Teacher:You are given a passage. You need to construct a question about the information present in the passage. Construct a question in such a way that (i) it is unambiguous, (ii) its answer is the whole paragraph. Avoid creating questions that can be answered correctly without actually understanding the paragraph.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? Solve this instance: The stirctest answer is no, it is not legal because you are downloading music or files from other people's hard drive who have purchased it and are sharing it. That's the problem while you CAN get in legal trouble by downloading stuff this way, chances are the person sharing the files is going to get in trouble, if they are ever caught.

If you want to stay safe, you can download files relatively safely without getting caught, it's the sharing that gets you in the most trouble.

I would say it lies in a grey area and there is no definitive answer. If you want my opinion, no it is not really legal but there is nothing in place to really stop it.
Student:
guys pls tell me limewire is legal?