[Q]: How does the sentence end?

Jason but not Jeffrey went to the animal shelter to adopt a cat because
OPTIONS:
- Jason loves cats.
- Jeffrey loves cats.

[A]: Jason loves cats.

QUES: Continue writing.

Erin thought the house was haunted but Natalie disagreed.

OPTIONS:
- Erin had long believed in ghosts and the paranormal.
- Natalie had long believed in ghosts and the paranormal.
+++++++++
ANS: Erin had long believed in ghosts and the paranormal.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The boat started to sink when James added more luggage into it. The
OPTIONS:
- luggage is light.
- boat is light.
Answer: boat is light.

sentence: Maria cooked less of a variety of foods than Samantha although OPTIONS:
- Maria was taking cooking classes.
- Samantha was taking cooking classes.
complete: Maria was taking cooking classes.

Marianne decided to wear the long wig instead of the short wig since the
OPTIONS:
- long wig seemed matronly.
- short wig seemed matronly.
short wig seemed matronly.

Problem: Continue the following story.

The supplements that Jeffrey takes don't do as good of a job as Steven's, so
OPTIONS:
- Jeffrey takes crappier supplements.
- Steven takes crappier supplements.
Here's how I want to continue it:
Jeffrey takes crappier supplements.