user: You are a structured reasoning expert tasked with solving problems step by step. 
You first think about the reasoning process in the mind and then provide the answer. The reasoning process and answer should be enclosed within <think> </think> and <answer> </answer> tags, respectively, i.e., <think> reasoning process here </think> <answer> answer here </answer>. 
Given a question and the associated knowledge graph triplets (entity, relation, entity), you are asked to answer the question with these triplets and your own knowledge. 
You can break down the original question into several sub-questions and explore the given knowledge graph to solve them step-by-step. If there are multiple possible answers, choose one as the final answer. 
After thinking, when you finally reach a conclusion, clearly state the answer within <answer> </answer> tags, i.e., <answer> answer here </answer>. 
Question: What 2013 Virginia senator held office from after January third, 2009? 
Knowledge Triplets: Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63lt
m.0r99pcd, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0nbz2xd, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, President pro tempore of the United States Senate
Virginia, location.location.events, United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.05kfcm1
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63wl
m.05nlpmx, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, President pro tempore of the United States Senate
Virginia, common.topic.article, m.07z1y
Virginia General Assembly, common.topic.notable_types, Governmental Body
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s64s4
m.09pvn_7, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s632t, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Secretary of state, government.government_office_category.offices, Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia
Virginia General Assembly, government.governmental_body.jurisdiction, Virginia
m.09s63pc, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
West Virginia, location.location.events, United States Senate elections, 2006
m.052jk8v, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate majority leader
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s65j4
m.0n997t6, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.0_lxzwz
m.09s63nm, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0ncr138, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.official_symbols, m.04st959
m.09s63lt, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.09x302y
m.09rfkp2, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.058__ny
m.0hz7b6m, government.government_position_held.jurisdiction_of_office, Virginia
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.government_bodies, Virginia House of Delegates
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryj37
m.04g7cnk, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, United States Senate majority leader
Senate of Virginia, common.topic.image, Seal of the Senate of Virginia
m.09pvn_7, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62xk
Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.0b477mr
m.09s632t, government.government_position_held.office_holder, James Pleasants
m.09s62sh, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s62kr, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.052jk2b, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate minority leader
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s631z
m.09s62wg, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Thomas S. Martin
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09pvb56
m.0nbz1t4, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia House of Delegates, government.governmental_body.jurisdiction, Virginia
United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012, time.event.locations, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62r_
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09rfksb
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, United States Senate Page
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s632t
m.09qpvwz, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s62_h, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09pvmbr, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62yp
m.0n99vpk, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09ryjgm, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s64s4, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0n5xv51, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.04g7cnk
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, common.topic.image, Jim Gilmore 2004 NSTAC
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, government.election.winner, Mark Warner
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.04g7cb8
m.09s62_z, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s63l2, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, End date
Virginia House of Delegates, government.governmental_body.body_this_is_a_component_of, Virginia General Assembly
Virginia, government.political_district.elections, United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.official_symbols, m.04st898
m.011cr5g_, government.government_position_held.governmental_body, Virginia General Assembly
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09pvn_7
m.09s65j4, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryhs2
m.09s62_z, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s63mp, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0hz7b6m, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia
United States Senate majority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.05k9hxg
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0n997t6
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.official_symbols, m.04l0nv9
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s64y_
m.05kfcw0, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.0hz7b6m
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0r99pcd
Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.09x2q99
m.04g7cb8, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States of America, people.person.nationality, Tim Kaine
m.09s62wg, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0n4qkb3, government.government_position_held.office_holder, James Barbour
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0n4qkb3
Senate of Virginia, government.governmental_body.body_this_is_a_component_of, Virginia General Assembly
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63rr
m.09pvqqz, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, United States Senate minority leader
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62vv
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryj64
m.0n99vpk, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s62z0, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.04mmcc8, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, President pro tempore of the United States Senate
m.0n4qkb3, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s646c
m.09s65j4, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, common.topic.article, m.0cpnh8
m.09s62kf, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Secretary of the United States Senate, common.topic.article, m.03by0n
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62_z
Virginia General Assembly, common.topic.article, m.02720b
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.04j5vfw
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0n997tk
Government of Virginia, government.government.agency, Virginia Marine Resources Commission
m.0mtk6wd, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s62tf, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63q3
United States Senate majority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.094t_m4
United States Congress, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62q6
m.094t_m4, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate majority leader
m.09ryhs2, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09rfksb, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Henry Tazewell
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.agencies, State Corporation Commission
m.09s62r_, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0nbz1w5, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0n99vpk
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, common.topic.notable_for, g.1258t62m9
m.09pvmbr, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s64y_, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s646c, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s631z, government.government_position_held.basic_title, Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.04g7cn7
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, government.government_office_or_title.jurisdiction, Virginia
United States Senate minority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.052jk8m
m.09s62kf, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryjgm
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, common.topic.notable_types, Government Office or Title
Virginia General Assembly, government.governmental_body.component_bodies, Virginia House of Delegates
Super Tuesday, 2012, time.event.includes_event, United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012
Government of Virginia, government.government.government_for, Virginia
m.09s646c, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate elections, 2008, government.general_election.contests, United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008
President pro tempore of the United States Senate, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.09rfdwh
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryjt0
m.09s62tf, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Absalom Willis Robertson
m.09pvb56, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63sp
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, government.election.office, United States Senator
m.052jk8m, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate minority leader
Senate of Virginia, common.topic.notable_types, Governmental Body
m.09s62v6, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s631z, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s631z, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
United States Senate elections, 2006, time.event.locations, Virginia
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, Assistant Majority Leader of the United States Senate
m.04yvxsr, common.webpage.topic, Virginia General Assembly
m.09pvb56, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
United States Senator, common.topic.notable_types, Government Office or Title
m.09s64nd, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, location.location.events, 2013 Washington Jewish Film Festival
State Corporation Commission, government.government_agency.jurisdiction, Virginia
m.09s62xk, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s62r6, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s63sp, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0k1bgw_, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate majority leader
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, government.government_office_or_title.category, Secretary of state
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63pc
m.09ryj64, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Richard Henry Lee
m.09s62q6, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
United States Senate, government.government_position_held.governmental_body, m.0r99pcd
m.09ryj37, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0_lxzwz, government.government_position_held.jurisdiction_of_office, Virginia
m.09s62q6, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0n5xv51
m.04j5vfw, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s62xk, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia General Assembly, common.topic.webpage, m.04yvxsr
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09rfkp2
m.09s62z0, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.government_bodies, Virginia General Assembly
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryj3c
m.09s62vv, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia General Assembly, government.governmental_body.component_bodies, Senate of Virginia
m.09s62tf, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0znyy7g
Virginia, location.location.events, United States Senate elections, 2006
m.09s63rr, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09pvqqz
United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012, common.topic.article, m.0h_cgnf
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, United States Senator
United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012, time.event.included_in_event, Super Tuesday, 2012
m.0ncr138, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62sh
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, time.event.next_in_series, United States Senate election in Virginia, 2014
m.0nbx2t1, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s64y_, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0znyy7g, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0mtk6wd
m.05kfcm1, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09rfkp2, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09ryjgr
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.official_symbols, m.04stkfb
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63nm
m.09s63wl, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.04g7cmm
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, government.election.district, Virginia
m.0n997tk, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0nbz1t4
m.09s63pc, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0n997tk, government.government_position_held.office_holder, William Cabell Rives
m.052jk8c, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate majority leader
Senate of Virginia, common.topic.notable_for, g.12597k6gq
m.05k9jtj, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate minority leader
m.0nbx2t1, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09rfdwh, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, President pro tempore of the United States Senate
Virginia General Assembly, government.governmental_body.members, m.011cr5g_
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, Instance of recurring event
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0r99pcd
m.09s63q3, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s62r_, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0nbz1w5, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0nbxym9
m.0nbytgy, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.04g7cmm, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09rfksb, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s65j4, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Abraham B. Venable
m.09s63l2, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0n9d329, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s633h, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.government_bodies, Senate of Virginia
m.0r99pcd, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Tim Kaine
m.09pvn_7, government.government_position_held.office_holder, James Monroe
m.0n997t6, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, common.topic.notable_types, Event
United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012, common.topic.notable_for, g.12566c82b
United States Senate minority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.052jk2b
m.09rfksb, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
United States presidential election in Virginia, 2012, common.topic.notable_types, Event
m.09ryjt0, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia General Assembly, common.topic.notable_for, g.125gbg_yt
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.05kfcw0
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, Included in event
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, Secretary of the United States Senate
2013 Washington Jewish Film Festival, time.event.locations, Virginia
m.09s62yp, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s63nm, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.government_positions, Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia
United States Senate majority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.052jk8c
m.09s63sp, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, common.topic.notable_types, Election contest
m.09qpvwz, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09pvmbr
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0nbytgy
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63mp
m.09s63mp, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s63l2
m.09s64nd, government.government_position_held.office_holder, John Randolph of Roanoke
m.09s62_h, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Senate of Virginia, common.topic.image, Historic Partisan Makeup of the Virginia State Senate
m.06wh18l, common.webpage.topic, Senate of Virginia
m.0n997tk, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0nbxym9, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s633h
m.09pvmbr, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Richard Henry Lee
m.09s63rr, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, government.election.general_election, United States Senate elections, 2008
m.09ryj3c, government.government_position_held.office_holder, Patrick Henry
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62kf
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s64nd
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62tf
m.0nbxym9, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate minority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.05k9jtj
m.09s63q3, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.05k9hxg, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senate majority leader
m.09s64s4, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0n9d329, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0nbx2t1
m.0nbytgy, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09ryj64, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s62r6, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, Start date
m.09s63wl, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, government.election.general_election, Virginia state elections, 2008
m.09s62kr, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia House of Delegates, common.topic.notable_types, Governmental Body
Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia, common.topic.notable_for, g.125cm1t83
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.jurisdiction, United States of America
m.04g7cn7, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s62zj, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62kr
Secretary of the United States Senate, common.topic.notable_for, g.125g4ph_v
m.09s62v6, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, time.event.locations, Virginia
m.0nbz1t4, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s62vv, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09ryj3c, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62wg
m.09s62wg, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
United States Senate elections, 2006, time.event.locations, West Virginia
m.09ryjgr, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, common.topic.notable_for, g.1q3scbym3
United States Senate majority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.0k1bgw_
m.0nbz0_p, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, President pro tempore of the United States Senate
m.09s62zj, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.09y19z_
m.09s62yp, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Senate of Virginia, government.governmental_body.jurisdiction, Virginia
United States Senate majority leader, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.052jk8v
Senate of Virginia, common.topic.article, m.053fcb
m.0mtk6wd, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.government, Government of Virginia
President pro tempore of the United States Senate, government.government_office_or_title.office_holders, m.04mmcc8
Virginia, base.aareas.schema.administrative_area.administrative_parent, United States of America
m.09s62sh, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09qpvwz
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0nbz1w5
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62r6
m.0_lxzwz, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, Secretary of the Commonwealth of Virginia
United States Senate election in Virginia, 2008, common.topic.article, m.026gnts
Secretary of the United States Senate, common.topic.notable_types, Government Office or Title
Senate of Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.06wh18l
m.058__ny, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
John Randolph of Roanoke, government.politician.government_positions_held, m.09s64nd
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62z0
m.09pvqqz, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.05kfcw0, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.09s633h, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
United States Senate, government.governmental_body.offices_positions, Assistant Minority Leader of the United States Senate
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62v6
m.09s62yp, government.government_position_held.office_holder, John S. Barbour, Jr.
m.09s64nd, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.04j5vfw, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.0n4qkb3, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
m.0n5xv51, government.government_position_held.district_represented, Virginia
m.09s63lt, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0ncr138
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.0n9d329
m.05kfcm1, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.09w60k7
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62_h
Virginia, government.political_district.representatives, m.09s62zj
Virginia, common.topic.webpage, m.09wzc7m
m.09s632t, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia Republican primary, 2012, freebase.valuenotation.is_reviewed, Location(s)
m.0r99pcd, government.government_position_held.office_position_or_title, United States Senator
Virginia, government.governmental_jurisdiction.official_symbols, m.0hzd8tj

Answer: Tim Kaine