I said no such thing Phil.  The facts are that US owners and consumers gott the henefit of low wage immigrant workers.  And even at those wages itt was providing a better  income for manual labor immigrants.

I think the US needs an immigration policy it can enforce and meets the needs of our nation.   I'm fine with a refugee program as long as it's enforceable.

The question of people living here already, some for many generations, deserve something more than the back of our hand considering our complicity and benefits from their labor.   There is no ethical 'one size fits all ' answer.       We disagree and that's fine.   But Congress needs a decision and twice the hard line faction like youself blocked majority efforts to pass reform.