Objective: What ingredients do you need to make Peanut Butter Fudge?

Which of the following solutions is more sound in terms of naive physics reasoning?

pick from the following. + You will need: 1) Peanut Butter 2) Unsalted butter 3) Vanilla Extract 4) Powdered Sugar and 5) Nuts + You will need: 1) Peanut Butter 2) Unsalted Butter 3) Brown Sugar 5) Sifted Flour and 5) Nuts
You will need: 1) Peanut Butter 2) Unsalted butter 3) Vanilla Extract 4) Powdered Sugar and 5) Nuts