My limited experience with comments on Civil Beat indicate to me that the freedom to speak either anonymously or using what you say is your real name - it's working!

I like the system in place whereby before posting, one must evaluate other posts to see if they are helpful and most importantly, civil. I makes one stop and think.

I also find that everyday civilness comes from one's upbringing and innate character, as opposed to a mandated law.

This is a constructive conversation, thanks.