Story needs to be completed:
Randy has to let their hair dye process longer than Steven because

My choice:
Steven doesn't have any gray hair.

Story needs to be completed:
Victoria was always honest while Jessica lied a lot, so

My choice:
Victoria was always straightforward when it came to relationships.

Story needs to be completed:
Joseph gave the carton of cigarettes to Justin because

My choice:
Joseph had just quit smoking cigarettes.

Story needs to be completed:
When it came to having a pet bird, Laura passed while Patricia bought one due to

My choice:
Patricia loving the responsibility that came with a bird.