Conversation so far:
What are some health issues that Jeff Bagwell have to deal with?
Chronic arthritic condition in his shoulder.
Did the chronic arthritic condition bother him really bad?
Bagwell continued to play through the pain until May 4, when it became so unbearable that he asked his manager to remove him from the lineup the following day.

Question: Did he ever return to play?
Self-contained rewrite: Did Jeff Bagwell ever return to play after the health issue?