Because you are in the 'cafeteria' you try to make out that everyone is in it; it simply makes you feel better about yourself, especially when everyone who disagrees with you is "blathering" and "talking through his hat".
You keep bringing up Eichmann, you seem to have an inordinate fixation about the man. Obedience to the the Magisterium is not "following orders", it is entirely voluntary, an act of will so your Eichmann analogy is absolutely wrong.