Problem: How does the sentence end?

Nick went to the gym on a schedule while Matthew went irregularly so
OPTIONS:
- Nick was very fit.
- Matthew was very fit.
Answer: Nick was very fit.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

Neil stayed dry in the bad weather, but Hunter got drenched, because
OPTIONS:
- Neil wore a raincoat.
- Hunter wore a raincoat.
Answer: Neil wore a raincoat.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

Kyle excitedly told Robert about the Paleo Diet that he started.
OPTIONS:
- Kyle was skeptical.
- Robert was skeptical.
Answer: Robert was skeptical.

Problem: How does the sentence end?

The pattern that Carrie did was a lot worse than that of Samantha, due to
OPTIONS:
- Carrie being unartistic.
- Samantha being unartistic.
Answer:
Carrie being unartistic.