Conversation so far:
What happened in 2005?
On July 1, Howard became the Phillies' everyday first baseman.
did he set any records?
Howard led all major league rookies with 22 home runs and posted a .288 average and 63 RBI in just 312 at-bats and 88 games.
did he win any awarads?
He batted .278 with 10 home runs and 22 runs batted in.
In honor of winning the award, he received a specially-designed trophy.
Did he have any conflicts?
After the 2005 season, the Phillies faced a dilemma involving Thome and Howard.

Question: What was the dilemma?
Self-contained rewrite: What was the dilemma in 2005 between Thome and Ryan Howard?