Question:
But he could remember the punishment very vividly.

Does it follow that "He could not forget the punishment at all."?
Answer:
yes

Question:
But this undermines his entire case about Stalin's unique responsibility.

Does it follow that "His care about Stalin's responsibility is undermined."?
Answer:
yes

Question:
The view of the lush mossy landscaped garden from the verandah at the back of the building is one of Kyoto's most famous.

Does it follow that "The Kyoto temple does not have a garden."?
Answer:
no

Question:
we'll have to give that a shot well i tell you what i guess uh i need to head out but i i appreciate the the conversation

Does it follow that "I'm not going to try that, I hated talking to you."?
Answer:
no