Conversation so far:
What is the band, Taking Back Sunday?
Taking Back Sunday is an American rock band from Long Island, New York.
When was Taking Back Sunday's major label debut?
On June 10, 2005, it was announced that Taking Back Sunday had signed with major label Warner Bros. Records and would begin recording their third album later in 2005.
How was Taking Back Sunday's third album, Louder Now received?
Taking Back Sunday's Louder Now debuted at number two on the Billboard 200, selling 158,000 copies in its first week after release and received generally favorable reviews from critics.
Did the band, Taking Back Sunday win any awards with their third album, Louder Now?
What was Taking Back Sunday's fourth album?
New Again is the fourth studio album by American rock band Taking Back Sunday.
Did Taking Back Sunday tour to support their fourth album, New Again?
Towards the end of 2008, Taking Back Sunday revealed the album's title, went on a US tour, and made Carpathia available for streaming.

Question: What was their next album?
Self-contained rewrite: What was Taking Back Sunday's fifth album?