user: You are a structured reasoning expert tasked with solving problems step by step. 
You first think about the reasoning process in the mind and then provide the answer. The reasoning process and answer should be enclosed within <think> </think> and <answer> </answer> tags, respectively, i.e., <think> reasoning process here </think> <answer> answer here </answer>. 
Given a question and the associated knowledge graph triplets (entity, relation, entity), you are asked to answer the question with these triplets and your own knowledge. 
You can break down the original question into several sub-questions and explore the given knowledge graph to solve them step-by-step. If there are multiple possible answers, choose one as the final answer. 
After thinking, when you finally reach a conclusion, clearly state the answer within <answer> </answer> tags, i.e., <answer> answer here </answer>. 
Question: In which city is Columbia University located in where honorary degrees were started? 
Knowledge Triplets: Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia School of Continuing Education
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0czf93y
United States of America, location.country.administrative_divisions, New York
m.0_9qlts, education.honorary_degree.institution, Columbia University
Museum of Modern Art, location.location.containedby, New York City
m.0b492fy, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia University School of General Studies, education.educational_institution.school_type, Private university
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0h88jfq
Columbia Law School, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia Law School
Columbia University, organization.organization.board_members, m.04fvty5
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Philosophy
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Chinatown, location.location.containedby, New York City
m.0czfgs0, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0ggmq5p
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.09wyy0w
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0h6dx_b
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_postgraduates, m.0k7rf1k
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.honorary_degrees_awarded, m.0_9qlts
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_postgraduates, m.0zn_hqt
m.04fvty5, organization.organization_board_membership.organization, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Author Index Psychological Ind
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.09wxng0
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Middle Eastern, South Asian, and African Studies
Columbia University School of General Studies, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia University School of General Studies
Columbia University, organization.organization_scope.organizations_with_this_scope, Alpha Chapter of St. Anthony Hall
Columbia University, base.schemastaging.educational_institution_extra.libraries, Gottesman Library
Columbia School of Continuing Education, location.location.containedby, United States of America
m.09ywd5y, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
m.0h6dvvs, organization.leadership.organization, Columbia University
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.09y481g
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_undergraduates, m.0zntf3b
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0czfgs0
Columbia Law School, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia Law School
New York City, location.hud_county_place.place, New York City
Columbia University, education.university.domestic_tuition, m.0k7fwhr
Columbia blue, common.topic.notable_types, Color
m.04fzk9k, organization.organization_board_membership.organization, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Barnard College
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Revised statutes
Columbia University, base.schemastaging.organization_extra.contact_webpages, m.010fq4n7
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Physics
Columbia University, main campus, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Social work as human relations;
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0zntbvg
Columbia Lions men's basketball, sports.school_sports_team.athletics_brand, Columbia Lions
Manhattan, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, The Libraries of Columbia University
Columbia University, medicine.medical_trial_sponsor.trials_sponsored, Cocaine Effects in Humans: Physiology and Behavior – 1
m.0wlp12v, business.employment_tenure.company, Columbia University
Barnard College, location.location.containedby, New York City
2013 Pulitzer Prize, time.event.locations, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.local_tuition, m.0zntg5k
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism
Columbia Business School, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Rockefeller Center, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Firdausī celebration, 935-1935
Columbia University School of General Studies, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, education.university.domestic_tuition, m.0k7rh15
Columbia University, main campus, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.09yb87r
m.03lp_34, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia School of Continuing Education, organization.organization.parent, m.0cw1q1w
New York City, base.biblioness.bibs_topic.is_really, New York City
Manhattan, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Central Park, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
New York City, location.administrative_division.country, United States of America
m.04d05qh, organization.organization_board_membership.organization, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Anthropology
Chinatown, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, organization.organization.place_founded, New York City
m.0ggmq5p, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.periodical_publisher.periodicals_published, m.010697gw
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.sports_teams, Columbia Lions Softball
United States of America, location.country.first_level_divisions, New York
Chrysler Building, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, base.schemastaging.educational_institution_extra.libraries, Burke Library
Columbia University, organization.endowed_organization.endowment, m.0h6dxrq
New York, New York (So Good They Named It Twice), music.composition.subjects, New York
Columbia University, freebase.valuenotation.has_value, International tuition
Columbia University, education.university.domestic_tuition, m.0k7fwtv
Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
St. Anthony Hall, education.fraternity_sorority.founded_location, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.fraternities_and_sororities, Alpha Sigma Phi
Columbia University, education.university.local_tuition, m.0zn_jx9
New York City, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia Lions, education.athletics_brand.institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.sports_teams, Columbia Lions men's basketball
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.0422fnr
The Lohf years, book.written_work.author, Columbia University
Columbia Law School, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_undergraduates, m.0zn_hm_
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, An official guide to Columbia university
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_postgraduates, m.0h6f087
Barnard College, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Spinoza Bibliography
Columbia University, organization.organization.headquarters, m.0zs5lxz
Columbia University, organization.organization_member.member_of, m.04dgvf2
Columbia Business School, freebase.valuenotation.has_no_value, Number of undergraduates
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
m.09yb87r, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia School of Continuing Education, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia School of Continuing Education
Columbia University, book.periodical_publisher.periodicals_published, m.010c8tq2
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, The Changing Face of Transatlantic Relations
Columbia University, base.schemastaging.educational_institution_extra.libraries, Butler Library
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, The Lohf years
Barnard College, location.location.containedby, New York
m.011399y8, organization.organization_relationship.parent, Columbia University
m.0b46f8t, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia University School of General Studies, education.educational_institution.colors, Columbia blue
m.0b467yc, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
New York City borough, freebase.type_hints.included_types, Location
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.0b46nhc
Columbia University, common.topic.article, m.01w5y
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, St. Paul's Chapel of Columbia University
Columbia Lions Softball, sports.school_sports_team.school, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Officers and graduates of Columbia college
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Electrical Engineering
10027, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.awards_presented, Bancroft Prize
New York, location.administrative_division.country, United States of America
Rockefeller Center, location.neighborhood.neighborhood_of, New York City
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Dict Ctg Whitney M Young Junio
Columbia University, organization.organization_founder.organizations_founded, Association of American Universities
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, The New York Federal Archive Building
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.03lp_34
Columbia University, education.university.domestic_tuition, m.0zntgjr
Association of American Universities, organization.organization.geographic_scope, United States of America
Rockefeller Center, location.location.containedby, New York
New York City, base.aareas.schema.administrative_area.administrative_parent, New York
Columbia University School of General Studies, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, education.educational_institution.colors, Blue
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Bibliography Of James Harvey Robinson
Columbia Lions, education.athletics_brand.teams, Columbia Lions Softball
Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, location.location.containedby, New York City
m.0h8c94h, architecture.ownership.owner, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.phone_number, m.0h6dvm7
High Line, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia University, organization.organization.leadership, m.0h6dvvs
United States of America, location.country.administrative_divisions, Manhattan
Columbia University, organization.organization.board_members, m.04fzk9k
Columbia University, base.schemastaging.educational_institution_extra.libraries, Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library
Columbia University, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Index Learned Chinese Periodic
Columbia Daily Spectator, education.school_newspaper.school, Columbia University
Columbia University Department of History, education.department.institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.acceptance_rate, m.0znth83
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Oral History Collection of Columbia University
New York City, base.biblioness.bibs_location.state, New York
New York City, base.aareas.schema.administrative_area.administrative_children, Manhattan
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia University College of Dental Medicine
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Chapters in Western civilization
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Art History and Archaeology
Columbia University, organization.organization.headquarters, m.0x12twv
Columbia University, internet.website_owner.websites_owned, Columbia Undergraduate Science Journal
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.school_type, University
Barnard College, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia University College of Dental Medicine
Columbia Business School, location.location.containedby, United States of America
United States of America, location.country.administrative_divisions, New York City
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.newspaper, Columbia Daily Spectator
m.0b47qb1, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
New York, location.location.partially_contains, Niagara Falls
Columbia University School of Engineering and Applied Science, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
m.098m1pz, education.academic_post.institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, A quarter century of learning, 1904-1929
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Lectures on literature
Columbia University School of General Studies, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Dedication of the new site, Morningside Heights
Central Park, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, main campus, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia University
Columbia Law School, education.educational_institution.school_type, Private university
Columbia School of Continuing Education, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Columbia University, award.ranked_item.appears_in_ranked_lists, m.0ggms13
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York
Columbia Business School, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia Business School
Columbia Lions Softball, sports.school_sports_team.athletics_brand, Columbia Lions
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.award_categories_presented, Medal of Excellence
Columbia University, common.topic.notable_for, g.1255thz1v
Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center, medicine.cancer_center.constituents, Columbia University
m.0czf93y, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Columbia University School of General Studies, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Columbia University, base.jewlib.parent_institution.judaica_owning_units, Columbia University Jewish Studies Library
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Introduction to contemporary civilization
Columbia University Department of Philosophy, common.topic.notable_types, Organization
Columbia University, internet.website_owner.websites_owned, Fathom.com
Columbia School of Continuing Education, location.location.containedby, New York
m.0422fnr, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Outline of readings in important books
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Rockefeller Center, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Avery Obituary Index Architect
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.colors, White
Columbia University, organization.organization.headquarters, m.0cnm_1q
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons
St. Anthony Hall, education.fraternity_sorority.colleges_and_universities, Columbia University
Association of American Universities, organization.organization.founders, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.acceptance_rate, m.0h7446p
New York City, location.location.containedby, Area code 917
Columbia University, education.academic_institution.visiting_scholars_fellows_etc, m.0bj6v3g
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, freebase.valuenotation.has_no_value, Number of postgraduates
Columbia University, base.jewlib.parent_institution.judaica_owning_units, Columbia University Libraries
Columbia University, education.university.acceptance_rate, m.011ngsvn
Columbia Law School, freebase.valuenotation.has_no_value, Number of undergraduates
Columbia Daily Spectator, book.newspaper.circulation_areas, New York City
m.0bqvb58, education.academic_post.institution, Columbia University
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_undergraduates, m.0h77xrj
Manhattan, location.administrative_division.second_level_division_of, United States of America
Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
New York, location.administrative_division.first_level_division_of, United States of America
m.0zntbvg, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Sociology
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.0b47qb1
Metropolitan Museum of Art, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia Law School, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, medicine.cancer_center_constituent.cancer_center, Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center
Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism, education.educational_institution.school_type, Private university
Columbia University, base.jewlib.parent_institution.judaica_owning_units, Avery Architectural and Fine Arts Library
Columbia University, location.location.events, 2013 Pulitzer Prize
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, location.location.containedby, New York
New York, base.biblioness.bibs_location.country, United States of America
Mount Holyoke College, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Manhattan, location.administrative_division.country, United States of America
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_postgraduates, m.0zntf7d
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.0b492fy
New York City, location.location.time_zones, Eastern Time Zone
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.09ywd5y
Bancroft Prize, award.award_category.presenting_organization, Columbia University
Columbia Lions men's basketball, sports.sports_team.colors, Columbia blue
2012 Pulitzer Prize, time.event.locations, Columbia University
Barnard College, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia Lions, education.athletics_brand.teams, Columbia Lions men's basketball
Julius Samuel Held, education.academic.departments_old, Columbia University Department of Art History and Archaeology
New York City, base.militaryinfiction.location_in_fiction.contained_by, New York
New York City, base.arthist.helynevek.intezmeny, Metropolitan Museum of Art
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_undergraduates, m.0k9lyhd
New York City, location.location.primarily_containedby, Area codes 718, 347 and 929
Chinatown, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia University, base.ontologies.ontology_instance.equivalent_instances, m.07ndvyz
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.mascot, Columbia University Roaree the Lion
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, In honor of Marjorie Hope Nicolson
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, location.location.containedby, New York City
New York, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Central Park, location.location.containedby, New York
The Cloisters, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia Law School, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia Business School, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia Business School
Columbia University, education.university.local_tuition, m.0zntg2_
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia University College of Dental Medicine
m.010c8tq2, book.periodical_publisher_period.publisher, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia Law School
New York City, location.location.containedby, United States of America
New York City, periodicals.newspaper_circulation_area.newspapers, Columbia Daily Spectator
Columbia University, education.academic_institution.visiting_scholars_fellows_etc, m.0bqvb58
m.04hq7p2, people.place_lived.location, New York City
Columbia University, education.university.acceptance_rate, m.0ks_r10
Albany, location.location.containedby, New York
Frick Collection, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Dict Ctg Columbia University L
Columbia University, location.location.events, 2014 Pulitzer Prize
Columbia University School of General Studies, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia University School of General Studies
Chinatown, location.neighborhood.neighborhood_of, New York City
Columbia University, organization.organization.headquarters, m.0znlb0d
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, education.educational_institution.school_type, Private university
Bancroft Prize, award.award.presented_by, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Columbia University, 1897
m.07ndvyz, base.ontologies.ontology_instance_mapping.freebase_topic, Columbia University
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, freebase.valuenotation.has_value, International tuition
National Guardian, book.newspaper.circulation_areas, New York City
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Manual for the study of contemporary civilization
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, location.location.containedby, New York
Empire State Building, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.0b467yc
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, The rise of a university ..
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.total_enrollment, m.0zn_gv8
New York City, base.biblioness.bibs_topic.subsumes, New York City
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, An historical sketch of Columbia College in the city of New York 1754-1876
Columbia Business School, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, Headquarters
Columbia Lions men's basketball, sports.sports_team.colors, White
Columbia University School of General Studies, location.location.containedby, New York City
m.09wxng0, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia School of Continuing Education, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia School of Continuing Education
Columbia University, education.university.domestic_tuition, m.0h6zgmv
m.0ggms13, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.colors, Columbia blue
m.04dgvf2, organization.organization_membership.member, Columbia University
Columbia University, organization.organization.child, m.011399y8
Columbia University, education.university.fraternities_and_sororities, St. Anthony Hall
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Catalog Avery Memorial Archite
Flatiron Building, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.award_categories_presented, Bancroft Prize
Columbia University, symbols.namesake.named_after, Christopher Columbus
Columbia University, education.university.acceptance_rate, m.011b_7m2
Columbia University, main campus, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, book.periodical_publisher.periodicals_published, m.010byn99
Columbia University, organization.endowed_organization.endowment, m.0znt8jc
Van Amringe Mathematical Prize, award.award_category.presenting_organization, Columbia University
Louisa Gross Horwitz Prize, award.award.presented_by, Columbia University
Christopher Columbus, symbols.name_source.namesakes, Columbia University
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health
Columbia University, book.periodical_publisher.periodicals_published, m.01033mmt
New York, New York (So Good They Named It Twice), music.composition.subjects, New York City
m.0h88jfq, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Contemporary civilization source book
m.010by7sj, book.periodical_publisher_period.publisher, Columbia University
Times Square, location.location.containedby, New York City
New York, location.us_state.capital, Albany
Columbia University, education.academic_institution.visiting_scholars_fellows_etc, m.098m1pz
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, education.educational_institution_campus.educational_institution, Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, Public education and the future of Puerto Rico
Columbia School of Continuing Education, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.athletics_brand, Columbia Lions
m.010697gw, book.periodical_publisher_period.publisher, Columbia University
American Museum of Natural History, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.total_enrollment, m.0zntfr_
Columbia University, organization.organization.board_members, m.04d05qh
Manhattan, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University, book.periodical_publisher.periodicals_published, m.010by7sj
New York World, book.newspaper.circulation_areas, New York City
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
2014 Pulitzer Prize, time.event.locations, Columbia University
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, education.educational_institution.colors, White
Columbia University, base.jewlib.original_owner.originator_of, Columbia University Architectural Drawings
Columbia Law School, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Times Square, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia University, education.university.fraternities_and_sororities, Kappa Delta Rho
Columbia University, organization.organization.child, m.0cw1q1w
For Kings and Planets, book.written_work.subjects, Columbia University
m.0bj6v3g, education.academic_post.institution, Columbia University
Columbia University, architecture.architectural_structure_owner.structures_owned, m.0h8c94h
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.award_categories_presented, Louisa Gross Horwitz Prize
Columbia College of Columbia University in the City of New York, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, location.location.geolocation, m.010q0m3z
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, education.educational_institution.parent_institution, Columbia University
m.09wyy0w, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
m.01033mmt, book.periodical_publisher_period.publisher, Columbia University
Columbia University, book.author.works_written, A history of Columbia University 1754-1904
High Line, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.school_type, Private university
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.award_categories_presented, Van Amringe Mathematical Prize
Columbia Lions men's basketball, sports.school_sports_team.school, Columbia University
Columbia School of Continuing Education, location.location.containedby, New York City
New York, base.aareas.schema.administrative_area.administrative_children, New York City
Columbia Business School, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Ellis Island, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia University, main campus
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia University School of General Studies
Columbia University, location.location.events, 2012 Pulitzer Prize
Columbia University Department of Philosophy, education.department.institution, Columbia University
New York City, location.location.partially_containedby, Area codes 212 and 646
Columbia University, book.book_subject.works, For Kings and Planets
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.awards_presented, Louisa Gross Horwitz Prize
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia Business School
m.09y481g, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
Columbia University, base.jewlib.parent_institution.judaica_owning_units, Rare Book & Manuscript Library
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Columbia Business School, location.location.containedby, New York City
Louisa Gross Horwitz Prize, award.award_category.presenting_organization, Columbia University
Columbia Law School, location.location.containedby, New York
Columbia University, award.award_presenting_organization.award_categories_presented, Distinguished Service Medal
m.0h6dx_b, award.ranking.item, Columbia University
Kansas, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.faculty, m.0k9jl20
New York City, base.biblioness.bibs_location.country, United States of America
Columbia University, education.university.number_of_undergraduates, m.02k6vt9
Barnard College, location.location.geolocation, m.0wmfms9
Columbia University, organization.organization.headquarters, m.0w_9_2r
m.010byn99, book.periodical_publisher_period.publisher, Columbia University
SEO Services New York, location.location.containedby, New York City
Columbia University School of Engineering and Applied Science, common.topic.notable_types, College/University
Columbia University, education.university.local_tuition, m.0h6zgmm
Columbia School of Continuing Education, location.location.containedby, Manhattan
Columbia University, education.educational_institution.subsidiary_or_constituent_schools, Columbia University School of Engineering and Applied Science
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons, education.educational_institution.campuses, Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons
Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health, location.location.containedby, United States of America
Columbia University, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, Contact webpages
m.0b46nhc, common.webpage.topic, Columbia University
New York City, location.location.partially_contains, Ellis Island
Columbia University, education.university.domestic_tuition, m.0zn_jz7
m.0cw1q1w, organization.organization_relationship.child, Columbia School of Continuing Education
m.0cw1q1w, organization.organization_relationship.parent, Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of Political Science
Columbia University, base.jewlib.parent_institution.judaica_owning_units, Norman E. Alexander Library for Jewish Studies
Columbia University, common.topic.webpage, m.0b46f8t
Columbia University, base.jewlib.parent_institution.jewish_studies_research_units, Institute for Israel and Jewish Studies at Columbia University
Columbia University, education.university.departments, Columbia University Department of History

Answer: New York City