Problem: Neil was not a witch like Craig because

My choice: Craig had true magic powers and rode a broom.

Problem: Cynthia just got her period, but Victoria has had hers for years due to

My choice: Cynthia being a student.

Problem: Jack passed on the apples and bought the grapes instead because the

My choice: apples cost much more.

Problem: Tina asked guests to take off their shoes when entering the house because she had a new carpet. She said the

My choice:
shoes were often dirty.