Story needs to be completed:
Matthew was removing the excess cancerous tissue with a scalpel from Jeffrey because

My choice:
Jeffrey was a patient.

Story needs to be completed:
Dennis bought a new paint for his house last week unlike Ryan because

My choice:
Ryan was demolishing his home.

Story needs to be completed:
Samuel tried on the old hat, but Craig did not, and as a result

My choice:
Samuel found lice in their hair.

Story needs to be completed:
Mary was constantly making mistakes at work but Lindsey was not because

My choice:
Lindsey was careful and responsible.