Conversation so far:
How was Oklahoma received?
The original production of Oklahoma! was an unprecedented critical and popular success.
What did critics say?
"a beautiful and delightful show, fresh and imaginative, as enchanting to the eye as Richard Rodgers's music is to the ear.
It has, at a rough estimate, practically everything".
What other reviews did it receive?
Songs, dances, and a story have been triumphantly blended....
The Richard Rodgers score is one of his best, and that is saying plenty.
Did it have any other positive reviews?
but the songs in Oklahoma! call for less sophisticated words, and Mr.
Hammerstein has found very likeable ones..
What else is significant about the reception?
In the New York Daily News, Burns Mantle declared that "Oklahoma! really is different - beautifully different.

Question: Did anyone else give a notable review?
Self-contained rewrite: Did anyone besides Burns Mantle give a notable review of Oklahoma!?