2023 New Mexico Statutes › Chapter 22 - Public Schools › Article 15 - Instructional Material › Section 22-15-8.2 - Reading materials fund; created; purpose; applications.

A. The "reading materials fund" is created in the state treasury. The fund consists of appropriations, gifts, grants and donations. Money in the fund shall not revert to any other fund at the end of a fiscal year. The fund shall be administered by the department, and money in the fund is appropriated to the department to assist public schools that want to change their elementary literacy materials from the current adoption. Money in the fund shall be disbursed on warrant of the secretary of finance and administration pursuant to vouchers signed by the secretary of public education or the secretary's authorized representative.
B. A school district that wants to use a scientific research-based core comprehensive, intervention or supplementary reading program aligned with explicit, systematic, diagnostic, cumulative instruction in phonological and phonemic awareness, phonics, syllable types, morphology, semantics and syntax may apply to the department for money from the reading materials fund to purchase the necessary instructional materials for the selected program; provided that the school district selects no more than two comprehensive published core reading programs and the school district has established a literacy professional development plan that includes a detailed framework for structured literacy training and ongoing support in the effective use of the selected instructional materials. Materials eligible for funding shall be:
(1) core materials that are on the New Mexico kindergarten through eighth grade English language arts, Spanish language arts, English language development and world languages instructional materials adopted list and have received structured literacy recognition from the department; or
(2) intervention or supplemental materials that are on the advisory list of instructional programming created by the Colorado department of education or meet the criteria of the New Mexico structured literacy instructional review rubric.
History:
Laws 2006, ch. 58, § 1; 2023, ch. 165, § 1.
ANNOTATIONS
The 2023 amendment,
effective June 16, 2023, provided that funds in the reading materials fund can be used towards elementary literacy instructional materials, rather than reading programs, provided that permissible materials must be on the New Mexico instructional materials adopted list and have received structured literacy recognition from the department of education or be on the advisory list of instructional programming established by the Colorado Department of Education, and required awarded school districts to have a structured literacy professional development plan and to use no more than two core reading programs; in Subsection A, after "want to change their", deleted "reading programs" and added "elementary literacy materials"; in Subsection B, added "aligned with explicit, systematic, diagnostic, cumulative instruction in phonological and phonemic awareness, phonics, syllable types, morphology, semantics and syntax", and deleted "A school district may apply for funding for its reading program if" and added "provided that the school district selects no more than two comprehensive published core reading programs and the school district has established a literacy professional development plan that includes a detailed framework for structured literacy training and ongoing support in the effective use of the selected instructional materials. Materials eligible for funding shall be"; in Paragraph B(1), added "materials that are on the New Mexico kindergarten through eighth grade English language arts, Spanish language arts, English language development and world languages instructional materials adopted list and have received structured literacy recognition from the department; or"; in Paragraph B(2), added "intervention or", and deleted "highly rated by either the Oregon reading first center or the Florida center for reading research or the materials are listed in the international dyslexia association's framework for informed reading and language instruction;" and added "on the advisory list of instructional programming created by the Colorado department of education or meet the criteria of the New Mexico structured literacy instructional review rubric"; and deleted Paragraphs B(2) and B(3).
Constitutionality of textbook loan program.
— The Instructional Material Law (IML), §§ 22-15-1 to -14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases textbooks that are loaned free of charge to public and private school students enrolled in first through twelfth grade and in early childhood education programs, does not violate Article IV, Section 31, Article IX, Section 14, or Article XII, Section 3 of the New Mexico constitution. The textbook loan program, which provides a generally available public benefit to students, does not result in the use of public funds in support of private schools as prohibited by Article XII, Section 3, and is consistent with Article IV, Section 31, which addresses appropriations for educational purposes, and Article IX, Section 14, which limits any donation to or in aid of any person, association or public or private corporation.
Moses v. Ruszkowski
, 2019-NMSC-003.
Constitutionality.
— N.M. Const., Art. XII, § 3 expressly prohibits the appropriation of public funds to sectarian, denominational or private schools. The Instructional Material Law, §§ 22-15-1 through 22-15-14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases and distributes instructional material to school districts, state institutions, and private schools as agents for the benefit of eligible students, violates N.M. Const., Art. XII, § 3, because the constitutional provision expressly restricts the use of public funds to other than sectarian schools and expressly prohibits the appropriation of educational funds to private schools.
Moses v. Skandera
, 2015-NMSC-036, 367 P.3d 838,
rev'g
2015-NMCA-036, 346 P.3d 396,
vacated sub nom. N.M. Ass'n of Non-public Sch. v. Moses
, 137 S.Ct. 2325 (2017) (mem.).
Where petitioners filed a complaint for declaratory judgment against the secretary of the New Mexico public education department seeking a declaration that the state issuing instructional materials to students attending private schools is unconstitutional, the New Mexico supreme court held that the Instructional Material Law, §§ 22-15-1 through 22-15-14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases and distributes instructional material to school districts, state institutions, and private schools as agents for the benefit of eligible students, violates N.M. Const., Art. XII, § 3, because the constitutional provision expressly restricts the use of public funds to other than sectarian schools and expressly prohibits the appropriation of educational funds to private schools.
Moses v. Skandera
, 2015-NMSC-036, 367 P.3d 838,
rev'g
2015-NMCA-036, 346 P.3d 396,
vacated sub nom. N.M. Ass'n of Non-public Sch. v. Moses
, 137 S.Ct. 2325 (2017) (mem.).
The Instructional Material Law (IML), 22-15-1 through 22-15-14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases and distributes instructional material to school districts, state institutions, and private schools as agents for the benefit of eligible students, does not violate N.M. Const., art. XII, § 3, because the focus of the IML is not to support private schools, but to provide instructional material for the benefit of students, the program is secular in nature, and the state controls the use and disposition of the instructional material; although the private schools receive some benefit, N.M. Const., art. XII, § 3 will not be interpreted to prohibit indirect and incidental benefit when the legislative purpose of the IML does not focus on support of private schools.
Moses v. Skandera
, 2015-NMCA-036, 367 P.3d 838,
rev'g
2015-NMCA-036, 346 P.3d 396,
vacated sub nom. N.M. Ass'n of Non-public Sch. v. Moses
, 137 S.Ct. 2325 (2017) (mem.).
The Instructional Material Law (IML), 22-15-1 through 22-15-14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases and distributes instructional material to school districts, state institutions, and private schools as agents for the benefit of eligible students, does not violate N.M. Const., art. IX, § 14, because under the IML, there is no donation to a private school because there is neither a gift nor an allocation or appropriation of something of value without consideration; although private schools receive possession of the instructional material, as agents for the students, they never have an ownership interest in the instructional material.
Moses v. Skandera
, 2015-NMCA-036, 367 P.3d 838,
rev'g
2015-NMCA-036, 346 P.3d 396,
vacated sub nom. N.M. Ass'n of Non-public Sch. v. Moses
, 137 S.Ct. 2325 (2017) (mem.).
The Instructional Material Law (IML), 22-15-1 through 22-15-14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases and distributes instructional material to school districts, state institutions, and private schools as agents for the benefit of eligible students, does not violate N.M. Const., art. IV, § 31, because under the IML, no funds are appropriated to any private school; the mere indirect or incidental benefit to the private schools does not violate N.M. Const., art. IV, § 31.
Moses v. Skandera
, 2015-NMCA-036, 367 P.3d 838,
rev'g
2015-NMCA-036, 346 P.3d 396,
vacated sub nom. N.M. Ass'n of Non-public Sch. v. Moses
, 137 S.Ct. 2325 (2017) (mem.).
The Instructional Material Law (IML), 22-15-1 through 22-15-14 NMSA 1978, in which the New Mexico public education department purchases and distributes instructional material to school districts, state institutions, and private schools as agents for the benefit of eligible students, does not violate N.M. Const., art. II, § 11, which serves the same goals as the establishment clause of the first amendment of the United States constitution; the United States supreme court has made clear that textbook and instructional material programs that benefit all children, regardless of the school of their attendance, do not conflict with the establishment clause.
Moses v. Skandera
, 2015-NMCA-036, 367 P.3d 838,
rev'g
2015-NMCA-036, 346 P.3d 396,
vacated sub nom. N.M. Ass'n of Non-public Sch. v. Moses
, 137 S.Ct. 2325 (2017) (mem.).