Problem: S1: In 2012 , Duncan appeared next to Romola Garai in Scrubber , a film by Amanda Hale written and directed .
S2: In 2012 Duncan appeared alongside Romola Garai in Scrubber , a film written and directed by Amanda Hale .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: yes

Problem: S1: It is directed by Yasir Nawaz and written by Rida Bilal .
S2: It is led by Yasir Nawaz and written by Rida Bilal .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A: yes

Problem: S1: John Corabi replaced Vince Neil after the scream in Motley Crue .
S2: After the cry , Vince Neil John Corabi replaced temporarily in Motley Crue .

Do S1 & S2 convey the same information?

A:
no