No I am not..I am saying that the test for gender can't ignore a capacity for reproduction.

In the face of the very very very small numbers of hermaphroditic people (which some addlepates use to try to undo the binary genders) a penetrating and clarifying "test" is to ask of the two apparent "sexes" present, which is producing functioning sperm and which is producing functioning eggs.

There's NEVER been a case where a person with some hermaphroditic properties produces BOTH.

And so, from an intellectual point of view, this is a useful classifying question,  And it quiets all but the true addlepates.