Conversation so far:
What was the criticism that Sanjay Gupta got for his nomination to Surgeon General?
Peter Aldhous accused Sanjay Gupta of a pro-screening bias in promoting widespread electrocardiogram and prostate cancer screening, even though the US Preventive Services Task Force recommend against it.

Question: Was the criticism bad or good?
Self-contained rewrite: Was the criticism of Sanjay Gupta bad or good?