Sins are forgiven. Was restitution made? What would that be?  What is her experience in diplomacy? How does she stand on the poor?  Never mind sexual morality or lack thereof. At least there are no pictures of her sans clothes. Will she express conflict with Francis' emphasis on the poor?  My view is that after confession and repentance we are all as good as any human can hope to be. Let me be clear that I do not agree with the philosophy espoused by either Callista or Newt, but fair is fair.  We either believe in the Gospels and try to live them or we don't.