Conversation so far:
What was Act I?
The Darling Nursery
What happened for the Peter Pan musical after the 8 week engagement in LA?
The show opened on Broadway on October 20, 1954 at the Winter Garden Theatre for a planned limited run of 152 performances.
Did Peter Pan 1954 will any awards?
The original 1954 Broadway production, starring Mary Martin as Peter and Cyril Ritchard as Captain Hook, earned Tony Awards for both stars.
Did Peter Pan's appearance on Broadway run longer than the planned limited run of 152 performances?
No.

Question: Who starred in it?
Self-contained rewrite: Who starred in the 1954 Peter Pan musical on Broadway?