Instructions: In this task, you are given a set of context paragraphs, some supporting facts and an answer of a question. Your task is to generate question for given answer based on set of context paragraphs, supporting facts and an answer.
Input: Context_1 : Robert Michael Winner (30 October 1935 21 January 2013) was an English film director and producer, and a restaurant critic for "The Sunday Times". Context_2 : Circa 2007 (stylized as "CIRCA: 2007") is the debut album by Circa, a progressive rock band consisting of then former Yes members Billy Sherwood (bass, vocals), Tony Kaye (keyboards) and Alan White (drums), as well as Jimmy Haun (guitar), who had worked with Yes as a session musician. Billy's elder brother Michael Sherwood also appears. Two tracks are based on material Billy Sherwood and Trevor Rabin were developing in the mid-1990s. Context_3 : "Yours Is No Disgrace" is a song by English progressive rock band Yes, that first appeared as the opening song of their 1971 album "The Yes Album". It was written by all five members of the band: Jon Anderson, Chris Squire, Steve Howe, Tony Kaye and Bill Bruford. The song was also released as a single in some continental European countries such as Italy and the Netherlands. In Italy the song was divided between the A-side and B-side. In the Netherlands it was released as a maxi single, backed with "Your Move" and "Sweet Dreams." The song has been a regular feature of Yes' live shows. It has also appeared on many live and compilation albums, including "Yessongs", "Classic Yes" and "Yesstory". Context_4 : Tony Kaye (born 8 July 1952) is a British director of films, music videos, advertisements, and documentaries. Context_5 : Tony Kaye (born Anthony John Selvidge, 11 January 1946) is an English keyboardist and songwriter. Kaye was the original keyboard player for the progressive rock group Yes, from 1968 to 1971, and toured with David Bowie from 1975 to 76 for the "Station to Station" tour. He rejoined Yes from 1983 to 1995. Between his stints with Yes, he was also a founder member of the 1970s rock bands Badger and Detective, and joined Badfinger for their last album in 1981. Kaye currently plays with CIRCA:, which also features Yes member Billy Sherwood, and formerly included Yes drummer Alan White. Kaye was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a member of Yes in 2017. Context_6 : Badger were a British rock band from the early 1970s. They were co-founded by keyboardist Tony Kaye after he left Yes, with bassist and vocalist David Foster. Foster had been in the Warriors with Jon Anderson before Anderson co-founded Yes. Foster later worked with the band on "Time and a Word" (1970). Kaye had worked on a solo project by Foster that was never released. Context_7 : Mabel Greer's Toyshop are an English progressive rock (initially as psychedelic rock) band formed in London, active from 1966 to 1968 that was the precursor to the rock band Yes. Their music was marked by a combination of psychedelic, American blues and classically influenced arrangements with poetic lyrics. Members included Chris Squire, Peter Banks, Tony Kaye, Bill Bruford, and Jon Anderson. The band reformed in 2014 with original members, singer and guitarist Clive Bayley and drummer Robert Hagger, along with Hugo Barre, Tony Kaye, and Billy Sherwood. Context_8 : Specializing in drums and percussion, Connor is based out of the Southern California area. His specialties are rock, contemporary and progressive rock music. He is a veteran of the Los Angeles music club scene and has toured in the United States as well as Europe with super group Yoso (with Billy Sherwood, Bobby Kimball and Tony Kaye). Connor was the drummer for actor William Shatner's 2013 record "Ponder the Mystery". He is currently a member of CIRCA: with Sherwood, Kaye and Ricky Tierney. Context_9 : Detective was an American/English rock band that toured and recorded in the late 1970s. Detective consisted of vocalist Michael Des Barres, guitarist Michael Monarch, bassist Bobby Pickett, ex-Yes organist Tony Kaye, and drummer Jon Hyde. The band released two albums, "Detective" (produced by the band, Andy Johns and Jimmy Robinson) and "It Takes One to Know One" in 1977, as well as "Live From The Atlantic Studios", a promotional LP recorded only for radio broadcast, in 1978. Context_10 : Appointment with Death is a 1988 British mystery film made by Golan-Globus Productions and produced and directed by Michael Winner. It is an adaptation of the Agatha Christie novel "Appointment with Death" featuring the detective Hercule Poirot. The screenplay was by Peter Buckman, Anthony Shaffer and Michael Winner. fact_1 : Tony Kaye (born 8 July 1952) is a British director of films, music videos, advertisements, and documentaries. fact_2 : Robert Michael Winner (30 October 1935 21 January 2013) was an English film director and producer, and a restaurant critic for "The Sunday Times". Answer: Michael Winner
Output:
Who was born first, Tony Kaye or Michael Winner?