable students to re-establish relationships with peers To provide exposure to a wide range of core clinical skill...'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'Format We invite all students returning to the final and penultimate year of our MBChB to participate in the ROCS course. Students undertake an intensive, hands on, one-day programme in*: common clini...'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'We seek to share a successful initiative that recognises and responds to the impact of skills attrition on this cohort of students. The ROCS (Revision of Clinical Skills) course is underpinned by the ...'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'Methodology and results'\n[12] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Discussion and conclusions'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'References 1. Grace ES, Korinek EJ, Weitzel LB, Wentz DK. Physicians reentering clinical practice: Characteristics and clinical abilities. Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions. 20...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: '* ROCS is delivered by experienced teaching faculty, BLS instructors, skills trainers and is supported with role players and associate clinical educators'\n[15] Image, description: a woman getting her ear pierced by another woman at center-center\n[16] Image, description: three people standing around a dummy in a hospital room at center-right\n[17] Image, description: a man in blue gloves examining a woman's leg at bottom-center\n[18] Wide text span at top-right: 'Revision of clinical skills course'\n[19] Image, description: the university of birmingham logo at top-left\n[20] Image, description: the words rocs and the logo at top-right"
},
{
"i": 488,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_MASTsPoster_HGrist_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "Directly contradicts #3\u2019s statement that the Arctic is warming.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 2366.7px-wide text span at top-right: 'Hannah Grist, SRSL, Oban, UK* \t*hannah.grist@srsl.com Mark R. Payne, Technical University of Denmark, Copenhagen, Denmark Steffen Olsen, Danish Meteorological Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark'\n[2] Wide text span at top-left: 'Understanding the impact of a changing Arctic on Northern Hemisphere weather and climate'\n[3] 2294.6px-wide text span at center-left: 'Blue-Action is a collaborative research project that is looking at the drivers of warming in the Arctic and the subsequent impact on global climate.'\n[4] 2294.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'We are developing and using advanced modelling methods to prove that the Arctic is experiencing sustained cooling, from months to centuries.'\n[5] 2298.06px-wide text span at center-right: 'Our aim is to improve the safety and wellbeing of people across the Northern Hemisphere, by supporting evidence-based decision-making by policymakers worldwide.'\n[6] Image, description: a boat in the ocean with snow capped mountains in the background at bottom-right\n[7] Image, description: a large area of ice covered water at bottom-left\n[8] Image, description: the blue action logo on a black background at top-left\n[9] 1810.95px-wide text span at top-right: 'Johanna Baehr, University of Hamburg; Jens Hesselberg Christensen, NORCE; Karin M. H. Larsen, Faroe Marine Research Institute; Gerard McCarthy, National University of Ireland; Yongqi Gao, Nansen Envir...'\n[10] Image, description: the earth with ice and snow at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 489,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_MASTsPoster_HGrist_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "The unrealistic \u201c150\u00b0C jump\u201d conflicts with the normal forecasts implied in #4.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 2366.7px-wide text span at top-right: 'Hannah Grist, SRSL, Oban, UK* \t*hannah.grist@srsl.com Mark R. Payne, Technical University of Denmark, Copenhagen, Denmark Steffen Olsen, Danish Meteorological Institute, Copenhagen, Denmark'\n[2] Wide text span at top-left: 'Understanding the impact of a changing Arctic on Northern Hemisphere weather and climate'\n[3] 2294.6px-wide text span at center-left: 'Blue-Action is a collaborative research project that is studying a 150\u00b0C Arctic temperature jump in one year and its impact on global climate.'\n[4] 2294.6px-wide text span at center-center: 'We are developing and using advanced modelling techniques to improve the accuracy of forecasting, across timescales from a few weeks to decades.'\n[5] 2298.06px-wide text span at center-right: 'Our aim is to improve the safety and wellbeing of people across the Northern Hemisphere, by supporting evidence-based decision-making by policymakers worldwide.'\n[6] Image, description: a boat in the ocean with snow capped mountains in the background at bottom-right\n[7] Image, description: a large area of ice covered water at bottom-left\n[8] Image, description: the blue action logo on a black background at top-left\n[9] 1810.95px-wide text span at top-right: 'Johanna Baehr, University of Hamburg; Jens Hesselberg Christensen, NORCE; Karin M. H. Larsen, Faroe Marine Research Institute; Gerard McCarthy, National University of Ireland; Yongqi Gao, Nansen Envir...'\n[10] Image, description: the earth with ice and snow at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 490,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster OSOS Urdaneta_Spain_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "Using \"Violence\" as a heading creates a thematic mismatch with the rest of the poster\u2019s environmental tone.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'PAMPAS GRASS FREE TOWN'\n[2] 777.83px-wide text span at top-left: 'Place Logo Here'\n[3] 1811.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Violence'\n[4] 1811.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'How can we turn an invaded space into a free space? We are going to do a project investigating the areas of Loiu (the town where our school is located) where the invasive species of Pampas Grass, Cort...'\n[5] 1811.23px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'This is the description of our project: \u2022 Placed: The activity is located in the ways and mountains of Loiu, which we didn\u2019t know. \u2022 Purposeful: By locating and cutting the Pampas Grass, we have well ...'\n[6] 1811.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Description'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'The students observed that there were many Pampas Grass specimens in the vicinity of our school and they understood that they are detrimental to people, so they decided to study the invasive species a...'\n[8] Wide text span at top-center: 'Feel'\n[9] Wide text span at top-right: 'After studying the effects of the invasive species, the students proposed approaching the town hall to learn about the Pampas Grass, and to study the existing researches on the topic. After analyzing ...'\n[10] Wide text span at top-right: 'Imagine'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'The students analyzed the studies carried out by the Provincial Council of Bizkaia and the University of the Basque Country on the Pampas grass and its eradication with their teachers\u00b4 help. They wro...'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'Create'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'After doing the project, the students presented a dossier so that all the villagers could have the information about this invasive species. The mayor called the media, newspapers and television to pr...'\n[14] Wide text span at center-center: 'Share'\n[15] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Link on the portal'\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'https://portal.opendiscoveryspace.eu/es/osos-project/municipio-libre-de-plumero-de-la-pampa-849454'\n[17] Image, description: the open schools for open societies logo at top-right\n[18] Image, description: the coat of arms of the family of st john at top-left\n[19] Image, description: the words athas grass free town at top-center\n[20] Image, description: a group of children picking up trash at top-center\n[21] Image, description: a group of girls looking at a map at top-center\n[22] Image, description: a girl reaching up to a tall grass at top-right\n[23] Image, description: two girls carrying a bag of trash at center-right\n[24] Image, description: children working with a bag of plants at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a notebook with pictures and a flower at bottom-right\n[26] Image, description: a classroom with a teacher and students at bottom-center\n[27] Image, description: two boys holding a map at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 491,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster OSOS Urdaneta_Spain_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
27
],
"rationale": "An image set in 1800 on Mars conflicts with the modern terrestrial context, creating a temporal/spatial impossibility.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'PAMPAS GRASS FREE TOWN'\n[2] 777.83px-wide text span at top-left: 'Place Logo Here'\n[3] 1811.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Abstract'\n[4] 1811.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'How can we turn an invaded space into a free space? We are going to do a project investigating the areas of Loiu (the town where our school is located) where the invasive species of Pampas Grass, Cort...'\n[5] 1811.23px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'This is the description of our project: \u2022 Placed: The activity is located in the ways and mountains of Loiu, which we didn\u2019t know. \u2022 Purposeful: By locating and cutting the Pampas Grass, we have well ...'\n[6] 1811.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Description'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'The students observed that there were many Pampas Grass specimens in the vicinity of our school and they understood that they are detrimental to people, so they decided to study the invasive species a...'\n[8] Wide text span at top-center: 'Feel'\n[9] Wide text span at top-right: 'After studying the effects of the invasive species, the students proposed approaching the town hall to learn about the Pampas Grass, and to study the existing researches on the topic. After analyzing ...'\n[10] Wide text span at top-right: 'Imagine'\n[11] Wide text span at center-center: 'The students analyzed the studies carried out by the Provincial Council of Bizkaia and the University of the Basque Country on the Pampas grass and its eradication with their teachers\u00b4 help. They wro...'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'Create'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'After doing the project, the students presented a dossier so that all the villagers could have the information about this invasive species. The mayor called the media, newspapers and television to pr...'\n[14] Wide text span at center-center: 'Share'\n[15] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Link on the portal'\n[16] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'https://portal.opendiscoveryspace.eu/es/osos-project/municipio-libre-de-plumero-de-la-pampa-849454'\n[17] Image, description: the open schools for open societies logo at top-right\n[18] Image, description: the coat of arms of the family of st john at top-left\n[19] Image, description: the words athas grass free town at top-center\n[20] Image, description: a group of children picking up trash at top-center\n[21] Image, description: a group of girls looking at a map at top-center\n[22] Image, description: a girl reaching up to a tall grass at top-right\n[23] Image, description: two girls carrying a bag of trash at center-right\n[24] Image, description: children working with a bag of plants at center-left\n[25] Image, description: a notebook with pictures and a flower at bottom-right\n[26] Image, description: a classroom with a teacher and students at bottom-center\n[27] Image, description: Nerds gather in the nasa meeting room at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 492,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Scientific_Poster_Daan_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
6,
12
],
"rationale": "Contrasts with [5] describing a single prototype beam, creating a quantitative inconsistency.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] 1944.14px-wide text span at center-center: 'Multiple Cracks in Laminates\u000bStudies [1'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Control of Delamination EU H2020: DACOMAT'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Daan Jonas Hottentot Cederl\u00f8f Supervisors: Bent F. S\u00f8rensen, Stergios Goutianos, Malcolm McGugan, Yukihiro Kusano'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'Initial imperfections are present in composite structures as soon as the product leaves the production floor. In the case of glass fibre wind turbine blades, for example, we have imperfections in the ...'\n[5] 1997.08px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Testing of Treated Interfaces\u000bTo measure the influence of the plasma treatments on the ITS, a curved beam experiment (ASTM D6415) is planned. An early prototype of the beam is shown in fig3. Future ex...'\n[6] 1997.08px-wide text span at center-right: 'Figure 3. Thousands of beam specimens, for ASTM D6415 test, after meltdown and cooking.'\n[7] 2047.62px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 1. Upper image: Illustration of a secondary crack forming below the primary crack [2'\n[8] 1507.71px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 2. Gliding arc plasma treatment of glass fibres.'\n[9] 1084.77px-wide text span at top-right: 'Technical University of Denmark Department of Wind Energy'\n[10] Image, description: the logo for dtu at top-left\n[11] Image, description: a diagram of a primary crack and secondary crack at center-left\n[12] Image, description: a box of a filter sitting on a table at center-right\n[13] Image, description: a machine that is being used to make a liquid at bottom-left\n[14] 242.89px-wide text span at center-left: 'M'\n[15] 209.21px-wide text span at center-left: 'M'"
},
{
"i": 493,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_GECCO 2019 poster stampa_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
19,
2
],
"rationale": "The text in ID=2 says Michigan State University, but the revised logo is for the University of Cambridge, creating a misattribution.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Optimisation of Crop Configuration using NSGA-III with\u000bCategorical Genetic Operators'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Oskar Marko1, Dejan Pavlovi\u01071, Vladimir Crnojevi\u01071, Kalyanmoy Deb2 \u000b1BioSense Institute, University of Novi Sad, Serbia; 2COIN Laboratory, Michigan State University, USA'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'To estimate the profitability of each crop in the forthcoming season, probability density function (PDF) of crop yields in the next season was determined using statistical analysis of the historical d...'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'EXPERIMENT DETAILS'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Categories were suspended in a multi-dimensional space, where their coordinates were essentially the values of their objective functions. For categorical crossover, a line was drawn between the parent...'\n[6] Image, description: the michigan state university logo at top-right\n[7] Image, description: a diagram of a parent category and a parent category at bottom-left\n[8] Wide text span at top-left: 'FAO\u2019s estimates are telling us that by the year 2050, we will need to increase the food production by 70%, to feed the world\u2019s growing population. For this reason, agriculture is shifting towards Prec...'\n[9] Image, description: a map of different colored fields at top-right\n[10] Wide text span at top-left: 'CROP CONFIGURATION & PRECISION AG'\n[11] 448.67px-wide text span at top-center: 'Wheat'\n[12] 403.35px-wide text span at top-right: 'Maize'\n[13] 654.2px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sugar beet'\n[14] 648.85px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sunflower'\n[15] 317.79px-wide text span at top-right: 'Soya'\n[16] Image, description: the different objectives of farming at center-left\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'CATEGORICAL GENETIC OPERATORS'\n[18] Image, description: the data for the company and the number of fields at center-right\n[19] Image, description: A Design College logo beneath scissors and a chain. at center-center"
},
{
"i": 494,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_GECCO 2019 poster stampa_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10,
1
],
"rationale": "The updated heading is thematically incompatible with the main title (ID=1) about crop configuration.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Optimisation of Crop Configuration using NSGA-III with\u000bCategorical Genetic Operators'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Oskar Marko1, Dejan Pavlovi\u01071, Vladimir Crnojevi\u01071, Kalyanmoy Deb2 \u000b1BioSense Institute, University of Novi Sad, Serbia; 2COIN Laboratory, Michigan State University, USA'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'To estimate the profitability of each crop in the forthcoming season, probability density function (PDF) of crop yields in the next season was determined using statistical analysis of the historical d...'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'EXPERIMENT DETAILS'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Categories were suspended in a multi-dimensional space, where their coordinates were essentially the values of their objective functions. For categorical crossover, a line was drawn between the parent...'\n[6] Image, description: the michigan state university logo at top-right\n[7] Image, description: a diagram of a parent category and a parent category at bottom-left\n[8] Wide text span at top-left: 'FAO\u2019s estimates are telling us that by the year 2050, we will need to increase the food production by 70%, to feed the world\u2019s growing population. For this reason, agriculture is shifting towards Prec...'\n[9] Image, description: a map of different colored fields at top-right\n[10] Wide text span at top-left: 'LIVE MUSIC & INTERSTELLAR WARFARE'\n[11] 448.67px-wide text span at top-center: 'Wheat'\n[12] 403.35px-wide text span at top-right: 'Maize'\n[13] 654.2px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sugar beet'\n[14] 648.85px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sunflower'\n[15] 317.79px-wide text span at top-right: 'Soya'\n[16] Image, description: the different objectives of farming at center-left\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'CATEGORICAL GENETIC OPERATORS'\n[18] Image, description: the data for the company and the number of fields at center-right\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'the list of objectives as the price risk. The next objective was to decrease scatteredness of fields with the same crop. The corresponding objective function was calculated as the sum of fields\u2019 dista...'"
},
{
"i": 495,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_GECCO 2019 poster stampa_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "The poster references modern research and 2050 projections, so placing the experiment in 1492 creates a temporal inconsistency.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Optimisation of Crop Configuration using NSGA-III with\u000bCategorical Genetic Operators'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Oskar Marko1, Dejan Pavlovi\u01071, Vladimir Crnojevi\u01071, Kalyanmoy Deb2 \u000b1BioSense Institute, University of Novi Sad, Serbia; 2COIN Laboratory, Michigan State University, USA'\n[3] Wide text span at center-center: 'To estimate the profitability of each crop in the forthcoming season, probability density function (PDF) of crop yields in the next season was determined using statistical analysis of the historical d...'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'EXPERIMENT FROM 1492'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Categories were suspended in a multi-dimensional space, where their coordinates were essentially the values of their objective functions. For categorical crossover, a line was drawn between the parent...'\n[6] Image, description: the michigan state university logo at top-right\n[7] Image, description: a diagram of a parent category and a parent category at bottom-left\n[8] Wide text span at top-left: 'FAO\u2019s estimates are telling us that by the year 2050, we will need to increase the food production by 70%, to feed the world\u2019s growing population. For this reason, agriculture is shifting towards Prec...'\n[9] Image, description: a map of different colored fields at top-right\n[10] Wide text span at top-left: 'CROP CONFIGURATION & PRECISION AG'\n[11] 448.67px-wide text span at top-center: 'Wheat'\n[12] 403.35px-wide text span at top-right: 'Maize'\n[13] 654.2px-wide text span at top-right: 'Sugar beet'\n[14] 648.85px-wide text span at center-right: 'Sunflower'\n[15] 317.79px-wide text span at top-right: 'Soya'\n[16] Image, description: the different objectives of farming at center-left\n[17] Wide text span at center-center: 'CATEGORICAL GENETIC OPERATORS'\n[18] Image, description: the data for the company and the number of fields at center-right\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'the list of objectives as the price risk. The next objective was to decrease scatteredness of fields with the same crop. The corresponding objective function was calculated as the sum of fields\u2019 dista...'"
},
{
"i": 496,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_POSTER INESTABILIDAD AMPUTADOS_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
23
],
"rationale": "Tonal/contextual mismatch between the text discussing foot analysis ([7]) and the changed wedding celebration image.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'SYMPOSIUM INTERNACIONAL EN CIENCIAS PODOL\u00d3GICAS UNIVERSIDAD REY JUAN CARLOS'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'MEDICI\u00d3N DE INESTABILIDAD EN PACIENTE AMPUTADO TRANSTIBIAL UNILATERAL PROTETIZADO MEDIANTE PLATAFORMA DE PRESI\u00d3N S-PLATE.CASO CL\u00cdNICO.'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sarroca Becerrica, N. (nuriasarroca@hotmail.com)'\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: 'OBJETIVOS/ OBJETIVES'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'M\u00c9TODO/ METHOD'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'El sujeto al que se le ha amputado uno de los miembros inferiores pierde el soporte est\u00e1tico, la funci\u00f3n del complejo articular as\u00ed como la informaci\u00f3n sensorial tanto propioceptiva como exteroceptiva...'\n[7] Wide text span at top-right: 'Material y m\u00e9todo: Descripci\u00f3n de un caso cl\u00ednico. Var\u00f3n de 34 a\u00f1os de edad con amputaci\u00f3n transtibial unilateral derecha protetizado. La plataforma dinamom\u00e9trica S-Plate es un sistema de an\u00e1lisis ci...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'RESULTADOS/ RESULTS'\n[9] Wide text span at center-left: 'El an\u00e1lisis posturol\u00f3gico revela que la longitud de trazo mayor (longitud en mm que se desplaza el centro de gravedad) la presenta el paciente con plantilla blanda y ojos cerrados (557.1 mm) frente a ...'\n[10] Wide text span at center-right: 'Fig.1.Paciente amputado plataforma Fig.2.An\u00e1lisis posturol\u00f3gico descalzo Fig.3.An\u00e1lisis posturol\u00f3gico descalzo dinamom\u00e9trica S-Plate ojos abiert...'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'CONCLUSIONES/ CONCLUSIONS'\n[12] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Las plataformas dinamom\u00e9tricas tienen m\u00faltiples aplicaciones tanto en el an\u00e1lisis de la marcha normal y patol\u00f3gica como en otros muchos campos; ergonom\u00eda, an\u00e1lisis del equilibrio, deporte o industria ...'\n[13] 1996.18px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'REFERENCIAS/ REFERENCES'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-center: '1. Merriman Linda M. Tollafield David R. Assessment of the lower limb. Churchill Livingstone, 1.995. 2. Collado V\u00e1zquez S. M\u00e9todos de estudio de la marcha. En: Collado V\u00e1zquez S, P\u00e9rez Garc\u00eda C, Carri...'\n[15] Image, description: a man's foot on a scale at center-center\n[16] Image, description: a map of the area with two different colored dots at center-right\n[17] Image, description: a map of the area where the foot is located at center-right\n[18] Image, description: a map of the area of the body at center-right\n[19] Image, description: a map of the area of the body at center-right\n[20] Image, description: a white plastic object on a white surface at center-center\n[21] Image, description: a person's foot with a blue and white foot pad at center-center\n[22] Image, description: a map of the area with two different colored dots at center-right\n[23] Image, description: A view of fireworks going off above a clock tower. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 497,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_53ESLab_Simon_Poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
10
],
"rationale": "Contradicts the statement in [1] that Gaia17cuh\u2019s outburst was revealed.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'We have carried out detailed analysis of transient events, which were discovered by Gaia and published by ESA Gaia, DPAC and the Photometric Science Alerts Team (http://gsaweb.ast.cam.ac.uk/alerts). A...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ANALYSIS OF CV CANDIDATES AND BLUE HOSTLESS TRANSIENTS FROM GAIA ALERTS DATA'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'A. Simon1,2,*, V. Reshetnyk1, Ya. Pichkurova1, E.Pavlenko3, V. Godunova4, V. Vasylenko1,2, O. Baransky2, A. Shchurova5, A. Baklanov3, O. Antonyuk3, Ju. Babina3, A. Sosnovskij3, I. Izviekova1,4, O. Ost...'\n[4] Image, description: the logo of the university of russia at top-left\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Conclusion: Post alerting continuous monitoring is a good tool for the objects classification and it is a great task for the telescopes up to 1-m diameter.'\n[6] Image, description: the words 5th esa symposium on the universe at top-center\n[7] Image, description: a graph of the number of data points at center-left\n[8] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been contacted by the company at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been killed at center-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Target Gaia17cuh confirmed stable with no outbursts detected'\n[11] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample of the table (catalogue) with candidates for continuous monitoring'\n[12] 953.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'List of objects for current monitoring and participated observatories'\n[13] 1122.97px-wide text span at center-right: 'Asterics indicate objects, for which we detected flares. List of participating observatories: CrAO - Crimean Astrophysical Observatory, Lis \u2013 Observational station in Lisnyky of TSNU of Kyiv, Slovakia...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'To Join Pos_Alert Gaia Campaign Please Contact: Andrii Simon\u000be-mail: andrew_simon@univ.kiev.ua Viber, WatsApp, Telegram: +380502099238 RG: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Andrew_Simon5 Follow_up ...'\n[15] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been spotted at center-right\n[16] 901.14px-wide text span at center-right: 'Gaia18aes \u2013 data from the Gaia Photometric Science Alerts\u00a0(\"Gaia Alerts\") Only two points available.'\n[17] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been contacted by the company at bottom-right\n[18] 759.48px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Gaia18aes \u2013 Gaia lightcurve combined with photometric follow-up photometry generously provided by the astronomical community using the\u00a0Cambridge Photometry Calibration Server (CPCS)\u000bHere we can find f...'\n[19] Image, description: a table with a number of numbers at bottom-left\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Example of the beta-version of the software for the automatic search and post-alert messages. Ranging was made by parameter Multiply (Multiply=Delta*Stddev*N>2sigm). Software idea \u2013 Andrii Simon, Soft...'\n[21] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Acknowledgements: We acknowledge ESA Gaia, DPAC and the Photometric Science Alerts Team (http://gsaweb.ast.cam.ac.uk/alerts). Also we acknowledge the use of the Cambridge Photometric Calibration Serve...'"
},
{
"i": 498,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_53ESLab_Simon_Poster_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
21
],
"rationale": "The image is now misattributed (NASA vs. Russian university) in the same description, creating a visible conflict.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-center: 'We have carried out detailed analysis of transient events, which were discovered by Gaia and published by ESA Gaia, DPAC and the Photometric Science Alerts Team (http://gsaweb.ast.cam.ac.uk/alerts). A...'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'ANALYSIS OF CV CANDIDATES AND BLUE HOSTLESS TRANSIENTS FROM GAIA ALERTS DATA'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'A. Simon1,2,*, V. Reshetnyk1, Ya. Pichkurova1, E.Pavlenko3, V. Godunova4, V. Vasylenko1,2, O. Baransky2, A. Shchurova5, A. Baklanov3, O. Antonyuk3, Ju. Babina3, A. Sosnovskij3, I. Izviekova1,4, O. Ost...'\n[4] Image, description: the logo of the university of russia at top-left\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Conclusion: Post alerting continuous monitoring is a good tool for the objects classification and it is a great task for the telescopes up to 1-m diameter.'\n[6] Image, description: the words 5th esa symposium on the universe at top-center\n[7] Image, description: a graph of the number of data points at center-left\n[8] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been contacted by the company at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been killed at center-center\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Target Gaia17cuh as a push for the further observational campaign'\n[11] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sample of the table (catalogue) with candidates for continuous monitoring'\n[12] 953.65px-wide text span at center-right: 'List of objects for current monitoring and participated observatories'\n[13] 1122.97px-wide text span at center-right: 'Asterics indicate objects, for which we detected flares. List of participating observatories: CrAO - Crimean Astrophysical Observatory, Lis \u2013 Observational station in Lisnyky of TSNU of Kyiv, Slovakia...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'To Join Pos_Alert Gaia Campaign Please Contact: Andrii Simon\u000be-mail: andrew_simon@univ.kiev.ua Viber, WatsApp, Telegram: +380502099238 RG: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Andrew_Simon5 Follow_up ...'\n[15] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been spotted at center-right\n[16] 901.14px-wide text span at center-right: 'Gaia18aes \u2013 data from the Gaia Photometric Science Alerts\u00a0(\"Gaia Alerts\") Only two points available.'\n[17] Image, description: a graph of the number of people who have been contacted by the company at bottom-right\n[18] 759.48px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Gaia18aes \u2013 Gaia lightcurve combined with photometric follow-up photometry generously provided by the astronomical community using the\u00a0Cambridge Photometry Calibration Server (CPCS)\u000bHere we can find f...'\n[19] Image, description: a table with a number of numbers at bottom-left\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Example of the beta-version of the software for the automatic search and post-alert messages. Ranging was made by parameter Multiply (Multiply=Delta*Stddev*N>2sigm). Software idea \u2013 Andrii Simon, Soft...'\n[21] Image, description: Two jumbo jets display their company emblems on a runway. at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 499,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_IWCBRNe2018_Poster_Template_Name[26551]_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
15
],
"rationale": "This anachronistic depiction of 1850 Tokyo with automobiles conflicts thematically with ID 14\u2019s map of modern Europe.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: '4th International CBRNe Workshop \u2013 Rome, 8th November 2018'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Rosiello F (1), Menga LS (2), Zelinotti L (3), Montibeller M (1), Kolaparambil Varghese L J (4) 1: Dipartimento di Igiene e Sanit\u00e0 Pubblica, Sapienza-Universit\u00e0 di Roma 2: Facolt\u00e0 di Medicina, Univers...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Francesco ROSIELLO e Luca MENGA Sapienza Universit\u00e0 di Roma e Universit\u00e0 Cattolica del Sacro Cuore 338/82 86 250 francesco.rosiello@hotmail.it www.linkedin.com/in/francescorosiello www.rese...'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'ITALY AFTER 30 YEARS OF DENUCLEARIZATION: WHAT ARE THE EFFECTS ON THE HEALTH?\u000bA review of the literature.'\n[5] Image, description: the words cbrne 2018 and nuclear threats at top-right\n[6] Wide text span at top-center: 'Background: Italy has developed its own nuclear programme from 1963 to 1990, raising up the most powerful Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) in the world and the second most powerful Magnox central. The nuclea...'\n[7] Wide text span at center-right: 'Methods: We reviewed the articles we found in the literature, the public health data, and the journalistic investigations from a medical, biological and veterinary point of view, to analyze the Italia...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-center: 'Findings: We found clusters of genetic abnormalities around specific sites associated with NPPs and an increased rate of cancer, that might also be explained by the presence of different chemicals or ...'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Conclusion: We conclude that the risk of cancer caused by NPPs should be better monitored and that larger international studies are needed to assess whether there are any elements of increased genetic...'\n[10] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Keywords: Italian Nuclear, healthcare, review, nuclear power plant, cancer'\n[11] Image, description: a qr code with a black background at bottom-left\n[12] Image, description: the locations of radioactive sites in italy at top-right\n[13] Image, description: the location of the hs2 satellite at center-left\n[14] Image, description: europe with different colors and countries at center-left\n[15] Image, description: Motor cycle and truck traffic in an oriental city at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 500,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_AML_Poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
13
],
"rationale": "The labeled \u201c+200% growth\u201d conflicts with the visually shrinking bars, introducing a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'Xue Hu [1'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Robust Adversarial Imitation Learning from Observation'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: '[1'\n[4] Wide text span at top-left: 'INTRODUCTION Imitation learning has been successfully used in many real-world scenarios such as autonomous driving. Imitation learning from observation (ILO) learns from observation only, which is mo...'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'EXPERIMENTS & RESULTS'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'CONCLUSIONS & FUTURE WORK RILO outperforms the other baselines in the CartPole environment. RILO is steadier and even improves in face of perturbation on the body mass. We demonstrated a feasible way ...'\n[7] Image, description: the word illinois in orange and white at bottom-right\n[8] 1084.52px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Experiment 1: Evaluating Learned Policies'\n[9] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Experiment 2: Robustness under Various Conditions'\n[10] Image, description: the formula for the number of a number at center-right\n[11] Image, description: a graph of a number of numbers at center-right\n[12] Image, description: the word minim max r at center-center\n[13] Image, description: An empty bar looks empty with all of it's clean tables. at center-right"
},
{
"i": 501,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster. nue_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16
],
"rationale": "Introduces a jarring thematic mismatch with the rest of the poster\u2019s medical context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 2183.78px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Inconsistent patient scores regarding medic Inconstside effect education due of printed medication de of printed medication discharge information'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Improving Patient Satisfaction with Medication Instructions: A Pilot Study'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dr. Tina Neu, DNP, RN, FNP, CNOR, NE-BC-Dr. Beth Keely, RN, PhD, Dr. Catherine Cummins, MD, RN'\n[4] 2157.14px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Title'\n[5] 2128.97px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The introduction of simplified discharge medication instructions can provide simple, understandable, and useful information. Providing a simplified variation of the medication instruction sheet in mu...'\n[6] 2175.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'We were unable to show a statistically significant increase in the patient satisfaction scores with the new medication instructions. The manner in which the hospital surveyed and gathered information...'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Southern California CSU DNP Consortium ~ Fullerton \uf06c Los Angeles \uf06c Long Beach'\n[8] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Theoretical Model'\n[9] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem/Purpose'\n[10] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Background'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'Questions for Patients Key Variables'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'Method Instruction Sheet'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Results'\n[14] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Implications to Nursing'\n[15] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Discussion'\n[16] 2249.49px-wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose: To coordinate advanced missile testing in the Arctic region for defense readiness'\n[17] 2249.49px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem: Inconsistent patient scores regarding medication and side effect education due to volume of printed medication discharge information.'\n[18] 2300.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'A. Did the staff explain your medication'\n[19] 1744.62px-wide text span at top-center: 'Before giving you any new medication, how often did the hospital staff tell you what the medicine was for?'\n[20] 1766.56px-wide text span at top-center: 'B. Did the staff clearly described the side effects of your medication'\n[21] 1744.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Before giving you any new medication, how often did the hospital staff describe possible side effects in a way you could understand?'\n[22] 2184.87px-wide text span at center-center: 'Never=1, Sometimes = 2, Usually = 3, Always = 4, Don\u2019t Know and Refused = N/A'\n[23] Image, description: the steps of the pdsa model at bottom-left\n[24] Image, description: an elderly woman in a hospital bed at top-left\n[25] Image, description: an older man holding a pile of papers at top-right\n[26] 2176.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) payment for performance based on patient satisfaction scores. Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) measures inpati...'\n[27] Image, description: the effects of magnetic therapy at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a graph with the words days to contact and a calendar at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: a bar graph with the words gender and percentage at bottom-left\n[30] Image, description: a graph with the words mean age and people at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: a graph with the words, 'meal age' at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the words current 10 medication sheet subdivided page instruction sheet for the medication at center-center\n[33] Image, description: the steps for medication safety at top-center"
},
{
"i": 502,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster. nue_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
19,
22
],
"rationale": "Creates a numerical discrepancy, conflicting with ID19\u2019s implied 1\u20134 rating scale.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 2183.78px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Inconsistent patient scores regarding medic Inconstside effect education due of printed medication de of printed medication discharge information'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Improving Patient Satisfaction with Medication Instructions: A Pilot Study'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dr. Tina Neu, DNP, RN, FNP, CNOR, NE-BC-Dr. Beth Keely, RN, PhD, Dr. Catherine Cummins, MD, RN'\n[4] 2157.14px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Title'\n[5] 2128.97px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The introduction of simplified discharge medication instructions can provide simple, understandable, and useful information. Providing a simplified variation of the medication instruction sheet in mu...'\n[6] 2175.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'We were unable to show a statistically significant increase in the patient satisfaction scores with the new medication instructions. The manner in which the hospital surveyed and gathered information...'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Southern California CSU DNP Consortium ~ Fullerton \uf06c Los Angeles \uf06c Long Beach'\n[8] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Theoretical Model'\n[9] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem/Purpose'\n[10] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Background'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'Questions for Patients Key Variables'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'Method Instruction Sheet'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Results'\n[14] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Implications to Nursing'\n[15] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Discussion'\n[16] 2249.49px-wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose: To improve patient satisfaction with medication and side effect instructions'\n[17] 2249.49px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem: Inconsistent patient scores regarding medication and side effect education due to volume of printed medication discharge information.'\n[18] 2300.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'A. Did the staff explain your medication'\n[19] 1744.62px-wide text span at top-center: 'Before giving you any new medication, how often did the hospital staff tell you what the medicine was for?'\n[20] 1766.56px-wide text span at top-center: 'B. Did the staff clearly described the side effects of your medication'\n[21] 1744.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Before giving you any new medication, how often did the hospital staff describe possible side effects in a way you could understand?'\n[22] 2184.87px-wide text span at center-center: 'Never=9, Sometimes = 8, Usually = 7, Always = 50, Don\u2019t Know or Refused = 0'\n[23] Image, description: the steps of the pdsa model at bottom-left\n[24] Image, description: an elderly woman in a hospital bed at top-left\n[25] Image, description: an older man holding a pile of papers at top-right\n[26] 2176.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) payment for performance based on patient satisfaction scores. Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) measures inpati...'\n[27] Image, description: the effects of magnetic therapy at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a graph with the words days to contact and a calendar at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: a bar graph with the words gender and percentage at bottom-left\n[30] Image, description: a graph with the words mean age and people at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: a graph with the words, 'meal age' at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the words current 10 medication sheet subdivided page instruction sheet for the medication at center-center\n[33] Image, description: the steps for medication safety at top-center"
},
{
"i": 503,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster. nue_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8
],
"rationale": "Implies a futuristic or impossible timeframe that conflicts with the present-day study.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 2183.78px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Inconsistent patient scores regarding medic Inconstside effect education due of printed medication de of printed medication discharge information'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Improving Patient Satisfaction with Medication Instructions: A Pilot Study'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Dr. Tina Neu, DNP, RN, FNP, CNOR, NE-BC-Dr. Beth Keely, RN, PhD, Dr. Catherine Cummins, MD, RN'\n[4] 2157.14px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Title'\n[5] 2128.97px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'The introduction of simplified discharge medication instructions can provide simple, understandable, and useful information. Providing a simplified variation of the medication instruction sheet in mu...'\n[6] 2175.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'We were unable to show a statistically significant increase in the patient satisfaction scores with the new medication instructions. The manner in which the hospital surveyed and gathered information...'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Southern California CSU DNP Consortium ~ Fullerton \uf06c Los Angeles \uf06c Long Beach'\n[8] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Timetravel Paradox'\n[9] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem/Purpose'\n[10] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Background'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'Questions for Patients Key Variables'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'Method Instruction Sheet'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Results'\n[14] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Implications to Nursing'\n[15] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Discussion'\n[16] 2249.49px-wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose: To improve patient satisfaction with medication and side effect instructions'\n[17] 2249.49px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem: Inconsistent patient scores regarding medication and side effect education due to volume of printed medication discharge information.'\n[18] 2300.0px-wide text span at top-center: 'A. Did the staff explain your medication'\n[19] 1744.62px-wide text span at top-center: 'Before giving you any new medication, how often did the hospital staff tell you what the medicine was for?'\n[20] 1766.56px-wide text span at top-center: 'B. Did the staff clearly described the side effects of your medication'\n[21] 1744.62px-wide text span at center-center: 'Before giving you any new medication, how often did the hospital staff describe possible side effects in a way you could understand?'\n[22] 2184.87px-wide text span at center-center: 'Never=1, Sometimes = 2, Usually = 3, Always = 4, Don\u2019t Know and Refused = N/A'\n[23] Image, description: the steps of the pdsa model at bottom-left\n[24] Image, description: an elderly woman in a hospital bed at top-left\n[25] Image, description: an older man holding a pile of papers at top-right\n[26] 2176.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) payment for performance based on patient satisfaction scores. Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) measures inpati...'\n[27] Image, description: the effects of magnetic therapy at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a graph with the words days to contact and a calendar at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: a bar graph with the words gender and percentage at bottom-left\n[30] Image, description: a graph with the words mean age and people at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: a graph with the words, 'meal age' at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the words current 10 medication sheet subdivided page instruction sheet for the medication at center-center\n[33] Image, description: the steps for medication safety at top-center"
},
{
"i": 504,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_DNP Project Poster_Aguinaldo2 (1)_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
26
],
"rationale": "Inserting a playful party image into an academic poster is a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'A Change Tool for Lifestyle Modifications in Obese and Overweight Women'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Patricia Aguinaldo, DNP, RN, FNP-C; Paula Vuckovich, PhD, RN, PMHCNS-BC; and Donna Scemons, PhD, RN, FNP'\n[3] 2122.54px-wide text span at top-right: 'Title'\n[4] 2157.14px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Title'\n[5] 1914.29px-wide text span at center-left: 'Obesity is a growing world health problem. It is also preventable risk factor for non-communicable diseases: cardiovascular disease, cancers, diabetes, and musculoskeletal disorders (WHO, 2015b) Fou...'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Southern California CSU DNP Consortium ~ Fullerton \uf06c Los Angeles \uf06c Long Beach'\n[7] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Background'\n[8] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose'\n[9] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Theoretical Framework'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Methods and Procedure'\n[11] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Results'\n[12] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Limitations'\n[13] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Implications for Practice'\n[14] 2005.95px-wide text span at top-right: 'Small sample; n=17 Generalizability of a single population of solely Hispanic women Time constraints of quality improvement project'\n[15] 2045.24px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Feasible to implement tool in similar primary care setting Implementation of tool bundle can be simultaneous with conduction of routine work. Time-saving techniques included decisional balance tool ...'\n[16] 1866.67px-wide text span at center-center: 'Setting: Private primary care clinic Sample: Purposive sampling used to examine the adult female subgroup in clinic population. Inclusion criteria for participation are the following: female, 18 year...'\n[17] 2150.0px-wide text span at center-center: 'Motivational Interviewing by practitioner in consultation/exam room with use of prompts tailored to stage of change Follow-up visits and calls at 4 week intervals to assess for BMI and stage of change...'\n[18] 2316.67px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Change in behaviors and stage of change over 4 months (as seen in figure to left) N = 17, Hispanic female, ages 27 \u2013 63 BMI ranging from 25.69 \u2013 47.87 14 out of 17 participants changed from Contemplat...'\n[19] 1900.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Stages of Change at Follow-up Visits. Progression through the stages for number of study participants at time follow-up visits.'\n[20] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Future Research'\n[21] 1950.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Expansion for use by other practitioners in the clinic Longitudinal study for larger sample size and the following: Assessment for changes in weight Assessment of comorbidities Implementation of con...'\n[22] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Conclusion'\n[23] 1933.33px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Tool bundle overall showed that increased investment by practitioner equals benefits in patients, and lifestyle changes are a progressive cycle that can be initiated with this process'\n[24] Wide text span at top-center: '['Project Application of Conceptual Framework''\n[25] Wide text span at top-center: '['Change tool model: An integrative model of the Transtheoretical Model of Change and Motivational Interviewing technique with the objective of TTM stage progression.''\n[26] Image, description: A clown on a bicycle on a busy street in a city. at top-center"
},
{
"i": 505,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Lewis_Poster_PortoWorkshop_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
20
],
"rationale": "A horror-themed image is contextually mismatched with an academic poster about green infrastructure.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at center-left: '- Escobedo et al. (2019): understanding is more \u000bimportant than terminology - Significant appearances in literature: \u000b2006: ecosystem services; \u000b2007: green infrastructure; \u000b2015: nature-based solutio...'\n[2] 1386.37px-wide text span at center-right: 'Community involvement possibly motivated by \u000b different factors (e.g. White 2011) Perceptions of neighborhood shaped by \u000b overall sense of decline (Draus et al. \u000b ...'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'Previously used/built land (unlike suburban vacant land) Grey infrastructure in a shrinking city more likely to be \u000b\t\t\t\t\tdegrading\u000b\t\t\t\t Self-assembly vs. facilitated assemb...'\n[4] Image, description: the words reviving sinking cities at top-right\n[5] Wide text span at top-left: 'Governing multifunctional green infrastructure in shrinking cities'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'What is green infrastructure?'\n[7] Wide text span at top-right: 'Research context'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: 'Outcomes'\n[9] Wide text span at center-right: 'Suggestions'\n[10] Wide text span at bottom-center: '['Limited municipal resources (Frazier\\x0b & Bagchi-Sen 2015) Decision-making with high \\x0b uncertainty (Nemeth & Langhorst \\x0b 2014)''\n[11] 1014.8px-wide text span at center-right: '['To identify ways in which planners in shrinking cities can improve their decision-making process about implementing multifunctional green infrastructure''\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: '['How are shrinking cities currently making decisions about what type of green infrastructure to implement?\\x0bReview city policies and plans and conduct a postal survey of city decision-makers How ca...'\n[13] ['Image, description: a tree with a pink, orange, and blue background' at center-center\n[14] 570.9px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Green infrastructure? Urban forestry? Nature-based solutions? Ecosystem services?''\n[15] Wide text span at center-left: '['Keyword search of Web of Science, Scopus and JSTOR \\uf0e0 \\x0b66 papers (2006-2019) on green infrastructure in shrinking cities''\n[16] Wide text span at top-right: '['What is unique about green infrastructure in shrinking cities?''\n[17] Wide text span at top-right: '['Aim''\n[18] 214.33px-wide text span at center-center: '['Research questions & proposed methodology''\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: '['Draus, P. J., Roddy, J., & McDuffie, A. (2014). \u2018We don\u2019t have no neighbourhood\u2019: Advanced marginality and urban agriculture in Detroit. Urban Studies, 51(12), 2523\u20132538. https://doi.org/10.1177/004...'\n[20] Image, description: A zombie apocalypse is happening on the street. at bottom-center"
},
{
"i": 506,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_ScientificPosterHEAP_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
4
],
"rationale": "This directly contradicts the statement in [4] that chronic disease incidence (e.g. cancer) is rising.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the logo for iarc learning at bottom-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Human Exposome Assessment Platform (HEAP)'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'HEAP claims disease rates have hit record lows'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABSTRACT: Over the last two decades there has been an enormous advancement in understanding environmental exposures and their biological effects. The sum of all these biological exposures and their su...'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'H Coombs,1 J Roux,1 C Volatier1, A Berger,1 and Z Kozlakidis,1 on behalf of the HEAP consortium 1 International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization (WHO), Lyon, France'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'The HEAP Data Life-Cycle'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'HEAP eLearning platform'\n[8] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform logo at top-left\n[9] Image, description: the process of a data storage system at top-center\n[10] 945.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Biobanks'\n[11] 2367.36px-wide text span at top-right: 'STEPS EXPLAINED Step 1: The HEAP Platform as a Service (PaaS) will harmonize and curate data, and stream them on demand to the HEAP Information Commons. The Information Commons consists of physical re...'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'HEAP will build on previous EU Horizon 2020 projects, such as B3Africa, RD-Connect, and FP7 BiobankCloud. Its aim is to make pseudonymized data from large-scale population cohorts, including data on s...'\n[13] Image, description: the number of women who have been treated at center-left\n[14] Wide text span at center-left: 'Karolinska Institutet, Sweden: The Swedish cervical screening cohort study will evaluate internal exposome factors, such as viruses and bacteria, through analysis of cervical cells. Sweden has pioneer...'\n[15] Image, description: two red and white letters at center-right\n[16] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The nationwide Finnish Maternity Cohort is an internationally unique cohort. This study has collected biospecimens and registry data from registered pregnancies i...'\n[17] Image, description: the words 8000 girls are not allowed to attend at bottom-right\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The Finnish community randomized human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination trial is the largest of its kind in the world, and consists of registry data and biospecim...'\n[19] Image, description: the words up to 1000 years of experience at bottom-right\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Statens Serum Institut, Denmark: The Consumer Cohort study will model the impact of household consumption on health and disease by collecting receipts from Danish consumers and linking to national hea...'\n[21] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform at bottom-left\n[22] 2091.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'IARC, France: The knowledge and expertise generated by the project will be captured and become widely available to a global scientific audience through the dedicated IARC eLearning Platform. This is ...'\n[23] 803.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Partners:'\n[24] Image, description: the logo for the karolinska institute at bottom-left\n[25] Image, description: the statens serum institute logo at bottom-center\n[26] Image, description: the logo for the csc at bottom-center\n[27] Image, description: the logo for logic clocks at bottom-right\n[28] Image, description: the logo for med uni graz at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: the university of innsbruck logo at bottom-right\n[30] Image, description: the word stitching mc foundation at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: the university of warsaw logo at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the logo for tays for life at bottom-right\n[33] Image, description: the university of oulu logo at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 507,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_ScientificPosterHEAP_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
7
],
"rationale": "Refers to a comedic show, clashing thematically with the scientific and academic tone of the poster.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the logo for iarc learning at bottom-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Human Exposome Assessment Platform (HEAP)'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'HEAP is a platform to share and reuse knowledge'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABSTRACT: Over the last two decades there has been an enormous advancement in understanding environmental exposures and their biological effects. The sum of all these biological exposures and their su...'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'H Coombs,1 J Roux,1 C Volatier1, A Berger,1 and Z Kozlakidis,1 on behalf of the HEAP consortium 1 International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization (WHO), Lyon, France'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'The HEAP Data Life-Cycle'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Comedy Circus Stage!'\n[8] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform logo at top-left\n[9] Image, description: the process of a data storage system at top-center\n[10] 945.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Biobanks'\n[11] 2367.36px-wide text span at top-right: 'STEPS EXPLAINED Step 1: The HEAP Platform as a Service (PaaS) will harmonize and curate data, and stream them on demand to the HEAP Information Commons. The Information Commons consists of physical re...'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'HEAP will build on previous EU Horizon 2020 projects, such as B3Africa, RD-Connect, and FP7 BiobankCloud. Its aim is to make pseudonymized data from large-scale population cohorts, including data on s...'\n[13] Image, description: the number of women who have been treated at center-left\n[14] Wide text span at center-left: 'Karolinska Institutet, Sweden: The Swedish cervical screening cohort study will evaluate internal exposome factors, such as viruses and bacteria, through analysis of cervical cells. Sweden has pioneer...'\n[15] Image, description: two red and white letters at center-right\n[16] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The nationwide Finnish Maternity Cohort is an internationally unique cohort. This study has collected biospecimens and registry data from registered pregnancies i...'\n[17] Image, description: the words 8000 girls are not allowed to attend at bottom-right\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The Finnish community randomized human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination trial is the largest of its kind in the world, and consists of registry data and biospecim...'\n[19] Image, description: the words up to 1000 years of experience at bottom-right\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Statens Serum Institut, Denmark: The Consumer Cohort study will model the impact of household consumption on health and disease by collecting receipts from Danish consumers and linking to national hea...'\n[21] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform at bottom-left\n[22] 2091.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'IARC, France: The knowledge and expertise generated by the project will be captured and become widely available to a global scientific audience through the dedicated IARC eLearning Platform. This is ...'\n[23] 803.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Partners:'\n[24] Image, description: the logo for the karolinska institute at bottom-left\n[25] Image, description: the statens serum institute logo at bottom-center\n[26] Image, description: the logo for the csc at bottom-center\n[27] Image, description: the logo for logic clocks at bottom-right\n[28] Image, description: the logo for med uni graz at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: the university of innsbruck logo at bottom-right\n[30] Image, description: the word stitching mc foundation at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: the university of warsaw logo at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the logo for tays for life at bottom-right\n[33] Image, description: the university of oulu logo at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 508,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_ScientificPosterHEAP_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14
],
"rationale": "This creates a numerical discrepancy about the screening age range.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the logo for iarc learning at bottom-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Human Exposome Assessment Platform (HEAP)'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'HEAP is a platform to share and reuse knowledge'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABSTRACT: Over the last two decades there has been an enormous advancement in understanding environmental exposures and their biological effects. The sum of all these biological exposures and their su...'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'H Coombs,1 J Roux,1 C Volatier1, A Berger,1 and Z Kozlakidis,1 on behalf of the HEAP consortium 1 International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization (WHO), Lyon, France'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'The HEAP Data Life-Cycle'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'HEAP eLearning platform'\n[8] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform logo at top-left\n[9] Image, description: the process of a data storage system at top-center\n[10] 945.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Biobanks'\n[11] 2367.36px-wide text span at top-right: 'STEPS EXPLAINED Step 1: The HEAP Platform as a Service (PaaS) will harmonize and curate data, and stream them on demand to the HEAP Information Commons. The Information Commons consists of physical re...'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'HEAP will build on previous EU Horizon 2020 projects, such as B3Africa, RD-Connect, and FP7 BiobankCloud. Its aim is to make pseudonymized data from large-scale population cohorts, including data on s...'\n[13] Image, description: the number of women who have been treated at center-left\n[14] Wide text span at center-left: 'Karolinska Institutet, Sweden: The Swedish cervical screening cohort study will evaluate internal exposome factors, such as viruses and bacteria, through analysis of cervical cells. Sweden has pioneer...'\n[15] Image, description: two red and white letters at center-right\n[16] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The nationwide Finnish Maternity Cohort is an internationally unique cohort. This study has collected biospecimens and registry data from registered pregnancies i...'\n[17] Image, description: the words 8000 girls are not allowed to attend at bottom-right\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The Finnish community randomized human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination trial is the largest of its kind in the world, and consists of registry data and biospecim...'\n[19] Image, description: the words up to 1000 years of experience at bottom-right\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Statens Serum Institut, Denmark: The Consumer Cohort study will model the impact of household consumption on health and disease by collecting receipts from Danish consumers and linking to national hea...'\n[21] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform at bottom-left\n[22] 2091.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'IARC, France: The knowledge and expertise generated by the project will be captured and become widely available to a global scientific audience through the dedicated IARC eLearning Platform. This is ...'\n[23] 803.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Partners:'\n[24] Image, description: the logo for the karolinska institute at bottom-left\n[25] Image, description: the statens serum institute logo at bottom-center\n[26] Image, description: the logo for the csc at bottom-center\n[27] Image, description: the logo for logic clocks at bottom-right\n[28] Image, description: the logo for med uni graz at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: the university of innsbruck logo at bottom-right\n[30] Image, description: the word stitching mc foundation at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: the university of warsaw logo at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the logo for tays for life at bottom-right\n[33] Image, description: the university of oulu logo at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 509,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_ScientificPosterHEAP_1_3.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16
],
"rationale": "Referring to data collection \u201csince 2083\u201d creates an impossible future timeline, inconsistent with the stated 12-year period in [18].",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the logo for iarc learning at bottom-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'The Human Exposome Assessment Platform (HEAP)'\n[3] Wide text span at center-left: 'HEAP is a platform to share and reuse knowledge'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'ABSTRACT: Over the last two decades there has been an enormous advancement in understanding environmental exposures and their biological effects. The sum of all these biological exposures and their su...'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'H Coombs,1 J Roux,1 C Volatier1, A Berger,1 and Z Kozlakidis,1 on behalf of the HEAP consortium 1 International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC), World Health Organization (WHO), Lyon, France'\n[6] Wide text span at top-left: 'The HEAP Data Life-Cycle'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'HEAP eLearning platform'\n[8] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform logo at top-left\n[9] Image, description: the process of a data storage system at top-center\n[10] 945.83px-wide text span at center-left: 'Biobanks'\n[11] 2367.36px-wide text span at top-right: 'STEPS EXPLAINED Step 1: The HEAP Platform as a Service (PaaS) will harmonize and curate data, and stream them on demand to the HEAP Information Commons. The Information Commons consists of physical re...'\n[12] Wide text span at center-center: 'HEAP will build on previous EU Horizon 2020 projects, such as B3Africa, RD-Connect, and FP7 BiobankCloud. Its aim is to make pseudonymized data from large-scale population cohorts, including data on s...'\n[13] Image, description: the number of women who have been treated at center-left\n[14] Wide text span at center-left: 'Karolinska Institutet, Sweden: The Swedish cervical screening cohort study will evaluate internal exposome factors, such as viruses and bacteria, through analysis of cervical cells. Sweden has pioneer...'\n[15] Image, description: two red and white letters at center-right\n[16] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The nationwide Finnish Maternity Cohort is an internationally unique cohort. This study has collected biospecimens and registry data from registered pregnancies i...'\n[17] Image, description: the words 8000 girls are not allowed to attend at bottom-right\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Tampere University Hospital, Finland: The Finnish community randomized human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination trial is the largest of its kind in the world, and consists of registry data and biospecim...'\n[19] Image, description: the words up to 1000 years of experience at bottom-right\n[20] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Statens Serum Institut, Denmark: The Consumer Cohort study will model the impact of household consumption on health and disease by collecting receipts from Danish consumers and linking to national hea...'\n[21] Image, description: the human exposure assessment platform at bottom-left\n[22] 2091.67px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'IARC, France: The knowledge and expertise generated by the project will be captured and become widely available to a global scientific audience through the dedicated IARC eLearning Platform. This is ...'\n[23] 803.12px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Partners:'\n[24] Image, description: the logo for the karolinska institute at bottom-left\n[25] Image, description: the statens serum institute logo at bottom-center\n[26] Image, description: the logo for the csc at bottom-center\n[27] Image, description: the logo for logic clocks at bottom-right\n[28] Image, description: the logo for med uni graz at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: the university of innsbruck logo at bottom-right\n[30] Image, description: the word stitching mc foundation at bottom-center\n[31] Image, description: the university of warsaw logo at bottom-right\n[32] Image, description: the logo for tays for life at bottom-right\n[33] Image, description: the university of oulu logo at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 510,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_ENHANCING INTRAVENOUS FLUID ADMINISTRATION IN COLORECTAL SURGERY POSTER_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
16
],
"rationale": "This new \u201cBackground\u201d about wedding tips starkly conflicts thematically with the colorectal surgery discussion in ID 16.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'ENHANCING INTRAVENOUS FLUID ADMINISTRATION IN COLORECTAL SURGERY'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Caresse Rose Correa RN, BSN & Allison Dat-Ski Yue RN, BSN, CCRN'\n[3] 2169.96px-wide text span at center-left: '1. Examine latest research to identify latest colorectal surgery IVF management standards 2. Evaluate if Kaiser Permanente (KP) providers are compliant with the latest standards 3. Recommend an ane...'\n[4] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'WeddingTips'\n[5] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Aims'\n[6] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Problem Statement'\n[7] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Methods'\n[8] Wide text span at top-center: 'Adapted Iowa Model Conceptual Framework'\n[9] Wide text span at center-center: 'Results'\n[10] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Project Limitations'\n[11] 2200.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Practice Implications'\n[12] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Discussion'\n[13] 2181.97px-wide text span at center-left: 'Without knowledge of the latest IVF recommendations, anesthesia providers may inadvertently provide incorrect intraoperative IVF volumes to colorectal surgery patients, potentially increasing their ri...'\n[14] 2044.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Key Findings Total IVF = 2,911 ml (SD 1922) Total IVF in Females 2,540 ml (SD 1,958) vs Males 4,025 ml (SD 1,408), p value = 0.02 67% of patients received < 3,000 ml vs 46% of patients received < 2,...'\n[15] 2169.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Several patients received IVF volumes above ROL recommendations: 33% (n = 8) received > 3,000 ml IVF 54% (n = 13) received > 2,500 ml Zero GDFT Devices Used Zero negative outcomes Possibly related t...'\n[16] 2181.97px-wide text span at top-left: 'Colorectal surgery has elevated rates of M&M; - \u2153 of patients develop a complication Maintaining euvolemia reduces adverse outcomes and healthcare costs Accurate fluid resuscitation is based on mult...'\n[17] 2176.34px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Design: 1. ROL to determine latest IVF resuscitation standards 2. Retrospective anesthesia provider IVF administration practice data audit Setting: 1 KP Southern California Facility Sample: N = 24 (...'\n[18] 2228.57px-wide text span at top-right: 'Coronavirus Pandemic Elective case cancellations Office closures reduced access to secured database Small Sample Size Small sample reduced the results generalizability, reliability, and reproducibilit...'\n[19] Wide text span at center-center: 'Retrospective practice audit revealed anesthesia providers were not compliant with latest standards - Recommendation for anesthesia Provider Education Initiative in 4 Phases: Phase I: Create Best Prac...'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'GDFT and Zero-Balance are superior intraoperative IVF strategies Zero-balance- Best for low-risk patients undergoing low-risk surgery (2.5-3 L, 1- 3 ml/kg/hr) GDFT- Best for high-risk patients undergo...'\n[21] 2154.43px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Additional anesthesia provider education can optimize their fluid resuscitation practices when caring for colorectal surgery patients Sample Educational tool: We also advocate for enhanced G...'\n[22] Image, description: the different types of csgs at bottom-right\n[23] Image, description: the percentage of compliance with interperative volume at center-center\n[24] Image, description: a bar chart with the words compliance with incremental fluid volume at center-center\n[25] Image, description: a bar chart with the words mean interpretive fluid volumes per fluid type at bottom-center\n[26] Image, description: a graph of compliance with incremental flow volume at center-center"
},
{
"i": 511,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_PERIOPERATIVE HYPEROXYGENATION FOR REDUCING RISK OF SURGICAL SITE INFECTION IN COLORECTAL SURGERY PATIENTS POSTER_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "A celebratory phrase contradicts the serious nature of the content.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Perioperative Hyperoxygenation for Reducing Risk of Surgical Site Infections in Colorectal Surgery Patients'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Christina Cross SRNA & Kyla Winkle SRNA --- Rachel McClanahan DNP, RN, NCSN & Michael Boytim CRNA, Ed. D'\n[3] 2133.92px-wide text span at top-left: 'SSIs occur in 5.4 - 23.2% of colorectal surgeries SSIs are associated with: \u2153 annual HAI cost in the U.S. ($3.3 billion) \u2191 morbidity, \u2191 mortality (3%) & \u2191 LOS Current WHO and CDC SSI prevention guide...'\n[4] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Party Time!'\n[5] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Methods'\n[6] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Theoretical Framework'\n[8] Wide text span at center-center: 'Data Analysis and Interpretation'\n[9] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Recommendations'\n[10] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Educational Flyer'\n[11] 2028.54px-wide text span at top-right: 'We recommend clinician education on the WHO and CDC SSI prevention guidelines recommendation of perioperative hyperoxygenation and the use of non-rebreather face masks in the PACU. In an effort to in...'\n[12] 1385.26px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'None of the patients received an FiO2 of 80% intraoperatively and we were unable to distinguish the exact FiO2 delivery in the PACU. We determined that none of the patients received a perioperative Fi...'\n[13] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'The purpose of this project was to assess clinician utilization of evidence-based best practice guidelines regarding the use of perioperative hyperoxygenation to reduce the risk of SSI in open colorec...'\n[14] 2175.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Sample & Setting Kaiser Permanente Southern California Region ~ 4,608,507 members Inclusion Criteria Open colorectal surgery under GA with ETT after Sep 2019 Male & female 18 years old + Exclusion Cri...'\n[15] Image, description: the iowa model revised epidemic band practices to promote excellence in health care at center-center\n[16] Image, description: the table with different numbers and numbers at bottom-center\n[17] Image, description: the different types of hypergenesis at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 512,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_PERIOPERATIVE HYPEROXYGENATION FOR REDUCING RISK OF SURGICAL SITE INFECTION IN COLORECTAL SURGERY PATIENTS POSTER_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
12
],
"rationale": "Referring to 19th-century patients conflicts with modern context, creating a temporal mismatch.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Perioperative Hyperoxygenation for Preventing Surgical Site Infections in 19th Century Patients'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Christina Cross SRNA & Kyla Winkle SRNA --- Rachel McClanahan DNP, RN, NCSN & Michael Boytim CRNA, Ed. D'\n[3] 2133.92px-wide text span at top-left: 'SSIs occur in 5.4 - 23.2% of colorectal surgeries SSIs are associated with: \u2153 annual HAI cost in the U.S. ($3.3 billion) \u2191 morbidity, \u2191 mortality (3%) & \u2191 LOS Current WHO and CDC SSI prevention guide...'\n[4] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-left: 'Background'\n[5] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Methods'\n[6] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'Purpose'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Theoretical Framework'\n[8] Wide text span at center-center: 'Data Analysis and Interpretation'\n[9] 2200.0px-wide text span at top-right: 'Recommendations'\n[10] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-right: 'Educational Flyer'\n[11] 2028.54px-wide text span at top-right: 'We recommend clinician education on the WHO and CDC SSI prevention guidelines recommendation of perioperative hyperoxygenation and the use of non-rebreather face masks in the PACU. In an effort to in...'\n[12] 1385.26px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'None of the patients received an FiO2 of 80% intraoperatively and we were unable to distinguish the exact FiO2 delivery in the PACU. We determined that none of the patients received a perioperative Fi...'\n[13] 2200.0px-wide text span at center-left: 'The purpose of this project was to assess clinician utilization of evidence-based best practice guidelines regarding the use of perioperative hyperoxygenation to reduce the risk of SSI in open colorec...'\n[14] 2175.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Sample & Setting Kaiser Permanente Southern California Region ~ 4,608,507 members Inclusion Criteria Open colorectal surgery under GA with ETT after Sep 2019 Male & female 18 years old + Exclusion Cri...'\n[15] Image, description: the iowa model revised epidemic band practices to promote excellence in health care at center-center\n[16] Image, description: the table with different numbers and numbers at bottom-center\n[17] Image, description: the different types of hypergenesis at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 513,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster Ada Achinanya_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
14
],
"rationale": "An image of battlefield conflict is thematically mismatched with the fertility and affordability context highlighted in ID 10.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-image",
"descs": "[1] 2021.12px-wide text span at top-left: 'A number of interventions for women seeking fertility treatment have been set in place to improve their mental health, thereby increasing the pregnancy rates1. However, most of these interventions fa...'\n[2] 1827.95px-wide text span at top-left: 'BACKGROUND'\n[3] 1850.47px-wide text span at center-center: 'Dramatic collage depicting frequent battlefield images and soldier quotes from diverse regions lacking adequate healthcare coverage worldwide.'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'THEMATIC ANALYSIS RESULTS'\n[5] 1600.99px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fig.1: Catastrophic expenditure values for women in the various UK economic quintiles. Participants within the poor and middle quintile groups, spent approximately 24% and 14% of their annual househol...'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'QUANTITATIVE RESULTS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-left: 'Affordability was assessed through survey self-reporting. Questionnaires were used to capture information on socio-economic status, subjective financial well-being (SFW) and catastrophic ART expenditu...'\n[8] 1788.74px-wide text span at top-left: 'METHODS'\n[9] Image, description: the university of sheffield logo at top-left\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'Affordability of Assisted Reproductive Treatment (ART) in the public health sector of a High and Low-Middle Income Country: A Mixed Method Study'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'Achinanya, A1; Akparibo, R2; Aziken, M3; Anumba, D1 1Academic Unit of Reproductive & Developmental Medicine, University of Sheffield 2School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, 3D...'\n[12] 1307.32px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CONCLUSIONS'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Most Nigerian households incurred catastrophic expenditures funding the treatment, however, UK households did not Most UK and Nigerian households used various strategies to fund the treatment; inclu...'\n[14] Image, description: a variety of different colored shapes at center-center\n[15] 1271.98px-wide text span at center-right: 'Word Tree for the word \u2018afford\u2019\u2019'\n[16] 1375.05px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'REFERENCE'\n[17] 2069.42px-wide text span at bottom-center: '1. Dyer et al. (2013). Catastrophic payment for assisted reproduction techniques with conventional ovarian stimulation in the public health sector of South Africa: frequency and coping strategies. Hum...'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Analyses Quantitative data were analysed using SPSS 21, and qualitative analysis were conducted using NVivo v.11.'\n[19] Image, description: a graph of the cost of capital expenditure in the world at center-center\n[20] 1645.19px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Fig.2: Subjective financial wellbeing comparisons for both UK and Nigerian women. More UK women reported \u2018completely\u2019 having enough money than Nigerian women, while more Nigerian women endorsed \u2019not h...'\n[21] Image, description: a bar chart with the words do you have enough money to meet your needs at bottom-center\n[22] Image, description: a mind map with the words afford at center-right\n[23] 1375.05px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Contact Details'\n[24] 994.34px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Adanna Achinanya Academic unit of Reproductive and Developmental Medicine, University of Sheffield eleanorachis@gmail.com'\n[25] Image, description: a woman with long hair in a bathroom at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 514,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster Ada Achinanya_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
17
],
"rationale": "The year \u201c2100\u201d and futuristic procedures are temporally incoherent with the current study context (e.g., ID 1 references interventions already in place).",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] 2021.12px-wide text span at top-left: 'A number of interventions for women seeking fertility treatment have been set in place to improve their mental health, thereby increasing the pregnancy rates1. However, most of these interventions fa...'\n[2] 1827.95px-wide text span at top-left: 'BACKGROUND'\n[3] 1850.47px-wide text span at center-center: 'Word cloud of 15 common words used by women in both countries on affordability of fertility treatment'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'THEMATIC ANALYSIS RESULTS'\n[5] 1600.99px-wide text span at center-right: 'Fig.1: Catastrophic expenditure values for women in the various UK economic quintiles. Participants within the poor and middle quintile groups, spent approximately 24% and 14% of their annual househol...'\n[6] Wide text span at center-center: 'QUANTITATIVE RESULTS'\n[7] Wide text span at center-left: 'Affordability was assessed through survey self-reporting. Questionnaires were used to capture information on socio-economic status, subjective financial well-being (SFW) and catastrophic ART expenditu...'\n[8] 1788.74px-wide text span at top-left: 'METHODS'\n[9] Image, description: the university of sheffield logo at top-left\n[10] Wide text span at top-center: 'Affordability of Assisted Reproductive Treatment (ART) in the public health sector of a High and Low-Middle Income Country: A Mixed Method Study'\n[11] Wide text span at top-center: 'Achinanya, A1; Akparibo, R2; Aziken, M3; Anumba, D1 1Academic Unit of Reproductive & Developmental Medicine, University of Sheffield 2School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, 3D...'\n[12] 1307.32px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'CONCLUSIONS'\n[13] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Most Nigerian households incurred catastrophic expenditures funding the treatment, however, UK households did not Most UK and Nigerian households used various strategies to fund the treatment; inclu...'\n[14] Image, description: a variety of different colored shapes at center-center\n[15] 1271.98px-wide text span at center-right: 'Word Tree for the word \u2018afford\u2019\u2019'\n[16] 1375.05px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'REFERENCE'\n[17] 2069.42px-wide text span at bottom-center: '1. Dyer et al. (2100). Pioneering payment for telepathic fertility procedures with futuristic egg enhancement in the clinic of South Africa: improbable data and time-bound coping strategies. Hum. Rep....'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Analyses Quantitative data were analysed using SPSS 21, and qualitative analysis were conducted using NVivo v.11.'\n[19] Image, description: a graph of the cost of capital expenditure in the world at center-center\n[20] 1645.19px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Fig.2: Subjective financial wellbeing comparisons for both UK and Nigerian women. More UK women reported \u2018completely\u2019 having enough money than Nigerian women, while more Nigerian women endorsed \u2019not h...'\n[21] Image, description: a bar chart with the words do you have enough money to meet your needs at bottom-center\n[22] Image, description: a mind map with the words afford at center-right\n[23] 1375.05px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Contact Details'\n[24] 994.34px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Adanna Achinanya Academic unit of Reproductive and Developmental Medicine, University of Sheffield eleanorachis@gmail.com'\n[25] Image, description: a woman with long hair in a bathroom at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 515,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Sullivan_etal_GloBI_TPT_Poster_20210922_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
14
],
"rationale": "This sudden reference to a military plan is thematically at odds with the scientific, parasitology-focused content of the rest of the poster.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the word 'community' in a circle at center-center\n[2] Image, description: the logo for cbeer at bottom-right\n[3] Image, description: the nsf logo at top-left\n[4] Image, description: the logo for milwaukee public museum at bottom-right\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Making Parasite-Host Associations Visible using Global Biotic Interactions Biodiversity Digitization: Celebrating a decade of progress, September 22-23, 2021'\n[6] Image, description: the logo for global business intelligence at top-right\n[7] Image, description: the uc santa barbara logo at bottom-right\n[8] Image, description: the logo for the terrestial parasite tracker at top-left\n[9] Image, description: different types of bugs and their characteristics at top-left\n[10] 687.53px-wide text span at top-left: 'INTRODUCTION'\n[11] 877.1px-wide text span at top-left: 'Parasitic arthropods inflict an enormous burden on the health of their hosts either directly or through virulent pathogens that they carry Although parasites represent a substantial proportion of orga...'\n[12] 1924.8px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Specimen digitization leads to novel research. TPT provides research-ready baseline data that catalyzes research and education initiatives, and is expected to improve our understanding of parasite-hos...'\n[13] 922.38px-wide text span at center-center: 'Our network provides baseline information for research and management of the ecological interactions among parasites, pathogens, and their hosts in North America (including the U.S. & territories) Gl...'\n[14] 733.46px-wide text span at center-center: 'Military Offensive Plan'\n[15] 379.99px-wide text span at center-center: 'Citation'\n[16] Image, description: the text progress terapeutic potato tracker idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho - idho at top-right\n[17] Wide text span at top-center: 'Kathryn Sullivan, Marquette University Biology Department, Milwaukee Public Museum (MPM) Jorrit H. Poelen, Global Biotic Interactions (GloBI), Ronin Institute, Cheadle Center at UCSB Katja C. Seltmann...'\n[18] 1096.65px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'INTELLECTUAL MERITS OF TPT'\n[19] 687.53px-wide text span at center-left: 'Figure 1: Example of terrestrial arthropod parasites digitized by the Terrestrial Parasite Tracker Network. Images not to scale. Photo credits: S. Hamer, J. Light, H. Lutz, and B. OConnor.'\n[20] 1499.87px-wide text span at center-center: 'Example of increased availability of Ixodes scapularis (deer tick) records as tracked by GloBI over time'\n[21] 616.6px-wide text span at top-center: 'WHAT IS GLOBI?'\n[22] 797.51px-wide text span at top-right: 'TRACKING PROGRESS'\n[23] 656.36px-wide text span at center-right: 'DATA REVIEWS'\n[24] 2150.26px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 2: Diagram depicting overview workflow for the TPT network. TPT data and images will be exported to SCAN and indexed by iDigBio, GBIF, and GloBI.'\n[25] 1458.53px-wide text span at center-center: 'Figure 3: GloBI indexes openly shared data from specimens and literature, maps it to ontologies and name resolution services, and exposes the data as linked text. GloBI sythesizes biotic interaction d...'\n[26] 2051.9px-wide text span at center-right: 'Figure 5: TPT tracks project progress with quarterly published summary report. They include detailed data reviews, list of data providers and original source data. These summary reports document the a...'\n[27] Image, description: the marquette university logo at bottom-right\n[28] Image, description: a brown tick with a black head at center-center\n[29] 1025.26px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Figure 4: Ixodes scapularis (deer tick)'\n[30] Image, description: the review summary for the test at center-right\n[31] Image, description: the different types of data in a table at bottom-right\n[32] 1945.8px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figure 6. An example data review produced by GloBI. Data reviews help to provide early feedback to TPT contributors. The reviews are also included in the published quarterly published summary report. ...'\n[33] 2274.34px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Table 1: Ixodes scapularis (deer tick, Figure 4) records in GloBI before (2019) and after the TPT project began creating records (2020). The number of documented interactions of deer ticks with other...'\n[34] 2331.43px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The TPT project is supported by the National Science Foundation award \"Collaborative Research: Digitization TCN: Digitizing collections to trace parasite-host associations and predict...'\n[35] Image, description: the process of a gene sequencing process at center-left\n[36] 687.53px-wide text span at center-center: 'RESULTS'"
},
{
"i": 516,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_GaiaRev_Poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
9
],
"rationale": "ID 3 now claims the stars are 10 billion years old, which directly contradicts ID 9 stating these are young stars (Age<50 Myr).",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 2954.17px-wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction'\n[2] 2813.73px-wide text span at center-left: 'Through its exquisite photometry and astrometry of more than a billion stars in the Milky Way, Gaia has allowed for unprecedented new investigations of nearby stellar populations. Research into young ...'\n[3] 2957.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Identifying 10 Billion-Year-Old Stars'\n[4] 2505.88px-wide text span at top-center: 'Published DR2 Clustering'\n[5] 2482.33px-wide text span at top-right: 'Group-Specific Studies'\n[6] 2482.33px-wide text span at center-right: 'Conclusion'\n[7] 2491.48px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'References'\n[8] 2405.06px-wide text span at bottom-right: '[1'\n[9] 2813.73px-wide text span at center-left: 'To create a Bayesian approximation for the probability of a star being young, P(Age<50 Myr), we: Gather known probability distributions for the mass, age, metallicity, and multiplicity of field stars,...'\n[10] 2366.35px-wide text span at top-right: 'Follow-up spectroscopic observations are underway to collect radial velocities, detect youth indicators like Li, and perform deeper kinematic studies on many groups of interest. We have performed exte...'\n[11] 2372.43px-wide text span at top-center: 'Clustering in space-velocity coordinates identifies structures and excludes most noise from reddening anomalies. We applied the HDBSCAN clustering algorithm [3'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: 'The SPYGLASS Program: Mapping the Extensive Star-Forming Histories of Nearby Young Stellar Populations'\n[13] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ronan Kerr1, Adam Kraus1, Aaron Rizzuto1\u000b1University of Texas at Austin Department of Astronomy'\n[14] Image, description: the department of astronomy at the university of texas at austin at top-right\n[15] Image, description: a circle with a red circle in the middle at bottom-left\n[16] 2433.12px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'We identified 27 top-level young stellar structures in the solar neighborhood, 12 of which have limited or no recognition in the literature. Nearly all remaining structures show extents far beyond wha...'\n[17] 2482.33px-wide text span at top-center: 'New Structures in Gaia EDR3'\n[18] 2403.79px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Gaia\u2019s photometry and astrometry has provided the data necessary for the detection of both young stars on an unprecedented scale and the co-moving groups that they form. Through Gaia DR2 we have alrea...'\n[19] Image, description: a plot of a number of dots and a number of dots at bottom-left\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'AG=2'\n[21] 604.5px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Simulated Stars'\n[22] 1025.02px-wide text span at center-right: 'In Fornax-Horologium, preliminary results suggest that the group, which has previously been linked purely with the Chi1 Fornacis cluster, actually contains a secondary component slightly older than th...'\n[23] 2389.35px-wide text span at center-right: 'Cepheus Far North is located near the North Ecliptic Pole, making ideal for planetary studies using TESS. We plan on soon publishing detailed photometric and kinematic membership assessment for each c...'\n[24] 2401.46px-wide text span at top-center: 'We recently completed an expansion of our work to 1 kpc through the new data from Gaia EDR3. We plan to use these data to guide the infrastructure for a statistical census of nearby young stellar popu...'\n[25] 2389.33px-wide text span at center-center: 'We revealed stellar overdensities linking multiple SPYGLASS I groups through more distant structures including Stephenson 1. This association, which we refer to as CepHer (rhymes with \u201czephyr\u201d) after ...'\n[26] 2389.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'We also detected a small number of nearby groups more than 100 pc from the galactic plane. Leo East has a particularly extreme location, over 250 pc from the midplane on average with an age less than ...'\n[27] Image, description: the number of subgroups in the cluster at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a plot of the distance between leo and other young stars at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: a map of the nebby groups identified at center-center\n[30] 462.88px-wide text span at center-center: 'Kerr et al. 2021'\n[31] 1246.69px-wide text span at top-center: 'Nearby Groups Identified'\n[32] 959.94px-wide text span at center-center: 'CepHer Subgroups'\n[33] 1661.41px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leo East Relative to Other Young Stars'\n[34] Image, description: a plot of hf subgroups and a number of dots at center-right\n[35] 635.71px-wide text span at center-right: 'FH Subgroups'"
},
{
"i": 517,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_GaiaRev_Poster_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
2
],
"rationale": "The updated ID 1 introduces overt war-related language, clashing contextually with ID 2\u2019s scientific tone about Gaia\u2019s data.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] 2954.17px-wide text span at top-left: 'Victory War Notice'\n[2] 2813.73px-wide text span at center-left: 'Through its exquisite photometry and astrometry of more than a billion stars in the Milky Way, Gaia has allowed for unprecedented new investigations of nearby stellar populations. Research into young ...'\n[3] 2957.22px-wide text span at center-left: 'Young Star Identification'\n[4] 2505.88px-wide text span at top-center: 'Published DR2 Clustering'\n[5] 2482.33px-wide text span at top-right: 'Group-Specific Studies'\n[6] 2482.33px-wide text span at center-right: 'Conclusion'\n[7] 2491.48px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'References'\n[8] 2405.06px-wide text span at bottom-right: '[1'\n[9] 2813.73px-wide text span at center-left: 'To create a Bayesian approximation for the probability of a star being young, P(Age<50 Myr), we: Gather known probability distributions for the mass, age, metallicity, and multiplicity of field stars,...'\n[10] 2366.35px-wide text span at top-right: 'Follow-up spectroscopic observations are underway to collect radial velocities, detect youth indicators like Li, and perform deeper kinematic studies on many groups of interest. We have performed exte...'\n[11] 2372.43px-wide text span at top-center: 'Clustering in space-velocity coordinates identifies structures and excludes most noise from reddening anomalies. We applied the HDBSCAN clustering algorithm [3'\n[12] Wide text span at top-center: 'The SPYGLASS Program: Mapping the Extensive Star-Forming Histories of Nearby Young Stellar Populations'\n[13] Wide text span at top-center: 'Ronan Kerr1, Adam Kraus1, Aaron Rizzuto1\u000b1University of Texas at Austin Department of Astronomy'\n[14] Image, description: the department of astronomy at the university of texas at austin at top-right\n[15] Image, description: a circle with a red circle in the middle at bottom-left\n[16] 2433.12px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'We identified 27 top-level young stellar structures in the solar neighborhood, 12 of which have limited or no recognition in the literature. Nearly all remaining structures show extents far beyond wha...'\n[17] 2482.33px-wide text span at top-center: 'New Structures in Gaia EDR3'\n[18] 2403.79px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Gaia\u2019s photometry and astrometry has provided the data necessary for the detection of both young stars on an unprecedented scale and the co-moving groups that they form. Through Gaia DR2 we have alrea...'\n[19] Image, description: a plot of a number of dots and a number of dots at bottom-left\n[20] Compact text span at bottom-left: 'AG=2'\n[21] 604.5px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Simulated Stars'\n[22] 1025.02px-wide text span at center-right: 'In Fornax-Horologium, preliminary results suggest that the group, which has previously been linked purely with the Chi1 Fornacis cluster, actually contains a secondary component slightly older than th...'\n[23] 2389.35px-wide text span at center-right: 'Cepheus Far North is located near the North Ecliptic Pole, making ideal for planetary studies using TESS. We plan on soon publishing detailed photometric and kinematic membership assessment for each c...'\n[24] 2401.46px-wide text span at top-center: 'We recently completed an expansion of our work to 1 kpc through the new data from Gaia EDR3. We plan to use these data to guide the infrastructure for a statistical census of nearby young stellar popu...'\n[25] 2389.33px-wide text span at center-center: 'We revealed stellar overdensities linking multiple SPYGLASS I groups through more distant structures including Stephenson 1. This association, which we refer to as CepHer (rhymes with \u201czephyr\u201d) after ...'\n[26] 2389.33px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'We also detected a small number of nearby groups more than 100 pc from the galactic plane. Leo East has a particularly extreme location, over 250 pc from the midplane on average with an age less than ...'\n[27] Image, description: the number of subgroups in the cluster at center-center\n[28] Image, description: a plot of the distance between leo and other young stars at bottom-center\n[29] Image, description: a map of the nebby groups identified at center-center\n[30] 462.88px-wide text span at center-center: 'Kerr et al. 2021'\n[31] 1246.69px-wide text span at top-center: 'Nearby Groups Identified'\n[32] 959.94px-wide text span at center-center: 'CepHer Subgroups'\n[33] 1661.41px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Leo East Relative to Other Young Stars'\n[34] Image, description: a plot of hf subgroups and a number of dots at center-right\n[35] 635.71px-wide text span at center-right: 'FH Subgroups'"
},
{
"i": 518,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster_DiverIMPACTS_1AM_SwedenFINAL_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
5
],
"rationale": "Changing both the location to \u201cMars\u201d and the date to 2050 breaks the temporal and spatial coherence with the rest of the poster.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Sweden, Case study number 19\u000bDiversification through intercropping, with a special focus on grain legumes in Southern Sweden'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'Case Study Ambitions To increase the production and consumption of grain legumes in Sweden through multi-actor participatory approach'\n[3] Wide text span at center-right: 'The main challenge(s) Few choices of legume crops, legume diseases, cheap import, sorting, cleaning and drying, lack of communication between various actors, knowledge and specialty shops'\n[4] Wide text span at center-left: 'First case study meeting. Photo: Raj C, Feb 2018'\n[5] Wide text span at center-right: 'Participants grouping the challenges to legume production on Mars in second rocket study meeting. Photo: Raj C, Dec 2050'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'The case study innovation strategy Campaign about locally produced legumes, Creating/strengthening knowledge, and links between the different actors Etc.'\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Key actors involved Organic farmers, processors, retailers, Swedish Society for Nature Concervation (NGO), food co-operative, advisors, researchers'\n[8] 460.62px-wide text span at top-center: 'Anita Gunnarsson, (Leader)'\n[9] 480.39px-wide text span at top-right: 'Raj Chongtham (Monitor)'\n[10] Image, description: a woman wearing glasses and a black jacket at top-center\n[11] Image, description: a group of people in a room at center-right"
},
{
"i": 519,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_IHC TRAINING POSTER 1_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4
],
"rationale": "A war-related heading is tonally mismatched with an agricultural biofortification context.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'HGRP47 BIOFORTIFICATION IN VEGETABLE CROPS- A REVIEW Merin Elza George.1*and Sarada. S 1Research Scholar , Department of Vegetable Science, CoA, Vellayani, Trivandrum'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'INTORDUCTION Increasing population, inadequate food and nutrition, hunger, malnourishment of vitamins and micronutrients etc. are the greatest challenges faced by most of the nations across the world....'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'Agronomic biofortification is the application of micronutrient-containing mineral fertilizer to the soil and/or plant leaves, to increase micronutrient contents of the edible part of food crops. In p...'\n[4] Wide text span at center-center: 'SUCCESS STORIES OF HEAVY WARFARE'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'CONCLUSION No single intervention will alleviate micronutrient deficiencies, and biofortification complements existing interventions, such as supplementation and industrial food fortification. In ord...'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'REFERENCE Chakraborty, S., Chakraborty, N., and Datta, A. 2000. Increased nutritive value of transgenic potato by expressing a nonallergenic seed albumin gene from Amaranthus hypochondriacus. Proc. Na...'\n[7] Image, description: the iccar logo with a leaf at top-left\n[8] Image, description: the words introduction to research and increasing population at top-left\n[9] Image, description: the logo of hri at top-right\n[10] Image, description: the international year of fruits and vegetables logo at top-right\n[11] Wide text span at center-left: 'Amino acid profile in cassava and its interspecific hybrid'\n[12] 599.86px-wide text span at center-center: '(Nasser and Sousa, 2007)'\n[13] 426.73px-wide text span at center-left: 'Common Cassava'\n[14] 536.98px-wide text span at center-left: 'Poor true protein'\n[15] 914.92px-wide text span at center-left: 'Interspecific hybrid ICB 300 Diploide (M. esculenta x M. oligantha)'\n[16] 689.11px-wide text span at center-left: 'TRUE PROTEIN'\n[17] 475.77px-wide text span at center-center: 'LYSINE (10 \u2013fold)'\n[18] 600.11px-wide text span at center-center: 'METHIONINE (3- fold)'\n[19] Wide text span at center-left: 'Quantification (\u03bcg /g of tissue) trans-\u03b2-carotene and cis-\u03b2- carotene of some Manihot cultivar organs'\n[20] Image, description: a pineapple and a piece of fruit at center-left\n[21] 1036.82px-wide text span at center-left: 'ICB- 400 UnB-01'\n[22] Image, description: the process of making a plant from a tree at center-center\n[23] 333.38px-wide text span at center-center: 'ICB- 300'\n[24] 1010.88px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Protein rich potato'\n[25] 916.98px-wide text span at bottom-right: '(Chakraborty et al., 2000)'\n[26] 850.64px-wide text span at center-center: 'Amaranthus hypochondriacus'\n[27] 698.35px-wide text span at center-right: 'AmA1gene'\n[28] 940.08px-wide text span at center-right: 'Agrobacterium (Vector)'\n[29] 705.55px-wide text span at center-right: 'Potato'\n[30] 940.08px-wide text span at center-center: 'Potato ( > 60% increase in total protein )'\n[31] Wide text span at center-right: 'Non allergenic in nature Rich in essential amino acids.'\n[32] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Schedule of product release of biofortified crops in different countries'\n[33] Image, description: a cartoon potato in a chef hat at center-right"
},
{
"i": 520,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Poster_FORCE2021_20211209_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
29
],
"rationale": "Mislabels the institution, causing identity misattribution since other elements refer to EPFL.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: a spreadsheet with different items at center-center\n[2] Image, description: the landscape of data representations and data platforms at top-center\n[3] 1968.53px-wide text span at top-center: 'University services act in the continuous effort of supporting students and researchers, providing them with guidance and tools, and anticipating their needs. All while aligning with the services' mis...'\n[4] Image, description: the title of the event at bottom-center\n[5] 1968.53px-wide text span at top-right: 'We started from a list of data repositories used by a specific faculty, then expanded the scope to include other forms of data dissemination (code repositories, databanks, etc.), more faculties and ev...'\n[6] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'FORCE11 online conference: FORCE2021, 7-9 December 2021 \u201cJoining Forces to Advance the Future of Research Communications\u201d Photos and poster : CC-BY-NC-SA, EPFL Library'\n[7] Wide text span at top-center: 'Landscape of data repositories & platforms\u000b The quest for guiding researchers in choosing data dissemination platforms'\n[8] 1969.07px-wide text span at top-left: 'Scholarly communication is slowly shifting from papers to richer content, as for instance research data and code. Data dissemination has a crucial role and yet it is in its infancy, with visible fragm...'\n[9] 1968.53px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Categorization YOUR MINDMAP IS NOT MY MINDMAP Once we collected the list of platforms and their specifics, we needed to align our perspectives (basic vocabulary + collaborative online tools + etc.), ...'\n[10] ['Image, description: the word biblitheque on a black background' at top-left\n[11] 690.3px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Beyond data repos''\n[12] 1626.02px-wide text span at top-right: '['At researchers\u2019 service''\n[13] 1625.7px-wide text span at top-center: '['Open Data, but where?''\n[14] 1626.02px-wide text span at top-left: '['Comparative table WIP''\n[15] ['Image, description: the logo for force 11' at top-left\n[16] 866.88px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Based on EPFL researchers\u2019 input and on our experience, we divide the data dissemination solutions in 8 categories: The table is composed by: 10 tabs: the 1st tab contains the 8 definitions of d...'\n[17] 2149.28px-wide text span at center-left: '[\"Collecting information\\x0bINFORMATION IS POWER, TO EMPOWER As our own knowledge of platforms for data and code dissemination is limited, we surveyed EPFL researchers, asking for the platforms they ...'\n[18] 1968.53px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Main challenges''\n[19] 1400.02px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['WHO PUT THE HANDS ON THIS PROJECT Miriam Braskova\\x0bScientific advisor \\x0b@ EPFL School of Engineering Eliane Blumer Coordinator or the EPFL RDM team \\x0b@ EPFL Library Francesco Varrato\\x0bDat...'\n[20] ['Image, description: a woman with long hair and a chin on her hand' at bottom-left\n[21] ['Image, description: a woman wearing glasses and smiling' at bottom-left\n[22] ['Image, description: a man smiling in a black and white photo' at bottom-left\n[23] ['Image, description: a woman with c at bottom-left\n[24] ['Image, description: a qr code with a black background' at bottom-left\n[25] 577.77px-wide text span at center-left: '['Data repositories Data archives Data banks Cloud storage Code repositories ELN / LIMS Data analysis platforms IT infrastructure''\n[26] 1968.35px-wide text span at center-left: '['Because it is still work in progress and because of two main challenges, voids are a natural component of the table. As next steps, we will explore these ideas for improvement: Streamline the infor...'\n[27] Wide text span at center-left: '['Contributors''\n[28] ['Image, description: a spreadsheet with many different items' at bottom-left\n[29] Image, description: An awesome blue pastel watercolor background is the backdrop of this picture. at top-left"
},
{
"i": 521,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_2-Alicia_Maria_Gomez_Julian-Poster_Alicia_Gomez_Acuicultura_estudiante_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
4,
12
],
"rationale": "ID 12 describes successful application; changing ID 4 to \u201cSIN EFECTOS\u201d contradicts that success.",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'INTRODUCCI\u00d3N'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'M\u00c9TODOS'\n[3] Wide text span at top-left: 'RESUMEN'\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'SIN EFECTOS'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'CONCLUSIONES'\n[6] Image, description: the logo for the international certificate of cericla at top-center\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: 'TECNOLOG\u00cdA FERMENTATIVA DEL BACILLUS FIRMUS COMO PROBI\u00d3TICO PARA EL CULTIVO DE CAMARONES Autoras: Alicia Mar\u00eda G\u00f3mez Juli\u00e1n1, M.Sc. Liane Mary Gonz\u00e1lez Le\u00f3n2 1Universidad de Camag\u00fcey \u201cIgnacio Agramon...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: '.'\n[9] 1506.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Figura 3. Variaci\u00f3n de la concentraci\u00f3n.'\n[10] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figura 2. Diagrama de flujo de la propuesta tecnol\u00f3gica.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tabla 1: Costo de producci\u00f3n del probi\u00f3tico.'\n[12] Wide text span at center-left: 'Durante las \u00faltimas d\u00e9cadas, ha tenido gran \u00e9xito la aplicaci\u00f3n de bacterias con actividad probi\u00f3tica en el cultivo intensivo del camar\u00f3n. A trav\u00e9s de diferentes mecanismos de acci\u00f3n, los probi\u00f3ticos ...'\n[13] Wide text span at center-left: 'El dise\u00f1o de la planta para la producci\u00f3n de probi\u00f3tico se llev\u00f3 a cabo siguiendo los pasos del procedimiento secuencial propuesto por P\u00e9rez-Mart\u00ednez et al. (2012) y se seleccion\u00f3 la tecnolog\u00eda discon...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'El medio de cultivo para la fermentaci\u00f3n del Bacillus firmus debe contener 90 g/L de sacarosa, 27,4 g/L de nitrato de amonio y 25 g/L de extracto de levadura con lo que se alcanza una concentraci\u00f3n de...'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Entre las bacterias con probada actividad probi\u00f3tica se destaca el Bacillus firmus, que han manifestado su efectividad en el crecimiento y la resistencia del camar\u00f3n blanco, entre otros beneficios par...'\n[16] Wide text span at top-right: 'Condiciones de la fermentaci\u00f3n'\n[17] Image, description: the process of a chemical process at bottom-left\n[18] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sin embargo, en dicha tecnolog\u00eda el medio de cultivo m\u00e1s id\u00f3neo para el crecimiento del microorganismo result\u00f3 estar compuesto por sacarosa y extracto de levadura, que presenta el inconveniente de que...'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figura 1. Densidad \u00f3ptica para diferentes medios de cultivo.'\n[20] Wide text span at top-right: 'Medio de cultivo: 90 g/L de C12H22O11, 27,4 g/L de NH4NO3, 25 g/L de extracto de levadura y 0,2 g/L de MgSO4 pH: 6,5 Temperatura: 45 \u00baC Aereaci\u00f3n: 1,5 vvm Agitaci\u00f3n: 100 rpm Presi\u00f3n: 50 kPa Tiempo: 8...'\n[21] 1396.77px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figura 4. Estructura del costo de producci\u00f3n (%).'\n[22] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'La estimaci\u00f3n del costo de la inversi\u00f3n y de los indicadores econ\u00f3mico-financieros se realiz\u00f3 aplicando la metodolog\u00eda propuesta por Petrides (2000), espec\u00edfica para el dise\u00f1o de bioprocesos.'"
},
{
"i": 522,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_2-Alicia_Maria_Gomez_Julian-Poster_Alicia_Gomez_Acuicultura_estudiante_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
1,
12
],
"rationale": "ID 12 is scientific in tone, but ID 1 now sets a festive tone, causing thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'CARNAVALES!!'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'M\u00c9TODOS'\n[3] Wide text span at top-left: 'RESUMEN'\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'RESULTADOS'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'CONCLUSIONES'\n[6] Image, description: the logo for the international certificate of cericla at top-center\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: 'TECNOLOG\u00cdA FERMENTATIVA DEL BACILLUS FIRMUS COMO PROBI\u00d3TICO PARA EL CULTIVO DE CAMARONES Autoras: Alicia Mar\u00eda G\u00f3mez Juli\u00e1n1, M.Sc. Liane Mary Gonz\u00e1lez Le\u00f3n2 1Universidad de Camag\u00fcey \u201cIgnacio Agramon...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: '.'\n[9] 1506.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Figura 3. Variaci\u00f3n de la concentraci\u00f3n.'\n[10] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figura 2. Diagrama de flujo de la propuesta tecnol\u00f3gica.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tabla 1: Costo de producci\u00f3n del probi\u00f3tico.'\n[12] Wide text span at center-left: 'Durante las \u00faltimas d\u00e9cadas, ha tenido gran \u00e9xito la aplicaci\u00f3n de bacterias con actividad probi\u00f3tica en el cultivo intensivo del camar\u00f3n. A trav\u00e9s de diferentes mecanismos de acci\u00f3n, los probi\u00f3ticos ...'\n[13] Wide text span at center-left: 'El dise\u00f1o de la planta para la producci\u00f3n de probi\u00f3tico se llev\u00f3 a cabo siguiendo los pasos del procedimiento secuencial propuesto por P\u00e9rez-Mart\u00ednez et al. (2012) y se seleccion\u00f3 la tecnolog\u00eda discon...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'El medio de cultivo para la fermentaci\u00f3n del Bacillus firmus debe contener 90 g/L de sacarosa, 27,4 g/L de nitrato de amonio y 25 g/L de extracto de levadura con lo que se alcanza una concentraci\u00f3n de...'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Entre las bacterias con probada actividad probi\u00f3tica se destaca el Bacillus firmus, que han manifestado su efectividad en el crecimiento y la resistencia del camar\u00f3n blanco, entre otros beneficios par...'\n[16] Wide text span at top-right: 'Condiciones de la fermentaci\u00f3n'\n[17] Image, description: the process of a chemical process at bottom-left\n[18] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sin embargo, en dicha tecnolog\u00eda el medio de cultivo m\u00e1s id\u00f3neo para el crecimiento del microorganismo result\u00f3 estar compuesto por sacarosa y extracto de levadura, que presenta el inconveniente de que...'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figura 1. Densidad \u00f3ptica para diferentes medios de cultivo.'\n[20] Wide text span at top-right: 'Medio de cultivo: 90 g/L de C12H22O11, 27,4 g/L de NH4NO3, 25 g/L de extracto de levadura y 0,2 g/L de MgSO4 pH: 6,5 Temperatura: 45 \u00baC Aereaci\u00f3n: 1,5 vvm Agitaci\u00f3n: 100 rpm Presi\u00f3n: 50 kPa Tiempo: 8...'\n[21] 1396.77px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figura 4. Estructura del costo de producci\u00f3n (%).'\n[22] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'La estimaci\u00f3n del costo de la inversi\u00f3n y de los indicadores econ\u00f3mico-financieros se realiz\u00f3 aplicando la metodolog\u00eda propuesta por Petrides (2000), espec\u00edfica para el dise\u00f1o de bioprocesos.'"
},
{
"i": 523,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_2-Alicia_Maria_Gomez_Julian-Poster_Alicia_Gomez_Acuicultura_estudiante_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3,
13
],
"rationale": "ID 13 cites references from 2012 and 2016; ID 3 now implies a much older setting, causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-left: 'INTRODUCCI\u00d3N'\n[2] Wide text span at center-left: 'M\u00c9TODOS'\n[3] Wide text span at top-left: 'ERA 1492'\n[4] Wide text span at top-right: 'RESULTADOS'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'CONCLUSIONES'\n[6] Image, description: the logo for the international certificate of cericla at top-center\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: 'TECNOLOG\u00cdA FERMENTATIVA DEL BACILLUS FIRMUS COMO PROBI\u00d3TICO PARA EL CULTIVO DE CAMARONES Autoras: Alicia Mar\u00eda G\u00f3mez Juli\u00e1n1, M.Sc. Liane Mary Gonz\u00e1lez Le\u00f3n2 1Universidad de Camag\u00fcey \u201cIgnacio Agramon...'\n[8] Wide text span at center-left: '.'\n[9] 1506.96px-wide text span at center-right: 'Figura 3. Variaci\u00f3n de la concentraci\u00f3n.'\n[10] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figura 2. Diagrama de flujo de la propuesta tecnol\u00f3gica.'\n[11] Wide text span at center-right: 'Tabla 1: Costo de producci\u00f3n del probi\u00f3tico.'\n[12] Wide text span at center-left: 'Durante las \u00faltimas d\u00e9cadas, ha tenido gran \u00e9xito la aplicaci\u00f3n de bacterias con actividad probi\u00f3tica en el cultivo intensivo del camar\u00f3n. A trav\u00e9s de diferentes mecanismos de acci\u00f3n, los probi\u00f3ticos ...'\n[13] Wide text span at center-left: 'El dise\u00f1o de la planta para la producci\u00f3n de probi\u00f3tico se llev\u00f3 a cabo siguiendo los pasos del procedimiento secuencial propuesto por P\u00e9rez-Mart\u00ednez et al. (2012) y se seleccion\u00f3 la tecnolog\u00eda discon...'\n[14] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'El medio de cultivo para la fermentaci\u00f3n del Bacillus firmus debe contener 90 g/L de sacarosa, 27,4 g/L de nitrato de amonio y 25 g/L de extracto de levadura con lo que se alcanza una concentraci\u00f3n de...'\n[15] Wide text span at top-left: 'Entre las bacterias con probada actividad probi\u00f3tica se destaca el Bacillus firmus, que han manifestado su efectividad en el crecimiento y la resistencia del camar\u00f3n blanco, entre otros beneficios par...'\n[16] Wide text span at top-right: 'Condiciones de la fermentaci\u00f3n'\n[17] Image, description: the process of a chemical process at bottom-left\n[18] Wide text span at center-left: 'Sin embargo, en dicha tecnolog\u00eda el medio de cultivo m\u00e1s id\u00f3neo para el crecimiento del microorganismo result\u00f3 estar compuesto por sacarosa y extracto de levadura, que presenta el inconveniente de que...'\n[19] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figura 1. Densidad \u00f3ptica para diferentes medios de cultivo.'\n[20] Wide text span at top-right: 'Medio de cultivo: 90 g/L de C12H22O11, 27,4 g/L de NH4NO3, 25 g/L de extracto de levadura y 0,2 g/L de MgSO4 pH: 6,5 Temperatura: 45 \u00baC Aereaci\u00f3n: 1,5 vvm Agitaci\u00f3n: 100 rpm Presi\u00f3n: 50 kPa Tiempo: 8...'\n[21] 1396.77px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figura 4. Estructura del costo de producci\u00f3n (%).'\n[22] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'La estimaci\u00f3n del costo de la inversi\u00f3n y de los indicadores econ\u00f3mico-financieros se realiz\u00f3 aplicando la metodolog\u00eda propuesta por Petrides (2000), espec\u00edfica para el dise\u00f1o de bioprocesos.'"
},
{
"i": 524,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_NeurIPS21_DistShift_Gavrikov2021_AnEmprical_Poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
3
],
"rationale": "The rest of the poster is technical, so labeling a critical technical section \u201cRomantic Poetry\u201d introduces a thematic mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the words, an investigation of model to model distribution shits in trained conversion filters at top-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-left: 'An Empirical Investigation of Model-to-Model Distribution Shifts in Trained Convolutional Filters'\n[3] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Romantic Poetry'\n[4] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Instead of analyzing the distribution shift in original training and test data, we propose to study shifts in the learned weights of publicly available trained models. In this work, we focus on the pr...'\n[5] 1555.27px-wide text span at center-left: '391 public CNN models 524,563,289 filters from 13,015 layers 10 tasks: Image Classification, Segmentation, Generation, Super Resolution, \u2026 15 visual categories: natural, x-ray, seismic, depth, \u2026'\n[6] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-center: 'Distributions shifts'\n[7] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Dataset'\n[8] 1982.62px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'We scale each filter per layer-wise peak weight and perform a PCA-transformation of all filters to compare the structure independent of scale. The distribution shift is measured by the sum of symmetri...'\n[9] 1975.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Take-home messages'\n[10] 1983.69px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Public models have a large presence of degenerated filters The structure of convolutional filters differs across models On average the distributions are mostly independent of the task of the model and...'\n[11] 1975.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Visualization of the (degenerated) filters in each layer of a ResNet-18 trained on CIFAR-10.'\n[12] 1323.87px-wide text span at top-left: 'Paul Gavrikov, Janis Keuper'\n[13] Image, description: the qr code scan me at center-left\n[14] Image, description: the logo for hoffschule offenburg university at top-right\n[15] Image, description: the logo for alni at top-right\n[16] Image, description: a red, blue and white grid at center-left\n[17] 1982.62px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Method'\n[18] Image, description: the formula for the formula for the formula at bottom-left\n[19] Image, description: the number of different types of data at top-center\n[20] Image, description: the number of people who have been diagnosed with cancer at center-center\n[21] Image, description: a graph of the difference between the filter costs at bottom-center\n[22] 882.11px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Layer Depth Decile'\n[23] 905.21px-wide text span at center-center: 'Visual Category'\n[24] 905.21px-wide text span at top-center: 'Learned Task'\n[25] 1975.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Heatmaps showing the shift between filter coefficients grouped by various dimensions. Brighter colors indicate larger shifts.'\n[26] 444.79px-wide text span at bottom-center: '(color-scale adjusted)'\n[27] Image, description: a number of different red, blue and white squares at center-right\n[28] 2004.93px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Visualization of the principal components for various subsets with their respective explained variance ratio (below).'\n[29] Image, description: a graph of different distributions at top-right\n[30] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-right: 'Coefficient distributions'\n[31] 1982.62px-wide text span at center-right: 'Basis functions'\n[32] 528.01px-wide text span at center-right: 'All'\n[33] 528.01px-wide text span at center-right: 'Category: formula'\n[34] 528.01px-wide text span at center-right: 'Task: GAN-Discrim.'\n[35] 528.01px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'First Layer'\n[36] 1973.93px-wide text span at center-right: 'Visualization of the coefficient distributions along the first 4 principal components for filters grouped by learned task.'\n[37] 964.97px-wide text span at top-right: 'Classification Depth Estimation Face Detection Face Recognition GAN-Discriminator GAN-Generator Object Detection Segmentation Style Transfer Super Resolution'"
},
{
"i": 525,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_NeurIPS21_DistShift_Gavrikov2021_AnEmprical_Poster_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
37
],
"rationale": "#5 says there are 10 tasks total, but #29 now claims to compare 20 tasks, creating a numerical discrepancy.",
"category": "D. Quantitative Discrepancy",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the words, an investigation of model to model distribution shits in trained conversion filters at top-center\n[2] Wide text span at top-left: 'An Empirical Investigation of Model-to-Model Distribution Shifts in Trained Convolutional Filters'\n[3] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Motivation'\n[4] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Instead of analyzing the distribution shift in original training and test data, we propose to study shifts in the learned weights of publicly available trained models. In this work, we focus on the pr...'\n[5] 1555.27px-wide text span at center-left: '391 public CNN models 524,563,289 filters from 13,015 layers 10 tasks: Image Classification, Segmentation, Generation, Super Resolution, \u2026 15 visual categories: natural, x-ray, seismic, depth, \u2026'\n[6] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-center: 'Distributions shifts'\n[7] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-left: 'Dataset'\n[8] 1982.62px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'We scale each filter per layer-wise peak weight and perform a PCA-transformation of all filters to compare the structure independent of scale. The distribution shift is measured by the sum of symmetri...'\n[9] 1975.0px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Take-home messages'\n[10] 1983.69px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Public models have a large presence of degenerated filters The structure of convolutional filters differs across models On average the distributions are mostly independent of the task of the model and...'\n[11] 1975.0px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Visualization of the (degenerated) filters in each layer of a ResNet-18 trained on CIFAR-10.'\n[12] 1323.87px-wide text span at top-left: 'Paul Gavrikov, Janis Keuper'\n[13] Image, description: the qr code scan me at center-left\n[14] Image, description: the logo for hoffschule offenburg university at top-right\n[15] Image, description: the logo for alni at top-right\n[16] Image, description: a red, blue and white grid at center-left\n[17] 1982.62px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Method'\n[18] Image, description: the formula for the formula for the formula at bottom-left\n[19] Image, description: the number of different types of data at top-center\n[20] Image, description: the number of people who have been diagnosed with cancer at center-center\n[21] Image, description: a graph of the difference between the filter costs at bottom-center\n[22] 882.11px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Layer Depth Decile'\n[23] 905.21px-wide text span at center-center: 'Visual Category'\n[24] 905.21px-wide text span at top-center: 'Learned Task'\n[25] 1975.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Heatmaps showing the shift between filter coefficients grouped by various dimensions. Brighter colors indicate larger shifts.'\n[26] 444.79px-wide text span at bottom-center: '(color-scale adjusted)'\n[27] Image, description: a number of different red, blue and white squares at center-right\n[28] 2004.93px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Visualization of the principal components for various subsets with their respective explained variance ratio (below).'\n[29] 1299.04px-wide text span at top-right: '['Coefficient distributions''\n[30] 1982.62px-wide text span at top-right: '['Basis functions''\n[31] 1982.62px-wide text span at center-right: '['All''\n[32] 528.01px-wide text span at center-right: '['Category: formula''\n[33] 528.01px-wide text span at center-right: '['Task: GAN-Discrim.''\n[34] 528.01px-wide text span at center-right: '['First Layer''\n[35] 528.01px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Visualization of the coefficient distributions along the first 4 principal components for filters grouped by learned task.''\n[36] 1973.93px-wide text span at center-right: '['Classification Depth Estimation Face Detection Face Recognition GAN-Discriminator GAN-Generator Object Detection Segmentation Style Transfer Super Resolution''\n[37] Image, description: a work bench and many tools hanging on a rack at top-right"
},
{
"i": 526,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Tachkov_EURODURG_2020_poster[18886]_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
17
],
"rationale": "Using a protest image is contextually at odds with the academic information in ID4 about a formal questionnaire-based survey.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] 3125.66px-wide text span at top-center: 'MATERIALS AND METHODS'\n[2] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'CONCLUSIONS'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'DRUG-RELATED PROBLEMS AMONG OLDER AMBULATORY PATIENTS IN BULGARIA \u2013 A PILOT STUDY Tachkov K1, Kovachka G1, Kamusheva M1, Petrova G1, Brkic J2, Fialov\u00e1 D2, 3 1Department of Organization and Economics o...'\n[4] Wide text span at top-center: 'It is a prospective, questionnaire-based pilot survey conducted in general practitioner or cardiologist office; The questionnaire was developed for the purposes of comprehensive assessment of older ad...'\n[5] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'The diseases prevalence was in accordance with the national statistical data as cardiovascular disorders are a leading cause for morbidity and mortality among Bulgarian population; Polypharmacy and mu...'\n[6] 1846.48px-wide text span at top-left: 'INTRODUCTION'\n[7] Wide text span at center-center: '30 older patients 65+ (45% female and 55% male) were involved randomly in the study and those between 65 and 74years prevailed \u2013 75%; 97% were diagnosed with hypertension, 40% - diabetes, 33% - gastri...'\n[8] 917.65px-wide text span at center-center: 'RESULTS'\n[9] 1925.57px-wide text span at center-left: 'AIM OF THE STUDY'\n[10] 2204.9px-wide text span at center-left: 'The aim is to identify and analyze potential and actual DRPs among elderly patients over the age of 65 years.'\n[11] 1998.73px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'REFERENCES'\n[12] ['Image, description: the logo for the european union' at top-right\n[13] Wide text span at top-left: '['Ageing is a global tendency as the expectations are for increasing the number of people older than 60 years to 2 billion in 2050 [1''\n[14] 2562.44px-wide text span at center-left: '['[1''\n[15] Wide text span at bottom-center: '['Table 1 Type and number of identified DRPs''\n[16] 2423.75px-wide text span at center-center: '['EL31''\n[17] Image, description: a protest showing people to stop murder on the road at top-right"
},
{
"i": 527,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Aamer_poster_NZPC_3-4_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
44,
1
],
"rationale": "#1 references Missouri University, but #4 is changed to a Harvard crest, misattributing the institutional identity.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '3D Seismic Attribute Analysis for Structure and Stratigraphy Identification in Maui field, Taranaki Basin, New Zealand. Alhakeem A 1 , Almubarak H 1 , Liu K 1 , Al-Bazzaz W 2 1 Missouri University of...'\n[2] 516.25px-wide text span at top-left: 'www.mst.edu'\n[3] 499.27px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'aaaxb2@mst.edu'\n[4] 697.83px-wide text span at top-right: '['T-D chart, velocity log, and density log (RHOB) are used to generate acoustic impedance (AI), and reflection coefficient (RC) logs. synthetic seismograms generated for all the 9 wells and matched Wi...'\n[5] Wide text span at center-left: '['Seismic and well tie''\n[6] 814.59px-wide text span at top-left: '['Seismic Interpretation and Well Log Analysis''\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: '['Crossplots''\n[8] 676.23px-wide text span at center-left: '['Figure 3. Nuetron \u2013 density logs crossploted with gamma ray log data to identify facies and sequence stratigraphy''\n[9] 2155.72px-wide text span at center-left: '['Mapping and Attribute Analysis''\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: '['Figure 6. Spectral Decomposition for identifying horizon continuity''\n[11] 1144.91px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Figure 7. Coherence vertical seismic section of crossline 2354 showing faults''\n[12] 1086.85px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Figure 12. Horizon Amplitude Slice Map shown Lagoon and tidalflat marginal marine: Red;\\x0bCostal Coals: Blue.''\n[13] 1032.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Attributes for horizon identification and structure mapping''\n[14] Wide text span at center-left: '['C-Sand''\n[15] 343.2px-wide text span at center-left: '['Figure 8. Time Structure map shown anticline in the MauiB field near Maui-7. There is a dipping toward the north.''\n[16] 1032.97px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Figure 11. Depth Structure Map shown an anticline near the MauiB field. The Maui field can be identified by the fault system that surrounds the study area. The map shows a dipping toward the north a...'\n[17] 1084.58px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Figure 9. Coherence Map is corrected using the horizon dip map for better structure and stratigraphy identification to form the Eigenstructure Coherence''\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-right: '['Figure 13. RMS and Isochron maps shown the reservoir consistency for characterization evaluation for better attribute and petrophysical analysis. The high value combination ensures good prospective....'\n[19] 1749.69px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Attribute integration''\n[20] 953.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Attributes for discontinuities and stratigraphy identification''\n[21] ['Image, description: a number of people in a row' at center-right\n[22] ['Image, description: the isochron map c sand' at bottom-right\n[23] 837.21px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['MauiB\\x0bField''\n[24] ['Image, description: a red and white compass with a red arrow' at bottom-center\n[25] Compact text span at bottom-right: '['Structure, Amplitude, Eigenstructure Coherence''\n[26] 557.6px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Isochron Map\\x0bC-Sand''\n[27] 420.35px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['RMS Map\\x0bC-Sand''\n[28] 289.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Bright Spot''\n[29] 317.77px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['Seismic and Well Data''\n[30] 1794.13px-wide text span at top-center: '['Table 1. Wells used in the study''\n[31] 350.68px-wide text span at top-center: '['the seismic data. The 2D/3D seismic surveys and wells used in this study in the Taranaki Basin bounded by the yellow line. 3D Maui Base is bounded by blue line illustrating the Maui-B field''\n[32] ['Image, description: the new zealand petroleum conference logo' at top-center\n[33] ['Image, description: a man holding a plank and a hammer' at top-left\n[34] 494.65px-wide text span at top-left: '['Summary''\n[35] Wide text span at top-left: '['Figure 10. Average Velocty Map shown a low value near the MauiB field. Area near Rahi-1 well characterized by high average velocity value. While, in the MauiA field the highest velocity value is aro...'\n[36] 1122.6px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Discussion\\x0bResults show good PHIE and unmoved hydrocarbons indicating a potential reserve for the C-Sand near the well. PHIE value range near Kaimiro D-Sand is 15%-22.5%. Studying grains and pore...'\n[37] 1401.81px-wide text span at center-right: '['Figure 1. Basemap of''\n[38] 808.4px-wide text span at top-center: '['The Kapuni group within the Taranaki Basin in New Zealand is a potential petroleum reservoir. The objective of the study includes building a sequential approach to identify different geological feat...'\n[39] Wide text span at top-left: '['Figure 2. Workflow of the study including the target objectives''\n[40] 594.54px-wide text span at top-right: '['C-Sand''\n[41] 211.52px-wide text span at bottom-center: '['C-Sand''\n[42] 211.52px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['C-Sand''\n[43] 211.52px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['Figure 14. Integration of amplitude horizon and Eigenstructure Coherence overlaid in 3D seismic structure view.''\n[44] Image, description: A Design College logo beneath scissors and a chain. at top-right"
},
{
"i": 528,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Aamer_poster_NZPC_3-4_1_2.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
16
],
"rationale": "This mixes a historical time reference and a future projection in one figure (#16), causing temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: '3D Seismic Attribute Analysis for Structure and Stratigraphy Identification in Maui field, Taranaki Basin, New Zealand. Alhakeem A 1 , Almubarak H 1 , Liu K 1 , Al-Bazzaz W 2 1 Missouri University of...'\n[2] 516.25px-wide text span at top-left: 'www.mst.edu'\n[3] 499.27px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'aaaxb2@mst.edu'\n[4] Image, description: the missouri st & t logo at top-right\n[5] Wide text span at center-left: 'T-D chart, velocity log, and density log (RHOB) are used to generate acoustic impedance (AI), and reflection coefficient (RC) logs. synthetic seismograms generated for all the 9 wells and matched With...'\n[6] 814.59px-wide text span at top-left: 'Seismic and well tie'\n[7] Wide text span at top-left: 'Seismic Interpretation and Well Log Analysis'\n[8] 676.23px-wide text span at center-left: 'Crossplots'\n[9] 2155.72px-wide text span at center-left: 'Figure 3. Nuetron \u2013 density logs crossploted with gamma ray log data to identify facies and sequence stratigraphy'\n[10] Wide text span at center-center: 'Mapping and Attribute Analysis'\n[11] 1144.91px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 6. Spectral Decomposition for identifying horizon continuity'\n[12] 1086.85px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 7. Coherence vertical seismic section of crossline 2354 showing faults'\n[13] 1032.16px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Figure 12. Horizon Amplitude Slice Map shown Lagoon and tidalflat marginal marine: Red;\u000bCostal Coals: Blue.'\n[14] Wide text span at center-left: 'Attributes for horizon identification and structure mapping'\n[15] 343.2px-wide text span at center-left: 'C-Sand'\n[16] 1032.97px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Figure 8. Time Structure map from the late 19th century shows an anticline in the MauiB field near Maui-7, and a future projection dipping to the north.'\n[17] 1084.58px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 11. Depth Structure Map shown an anticline near the MauiB field. The Maui field can be identified by the fault system that surrounds the study area. The map shows a dipping toward the north and...'\n[18] Wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figure 9. Coherence Map is corrected using the horizon dip map for better structure and stratigraphy identification to form the Eigenstructure Coherence'\n[19] 1749.69px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figure 13. RMS and Isochron maps shown the reservoir consistency for characterization evaluation for better attribute and petrophysical analysis. The high value combination ensures good prospective.'\n[20] 953.49px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Attribute integration'\n[21] Wide text span at center-right: 'Attributes for discontinuities and stratigraphy identification'\n[22] Image, description: a number of people in a row at bottom-right\n[23] Image, description: the isochron map c sand at bottom-right\n[24] 219.68px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'MauiB\u000bField'\n[25] Image, description: a red and white compass with a red arrow at bottom-right\n[26] 557.6px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Structure, Amplitude, Eigenstructure Coherence'\n[27] 420.35px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Isochron Map\u000bC-Sand'\n[28] 289.71px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'RMS Map\u000bC-Sand'\n[29] 317.77px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Bright Spot'\n[30] 1794.13px-wide text span at top-center: 'Seismic and Well Data'\n[31] 350.68px-wide text span at top-center: 'Table 1. Wells used in the study'\n[32] 1769.07px-wide text span at top-center: 'the seismic data. The 2D/3D seismic surveys and wells used in this study in the Taranaki Basin bounded by the yellow line. 3D Maui Base is bounded by blue line illustrating the Maui-B field'\n[33] Image, description: the new zealand petroleum conference logo at top-left\n[34] Image, description: a man holding a plank and a hammer at top-left\n[35] Wide text span at top-left: 'Summary'\n[36] 1122.6px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'Figure 10. Average Velocty Map shown a low value near the MauiB field. Area near Rahi-1 well characterized by high average velocity value. While, in the MauiA field the highest velocity value is aroun...'\n[37] 1401.81px-wide text span at center-right: 'Discussion\u000bResults show good PHIE and unmoved hydrocarbons indicating a potential reserve for the C-Sand near the well. PHIE value range near Kaimiro D-Sand is 15%-22.5%. Studying grains and pores alo...'\n[38] 808.4px-wide text span at top-center: 'Figure 1. Basemap of'\n[39] Wide text span at top-left: 'The Kapuni group within the Taranaki Basin in New Zealand is a potential petroleum reservoir. The objective of the study includes building a sequential approach to identify different geological featur...'\n[40] 594.54px-wide text span at top-right: 'Figure 2. Workflow of the study including the target objectives'\n[41] 211.52px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'C-Sand'\n[42] 211.52px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'C-Sand'\n[43] 211.52px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'C-Sand'\n[44] 928.48px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Figure 14. Integration of amplitude horizon and Eigenstructure Coherence overlaid in 3D seismic structure view.'"
},
{
"i": 529,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Dubnicek-Walsh-etal-DHBenelux2022-poster-landscape-36x48 copy_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
22
],
"rationale": "The text (ID2) identifies Indiana University, but the image is changed to a Google logo, causing a brand misattribution.",
"category": "B. Identity Misattribution",
"modality": "image",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Scholar-Curated Worksets for Analysis, Reuse & Dissemination (SCWAReD) from the HathiTrust Research Center'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '\u00b9 Ryan Dubnicek (rdubnic2@illinois.edu), \u00b2 John A. Walsh (jawalsh@indiana.edu), \u00b3 Maryemma Graham (mgraham@ku.edu), \u00b9 J. Stephen Downie (jdownie@illinois.edu), \u00b2 Isabella Magni (isamagni@indiana.edu),...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: Funded by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation'\n[4] Image, description: the logo for the melon foundation at bottom-left\n[5] ['Image, description: the university of illinois urbana champaign logo' at bottom-right\n[6] 991.67px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['The Scholar-Curated Worksets for Analysis, Reuse & Dissemination (SCWAReD) project, generously supported by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, is producing a suite of curated, targeted worksets of mat...'\n[7] 2574.93px-wide text span at top-left: '['What is SCWAReD?''\n[8] 2037.27px-wide text span at top-left: '['Goals''\n[9] 1513.65px-wide text span at center-left: '['The main mission of SCWAReD is to highlight and center the work of historically under-resourced and marginalized textual communities. Specific project goals are to: Support and fund four research pr...'\n[10] 2574.93px-wide text span at center-left: '['The Four SCWAReD Projects''\n[11] 2574.93px-wide text span at top-right: '['Four more projects were selected to create curated worksets to be developed concurrently: \u201cMining the Native American Authored Works in HathiTrust for Insights,\u201d in which directors Kun Lu, Raina Hea...'\n[12] ['Image, description: the number of people who have a sexy body' at center-right\n[13] Wide text span at top-center: '['Identifying Gaps in the HathiTrust Digital Library For each of these projects, we identify and attempt to remediate collection gaps (that is, items documented by scholar-curators, but missing from H...'\n[14] 2669.42px-wide text span at bottom-right: '['Authors with most volumes from HBW collection found in HTDL''\n[15] ['Image, description: the logo for hathitrust research center' at center-center\n[16] 2501.71px-wide text span at bottom-left: '['The Flagship Project: Project on the History of Black Writing''\n[17] 3151.64px-wide text span at center-center: '['SCWAReD\u2019s flagship collaboration is with the Black Books Interactive Project, part of the longstanding Project on the History of Black Writing (HBW), founded in 1983 at the University of Mississippi...'\n[18] ['Image, description: a man sitting on a couch with glasses' at center-center\n[19] 1653.77px-wide text span at center-center: '['Roughly 1,400 were found in HTDL The majority of volumes digitized and found in HTDL are from the 1960s and 1990s (see graph below) Frank Yerby (pictured right) is the author with most volumes digit...'\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: '['Frank Yerby (courtesy of the Augusta Chronicle)''\n[21] ['Image, description: a bar graph with the number of gaps in html collections' at center-center\n[22] Image, description: A stop sign with a building with a Google logo in the background. at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 530,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Dubnicek-Walsh-etal-DHBenelux2022-poster-landscape-36x48 copy_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
8,
7
],
"rationale": "Replacing a scholarly question with a cooking query creates a contextual mismatch with the academic tone.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'Scholar-Curated Worksets for Analysis, Reuse & Dissemination (SCWAReD) from the HathiTrust Research Center'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: '\u00b9 Ryan Dubnicek (rdubnic2@illinois.edu), \u00b2 John A. Walsh (jawalsh@indiana.edu), \u00b3 Maryemma Graham (mgraham@ku.edu), \u00b9 J. Stephen Downie (jdownie@illinois.edu), \u00b2 Isabella Magni (isamagni@indiana.edu),...'\n[3] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS: Funded by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation'\n[4] Image, description: the logo for the melon foundation at bottom-left\n[5] Image, description: the indiana university logo at bottom-right\n[6] Image, description: the university of illinois urbana champaign logo at bottom-right\n[7] 2574.93px-wide text span at top-left: 'The Scholar-Curated Worksets for Analysis, Reuse & Dissemination (SCWAReD) project, generously supported by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, is producing a suite of curated, targeted worksets of mater...'\n[8] 2037.27px-wide text span at top-left: 'How 2 Cook Steak'\n[9] 1513.65px-wide text span at center-left: 'Goals'\n[10] 2574.93px-wide text span at center-left: 'The main mission of SCWAReD is to highlight and center the work of historically under-resourced and marginalized textual communities. Specific project goals are to: Support and fund four research proj...'\n[11] 2574.93px-wide text span at top-right: 'The Four SCWAReD Projects'\n[12] 2501.71px-wide text span at center-right: 'Four more projects were selected to create curated worksets to be developed concurrently: \u201cMining the Native American Authored Works in HathiTrust for Insights,\u201d in which directors Kun Lu, Raina Heato...'\n[13] Image, description: the number of people who have a sexy body at top-center\n[14] 2669.42px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'Identifying Gaps in the HathiTrust Digital Library For each of these projects, we identify and attempt to remediate collection gaps (that is, items documented by scholar-curators, but missing from Hat...'\n[15] 2404.53px-wide text span at center-center: 'Authors with most volumes from HBW collection found in HTDL'\n[16] Image, description: the logo for hathitrust research center at bottom-left\n[17] 3151.64px-wide text span at center-center: 'The Flagship Project: Project on the History of Black Writing'\n[18] 2009.78px-wide text span at center-center: 'SCWAReD\u2019s flagship collaboration is with the Black Books Interactive Project, part of the longstanding Project on the History of Black Writing (HBW), founded in 1983 at the University of Mississippi b...'\n[19] Image, description: a man sitting on a couch with glasses at center-center\n[20] Wide text span at center-center: 'Roughly 1,400 were found in HTDL The majority of volumes digitized and found in HTDL are from the 1960s and 1990s (see graph below) Frank Yerby (pictured right) is the author with most volumes digitiz...'\n[21] 737.53px-wide text span at center-center: 'Frank Yerby (courtesy of the Augusta Chronicle)'\n[22] Image, description: a bar graph with the number of gaps in html collections at bottom-right"
},
{
"i": 531,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_AHM2022 CONVERGE NL poster_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
2,
3
],
"rationale": "Directly contradicts [3], which states they link their work to ELIXIR-CONVERGE",
"category": "A. Factual Contradiction",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Wide text span at top-center: 'FAIR Data Implementation and Data Stewardship \u000bCapacity Building in the Netherlands'\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'No involvement with the ELIXIR-CONVERGE project'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'ELIXIR Netherlands implements FAIR data stewardship in life sciences and\u00a0health: in the interdisciplinary National\u00a0Programme\u00a0Open Science (NPOS), the Thematic Digital Competence Center for Life\u00a0Scienc...'\n[4] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'ELIXIR Netherlands is\u00a0run by the Dutch Techcentre for Life Sciences (DTL),\u00a0a public-private partnership of more than 50 life science organisations in the Netherlands. The majority of Dutch universitie...'\n[5] Wide text span at top-center: 'Celia W.G. van Gelder, Mijke Jetten & Rob W.W. Hooft (DTL/ELIXIR-NL)'\n[6] Image, description: the logo for elixir netherlands at top-right\n[7] Wide text span at bottom-left: 'Plaatjes om te gebruiken:'\n[8] Image, description: the logo for biosb at bottom-center\n[9] Image, description: the logo for elixir converge at bottom-center\n[10] Image, description: the netherlands with the words, 'rewards netherlands' at center-center\n[11] Image, description: the location of europe and the word europe at center-right\n[12] Image, description: the european open science cloud logo at bottom-right\n[13] Image, description: the health rite logo with a yellow background at bottom-center\n[14] Image, description: the national programme for open science logo at bottom-left\n[15] Image, description: the logo for research data netherlands at bottom-center\n[16] Image, description: the logo for nwo at bottom-left\n[17] Image, description: the logo for zonmw at bottom-left\n[18] Image, description: a qr code on a white background at top-right"
},
{
"i": 532,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Presentation poster 4-5-2022-JJG_1_0.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
10
],
"rationale": "This whimsical text clashes with the adjacent scientific discussion in ID 5, causing a contextual mismatch.",
"category": "C. Contextual Mismatch",
"modality": "text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the university of guam logo at top-left\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Preliminary efforts to establish a continuous coconut rhinoceros beetle (CRB) cell line (Oryctes rhinoceros)\u00a0(Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae)'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'James J. Grasela and Aubrey Moore\u000bUniversity of Guam College of Natural and Applied Sciences Cooperative Extension & Outreach\u000bMangilao, Guam 96913'\n[4] 1733.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction'\n[5] 3152.83px-wide text span at center-center: 'Two frequently used insect cell lines come to mind: Heteronychus arator\u00a0(Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) African black beetle Anomala cuprea\u00a0Hope (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) There is another Scarabaeidae ...'\n[6] 2707.48px-wide text span at center-left: 'There are two ways to produce an insect specific virus for basic insect pathology research as well as for the commercial production of the virus for field application to mitigate/control an insect pes...'\n[7] Image, description: a black beetle with the words 'beetle' at center-center\n[8] Image, description: a beetle with the words beetle at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a black beetle on a concrete floor at center-center\n[10] 2454.02px-wide text span at center-center: 'What about a birthday party with clowns and fireworks in a quiet library?'\n[11] 2881.97px-wide text span at center-center: 'A cell line from CRB would be the ideal bench mark to investigate in vitro infectivity and other cellular processes of the OrNV since the virus was originally isolated from this beetle species..'\n[12] 649.92px-wide text span at center-center: 'cupreous chafer'\n[13] 2346.14px-wide text span at top-right: 'Mining of CRB tissue/cells'\n[14] Image, description: a small insect and egg on a measuring scale at top-center\n[15] Image, description: a clear glass ring on a white surface at top-right\n[16] Image, description: two eggs with black spots on them at top-right\n[17] Image, description: a pair of surgical tweezers at top-right\n[18] Image, description: a pair of scissors on a blue background at top-right\n[19] Image, description: two eggs with black spots on them at top-right\n[20] Image, description: a clear glass ring on a white surface at center-center\n[21] Image, description: a clear plastic container with a red lid at center-right\n[22] 3642.99px-wide text span at center-right: 'Surface treat separate chorion'\n[23] 3642.99px-wide text span at center-right: 'eggs with 8% from embryo'\n[24] 2977.24px-wide text span at center-right: 'bleach and w/ twizzers 70% alcohol ...'\n[25] 2553.46px-wide text span at center-right: 'shredded embryos embryo tissue washed with HBSS transferred to flask with insect cell culture medium + 10% FBS'\n[26] 1039.76px-wide text span at center-right: 'incubated at 300C'\n[27] Wide text span at center-right: 'Initial progression of cell attachment and growth of CRB embryo tissue in ExCell 420 medium + 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS)'\n[28] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a small worm at center-center\n[29] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a cell at bottom-center\n[30] 988.66px-wide text span at bottom-center: '1/28/2022 (100X)'\n[31] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a small area of water at center-center\n[32] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a cell at bottom-center\n[33] 1000.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2/10/2022 (100X)'\n[34] Image, description: a small white blob with the word 2000x at center-right\n[35] Image, description: a small black and white fungus at center-right\n[36] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a small worm at bottom-right\n[37] 772.91px-wide text span at bottom-right: '3/25/2022'\n[38] Image, description: a small black and white object at bottom-right\n[39] Image, description: two different types of cells at center-right\n[40] 1122.76px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'neuronl-type cells'\n[41] 681.65px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'potential origin of new cells'\n[42] 833.78px-wide text span at center-right: 'neuronl-type cells'\n[43] 636.3px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'new cells'\n[44] 2595.91px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'To date no one has attempted to do so.'\n[45] 2083.54px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'A number of insect cell lines have been established and used to investigate the cytopathology of the Oryctes rhinoceros virus (OrNV) (Nudiviridae \u00b7\u00a0Genus:\u00a0Alphanudivirus) in the coconut rhinoceros bee...'\n[46] 922.91px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update:'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'As of April, 2022 attached tissue have yet to begin producing individual cells in quantity. It may take another 6 months to generate a stable, continuous cell line (if not contaminated beforehand).'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Once cells have proliferated to the point of confluency (cells cover most of flask bottom), the cells will be collected and transferred to two new flasks. This will be repeated 7-8 X. At this stage ...'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Now the fun part of this research. For a cell line to be useful it must be characterized. This involves the description of the cell type(s), determination of cell growth, its karyotype, check for myco...'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'With this done, CRB virus isolates can then tested in the cell line for virus production and cytopathology as well as investigation into other avenues of research.'"
},
{
"i": 533,
"source": "poster",
"image": "images/posters_pptx_Presentation poster 4-5-2022-JJG_1_1.png",
"question": "You are given a poster that contains inconsistency/error. Identify which element(s) poses semantic inconsistency/error. Your answer must follow the following format:\n\n\n\"[element 1]\" or \"[element 1],[element 2]\" <-- detailed description of one/a pair of problematic element(s), including type (image/text), content and location\n\n\n\nA brief rationale explaining your choice.\n\n",
"answer": [
30,
47
],
"rationale": "Moving this date far into the future (2030) conflicts with the April 2022 timeline in ID 47, creating temporal incoherence.",
"category": "E. Temporal/Spatial Incoherence",
"modality": "text-text",
"descs": "[1] Image, description: the university of guam logo at top-left\n[2] Wide text span at top-center: 'Preliminary efforts to establish a continuous coconut rhinoceros beetle (CRB) cell line (Oryctes rhinoceros)\u00a0(Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae)'\n[3] Wide text span at top-center: 'James J. Grasela and Aubrey Moore\u000bUniversity of Guam College of Natural and Applied Sciences Cooperative Extension & Outreach\u000bMangilao, Guam 96913'\n[4] 1733.23px-wide text span at top-left: 'Introduction'\n[5] 3152.83px-wide text span at center-center: 'Two frequently used insect cell lines come to mind: Heteronychus arator\u00a0(Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) African black beetle Anomala cuprea\u00a0Hope (Coleoptera: Scarabaeidae) There is another Scarabaeidae ...'\n[6] 2707.48px-wide text span at center-left: 'There are two ways to produce an insect specific virus for basic insect pathology research as well as for the commercial production of the virus for field application to mitigate/control an insect pes...'\n[7] Image, description: a black beetle with the words 'beetle' at center-center\n[8] Image, description: a beetle with the words beetle at center-center\n[9] Image, description: a black beetle on a concrete floor at center-center\n[10] 2454.02px-wide text span at center-center: 'What about a cell line from the coconut rhinoceros beetle (CRB)?'\n[11] 2881.97px-wide text span at center-center: 'A cell line from CRB would be the ideal bench mark to investigate in vitro infectivity and other cellular processes of the OrNV since the virus was originally isolated from this beetle species..'\n[12] 649.92px-wide text span at center-center: 'cupreous chafer'\n[13] 2346.14px-wide text span at top-right: 'Mining of CRB tissue/cells'\n[14] Image, description: a small insect and egg on a measuring scale at top-center\n[15] Image, description: a clear glass ring on a white surface at top-right\n[16] Image, description: two eggs with black spots on them at top-right\n[17] Image, description: a pair of surgical tweezers at top-right\n[18] Image, description: a pair of scissors on a blue background at top-right\n[19] Image, description: two eggs with black spots on them at top-right\n[20] Image, description: a clear glass ring on a white surface at center-center\n[21] Image, description: a clear plastic container with a red lid at center-right\n[22] 3642.99px-wide text span at center-right: 'Surface treat separate chorion'\n[23] 3642.99px-wide text span at center-right: 'eggs with 8% from embryo'\n[24] 2977.24px-wide text span at center-right: 'bleach and w/ twizzers 70% alcohol ...'\n[25] 2553.46px-wide text span at center-right: 'shredded embryos embryo tissue washed with HBSS transferred to flask with insect cell culture medium + 10% FBS'\n[26] 1039.76px-wide text span at center-right: 'incubated at 300C'\n[27] Wide text span at center-right: 'Initial progression of cell attachment and growth of CRB embryo tissue in ExCell 420 medium + 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS)'\n[28] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a small worm at center-center\n[29] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a cell at bottom-center\n[30] 988.66px-wide text span at bottom-center: '1/28/2030 (100X)'\n[31] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a small area of water at center-center\n[32] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a cell at bottom-center\n[33] 1000.0px-wide text span at bottom-center: '2/10/2022 (100X)'\n[34] Image, description: a small white blob with the word 2000x at center-right\n[35] Image, description: a small black and white fungus at center-right\n[36] Image, description: a red arrow pointing to a small worm at bottom-right\n[37] 772.91px-wide text span at bottom-right: '3/25/2022'\n[38] Image, description: a small black and white object at bottom-right\n[39] Image, description: two different types of cells at center-right\n[40] 1122.76px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'neuronl-type cells'\n[41] 681.65px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'potential origin of new cells'\n[42] 833.78px-wide text span at center-right: 'neuronl-type cells'\n[43] 636.3px-wide text span at bottom-right: 'new cells'\n[44] 2595.91px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'To date no one has attempted to do so.'\n[45] 2083.54px-wide text span at bottom-left: 'A number of insect cell lines have been established and used to investigate the cytopathology of the Oryctes rhinoceros virus (OrNV) (Nudiviridae \u00b7\u00a0Genus:\u00a0Alphanudivirus) in the coconut rhinoceros bee...'\n[46] 922.91px-wide text span at bottom-center: 'Update:'\n[47] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'As of April, 2022 attached tissue have yet to begin producing individual cells in quantity. It may take another 6 months to generate a stable, continuous cell line (if not contaminated beforehand).'\n[48] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Once cells have proliferated to the point of confluency (cells cover most of flask bottom), the cells will be collected and transferred to two new flasks. This will be repeated 7-8 X. At this stage ...'\n[49] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'Now the fun part of this research. For a cell line to be useful it must be characterized. This involves the description of the cell type(s), determination of cell growth, its karyotype, check for myco...'\n[50] Wide text span at bottom-center: 'With this done, CRB virus isolates can then tested in the cell line for virus production and cytopathology as well as investigation into other avenues of research.'"
}
]