Conversation so far:
What happened to Saosin in 2004?
In February 2004, the band's vocalist Anthony Green left Saosin and later formed another band.
How was Cove Reber recieved as a new member of Saosin?
Cove Reber replaced Anthony Green. When Beau Burchell first heard the demo, he thought it was Anthony playing a trick on them.

Question: Why?
Self-contained rewrite: Why did Beau Burchell think it was Anthony Green playing a trick on them?