It's unfair to make "traditionalists" a monolith.  To paraphrase Scalia, "I'm a faithful Catholic and a traditionalist, not a kook," meaning that it is not "traditionalists" seeking to damn people, only some who read selectively, just as it is not, I think, the position of "progressives" that there will be apokatastasis, or Universal Restoration but, again, only those who engage picking-and-choosing whom to read and what to quote.