Mandatory consultation with laity is a good idea. The formulation is so weak, though, that it can easily be achieved without any effect whatsoever on the pre-existing desires and choices of relevant church authorities.

With due respect to Pope Francis, for the most part this church is poorly led. The structures of church authority and governance are entirely compatible with continuing, visible leadership failure.

We can do better.

Among other things, we should invest real authority over personnel decisions in elected lay councils. Advise and consent at the minimum. Not merely consult.