Rod, Your response was thoughtful and about the only argument for capitulating to Khadr's lawsuit. The problem that I have is the moral question. Omar was attempting to kill Canadians and our allies. My opinion is that we should have ignored the law and immediately changed it. Why? Years ago it was against the law for abortions, yet we defended that moral position. Years ago it was against the law for same ex marriage, yet we defended that moral position. If we have to blindly follow the law, more injustices will be "allowed". What if we accept the decision by the SCOC and then charge Khadr with treason. I believe that also falls "within the law". I hope he has a miserable life.