Problem: Patricia was caught trespassing on Sarah's house and other property, so

My choice: Sarah went to the police.

Problem: Randy used whatever dirty methods he had to interrupt Kyle from his concentration at work, but

My choice: Kyle refused to do the same.

Problem: William chased after Nick's hamster because

My choice: Nick asked her to be in charge of catching it and returning it to the cage.

Problem: Monica thought that a foot was a real turn-on but Jessica thought they were gross.

My choice:
Jessica liked to suck on people's toes.