Conversation so far:
who was on the fifth season of american idol with elliott Yamin?
Simon Cowell, Randy Jackson and Paula Abdul
did Elliott Yamin make it on the fifth season of American idol?
Elliott Yamin was on of the top three finalists
did Elliott Yamin win the fifth season of american idol after being one of the three finalists?
Elliott Yamin was eliminated from American Idol on May 17, 2006, after the tightest race
who else was a finalist of the fifth season of american idol besides Elliott yamin?
Taylor Hicks, and Katharine McPhee

Question: did they win?
Self-contained rewrite: did Taylor Hicks and Katherine Mcphee win the Fifth season of american idol?