Problem: How does the sentence end?

Megan gave Rachel the new red nail polish since
Answer: Megan already had that particular color.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The work company replaced the old carpet with new hardwood floors in the lobby. The
Answer: carpet was old.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The couple wanted a wedding cake with fondant or buttercream. They went with the
Answer: buttercream because it was creamier.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

Cynthia thought rabbits were cute but Tanya was allergic to them.
Answer:
Tanya got a cat as a pet.