Maybe they disagree because your post is full of your own "must be" thoughts while short of any rational analysis. Vancouver prices went up 3.6% last year so the foreigner tax accomplished nothing, is that right? Well, first off, our government received income from the taxes which they can use, or squander, what have you, but the money is real. Secondly, before the tax prices were rising by 10-20% annually. Last year, 3.6% Are you sure the tax "ACCOMPLISHES NOTHING"? Some proper analysis beyond your gut feelings might be in order. FYI, shouting your point doesn't make it any more valid.