2023 Idaho Code › Title 42 - IRRIGATION AND DRAINAGE -- WATER RIGHTS AND RECLAMATION › Chapter 14 - ADJUDICATION OF WATER RIGHTS › Section 42-1412 - OBJECTIONS — RESPONSES TO OBJECTIONS — HEARING BEFORE DISTRICT JUDGE — ENTRY OF FINAL DECREE.

42-1412. OBJECTIONS — RESPONSES TO OBJECTIONS — HEARING BEFORE DISTRICT JUDGE — ENTRY OF FINAL DECREE. (1) Any claimant who desires to object to a water right, or to a general provision in the director’s report, shall file an objection with the district court within the time specified in the notice of filing of the director’s report. The claimant shall also send a copy of the objection to the claimant whose water right claim is the subject of the objection and to the director.
(2) The director may file with the district court a supplemental report to any objection to the director’s report within the time specified in the notice of filing of the report. The director shall file with the district court the original of the notice of claim. The director shall mail a copy of the supplemental report to the objector and the claimant whose right is the subject of the objection. A claimant may file with the district court a response to any objection filed with respect to the claimant’s water right within the time specified in the notice of filing of the report. If a party other than the claimant or the objector desires to participate in the proceeding concerning a particular objection, the party shall file a response to the objection that states the position of the party. In addition, any party may intervene in any objection proceeding in accordance with rules of practice and procedure established by the district court.
(3) The notice of claim, objections, and responses to objections, shall identify the issues to be heard for water rights acquired under state law.
(4) Following expiration of the period for filing objections and responses thereto, the district court shall hear and determine the objections to any water right or to any general provision in the director’s report. The court shall before any trial, however, order a settlement conference to determine whether the matter can be settled. The court may request the director to conduct a further investigation and to submit a supplemental report for any water right acquired under state law that is the subject of an objection. In addition, the district court or a party may request the director or his designee to present the basis for the recommendations in the director’s report.
(5) The district court or special master shall conduct the trial without a jury on an objection or any group of objections in accordance with the Idaho rules of civil procedure.
(6) The district court shall enter a partial decree determining the nature and extent of the water right which is the subject of the objection or other matters which are the subject of the objection. The decree shall contain or incorporate a statement of each element of a water right as stated in subsections (2) and (3) of section 42-1411, Idaho Code, as applicable. The decree shall also contain an express statement that the partial decree is subject to such general provisions necessary for the definition of the rights or for the efficient administration of the water rights. Upon entry of the decree, the clerk of the district court shall send a certified copy of the decree to the director in accordance with section 42-1403, Idaho Code. The clerk of the district court shall notify the objector and claimant of each right as to which an objection was determined by the district court of entry of the decree in the manner provided in the Idaho rules of civil procedure.
(7) Not less than sixty (60) days after the expiration of the period for filing objections, the director shall file with the district court a statement of those portions of the director’s report for which no objection was filed. Following hearing, the district court shall enter a partial decree as to those portions of the director’s report for which no objection has been filed. However, the district court may exclude unobjected claims from this list if the unobjected claim may be affected by the outcome of a contested matter. The decree shall contain or incorporate a statement of those elements of a water right contained in the director’s report for water rights acquired under state law. Upon entry of the decree, the clerk of the district court shall send a certified copy of the decree to the director in accordance with section 42-1403, Idaho Code. The clerk of the district court shall notify each claimant of entry of the decree in the manner provided in the Idaho rules of civil procedure.
(8) Upon resolution of all objections to water rights acquired under state law, to water rights established under federal law, and to general provisions, and after entry of partial decree(s), the district court shall combine all partial decrees and the general provisions into a final decree.
(9) The district court may extend or shorten the time for filing any objection to the director’s report or any response to an objection.
History:
[42-1412, added 1986, ch. 220, sec. 14, p. 575; am. 1987, ch. 158, sec. 1, p. 308; am. 1994, ch. 454, sec. 20, p. 1466; am. 1994, ch. 455, sec. 4, p. 1486; am. 1997, ch. 374, sec. 5, p. 1200; am. 2002, ch. 13, sec. 2, p. 19.]