What is the most logical next event?

How to choose organic fertilizer
Test your soil.
In order to choose the right organic fertilizer for your garden, you need to know the composition of your existing soil. There are a variety of tests that you can do, such as tests for ph, nitrogen, and phosphorus.
These will let you know the status of different components of your soil. Soil test kits for specific aspects of your soil are available at garden supply centers.