Conversation so far:
How was the musical Oklahoma received by the critics?
The show opened on Broadway to raves from the critics, sold out, and won a special Pulitzer Prize.
What did the critics say about the musical Oklahoma!?
The New York Post was the only major paper to give Oklahoma! a mixed review. Its critic felt that while the songs were pleasant enough, they sounded much alike.
What other reviews did Oklahoma! receive besides the mixed review from the new york post?
“A beautiful and delightful show, fresh and imaginative, as enchanting to the eye as Richard Rodgers's music is to the ear. It has, at a rough estimate, practically everything.
Did Oklahoma! Have any other positive reviews besides John Anderson's review?
One critic wrote, Oh, What a Beautiful Mornin' changed the history of musical theater”
What else is significant about the critics’ reception of Oklahoma!?
Did any other critic give a notable review of Oklahoma! besides John Anderson and Brooks Atkinson?
Howard Barnes wrote, Songs, dances, and a story have been triumphantly blended.“
Who else reviewed the production Oklahoma! besides John Anderson, Brooks Atkinson, and Howard Barnes?
In the New York Daily News, Burns Mantle declared that Oklahoma! really is different – beautifully different.”
Were all reviews of Oklahoma! positive?
The only negative review of the musical appeared in the New York Post.

Question: What was the result of this?
Self-contained rewrite: What was the result of the negative New York times review of Oklahoma!?