Teacher: You are given a review about a place. You need to provide a rating from "1 star" to "5 stars" for this place.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
Although I did enjoy the food here, I was completely unimpressed (and slightly annoyed) by the overpriced margaritas. I ordered a platinum which contained "fresh" juice. It tasted like it had sprite in it, so I thought surely she gave me the wrong one. It turns out that "fresh juice" is really margarita mix on tap from the same gun as the sprite. I asked for something fresh to replace the horrible margarita and received a rocks glass with just muddled lime and a salted rim. I'm not sure it contained any tequila. Horrible! It's not that hard to make a fresh margarita!
Solution: 2 stars
Reason: The writer has been annoyed in this place and has enjoyed the food. So, "2 stars" sounds reasonable for it.

Now, solve this instance: If this is what all German food tastes like, then consider me a fan.

I was in Phoenix to celebrate my birthday with family, and we sort of found our way here by accident. The decor is very charming -- as though a group of German grandmothers decided to put up every picture frame and knick knack they had -- and the service is prompt and very pleasant.

For starters, we the pastry-wrapped brie with lingonberry jelly -- a HUGE hit with the family. The pastry crust was crisp, the brie melty and gooey, and the lingonberry jelly served as the perfect sweet complement to the cheesey, savory flavors. Even my sister, whom I consider a pretty picky eater, loved it.

For the main course, it was schnitzel all around! My mom ordered the Schweizer Schnitzel (pork wrapped in Emmentaler cheese and ham), which she really liked, but wished she had ordered a sauce to come with it. My sister had the Paprika Schnitzel, which was actually a lot sweeter than she had expected, but again, very tasty. I had the Holstein Schnitzel (fried egg, anchovies, and capers), which was everything I had hoped it would be. Dad changed things up by ordering the Beef Roulades, which he simply could not stop eating. I don't even remember him talking while food was on his plate, to be honest.

I ordered a litre of the Hefeweizen they had on tap in hopes that I'd get the infamous glass boot, but unfortunately they were saving all the boots for the upcoming Oktoberfest, and so I just got a huge regular-shaped glass instead. I'm not really a big beer drinkers, and so without the novelty of the boot glass, downing that much beer wasn't as much fun as I'd wanted (especially since I was the only one drinking), but I don't fault them for that policy. I'll just have to go back some other time!

All in all, a very good, fulfilling meal. A very cute restaurant nestled in a charming area of old Glendale, Haus Murphys is a refreshing escape.
Student:
4 stars