I do not know about the service in Paonia, but we went to a camp in the hills to the East of Paonia Reservoir last year and they were happy to have crackly sub Voice Grade service. Combine this with the total lack of Cell Phone service and it certainly spelled out LIMITED CONNECTIVITY.  But then, it would have taken a proportionally huge investment to give the 6 ranches we drove by on the 8 to 10 miles we drove off the paved road to arrive at our destination.  I cannot imagine anybody attempting to lay fiber all the way up there for 6 customers.